Mayfair Jewelers, Inc. v. SAI Investment, LLC (2016)
Citation: No. 3:15-cv-00012, memorandum opinion filed March 17, 2016 · Court: District Court of the Virgin Islands, Division of St. Thomas and St. John · Source: full opinion from GovInfo (U.S. Courts collection).
Facts
SAI, a jeweler that rented seasonal space inside Mayfair’s St. Thomas store, left its display cases with Mayfair between seasons. After a rent dispute SAI chose not to return for the 2014–2015 season and repeatedly asked for the cases; Mayfair refused. Mayfair sued for breach of contract and false advertising; SAI counterclaimed for conversion and moved for partial summary judgment on that counterclaim.
Holding
Mayfair’s own admissions satisfied the elements of conversion. Its defense of “distraint”, which the court construed as a possessory lien, failed: under 28 V.I.C. § 582 a person who safely keeps or stores personal property at the owner’s request has a lien for reasonable charges and may retain possession until paid, but § 587 requires evidence of the lien to be filed “in the recorder’s office of the judicial division where the property is situated”, and Mayfair showed neither a filing nor any law excusing it. The opinion closes “An appropriate Judgment follows.”
Reasoning
The court quoted § 582 and § 587 and relied on Beaupierre v. Industrious, 19 V.I. 424 (Terr. Ct. 1983), for the rule that without a timely recorded claim the statutory lien’s protection is unavailable to a person who keeps another’s property. Mayfair also disclaimed any statutory claim to hold the cases.
Practical impact
In the Virgin Islands a storer or repairer that keeps goods for unpaid charges without a recorded claim risks conversion liability; a buyer or lender should check the Recorder of Deeds for a § 587 filing before treating a holder’s retention as lawful. The opinion does not address sale procedure, lender priority or buyer title under the lien.
Good-law status
Full opinion read 2026-10-18. No later treatment was located in this bounded review (no commercial citator used); the quoted statutes were not independently retrieved because the V.I. Code is available only through a LexisNexis viewer whose terms bar automated use.
Applies in →
Legal information, not legal advice. Verify current law and subsequent treatment before acting.