Idaho Property Management Services v. Macdonald

Decision: 157 Idaho 959, 342 P.3d 671 (Ct. App. 2014); Idaho Court of Appeals; 2014-12-16. primary source

Source note (2026-10-18):

  • Links on this page to https://static.case.law/idaho/157/cases/0959-01.json are an (unofficial Caselaw Access Project copy, retrieved before 2026-10-18; host disallows automated access); no official or otherwise permitted full-text copy was located on 2026-10-18.

Full reporter opinion retrieved from CAP, an unofficial host; court-issued PDF independently recovered from cases.justia.com after the original isc.idaho.gov URL returned 404. Both failed capture and recovered body are preserved.

Facts

A home owner abandoned a manufactured home on a rented park lot. Macdonald held a title-recorded security interest and was labelled “legal owner” on ITD records. The park sought a lien sale, then demanded rent, late fees and trespass damages from Macdonald; the trial court granted summary judgment after treating his response as deficient without determining whether the park proved a recognized cause of action. primary source

Holding and reasoning

Judgment vacated and remanded. An unopposed factual showing still must establish each legal element. Trespass was not properly pleaded and a title-recorded lienholder was not shown to have an owner’s removal/trespass duty. Section 55-2009A required timely written abandonment/arrears notice with rental charges; an eight-month-late demand did not satisfy it. The evidence did not establish liability for wrongful opposition to a lien sale either. primary source

Complete disposition and limits

The park’s trial fees/costs were vacated because it no longer prevailed; appellate costs to Macdonald. The court reserved whether the lienholder’s own written notice under subsection (1) is a further prerequisite to landlord recovery, and whether “legal owner” has exactly the motor-title meaning throughout the residency act. The decision is not a general immunity for every lienholder after proper statutory notice and does not hold all filed oppositions timely or wrongful. Current §§ 55-2009A–F still require the separate authorization, opposition, publication, inspection and title steps. primary source

Treatment and current-law boundary

Full opinion and current relevant statutes were checked. Targeted current name/citation searches did not reveal a contrary decision on the precise holding; no comprehensive citator or exhaustive later-case corpus was available. Reported disagreement, statutory changes and reserved issues are described rather than certified away. primary source

Applies in

idaho

Legal information, not legal advice. Verify the actual order, statute and complete opinion for the transaction.