Stark Hickey, Inc. v. Standard Accident Insurance Co. (1939)

Citation: 291 Mich. 350; 289 N.W. 172 · Court: Michigan Supreme Court · Decided: December 19, 1939 · Opinion: Chandler, J. (unanimous)

Source note (2026-10-18):

  • Links on this page to https://static.case.law/mich/291/cases/0350-01.json are an (unofficial Caselaw Access Project copy, retrieved before 2026-10-18; host disallows automated access); no official or otherwise permitted full-text copy was located on 2026-10-18.

Facts

A Ford stolen in Toledo, with its motor number changed, was placed with a Detroit auto-parts dealer by a constable to find a buyer. Used-car dealer Beglinger paid USD 350 and received a notarized bill of sale signed by “Jack Altman, constable and agent,” reciting foreclosure of a garageman’s lien the parts dealer did not have; there was no statutory publication of a lien claim. The buyer obtained a title transfer from the Secretary of State on the constable’s bill of sale. After further sales, Detroit police seized the car from the plaintiff dealer as stolen. The plaintiff sued the constable’s surety on his official bond. The trial court entered judgment notwithstanding a USD 484 jury verdict for the plaintiff.

Holding

Reversed; judgment on the verdict. A constable who undertakes a garage keeper’s lien sale under color of office and conducts it fraudulently commits misfeasance for which the surety on his official bond is liable to injured third parties, even though the garage keeper’s statute did not require a constable to conduct such sales.

Reasoning

The test is whether the officer would have acted as he did without his official character; the purchaser relied on a constable’s bill of sale precisely because the Department of State accepted it for title transfer (a department witness testified that bills of sale by a sheriff, deputy sheriff or judge of a court of record were also accepted). Having undertaken a lawful act within the apparent scope of office, the constable had to complete it lawfully.

Practical impact

  • Buyers: a bill of sale reciting a lien foreclosure is only as good as the lien and the statutory procedure behind it; a title issued on a fraudulent lien-sale bill of sale did not protect against the true owner. Today’s garage keeper’s act requires a Department of State certificate of foreclosure (MCL 570.305).
  • Remedy: official bonds may answer for officer misconduct in conducting private lien sales.

Good-law status

The full opinion was independently read on Justia on 2026-10-17 (291 Mich. at 352–358). Its Department of State testimony describes historical practice, not a current execution-title checklist. The opinion applies the then-existing constable bond and garage-lien statutes. Comprehensive later-treatment and current statutory-fit checks remain needs_verification; a citation count does not establish good-law status.

Applies in →

michigan

Legal information, not legal advice.