Decker v. Aurora Motors, Inc. (1966)
Citation: 409 P.2d 603 · Court: Alaska Supreme Court · Decided: January 10, 1966.
Source note (2026-10-18):
- Links on this page to
https://static.case.law/p2d/409/cases/0603-01.jsonare an (unofficial Caselaw Access Project copy, retrieved before 2026-10-18; host disallows automated access); no official or otherwise permitted full-text copy was located on 2026-10-18.
Facts
Aurora sold a Pontiac under a July 1963 instalment agreement; the issued title disclosed its security interest. A year later Decker repaired the vehicle at the buyer’s request and retained it for USD 284.04. Aurora obtained summary judgment in replevin for the car or its value. Complete reported opinion, unofficial CAP archive.
Holding
The court affirmed the earlier recorded vehicle creditor’s priority and right to possession over the later repair lien. The 1957 amendment to the Motor Vehicle Act displaced the contrary priority approach in Blackard v. City National Bank, 142 F. Supp. 753 (D. Alaska 1956); Blackard should not be followed on that issue. The UCC possessory-lien rule expressly preserved statutes providing otherwise. Opinion, 409 P.2d at 604–607.
Allowing the buyer to possess/use the vehicle did not imply lender consent to subordinate. The contract required the vehicle to remain free of other liens. Aurora’s erroneous use of attachment rather than the proper replevin procedure did not waive its security or prejudice Decker; dissolving the attachment did not defeat the court’s disposition. The court approved disallowing attachment costs and reducing the attorney-fee award. Summary judgment was affirmed. Opinion, at 607–608.
Reasoning
The vehicle filing statute supplied constructive notice and an express earlier-security preference; the repair-lien provisions and UCC former § 9-310 were read together. The court rejected implied subordination on the actual agreement and found no substantial prejudice from the mistaken writ. Opinion.
Practical impact
Retention for repair does not establish seniority over an earlier vehicle lender. This decision concerns priority/replevin and does not approve a completed auction or hold that every lien sale clears lenders. Current AS 28.10.391 expressly distinguishes ordinary repair/storage claims from the AS 28.10.502 business-tow exception; AS 45.29.333 is the current general possessory-priority provision. Opinion, official Title 28, official Title 45.
Good-law status
Full opinion, footnotes, subsidiary writ/cost/fee holdings and disposition checked on 2026-10-17. The archived reproduction has OCR errors and is not an official current statute compilation. Former AS 28.10.510/45.05.750 numbering is historical; the present statutory tow exception cannot be suppressed by quoting this repair case. Targeted later-case searches did not establish a later Alaska decision reversing this repair-priority holding; that search boundary is not an exhaustive still-good-law certificate. Primary bodies and failed original Justia download are retained separately in the Alaska evidence directory.
Applies in →
Legal information, not legal advice. Verify current statutes and subsequent case history before acting.