USA Foreclosure Wiki

United States v. Whiting Pools, Inc. (1983)

3 min read

United States v. Whiting Pools, Inc. (1983)

Citation: 462 U.S. 198 (No. 82-215) · Court: Supreme Court of the United States · Decided: June 8, 1983 (argued April 19, 1983) · Opinion: Blackmun, J., for a unanimous Court.

Facts

The IRS seized the tangible personal property of Whiting Pools, a swimming-pool business, to satisfy a federal tax lien. Promptly afterward, Whiting Pools filed a Chapter 11 petition. The Bankruptcy Court ordered the IRS to turn the property over on condition that the debtor provide specified protection for the IRS’s interest. The District Court reversed; the Court of Appeals held that a turnover order could issue against the IRS under 11 U.S.C. § 542(a).

Holding

  1. “The reorganization estate includes property of the debtor that has been seized by a creditor prior to the filing of a petition for reorganization.”
  2. “Section 542(a) authorizes the Bankruptcy Court to order the IRS to turn over the seized property.” The IRS “is bound by § 542(a) to the same extent as any secured creditor,” and “the Internal Revenue Code does not transfer ownership of such property until the property is sold to a bona fide purchaser at a tax sale.” (Syllabus.)

Reasoning

Congress chose to protect secured creditors “by imposing limits or conditions on the trustee’s power to sell, use, or lease property subject to a secured interest, rather than by excluding such property from the reorganization estate.” (Syllabus.) Under the Internal Revenue Code, a levy gives the IRS possession, but “[o]wnership of the property is transferred only when the property is sold to a bona fide purchaser at a tax sale,” citing 26 U.S.C. § 6339(a)(2); “[u]ntil such a sale takes place, the property remains the debtor’s, and thus is subject to the turnover requirement.”

Practical impact

  • Timing of title at an IRS sale. The buyer’s title arises at the sale and the § 6339 certificate, not at the seizure. Until then the owner may pay and recover the property (26 U.S.C. § 6337(a)) or a bankruptcy filing may pull it back into the estate.
  • Equipment and vehicles in bankruptcy. Equipment seized pre-petition by a creditor (here, the IRS) can be ordered returned to an operating Chapter 11 debtor, subject to adequate protection. A scheduled IRS or creditor auction can therefore be cancelled by a filing.
  • Compare city-of-chicago-v-fulton-2021 (mere retention of a seized vehicle does not violate the automatic stay; the § 542 turnover duty was left undecided).

Good-law status

Still good law; cited and distinguished in City of Chicago v. Fulton (2021).

Applies in →

All jurisdictions (federal bankruptcy and tax law). See forfeiture-and-government-seizure-sales, equipment-and-machinery, bankruptcy-363-sales, bankruptcy-automatic-stay-federal, federal-tax-liens.

Sources

Disclaimer. This page is legal information, not legal advice. It summarizes a court decision that may have been limited or distinguished by later authority. Nothing here creates an attorney-client relationship. Read the full opinion and consult a licensed attorney before acting.

Graph View

Backlinks