Final review 2026-10-18: the full opinion could not be retrieved from a permitted source (the court site returns a bot challenge, Justia returns a security challenge, and CounselStack is not used). The summary below is from the 2026-10-17 reading and is not counted as a verified holding in this review.

Rogers Group, Inc. v. Gilbert (2016)

Citation: No. M2015-01044-COA-R3-CV · Court: Court of Appeals of Tennessee at Nashville, on appeal from the Davidson County Chancery Court · Filed: May 3, 2016 · Opinion: Dinkins, J. (McBrayer and Goldin, JJ., joining)

Source: official court opinion PDF at source_url, attributed by the earlier reviewer to an actual 2026-10-16 browser retrieval; that provenance is retained. Independent full-text review on 2026-10-17 used a public reproduction (Justia) that now returns a security challenge; no body was retained. A later blocked official-host fetch does not invalidate the earlier retrieval.

Facts

After obtaining a USD 214,071.62 judgment, the creditor moved for an order charging the debtor’s interest in an LLC. The debtor objected that he and his wife held the membership interest as tenants by the entirety. The chancery court entered the charging order and the debtor appealed.

Holding

Appeal dismissed and case remanded: this particular charging order was not final because the LLC had not supplied the required accounting and further proceedings were needed to determine the relief.

Reasoning

  • The court quoted § 48-249-509: a court may charge a member’s “financial rights with payment of the unsatisfied amount of the judgment”; the creditor “has only the rights of a transferee”; and the section “is the sole and exclusive remedy of a judgment creditor with respect to the judgment debtor’s membership interest or financial rights.” The Revised LLC Act applies to LLCs formed on or after January 1, 2006.
  • A charging order functions like a garnishment of the debtor’s financial rights, so finality follows the garnishment cases.

Practical impact

The statute restricts the judgment creditor to financial/transferee rights. The court did not decide the entireties objection, a single-member exception, or a categorical ban on every possible foreclosure. Finality must be assessed against what remains to be done in the charging proceeding.

Good-law status

needs_verification. No comprehensive later-treatment research was completed. The independent review retrieved § 48-249-509’s full 2025 Code reproduction and confirmed the exclusive-remedy/transferee language, but that is not a determination of the opinion’s current precedential status.

Applies in →

tennessee