Clarkeies Market, L.L.C. v. Associated Grocers of New England, Inc. (2004)
Citation: 2004 BNH 008, No. 01-10700-JMD · Decided: April 8, 2004. Full primary opinion reviewed; source-host and later-treatment boundaries appear below.
Facts and posture
After March 2001 stay relief, AGNE took possession of inventory/equipment and other permitted tangible interests at two stores, operated them and sought a deficiency. Berlin’s attempted going-concern sale failed after a mill closure; the store closed, some equipment was sold and the remainder removed through an experienced dealer. Woodsville equipment was still being used to operate the store more than three years later. The stay order reserved senior secured rights and excluded specified intangibles; it was not a universal free-and-clear authorization. Clarkeies.
Berlin holding
AGNE could assert a Berlin-note deficiency. Temporary operation to preserve value, inventory sales with debtor knowledge and implicit court approval, meaningful buyer negotiations, subsequent closure and equipment disposal through a knowledgeable dealer were commercially reasonable on this record. A better hypothetical price or absence of an independent appraiser/broker did not alone defeat the method. The six-month attempted operational turnaround was not an automatic unreasonable-delay rule. See pages 12–16. Clarkeies.
Woodsville holdings
AGNE could not assert a Woodsville-note deficiency. The court found prolonged retention/use amounted to implied strict foreclosure in full satisfaction. Alternatively, even if the absence of statutory retention notice defeated that theory, failure to dispose within a commercially reasonable time, despite years of use and no demonstrated inability to liquidate, defeated the deficiency. It rejected the proposed retention-plus-deficiency-plus-presumption analysis. The opinion acknowledged the disputed implied-acceptance doctrine and First Circuit/state-law uncertainty rather than announcing a definitive NH Supreme Court rule. See pages 16–20 and footnotes 6–9. Clarkeies.
Finality and later proceeding
The opinion expressly is unreported and interlocutory, and does not finally allow AGNE’s total claim or set every credit. The retrieved 2005 BNH 002 adversary opinion addresses different acquisition/fiduciary/misrepresentation/equitable-subordination counts; its lien-validity count was left for claims allowance. It is not proof that this 2004 interlocutory opinion became a final allowed-claim judgment or that an appeal affirmed all reasoning. The current court index corroborates the two-store outcome but is not substituted for the full opinion. Clarkeies; clarkeies-2005; clarkeies-index.
Current statutory treatment
The court applied former Article 9 governing March 2001. Current §9-620(b) says purported acceptance is ineffective without the specified consent/proposal; current §9-626 supplies the nonconsumer deficiency rule. Therefore this historical implied-strict-foreclosure analysis cannot be silently transplanted into current acceptance law. Commercial reasonableness remains required by §9-610 and delay remains assessed on actual facts; this opinion does not create a universal statutory liquidation deadline. Clarkeies; RSA 382-A.
Practical impact and status
Operating repossessed business assets and preserving them for a real sale differ from indefinitely treating them as one’s own while demanding a deficiency. The complete historical holding and its current-code boundary are verified. Final claim allowance and comprehensive later treatment are not certified; the missing transaction-specific final order is not represented as an unanswered statewide legal rule or an automatic schema penalty. Clarkeies; RSA 382-A.
Applies in →
Legal information, not legal advice. Verify the applicable current law and case-specific record before acting.