Scotlynn Transport, LLC v. Plains Towing and Recovery, LLC (2024)
Primary opinion: complete judicial opinion, actually retrieved and reviewed October 18, 2026. The source contains the decision, not merely a case summary. The opinion citation governs the factual, procedural and holding paragraphs below.
Facts and procedural posture
Police directed Plains Towing to remove Scotlynn’s crashed tractor and trailer. Scotlynn paid the initial invoices and retrieved the trailer, but left the tractor while awaiting an insurance adjuster. The parties exchanged messages concerning continued storage at USD 100 per day. Plains later sent the agency notice and obtained an abandoned title. Scotlynn asserted claim and delivery, conversion, fraud and implied-contract claims; the circuit court granted Plains summary judgment.
Complete holding and disposition
The Supreme Court, unanimously through Justice Salter, affirmed in part, reversed in part and remanded. The communications and conduct could support an implied storage contract. A fact finder therefore had to resolve whether the tractor ceased to be impounded and was instead held by agreement; a removal agency could not obtain title merely by continuing to describe consensual storage as impoundment. The court did not itself find the contract, fix damages, or finally decide the remanded conversion/ownership consequences.
Three asserted notice defects did not independently defeat the transfer: describing the tractor as abandoned rather than impounded/wrecked, the disputed fee statement, and the agency form’s reference to receipt. The circuit court’s statutory sending-versus-receipt conclusion had not been challenged on appeal. The Supreme Court accordingly did not newly adjudicate an unrestricted constitutional or statutory no-receipt rule. Footnote 6 specifically explains that Mahoney had not decided receipt.
The opinion also recognizes that section 32-36-9 does not list every category appearing in section 32-36-8. Footnote 2 discusses the police-removal cross-reference in 32-30-15; the actual impoundment facts avoided a universal holding concerning every wrecked vehicle. It is inaccurate to turn that discussion into a categorical holding that every wrecked vehicle automatically vests under 32-36-9.
The fraud argument’s changed theory on appeal raised preservation problems. Even considering it, Scotlynn did not identify the necessary particular false representation. The Department of Revenue was not a party, and the opinion did not adjudicate a separate administrative challenge to the issued title. Those limits matter alongside the surviving contract and derivative property issues.
Current statutes and forms
The opinion describes the forty-five-day certified-mail sending requirement, the storage-charge interruption after ten days until notice is sent, and the distinct thirty-day title clock. Those rules belong to the removal route. They do not substitute for the separate receipt-based reclaim and forty-five-day branches in the insurer-requested auction-agency statute. The historical EForm 2469 discussed in the case is not evidence that it remains the current packet.
Current full SDCL title 32, including 32-36-8/9 and 32-3-74–76; current Form 1026 body.
Actual retrieved later treatment
The complete later opinions in Remington Enterprises v. Wholesome Homemade, 2025 S.D. 1, Anderson, 2025 opinion, and Viva, 2026 S.D. 42 cite Scotlynn for summary-judgment principles. They do not resolve the towing-title issues or establish what occurred on remand. The complete 2024 opinion was reviewed on October 18, 2026; no comprehensive negative-treatment certificate is asserted.
Practical boundary
For a buyer, obtain the underlying removal, notice and storage-agreement evidence, not merely a title image. For owners and lenders, distinguish issues actually preserved and decided from a form’s language and from hypothetical constitutional objections. Scotlynn does not decide every receipt dispute, every wrecked-vehicle transfer or final ownership on the unresolved contract facts.
Applies in →
Legal information, not legal advice. Laws and procedures change; consult qualified counsel about a particular transaction.