Final review 2026-10-18: the full opinion could not be retrieved from a permitted source (the court site returns a bot challenge, Justia returns a security challenge, and CounselStack is not used). The summary below is from the 2026-10-17 reading and is not counted as a verified holding in this review.
Roberson v. West Nashville Diesel, Inc. (2006)
Citation: No. M2004-01825-COA-R3-CV (cited by the same court as 2006 WL 287389) · Court: Court of Appeals of Tennessee at Nashville, on appeal from the Davidson County Circuit Court · Filed: February 3, 2006 · Opinion: Cottrell, J. (Koch, P.J., M.S., and Cain, J., joining)
Source: official court opinion PDF at source_url, attributed by the earlier reviewer to an actual
2026-10-16 browser retrieval; that provenance is retained. Independent full-text review on 2026-10-17
used the (reproduction link removed: CounselStack is not used). A later blocked official-host fetch does not invalidate the earlier retrieval.
The official court PDF returned a browser-validation HTML page, not opinion text.
Facts
A diesel repair shop repaired four pieces of a customer’s equipment (trucks and a Cat loader) and was owed USD 14,706. Two years after the work, it notified the customer by registered mail that he also owed USD 10 per vehicle per day for storage (over USD 30,000) and that the equipment would be auctioned. At the auction the shop bought three pieces for the repair balances and sold the loader to a third party for USD 8,500. The trial court allowed the repair charges, disallowed storage, awarded the owner USD 12,000 as the difference between market value and the repair bills, and found a Consumer Protection Act violation.
Holding
Modified in part and reversed in part. With no challenge to the auction procedure, the owner was entitled only to the surplus under Tenn. Code Ann. § 66-14-106 (USD 1,359 on the loader), not to a market-value measure; storage fees were not recoverable; and the Consumer Protection Act award was reversed for lack of an ascertainable loss.
Reasoning
- The shop could enforce its statutory repairer’s lien by sale under §§ 66-14-101 et seq.; “absent allegations of impropriety regarding the sale, the fair market value of the equipment was determined by the sale.”
- Section 66-14-106, quoted in the opinion, directs the artisan to satisfy its lien and sale charges from the proceeds and to hold the balance for the person entitled to the goods.
- Any storage lien “rests on an actual obligation to pay the storage costs”; there was no agreement or notice, and the shop let undisclosed fees mount for years.
- The garagekeeper’s lien of § 66-19-103 is distinct from the repairer’s lien (footnote 5).
Practical impact
The decision measures the owner’s recovery where valid repair charges and the auction procedure were unchallenged. It does not immunize every completed auction from challenge. Its rejection of storage charges depends on the absence of agreement or notice and the prolonged accumulation of undisclosed fees.
Good-law status
needs_verification. The full Jones v. Hicks (2010) text cites this decision on reasonable charges,
but one later citation is not a comprehensive treatment check. The independent review retrieved the
2025 Code reproduction of § 66-14-106, including its twelve-month unclaimed-surplus provision. The
2025 MOTION Act and the enacted-bill record for 2026 Pub. Ch. 661 change related procedures; they do
not establish negative or positive treatment of this decision. See tennessee module 12.