Buying a piece of equipment at a forced sale in New York
▸ For Buyers / Operators — Sale channels, title documents, surviving liens, taxes and the checklist appear below.
▸ For Owners / Debtors — Notice, redemption, proceeds and unsettled questions appear in the channel descriptions below.
How these sales happen in New York
Court and execution sales
-
Form and issuance: An execution names the judgment and parties. 1 It directs that “only the property in which a named judgment debtor … has an interest … be levied upon or sold.” 1 It may be issued by the clerk or by the creditor’s attorney “as officer of the court” to the sheriff of any county. 1 It must be returned within 60 days unless served, extendable in writing by up to 60 days at a time (1).
-
Payment terms and buyer document: CPLR 5233 supplies no statewide deposit/balance schedule; 2 permits court regulation of enforcement. 3 The 10% deposit/three-business-day balance/default provisions on the same page are expressly real-property terms. 4 The Erie civil division, changed September 8, 2026, specifies at least 10% cash at bidding’s close, balance by 4 p.m. that day unless preapproved, no credit bid without a pre-sale court order, and no release until full payment. 5 Its personalty documents are a receipt, release, certificate of sale and execution copy. 4 Erie does not state a bidder-default forfeiture/resale/damages rule there: needs_verification. 4 These are named local practices, not terms for every NY county or marshal. 4 No statute fixes a deposit, balance deadline, credit bid or bidder-default rule; terms come from the officer’s practice or a court order under CPLR 5240. 4 The NYC DOF terms above are †. 4
Administrative and tax sales
- Sale method: The officer proceeds “in all respects, with like effect, and in the same manner prescribed by law in respect to executions” (§ 692(f)), that is, CPLR 5233. 6 Sales-tax warrants work the same way under 7. 8 The § 692(c) assessment/demand timing is an income-tax provision; § 1141(b) is the separate sales-tax warrant authority. 6
Lienholder sales
-
Other notable liens (artisans, animals, carriers, jewellers, molds, breeding and more) — Artisan’s lien on personal property: Holder: A person who makes, alters, repairs or performs work on, or enhances the value of, an article of personal property at the owner’s request or consent, while lawfully in possession (§ 180). 9 Rank against a lender: Possessory service lien: UCC 9-333(b) gives it priority over a security interest in the goods unless the creating statute expressly provides otherwise, and this one does not. 9 Only where the 9-333(a) predicates are met (ordinary-course services or materials … Court and sale route: No court order: sale under Lien Law art. 9 (§§ 200-204). 9 The owner or anyone entitled to notice may bring a special proceeding within ten days of service to contest validity or … Public auction to the highest bidder in the city or town where the lien was acquired (Lien Law § 202(1)); bona fide private sale for property under USD 100 (§ 202(2)); redemption … Buyer’s title: No express purchaser-title or discharge clause. 9 The purchaser takes the owner’s interest freed of the lien being enforced; under UCC 9-315(a)(1) a security interest continues in the goods … 9
-
Other notable liens (artisans, animals, carriers, jewellers, molds, breeding and more) — Bailee of animals: veterinarians, livery, boarding and pasturing: Holder: A licensed veterinarian treating or boarding a domestic animal, or a livery, boarding-stable, pasturing or boarding keeper, including for kept wagons, trucks, carts, carriages, vehicles and harness, under an express or implied agreement with the owner, … Rank against a lender: Possessory service lien: UCC 9-333(b) gives it priority over a security interest in the goods unless the creating statute expressly provides otherwise, and this one does not. 9 Only where the 9-333(a) predicates are met (ordinary-course services or materials … Court and sale route: No court order: sale under Lien Law art. 9 (§§ 200-204). 9 The owner or anyone entitled to notice may bring a special proceeding within ten days of service to contest validity or … Public auction to the highest bidder in the city or town where the lien was acquired (Lien Law § 202(1)); bona fide private sale for property under USD 100 (§ 202(2)); redemption … Buyer’s title: No express purchaser-title or discharge clause. 9 The purchaser takes the owner’s interest freed of the lien being enforced; under UCC 9-315(a)(1) a security interest continues in the goods … 9
-
Other notable liens (artisans, animals, carriers, jewellers, molds, breeding and more) — Truckmen and draymen lien: Holder: A person carting or trucking property, who may retain enough of it to secure compensation (§ 187(1)). 9 Rank against a lender: Possessory service lien: UCC 9-333(b) gives it priority over a security interest in the goods unless the creating statute expressly provides otherwise, and this one does not. 9 Only where the 9-333(a) predicates are met (ordinary-course services or materials … Court and sale route: No (§ 187(2)); action under art. 9 preserved. 9 Public sale (§ 187(2)). 9 Buyer’s title: No express purchaser-title or discharge clause. 9 The purchaser takes the owner’s interest freed of the lien being enforced; under UCC 9-315(a)(1) a security interest continues in the goods … 9
-
Other notable liens (artisans, animals, carriers, jewellers, molds, breeding and more) — Watch, clock and jewelry repair lien: Holder: A person performing work on a watch, clock or jewelry for a price (§ 186). 9 Rank against a lender: Possessory service lien: UCC 9-333(b) gives it priority over a security interest in the goods unless the creating statute expressly provides otherwise, and this one does not. 9 Only where the 9-333(a) predicates are met (ordinary-course services or materials … Court and sale route: No (§ 186); enforcement by action under art. 9 remains available. 9 Public or bona fide private sale (§ 186). 9 Buyer’s title: No express purchaser-title or discharge clause. 9 The purchaser takes the owner’s interest freed of the lien being enforced; under UCC 9-315(a)(1) a security interest continues in the goods … 9
-
Other notable liens (artisans, animals, carriers, jewellers, molds, breeding and more) — Mold, die, form and pattern lien: Holder: A molder (including a tool or die maker) holding a customer’s dies, molds, forms or patterns (§§ 150-151). 10 Rank against a lender: Expressly junior: the lien ‘shall not have priority over any security interest … that is perfected at the time the molder acquires the lien’ (§ 151). 10 Court and sale route: No; the customer may bring a proceeding within ten days of the sale notice to fix the amount (§ 154(1)(e)). 10 Buyer’s title: No purchaser-title clause; the lien is junior to security interests perfected when it arose (§ 151), and such interests continue under UCC 9-315(a)(1) unless their holder authorized a disposition … 10
Where sales are announced
-
Legal-notice statute: Where law requires newspaper publication, a “newspaper” must be of general circulation, printed and distributed at least weekly for one year, with paid circulation and periodicals-mail entry, subject to § 60(a)‘s express grandfather exceptions for qualifying older publications. 11 Free advertising papers do not qualify (11).
-
Erie County Sheriff Civil Enforcement: Erie County Sheriff Civil Enforcement, changed September 8, 2026, links its scheduled sheriff-sale portal and describes personalty auctions at the property location, documents and payment terms (§ 12.1). Its statutory sale postings remain local. Erie County Sheriff Civil Enforcement This verifies one upstate officer’s practice, not all 57 non-NYC counties. Erie County Sheriff Civil Enforcement
Official channels listed in section 12.7:
What the buyer gets
-
The buyer takes only “the interest of the judgment debtor” (12). Seizure must not interfere with pledgees or lessees (CPLR 5232(b)). 12
-
“Nothing herein shall be deemed to defeat or impair the rights of any secured party” under UCC 9-102 (13).
Taxes and fees
- Equipment / business assets: Taxable retail tangible-property receipts: 4% plus applicable local tax (§§ 1101(b)(4), 1105(a)), subject to asset/use exemptions rather than a general forced-sale exemption. 14 The USD 600 residential occasional-sale rule excludes sheriff/auctioneer sales (§ 1115(a)(18)). 14 DTF’s 15, estate-sales/auctions section, expressly assigns collection to auctioneer/sheriff/third party. 16 DTF 17 includes a buyer’s premium in taxable receipts on its stated facts. 18 includes receivers, trustees, assignees and other fiduciaries in “person”; 19 includes vendors among persons required to collect. 20 A fiduciary making taxable sales as a vendor therefore has collection obligations, not a status-based exemption. 14 This does not by itself impose personal liability for every preappointment debt or resolve the distinct bulk-sale exclusions. 14 Bulk-sale successor liability is a separate issue (§ 12.5) 14
Step-by-step checklist
- Check the sale was held in the town where the lien arose, after two weekly publications, 15+ days after the first (Lien Law § 202(1)). 21 Collect the original clipping and affidavit of publication (MV-901C ¶¶ 4–5). 21
Open questions
Section 12 leaves the following matters unsettled (needs_verification).
-
“Special mobile equipment” and “implement[s] of husbandry” are excluded (§ 2102(a)(6)–(7)) and do not receive DMV title by that provision. Particular transfer-proof or other recording requirements remain needs_verification; exclusion from DMV title is not itself a complete conveyancing/document rule.
-
Onondaga field operations: Onondaga field operations describes execution levies; it is an operational contact source, not proof of a current personalty auction calendar.
Related
new-york, equipment-and-machinery, erie-ny, new-york-ny, onondaga-ny, suffolk-ny
Primary sources
Legal information, not legal advice. Verify against the cited primary sources before acting. Last verified: 2026-10-17.
Footnotes
-
CPLR 5240; NYC DOF auction instructions; Erie civil division ↩ ↩2 ↩3 ↩4 ↩5 ↩6
-
UCC 9-315(a)(1); UCC 9-333(b) ↩ ↩2 ↩3 ↩4 ↩5 ↩6 ↩7 ↩8 ↩9 ↩10 ↩11 ↩12 ↩13 ↩14 ↩15 ↩16 ↩17 ↩18 ↩19 ↩20 ↩21
-
Sales From Your Home bulletin; TSB-A-24(48)S (Oct. 16, 2024); Tax Law § 1101(a); § 1131(1) ↩ ↩2 ↩3 ↩4 ↩5
-
TSB-A-24(48)S (Oct. 16, 2024); Tax Law § 1101(a); § 1131(1) ↩
-
Sales From Your Home bulletin; Tax Law § 1101(a); § 1131(1) ↩
-
Sales From Your Home bulletin; TSB-A-24(48)S (Oct. 16, 2024) ↩