Nickell v. Lambrecht (1970)
Citation: 29 Mich. App. 191; 185 N.W.2d 155; 8 U.C.C. Rep. Serv. 1381 · Court: Michigan Court of Appeals, Division 1 (Docket No. 8165) · Decided: December 10, 1970 · Opinion: Levin, J.
Source note (2026-10-18):
- Links on this page to
https://static.case.law/mich-app/29/cases/0191-01.jsonare an (unofficial Caselaw Access Project copy, retrieved before 2026-10-18; host disallows automated access); no official or otherwise permitted full-text copy was located on 2026-10-18.
Facts
The registered owner of a highway tractor “leased” it to Morse Robinson for 15 weeks at USD 4,800, with title to pass on full payment and the lessee to keep it in repair. After a collision, a garage repaired the tractor at Robinson’s request for USD 531.02; Robinson paid neither the garage nor the owner. The garage refused the owner’s demand for the tractor, claiming a lien. The trial court awarded the owner USD 900 for loss of use and denied the lien.
Holding
Reversed. Where a “lease” is in substance a conditional sale, a mechanic who repairs the property at the request of the lessee-purchaser has a common-law possessory artisan’s lien for the repairs that takes priority over the unpaid lessor-seller’s security interest. The abandoned-vehicle reporting provisions then in force (former MCL 257.252e and 570.302a) did not forfeit the lien where the vehicle had value beyond the repairs and the owner learned its location within the statutory period.
Reasoning
The common-law artisan’s lien survives the 1846 statutory artisan’s lien and the 1915 garage keeper’s lien act, so a repairer may rely on it without meeting statutory formalities. Under UCC 9-310 (now 9-333), a lien given “by statute or rule of law” for services in the ordinary course of business takes priority over a perfected security interest unless a statute expressly provides otherwise; a common-law lien is not statutory. Requiring the title-retaining seller’s consent would revive the formalism Article 9 abolished. The court distinguished Joy Oil Co. v. Fruehauf Trailer Co., 319 Mich. 277 (1947), a true lease where the statutory garage lien failed for lack of the registered owner’s consent.
Practical impact
- Buyers at repairer sales: the opinion establishes possessory-lien priority against this unpaid seller; it does not adjudicate discharge of a competing interest at a completed sale. Priority and purchaser title require separate analysis.
- Lenders and lessors: a lease intended as security is treated as a security interest; nominal title does not defeat a repairer’s lien.
- Owners: non-consent alone does not prevent a common-law lien when the transaction is really a sale.
Good-law status
The full reporter opinion, including its notes, was independently read on OpenJurist on 2026-10-17; its automated good-law badge is not adopted. The disposition is reversal and remand for judgment for the repair amount (29 Mich. App. at 203). The published delta-engineered-plastics-v-autolign-2009 later cites Nickell on possessory-lien priority. That specific treatment is not comprehensive citator clearance; all later history and current statutory fit remain needs_verification.
Applies in →
Legal information, not legal advice.