Kobuk Engineering & Contracting Services, Inc. v. Superior Tank & Construction Co-Alaska, Inc. (1977)
Citation: 568 P.2d 1007 · Court: Alaska Supreme Court · Decided: September 9, 1977.
Source note (2026-10-18):
- Links on this page to
https://static.case.law/p2d/568/cases/1007-01.json,https://static.case.law/p2d/627/cases/1060-01.jsonare an (unofficial Caselaw Access Project copy, retrieved before 2026-10-18; host disallows automated access); no official or otherwise permitted full-text copy was located on 2026-10-18.
Facts
Kobuk bought remote oilfield equipment for USD 55,300, paying USD 6,000 down and securing the balance. After default, Superior acquired the collateral at its own sale for a USD 10,000 credit; it leased the goods to Mobil and resold them for USD 25,000 about six weeks later. The sale notice reached a few public offices; the record did not prove sustained posting or a meaningful effort to reach equipment buyers. Complete reported opinion, unofficial CAP archive.
Holding
The trial court clearly erred in finding the sale commercially reasonable. Superior did not establish recognized-market/current-market-price or reasonable-dealer-practice conditions. Low price alone would not suffice, but deficient marketing, self-purchase, lack of credible contemporaneous value proof, and profitable prompt rental/resale together required reversal. Opinion, 568 P.2d at 1010–1012.
An unreasonable sale did not automatically forfeit every deficiency. Fair/reasonable collateral value at repossession must be offset; value is rebuttably presumed at least equal to debt. Creditor must rebut with a fair contemporaneous appraisal or convincing condition/comparable-price evidence. The case was remanded for that determination. Separately, the court obtained an express trial finding that no payment extension had been granted and upheld that finding under clear-error review. Judgment was reversed and remanded. Opinion, at 1012–1014.
Reasoning
The sale price was not reliable proof of collateral value where the creditor controlled a poorly marketed sale and quickly obtained substantially more from use/resale. The rebuttable-presumption remedy approximates a compliant disposition while placing valuation proof on the creditor. The court did not require an appraisal in every remote-location sale; convincing alternative evidence could suffice. Opinion.
Practical impact
A credit bid does not by itself prove market value or a valid deficiency. Price, marketing, conduct and subsequent transactions must be considered together. Modern Alaska aircraft decision crowley-v-northern-aviation-2019 cites Kobuk for this commercial-reasonableness principle and requires real disposition/accounting findings. Kobuk, Crowley, slip opinion p. 24 n.31.
Good-law status
Full holding and subsidiary no-extension issue checked 2026-10-17. Crowley (2019) provides a retrieved later affirmative application; Hoch v. Ellis, 627 P.2d 1060 (Alaska 1981), also applies the deficiency presumption. Current AS 45.29.610/.625/.626 and chapter 49 SLA 2026 govern current transactions; § .626 expressly distinguishes nonconsumer proof rules from consumer treatment. This is bounded treatment/current-statute verification, not an exhaustive citator certificate. Hoch full reported opinion, official Title 45, operative SB 252.
Applies in →
Legal information, not legal advice. Verify current law and case history before acting.