In re Marty R. Tate (2016)
Decided: March 4, 2016. Citation: No. 15-03814, Doc. 63 (Bankr. S.D. Ala. Mar. 4, 2016).
Facts
Truck debtor sought turnover from Mississippi repairer; the titled lender agreed priority subject to the disputed repair amount. Debtor’s plan supplied no protection for the possessory claim. official-tate mirror-title-75 cornell362 opinion-cole-2025
Holding
Turnover denied WITHOUT prejudice. Stay-relief motion was continued/reset for April 13 status, NOT granted. The truck’s value adequately protected the repairer for § 362(d)(1); lack of equity met (d)(2)(A), but reorganization necessity remained to be addressed. official-tate mirror-title-75 cornell362 opinion-cole-2025
Reasoning
Unprotected turnover would eliminate the possessory lien. Lender’s priority concession did not establish the disputed repair amount. Debtor received an opportunity to propose adequate plan treatment before a future stay-relief ruling. official-tate mirror-title-75 cornell362 opinion-cole-2025
Practical impact
Retention, turnover and stay relief are distinct. Neither state lien nor this order authorizes an immediate auction during a federal stay. official-tate mirror-title-75 cornell362 opinion-cole-2025
Good-law status and treatment
Full three-page signed/file-stamped official order reviewed. The opinion’s printed § 7-9-333 is a citation omission: Mississippi’s pertinent current section is § 75-9-333. No later docket outcome is claimed; disposition verification does not require guessing the eventual plan or a comprehensive citator certificate. Compare In re Cole (2025): payment of the allowed labor charge permitted turnover there; it does not transform Tate’s continued stay-relief motion into a granted motion. official-tate mirror-title-75 cornell362 opinion-cole-2025
Applies in →
Legal information, not legal advice. Verify current law and case treatment before acting.