Hiltz v. Gould; Gould v. Hiltz (1954)
Citation: 99 N.H. 85, 105 A.2d 48 (1954) · Decided: May 19, 1954. Full primary opinion reviewed; source-host and later-treatment boundaries appear below.
Source note (2026-10-18):
- Links on this page to
https://static.case.law/nh/127/cases/0073-01.json,https://static.case.law/nh/99/cases/0085-01.jsonare an (unofficial Caselaw Access Project copy, retrieved before 2026-10-18; host disallows automated access); no official or otherwise permitted full-text copy was located on 2026-10-18.
Facts and issue
A garage performed work on a truck and scoop, with a winch bolted to the truck, intended to operate together. Evidence conflicted on whether the entire job was one contract. The owners brought trover; the repairer also sought payment in a separate assumpsit action. The issue was a common-law lien covering the unit in addition to the statutory motor-vehicle lien. Hiltz (reporter).
Common-law and jury holdings
The statute did not supersede/restrict the preexisting common-law artisan lien; common-law and statutory liens can operate together. If the jury found the work was under a single contract, the lien could cover all property included in that unit/job. Charging only the statutory lien did not adequately tell the jury that alternative basis. The preserved exception on that vital issue required a new trial in Hiltz v. Gould. The Court did not conclusively find the single-contract facts itself. Hiltz (reporter).
Companion action
In Gould v. Hiltz the repairer did not brief or argue exceptions; they were waived, and judgment on the verdict was ordered. This companion disposition must not be omitted or described as reversal of both actions. All concurred. Hiltz (reporter).
Later treatment and current limits
Iacomini (1985), pages 76–77, expressly relies on Hiltz for coexistence of common-law and statutory repair liens, while requiring true-owner authorization. Current §9-333’s rule-of-law lien language and RSA 444’s non-Article-9 sale remedy must be distinguished from creation of the common-law right. The later USD 1,000 eligibility ceiling in the separate RSA 451-B statutory grant is not evidence that Hiltz’s common-law category was silently abolished. Full holdings and the identified later reliance verified; no comprehensive current citator certificate is claimed. Iacomini (reporter); Hiltz (reporter); RSA 382-A; RSA 444; RSA 451-B.
Practical impact
Equipment, accessories and multiple articles under a single authorized repair contract may raise an actual common-law lien issue. Record that regime expressly as common-law with statutory enforcement, rather than fabricate an additional statutory creation for each component. Hiltz (reporter); RSA 444.
Applies in →
Legal information, not legal advice. Verify the applicable current law and case-specific record before acting.