Greenwood Petroleum Co. v. Wingard (Ex parte J.M. Smith Corp.) (2000)
Citation: 341 S.C. 442, 535 S.E.2d 131 (citation from the Caselaw Access Project record, https://static.case.law/sc/341/cases/0442-01.json) · Court: Supreme Court of South Carolina, Opinion No. 25169, on certiorari to the Court of Appeals · Heard: January 5, 2000 · Filed: July 10, 2000 · Opinion: Burnett, A.J.
Source note (2026-10-18):
- Links on this page to
https://static.case.law/sc/341/cases/0442-01.jsonare an (unofficial Caselaw Access Project copy, retrieved before 2026-10-18; host disallows automated access); no official or otherwise permitted full-text copy was located on 2026-10-18.
Source: slip opinion at the source_url (S.C. Judicial Branch), retrieved 2026-10-16, and the
Caselaw Access Project text, retrieved the same day. Both were independently
retrieved in full on 2026-10-17; the raw bodies, retrieval metadata and checksums
are retained. CAP is an unofficial verbatim opinion copy. Its record also reports
rehearing denied August 7, 2000.
Facts
A pharmacy’s lender (J.M. Smith Corp.) held a perfected security interest in all inventory, accounts, fixtures and equipment securing about USD 64,000. After the tenants filed bankruptcy and the lease ended, the landlord levied for distress under §§ 27-39-210 to -360 and seized collateral to collect USD 12,000 in back rent. The magistrate, circuit court and Court of Appeals held the landlord’s distress lien primed the security interest.
Holding
Reversed. “Petitioner’s prior perfected security interest has priority over respondent’s lien.” UCC priority rules govern disputes between secured creditors and landlords’ distress liens.
Reasoning
- Article 9 excludes landlords’ liens from its scope, but in repealing former § 27-39-260 in 1988 the General Assembly expressly replaced the old landlord-priority rule with the UCC rule (Act No. 494, quoted in the opinion).
- Under the UCC, a security interest perfected before a creditor acquires a lien “by attachment, levy, or the like” prevails, and a landlord becomes a lien creditor only when it levies for distress (Burnett v. Boukedes, 240 S.C. 144 (1962)).
- Tolemac (third-party owners’ goods distrainable) does not extend to perfected secured creditors, who have given public notice of their interests.
Practical impact
For a buyer at a South Carolina landlord distress sale of business equipment, an earlier perfected lender retains priority. This does not announce that every statutory service lien or administrative sale is subordinate to all lenders: possessory service liens and expressly ranked statutory liens have their own rules. For secured lenders, perfection before the landlord’s levy protects collateral on leased premises under this holding.
Good-law status
The still_good frontmatter value is a bounded assessment of this priority holding,
not comprehensive citator clearance. The independent review checked the complete
opinion, its reversal of the Court of Appeals, distinction of Tolemac, the 2000
third-party-property amendment, and current revised Article 9. Former § 36-9-301 is
now § 36-9-317(a)(2); the separate possessory-service rule is § 36-9-333. Absence of
retrieved negative history is not proof that no negative treatment exists.
Primary treatment/statutory sources independently retrieved in full on 2026-10-17:
The online statutes are the legislature’s unofficial compilation through 2025; the independent review also checked 2026 enacted texts.
Applies in →
Legal information, not legal advice. Verify the opinion, current statutes and subsequent treatment before acting. Holding verified: 2026-10-17; exhaustive negative-treatment clearance is not certified.