Motors Insurance Corporation v. Autobot Towing, LLC

Citation: No. WD87590 (Mo. App. W.D. July 8, 2025). Topics: Due process; sale procedure; buyer title.

Facts

The insurer titled a recovered stolen truck in its name. Autobot relied on the police report’s dealer name, failed the statutory owner-record/notice process, and sold through Facebook for USD 2,500 rather than to an authorized destruction buyer.

Holding and limits

The USD 35,015 conversion judgment was affirmed: substantial evidence supported noncompliance and damages fell within the evidentiary range. Section 304.155.12 permits scrap-only disposition to a scrap operator/licensed salvage dealer, not this ordinary purchaser. Footnote 3 expressly leaves undecided whether statutory compliance belongs to conversion’s elements or an affirmative defense. The dealer’s third-party summary judgment and dismissed replevin claim were not the appeal’s disposition. Full judicial opinion.

Reasoning and practical impact

Police paperwork does not replace the required DOR/other-state owner search or statutory no-record investigation. amond-v-ron-york-sons-towing-2009 supports the conversion analysis. Opinion.

Treatment and currentness

Full fifteen-page opinion, not Justia’s AI synopsis, was read. No comprehensive later-treatment or transfer-history certificate is claimed.

▸ For Buyers / Operators — Compare the actual holding and statutory sale channel before relying on the transfer.

▸ For Owners / Debtors — Distinguish the verified remedy and disposition from issues the court did not decide.


This page provides general legal information, not legal advice. Consult a qualified attorney licensed in the relevant jurisdiction for advice about a specific situation.