Mack Motor Truck Corporation v. Wolfe
Citation: 303 S.W.2d 697 (Mo. App. 1957). Topics: Sale procedure; lien priority; repair and storage.
Facts
A repairer retained a truck subject to a Florida-recorded conditional sale not recorded in Missouri. The vendor replevied the truck.
Holding and limits
Reversed and remanded for USD 404.87 repair recovery or return under the prescribed alternative judgment. The independent common-law repair lien survived §§430.010–430.050 without a signed memorandum and prevailed over this competing interest. Common-law storage recovery failed: the garage was not shown to be a warehouseman. The court declined dismissal for briefing defects because the short record made the issues clear. Rehearing/certification motions were denied July 19, 1957. Full judicial opinion.
Reasoning and practical impact
The court expressly did not need to decide priority against a duly Missouri-recorded mortgage. Do not transplant obsolete foreign-recording law into current UCC/title perfection. Opinion.
Treatment and currentness
gale-v-hooper-mo-1959 later addresses that Missouri-recorded-mortgage issue. The Supreme Court’s transferred Gale opinion, 330 S.W.2d 826, 827 (1959), expressly relies on Mack’s analysis while affirming only the agreed, precisely limited circumstances. Monarch Loan, 361 S.W.2d 328, 330–332 (1962), follows both opinions for the repair/not-storage distinction and replevin pleading. The 2013 BancorpSouth opinion, pages 17–18 and footnote 5, limits the artisan analogy to possessory, value-enhancing chattels, not a tax consultant’s refund claim. Full holding and this identified treatment are verified; no comprehensive modern good-law certificate is claimed.
▸ For Buyers / Operators — Compare the actual holding and statutory sale channel before relying on the transfer.
▸ For Owners / Debtors — Distinguish the verified remedy and disposition from issues the court did not decide.
This page provides general legal information, not legal advice. Consult a qualified attorney licensed in the relevant jurisdiction for advice about a specific situation.