Mossman v. Banatex, LLC (2015)
Citation: 479 S.W.3d 854 (see also 440 S.W.3d 835 (2013), order on suspension of the judgment) · Court: Court of Appeals of Texas, El Paso (No. 08-13-00245-CV; transferred from Fort Worth under the docket-equalization order) · Decided: May 14, 2015 · Opinion: McClure, C.J.
Source note (2026-10-18):
- Links on this page to
https://static.case.law/sw3d/479/cases/0854-01.jsonare an (unofficial Caselaw Access Project copy, retrieved before 2026-10-18; host disallows automated access); no official or otherwise permitted full-text copy was located on 2026-10-18.
Source: opinion text from the Caselaw Access Project at the source_url, retrieved 2026-10-16.
Facts
A transmission shop in Lewisville repaired a 2001 Jaguar for USD 1,838.90. Under a program with the shop, the customer financed the bill through Banatex, and the shop assigned its receivables and “the liens on the repaired vehicle” to Banatex. After the customer defaulted, Banatex sent the Property Code § 70.006 notices and presented a copy to the Denton County Tax Assessor-Collector, which refused to file and forward it on the ground that Banatex did not hold a worker’s lien. The trial court issued mandamus compelling the office to file and serve facially compliant notices.
Holding
Affirmed. The tax assessor-collector’s role “is only to file and serve any notices which facially comply with the Section 70.006”; because the notice “appears regular on its face, the TAC had a duty to file and serve it.”
Reasoning
- Section 70.006 requires the possessory lienholder to file the notice with the county assessor- collector, which must forward copies to the owner and title lienholders; the sale cannot proceed without that step.
- The office is not the proper party to litigate whether the lien is valid or was validly assigned; the owner and the first lienholder have the motive and opportunity to do so, and false notices are criminalized by § 70.006(b-3).
- A statutory lien created “in favor of a worker” is not for that reason unassignable; § 70.006 itself speaks of the “holder of a lien.”
Practical impact
For repair-lien buyers and lienholders, the county filing is a ministerial gate: acceptance by the assessor-collector does not validate the lien, and the title lienholder must challenge a doubtful lien itself. Buyers should check who filed the notice and whether the filer was the repairer.
Good-law status
The original CAP retrieval is preserved. A new attempt returned HTTP 403; the full 14-page court
opinion was independently retrieved at independent_source_url on 2026-10-17.
Later legislation qualifies assignment. The current Property Code § 70.001(b-2) provides that “a
worker’s right to possession under this section may not be assigned to a third party in return for
payment of any amount due,” and the section’s history lists an amendment by Acts 2015, 84th Leg.,
ch. 1058 (H.B. 2076), effective June 19, 2015 — after this decision (current text retrieved
2026-10-16 from statutes.capitol.texas.gov). The ministerial-duty holding is not addressed by that
amendment. That limited comparison was repeated against the official
Property Code ch. 70 on 2026-10-17;
later judicial treatment and complete currentness remain needs_verification.