FedEx Corporate Services v. Costume Gallery (2024)

Citation: 2024 PA Super 152, No. 1585 EDA 2023 (July 22, 2024). Court: Superior Court of Pennsylvania. Full official court document retrieved October 17, 2026. The complete court-authored PDF is on an official public host.

Third parties claiming an interest in business personalty petitioned to set aside a writ, levy and scheduled sheriff’s sale. A prior bank attachment had ended; a later levy on different personal property occurred outside Rule 3106(d)‘s ninety-day period. The Superior Court found that levy invalid and vacated the order denying relief, remanding for further proceedings.

The majority also held that parties in interest could use Rules 3121 and 3132 to challenge procedural defects without first pursuing sheriff interpleader under Rule 3202. They sought judicial review of the writ/levy, not a sheriff’s ownership adjudication. The writ’s timely initial service did not indefinitely authorize new execution proceedings after the original attachment terminated.

The separately retrieved full ten-page Kunselman dissent argues that the appellants waived a challenge to the trial court’s alternative standing ruling and that the majority improperly supplied an unpreserved argument. The majority expressly rejects that waiver analysis. This is a genuine preservation disagreement, not a second majority holding or elimination of ownership-claim rules. The decision supplies a current primary example of execution-defect relief; it neither eliminates property-claim deadlines for ownership disputes nor adjudicates all purchaser lien-survival questions. Full text is verified; comprehensive later treatment remains needs_verification.

Applies in pennsylvania.

Legal information, not legal advice. Verify current law and later treatment before relying on this decision.