FGAP Investment Corp. v. A1 Body and Glass of Coral Springs, LLC (2021)
Citation: No. 4D21-320 · Court: Florida Fourth District Court of Appeal · Decided: August 4, 2021 · Opinion: Gross, J.; Conner, C.J., and Warner, J., concurring. Pablo Henao was also an appellee.
Source: the complete court-authored opinion in an unofficial Justia reproduction, both HTML and four-page PDF, retrieved 2026-10-17 through the web tool. Pinpoints use the PDF’s printed pages; the website’s summaries are not the source of the holdings. A targeted search did not locate an official 2021 copy.
Facts
FGAP financed Henao’s Mercedes-Benz. After an accident, he delivered it to A1 for repairs and specifically requested a written estimate. After repair, the insurer paid all but a USD 1,000 deductible; Henao did not collect the car. A1 noticed a lien/sale claiming USD 3,565, including storage and sale costs. FGAP posted that amount as a bond, and A1 sued to recover the bond. The county court rejected FGAP’s standing objections/defenses and entered summary judgment for A1. (Opinion, pp. 1–2.)
Holding
Reversed and remanded with instructions. Genuine factual issues about A1’s substantial compliance with the Florida Motor Vehicle Repair Act precluded summary judgment. No written estimate appeared in the record, despite the customer’s request and repair cost exceeding the threshold under § 559.905, Florida Statutes (2019). The court did not finally determine that the shop had lost its lien. (Opinion, pp. 2–3.)
Under § 713.585(5), Florida Statutes (2019), FGAP had standing to raise the shop’s Repair Act violations defensively in the action against the bond. Remand included entry of an order complying with § 713.585(7). (Opinion, pp. 3–4.)
Reasoning
The court relied on § 559.919’s substantial-compliance restriction on enforcing a repair lien and on § 713.585(5)‘s express lienholder standing. Footnote 1 describes the amendment to § 559.917 effective January 1, 2020 as clarifying lienholder bond rights already apparent in § 713.585(5); the holding addressed the 2019 dispute. This is not a holding that substantial compliance excuses every § 713.585 sale-notice defect. (Opinion, pp. 3–4 & p. 4 n.1.)
Practical impact
A repair shop’s claim against a release bond can face a financing lienholder’s statutory defenses. The decision establishes defensive standing and the need to resolve compliance facts, rather than a final damages award or completed-sale title rule. Compare doral-collision-center-v-daimler-trust-2022 for strict compliance with its historical § 713.585 notice requirements.
Good-law status
The related fgap-investment-v-a1-body-glass-2024 opinion reports that FGAP later prevailed on the merits, but affirms denial of attorney fees on a discretionary-fee/incomplete-record analysis. It does not explain the eventual merits ground or replace this opinion’s reversal with a new merits ruling. The two opinions are linked by the same parties, Henao repair dispute and underlying county case; the 2024 opinion does not cite the 2021 opinion expressly. No complete citator or rehearing/mandate review was performed; broader status remains needs_verification. (2024 official opinion, pp. 1–3.)
Applies in →
Legal information, not legal advice.
Independent Primary-Text Comparison — 2026-10-17
Related 2024 fee appeal reports eventual FGAP merits victory but does not state the merits ground; relationship inferred from parties/repair/underlying case. Current operative comparison: § 559.917; § 559.919; § 713.585. Full holding verification is not a comprehensive still-good-law certificate. Where the former source URL failed, the working full-opinion source now appears in metadata; original failed receipts remain separate in the review evidence.
Legal information, not legal advice. Verify against the cited primary sources and consult a licensed Florida attorney before acting.