Bryant v. Whitcher (1872)
Citation: 52 N.H. 158 (1872) · Decided: July 1872 (day not established by the reporter body). Full primary opinion reviewed; source-host and later-treatment boundaries appear below.
Source note (2026-10-18):
- Links on this page to
https://static.case.law/nh/52/cases/0158-01.jsonare an (unofficial Caselaw Access Project copy, retrieved before 2026-10-18; host disallows automated access); no official or otherwise permitted full-text copy was located on 2026-10-18.
Question and facts
The question was whether a sheriff’s execution sale gave the purchaser title against someone who actually owned the goods. The defendants relied on a completed purchase before attachment; knowledge of the later sheriff sale did not itself divest their earlier title. The opinion reasons from ownership and limits of the writ, rather than creating a general cure of wrongful seizure. Bryant (reporter).
Holding and disposition
NH did not adopt the English market-overt doctrine. The sheriff could sell only the debtor’s interest, and the auction purchaser acquired no greater title against the true third-party owner. A completed pre-attachment purchase would be a defense notwithstanding knowledge of the later execution sale. Case discharged. See pages 158–162. Bryant (reporter).
Important distinctions
The opinion distinguishes an irregular taking/sale of the debtor’s own goods from a wholly unauthorized taking of another person’s goods. It also distinguishes sale of one co-owner’s share from transfer of everyone’s title. Its discussion that an older case had been overruled concerns Pettingill’s officer-liability proposition, not an overruling of Bryant itself. Do not turn a search hit for ‘overruled’ into negative treatment of the holding. Bryant (reporter).
Treatment, source and currentness
CAP raw JSON and the independently recovered full reader opinion were compared. Provider day metadata differs; only the reporter-supported month/year is used. No later controlling opinion overruling the ownership holding was located in this bounded review. Current RSA 528:8–10’s equity/tender distinctions, RSA 536-A:19’s replevin against property held under legal process, and UCC 2-403/9-315 must be applied alongside this historical ownership rule. Special modern purchaser protections such as 451-C:13 or 7-210(e) control their own cases; Bryant is not a universal repeal of them. Bryant (reporter); RSA 528; RSA 536-A-full; RSA 382-A.
Practical impact
Establish the debtor’s ownership/share and substantive lien discharge. An officer receipt or new DMV title is not proof that a third person’s ownership was adjudicated. Bryant (reporter); RSA 528.
Applies in →
Legal information, not legal advice. Verify the applicable current law and case-specific record before acting.