Auto-Owners Insurance Co. v. J & T Towing (2026)

Citation: No. 369819, Wayne Circuit Court LC No. 21-009871-AV (published; Michigan Appeals Reports citation pending) · Court: Michigan Court of Appeals · Decided: April 13, 2026 · Panel: Korobkin, P.J., and Young and Bazzi, JJ. (per curiam) · On remand from the Michigan Supreme Court, 14 N.W.3d 407 (2024) (order).

Facts

After a September 2019 crash, the Van Buren Police Department impounded the driver’s car and had J & T Towing (Crova Towing) tow and store it; the driver died and police placed a hold. On January 4, 2021, the Department of State issued a notice of abandonment telling the owner it could petition within 20 days to contest abandonment or the fees. The hold was lifted and the car released on January 7, 2021, after 480 days of storage at USD 25 a day (a USD 12,304.20 bill). Auto-Owners, which became the titled owner on January 8, petitioned the district court on February 9, 2021 to contest the fees. The district court found the fees reasonable; the circuit court reversed and ordered a refund.

Holding

Because MCL 257.252a(6) says a hearing request “shall be made by filing a petition … within 20 days after the date of the notice,” the deadline is mandatory. The petition was untimely, so the district court should have dismissed it rather than hold a hearing. The circuit court’s judgment was vacated and the case remanded for dismissal.

Reasoning

“Shall” is a mandatory directive. The 20-day period recurs throughout 257.252a — the parallel fee-challenge petition (subsection 14), the owner-and-secured-party rule (subsection 8) and the earliest sale date (subsection 18) — showing the Legislature’s emphasis on the deadline.

Practical impact

  • The late fee-hearing petition required dismissal; the decision does not adjudicate an auction purchaser’s title or immunize every defective disposition. The majority rejected the asserted notice objections on this record and declined statutory attorney fees because the required hearing should not have occurred (slip opinion pp. 4–7, n. 6).
  • Young’s separate concurrence discusses the petition’s selected issue and the form’s presentation; it is not an additional majority holding. Full concurrence, independently retrieved 2026-10-17.

Good-law status

The seven-page published majority opinion and separate concurrence were independently retrieved on 2026-10-17. Full-opinion verification does not establish comprehensive subsequent appellate history or treatment. Those checks remain needs_verification; the earlier inference from a publisher’s citation count is withdrawn.

Applies in →

michigan

Legal information, not legal advice.