Doral Collision Center, Inc. v. Daimler Trust (2022)

Citation: 341 So. 3d 424 · Court: Florida Third District Court of Appeal · Decided: June 8, 2022 · Opinion: Gordo, J.; Lobree and Bokor, JJ., concurring.

Source: complete twelve-page official court opinion, retrieved 2026-10-17. Pinpoints below use printed slip-opinion pages. The opinion expressly quotes the 2018 statute; its events occurred in 2018–2019.

Facts

Doral contracted with Jesus Leon and Kazuki Sushi Bar LLC to repair a Mercedes-Benz. Its June 2019 lien/sale notice scheduled an auction for July 25, although repairs were not completed until July 22. The notice described the owner’s bond right but omitted the required lienholder-rights notice. Daimler Trust, the registered owner, posted a USD 46,000 bond on July 23; Daimler Title was the lienholder. Doral sought lien enforcement, contract damages against Leon and Sushi Bar, and unjust enrichment against Daimler and the contracting parties. The appeal concerned summary judgment for Daimler. (Opinion, pp. 2–4.)

Holding

Affirmed. Strict compliance with the § 713.585 requirements quoted in the opinion was necessary for Doral’s lien enforcement. Scheduling sale three days after repair completion violated former subsection (1)(f)‘s sixty-day minimum. The notice also failed former subsection (1)(j)‘s requirement to inform the lienholder of its subsection (5) hearing/bond rights. The lien was unenforceable on the record presented. (Opinion, pp. 3, 5–8.)

Doral could not use unjust enrichment against Daimler to circumvent the statutory requirements. The express repair contract and the still-pending breach-of-contract claims also supported summary judgment on the alternative theory. The court did not dispose of the contract claims against Leon and Sushi Bar. (Opinion, pp. 8–12; p. 4 n.1.)

Reasoning

The court read the mandatory notice contents strictly and found no general substantial-compliance or lack-of-prejudice exception in the § 713.585 text before it. Its unjust-enrichment analysis applied the rule against using implied-contract recovery to evade the repair statute and separately considered the express-contract remedy. These are the court’s reasons, rather than a conclusion that every possible shop claim disappears after any procedural error. (Opinion, pp. 5–12.)

Practical impact

The decision supplies a concrete historical consequence for the two identified repair-lien defects: failed lien enforcement and no unjust-enrichment workaround against Daimler. It does not determine a completed auction purchaser’s title, every later notice defect, or the effect of all amendments after the statutory text it applied. Compare fgap-investment-v-a1-body-glass-2021, which concerns substantial compliance with the separate Motor Vehicle Repair Act and defensive standing in a bond action.

Good-law status

Historical holding verified against the official opinion. No complete citator, mandate/rehearing review or comparison of every later statutory amendment was performed; present precedential status remains needs_verification. Former subsection numbers must not be presented as current 2026 numbering.

Applies in →

florida

Legal information, not legal advice.

Independent Primary-Text Comparison — 2026-10-17

Strict compliance with the 2018 sale predicates is distinct from FGAP’s substantial Repair Act compliance; no every-defect/downstream-title holding. Current operative comparison: § 713.585; § 559.919. Full holding verification is not a comprehensive still-good-law certificate. Where the former source URL failed, the working full-opinion source now appears in metadata; original failed receipts remain separate in the review evidence.

Legal information, not legal advice. Verify against the cited primary sources and consult a licensed Florida attorney before acting.