Elite Towing, Inc. v. LSI Financial Group (1999)
Citation: 985 S.W.2d 635 · Court: Court of Appeals of Texas, Austin (No. 03-98-00047-CV) · Decided: January 28, 1999 · Opinion: Yeakel, J.
Source note (2026-10-18):
- Links on this page to
https://static.case.law/sw2d/985/cases/0635-01.jsonare an (unofficial Caselaw Access Project copy, retrieved before 2026-10-18; host disallows automated access); no official or otherwise permitted full-text copy was located on 2026-10-18.
Source: opinion text from the Caselaw Access Project at the source_url, retrieved 2026-10-16.
Facts
Elite Towing took possession of a 1994 Mitsubishi towed from a church parking lot on June 26, 1996. The car was subject to a recorded security interest serviced by LSI. On July 2 Elite sent a single notice to the owner and the original lienholder announcing a public sale on August 1. On August 1 Elite’s president conducted the sale; the only bidder, buying for an affiliate, paid USD 540. LSI sued under Property Code § 70.006 and won partial summary judgment on liability, then damages of USD 8,625 and attorney’s fees.
Holding
Affirmed. Elite “did not comply with the notice requirement under section 70.006 of the Property Code.” The vehicle was in fact sold even though a restraining order later blocked a title transfer.
Reasoning
- Reading ch. 70 as a whole, the § 70.004 notice (sent within days of possession for a garageman’s lien) and the § 70.006 sale notice serve different purposes and are separate. Under § 70.006 as then written, a lienholder had to retain the vehicle 30 days after charges accrued, then give notice, and could not sell until the 31st day after that notice — “a minimum of 61 days” (adopting Dob’s Tire & Auto Center v. Safeway Insurance Agency, 923 S.W.2d 715 (Tex. App.—Houston [1st Dist.] 1996)).
- The Transportation Code provision letting a law-enforcement notice under § 683.012 satisfy ch. 70 did not help: no police agency was involved in this private tow.
- Title is a collateral issue where no competing title claim exists, so the sale could be proved by the record.
Practical impact
For a lienholder, a garage or tow lot that compresses the ch. 70 notice periods is liable in damages and fees. For a buyer at a garage or storage lien sale, a sale held on one combined notice is the kind of defect that leads to litigation over the vehicle; check the notice dates against the current statute before bidding.
Good-law status
The original CAP retrieval of 2026-10-16 is preserved. CAP returned HTTP 403 on the independent
attempt; a public Leagle page supplied only a subscription-truncated opening. The full published
opinion, including its affirmance and footnotes, was retrieved at independent_source_url on
2026-10-17. It confirms liability, the historical two-notice timing and the fee ruling.
Section 70.006 has been rewritten since 1999: the sale now may not occur before the 31st day after a copy of the notice is filed with the county tax assessor-collector, with added notice contents and a priority penalty for non-franchised motor-vehicle worker liens (Prop. Code § 70.006(a)–(f), (b-1)–(b-2), current text retrieved 2026-10-16 from statutes.capitol.texas.gov). The separateness of the § 70.004 and § 70.006 notices remains consistent with the current text, independently retrieved from the official Property Code ch. 70 on 2026-10-17. This is a statutory comparison, not a finding of judicial distinguishing treatment or a complete citator/currentness clearance. The current VTR-265-S vehicle-storage packet also requires its law-enforcement notification/custody step; the historical 61-day formula is not the present packet. The independently retrieved August 2026 Title Manual, pp. 23-6, 23-12 and 23-17, distinguishes independent-repairer filing, franchise-dealer notice and storage police-report clocks. The statutory/agency-clock reconciliation remains open; this historic garageman decision does not resolve it or apply the worker-specific priority penalty.