Bar-Til, Inc. v. Superior Asphalt, Inc. (2017)

Decided: May 9, 2017. Citation: 219 So. 3d 553 (Miss. Ct. App. 2017).

Facts

Counsel obtained a final judgment; the judgment debtor interpled payment while rival creditors garnished the recovery. Chancery apportioned the inadequate fund rather than honoring counsel’s full earned charge. opinion-bartil-pdf bartil-treatment-ca5

Holding

Reversed and remanded: counsel’s common-law charging lien attached to the recovery despite payment into the registry and had priority over competing garnishors. The reasonable forty-percent fee and documented expenses were payable first; remaining garnishment priority followed first service, not earliest judgment date. opinion-bartil-pdf bartil-treatment-ca5

Reasoning

The legal work produced the fund and the contingency occurred on the satisfied judgment. Pending unstayed punitive-damages appeal did not prevent interpleader; postjudgment interest stopped upon interpleader. Mississippi had no statute creating this attorney lien. opinion-bartil-pdf bartil-treatment-ca5

Practical impact

This is recovery-money distribution, not a statutory creation or private right to auction a client’s unrelated machinery. opinion-bartil-pdf bartil-treatment-ca5

Good-law status and treatment

Full nine-page opinion reviewed. Fifth Circuit No. 17-60720 (June 29, 2018), pp. 7–11 and nn.24–25, cites Bar-Til’s final-judgment attachment/no-Mississippi-statute rules, while affirming extinguishment of another firm’s quantum-meruit lien for prejudicial four-year delay. That is a limiting application, not a universal extinguishment or overruling of Bar-Til. opinion-bartil-pdf bartil-treatment-ca5

Applies in →

mississippi

Legal information, not legal advice. Verify current law and case treatment before acting.