Conseco Loan Finance Co. v. Boswell (2004)

Citation: 687 N.W.2d 646 · Court: Minnesota Court of Appeals (No. A04-161) · Decided: October 19, 2004 · Opinion: Lansing, J.

Source note (2026-10-18):

  • Links on this page to https://static.case.law/nw2d/687/cases/0646-01.json are an (unofficial Caselaw Access Project copy, retrieved before 2026-10-18; host disallows automated access); no official or otherwise permitted full-text copy was located on 2026-10-18.

Facts

Conseco financed the purchase of a manufactured home (personal property) and perfected its purchase-money security interest on the title with the Department of Public Safety in 1999. The owners defaulted on both the loan and their lot rent in a Blaine manufactured-home park run by Uniprop, which evicted them and secured the home on site. Uniprop published notice of a public sale of the home as abandoned property for USD 2,107 in storage and preservation costs. The Anoka County Sheriff held an execution sale; Uniprop, the only bidder, bought the home for USD 1. Its fair market value was USD 36,000. A new certificate of title was issued. Conseco sued in replevin.

Holding

(1) A landlord storing evicted tenants’ property on the rental premises has only a claim, not a landlord’s lien, under 504B.365 and 504B.271. (2) Section 514.18 did not create a bailee lien because care/storage was not requested by the owner/legal possessor in a qualifying business transaction. (3) The lender did not authorize the sale, so 336.9-315(a)(1) continued its perfected security interest despite the USD 1 sheriff sale; the lender was entitled to permanent possession. (4) The sheriff and DPS were not necessary parties to declaratory relief: their sale/title acts were ministerial and affected no independent agency interest; 168A.12(3) makes replacement title nonconclusive. Summary judgment affirmed. Complete opinion, 687 N.W.2d 646, 649–651.

The opinion distinguishes the expressly authorized off-premises removal/storage lien from the on-site claim. It does not decide priority of that different lien against every perfected lender. It also notes the home was treated as personalty by the contract and parties; this is not a holding about every home affixed to real estate. Complete opinion.

Reasoning

Article 9 governs the security interest; a possessory lien primes it under § 336.9-333(b) only if a statutory possessory lien actually exists. Possessory liens are consensual in origin — they arise from services furnished at the owner’s request in the ordinary course of business. The sheriff’s acts in conducting the sale and DPS’s in issuing title were ministerial.

Practical impact

  • Buyers at sheriff’s and lien sales: a sale under an invalid or junior lien does not clear a perfected title lender; a clean-looking new title can still be defeated. Search title notations and confirm the seller’s lien actually arises under a statute.
  • Lenders: a perfected interest survives unauthorized sales; replevin is available against the sale buyer.
  • Landlords and parks: the on-site storage facts here yielded a claim, not a lien. Current 504B.365(3)(b)–(c) separately creates an offsite removal/storage lien and permits incorporated 514.18–.22 public sale after 60 days unpaid following execution of the eviction order. That current procedure is not established merely by repeating the opinion’s description of the 2002 statute.

Good-law status

Published opinion independently read in full on October 17, 2026, including both substantive lien/security and necessary-party issues. Gardner v. Lambert, A08-828 (Minn. App. May 12, 2009), a complete retrieved unpublished filed opinion, quotes Conseco’s two-remedy distinction and applies statutory on-site storage requirements after eviction following contract cancellation. Its unpublished status and its own facts are preserved; it is not an offsite-lender-priority holding.

Current complete 504B.365, 504B.271, 168A.12 and UCC chapter were separately retrieved. This full-holding verification and specific later treatment do not certify exhaustive subsequent history or every present-day statutory application. CourtListener returned HTTP 202 with an empty body here; its inherited citing-opinion count is removed.

Retrieval provenance

Complete reporter body: https://static.case.law/nw2d/687/cases/0646-01.json, primary-opinion republication on an unofficial host, retrieved October 17, 2026; raw JSON and checksum retained in Minnesota’s evidence manifest. Complete court-opinion transcription: https://law.justia.com/cases/minnesota/court-of-appeals/2004/opa040161-1019.html, retrieved through reader; local request 403. A guessed mn.gov older archive path returned a CAPTCHA body with HTTP 200, not an opinion; it is preserved as such, with no bypass attempted. Gardner’s actual filed PDF was recovered normally and retained.

Applies in →

minnesota


Legal information, not legal advice. Verify against the cited primary sources and consult a licensed attorney before acting.