CHS Capital, LLC v. Hellenbrand Farms, LLC (2019)

The complete opinion body was retrieved and independently reviewed on October17,2026 from the cited unofficial host (CAP report copy or Justia-hosted filed court PDF); no summary substitutes for the opinion.

Facts

Hellenbrand provided harvesting services and claimedUSD143,573.90. The debtor voluntarily auctioned crops with agreement that the lien would be paid. CHS, a prior secured lender aware of the lien, retained the jointly payable proceeds check.

Holding and reasoning

The six-month foreclosure provision in779.50(1)(b) is permissive and does not automatically extinguish the lien. CHS was not an innocent purchaser entitled to invoke the15-day recordation condition. Hellenbrand was entitled to its lien amount from proceeds; CHS was liable for conversion and civil theft for withholding it, with additional remedies reserved. A separate real-estate earnest-money claim also failed for the signature/agency defect.

Practical limits

The crop sale was voluntary and lienholder-consented. This is not a holding that every buyer at a defective779.50 lien-claimant auction takes free of all third-party interests, or that damages against CHS are automatically damages against a selling lienholder.

Good-law status

Historical holding verified. Comprehensive later treatment remains needs_verification; current statutory annotation is not a complete citator. This assurance question is separate from verification of the reported holding.

Rechecked 2026-10-18: a CourtListener citation search (results retained in schema/verification/wisconsin-evidence-2026-10-18/) returned no later opinion citing it; § 779.50 is unchanged in the statutes updated through 2025 Wis. Act 247. Not a commercial citator check.

Applies in

wisconsin

Legal information, not legal advice. Verify current primary sources before acting.