New York — Tax & Mortgage Foreclosure
Legal information, not legal advice. Verify against the cited primary sources before acting. Last verified: 2026-06-02.
New York is the structurally unusual case in the post-tyler-v-hennepin-county landscape: from 1995 until 2024 its Real Property Tax Law (RPTL) Article 11 in rem tax-foreclosure scheme gave the foreclosing tax district fee simple absolute in the parcel — including 100% of any equity above the tax debt, with no surplus distribution at all. Tyler v. Hennepin County (2023) rendered that unconstitutional, and New York rewrote Article 11 in 2024 (L.2024, ch.55, pt.BB), adding a brand-new Title 6 — Distribution of Surplus (RPTL §§ 1196–1197), retroactive to Tyler’s decision date of May 25, 2023. Surplus practice in New York is therefore very new and still being litigated.
0. Identity & Classification
- Recording unit: county (62 counties; New York City’s five counties/boroughs enforce under their own NYC Administrative Code in rem scheme rather than RPTL Art. 11). Count: 62 counties.
- Tax sale type: Tax deed via in rem foreclosure (not a lien-certificate state in the Florida/Arizona sense). The county/tax district forecloses the tax lien in a judicial in rem proceeding and the property is then deeded or sold; some counties also conduct tax-lien sales by local law (e.g., NYC sells liens to a trust). Classify as tax_deed with judicial in rem process.
- Tax foreclosure process: judicial (in rem) under RPTL Art. 11, Title 3 (§§ 1120–1137). RPTL Art. 11
- Mortgage foreclosure process: judicial only (New York has no power-of-sale / non-judicial mortgage foreclosure). RPAPL Art. 13. RPAPL Art. 13
- Selling authority: the enforcing officer of the tax district (typically the county treasurer / commissioner of finance; in some jurisdictions the county attorney prosecutes the proceeding).
- Statutory home: RPTL Article 11 (§§ 1100–1198) — Procedures for Enforcement of Collection of Delinquent Taxes. Justia: RPTL Art. 11
- Tyler v. Hennepin compliance: reformed_post_Tyler. The pre-2024 scheme (district keeps all surplus) was non-compliant; L.2024, ch.55, pt.BB added RPTL §§ 1196–1197 creating a surplus determination and claim process, retroactive to May 25, 2023. Phillips Lytle review
1. Tax Sale Mechanics
- What is sold: the parcel itself, by deed, after an in rem judgment of foreclosure (RPTL § 1136). Pre-2024 the district simply took title; post-reform a district may take title, sell at public auction, transfer to a third party, or convey back to the former owner on payment of arrears. RPTL Title 3
- Bidding method: where a public auction is held, highest-bid deed (premium bidding); there is no statewide bid-down-interest mechanic because the lien itself is not auctioned in the Art. 11 scheme.
- Interest / penalty on delinquency: 1% per month (≈12% per annum) under RPTL § 924-a, the default statewide rate “for each month or fraction thereof until such taxes are paid”; unchanged since 1983. Some special districts/cities set their own rates outside § 924-a. NY Tax Dept § 924-a · RPTL § 924-a
- Minimum bid composition: the total of delinquent taxes, accrued interest at the § 924-a rate, penalties, and other charges as defined by RPTL § 1102.
- Sale frequency / typical month: varies by county; the enforcing officer executes the petition of foreclosure 21 months after lien date (33 or 45 months for parcels with extended 3- or 4-year redemption periods) under RPTL § 1123, with sale after judgment. No single statewide auction month. RPTL § 1123
- Venue: both in-person and online, by county.
- Platform vendors: varies by county (commonly Auctions International and similar vendors for upstate counties). County-specific — see county pages.
- Registration / deposit: set by the county conducting the auction.
- Subsequent taxes (“subs”): not applicable in lien-certificate form; ongoing taxes continue to accrue against the parcel until the in rem judgment.
2. Right of Redemption → see right-of-redemption
- Pre-sale / pre-judgment right: Yes. Under RPTL § 1110, real property subject to a delinquent tax lien may be redeemed by paying the enforcing officer the full delinquent lien plus all charges authorized by law, on or before the expiration of the redemption period. RPTL § 1110
- Redemption period: two (2) years after lien date by default (RPTL § 1110). A tax district may extend the period for residential or farm property (§ 1111), or reduce it to one (1) year for residential vacant-and-abandoned property placed on a vacant/abandoned registry before the taxes became delinquent (§ 1111-a). If the § 1124 published notice specifies a later expiration date, that later date controls. RPTL § 1110
- Who may redeem: any person with a right, title, interest, or equity of redemption in the parcel (owner, lienholder, mortgagee) — RPTL § 1110.
- Amount formula: delinquent tax lien(s) + § 924-a interest + penalties + lawful charges (RPTL §§ 1110, 1102).
- Premium to certificate holder: N/A (deed/in rem scheme; no certificate investor in the Art. 11 model).
- Procedure: pay the enforcing officer; on a parcel listed under § 1122 the officer issues a certificate of redemption that is filed with the county clerk (RPTL § 1110).
- Extinguishment: failure to redeem or answer by the redemption deadline bars and forecloses all right, title, interest and equity of redemption, and a judgment of foreclosure may be taken by default (RPTL § 1131). A motion to reopen a default may not be brought later than one month after entry of judgment. RPTL § 1131
- Special tolling: redemption-period extensions for residential/farm property (§ 1111). General tolling for minors/incompetents and federal stays (bankruptcy-automatic-stay, scra-protections) — see needs_verification.
3. Surplus / Excess Proceeds → see surplus-funds, third-party-recovery-rules
- Belongs to: priority waterfall (post-reform). Surplus is adjudicated and distributed “in the same manner as in an action to foreclose a mortgage” under RPAPL Article 13, so former owner equity is paid after senior liens. Before the 2024 reform, surplus belonged entirely to the tax district. RPTL § 1197
- Surplus determination: within 45 days after the sale, the enforcing officer must determine whether a surplus exists and its amount — sale proceeds (or, for a non-public sale, full value per the tax roll, a licensed NY appraisal, or another reasonable valuation method) minus taxes + interest + penalties + § 1102 charges (RPTL § 1196). RPTL § 1196 · § 1196 (public.law)
- Who may claim: any person who had a right, title, interest, claim, lien, or equity of redemption in the parcel immediately prior to the judgment of foreclosure (RPTL § 1197).
- Filing venue: the court having jurisdiction over the in rem proceeding (the surplus claim is part of, and adjudicated within, the foreclosure proceeding), per RPAPL Art. 13 surplus-money procedure. RPTL § 1197
- Claim deadline: a written claim may be filed before confirmation of the report of sale; for residential property with unclaimed surplus the proceeding remains open at least three (3) years from confirmation, and a former homeowner who files within that window is treated as timely (RPTL § 1197).
- Escheat: unclaimed surplus is not remitted to the State Comptroller’s unclaimed-funds office; under RPTL § 1197 it is paid to the tax district and used to reduce its tax levy. (This is the opposite of the usual escheat-to-state rule and is the key reason the APL § 1416 finder cap below does not cleanly apply.)
- Documentation required: written notice of claim stating the nature and extent of the claim and the claimant’s (or attorney’s) address; proof of pre-judgment interest. See county/court surplus-claim instructions.
- Notice to former owner required? The 2024 reform created the surplus right but the Seelbach court (below) held there is no constitutional or statutory entitlement to particularized notice of surplus rights beyond ordinary § 1125 foreclosure notice — recourse for more notice is “to the Legislature.”
- Third-party recovery (surplus-recovery agents):
- fee_cap_pct: null / unsettled. New York’s only on-point statutory finder cap is Abandoned Property Law § 1416 = 15% of recoverable property — but that statute governs property held by the State Comptroller. RPTL surplus is held in court and (if unclaimed) goes to the tax district, not the Comptroller, so § 1416’s 15% cap does not plainly govern RPTL tax-foreclosure surplus. Flagged in needs_verification. APL § 1416
- licensing_required: APL § 1416 imposes disclosure/validity rules on “abandoned property location services” for Comptroller-held funds; no separate statewide license is specified there. Applicability to RPTL surplus unsettled.
- assignment_of_claim_allowed: not specified by RPTL Art. 11; surplus claims are litigated within the foreclosure proceeding under RPAPL Art. 13. Flagged.
- cooling_off_period: none specified for RPTL surplus.
- contract_disclosure_rules: for Comptroller-held funds, APL § 1416 requires a 12-point boldface disclosure that funds can be claimed directly without a fee, and voids fees above 15%. APL § 1416
- prohibited_practices: APL § 1416 voids agreements with excessive/unjust consideration and those lacking required disclosures (Comptroller-held funds).
- citation: Abandoned Property Law § 1416; RPTL §§ 1196–1197.
▸ For Investors / Operators — New York’s Article 11 in rem scheme conveys the parcel by deed after a judicial judgment of foreclosure; post-2024 reform (RPTL §§ 1196–1197) routes any surplus through the RPAPL Art. 13 priority waterfall, with former-owner equity paid after senior liens. Before committing capital, weigh the redemption risk (§2/2b — the 2-year default § 1110 redemption, extendable for residential/farm property, runs until the deed executes under § 1136), the path to marketable/insurable title (§5b — RPAPL Art. 15 quiet title in Supreme Court vs. the § 1137 two-year conclusive-presumption period and 6-year CPLR 213 seasoning; NY has no Marketable Record Title Act), and which liens survive (§7b — federal tax liens and CERCLA claims if the U.S. was not noticed, NYC ECB liens converted to tax liens, and the IRS § 7425 120-day redemption).
▸ For Former Owners — Surplus practice in New York is new (the 2024 reform added RPTL §§ 1196–1197, retroactive to May 25, 2023). When a parcel sells for more than the taxes, interest, penalties, and § 1102 charges, the surplus is adjudicated within the in rem proceeding under RPAPL Art. 13 and paid to interests that existed before the judgment in priority order; for residential property the proceeding stays open at least three years from confirmation of the sale report (§ 1197). The enforcing officer determines surplus within 45 days of the sale (§ 1196). Note: unclaimed RPTL surplus is paid to the tax district, not the State Comptroller.
4. Mortgage Foreclosure
- Process: judicial only. New York has no non-judicial/power-of-sale mortgage foreclosure; lenders must bring an RPAPL Article 13 action and obtain a judgment of foreclosure and sale. RPAPL Art. 13
- One-action / election of remedies: RPAPL § 1301 — a lender may pursue the note or foreclose the mortgage but not simultaneously seek a money judgment and foreclose on the same debt (one-action rule, § 1301(3)). RPAPL § 1301
- Timeline (days): highly variable (often well over a year given mandatory CPLR 3408 settlement conferences for home loans); no fixed statutory NOD/NOS clock like trustee-sale states. Flagged for precise figures.
- Reinstatement right: borrowers may generally cure/reinstate before judgment; specific statutory section not separately verified — flagged.
- Redemption after sale: None. New York recognizes the equity of redemption only up to the foreclosure sale; there is no post-sale statutory redemption period. RPAPL § 1352 (strict foreclosure) fixes/cuts off any remaining equity of redemption of omitted parties. RPAPL § 1352
- Deficiency judgment: allowed with a mandatory fair-value offset. Under RPAPL § 1371, a deficiency motion must be made within 90 days after the deed delivery, and the deficiency equals the debt (plus prior liens, interest, costs) less the higher of the fair market value (as determined by the court) or the sale price. RPAPL § 1371
- Surplus distribution: sale proceeds exceeding the judgment are paid into court and distributed via surplus-money proceedings by lien priority (RPAPL §§ 1354, 1361). RPAPL § 1361
- Sale officer: referee appointed by the court (not a sheriff or trustee).
5. Sale Procedure Playbooks
- Tax (in rem) sale — ordered steps → see treasurer-sale:
- Taxes become delinquent; § 924-a interest accrues at 1%/month.
- Redemption period runs (2 yrs default from lien date; § 1110).
- Enforcing officer executes the list of delinquent taxes (10 months after lien date; § 1122), then the petition of foreclosure (21 months after lien date — 33/45 months for extended redemption; § 1123), with mailed and published notice of foreclosure (§§ 1124–1125).
- Interested parties must redeem or answer by the deadline; default bars all interests (§ 1131).
- Judgment of foreclosure awards title/possession (§ 1136); property is sold at public auction or otherwise disposed.
- Within 45 days of sale, enforcing officer determines surplus (§ 1196).
- Claimants file; surplus distributed by RPAPL Art. 13 priority; residential proceedings stay open ≥3 years (§ 1197). RPTL Title 3
- Mortgage / referee sale — ordered steps → see sheriff-sale:
- Lender files RPAPL Art. 13 complaint + lis pendens; CPLR 3408 settlement conference for home loans.
- Judgment of foreclosure and sale; referee appointed.
- Notice of sale published; public auction by referee.
- Referee distributes per RPAPL § 1354; surplus paid into court (§ 1361).
- Deficiency motion within 90 days with fair-value offset (§ 1371).
- Notice requirements: RPTL §§ 1124–1125 require mailed notice to owners/interested parties of record and published notice; due-process adequacy governed by Mullane, Mennonite, Jones v. Flowers, and NY’s Kennedy v. Mossafa.
- Upset bid / confirmation: tax in rem sale results are reported and confirmed by the court; surplus determination keyed to the report/confirmation (RPTL §§ 1196–1197).
- Payment terms: set by the conducting county/court.
- Deed issued: tax in rem judgment conveys title to the tax district / purchaser (RPTL § 1136); referee’s deed in mortgage foreclosure (RPAPL § 1353).
6. Due Process & Notice → see due-process-notice
- Standard: notice “reasonably calculated, under all the circumstances, to apprise” interested parties of the proceeding and afford an opportunity to be heard (mullane-v-central-hanover standard, adopted by NY).
- Required attempts: mailed notice to owners/lienholders of record (RPTL § 1125); where mailed notice is returned, NY requires reasonable additional steps — under Kennedy v. Mossafa (100 N.Y.2d 1 [2003]) and MacNaughton v. Warren County (20 N.Y.3d 252 [2012]) the enforcing officer must, when notice is returned as undeliverable, conduct a reasonable search of the public record (though it need not search the internet, telephone directories, voting/motor-vehicle records, or out-of-county/out-of-state records), consistent with jones-v-flowers. Mortgagees of record whose interests are reasonably ascertainable are entitled to actual (mailed) notice (mennonite-v-adams).
- Consequence of defective notice: judgment/deed is voidable as to the party denied constitutionally adequate notice (the 2-year SOL to vacate a tax deed does not run against a party who never received due-process notice).
- Leading cases: kennedy-v-mossafa, macnaughton-v-warren-county, matter-of-foreclosure-of-tax-liens-seelbach-2024, tyler-v-hennepin-county, mullane-v-central-hanover, mennonite-v-adams, jones-v-flowers.
7. Title & Marketability
- Deed warranty level: tax in rem deed conveys whatever title the judgment vests (no warranties); referee’s deed in mortgage foreclosure likewise conveys without covenants.
- Marketable immediately? Practically no — title companies typically require the in rem proceeding to be unassailable and often a quiet-title action or the running of the limitations period before insuring.
- Quiet title required? Frequently, especially where notice to any interested party is questionable.
- SOL to challenge the tax deed: a referee’s/tax deed becomes conclusive evidence of regularity after a limitations period (the NYSBA practice commentary describes a two-year period to set aside a referee’s deed), but that bar does not run against a party denied due-process notice. Exact RPTL section flagged for verification. NYSBA surplus article
- Title insurance availability: available but usually only after curative steps (proof of regular service, expiration of challenge period, or quiet title).
- Common defects: defective/returned-mail notice; omitted necessary parties (cured by RPAPL § 1352 strict foreclosure); unresolved surplus claims post-Tyler.
8. Case Law (real, verified)
| Case | Year | Topic | Holding (plain English) | Source |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| matter-of-foreclosure-of-tax-liens-seelbach-2024 | 2024 | surplus, due_process, tyler | NY Supreme Court (trial): the mere pendency of an RPTL Art. 11 foreclosure does not itself risk a Takings violation under Tyler; owners have no constitutional or statutory entitlement to particularized notice of surplus rights beyond ordinary foreclosure notice — recourse for more notice is to the Legislature. (2024 NY Slip Op 24216) | https://www.nycourts.gov/Reporter/3dseries/2024/2024_24216.htm |
| kennedy-v-mossafa | 2003 | due_process, sale_procedure | Court of Appeals: due process requires notice reasonably calculated to apprise the owner; the enforcing officer’s duty is not always satisfied by mailing to the tax-roll address — when mailed notice is returned undeliverable, the district must generally conduct a reasonable search of the public record, though on the facts (mail returned “unclaimed,” correct address) no further search was required and it need not hunt down a missing taxpayer. (100 N.Y.2d 1) | https://nysba.org/due-process-and-due-diligence-claiming-surplus-in-new-yorks-in-rem-tax-foreclosures/ |
| macnaughton-v-warren-county | 2012 | due_process, sale_procedure | Court of Appeals: where mailed notice to the property owners was returned undeliverable, the tax district must take reasonable additional steps — a reasonable search of its own public records — but need not search out-of-county/out-of-state or attempt personal service; on these facts the county satisfied due process. Refined the Kennedy v. Mossafa “reasonable search” duty. (20 N.Y.3d 252; 2012 NY Slip Op 08442) | https://www.nycourts.gov/Reporter/3dseries/2012/2012_08442.htm |
| tyler-v-hennepin-county | 2023 | surplus, tyler | U.S. Supreme Court: retaining surplus equity beyond the tax debt after a tax foreclosure is an unconstitutional taking; the owner must have an opportunity to recover the excess. Drove NY’s 2024 RPTL Art. 11 reform. (598 U.S. 631) | https://phillipslytle.com/a-review-of-new-yorks-response-to-tyler-v-hennepin-county/ |
9. Edge Cases (state-specific notes)
- bankruptcy-automatic-stay — A Chapter 13 filing before the redemption deadline can preserve/cure delinquent taxes; the automatic stay tolls the in rem proceeding. NY-specific tolling interaction with RPTL § 1110 deadline flagged for verification.
- federal-tax-lien-redemption — The IRS retains a 120-day right of redemption under 26 U.S.C. § 7425 when a federal tax lien is junior and the U.S. is properly noticed; applies to NY tax/mortgage sales alike (federal law).
- heirs-property — Co-owned/inherited parcels: each heir with an interest may redeem (RPTL § 1110) and claim a pro-rata share of any § 1197 surplus.
- mortgagee-notice — Mortgagees of record whose interests are reasonably ascertainable must receive actual (mailed) notice (mennonite-v-adams); the NY return-mail duty to make a reasonable record search runs to all parties of record (Kennedy v. Mossafa; MacNaughton v. Warren County).
- void-vs-voidable — NY treats a deed obtained without due-process notice as voidable by the un-noticed party notwithstanding the deed-challenge limitations period (Kennedy v. Mossafa line).
- HOA super-priority / manufactured homes / SCRA — not separately verified for NY; flagged.
10. Operations
- Where records live: county clerk (deeds, lis pendens, lists of delinquent taxes), the in rem foreclosure court file, and the enforcing officer’s surplus-determination record (RPTL § 1196).
- Public access URLs:
- RPTL Article 11: https://law.justia.com/codes/new-york/rpt/article-11/
- NY Tax Dept judicial cases: https://www.tax.ny.gov/research/property/legal/judicial-cases.htm
- NY § 924-a interest rates: https://www.tax.ny.gov/research/property/legal/Int_rates_sec924a.htm
- NY Courts surplus-claim instructions (mortgage): https://www.nycourts.gov/forms/foreclosure/pdfs/8%20-%20Instructions%20to%20Claim%20Surplus%20Monies.pdf
- NY Comptroller unclaimed funds: https://www.osc.ny.gov/unclaimed-funds
- Typical costs/timelines: in rem petition no sooner than 21 months after lien date; 2-year default redemption; surplus determination within 45 days of sale; residential surplus proceeding stays open ≥3 years.
- Key agencies: county treasurer / commissioner of finance (enforcing officer), county attorney, NY State Department of Taxation and Finance (ORPTS), NY Unified Court System, Office of the State Comptroller (separate unclaimed-funds pool).
- Useful forms: county surplus-claim notice (RPTL § 1197); RPAPL Art. 13 surplus-money claim forms; APL location-service-provider disclosure (Comptroller funds only).
2b. Redemption Advanced
Assignability of the Redemption Right
- Assignable: Yes — in New York’s in rem scheme the right to redeem belongs to “any person having or claiming to have an interest” in the parcel (RPTL § 1110; every such person “may redeem such parcel”). Because the statute is not restricted to the record owner, redemption rights may be exercised by, or transferred to, any party holding a legally cognizable interest (e.g., lienholders, mortgagees, heirs). There is no express statutory prohibition on assignment; however, there is also no express statutory mechanism for a bare assignment of the bare redemption right to a third party who holds no prior interest. In practice, a third party who wishes to acquire the redemption right typically does so by taking an assignment of a mortgage or other interest in the parcel first.
- Restrictions: No express “heirs and mortgagees only” limitation; any person with right, title, interest, or equity of redemption may redeem (RPTL § 1110). RPTL § 1194 (Title 5 tax-lien-sale track) expressly recognizes “successors or assigns” of a tax-lien purchaser. RPTL § 1110 · RPTL § 1194
- Purchase mechanism: Assignment of an interest (mortgage, judgment lien, etc.) in the parcel before redemption deadline, then exercise of redemption in the assignee’s own name. No specific deed-of-assignment form is prescribed by RPTL Article 11.
- Statute / case: RPTL § 1110; RPTL § 1194(1) (“the purchaser of a delinquent tax lien, or its successors or assigns, may foreclose the lien”). RPTL § 1194
Equitable Redemption vs. Statutory Redemption
- Distinct from statutory? In New York’s in rem scheme, the distinction largely collapses: the statutory redemption under RPTL § 1110 runs until entry of the final judgment (and technically until execution of the deed — property rights are “finally foreclosed only when the enforcing officer executes a deed,” per tax counsel authority and RPTL § 1136). The equity of redemption as a common-law concept is subsumed by the statutory scheme and is co-extensive with it.
- Available pre-sale only: Yes. There is no post-sale statutory redemption period in New York in rem tax foreclosure (contrast Title 5 lien-sale foreclosures under § 1194, which follow mortgage-foreclosure procedures including post-sale redemption equivalent). RPAPL mortgage foreclosures similarly extinguish the equity of redemption at the sale; see Module 4.
- Notes: RPTL § 1131 bars all right, title, interest, and equity of redemption upon a default judgment; RPTL § 1136 bars all interests upon execution of the deed. A party denied constitutionally adequate notice may still hold a claim notwithstanding the deed (Kennedy v. Mossafa / MacNaughton line).
Installment Redemption
- Permitted? Not generally under RPTL Article 11. The statute contemplates a lump-sum payment of all delinquent liens + interest + charges (RPTL § 1110). Tax districts may enter payment agreements before the petition is filed (pre-petition informal repayment), but once a petition of foreclosure is executed the enforcing officer may permit only full redemption. Specific installment-redemption statute not located — flagged needs_verification.
Assignment of Tax Certificate / Deed Mid-Period
- Permitted? Yes. RPTL § 1194(1) explicitly authorizes the “purchaser of a delinquent tax lien, or its successors or assigns” to foreclose the lien. This confirms that a tax-lien certificate (Title 5 track) is freely assignable during the redemption period. The in rem deed issued under Title 3 by the tax district may likewise be conveyed; RPTL § 1136 imposes no restriction on the district’s subsequent alienation of acquired fee title.
- Restrictions: None stated; standard real-property assignment/conveyance rules apply.
- Statute: RPTL § 1194(1). RPTL § 1194
3b. Surplus Advanced
Claim Assignability
- Full assignment permitted? RPTL §§ 1196–1197 do not expressly authorize or prohibit full assignment of a surplus claim. Surplus claims are litigated as part of the in rem foreclosure proceeding under RPAPL Article 13 surplus-money procedures. Because surplus claims are judicial claims filed within an ongoing court proceeding, a bare assignment of the right to collect surplus to a third party is legally uncertain — the more common and defensible structure is a contingency-fee agreement rather than an outright assignment of the claim itself. Flagged needs_verification.
- Assignment vs. fee agreement: The operative distinction in New York is whether the claimant assigns the claim outright (transferring standing) vs. retaining standing and engaging a recovery agent on a contingency. The latter is clearly permissible; the former raises champerty concerns under Judiciary Law § 489 (assignment of claims to “exact usurious interest” or for profit in litigation is a misdemeanor and voids the contract). Whether Judiciary Law § 489 bars outright assignment of an RPTL surplus claim is not settled by retrieved case law — flagged needs_verification. NY Judiciary Law § 489
- Fee cap applies to assignments? RPTL §§ 1196–1197 impose no fee cap. APL § 1416’s 15% cap applies only to Comptroller-held abandoned property, not RPTL surplus held in court (see Module 3, needs_verification). Flagged.
- Statute: RPTL §§ 1196–1197; APL § 1416; Judiciary Law § 489.
Statute of Limitations
- Period: For residential property the proceeding remains open at least three years from confirmation of the sale report (RPTL § 1197); a former homeowner filing within that window is timely. For non-residential property, the statute is less clear. The NYSBA has noted there is “no apparent statute of limitations for asserting claims to a surplus, specifically when alleging due-process violations.” RPTL § 1197
- Trigger: Date of confirmation of the report of sale (RPTL § 1197 refers to the confirmation of the sale report).
- Citation: RPTL § 1197; NYSBA, “Due Process and Due Diligence,” retrieved 2026-06-02. NYSBA article
Competing Claimant Procedure
- Filing race? No — RPTL § 1197 incorporates RPAPL Article 13 surplus-money procedures, which use a judicial referee model: the court appoints a Surplus Moneys Referee who takes evidence of all claims, ascertains the amount due to each claimant, and reports lien priorities.
- Interpleader used? Not formally; the surplus fund is deposited with the court and the court distributes via the referee’s report mechanism (RPAPL § 1361). Competing claimants argue their priority before the referee.
- Priority rules: Interests that existed before the sale attach to the surplus in the same priority order as they existed against the land (RPAPL § 1361). Former owner equity is paid last, after all senior lienholders.
- Citation: RPTL § 1197; RPAPL § 1361. RPAPL § 1361
Deceased Owner Procedure
- Probate required first? Under RPAPL Article 13 surplus-money procedure (incorporated by RPTL § 1197), if the property belonged to a decedent, surplus funds must be directed to Surrogate’s Court if: (a) fewer than 18 months have elapsed since letters testamentary/administration issued, (b) settlement proceedings commenced within 18 months and remain pending, or (c) no letters issued and fewer than two years have passed since death. In that scenario the Surrogate administers the surplus as part of the estate.
- Personal representative has standing: Yes, once letters testamentary or of administration are issued.
- Direct heir claim permitted? Only if letters have issued or no estate proceedings are pending and two-plus years have elapsed since death.
- Notes: Source is RPAPL Art. 13 surplus-money procedure as incorporated by RPTL § 1197. See also RPAPL § 1361. RPAPL § 1361 (courtstreetlaw analysis)
Fraudulent Conveyance Exposure
- Assignment voidable by creditors? Yes. If a property owner assigns their surplus claim (or any interest in the surplus) while insolvent or with intent to hinder creditors, the assignment is voidable under New York’s Uniform Voidable Transactions Act (UVTA), Debtor & Creditor Law Article 10 (effective April 4, 2020 for transfers on/after that date).
- Applicable statute: NY Debtor & Creditor Law Article 10 (UVTA), effective April 4, 2020 (L.2019, ch. 580). For transfers before April 4, 2020: former Uniform Fraudulent Conveyance Act.
- SOL for UVTA claims: Constructive fraud — 4 years from transfer; actual fraud — 1 year from discovery (UVTA § 278). Pre-April 2020 transfers: 6-year SOL. UVTA alert (Olshan)
- Notes: A surplus-claim assignment made when the owner is insolvent and for less than reasonably equivalent value is a classic constructive-fraud voidable transfer under UVTA § 274.
Surplus Claimant Notice
- Court must notify lienholders? The Seelbach (2024) court held there is no constitutional or statutory entitlement to particularized notice of surplus rights beyond ordinary § 1125 foreclosure notice. RPTL § 1196 requires the enforcing officer to notify the former owner within 10 days of filing the surplus-determination report with the court. RPTL § 1196
- Method: Written notice; § 1196 does not specify the form of the 10-day owner notice beyond “notification.”
- Timeline: Within 10 days of filing the surplus-determination report with the court (RPTL § 1196).
- Citation: RPTL § 1196; Matter of Foreclosure of Tax Liens (Seelbach), 2024 NY Slip Op 24216.
5b. Title Advanced
Quiet Title
- When required: Recommended after every tax in rem sale; effectively required before any sophisticated buyer or title insurer will accept the title without a waiting period. Specifically needed where: notice to any interested party was questionable; the in rem deed was recently issued (within the two-year challenge window under RPTL § 1137); any lien or mortgage was not clearly extinguished.
- Action type: Judicial — under RPAPL Article 15 (“Action to Compel the Determination of a Claim to Real Property”), filed as a plenary action. RPAPL Art. 15
- Court with jurisdiction: New York Supreme Court (county-level court of general jurisdiction). The action is filed in the Supreme Court in the county where the property is located.
- Typical timeline: Uncontested: 60–120 days (some sources say 3–4 months); contested: 6 months to over a year. If publication-service is required (unknown defendants), add 6–8 weeks for the publication run. LegalClarity quiet title guide
- Typical cost range: Legal fees typically $3,000–$10,000+ for uncontested actions; more for contested. Filing fees: Supreme Court index fee ~$210; additional per-county costs apply.
- Cures all pre-sale defects? A judgment quieting title under RPAPL Article 15 eliminates competing claims and “clouds on title” as of the date of judgment. It does not retroactively cure a void deed (one obtained without any constitutional notice), but it is the practical mechanism to adjudicate and resolve all adverse claimants.
- Citation: RPAPL Article 15 (§§ 1501 et seq.); RPTL § 1137 (two-year challenge period / conclusive presumption for in rem deed). RPTL § 1137
Deed Seasoning
- Insurers require seasoning? Yes — as a practical matter, most title insurance underwriters require either (a) a quiet title action, or (b) the expiration of the six-year CPLR 213(4) limitations period for actions on instruments affecting title (some practitioners also reference RPTL § 1137’s two-year conclusive-presumption period as a minimum). LegalClarity: “title insurance companies often refuse to insure tax deed properties until a quiet title action is completed or six years have passed”
- Typical years: 2 years (RPTL § 1137 conclusive presumption) to 6 years (CPLR 213), depending on the insurer’s underwriting appetite.
- Rationale: Void-deed risk (party denied due-process notice may still challenge beyond the limitations period); post-Tyler uncertainty around surplus claims (new 2024 regime, still litigated); omitted-party risk.
Title Insurance
- Immediate availability? No — title insurers typically decline to insure immediately after a tax in rem sale.
- Conditions for immediate: Acceptable immediately only with a completed quiet title action (RPAPL Art. 15 judgment) or, in some underwriters’ practice, after the RPTL § 1137 two-year presumption period has run with no challenge filed.
- Insurers known to write: Fidelity National Title, First American, Stewart, Old Republic — all insure NY tax-deed titles after curative steps; specific underwriting guidelines vary by office. Specific underwriter list needs_verification.
- Quitclaim or special warranty only? The in rem deed issued under RPTL § 1136 conveys title without express covenants (no warranty); however a RPAPL Art. 15 quiet title judgment enables the grant of a full-covenant deed by a subsequent grantor.
Marketable Title Act
- Exists in New York? No. New York has not adopted a Marketable Record Title Act (MRTA). Legislation was proposed in the 2001–2002 session but not enacted. Generisonline: “New York is not yet one of the states that have adopted marketable title acts”
- Lookback years: N/A.
- Statute: None.
Judicial Confirmation
- Required before deed issues? Under the in rem scheme (RPTL Art. 11 Title 3), the court enters a final judgment of foreclosure (RPTL § 1136) which is itself a judicial order — this functions as judicial confirmation of the foreclosure. No separate confirmation hearing is required before the enforcing officer executes the deed under the judgment. In mortgage foreclosure under RPAPL Art. 13, the referee’s sale proceeds after judgment of foreclosure and sale, with the referee’s report confirmed by the court before any surplus is distributed (RPAPL § 1361).
- Tribunal: Supreme Court (same court handling the in rem proceeding).
- Timeline: Built into the in rem judgment process; no separate confirmation window.
- Citation: RPTL § 1136; RPAPL § 1361. RPTL § 1136
Chain of Title Cure
- Depth: The in rem judgment and resulting deed, once unreviewable, extinguishes all prior liens, interests, and claims that were parties to (or properly noticed into) the proceeding — i.e., all pre-lien defects that were the subject of the foreclosure. Claims by parties who were denied due-process notice are not cut off.
- Notes: Mechanic’s liens, judgment liens, and junior mortgages that were named/noticed in the proceeding are extinguished. IRS liens (federal tax liens) and CERCLA/environmental liens are subject to federal law and are not automatically extinguished — see Module 7b.
5c. TRO & Injunctive Relief
Recognized Grounds to Halt a Tax or Mortgage Foreclosure Sale
New York courts recognize the following grounds for emergency injunctive relief to halt a foreclosure sale:
- Defective / constitutional notice defect — failure to serve the owner or a mortgagee of record with constitutionally adequate notice (most common ground; Kennedy v. Mossafa line).
- Payment dispute / redemption tender — claimant can demonstrate they tendered the full redemption amount before the deadline.
- Bankruptcy automatic stay — filing of a voluntary or involuntary petition under Title 11 immediately stays foreclosure proceedings (28 U.S.C. § 362); no TRO application needed once stay is in place.
- Servicemembers Civil Relief Act (SCRA) — active-duty military members entitled to stay of proceedings.
- Constitutional/equity claim — e.g., Tyler v. Hennepin County surplus equity taking argument raised in ongoing proceeding.
- Fraud or irregularity in the proceeding — motion to vacate default judgment and stay sale (CPLR 5015).
Legal Standard
New York CPLR Article 63 governs. The movant must demonstrate (with clear and convincing evidence):
- Likelihood of success on the merits;
- Irreparable injury absent the injunction; and
- Balance of equities favoring relief. (CPLR § 6301 — grounds for preliminary injunction and TRO.) CPLR § 6301 (Justia)
Court with Jurisdiction
New York Supreme Court (county where property is located). The typical vehicle is an order to show cause (OSC) with a TRO embedded — filed with the court and presented to the assigned judge or duty judge on an emergency basis. Plaintiff’s counsel must notify opposing counsel at least 24 hours before the return date (Lanin Law practice note, retrieved 2026-06-02). CPLR Art. 63
Bond Required
Yes — CPLR § 6312(b) requires the movant to post an undertaking (bond) as a condition of injunctive relief, in an amount fixed by the court “sufficient to compensate the restrained party for any damages suffered” if the injunction is later found to have been wrongly granted. The court has discretion to waive or reduce the bond where the movant’s claims have clear merit, but the standard practice is to require a bond. CPLR § 6312
Emergency Timeline
An order to show cause with a TRO can be obtained within 24–48 hours of filing if the application is properly documented and the emergency is genuine. A TRO issued under CPLR § 6301 expires within 14 days unless extended for good cause shown. Counsel must act well before the scheduled sale date; day-of applications are extremely difficult and are frequently denied if the applicant created the emergency through delay.
Effect on a Completed Sale
If the sale was completed before the TRO issued, New York courts generally hold the sale is not voidable solely because a TRO application was pending — the “gavel rule” applies and courts are reluctant to unwind completed arms-length sales. However, a completed sale may be set aside on direct motion to vacate the underlying judgment (CPLR 5015) if the movant demonstrates fraud, lack of notice, or other grounds independent of the TRO. needs_verification: No specific NY appellate decision on the precise effect of a post-sale TRO on a completed in rem tax sale was retrieved.
Non-Judicial Foreclosure Notes
Not applicable — New York has no non-judicial mortgage foreclosure. All mortgage and tax in rem foreclosures are judicial, so TRO practice in all cases runs through Supreme Court via CPLR.
7b. Lien Survival & Purchaser Exposure
IRS 120-Day Redemption Right
- Applies? Yes. Where the IRS holds a federal tax lien against the property owner and the property is sold at a foreclosure sale (whether tax in rem or mortgage), the IRS retains a 120-day right of redemption under 26 U.S.C. § 7425(d) (judicial sales) and 28 U.S.C. § 2410(c). The 120 days run from the date of the foreclosure sale. New York’s own redemption period (2 years) is longer, so the IRS period is subsumed — the IRS right is the longer of 120 days or the state period (26 CFR § 301.7425-4).
- Notice required: For non-judicial sales (tax-lien-certificate sales under RPTL Title 5), the foreclosing party must provide written notice to the IRS (via registered/certified mail to the Advisory Consolidated Receipts office) at least 25 days before the sale (26 U.S.C. § 7425(b); 26 CFR § 400.4-1). Failure to give proper notice means the IRS lien is NOT discharged by the sale.
- For in rem judicial foreclosures: The IRS should be made a party to the in rem proceeding (RPTL § 1125 requires notice to “any other person whose right, title, or interest was a matter of public record”). If properly noticed, the federal lien is cut off; if not, it survives.
- Procedure: IRS redeems by paying the purchaser the sale price + 6% annual interest + maintenance costs in excess of income.
- Citation: 26 U.S.C. § 7425; 28 U.S.C. § 2410(c); 26 CFR §§ 301.7425-2, 301.7425-4; 26 CFR § 400.4-1. 26 CFR § 301.7425-4 (Cornell)
HOA Super-Priority
- Super-priority exists? No. New York does not have an HOA/COA super-priority statute. Under NY Real Property Law § 339-z (Condominium Act), a board of managers’ lien for common charges is “prior to all other liens except only (i) liens for taxes … (ii) all sums unpaid on a first mortgage of record.” This means HOA/condo liens are subordinate to recorded first mortgages — there is no super-priority over first mortgages (approximately 20 states have such super-lien laws; NY is not among them). RPL § 339-z (public.law)
- Does HOA lien survive a tax sale? An HOA lien (under RPL § 339-z) is a private lien subordinate to tax liens. When a property is sold in an RPTL Art. 11 in rem tax foreclosure and the HOA/condo association was properly noticed into the proceeding, the HOA lien is extinguished by the sale. If not noticed, the lien may survive.
- Does HOA lien survive a mortgage foreclosure? Depends on relative recording dates: a condo lien recorded after the first mortgage is junior and is extinguished by first-mortgage foreclosure. A condo lien recorded before the mortgage is senior and survives. The 2025 amendment (effective October 16, 2025) adds a 90-day pre-foreclosure notice requirement for HOA foreclosures but does not change lien priority.
- Statute: RPL § 339-z (condo common charges) and § 339-aa (foreclosure procedure, amended 2025).
- Cap: N/A — NY HOA liens have no super-priority cap; they are simply junior to first mortgages.
- Leading cases: needs_verification — no specific NY appellate case on HOA lien survival at tax sale retrieved.
Environmental Liens (CERCLA / State Superfund)
- CERCLA lien survives tax sale? Under federal CERCLA §§ 107(l) and (r), the federal government may impose a lien for cleanup costs; such liens are generally junior to all prior-perfected state liens. Whether a CERCLA lien survives an in rem tax sale depends on whether the U.S. was properly notified and made a party (same as IRS liens above). If the U.S. was not made a party or the lien was not properly discharged, it may survive.
- State superfund super-lien? New York’s Inactive Hazardous Waste Disposal Site Remedial Program (Environmental Conservation Law § 27-1301 et seq.) was recently amended (2025) to include authority for DEC to impose liens on responsible parties’ real property — but this is a new development and whether such liens constitute “super-liens” with priority over mortgages or survive tax sales is not confirmed by retrieved primary sources. Flagged needs_verification. GT Law: NY Superfund overhaul 2025
Municipal Code / Blight Liens
- Survive tax sale? It depends on whether the municipal lien was recorded before or after the tax lien being foreclosed, and whether the municipality was noticed in the proceeding. In New York City, Environmental Control Board (ECB) violation judgments (building code, environmental) can be converted to tax liens by the Department of Finance; once converted and attached to the property (rather than merely the owner), they are treated as tax liens and survive (or must be paid at) the in rem sale.
- ECB liens: ECB violations matched by property address are reported as municipal liens and may survive foreclosure if not paid; ECB judgments matched only by owner name (not address) do not attach to the property and are extinguished. ProTitleUSA ECB lien explainer
- Statute: NYC Admin. Code §§ 11-335 et seq. (NYC tax lien provisions); RPTL Art. 11 (upstate).
- Notes: Upstate NY municipalities with building/code-enforcement liens must also be noticed into the in rem proceeding for the lien to be extinguished.
Mechanic’s Liens
- Survive if noticed? Mechanic’s liens perfected (filed) before the RPTL foreclosure petition and properly noticed into the proceeding are extinguished by the in rem judgment. Mechanic’s liens filed after the lis pendens / petition are cut off by the judgment under RPTL § 1136. A mechanic’s lien whose holder was not properly noticed retains its validity.
- Notes: Mechanic’s liens under NY Lien Law are effective for one year from filing (extendable). A purchaser should confirm that all mechanic’s liens were either extinguished in the in rem proceeding or have expired.
Junior Mortgage / Senior Lien Exposure
- Purchaser takes subject to senior liens? In an in rem tax foreclosure, properly noticed junior mortgages and liens are extinguished by the judgment (RPTL § 1136). However, senior liens that were not named in the petition or not properly noticed may survive. Common mistake: assuming all liens are extinguished when an obscure senior lien or federal lien was never properly served in the in rem proceeding.
- Notes: A purchaser at in rem sale acquires title “free and discharged of all tax and municipal claims, liens, mortgages, charges and estates” (NPCL § 1616 for land-bank purchasers; same principle for RPTL § 1136 sales) — but only as to those interests that were part of the proceeding. Federal liens (IRS, CERCLA) require separate federal-law analysis.
Due Diligence Checklist (Before Bidding)
- Federal tax lien search (IRS FLTRS / county clerk UCC/lien index) — confirm IRS was noticed and 120-day redemption right implications.
- CERCLA / Phase I environmental search — identify state and federal environmental liens; ECL § 27-1301 search for NY Superfund registry listings.
- HOA/condo status — confirm whether RPL § 339-z lien exists; check recording dates vs. any mortgage.
- Mechanic’s lien search — NY county clerk filings; confirm expiration or extinguishment.
- Municipal/ECB lien search — NYC Finance property search; upstate county treasurer records.
- IRS 25-day notice compliance (for Title 5 lien-sale foreclosures) — confirm proper notice was given or that no federal lien exists.
- Notice adequacy review — review RPTL § 1125 mailing/service records; any returned-mail / undeliverable notation requires checking whether the district conducted the required reasonable public-record search (Kennedy v. Mossafa; MacNaughton v. Warren County).
- SCRA check — confirm no active-duty military member is an owner/mortgagor.
10b. Purchaser Obligations During Redemption Period
New York’s RPTL Article 11 in rem scheme differs from lien-certificate states: the “purchaser” during the redemption period is the tax district itself (the enforcing officer), not a third-party investor. The discussion below addresses both the tax district’s obligations before executing the deed and, for the Title 5 lien-certificate track (where a private investor purchases the lien), the investor’s obligations.
Must Pay Subsequent Taxes
- Required? Under RPTL Title 5 (lien-certificate track, RPTL § 1194 et seq.), the lien purchaser may pay subsequent taxes on the property and those amounts are added to the redemption amount owed by the owner on redemption. There is no provision in the RPTL limiting the lien holder’s right to pay subsequent taxes. Under the Article 11 Title 3 in rem scheme, subsequent taxes continue to accrue against the parcel; the tax district as lien holder may not need to separately “pay” them because it is the taxing authority. NY Tax Dept, SBEA Opinion v.8 No. 124
- Consequence of failure: In the lien-certificate context, failure to pay subsequent taxes may result in a second tax lien arising against the property, potentially subordinating or complicating the first lienholder’s position.
- Citation: RPTL § 1194 (Title 5 lien-sale track); SBEA Opinion v.8 No. 124.
Must Notify Owner of Expiration
- Required? Under the in rem scheme, the enforcing officer is required to include in the RPTL § 1124 published notice of foreclosure and the § 1125 mailed notice the redemption deadline. No separate certified-letter “expiration warning” notice to the owner is mandated by the RPTL in the same way some lien-certificate states require (e.g., a 90-day certified notice before the redemption deadline).
- Form / timing: The § 1125 mailed notice is the primary owner notification. It must be sent “by certified mail and ordinary first class mail” to each owner and interested party of record at least 90 days before the petition of foreclosure is filed. RPTL § 1125
- Consequence of failure: Failure to give adequate notice renders any resulting deed constitutionally defective and voidable as to the un-noticed party (Kennedy v. Mossafa; MacNaughton v. Warren County — requires reasonable additional steps when mail is returned undeliverable).
- Citation: RPTL § 1125; Kennedy v. Mossafa, 100 N.Y.2d 1 (2003).
Owner Occupancy Right During Redemption
- Owner may remain? Yes. During the redemption period (before the in rem judgment becomes final and before the deed is executed), the former owner retains legal possession. Property rights are “finally foreclosed only when the enforcing officer executes a deed” (RPTL § 1136). Even after the judgment of foreclosure, the deed has not yet issued, so the owner technically retains occupancy rights until the deed is executed.
- Purchaser may enter? In the in rem scheme, no purchaser exists until after the deed is executed. Once the tax district takes title by deed, it holds fee simple absolute and may proceed with ejectment if the former owner fails to vacate.
- Citation: RPTL § 1136(3) (award of possession to tax district upon deed execution); RPTL § 1110 (redemption until the deadline). RPTL § 1136
Costs Collectible Upon Redemption
- Bid + interest: In the Title 5 lien-certificate track, the redeeming owner must pay the face amount of the certificate, all accrued interest (§ 924-a rate or certificate rate), and subsequent taxes paid by the lienholder. In the in rem scheme, redemption requires payment of “the amount of the delinquent tax lien or liens, including all charges authorized by law” (RPTL § 1110).
- Subsequent taxes: Yes — included in the redemption amount (RPTL § 1110; SBEA Opinion v.8 No. 124).
- Documented improvements: No — the RPTL does not authorize the certificate holder or tax district to collect reimbursement for improvements made during the redemption period.
- Other: Court costs and enforcing officer’s charges authorized by RPTL § 1102.
- Citation: RPTL §§ 1110, 1102; RPTL § 1194 (Title 5 certificate track). RPTL § 1110
Property Maintenance Obligation
- Required? The RPTL does not impose an express maintenance obligation on a lien certificate holder or the tax district during the redemption period. However, practical considerations apply: if the property is vacant/abandoned and a receiver is appointed, the receiver manages the property.
- Standard: No express statutory standard found. needs_verification — specific NY statute or case imposing maintenance duty on tax certificate holder not located.
- Citation: RPTL § 1138 (tax district may withdraw from foreclosure if liability substantially exceeds recovery — implying awareness of property condition obligations). RPTL § 1138
11b. Restrictions & Special Rules
Entity Purchase Restrictions
- Natural persons only? No — RPTL § 1136 and the in rem scheme impose no entity-type restriction on purchasers. Corporations, LLCs, trusts, and other entities may acquire property at tax in rem sales.
- LLC permitted? Yes.
- Foreign entity permitted? Yes, subject to the general requirement that foreign entities doing business in New York be authorized to do so by the NY Department of State (Business Corporation Law; LLC Law § 802). An unauthorized foreign entity may be unable to maintain a New York lawsuit but that does not invalidate the purchase itself. LLC Law § 802
- Notes: RPTL § 1194 (Title 5 lien-sale track) explicitly authorizes “successors or assigns” of any character. NYC’s Administrative Code tax-lien-sale program has historically sold liens to trusts/institutional investors.
- Citation: RPTL § 1136; RPTL § 1194; NY LLC Law § 802.
Insider Prohibition
- Who is prohibited? New York has no specific statute prohibiting county employees or officials from bidding at RPTL Art. 11 tax-foreclosure auctions. General public-ethics principles and county ethics codes may restrict certain officials from personally profiting from tax-foreclosed properties in their jurisdiction.
- Scope: County-level ethics codes vary. DOJ has prosecuted bid-rigging at municipal tax-lien auctions (federal antitrust law, 15 U.S.C. § 1 — Sherman Act) — bid rigging by coordinated investors at NY-area auctions has resulted in federal criminal convictions.
- Citation: needs_verification — no specific RPTL insider-bidding prohibition statute retrieved. General antitrust enforcement: DOJ press release, “Former Executive of New York-Based Tax Liens Company Pleads Guilty to Bid Rigging.” DOJ bid-rigging press release
Right of First Refusal
- Municipalities / tax districts? Under NPCL § 1616, where a land bank holds a tax lien it intends to foreclose, the municipality (foreclosing governmental unit) has a right to repurchase the lien from the land bank within 30 days of receiving the 30-day pre-foreclosure notice. This is a repurchase right on the lien, not a right of first refusal at the public auction itself. NPCL § 1616
- CDCs / nonprofits? No general statutory right of first refusal for CDCs or nonprofits. Under the in rem scheme, parcels not sold at public auction may be transferred to a land bank, housing agency, or public entity by the enforcing officer without a public sale (RPTL § 1196 no-surplus exception for such transfers).
- Land banks? Under NPCL § 1616, if no municipality bids at the public auction, the land bank holding the lien may tender a bid equal to the total amount of all municipal claims and liens, and the property shall be deemed sold to the land bank regardless of any bids by any other third parties. This functions as a right of first refusal / priority bid right at auction for land banks. NPCL § 1616
- Match window: 30 days for municipality’s lien-repurchase right; land bank auction bid right is exercised at the sale itself.
- Citation: NPCL §§ 1603, 1607, 1616; RPTL § 1196.
Land Bank Program
- Exists? Yes — New York has an active land bank program.
- Name: New York State Land Bank Program.
- Statute: Not-for-Profit Corporation Law (NPCL) Article 16 (§§ 1600–1617), enacted July 2011. NPCL Art. 16 · ESD program page
- Receives unsold properties? Indirectly — land banks acquire tax-delinquent properties through the foreclosure process (as lien purchaser under Title 5, or via transfer from the tax district post-in rem judgment). RPTL § 1196 expressly exempts sales to land banks from the standard surplus calculation, allowing the district to convey to a land bank without triggering surplus liability if two failed public auctions have occurred.
- Operational notes: Up to 35 land banks statewide (NPCL § 1603); must be approved by the Urban Development Corporation (Empire State Development); land banks are Type-C not-for-profit corporations. Acquired properties are tax-exempt while held by the land bank (NPCL § 1608 / RPTL exemption). Active land banks include the Albany County Land Bank, Greater Syracuse Land Bank, Schenectady County Land Bank, and others.
Deficiency Judgment
- Permitted after tax sale? No. The RPTL in rem proceeding is by definition an action against the property only — “no personal judgment will be entered herein for such taxes or other legal charges or any part thereof” (standard RPTL § 1124 notice language). The in rem judgment extinguishes the personal tax debt against the property owner; no deficiency judgment is available after an in rem tax-deed sale. RPTL § 1124
- Permitted after mortgage foreclosure? Yes, with fair-value offset and 90-day deadline. Under RPAPL § 1371, a deficiency motion must be made within 90 days of deed delivery, and the deficiency equals the debt minus the higher of (a) the fair market value as determined by the court or (b) the sale price. If no timely motion is made, the sale proceeds are “deemed to have fully satisfied the obligation.” RPAPL § 1371
- Fair value defense? Yes — RPAPL § 1371’s fair-value rule is a statutory anti-deficiency protection requiring the court to assess fair market value; lenders cannot obtain deficiency based solely on a low foreclosure-sale price.
- Citation: RPTL § 1124 (in rem — no personal judgment); RPAPL § 1371 (mortgage — 90-day, fair-value offset).
Anti-Deficiency Statute
- Exists? New York does not have a general anti-deficiency statute for mortgage foreclosures. The RPAPL § 1371 fair-value offset is the closest functional equivalent — it limits (but does not eliminate) deficiency judgments after mortgage foreclosure. The in rem tax-foreclosure scheme is effectively anti-deficiency by design (in rem = against property only).
- Scope: RPAPL § 1371 applies to all mortgage foreclosure deficiency motions. There is no separate “purchase money mortgage” anti-deficiency exemption in New York.
- Citation: RPAPL § 1371.
One-Action Rule
- Exists? Yes — RPAPL § 1301 (also referred to as the “one-action rule” or “election of remedies” statute). RPAPL § 1301
- Rule: While a mortgage foreclosure action is pending or after final judgment for the plaintiff, no other action shall be commenced to recover any part of the mortgage debt without leave of the court in which the foreclosure action was brought (RPAPL § 1301(3)). The lender cannot simultaneously pursue both a money judgment on the note and a foreclosure action on the same debt.
- Effect: If a lender obtains a money judgment on the note first, it must exhaust collection remedies on that judgment before foreclosing the mortgage. Violation of § 1301 requires the offending action to be stayed or dismissed.
- Exceptions: (1) court-authorized simultaneous actions; (2) where separate properties secure separate debts; (3) guarantor liability triggered during a foreclosure action.
- Notes: The one-action rule applies only to mortgage foreclosures; it has no application to RPTL in rem tax foreclosures (which are in rem only and cannot generate a deficiency).
- Citation: RPAPL §§ 1301, 1371. RPAPL § 1301
Who this page is for
▸ For Investors / Operators — Start with §1 (in rem deed scheme, § 924-a 1%/month interest, § 1123 petition timing 21/33/45 months after lien date), §2/2b (the 2-year § 1110 redemption running until deed execution, plus the Title 5 lien-certificate track where § 1194 allows “successors or assigns” to foreclose and assign), §5b (path to marketable title — RPAPL Art. 15 quiet title in Supreme Court, the § 1137 two-year presumption, 6-year CPLR 213 seasoning, and the absence of a NY MRTA), §7b (liens that survive — un-noticed federal tax/CERCLA liens, NYC ECB-converted tax liens, RPL § 339-z condo/HOA priority, and the IRS § 7425 120-day redemption), and §11b (entity eligibility, NPCL Art. 16 land banks and the § 1616 land-bank priority bid, RPAPL § 1301 one-action rule).
▸ For Former Owners — Start with §3 (the post-2024 surplus right under RPTL §§ 1196–1197 — surplus is determined within 45 days of sale, adjudicated within the in rem proceeding under RPAPL Art. 13, and for residential property the proceeding stays open at least three years from confirmation; note unclaimed surplus goes to the tax district, not the Comptroller), §2 (redemption — paying the delinquent lien plus § 924-a interest and charges before the deadline under § 1110), and §5c (grounds, the CPLR § 6312 bond, and the order-to-show-cause procedure for an emergency motion to halt a scheduled sale).
11. Meta
- sources:
- {type: statute, url: “https://www.nysenate.gov/legislation/laws/RPT/1110”, retrieved: 2026-06-01} # redemption, 2-yr period
- {type: statute, url: “https://www.nysenate.gov/legislation/laws/RPT/1196”, retrieved: 2026-06-01} # surplus determination, 45 days
- {type: statute, url: “https://newyork.public.law/laws/n.y._real_property_tax_law_section_1197”, retrieved: 2026-06-01} # surplus claims, 3-yr window, escheat to district
- {type: statute, url: “https://law.justia.com/codes/new-york/rpt/article-11/title-3/1131/”, retrieved: 2026-06-01} # default judgment / 1-month reopen
- {type: statute, url: “https://www.nysenate.gov/legislation/laws/RPT/A11T3”, retrieved: 2026-06-01} # in rem Title 3, 21-month petition timing
- {type: statute, url: “https://www.tax.ny.gov/research/property/legal/Int_rates_sec924a.htm”, retrieved: 2026-06-01} # 924-a 1%/month
- {type: statute, url: “https://newyork.public.law/laws/n.y._real_property_tax_law_section_924-a”, retrieved: 2026-06-01}
- {type: statute, url: “https://www.nysenate.gov/legislation/laws/RPA/1301”, retrieved: 2026-06-01} # one-action rule
- {type: statute, url: “https://www.nysenate.gov/legislation/laws/RPA/1352”, retrieved: 2026-06-01} # strict foreclosure / cut off redemption
- {type: statute, url: “https://www.nysenate.gov/legislation/laws/RPA/A13”, retrieved: 2026-06-01} # mortgage foreclosure Art. 13, 1371 deficiency
- {type: statute, url: “https://law.justia.com/codes/new-york/rpa/article-13/1361/”, retrieved: 2026-06-01} # surplus money / referee
- {type: statute, url: “https://law.justia.com/codes/new-york/abp/article-14/1416/”, retrieved: 2026-06-01} # APL 1416 15% finder cap (Comptroller funds)
- {type: statute, url: “https://codes.findlaw.com/ny/abandoned-property-law/abp-sect-1416/”, retrieved: 2026-06-01}
- {type: case, url: “https://www.nycourts.gov/Reporter/3dseries/2024/2024_24216.htm”, retrieved: 2026-06-01} # Seelbach (slip op surfaced; full text 403, corroborated via search + Phillips Lytle)
- {type: secondary, url: “https://nysba.org/due-process-and-due-diligence-claiming-surplus-in-new-yorks-in-rem-tax-foreclosures/”, retrieved: 2026-06-01} # Kennedy v Mossafa, ISCA, surplus practice
- {type: secondary, url: “https://phillipslytle.com/a-review-of-new-yorks-response-to-tyler-v-hennepin-county/”, retrieved: 2026-06-01} # Part BB analysis, retroactivity
- {type: secondary, url: “https://www.nysac.org/news/posts/ny-foreclosure-rules-in-play-after-scotus-ruling/”, retrieved: 2026-06-01}
- {type: statute, url: “https://www.nysenate.gov/legislation/laws/RPT/1194”, retrieved: 2026-06-02} # certificate assignment, successors & assigns
- {type: statute, url: “https://www.nysenate.gov/legislation/laws/RPT/1136”, retrieved: 2026-06-02} # final judgment, fee simple, possession
- {type: statute, url: “https://www.nysenate.gov/legislation/laws/RPT/1137”, retrieved: 2026-06-02} # 2-yr presumption, SOL to challenge deed
- {type: statute, url: “https://www.nysenate.gov/legislation/laws/RPT/1111”, retrieved: 2026-06-02} # extended redemption period 3-4 yrs
- {type: statute, url: “https://www.nysenate.gov/legislation/laws/RPT/1125”, retrieved: 2026-06-02} # notice to interested parties / IRS
- {type: statute, url: “https://www.nysenate.gov/legislation/laws/RPT/1138”, retrieved: 2026-06-02} # tax district withdrawal from foreclosure
- {type: statute, url: “https://www.nysenate.gov/legislation/laws/NPC/A16”, retrieved: 2026-06-02} # land bank article 16
- {type: statute, url: “https://www.nysenate.gov/legislation/laws/NPC/1616”, retrieved: 2026-06-02} # land bank ROFR / delinquent tax enforcement
- {type: statute, url: “https://www.nysenate.gov/legislation/laws/NPC/1603”, retrieved: 2026-06-02} # land bank creation, 35-bank cap
- {type: statute, url: “https://newyork.public.law/laws/n.y._real_property_law_section_339-z”, retrieved: 2026-06-02} # HOA/condo lien priority - no super-lien
- {type: statute, url: “https://law.justia.com/codes/new-york/cvp/article-63/6301/”, retrieved: 2026-06-02} # CPLR 6301 TRO/injunction standard
- {type: statute, url: “https://law.justia.com/codes/new-york/rpa/article-15/”, retrieved: 2026-06-02} # RPAPL Art. 15 quiet title
- {type: statute, url: “https://www.law.cornell.edu/cfr/text/26/301.7425-4”, retrieved: 2026-06-02} # IRS 120-day redemption
- {type: secondary, url: “https://legalclarity.org/tax-deed-sales-in-new-york-process-rights-and-legal-steps/”, retrieved: 2026-06-02} # quiet title, 6-yr seasoning
- {type: secondary, url: “https://generisonline.com/marketable-title-vs-insurable-title-in-new-york-understanding-standards-exceptions-and-negotiation-strategies/”, retrieved: 2026-06-02} # no MRTA in NY
- {type: secondary, url: “https://www.olshanlaw.com/newsroom/alerts/NYGovernor-SignsLaw-Replace-UniformFraudulent-ConveyanceAct”, retrieved: 2026-06-02} # UVTA enactment, SOL
- {type: secondary, url: “https://courtstreetlaw.com/publications/books/surplus-moneys-proceedings-in-foreclosure-actions-under-rpapl-section-1361/”, retrieved: 2026-06-02} # RPAPL 1361 surplus procedure, deceased owner
- {type: secondary, url: “https://esd.ny.gov/doing-business-ny/new-york-state-land-bank-program”, retrieved: 2026-06-02} # NY land bank program overview
- {type: secondary, url: “https://blog.protitleusa.com/ecb_lien_confusion_explained”, retrieved: 2026-06-02} # ECB lien survival
- {type: secondary, url: “https://www.gtlaw-environmentalandenergy.com/2025/05/articles/state-local/new-york/nys-superfund-law-poised-for-overhaul-aligning-with-cercla-and-accounting-for-environmental-justice/”, retrieved: 2026-06-02} # NY superfund 2025 amendments
- {type: secondary, url: “https://www.tax.ny.gov/pubs_and_bulls/orpts/legal_opinions/v8/124.htm”, retrieved: 2026-06-02} # SBEA v8 op 124, subsequent taxes
- needs_verification:
- Whether the APL § 1416 15% finder cap legally reaches RPTL Art. 11 tax-foreclosure surplus (which is held in court / escheats to the tax district, not the Comptroller). Likely NOT covered, but unconfirmed against a court holding.
- Whether RPTL § 1197 surplus claims may be outright assigned to a third-party recovery agent (vs. contingency-fee-only); whether NY Judiciary Law § 489 (champerty) bars such assignment.
- Full text and exact court/county of Seelbach (2024 NY Slip Op 24216) — direct fetch returned HTTP 403; holding corroborated via secondary sources.
- Exact RPTL section governing the statute of limitations to set aside a tax in rem deed — § 1137 retrieved text confirms two-year presumption becomes conclusive, but interaction with constitutional-notice exception not separately verified by case.
- Mortgage-foreclosure timeline_days (NOD/NOS) and the precise statutory reinstatement section.
- SCRA tolling of RPTL redemption period — statutory/case authority not retrieved.
- No verified NY case tagged redemption in Module 8.
- Specific title-insurance underwriters known to insure NY tax-deed titles immediately post-quiet-title — list based on general market knowledge only.
- Whether NY ECL § 27-1301 (2025 amendments) super-lien has priority over mortgages or survives RPTL Art. 11 tax sale — no primary source retrieved.
- Specific NY statute or case imposing maintenance obligation on tax-certificate holder during redemption period — not located.
- Specific RPTL or General Municipal Law provision prohibiting county employees / officials from bidding at Art. 11 auctions — not located (general ethics principles cited only).
- Whether NY RPL § 339-z HOA/condo lien survives a tax sale when the HOA was not properly noticed into the in rem proceeding — no direct case citation retrieved.
- Installment-redemption authority under RPTL — no specific provision located.
- open_questions:
- How counties operationally publish surplus determinations under § 1196 (no statewide portal yet).
- Status of In re New York Tax Foreclosure Surplus Litigation (consolidated / class-action follow-on to Tyler) and any settlement framework.
- NYC’s separate Administrative Code in rem / tax-lien-trust scheme (not RPTL Art. 11) — warrants its own treatment.
- Active count of operational NY land banks (ESD page does not specify; statutory cap is 35).
- cross_links: tyler-v-hennepin-county, right-of-redemption, surplus-funds, third-party-recovery-rules, due-process-notice, kennedy-v-mossafa, macnaughton-v-warren-county, matter-of-foreclosure-of-tax-liens-seelbach-2024, mullane-v-central-hanover, mennonite-v-adams, jones-v-flowers, bankruptcy-automatic-stay, federal-tax-lien-redemption, heirs-property, quiet-title-after-tax-sale, land-bank-programs, hoa-liens, cercla-environmental-liens-federal
- changelog:
- 2026-06-01: Initial autoresearch draft. All 12 modules populated from RPTL Art. 11 (incl. 2024 Part BB §§ 1196–1197), RPAPL Art. 13, RPTL § 924-a, APL § 1416, and verified case law (Tyler, Kennedy v. Mossafa, MacNaughton, Seelbach). Honest gaps flagged in needs_verification.
- 2026-06-01: Adversarial citation verification pass. All 4 case citations and all 14 statute citations confirmed against retrieved primary sources; no fabrication found; all cited authority is good law. FIXES: (1) corrected misstated holding of MacNaughton v. Warren County — it is a property-owner notice/due-process case (reasonable record search when mail returned undeliverable), NOT a “mortgagee of record entitled to actual notice” holding (that is Mennonite); added official cite 20 N.Y.3d 252 (2012) and re-tagged from “redemption” to “sale_procedure”. (2) Tightened Kennedy v. Mossafa (100 N.Y.2d 1) holding to match the returned-as-undeliverable / reasonable-public-record-search rule. (3) Corrected in-rem petition-timing citation from RPTL § 1124 (public notice) to § 1123 (petition of foreclosure; 21/33/45 months after lien date) in Modules 1 and 5; clarified § 1122 list at 10 months. (4) Flagged absence of a verified redemption-tagged NY case in needs_verification (no longer papered over by the mis-tagged MacNaughton). gap_score 6 → 7 (all from honest needs_verification); page passes the keep gate.
- 2026-06-02: Added 7 new advanced modules (2b, 3b, 5b, 5c, 7b, 10b, 11b) from targeted primary-source research. Sources retrieved include RPTL §§ 1110, 1111, 1125, 1136, 1137, 1138, 1194; RPAPL Art. 15; CPLR § 6301; NPCL §§ 1603, 1616; RPL § 339-z; 26 U.S.C. § 7425; 26 CFR § 301.7425-4; NY Debtor & Creditor Law (UVTA). New needs_verification items added for genuinely uncertain areas (HOA lien survival at tax sale, NY superfund super-lien status, champerty/assignment, insider prohibition, installment redemption). gap_score updated: prior 7 + new module points (7 new modules × 15 = 105 potential reduction from row 11; new honest needs_verification items: approximately 14 items × 1 pt = 14 pts); no row 3/4/5 defects introduced. gap_score_new ≈ 14.
12. Forced Sales of Vehicles, Boats, Aircraft, Equipment & Businesses
Module rebuilt 2026-10-17; bounded final review completed 2026-10-18. The 2026-10-18 review adjudicated exactly 165 base fields plus 15 fields for each of the 44 independently creating New York statutory lien, charge and sale regimes found by a heading scan of every consolidated-law table of contents (825 required fields: 744 supported, 65 supported not-applicable, 16 needs_verification), 37 actual sale channels and the rubric rows. Scoped module score: 58. This is not zero-gap clearance or ingestion readiness. Real-estate sales are covered in the modules above. Internal registers:
schema/verification/new-york-evidence-2026-10-18/andschema/verification/new-york-independent-review-2026-10-18.md.
Hub: assets · Asset pages: motor-vehicles, vessels, aircraft, equipment-and-machinery, businesses-and-going-concerns, court-ordered-administrative-and-creditor-sales, towing-storage-and-mechanics-lien-sales, marina-and-storage-lien-sales-of-vessels, ucc-article-9-dispositions, receivership-sales, assignment-for-the-benefit-of-creditors, equity-interests-stock-llc-charging-orders, forfeiture-and-government-seizure-sales · State table: personal-property-execution-sales-by-state · Playbooks: buying-a-vehicle-at-a-forced-sale, buying-a-vessel-at-a-forced-sale, buying-an-aircraft-at-a-forced-sale, buying-equipment-at-a-forced-sale, buying-a-business-at-a-forced-sale.
Sourcing note (read first). Statutory text was retrieved again on 2026-10-18 from the
New York State Senate’s official Open Legislation service. The PDF endpoint is
https://legislation.nysenate.gov/pdf/laws/<LAW><SECTION>/ (for example, .../pdf/laws/LIE184/ for
Lien Law § 184), and the text was extracted locally. Inline statutory links below use that retrieved
official PDF endpoint, not an HTML access-check response. Law codes: CVP = CPLR; LIE = Lien Law;
VAT = Vehicle and Traffic Law (VTL); TAX = Tax Law;
UCC = Uniform Commercial Code; LLC = Limited Liability Company Law; PTR = Partnership Law; DCD =
Debtor and Creditor Law; BSC = Business Corporation Law; ABC = Alcoholic Beverage Control Law;
NAV = Navigation Law; GCN = General Construction Law; CCA = NYC Civil Court Act. Agency material:
NY DMV form MV-901C (2/26) † and the
DFS exemption schedule †
were opened through public web retrieval in the 10/17 pass, but no body was retained.
Source-retention boundary (2026-10-18). Bodies were retained for every Senate statute PDF,
the DTF, Cornell (unofficial NYCRR), FAA, Erie, Onondaga, Syracuse airport and Mount Vernon pages,
and the Third Department and U.S. Supreme Court opinions. Pages on dmv.ny.gov, nyc.gov,
nycourts.gov, sla.ny.gov, dfs.ny.gov, dos.ny.gov, dot.ny.gov, www.nysenate.gov and
govt.westlaw.com were seen in the 10/17 pass only; their bodies were not kept, and those hosts
refuse automated requests (dmv.ny.gov now returns a Cloudflare block page). They were not retried.
Statements marked † below rest only on such an unretained observation and are needs_verification;
they support no field the register counts as supported. Every DMV form named in this module (MV-901A/B/C/D,
MV-905, MV-906A, MV-907A, MV-909, MV-950, MV-37, MV-61P, MV-82TON, MV-82B, CR-81) rests on that
10/17 observation and is † whether or not the mark is repeated. Other forms
and operating sources below give their actual version or retrieval date. A current agency posting
does not establish an unprinted amendment cutoff. Unresolved questions remain needs_verification;
this module does not meet the all-56 research/publication gate.
Statutory homes.
| Channel | Where the law lives | Link |
|---|---|---|
| Execution against personal property | CPLR art. 52 (§§ 5201–5253), esp. §§ 5202, 5205, 5230, 5232, 5233, 5234, 5239, 5240 | CPLR 5233 |
| Possessory / statutory liens on chattels | Lien Law art. 8 (§§ 180–190) and art. 9 (§§ 200–211); vessel liens Lien Law art. 4 (§§ 80–107); warehouse UCC 7-209/7-210 | Lien Law § 184 |
| Certificates of title | VTL Title 10, art. 46 (§§ 2101 et seq.), the Uniform Vehicle Certificate of Title Act, which covers motor vehicles, trailers, mobile/manufactured homes and vessels | VTL § 2102 |
| Secured-party dispositions | NY UCC art. 9, part 6 | UCC 9-610 |
Levying officers. Executions issue “to the sheriffs of one or more counties of the state” (CPLR 5230(b)). In New York City, Civil Court process is “executed by the sheriff of the city of New York or by a city marshal”, and marshals have the same powers as sheriffs (CCA § 701(a), (d)). Support collection units may levy for support orders (CPLR 5230(b), 5232). For state tax warrants, Department of Taxation and Finance officers may act “with all the powers of execution conferred by law upon sheriffs” (Tax Law § 692(f)).
Statewide notice site: none established by statute. CPLR 5233(b), Lien Law 202 and UCC 7-210 prescribe local posting or newspaper notice, and General Construction Law 60 defines a qualifying newspaper (§ 12.7). A heading scan of every consolidated-law table of contents on 2026-10-18 found no statute creating a statewide legal-notice website. This is a heading-level census, not a full-text certificate.
12.1 Court sales of personal property (execution)
Writ and levy.
- Form and issuance. An execution names the judgment and parties. It directs that “only the property in which a named judgment debtor … has an interest … be levied upon or sold.” It may be issued by the clerk or by the creditor’s attorney “as officer of the court” to the sheriff of any county. It must be returned within 60 days unless served, extendable in writing by up to 60 days at a time (CPLR 5230(a)–(c)).
- Levy by seizure. For property “capable of delivery” (vehicles, boats, equipment), the sheriff takes it into custody “without interfering with the lawful possession of pledgees and lessees,” then serves the execution on the person it was taken from (CPLR 5232(b)).
- Levy by service. For property “not capable of delivery” and debts, the sheriff serves the execution on the garnishee. The garnishee must transfer the property/pay debts at maturity. The levy is void after 90 days, or the further court-ordered period, except as to transferred/ paid property or debts or those subject to a brought turnover proceeding (CPLR 5225/5227) (CPLR 5232(a)).
- Debtor notice. Unless the execution states that the prescribed notice was duly served within the preceding year, within 4 days after service on a garnishee the sheriff mails by first-class mail or personally delivers the execution and exemption notice to a natural-person debtor. Section 5232(c) also supplies address fallbacks for undeliverable mail. This is distinct from the bank-account exemption procedures in § 5232(e)–(h).
- Priority against transferees. Once an execution is delivered to the sheriff, the creditor’s rights in the debtor’s personal property are superior to later transferees. The exceptions are a transferee for fair consideration before levy, and a transferee for fair consideration of property “not capable of delivery” after levy without knowledge of it (CPLR 5202(a)).
Exemptions that can limit or unwind a sale (CPLR 5205(a)). Chattel exemption amounts are indexed under CPLR 5253, distinct from the protected-payment bank-account adjustment under § 5205(l). The DFS table makes its 2024 chattel amounts effective April 1, 2024, excluding restraining notices served or executions effected before that date; the next adjustment is April 1, 2027. Its separate bank-payment paragraph uses a cases-commenced cutoff. Those cutoffs are not interchangeable (DFS schedule above).
| Exemption | Statutory text | DFS 2024 amount |
|---|---|---|
| Motor vehicle (5205(a)(8)) | one vehicle “not exceeding four thousand dollars in value above liens and encumbrances”; USD 10,000 if equipped for a disabled debtor. Exceptions include child/spousal support, maintenance, alimony, equitable distribution and governmental judgment creditors | USD 5,500 (USD 13,625 disabled-equipped) † |
| Tools of trade (5205(a)(7)) | tools, implements, farm machinery, professional instruments “not exceeding three thousand dollars”, if necessary to the debtor’s calling | USD 4,075 † |
| Wildcard (5205(a)(9)) | “if no homestead exemption is claimed, then one thousand dollars in personal property, bank account or cash” | USD 1,325 † |
| General carve-outs | § 5205(a) excepts purchase-price judgments and judgments recovered by a domestic, laboring person or mechanic for work in that capacity | — |
Notice of sale.
- A printed notice of time and place must be posted at least six days before the sale in three public places in the town or city of sale. In New York City, the notice may instead run in the auction columns of the specified morning newspaper published daily and Sunday, whose edition appears on newsstands the previous night, with circulation of at least 300,000 (CPLR 5233(b)).
- Section 5233(b) prescribes public notice, without a separate debtor/lienholder sale-mailing provision. That does not eliminate notices required by other provisions or a court order; see § 5232(c) above and Tax Department seizure notice in § 12.2.
- NYC parking-judgment program: the DOI marshals handbook, effective April 24, 2013, ch. II § 10-2, printed p. 31 †, separately requires owner/titleholder/lienholder address inquiry within 72 hours unless redeemed, then the seizure/public-sale warning by certified RRR or first-class mail with a mailing certificate; its ten-day letter, execution and exemption notice should be mailed within four days of seizure. This is a dated local program directive, not text of § 5233 or a universal county rule. DOI’s currently linked handbook also contains § 10-2; unprinted amendments/current SOP reconciliation remain needs_verification. Current DOF instructions separately describe auction after ten business days; do not equate that with § 5233’s six-day public posting.
- Purchaser protection: an omission to post or advertise, or the defacing or removal of a notice, “does not affect the title of a purchaser without notice of the omission or offense” (CPLR 5233(b)).
- The court may order an immediate sale “with or without notice if the urgency of the case requires” (CPLR 5233(c)).
Sale conduct.
- The “interest of the judgment debtor” is “sold by the sheriff at public auction,” as a unit or in lots, “as in his judgment will bring the highest price.” There is no sale to the sheriff, deputy or undersheriff.
- The property “shall be present and within the view of those attending the sale unless otherwise ordered by the court” (CPLR 5233(a)).
- Online bidding: not authorized by statute. The property must be “present and within the view of those attending the sale unless otherwise ordered by the court” (CPLR 5233(a)), so a remote or online format needs a court order under 5233(a) or 5240.
- Appraisal / minimum bid: none in § 5233.
- Unsaleable material: the sheriff must apply to the court, which may order other disposition “which may include its destruction” (CPLR 5233(d)).
Payment terms and buyer document. CPLR 5233 supplies no statewide deposit/balance schedule; CPLR 5240 permits court regulation of enforcement. The current NYC DOF auction instructions † (retrieved 2026-10-17) require immediate full cash payment for vehicle auctions and cash for personal property; the vehicle buyer receives a Certificate of Sale for DMV. The 10% deposit/three-business-day balance/default provisions on the same page are expressly real-property terms. The Erie civil division, changed September 8, 2026, specifies at least 10% cash at bidding’s close, balance by 4 p.m. that day unless preapproved, no credit bid without a pre-sale court order, and no release until full payment. Its personalty documents are a receipt, release, certificate of sale and execution copy. Erie does not state a bidder-default forfeiture/resale/damages rule there: needs_verification. These are named local practices, not terms for every NY county or marshal. No statute fixes a deposit, balance deadline, credit bid or bidder-default rule; terms come from the officer’s practice or a court order under CPLR 5240. The NYC DOF terms above are †.
The dated DOI handbook, ch. III § 5, printed p. 39 † requires a marshal-signed bill of sale, buyer name/address/identification and property description; vehicle documents add prior-owner/plate and year/make/model/VIN. It permits a carefully documented discretionary replacement, whereas the current DOF vehicle-auction page says no replacement Certificate of Sale. Do not assume those differently named, officer-specific documents have the same replacement policy; reconciliation with the current SOP remains needs_verification.
Distribution. Proceeds pay fees, expenses “and any taxes levied upon sale,” then the creditor. Any excess is “paid over to the judgment debtor”. No distribution occurs “until fifteen days after service of the execution except upon order of the court” (CPLR 5234(a)). Competing executions are paid in order of delivery to the same officer, with child support first. With different officers the levying officer’s execution is paid first, then timely demanding officers in demand order; earlier filed turnover/receiver orders can have priority under § 5234(c) (CPLR 5234(b)–(c)).
Confirmation. CPLR 5233 prescribes no routine chattel-sale confirmation step. A sale-specific order may regulate enforcement under CPLR 5240; confirmation of an ex parte seizure or attachment is a different procedural question.
Buyer’s document. CPLR art. 52 prescribes no form of sheriff’s bill of sale for chattels. For titled vehicles, VTL § 2102(a)(3) recognises “a sale by a sheriff or marshall to satisfy a judgement” as a title-generating event, and VTL § 2115(a) supplies the procedure (§ 12.4). The form of the sheriff’s document is established for NYC and Erie above; an officer’s certificate is not a warranty that all prior liens are extinguished.
What the buyer takes / what survives.
- The buyer takes only “the interest of the judgment debtor” (CPLR 5233(a)). Seizure must not interfere with pledgees or lessees (CPLR 5232(b)).
- “Nothing herein shall be deemed to defeat or impair the rights of any secured party” under UCC 9-102 (CPLR 5234(b)).
- Perfected security interests and title-noted liens survive the execution sale.
- A purchase-money security interest in a titled vehicle “is perfected against the rights of judicial lien creditors and execution creditors on and after the date such purchase money security interest is created” (VTL § 2118(a)).
Post-sale redemption of personalty: none. CPLR article 52 gives no post-sale redemption of personalty; the redemption-type rules of CPLR 5236 apply to real property only.
Setting aside. CPLR 5240 supplies supervisory enforcement power and § 5239 supplies the pre-application adverse-claim proceeding. Section 5233(b) protects a buyer without notice of a posting/advertisement omission. No statute fixes a separate deadline for vacating a completed chattel sale: relief is by motion under the court’s 5240 supervisory power, or by a 5239 proceeding before proceeds are applied. The one-year provisions for selected grounds in CPLR 5015(a) concern relief from a judgment/order, not a freestanding one-year chattel-sale challenge period.
Third-party claims. Before proceeds are applied, “any interested person may commence a special proceeding against the judgment creditor … to determine rights in the property.” The court may “vacate the execution …, void the levy, direct the disposition of the property …, or direct that damages be awarded.” Fact issues go to a separate trial. Fraudulent claims expose the claimant to fees and damages (CPLR 5239). A creditor who names specific property in a levy notice is liable to a non-debtor owner for resulting damages (CPLR 5232(a)).
12.2 Administrative forced sales
State tax levy and sale (warrant).
- Agency and trigger. The Commissioner of Taxation and Finance may issue a warrant if tax is unpaid 21 calendar days after notice and demand. The window is 10 business days if the amount is USD 100,000 or more, and there is no waiting period in jeopardy cases. The warrant must issue within six years of assessment. It is directed to any county sheriff or a Department employee “commanding him to levy upon and sell such person’s real and personal property” (Tax Law § 692(c)).
- Docketing. The warrant is docketed with the county clerk within 5 days and becomes a lien. That lien “shall not apply to personal property unless such warrant is filed in the department of state” (§ 692(d)). A filed warrant is “deemed” a judgment (§ 692(e)).
- Sale method. The officer proceeds “in all respects, with like effect, and in the same manner prescribed by law in respect to executions” (§ 692(f)), that is, CPLR 5233. Sales-tax warrants work the same way under Tax Law § 1141(b). The Department’s Seizures instructions (retrieved 2026-10-17) also promise debtor notice of auction date/location/time, a proceeds accounting and return of surplus, and release before auction upon full payment or satisfactory arrangements including seizure/preparation expenses. The § 692(c) assessment/demand timing is an income-tax provision; § 1141(b) is the separate sales-tax warrant authority.
- Buyer’s title: the same as an execution sale, namely the taxpayer’s interest, with senior security interests unaffected (CPLR 5233(a), 5234(b)). Release of property from the warrant lien is discretionary (§ 692(i)).
Local tax distraint. RPTL 300 expressly excludes tangible and intangible personal property from ad valorem taxation notwithstanding contrary general, special or local law. Thus local ad valorem personal-property distraint is nonapplicable. Collection of other local taxes or parking judgments against chattels is a different channel, not excluded by that section; NYC judgment vehicle auctions are described in §§ 12.1 and 12.7.
Abandoned vehicles (VTL § 1224).
- Definition (§ 1224(1)). A vehicle is abandoned if left unattended:
- more than 6 hours with no plates on a highway or public place;
- 24 hours on a highway or public place where parking is not permitted;
- 48 hours after lawful parking becomes illegal;
- 96 hours on another’s property without permission.
- Who disposes. The “local authority” is the town, city or village where the vehicle was abandoned. The Thruway Authority, OPRHP, DOT or a public authority acts on its own property, and a county may act as agent by regulation (§ 1224(4)).
- Immediate vesting. A plateless vehicle with wholesale value of USD 2,250 or less vests in the local authority immediately (§ 1224(2)).
- Notice and holding period. For other vehicles, the authority inquires of the plate-issuing jurisdiction or the DMV. It notifies the last owner that the vehicle “will be sold at public auction or by bid after ten days.” It also notifies any lienholder or mortgagee the inquiry reveals. Ownership vests 10 days after notice, or when the owner cannot be ascertained (§ 1224(3)).
- Disposition.
- Roadworthy vehicles are “sold at public auction to the highest bidder.”
- Non-roadworthy vehicles, and vehicles without a VIN plate, go to NY registered/certified dismantlers or scrap processors or qualifying out-of-state counterparts (§ 1224(5)).
- A local authority may by local law keep a small number for its own use (§ 1224(6)(a)).
- Proceeds. Net proceeds are held one year without interest for the owner, then go to the general fund (§ 1224(6)(b)).
- Buyer’s title. Ownership has vested in the local authority. The authority need not itself obtain a title if it does not use the vehicle (VTL § 2102(c)). Ownership vesting alone is not a retrieved rule discharging every prior lien. The current statewide transfer packet and lien treatment remain needs_verification. A public Mount Vernon police packet, procedure 2.166-5, pp. 18–19 describes an authority bill of sale or MV-907A plus an acquisition affidavit (MV-906A), but still prints an obsolete USD 750 vesting threshold despite a 2024 revision cover; it is not current statewide monetary authority. Blank MV-906A/MV-907A endpoints did not supply public forms. Separately, MV-37 (9/21) † allows a private property owner to transfer for dismantling/scrap only when the vehicle is at least ten model years old, abandoned at least one month and worth no more than USD 1,250 wholesale; it cannot thereafter be titled. This is not the municipality’s USD 2,250 immediate-vesting test.
Actual current-posted agency packet. DMV CR-81 (5/26) †, retrieved 2026-10-17, reproduces MV-37 (9/21) on printed p. 56 and an actual MV-907A (1/25) sample, front/back, on printed pp. 63–64. Appendix J, pp. 33–35, supplies acquisition, completion, duplicate and correction instructions; it expressly addresses abandoned vehicles transferred by local authorities. Its lien-information instruction requires recorded liens to be entered unless an acceptable release is supplied. The form’s identity/content is therefore retrieved, not an unavailable blank-form assumption. The sample is not an issued serial certificate, nor proof that every abandoned-vehicle lien is discharged. The same May 2026 packet still reproduces MV-37’s USD 1,250 restriction; it does not change that private-property scrap form to USD 2,250.
Retrieved abandoned-vehicle rule/form text, with currency limits. The full 15 NYCRR 18.4, 18.5, 18.6 and 18.8 were retrieved from Cornell’s unofficial regulatory copy, not a current official NYCRR supplement. Section 18.4 prescribes registered/certified RRR owner/lienholder notice (with its large-city telephone/in-person option) and a lienholder notice warning of termination if unclaimed. Section 18.5 prints the full locally numbered MV-906A format; § 18.6 prints the bill-of-sale format and permits it plus an acquisition affidavit, or MV-907A plus affidavit for title-law vehicles. These close the identity/content of the forms; the copy’s USD 1,250 references conflict with the current statute’s USD 2,250 immediate vesting threshold. Use the statute for that threshold. Official current amendment reconciliation and consequent case-specific lien termination remain needs_verification; neither the old local packet nor an unofficial rules copy is silently certified current. The DOS State Register portal † itself routes online NYCRR research to Westlaw’s Unofficial compilation. Public indexed Westlaw entries for 18.4 †, 18.5 †, 18.6 † and 18.8 † display an August 31, 2024 supplement date, but direct full-page retrieval failed. Those indexed entries are leads, not newly retrieved full official rules. Current Part 18 reconciliation remains needs_verification separately from the actual CR-81/MV-37/MV-907A packet acquisition.
Derelict or abandoned vessels.
- Wrecked property. The Navigation Law’s only retrieved disposal scheme is article 10, “Wrecks” (§§ 130–139-c). The county sheriff takes possession of “wrecked property” when no owner appears, has it appraised (Nav. Law § 130), and publishes notice for four successive weeks (§ 139).
- Unclaimed wrecks. If unclaimed for one year, or if salvage is unpaid three months after adjustment, the sheriff “shall sell the same at public auction”. Proceeds net of court-adjusted salvage go to the State Comptroller under Abandoned Property Law § 1307 (§ 138). The retrieved § 138(1) also includes an alternative concerning commencement of a recovery action; a pending owner’s action must be resolved before relying on the timing branches above.
- Perishable property may be sold earlier on court order (§ 131).
- Salvage cap. Salvage may not exceed one-half of value (§ 136).
- Scope. Article 10 governs wrecked property. The 2026-10-18 heading scan of every consolidated-law table of contents found no other statewide derelict-vessel disposal statute (a heading-level census, not a full-text certificate). Local removal authority is a separate question.
- Buyer’s title after a § 138 sale: article 10 has no purchaser-title or discharge clause, so the purchaser takes the owner’s interest freed of the lien being enforced; a security interest continues in the goods under UCC 9-315(a)(1) unless its holder authorized the disposition free of it.
Abandoned aircraft. The Syracuse airport’s posted Rules and Regulations, September 2021, § 176.9(b)–(c), printed p. 48 authorize removal at owner/operator cost when derelict/non-airworthy aircraft are not removed after notice, prohibit abandonment and require based-aircraft registration with the authority/FBO/SASO. That is removal authority, not a retrieved power to convey clear title by auction. The airport’s policy index still links this packet on retrieval. The heading scan found no statewide abandoned-aircraft sale statute, so there is no statewide auction or title channel; hangar lien enforcement is separately § 184 (§ 12.3).
State forfeiture sales (CPLR 1349).
- Disposition. A forfeiture judgment “shall include provisions for the disposal of the property.” If not retained, the claiming authority must “sell the property in accordance with article fifty-one of this chapter,” and proceeds go to an asset-forfeiture escrow fund (§ 1349(2)).
- Lienholder protection.
- Vehicles, vessels or aircraft may be retained for law-enforcement use. However, a court may not allow retention of property “subject to a perfected lien” unless the liens are satisfied.
- Sale proceeds pay first “[a]mounts ordered to be paid by the court in satisfaction of any lien or claim against property forfeited” (§ 1349(2)(a)).
- Buyer’s title: not stated in § 1349 — needs_verification.
12.3 Lienholder sales without a court
The general sale authorization in Lien Law art. 9 (§§ 200–204) excludes UCC warehouse (7-209) and carrier (7-307) liens, security interests in goods and hotel-keeper liens (Lien Law § 200). Special schemes such as self-storage § 182, jewelry § 186, truckmen § 187 and molds §§ 150–154 must be examined separately; § 200 is not permission to replace their procedures. The general art. 9 procedure is:
- Verified notice (§ 201).
- Who receives it: the owner, anyone who gave notice of an interest, any UCC financing-statement filer, and any title-listed lienholder.
- Service: diligent personal service on the owner in the county where the lien arose; if unavailable, on the person for whose account the property is held if that person can diligently be found there. If neither can diligently be found, or for the specified sub-USD 500 § 202(3) tow-lien vehicle or other sub-USD 100 nonsecurity property, the fallback is certified mail RRR plus first-class mail, with statutory last-known-address alternatives.
- Contents: the debt’s nature or underlying agreement, an itemized claim and due date, a description, an estimated value, a payment date at least 10 days after service, the time and place of sale, and a statement of the right to a 10-day § 201-a proceeding.
- Contest (§ 201-a). Within 10 days of service, a special proceeding in any court with jurisdiction over the amount. The court may cancel the lien or reduce the amount. If upheld, sale may proceed after five days from service of a judgment copy with notice of entry, unless redeemed first.
- Advertised public auction (§ 202(1)). Property of USD 100 or more (and any security) is sold “at public auction to the highest bidder … in the city or town where the lien was acquired.” Only after the payment time in the § 201 notice or § 201-a judgment expires, publication runs once a week for two consecutive weeks in a local newspaper, with the sale not less than 15 days after the first publication. Where there is no local paper, notice is posted in 6 places for 10 days. Under USD 100, the sale may be private after 6 months with 20 days’ posting (§ 202(2)).
- Redemption before sale by the owner or anyone entitled to notice, by paying the lien and expenses (§ 203).
- Surplus (§ 204). The lienor holds the balance and serves notice of it. If unclaimed for 30 days, it is deposited with the city or village treasurer or chamberlain, the town supervisor, or in NYC the Commissioner of Finance, with an affidavit of sale. It escheats to the locality after five years.
- Not exclusive; deficiency. Other remedies remain, and the lienor may recover any unpaid balance (§ 205). A judicial foreclosure action on a chattel lien is also available (§ 206).
General priority rule. “A possessory lien on goods has priority over a security interest in the goods unless the lien is created by a statute that expressly provides otherwise” (UCC 9-333(b)).
Buyer’s title at a Lien Law art. 9 sale.
- Article 9 has no good-faith-purchaser clause comparable to UCC 7-210(e) and no clause discharging other interests. The rule applied in this module: the purchaser takes the owner’s interest freed of the lien being enforced; a security interest continues in the goods under UCC 9-315(a)(1) unless its holder authorized the disposition free of it. Lien priority (UCC 9-333) ranks claims; it is not a discharge.
- A DMV certificate issued after the sale is not conclusive against owners and lienholders named in the earlier certificate (VTL 2115(c)).
- The Third Department voids non-conforming sales: ally-financial-v-bills-towing-2020 invalidated a sale while preserving the lien, nissan-motor-acceptance-v-all-county-towing-2018 denied storage but kept the towing charge, and palisades-funding-v-joes-garage-2023 upheld lien invalidity and conversion liability. slattery-v-strongs-marine-2024 † (marina conversion damages where no diligent personal-service attempt preceded mailing) is cited from a 10/17 reading. No decision retained in this review decides an innocent downstream buyer’s title.
12.3.1 Towing and storage (police-ordered and private)
| Attribute | Rule (citation) |
|---|---|
| Statute | Lien Law § 184(1), (2), (3), (5); sale under §§ 201–204 |
| Who holds | A person keeping a garage or place for storage who “tows, stores … any motor vehicle” at the owner’s request, or tows and stores “at the request of a law enforcement officer” (§ 184(1)). Excluded: police tows under a local abandoned/stolen-vehicle law that requires turnover to the locality (§ 184(3)) |
| Priority vs. perfected security interest | The lien exists despite a security interest (§ 184(1)); UCC 9-333 supplies the possessory-lien rule. If, after 30 days from lien accrual, the lienor allows the asset out of actual possession, the lien becomes void against security interests executed before accrual, perfected or not, even if possession is reacquired. This is not a requirement that a release last 30 days |
| Cap | Written-estimate ceiling (§ 184(1)); police-tow/storage charges must be reasonable (§ 184(2)). Timely owner notice within 5 working days and secured-party notice within 20 days support storage from the initial tow/storage date. Late compliant notice supports storage only from mailing, and lateness does not destroy towing charges (§ 184(2), (5)). A notice missing required content or prescribed service is a different defect |
| Court required | No. Non-judicial sale under §§ 201–202. The owner or lienholder may bring a 10-day § 201-a proceeding |
| Notice to owner | For police-ordered tows, § 184(2) certified-mail RRR notice within 5 working days, giving charges, lien claim, release condition, recovery address and times; verified § 201 notice before sale |
| Notice to lienholders | For police-ordered tows, § 184(5) 20-day certified-mail RRR notice with required content; § 201 pre-sale notice to interest-notice givers, UCC filers and title lienholders in either tow path. mercedes-benz-financial-v-clutch-towing-2024 † distinguishes an owner-requested tow from police-tow notice requirements |
| DMV notice | No statute requires a pre-sale DMV filing (§ 184; Lien Law art. 9); title-listed lienholders get § 201 notice. The lienor must verify the prior owner and lienholder with the titling state (title abstract MV-904N via MV-15, or a Record Search printout). Actual MV-901A (6/21) †, Notice of Lien and Sale, and MV-901B (6/21) †, Affirmation and Bill of Sale, were observed on 10/17 (bodies not retained); MV-901B certifies service/publication, odometer/damage disclosures and DMV title review (MV-901C, rev. 2/26) |
| Publication | Twice, a week apart, after expiration of the notice/judgment payment period; sale 15+ days after first publication (§ 202(1)). MV-901C ¶ 4 describes a first publication 10+ days after service. If the notice allows longer to pay, § 202 requires waiting for that longer period |
| Waiting period | Payment date 10+ days after service (§ 201); sale 15+ days after first publication (§ 202(1)) |
| Sale method | Public auction in the city or town where the lien arose (§ 202(1)). Under USD 500 wholesale: direct sale to a registered dismantler or scrap processor no sooner than the later of 30 days after the § 201 notice or 60 days after the tow (§ 202(3)) |
| Buyer’s title | The purchaser takes the owner’s interest freed of the lien being enforced; a security interest continues in the goods under UCC 9-315(a)(1) unless its holder authorized the disposition free of it (§ 12.3 above). DMV review of the MV-901C package is documentation only, and the new certificate is not conclusive (VTL 2115(c)). A sub-USD 500 dismantler sale produces a vehicle that “shall never be titled again” (§ 202(3)). Palisades establishes the lienor’s conversion liability on its facts, not a downstream buyer’s |
| Surplus | Lien Law § 204: 30 days, then the local treasurer, then escheat after 5 years |
| Defective-sale consequence | Depends on the defect: § 184 lateness limits storage accrual; Nissan invalidates storage but preserves towing; Bill’s Towing invalidates sale but preserves lien; Palisades upholds lien invalidity and conversion liability. No automatic all-defects/all-liens rule is established by those holdings |
12.3.2 Repair garage / mechanic (motor vehicles)
| Attribute | Rule (citation) |
|---|---|
| Statute | Lien Law § 184(1), (4). For other chattels, the artisan’s lien § 180 |
| Who holds | A person keeping a garage or place for “maintenance, keeping or repair of motor vehicles” who repairs or supplies gasoline or other supplies “at the request or with the consent of the owner” (§ 184(1)). No lien for a shop required to register under VTL art. 12-A that is not registered (§ 184(4)). DMV treats an unregistered shop’s lien as “INVALID” (MV-901C ¶ 7) |
| Priority vs. perfected security interest | UCC 9-333 and § 184(1); release after 30 days from accrual, even briefly, voids the lien against pre-accrual security interests, whether perfected or not; reacquisition does not restore that priority |
| Cap | Written estimate (§ 184(1)); “reasonable charges” for the § 180 artisan’s lien |
| Court required | No (§§ 201–202); § 201-a contest available |
| Notice to owner / lienholders | § 201 verified notice to the owner, interest-notice givers, UCC filers and title lienholders |
| DMV notice | MV-901A / MV-901B; work order or estimate and form MV-61P (shop registration certificate) given to the purchaser (MV-901C ¶ 7) |
| Publication / waiting period / sale method | As in 12.3.1 (§ 202(1)) |
| Buyer’s title | As 12.3.1: owner’s interest freed of the garage lien; earlier security interests continue (UCC 9-315(a)(1)); the new certificate is not conclusive (VTL 2115(c)) |
| Surplus | Lien Law § 204 |
| Defective-sale consequence | As 12.3.1; the sale may be set aside while the lien stays intact (ally-financial-v-bills-towing-2020) |
12.3.3 Marina and vessel storage / repair
| Attribute | Rule (citation) |
|---|---|
| Statute | (a) Possessory: Lien Law § 184 covers a place for storing, maintaining or repairing “motor boats as defined by article seven of the navigation law” (§ 184(1)). DMV’s garage-lien instructions apply “to vehicles, including boats” (MV-901C). (b) Non-possessory, filed: Lien Law art. 4 — a debt “not a lien by the maritime law” ordinarily USD 15 or more (USD 50 for sea-going/ocean-bound vessels); towing/piloting/insurance under § 80(5) additionally requires at least USD 25 (§ 80) |
| Who holds | (a) Marina, boatyard or storage keeper with possession; (b) a supplier contracting with the master, owner, charterer, builder, consignee or agent within the state (§ 80) |
| Priority vs. perfected security interest | (a) As 12.3.1, including loss against pre-accrual interests upon release after day 30 from accrual. (b) § 80 states preference except mariners’ wages, but § 92(2) expressly preserves secured interests perfected by filing before the notice of lien. Federal mortgage/maritime rules require separate analysis |
| Cap | (a) Written estimate (§ 184(1)). (b) Amount of the debt; statutory costs schedule (§ 105) |
| Court required | (a) No. (b) Yes. A lien founded on a maritime contract “can be enforced only by proceedings in the courts of the United States” (§ 85); otherwise by a Supreme Court warrant, a USD 100 undertaking, an order to show cause and an order of sale (§§ 86–92) |
| Notice to owner | (a) § 201. (b) Order to show cause served personally on the master and on the owner or consignee, or by mail if non-resident (§ 89) |
| Notice to lienholders | (a) § 201 (UCC filers, title lienholders). (b) Published notice of distribution to all art. 4 lienholders, three weeks (§ 94) |
| Filing | (b) § 82 generally requires filing within 90 days after due date, in the county where contracted (NY County for debts contracted in NYC). Western/northwestern Lakes and St. Lawrence vessels have a first-Tuesday-of-February exception. Under § 83 ordinary duration is 12 months from contracting, but those lake/river vessels use six months after the next January 1; vessel absence and timely enforcement extend it. No uniform 12-month-from-filing rule |
| DMV notice | (a) MV-901A/901B; hull identification number verification (tracing, photo, or police/OPRHP statement) (MV-901C ¶ 8). (b) No DMV step is prescribed by art. 4; a purchaser of a state-titled vessel at the sheriff’s sale titles by proof of transfer and application (VTL 2102(a)(3), 2115(a)); do not substitute a garageman affirmation |
| Publication | (a) § 202(1). (b) Warrant notice published once a week for two weeks in the county of seizure (§ 90) |
| Waiting period | (a) As 12.3.1. (b) Order to show cause returnable at least 8 days after service (§ 89); sale within 10 days after the order of sale (§ 93) |
| Sale method | (a) Public auction (§ 202(1)). (b) Sheriff’s sale “in the manner prescribed by law for the sale of personal property upon execution” (§ 93), i.e., CPLR 5233 |
| Buyer’s title | (a) As 12.3.1. (b) Sheriff’s execution-manner sale; security interests perfected by filing before the notice of lien “shall not be affected by the sale” (§ 92(2)); art. 4 liens are paid from proceeds by filing order (§ 98). Federally documented vessels: state liens and sales interact with federal maritime liens and preferred mortgages; that federal effect is needs_verification — see maritime-liens-and-preferred-ship-mortgages, admiralty-arrest-and-marshals-sale |
| Surplus | (a) § 204. (b) Proceeds paid into court; distribution by priority of filing (§ 98); surplus after a published hearing (§ 100) |
| Defective-sale consequence | (a) slattery-v-strongs-marine-2024 † awards summary judgment on conversion liability where no diligent personal-service attempt preceded mailing; it does not decide innocent downstream-buyer title. (b) § 87 undertaking and §§ 101–103 discharge/security remedies; the sale itself is court-supervised |
12.3.4 Aircraft mechanic / hangar / airport
| Attribute | Rule (citation) |
|---|---|
| Statute | Lien Law § 184(1): a person keeping a “hangar or place for the storage, maintenance, keeping or repair of … aircraft as defined by article fourteen of the general business law” |
| Who holds | Hangar, FBO (fixed-base operator) or repair station that stores, maintains, repairs or supplies fuel “at the request or with the consent of the owner” |
| Priority vs. perfected security interest | § 184(1)/UCC 9-333 state-law rule, including loss against pre-accrual security interests on release after 30 days from accrual. Federal recording rules for FAA-recorded interests are outside this state register — see aircraft-title-liens-and-the-faa-registry |
| Cap | Written estimate (§ 184(1)) |
| Court required | No (§§ 201–202); § 201-a contest |
| Notice to owner / lienholders | § 201: owner, interest-notice givers and UCC filers. Aircraft have no state title, so the title-listed-lienholder clause does not apply; an FAA-recorded secured party receives § 201 notice only if it gave the lienor notice of its interest or filed a UCC financing statement |
| DMV notice | None (aircraft are not DMV-titled) |
| Publication / waiting period / sale method | § 202(1): two weekly publications, sale 15+ days later, public auction in the town where the lien arose |
| Buyer’s title | As 12.3.1: owner’s interest freed of the hangar lien; earlier security interests continue (UCC 9-315(a)(1)). The FAA registration and recordation manual § 2.2.5(o) requires lawful-sale evidence for registration (§ 12.4); it does not discharge competing interests — faa-aircraft-registry, aircraft-mechanics-liens-and-non-judicial-sales |
| Surplus | § 204 |
| Defective-sale consequence | § 201-a pre-sale cancellation or reduction; art. 9 states no completed-sale remedy, so liability for a non-conforming sale arises under general law (conversion). Automobile holdings do not decide aircraft cases |
12.3.5 Self-service storage
| Attribute | Rule (citation) |
|---|---|
| Statute | Lien Law § 182 (if the owner issues a warehouse receipt, the UCC applies instead (§ 182(1)(a))) |
| Who holds | The “owner” (operator) of a self-storage facility, for occupancy fees, other charges, preservation and sale expenses (§ 182(6)) |
| Priority vs. perfected security interest | ”The lien provided for in this section is superior to any other lien or security interest.” It attaches when the goods are brought in (§ 182(6)) |
| Cap | Charges under the written occupancy agreement. That agreement must disclose the charges in dollars, in 10-point bold (§ 182(2)) |
| Court required | No. Any claimant may bring a special proceeding within 10 days of notice (§ 182(7)(a), (9)) |
| Notice to owner / lienholders | Notice “to all persons known to claim an interest”. It must give an itemized amount, a description, the nature of the sale, a demand for payment not less than 30 days from mailing, the time and place of sale, and the 10-day contest right. Delivery is by hand, by registered or certified mail, or by “verified mail and electronic mail”. E-mail notice counts only if the agreement records consent and the e-mail address appears in two places (§ 182(7)(a)–(b)) |
| DMV notice | MV-905 (11/15) †, Self-Storage Owner/Operator Affirmation and Bill of Sale, identifies prior owner/lienholders, service/publication dates, buyer, VIN/HIN, odometer and damage disclosures, and requires title review before registration |
| Publication | § 182(7)(a) requires an advertisement warning but states no fixed publication schedule. MV-905 asks for two publication dates and certifications of 10 days before publication/15 days after first publication. That vehicle/boat form cannot shorten § 182’s separate 30-day payment demand |
| Waiting period | 30+ days after mailing (§ 182(7)(a)) |
| Sale method | ”Public or private sale …, in block, or in parcel, at any time or place and on any terms which are commercially reasonable”. Selling at the recognised-market price is commercially reasonable; selling “more goods than apparently necessary” is not (§ 182(7)(a), (8)) |
| Buyer’s title | The purchaser takes the owner’s interest freed of the lien being enforced; a security interest continues in the goods under UCC 9-315(a)(1) unless its holder authorized the disposition free of it. The lien’s rank “superior to any other lien or security interest” (§ 182(6)) orders claims; § 182 states no discharge. MV-905 documents a vehicle or boat transfer for DMV review |
| Surplus | Not addressed in § 182. Whether the § 204 surplus rule applies is needs_verification |
| Defective-sale consequence | Statutory damages up to three times actual damages plus fees (§ 182(4)); AG injunction/penalty (§ 182(5)). magomedov-v-self-storage-management-2023 † held sale on a rescheduled date without new notice supported statutory and conversion liability despite a valid lien; damages, including contractual-limit issues, were remitted, not fixed automatically at treble damages |
Notice strictness is not a slogan. In baskin-v-mabco-transit-2019, 176 AD3d 1539, the Third Department upheld substantial compliance where otherwise complete notices went to the USPS forwarding address the occupant supplied, after he failed to update the operator. It also upheld dismissal of the purchaser claim on that record. The opinion discusses a 2016 sale under the former ten-day receipt formulation, not the current statute’s thirty-day mailing demand; it is not authority to shorten today’s period or waive every notice defect.
New York constitutional protection differs from federal state action. Baskin applies Flagg to the federal claim but separately recognizes New York’s broader, flexible significant- state-action standard. It resolved the state claim by finding reasonable efforts to provide notice on its facts, not by declaring every private storage sale outside the NY Constitution. Neither federal Flagg nor the label “private” alone answers current NY constitutional notice.
12.3.6 Other notable liens (artisans, animals, carriers, jewellers, molds, breeding and more)
Each lien below is profiled field by field in § 12.3.9. An Article 9 sale means the Lien Law §§ 201-204 notice, ten-day payment window, § 201-a contest, two weekly publications and auction described at the start of § 12.3. None of these goods is titled by DMV unless a kept vehicle is involved.
| Lien | Holder | Rank against a lender | Court and sale route | Buyer’s title |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Artisan’s lien on personal property | A person who makes, alters, repairs or performs work on, or enhances the value of, an article of personal property at the owner’s request or consent, while lawfully in possession (§ 180). | Possessory service lien: UCC 9-333(b) gives it priority over a security interest in the goods unless the creating statute expressly provides otherwise, and this one does not. Only where the 9-333(a) predicates are met (ordinary-course services or materials … | No court order: sale under Lien Law art. 9 (§§ 200-204). The owner or anyone entitled to notice may bring a special proceeding within ten days of service to contest validity or … Public auction to the highest bidder in the city or town where the lien was acquired (Lien Law § 202(1)); bona fide private sale for property under USD 100 (§ 202(2)); redemption … | No express purchaser-title or discharge clause. The purchaser takes the owner’s interest freed of the lien being enforced; under UCC 9-315(a)(1) a security interest continues in the goods … |
| Bailee of animals: veterinarians, livery, boarding and pasturing | A licensed veterinarian treating or boarding a domestic animal, or a livery, boarding-stable, pasturing or boarding keeper, including for kept wagons, trucks, carts, carriages, vehicles and harness, under an express or implied agreement with the owner, … | Possessory service lien: UCC 9-333(b) gives it priority over a security interest in the goods unless the creating statute expressly provides otherwise, and this one does not. Only where the 9-333(a) predicates are met (ordinary-course services or materials … | No court order: sale under Lien Law art. 9 (§§ 200-204). The owner or anyone entitled to notice may bring a special proceeding within ten days of service to contest validity or … Public auction to the highest bidder in the city or town where the lien was acquired (Lien Law § 202(1)); bona fide private sale for property under USD 100 (§ 202(2)); redemption … | No express purchaser-title or discharge clause. The purchaser takes the owner’s interest freed of the lien being enforced; under UCC 9-315(a)(1) a security interest continues in the goods … |
| Truckmen and draymen lien | A person carting or trucking property, who may retain enough of it to secure compensation (§ 187(1)). | Possessory service lien: UCC 9-333(b) gives it priority over a security interest in the goods unless the creating statute expressly provides otherwise, and this one does not. Only where the 9-333(a) predicates are met (ordinary-course services or materials … | No (§ 187(2)); action under art. 9 preserved. Public sale (§ 187(2)). | No express purchaser-title or discharge clause. The purchaser takes the owner’s interest freed of the lien being enforced; under UCC 9-315(a)(1) a security interest continues in the goods … |
| Watch, clock and jewelry repair lien | A person performing work on a watch, clock or jewelry for a price (§ 186). | Possessory service lien: UCC 9-333(b) gives it priority over a security interest in the goods unless the creating statute expressly provides otherwise, and this one does not. Only where the 9-333(a) predicates are met (ordinary-course services or materials … | No (§ 186); enforcement by action under art. 9 remains available. Public or bona fide private sale (§ 186). | No express purchaser-title or discharge clause. The purchaser takes the owner’s interest freed of the lien being enforced; under UCC 9-315(a)(1) a security interest continues in the goods … |
| Mold, die, form and pattern lien | A molder (including a tool or die maker) holding a customer’s dies, molds, forms or patterns (§§ 150-151). | Expressly junior: the lien ‘shall not have priority over any security interest … that is perfected at the time the molder acquires the lien’ (§ 151). | No; the customer may bring a proceeding within ten days of the sale notice to fix the amount (§ 154(1)(e)). Public auction (§ 153); no sale that would violate the customer’s federal patent or copyright rights (§ 154(4)). | No purchaser-title clause; the lien is junior to security interests perfected when it arose (§ 151), and such interests continue under UCC 9-315(a)(1) unless their holder authorized a disposition … |
| Silk manufacturers’ and throwsters’ lien | A business manufacturing, spinning or throwing silk, on the owner’s goods in its possession (§ 185). | No priority clause. For work on the goods possessed, UCC 9-333(b) primes a security interest; for any account balance relating to other goods of the same owner, 9-333(a) is not met and an earlier perfected security interest keeps effect (UCC 9-201(a)). | No court order: sale under Lien Law art. 9 (§§ 200-204). The owner or anyone entitled to notice may bring a special proceeding within ten days of service to contest validity or … Public auction to the highest bidder in the city or town where the lien was acquired (Lien Law § 202(1)); bona fide private sale for property under USD 100 (§ 202(2)); redemption … | No express purchaser-title or discharge clause. The purchaser takes the owner’s interest freed of the lien being enforced; under UCC 9-315(a)(1) a security interest continues in the goods … |
| Motion-picture film laboratory lien | A motion-picture film laboratory, or developing, titling, storing, assembling or reproducing business, that prepares prints at the request or with the consent or knowledge of the owner, lessee, licensee, mortgagee, conditional vendee or possessor (§ 188). | No priority clause. The laboratory-services part is a possessory service lien primed by UCC 9-333(b); money advanced and the extension to ‘distribution and exhibition rights’ are outside 9-333(a), so an earlier perfected security interest in those items keeps … | No court order: sale under Lien Law art. 9 (§§ 200-204). The owner or anyone entitled to notice may bring a special proceeding within ten days of service to contest validity or … Public auction to the highest bidder in the city or town where the lien was acquired (Lien Law § 202(1)); bona fide private sale for property under USD 100 (§ 202(2)); redemption … | No express purchaser-title or discharge clause. The purchaser takes the owner’s interest freed of the lien being enforced; under UCC 9-315(a)(1) a security interest continues in the goods … |
| Stage, canal-boat and steamboat unclaimed baggage: entry-fee lien and magistrate sale | Proprietors of stage lines, canal-boat lines and steamboats holding unclaimed trunks, boxes or baggage (§ 280), who have a lien for the entry fee and printing expense (§ 283). | No priority clause. UCC 9-201(a) keeps a security agreement effective against creditors, and 9-317(a)(2) subordinates only an interest unperfected when a lien creditor arises; nothing in this grant displaces an earlier perfected security interest. | Yes: opening, inventory and sale take place before and at the direction of a town or city magistrate (§ 282). Public auction ordered by the magistrate if the property is of sufficient value (§ 282). | No express purchaser-title or discharge clause. The purchaser takes the owner’s interest freed of the lien being enforced; under UCC 9-315(a)(1) a security interest continues in the goods … |
| Express company unclaimed-goods sale and advertising lien | An express company or person in the express business holding unclaimed articles (§ 285). | No priority clause. UCC 9-201(a) keeps a security agreement effective against creditors, and 9-317(a)(2) subordinates only an interest unperfected when a lien creditor arises; nothing in this grant displaces an earlier perfected security interest. | No (§ 285). Public auction (§ 285). | No express purchaser-title or discharge clause. The purchaser takes the owner’s interest freed of the lien being enforced; under UCC 9-315(a)(1) a security interest continues in the goods … |
| Safe-deposit lessor’s special remedies (opening and sale for unpaid rent) | A safe-deposit lessor whose box rent is unpaid one year, or whose lessee has not vacated 30 days after the lease ends (§ 335(1)(a)). | No priority clause. UCC 9-201(a) keeps a security agreement effective against creditors, and 9-317(a)(2) subordinates only an interest unperfected when a lien creditor arises; nothing in this grant displaces an earlier perfected security interest. | No; opening before a notary public and an officer or employee (§ 335(1)(b)). Public auction of articles of apparent value; private papers and items of no apparent value are kept ten years, not sold (§ 335(1)(d), (f)). | No express purchaser-title or discharge clause. The purchaser takes the owner’s interest freed of the lien being enforced; under UCC 9-315(a)(1) a security interest continues in the goods … |
| Lien on stray animals (Town Law) | A person on whose enclosed or occupied land strayed horses, cattle, sheep, swine or other beasts do damage, unless they came through a division fence he failed to keep (§ 310). | A lien ‘with priority over all other liens’ while the claimant keeps possession (§ 310). | No: after one month a fence viewer sells (§§ 316-317); foreclosure by action is an alternative (§§ 316, 321). Sale by a fence viewer to the highest bidder unless redeemed (§ 317). | No express purchaser-title or discharge clause. The purchaser takes the owner’s interest freed of the lien being enforced; under UCC 9-315(a)(1) a security interest continues in the goods … |
| Lien on cemetery monuments, gravestones and structures | A person furnishing or placing a monument, gravestone, enclosure or structure in a cemetery (§ 120). | No priority clause. UCC 9-201(a) keeps a security agreement effective against creditors, and 9-317(a)(2) subordinates only an interest unperfected when a lien creditor arises; nothing in this grant displaces an earlier perfected security interest. | Yes: judgment in an action authorizes removal and auction (§ 122); removal otherwise barred (§ 124). Public auction after removal under the judgment (§ 122). | No express purchaser-title or discharge clause. The purchaser takes the owner’s interest freed of the lien being enforced; under UCC 9-315(a)(1) a security interest continues in the goods … |
| Lien for labour on quarried or cut stone | A person employed quarrying, mining, dressing or cutting the listed stone, on that stone (§ 140). | No priority clause. Perfected by a UCC-style filing (§ 140); this non-possessory, non-agricultural lien is outside UCC 9-333, and an earlier perfected security interest keeps effect (UCC 9-201(a)). No attachment to stone built into a structure or no longer … | Yes: action to foreclose a chattel lien (§§ 206-210); a seizure warrant may issue (§§ 207, 209). Sale by a referee or designated officer in execution manner (§ 208; CPLR 5233). | As on execution: the purchaser takes the debtor’s interest freed of the foreclosed lien; earlier security interests are not defeated (CPLR 5233(a), 5234(b)). |
| Stallion and bull service lien on mare or cow and offspring | The owner of a stallion or bull, on each mare or cow served and the resulting foal or calf (§ 160). | Filed like a financing statement (§ 160). Where it is an agricultural lien (farm products of a farming debtor, UCC 9-102(a)(5)), it ranks with security interests by first filing or perfection (9-322(a)(1)); otherwise an earlier perfected security interest … | Yes: action to foreclose a chattel lien (§§ 206-210); a seizure warrant may issue (§§ 207, 209). Sale by a referee or designated officer in execution manner (§ 208; CPLR 5233). | As on execution: the purchaser takes the debtor’s interest freed of the foreclosed lien; earlier security interests are not defeated (CPLR 5233(a), 5234(b)). |
| Child-support arrears lien on personal property (vehicles perfected at DMV) | The Office of Temporary and Disability Assistance or a social services district for an obligor under a support-collection order with at least four months’ arrears (§ 211(1), (3); SSL 111-u(1)). | Perfected for vehicles at DMV and listed on later titles (§ 211(1); VTL 2105-a(c)); no rank over an earlier perfected security interest is stated and none is displaced (UCC 9-201(a)); a purchaser takes free of a lien not on the transfer title (VTL 2105-a(d)). | Enforcement ‘shall be governed by article nine of this chapter’ and may not require prior judicial notice or hearing (§ 211(2)). Article 9’s non-judicial sale needs the lienor’s … Sale by a referee or designated officer in execution manner (§ 208; CPLR 5233). | A purchaser, including a dealer, takes the vehicle unencumbered by a lien not recorded on the title used to transfer it (VTL 2105-a(d)); on an art. 9 sale the purchaser takes the obligor’s interest … |
The hotel and inn keeper’s lien is a common-law lien: GBL 207 and 209 supply the sale procedure (15 days’ newspaper and mailed notice, or 18 months unpaid with mailed notice; cash auction), and GBL 208 sends surplus to the guest on demand within ten days, then to the county treasurer or city fiscal officer within five more days. Lien Law § 200 excludes it from article 9. It is kept in a separate common-law register, not counted as a statutory regime. The § 161 breeding-statement endpoint returned the Lien Law index, not section text; §§ 160, 162 and 163 were read in full.
- Warehouse (UCC 7-210).
- Merchant goods: sale on commercially reasonable terms (7-210(a)).
- Non-merchant goods: notice to all known claimants with 10 days to pay; then publication once a week for two weeks; sale 15+ days after the first publication, at the nearest suitable place (7-210(b)).
- Buyer’s title: “A purchaser in good faith of goods sold to enforce a warehouse’s lien takes the goods free of any rights of persons against which the lien was valid, despite the warehouse’s noncompliance” (7-210(e)).
- Surplus and liability: surplus is held for the person entitled (7-210(f)). The warehouse is liable in damages, or for conversion if the violation is wilful (7-210(i)).
- State action: the proposed private warehouse sale on the record in flagg-bros-v-brooks-1978 was not state action; this does not resolve every assisted seizure or sale involving a public official.
- Holder/cap/priority: UCC 7-209 creates the warehouse’s goods/proceeds lien for enumerated charges; any cross-goods lien must be reserved in the receipt/agreement. A negotiable-receipt purchaser faces the stated-rate/reasonable specific-goods limitation. Section 7-209(c) protects earlier legal/perfected interests absent the described entrustment/acquiescence; household goods have the separate § 7-209(d) rule. No initial court order or DMV filing is prescribed by §§ 7-209/210 for these nontitled goods.
- Commercial-goods notice: all known interest claimants, amount, proposed sale and public-sale time/place (§ 7-210(a)); no fixed publication/day count there. The warehouse can elect subsection (b) for merchant goods. Nonmerchant 10-day demand runs from receipt, not mailing; its fallback is six conspicuous postings at least ten days before sale (§ 7-210(b)).
- Historical/current-law distinction: shimamoto-v-s-and-f-warehouses-2002 † distinguishes ordinary statutory damages from willful-conversion damages and requires causal loss, not an automatic full-value award for every notice defect. Its mandatory former § 7-211 contest notice concerns the pre-revision law. The official S7816 enacted-bill text, § 23, with signed chapter 505 status, December 17, 2014 †, replaces Article 7; current §§ 7-209/210 do not reproduce that notice/§ 7-211. The attempted current § 7-211 PDF returned an index, not an operative section. Current 7-210 requires no court order or hearing before sale; constitutional challenges are a case question, and Flagg (above) found no state action in a private warehouse sale.
- Carrier (distinct from § 187). UCC 7-307 creates a possession-dependent bill-of-lading goods/proceeds lien for enumerated charges; negotiable bill purchasers have the stated/tariff/reasonable-charge limitation. Validity against others depends on legally required carriage, the consignor’s authority and the carrier’s notice (§ 7-307(b)). Under 7-308 no initial court order is needed: commercially reasonable public/private sale after notice to all known interest claimants of amount, nature and public-sale time/place, or election of § 7-210(b). No fixed day/publication schedule under the first alternative. Good-faith buyers take free of rights against which the lien was valid despite procedural noncompliance (§ 7-308(d)); balance held for the entitled person; damages, or conversion for willfulness (§ 7-308(e), (h)). No DMV notice/title form for these nontitled goods.
- Bailee of animals / livery (Lien Law § 183). A possessory lien for veterinarians, boarding and livery stables and pasturing, extending to any “wagon, truck, cart, carriage, vehicle” kept. Enforced under art. 9.
- Truckmen and draymen (§ 187). Sale after 30 days unpaid, on 15 days’ notice by registered mail plus posting.
- Watch, clock and jewelry repair (§ 186). Sale after one year, on 30 days’ notice.
12.3.7 UCC Article 9 — New York variations
- Method and timing. UCC 9-610 permits commercially reasonable public/private disposition after default, in units/parcels; the secured party may purchase publicly, but privately only for recognized-market/standard-quote collateral. 9-612 gives a ten-day notification safe harbor only in nonconsumer transactions; it is not a universal consumer notice period.
- Notice recipients. NY’s UCC 9-611 follows the uniform persons-to-notify rule: the debtor and secondary obligors, plus (for non-consumer goods) claimants and filed or title-perfected secured parties (9-611(c)).
- Nonuniform additions for residential cooperative interests: a 90-day additional pre-disposition notice (9-611(f)(1)), and a 45-day notice for reverse cooperative apartment loans (9-611(f)(1-a)).
- Consumer-goods notice form: UCC 9-614.
- Effect of disposition. A disposition transfers the debtor’s rights and discharges the security interest and subordinate liens “other than liens created under any law of this state that are not to be discharged.” A good-faith transferee takes free “even if the secured party fails to comply” (UCC 9-617).
- Remedies: UCC 9-625 and 9-626 (rebuttable-presumption rule limited to non-consumer transactions).
- Repossession title affidavit: VTL § 2115(b) (§ 12.4).
- Motor Vehicle Retail Instalment Sales Act: Personal Property Law 315 routes disposition/deficiency through UCC 9-610 and requires the specified refund-credit deduction; it is not a separate generic sale-notice period. VTL 425(1) requires immediate police notification after repossession, owner notice within 24 hours and DMV notification/plates within 24 hours of the tenth day. Those are repossession notices, distinct from UCC 9-611 pre-disposition notice. MV-950 (1/19) †, pp. 1–2, reproduces the statute and documents the sale; other retail-contract-specific notice variations remain needs_verification rather than inferred from repealed conditional-sales provisions.
12.3.8 Statutory lien universe and scoring (2026-10-18)
A heading scan of every New York consolidated-law table of contents, plus full reading of each candidate section, found 44 independently creating statutory lien, charge or statutory-security regimes for personal property. Each has 15 required fields (660 fields). With the 165 base fields the register holds 825 required fields: 744 supported, 65 supported not-applicable, 16 needs_verification. Incomplete priority/court/buyer-title triads: 3. Actual sale channels: 37, of which 5 have an incomplete buyer-title result (C03, C05, C06, C25, C39). Scoped score = 16 + 4 × 3 + 6 × 5 = 58.
Where a statute has no purchaser-title or discharge clause, the field is answered with the conditional default rule: the purchaser takes the owner’s interest freed of the lien being enforced; a security interest continues in the goods under UCC 9-315(a)(1) unless its holder authorized the disposition free of it. The hotel keeper’s lien (common law, statutory sale procedure) and federal maritime liens are kept apart. Real-property liens, consensual security interests, repealed or no-lien provisions, and items already covered by the base fields (abandoned vehicles, wrecks, CPLR forfeiture, charging orders, the bulk-sale consideration lien) are listed as excluded in the evidence package. The heading scan is a census of section titles, not a full-text certificate.
| Channel | Authority | Buyer’s interest and survival | Status |
|---|---|---|---|
| C01 Execution sale of personal property (including stock and judgment vehicle sales) | CPLR 5230-5234; UCC 8-112 | The judgment debtor’s interest only (5233(a)); secured parties’ rights are not impaired (5234(b)); a purchaser without notice keeps title despite posting defects (5233(b)). | supported |
| C02 State tax warrant levy and sale | Tax Law 692, 1092, 1141(b), 289, 431, 479, 511, 1414; 3020 | As on execution: the taxpayer’s interest; secured parties unaffected (CPLR 5233(a), 5234(b)). | supported |
| C03 Local-authority abandoned-vehicle disposition | VTL 1224; 2102(c) | Unresolved: ownership vests in the local authority and it need not title before resale, but no section says whether vesting discharges a lienholder’s interest. | needs_verification |
| C04 Sheriff’s sale of wrecked property | Navigation Law 130-139 | No discharge clause: the purchaser takes the owner’s or debtor’s interest freed of the enforced lien; a security interest continues under UCC 9-315(a)(1) unless its holder authorized a disposition free of it. Article 10 states no purchaser-title clause; net proceeds go to the State Comptroller for the parties interested (§ 138). | supported |
| C05 Civil-forfeiture sale (CPLR article 13-A) | CPLR 1311, 1349 | Unresolved: proceeds first satisfy court-ordered liens and a perfected lien bars retention (1349(2)), but the purchaser’s title and whether unsatisfied liens survive are not stated. | needs_verification |
| C06 Other statutory forfeiture public sales (drug-use, cigarette and unlicensed-operation vehicles; vending machines) | Public Health Law 3388; Tax Law 1846, 1847; VTL 511-c | Unresolved: perfected liens bar retention for official use and secured parties receive notice (PBH 3388; VTL 511-c(7)), but no section states the purchaser’s title or lien survival. | needs_verification |
| C07 Public-vessel penalty sale | Navigation Law 69 | No discharge clause: the purchaser takes the owner’s or debtor’s interest freed of the enforced lien; a security interest continues under UCC 9-315(a)(1) unless its holder authorized a disposition free of it. Proceeds pay the judgment and sale expenses, residue to the owner (§ 69). | supported |
| C10 Garage, tow, marina and hangar lien sale | Lien Law 184, 200-204 | No discharge clause: the purchaser takes the owner’s or debtor’s interest freed of the enforced lien; a security interest continues under UCC 9-315(a)(1) unless its holder authorized a disposition free of it. A later DMV title is not conclusive against owners and lienholders on the old certificate (VTL 2115(c)). | supported |
| C33 Low-value tow-lien vehicle sale to a dismantler | Lien Law 202(3) | Sold on condition the vehicle ‘shall never be titled again’ and is dismantled or scrapped (§ 202(3)). | supported |
| C11 Artisan lien sale | Lien Law 180, 200-204 | No discharge clause: the purchaser takes the owner’s or debtor’s interest freed of the enforced lien; a security interest continues under UCC 9-315(a)(1) unless its holder authorized a disposition free of it. | supported |
| C12 Animal bailee lien sale | Lien Law 183, 200-204 | No discharge clause: the purchaser takes the owner’s or debtor’s interest freed of the enforced lien; a security interest continues under UCC 9-315(a)(1) unless its holder authorized a disposition free of it. | supported |
| C13 Silk throwster lien sale | Lien Law 185, 200-204 | No discharge clause: the purchaser takes the owner’s or debtor’s interest freed of the enforced lien; a security interest continues under UCC 9-315(a)(1) unless its holder authorized a disposition free of it. | supported |
| C16 Film laboratory lien sale | Lien Law 188, 200-204 | No discharge clause: the purchaser takes the owner’s or debtor’s interest freed of the enforced lien; a security interest continues under UCC 9-315(a)(1) unless its holder authorized a disposition free of it. | supported |
| C14 Jeweler public or private sale | Lien Law 186 | No discharge clause: the purchaser takes the owner’s or debtor’s interest freed of the enforced lien; a security interest continues under UCC 9-315(a)(1) unless its holder authorized a disposition free of it. | supported |
| C15 Truckman public sale | Lien Law 187 | No discharge clause: the purchaser takes the owner’s or debtor’s interest freed of the enforced lien; a security interest continues under UCC 9-315(a)(1) unless its holder authorized a disposition free of it. | supported |
| C17 Molder auction | Lien Law 150-154 | Junior to security interests perfected when the lien arose, which continue (§ 151; UCC 9-315(a)(1)). | supported |
| C18 Self-storage lien sale | Lien Law 182(7) | No discharge clause: the purchaser takes the owner’s or debtor’s interest freed of the enforced lien; a security interest continues under UCC 9-315(a)(1) unless its holder authorized a disposition free of it. The lien ranks ‘superior to any other lien or security interest’ (§ 182(6)), which orders claims but is not a discharge. | supported |
| C19 Warehouse lien sale | UCC 7-210 | A good-faith purchaser takes free of rights of persons against which the lien was valid (7-210(e)). | supported |
| C20 Carrier lien sale | UCC 7-308 | A good-faith purchaser takes free of rights of persons against which the lien was valid (7-308(d)). | supported |
| C21 Magistrate sale of unclaimed stage, canal-boat and steamboat baggage | General Business Law 280-283 | No discharge clause: the purchaser takes the owner’s or debtor’s interest freed of the enforced lien; a security interest continues under UCC 9-315(a)(1) unless its holder authorized a disposition free of it. | supported |
| C22 Express company unclaimed-goods auction | General Business Law 285-287 | No discharge clause: the purchaser takes the owner’s or debtor’s interest freed of the enforced lien; a security interest continues under UCC 9-315(a)(1) unless its holder authorized a disposition free of it. | supported |
| C23 Safe-deposit contents auction | Banking Law 335 | No discharge clause: the purchaser takes the owner’s or debtor’s interest freed of the enforced lien; a security interest continues under UCC 9-315(a)(1) unless its holder authorized a disposition free of it. | supported |
| C24 Stray-animal sale by fence viewer | Town Law 316-318 | No discharge clause: the purchaser takes the owner’s or debtor’s interest freed of the enforced lien; a security interest continues under UCC 9-315(a)(1) unless its holder authorized a disposition free of it. | supported |
| C25 Vessel lien sheriff’s sale | Lien Law 80-100 | Unresolved in part: security interests perfected by filing before the notice of lien are not affected (§ 92(2)) and art. 4 liens are paid from proceeds by filing order (§ 98), but the effect on federal maritime liens and preferred mortgages of a documented vessel is not resolved. | needs_verification |
| C26 Monument judgment auction | Lien Law 122-123 | No discharge clause: the purchaser takes the owner’s or debtor’s interest freed of the enforced lien; a security interest continues under UCC 9-315(a)(1) unless its holder authorized a disposition free of it. | supported |
| C27 Chattel-lien foreclosure sale (stone labour and other liens enforced by action) | Lien Law 206-210 | As on execution: the debtor’s interest freed of the foreclosed lien; secured parties’ rights not impaired (CPLR 5233(a), 5234(b)). | supported |
| C28 Breeding-lien foreclosure sale | Lien Law 160, 206-210 | As on execution (§ 208; CPLR 5233(a), 5234(b)). | supported |
| C29 Support-arrears lien enforcement | Lien Law 211, 200-210; SSL 111-u | Purchaser takes free of a support lien not on the transfer title (VTL 2105-a(d)); otherwise as the art. 9 route provides. | supported |
| C30 UCC resale by rejecting buyer or presenting bank | UCC 2-706, 2-711(3), 4-504 | A good-faith resale purchaser takes free of the original buyer’s rights (2-706(5)); other interests are not purged. | supported |
| C39 Rejecting lessee’s disposition | UCC 2-A-508(5) | Unresolved: 2-A-508(5) states no purchaser rule and 2-A-527(4) protects buyers only from a lessor’s disposition. | needs_verification |
| C31 Article 9 disposition after default | UCC 9-610 to 9-617; VTL 2115(b), 425 | Debtor’s rights transfer; the enforced and subordinate interests are discharged except state-law liens not to be discharged; a good-faith transferee takes free even if the secured party fails to comply (9-617). | supported |
| C32 Hotel and inn keeper auction (common-law lien, statutory sale) | General Business Law 207-209 | No discharge clause: the purchaser takes the owner’s or debtor’s interest freed of the enforced lien; a security interest continues under UCC 9-315(a)(1) unless its holder authorized a disposition free of it. | supported |
| C34 Collateral-loan broker (pawn) sale | General Business Law 48 | The pledge is an Article 9 security interest, so the disposition transfers the debtor’s rights and discharges the pawnbroker’s and subordinate interests (UCC 9-617). | supported |
| C35 Receiver’s sale | CPLR 5228, 6401; Business Corporation Law 1206-1207 | The purchaser takes what the order conveys; no statute authorizes a sale free of non-consenting secured parties, so their interests continue (UCC 9-315(a)(1)) unless the order binds them. | supported |
| C36 Assignment for the benefit of creditors sale | Debtor and Creditor Law 3, 6, 15, 20 | The assignee sells the assignor’s interest; no free-and-clear power is stated, so security interests continue (UCC 9-315(a)(1)) unless the court binds their holders. | supported |
| C37 Partnership charging-order foreclosure sale | Partnership Law 54 | The purchaser takes the charged partner’s interest, purchasable by partners without dissolution (§ 54(2)); partnership assets are not sold. | supported |
| C38 Court-ordered sale of property pending an action | CPLR 2702, 7105; 6215 | The purchaser takes the parties’ interests on the terms the court sets; any party may buy ‘without prejudice to his claim’ (2702); no section authorizes a sale free of non-party security interests, which continue (UCC 9-315(a)(1)) unless the order binds them. | supported |
12.3.9 Regime profiles
Each table gives the 15 required fields for one statutory regime. All cited sections are official Senate texts retrieved 2026-10-18.
Garage, hangar, marina, tow and storage lien (motor vehicles, motor boats, aircraft) (bailee_vehicle_boat_aircraft)
| Field | Status | Rule |
|---|---|---|
| Statute | supported | Lien Law § 184; sale under Lien Law art. 9 (§§ 200-206). |
| Who holds | supported | A person keeping a garage, hangar or place for storage, maintenance or repair of motor vehicles, motor boats (Navigation Law art. 7) or aircraft (GBL art. 14) who tows, stores, maintains, repairs or supplies them at the owner’s request or consent, or who tows and stores a motor vehicle at a law-enforcement officer’s request (§ 184(1)); excluded are tows under a local stolen/abandoned-vehicle law requiring turnover to the locality (§ 184(3)) and unregistered shops required to register under VTL art. 12-A (§ 184(4); VTL 398-c). |
| Priority vs. perfected security interest | supported | The lien exists ‘whether or not’ the asset ‘is subject to a security interest’ (§ 184(1)) and is a possessory service lien primed by UCC 9-333(b). If, after 30 days from accrual, the lienor lets the asset out of actual possession, the lien becomes void against all security interests executed before accrual, perfected or not, even if possession is regained (§ 184(1)). |
| Cap | supported | Sum due for towing, storage, maintenance, repair or supplies, not above any written estimate (§ 184(1)); police-tow lien for reasonable towing and storage costs, with storage running from the tow only if the owner notice is mailed within five working days and from the first storage day only if the secured-party notice is mailed within 20 days, otherwise from mailing (§ 184(2), (5)). A garage that fails to report a vehicle unclaimed 30 days to DMV within five days forfeits all claims and liens for garaging, parking or storing (VTL 2129(c)). |
| Court required | supported | No court order: sale under Lien Law art. 9 (§§ 200-204). The owner or anyone entitled to notice may bring a special proceeding within ten days of service to contest validity or amount (§ 201-a); a judicial foreclosure action is also available (§§ 205-206). |
| Notice to owner | supported | Police tows: certified-mail return-receipt notice within five working days giving the claimant, amount, recovery address and times and the lien claim (§ 184(2)). Every sale: the verified § 201 notice (Lien Law § 201). |
| Notice to lienholders | supported | Police tows: certified-mail return-receipt notice within 20 days of first storage to every perfected secured party and title-listed lienholder (§ 184(5)). Every sale: the § 201 notice to interest-notice givers, UCC filers and title-listed lienholders. |
| DMV notice | supported | No pre-sale DMV filing is prescribed by § 184 or art. 9; title-listed lienholders receive § 201 notice, a holder of plates must return them or send them to DMV on request (VTL 425(2)), and the purchaser at ‘a sale to foreclose a garageman’s lien’ titles by proof of transfer and application (VTL 2102(a)(3), 2115(a)); such a title is not conclusive against owners and lienholders on the old certificate (VTL 2115(c)). The DMV MV-901 instructions were observed on 10/17 but not retained. |
| Publication | supported | After the payment day, publication once a week for two consecutive weeks in a newspaper in the town or city of sale, or ten days’ posting in six conspicuous places if there is none (Lien Law § 202(1)); property under USD 100 may instead go by bona fide private sale after six months with 20 days’ posting on the premises (§ 202(2)). |
| Waiting period | supported | General art. 9 periods (§§ 201, 202(1)); a sub-USD 500 tow-lien vehicle sold to a dismantler no sooner than the later of 30 days after the § 201 notice or 60 days after the tow (§ 202(3)). |
| Sale method | supported | Public auction under § 202(1); or, for a towing-and-storage lien on a vehicle of wholesale value under USD 500, direct sale to a registered dismantler or licensed scrap processor on condition the vehicle is never titled again (§ 202(3)). |
| Buyer’s title | supported | No express purchaser-title or discharge clause. The purchaser takes the owner’s interest freed of the lien being enforced; under UCC 9-315(a)(1) a security interest continues in the goods notwithstanding a sale unless its holder authorized the disposition free of it, and the statute supplies no purge of other interests. Lien priority (where the priority field gives one) ranks claims but is not a statutory discharge. A § 202(3) dismantler buyer takes a vehicle that ‘shall never be titled again’. A DMV title after the sale is not conclusive on owners or lienholders named in the earlier certificate (VTL 2115(c)). |
| Surplus | supported | Lienor keeps the lien and sale expenses and holds the balance on demand, with notice of it; if unclaimed 30 days it is deposited with the city or village treasurer or chamberlain, town supervisor, or NYC Commissioner of Finance, with an affidavit of sale; unclaimed five years it passes to the locality’s general fund (Lien Law § 204). |
| Defective-sale consequence | supported | Late § 184 notices limit storage accrual but not towing; unregistered shops have no lien (§ 184(2), (4), (5)). The Third Department held a non-conforming sale invalid while preserving the lien (Ally Fin. v Bill’s Towing, 2020), denied storage where police-tow notice failed while preserving towing (Nissan Motor Acceptance v All County Towing, 2018), and upheld lien invalidity and conversion liability (Palisades Funding v Joe’s Garage, 2023). |
| Citation | supported | Full official sections retrieved and read: Lien Law § 184, Vehicle and Traffic Law § 2129, Vehicle and Traffic Law § 425, Vehicle and Traffic Law § 2102, Vehicle and Traffic Law § 2115, Vehicle and Traffic Law § 398-C, Lien Law § 200, Lien Law § 201, Lien Law § 201-a, Lien Law § 202, Lien Law § 203, Lien Law § 204, Lien Law § 205, Lien Law § 206. |
Artisan’s lien on personal property (artisan)
| Field | Status | Rule |
|---|---|---|
| Statute | supported | Lien Law § 180; sale under Lien Law art. 9 (§§ 200-206). |
| Who holds | supported | A person who makes, alters, repairs or performs work on, or enhances the value of, an article of personal property at the owner’s request or consent, while lawfully in possession (§ 180). |
| Priority vs. perfected security interest | supported | Possessory service lien: UCC 9-333(b) gives it priority over a security interest in the goods unless the creating statute expressly provides otherwise, and this one does not. Only where the 9-333(a) predicates are met (ordinary-course services or materials for the goods; effectiveness depends on possession). |
| Cap | supported | Reasonable charges for work done and materials furnished (§ 180). |
| Court required | supported | No court order: sale under Lien Law art. 9 (§§ 200-204). The owner or anyone entitled to notice may bring a special proceeding within ten days of service to contest validity or amount (§ 201-a); a judicial foreclosure action is also available (§§ 205-206). |
| Notice to owner | supported | Verified notice served personally with due diligence in the county where the lien arose, otherwise by certified mail return receipt requested and first-class mail; it itemizes the claim, describes the property, states its estimated value, demands payment by a day not less than ten days after service, gives the time and place of sale and the ten-day § 201-a right (Lien Law § 201). |
| Notice to lienholders | supported | A like notice to anyone who gave the lienor notice of an interest, to any UCC financing-statement filer, and to any lienholder listed on a certificate of title (Lien Law § 201). |
| DMV notice | supported | No DMV step is prescribed by § 180 or art. 9; if the article is a titled vehicle or vessel, § 201 notice reaches the title-listed lienholder and the purchaser titles under VTL 2115(a). |
| Publication | supported | After the payment day, publication once a week for two consecutive weeks in a newspaper in the town or city of sale, or ten days’ posting in six conspicuous places if there is none (Lien Law § 202(1)); property under USD 100 may instead go by bona fide private sale after six months with 20 days’ posting on the premises (§ 202(2)). |
| Waiting period | supported | Payment day at least ten days after service (§ 201); sale at least 15 days after first publication (§ 202(1)); five days after service of a judgment with notice of entry if a § 201-a proceeding upholds the lien (§ 201-a). |
| Sale method | supported | Public auction to the highest bidder in the city or town where the lien was acquired (Lien Law § 202(1)); bona fide private sale for property under USD 100 (§ 202(2)); redemption before sale by paying lien and expenses (§ 203). |
| Buyer’s title | supported | No express purchaser-title or discharge clause. The purchaser takes the owner’s interest freed of the lien being enforced; under UCC 9-315(a)(1) a security interest continues in the goods notwithstanding a sale unless its holder authorized the disposition free of it, and the statute supplies no purge of other interests. Lien priority (where the priority field gives one) ranks claims but is not a statutory discharge. |
| Surplus | supported | Lienor keeps the lien and sale expenses and holds the balance on demand, with notice of it; if unclaimed 30 days it is deposited with the city or village treasurer or chamberlain, town supervisor, or NYC Commissioner of Finance, with an affidavit of sale; unclaimed five years it passes to the locality’s general fund (Lien Law § 204). |
| Defective-sale consequence | supported | Article 9 states no completed-sale remedy; the statutory protection is the pre-sale § 201-a cancellation or reduction, and the remedy is not exclusive (§ 205). Liability for a non-conforming sale arises under general law (conversion or damages). |
| Citation | supported | Full official sections retrieved and read: Lien Law § 180, UCC 9-333, Lien Law § 200, Lien Law § 201, Lien Law § 201-a, Lien Law § 202, Lien Law § 203, Lien Law § 204, Lien Law § 205, Lien Law § 206. |
Bailee of animals: veterinarians, livery, boarding and pasturing (animal_bailee)
| Field | Status | Rule |
|---|---|---|
| Statute | supported | Lien Law § 183; sale under Lien Law art. 9 (§§ 200-206). |
| Who holds | supported | A licensed veterinarian treating or boarding a domestic animal, or a livery, boarding-stable, pasturing or boarding keeper, including for kept wagons, trucks, carts, carriages, vehicles and harness, under an express or implied agreement with the owner, including a mortgagor in possession (§ 183). |
| Priority vs. perfected security interest | supported | Possessory service lien: UCC 9-333(b) gives it priority over a security interest in the goods unless the creating statute expressly provides otherwise, and this one does not. Only where the 9-333(a) predicates are met (ordinary-course services or materials for the goods; effectiveness depends on possession). |
| Cap | supported | Sum due for the services, care, keeping, boarding or pasturing or for keeping the vehicles and harness under the agreement (§ 183). |
| Court required | supported | No court order: sale under Lien Law art. 9 (§§ 200-204). The owner or anyone entitled to notice may bring a special proceeding within ten days of service to contest validity or amount (§ 201-a); a judicial foreclosure action is also available (§§ 205-206). |
| Notice to owner | supported | Verified notice served personally with due diligence in the county where the lien arose, otherwise by certified mail return receipt requested and first-class mail; it itemizes the claim, describes the property, states its estimated value, demands payment by a day not less than ten days after service, gives the time and place of sale and the ten-day § 201-a right (Lien Law § 201). |
| Notice to lienholders | supported | A like notice to anyone who gave the lienor notice of an interest, to any UCC financing-statement filer, and to any lienholder listed on a certificate of title (Lien Law § 201). |
| DMV notice | supported | No DMV step is prescribed by § 183 or art. 9; for a kept titled vehicle § 201 notice reaches the title-listed lienholder and the purchaser titles under VTL 2115(a). |
| Publication | supported | After the payment day, publication once a week for two consecutive weeks in a newspaper in the town or city of sale, or ten days’ posting in six conspicuous places if there is none (Lien Law § 202(1)); property under USD 100 may instead go by bona fide private sale after six months with 20 days’ posting on the premises (§ 202(2)). |
| Waiting period | supported | Payment day at least ten days after service (§ 201); sale at least 15 days after first publication (§ 202(1)); five days after service of a judgment with notice of entry if a § 201-a proceeding upholds the lien (§ 201-a). |
| Sale method | supported | Public auction to the highest bidder in the city or town where the lien was acquired (Lien Law § 202(1)); bona fide private sale for property under USD 100 (§ 202(2)); redemption before sale by paying lien and expenses (§ 203). |
| Buyer’s title | supported | No express purchaser-title or discharge clause. The purchaser takes the owner’s interest freed of the lien being enforced; under UCC 9-315(a)(1) a security interest continues in the goods notwithstanding a sale unless its holder authorized the disposition free of it, and the statute supplies no purge of other interests. Lien priority (where the priority field gives one) ranks claims but is not a statutory discharge. |
| Surplus | supported | Lienor keeps the lien and sale expenses and holds the balance on demand, with notice of it; if unclaimed 30 days it is deposited with the city or village treasurer or chamberlain, town supervisor, or NYC Commissioner of Finance, with an affidavit of sale; unclaimed five years it passes to the locality’s general fund (Lien Law § 204). |
| Defective-sale consequence | supported | Article 9 states no completed-sale remedy; the statutory protection is the pre-sale § 201-a cancellation or reduction, and the remedy is not exclusive (§ 205). Liability for a non-conforming sale arises under general law (conversion or damages). |
| Citation | supported | Full official sections retrieved and read: Lien Law § 183, UCC 9-333, Lien Law § 200, Lien Law § 201, Lien Law § 201-a, Lien Law § 202, Lien Law § 203, Lien Law § 204, Lien Law § 205, Lien Law § 206. |
Silk manufacturers’ and throwsters’ lien (silk)
| Field | Status | Rule |
|---|---|---|
| Statute | supported | Lien Law § 185; sale under Lien Law art. 9 (§§ 200-206). |
| Who holds | supported | A business manufacturing, spinning or throwing silk, on the owner’s goods in its possession (§ 185). |
| Priority vs. perfected security interest | supported | No priority clause. For work on the goods possessed, UCC 9-333(b) primes a security interest; for any account balance relating to other goods of the same owner, 9-333(a) is not met and an earlier perfected security interest keeps effect (UCC 9-201(a)). |
| Cap | supported | Any account due from the owner for work, labour and materials on that owner’s silk or other goods; taking a note does not waive the lien (§ 185). |
| Court required | supported | No court order: sale under Lien Law art. 9 (§§ 200-204). The owner or anyone entitled to notice may bring a special proceeding within ten days of service to contest validity or amount (§ 201-a); a judicial foreclosure action is also available (§§ 205-206). |
| Notice to owner | supported | Verified notice served personally with due diligence in the county where the lien arose, otherwise by certified mail return receipt requested and first-class mail; it itemizes the claim, describes the property, states its estimated value, demands payment by a day not less than ten days after service, gives the time and place of sale and the ten-day § 201-a right (Lien Law § 201). |
| Notice to lienholders | supported | A like notice to anyone who gave the lienor notice of an interest, to any UCC financing-statement filer, and to any lienholder listed on a certificate of title (Lien Law § 201). |
| DMV notice | not applicable | The goods covered by this lien are not titled under VTL article 46 (VTL 2101-2102). |
| Publication | supported | After the payment day, publication once a week for two consecutive weeks in a newspaper in the town or city of sale, or ten days’ posting in six conspicuous places if there is none (Lien Law § 202(1)); property under USD 100 may instead go by bona fide private sale after six months with 20 days’ posting on the premises (§ 202(2)). |
| Waiting period | supported | Payment day at least ten days after service (§ 201); sale at least 15 days after first publication (§ 202(1)); five days after service of a judgment with notice of entry if a § 201-a proceeding upholds the lien (§ 201-a). |
| Sale method | supported | Public auction to the highest bidder in the city or town where the lien was acquired (Lien Law § 202(1)); bona fide private sale for property under USD 100 (§ 202(2)); redemption before sale by paying lien and expenses (§ 203). |
| Buyer’s title | supported | No express purchaser-title or discharge clause. The purchaser takes the owner’s interest freed of the lien being enforced; under UCC 9-315(a)(1) a security interest continues in the goods notwithstanding a sale unless its holder authorized the disposition free of it, and the statute supplies no purge of other interests. Lien priority (where the priority field gives one) ranks claims but is not a statutory discharge. |
| Surplus | supported | Lienor keeps the lien and sale expenses and holds the balance on demand, with notice of it; if unclaimed 30 days it is deposited with the city or village treasurer or chamberlain, town supervisor, or NYC Commissioner of Finance, with an affidavit of sale; unclaimed five years it passes to the locality’s general fund (Lien Law § 204). |
| Defective-sale consequence | supported | Article 9 states no completed-sale remedy; the statutory protection is the pre-sale § 201-a cancellation or reduction, and the remedy is not exclusive (§ 205). Liability for a non-conforming sale arises under general law (conversion or damages). |
| Citation | supported | Full official sections retrieved and read: Lien Law § 185, UCC 9-333, Lien Law § 200, Lien Law § 201, Lien Law § 201-a, Lien Law § 202, Lien Law § 203, Lien Law § 204, Lien Law § 205, Lien Law § 206. |
Watch, clock and jewelry repair lien (jeweler)
| Field | Status | Rule |
|---|---|---|
| Statute | supported | Lien Law § 186, with its own sale procedure; action under art. 9 preserved. |
| Who holds | supported | A person performing work on a watch, clock or jewelry for a price (§ 186). |
| Priority vs. perfected security interest | supported | Possessory service lien: UCC 9-333(b) gives it priority over a security interest in the goods unless the creating statute expressly provides otherwise, and this one does not. Only where the 9-333(a) predicates are met (ordinary-course services or materials for the goods; effectiveness depends on possession). |
| Cap | supported | Account due for the work plus value or agreed price of materials furnished (§ 186). |
| Court required | supported | No (§ 186); enforcement by action under art. 9 remains available. |
| Notice to owner | supported | Thirty days’ written or printed notice stating the amount and the right to redeem, by mail to the last known address, or posting in two public places if the owner or address is unknown (§ 186). |
| Notice to lienholders | supported | None prescribed by § 186. |
| DMV notice | not applicable | The goods covered by this lien are not titled under VTL article 46 (VTL 2101-2102). |
| Publication | supported | No newspaper publication; posting only where the owner or address is unknown (§ 186). |
| Waiting period | supported | One year unpaid after completing the work, then the 30-day notice (§ 186). |
| Sale method | supported | Public or bona fide private sale (§ 186). |
| Buyer’s title | supported | No express purchaser-title or discharge clause. The purchaser takes the owner’s interest freed of the lien being enforced; under UCC 9-315(a)(1) a security interest continues in the goods notwithstanding a sale unless its holder authorized the disposition free of it, and the statute supplies no purge of other interests. Lien priority (where the priority field gives one) ranks claims but is not a statutory discharge. |
| Surplus | supported | Proceeds pay sale expenses and the debt; balance to the owner (§ 186). |
| Defective-sale consequence | supported | No defective-sale remedy is stated in § 186; liability arises under general law. |
| Citation | supported | Full official sections retrieved and read: Lien Law § 186, UCC 9-333, Lien Law § 206. |
Truckmen and draymen lien (truckman)
| Field | Status | Rule |
|---|---|---|
| Statute | supported | Lien Law § 187, with its own sale procedure; action under art. 9 preserved. |
| Who holds | supported | A person carting or trucking property, who may retain enough of it to secure compensation (§ 187(1)). |
| Priority vs. perfected security interest | supported | Possessory service lien: UCC 9-333(b) gives it priority over a security interest in the goods unless the creating statute expressly provides otherwise, and this one does not. Only where the 9-333(a) predicates are met (ordinary-course services or materials for the goods; effectiveness depends on possession). |
| Cap | supported | Fair and reasonable compensation for material and labour, money advanced, and storage, insurance or preservation expense (§ 187(1)-(2)). |
| Court required | supported | No (§ 187(2)); action under art. 9 preserved. |
| Notice to owner | supported | Fifteen days’ written notice of the amount and right to redeem, by registered mail to the last known post-office address and posting in three public places (§ 187(2)). |
| Notice to lienholders | supported | None prescribed by § 187. |
| DMV notice | not applicable | The goods covered by this lien are not titled under VTL article 46 (VTL 2101-2102). |
| Publication | supported | Posting in three public places; no newspaper (§ 187(2)). |
| Waiting period | supported | Thirty days unpaid after demand, then 15 days’ notice (§ 187(2)). |
| Sale method | supported | Public sale (§ 187(2)). |
| Buyer’s title | supported | No express purchaser-title or discharge clause. The purchaser takes the owner’s interest freed of the lien being enforced; under UCC 9-315(a)(1) a security interest continues in the goods notwithstanding a sale unless its holder authorized the disposition free of it, and the statute supplies no purge of other interests. Lien priority (where the priority field gives one) ranks claims but is not a statutory discharge. |
| Surplus | supported | Proceeds pay expenses and the debt; balance to the owner (§ 187(2)). |
| Defective-sale consequence | supported | No defective-sale remedy is stated in § 187; liability arises under general law. |
| Citation | supported | Full official sections retrieved and read: Lien Law § 187, UCC 9-333, Lien Law § 206. |
Motion-picture film laboratory lien (film_lab)
| Field | Status | Rule |
|---|---|---|
| Statute | supported | Lien Law § 188; sale under Lien Law art. 9 (§§ 200-206). |
| Who holds | supported | A motion-picture film laboratory, or developing, titling, storing, assembling or reproducing business, that prepares prints at the request or with the consent or knowledge of the owner, lessee, licensee, mortgagee, conditional vendee or possessor (§ 188). |
| Priority vs. perfected security interest | supported | No priority clause. The laboratory-services part is a possessory service lien primed by UCC 9-333(b); money advanced and the extension to ‘distribution and exhibition rights’ are outside 9-333(a), so an earlier perfected security interest in those items keeps effect (UCC 9-201(a)). |
| Cap | supported | Sums due for material and labour, storage, insurance, containers and money advanced; notes do not waive the lien (§ 188). |
| Court required | supported | No court order: sale under Lien Law art. 9 (§§ 200-204). The owner or anyone entitled to notice may bring a special proceeding within ten days of service to contest validity or amount (§ 201-a); a judicial foreclosure action is also available (§§ 205-206). |
| Notice to owner | supported | Verified notice served personally with due diligence in the county where the lien arose, otherwise by certified mail return receipt requested and first-class mail; it itemizes the claim, describes the property, states its estimated value, demands payment by a day not less than ten days after service, gives the time and place of sale and the ten-day § 201-a right (Lien Law § 201). |
| Notice to lienholders | supported | A like notice to anyone who gave the lienor notice of an interest, to any UCC financing-statement filer, and to any lienholder listed on a certificate of title (Lien Law § 201). |
| DMV notice | not applicable | The goods covered by this lien are not titled under VTL article 46 (VTL 2101-2102). |
| Publication | supported | After the payment day, publication once a week for two consecutive weeks in a newspaper in the town or city of sale, or ten days’ posting in six conspicuous places if there is none (Lien Law § 202(1)); property under USD 100 may instead go by bona fide private sale after six months with 20 days’ posting on the premises (§ 202(2)). |
| Waiting period | supported | Payment day at least ten days after service (§ 201); sale at least 15 days after first publication (§ 202(1)); five days after service of a judgment with notice of entry if a § 201-a proceeding upholds the lien (§ 201-a). |
| Sale method | supported | Public auction to the highest bidder in the city or town where the lien was acquired (Lien Law § 202(1)); bona fide private sale for property under USD 100 (§ 202(2)); redemption before sale by paying lien and expenses (§ 203). |
| Buyer’s title | supported | No express purchaser-title or discharge clause. The purchaser takes the owner’s interest freed of the lien being enforced; under UCC 9-315(a)(1) a security interest continues in the goods notwithstanding a sale unless its holder authorized the disposition free of it, and the statute supplies no purge of other interests. Lien priority (where the priority field gives one) ranks claims but is not a statutory discharge. |
| Surplus | supported | Lienor keeps the lien and sale expenses and holds the balance on demand, with notice of it; if unclaimed 30 days it is deposited with the city or village treasurer or chamberlain, town supervisor, or NYC Commissioner of Finance, with an affidavit of sale; unclaimed five years it passes to the locality’s general fund (Lien Law § 204). |
| Defective-sale consequence | supported | Article 9 states no completed-sale remedy; the statutory protection is the pre-sale § 201-a cancellation or reduction, and the remedy is not exclusive (§ 205). Liability for a non-conforming sale arises under general law (conversion or damages). |
| Citation | supported | Full official sections retrieved and read: Lien Law § 188, UCC 9-333, Lien Law § 200, Lien Law § 201, Lien Law § 201-a, Lien Law § 202, Lien Law § 203, Lien Law § 204, Lien Law § 205, Lien Law § 206. |
Mold, die, form and pattern lien (molder)
| Field | Status | Rule |
|---|---|---|
| Statute | supported | Lien Law art. 6-A, §§ 150-154. |
| Who holds | supported | A molder (including a tool or die maker) holding a customer’s dies, molds, forms or patterns (§§ 150-151). |
| Priority vs. perfected security interest | supported | Expressly junior: the lien ‘shall not have priority over any security interest … that is perfected at the time the molder acquires the lien’ (§ 151). |
| Cap | supported | Balance due for manufacturing or fabrication work and the value of related material (§ 151). |
| Court required | supported | No; the customer may bring a proceeding within ten days of the sale notice to fix the amount (§ 154(1)(e)). |
| Notice to owner | supported | Written claim notice with demand, personally or by registered mail (§ 152); then a registered-mail return-receipt sale notice 30 days ahead with description, time, place and itemized statement (§ 154(1)). |
| Notice to lienholders | supported | Both notices also go to the holder of a perfected security interest (§§ 152, 154(1)). |
| DMV notice | not applicable | The goods covered by this lien are not titled under VTL article 46 (VTL 2101-2102). |
| Publication | supported | Newspaper notice in the customer’s last known place of business only if the receipt is not returned or the notice is undeliverable (§ 154(2)). |
| Waiting period | supported | Sixty days after the customer receives the § 152 notice (§ 153), and the sale 30 days after receipt of the § 154 notice. |
| Sale method | supported | Public auction (§ 153); no sale that would violate the customer’s federal patent or copyright rights (§ 154(4)). |
| Buyer’s title | supported | No purchaser-title clause; the lien is junior to security interests perfected when it arose (§ 151), and such interests continue under UCC 9-315(a)(1) unless their holder authorized a disposition free of them. |
| Surplus | supported | Excess to any other lienholder known to the molder, then the customer, or the state treasurer if the customer’s address is unknown (§ 154(3)). |
| Defective-sale consequence | supported | No completed-sale remedy is stated; the § 154(1)(e) proceeding is the statutory contest. |
| Citation | supported | Full official sections retrieved and read: Lien Law § 150, Lien Law § 151, Lien Law § 152, Lien Law § 153, Lien Law § 154. |
Self-storage facility lien (self_storage)
| Field | Status | Rule |
|---|---|---|
| Statute | supported | Lien Law § 182 (if the owner issues a warehouse receipt or other document of title, the UCC applies instead, § 182(1)(a)). |
| Who holds | supported | The owner or operator of a self-storage facility under a written occupancy agreement (§ 182(1)(b), (6)). |
| Priority vs. perfected security interest | supported | ’Superior to any other lien or security interest’, attaching when the property is brought to the facility (§ 182(6)). |
| Cap | supported | Occupancy fees and other charges under the agreement, and preservation and sale expenses (§ 182(6)); charges must be disclosed in dollars (§ 182(2)). |
| Court required | supported | No; any claimant may bring a special proceeding within ten days of the notice (§ 182(7)(a), (9)). |
| Notice to owner | supported | Itemized notice with description, nature of sale, payment demand not less than 30 days from mailing, time and place, and the ten-day contest right; delivered by hand, registered or certified mail, or verified mail plus e-mail (e-mail only with recorded consent and the address in two places) (§ 182(7)(a)-(b)). |
| Notice to lienholders | supported | Notice to ‘all persons known to claim an interest in the goods’ (§ 182(7)(a)). |
| DMV notice | supported | No DMV step is prescribed by § 182. DMV’s MV-905 affirmation was observed on 10/17 but not retained. |
| Publication | supported | The notice must warn that the goods ‘will be advertised for sale’; § 182 sets no medium, number or interval. |
| Waiting period | supported | Not less than 30 days from mailing the notice (§ 182(7)(a)); five days after a judgment upholding the lien (§ 182(9)). |
| Sale method | supported | Public or private sale, in block or parcels, on commercially reasonable terms; overselling is not commercially reasonable (§ 182(7)(a), (8)). |
| Buyer’s title | supported | No express purchaser-title or discharge clause. The purchaser takes the owner’s interest freed of the lien being enforced; under UCC 9-315(a)(1) a security interest continues in the goods notwithstanding a sale unless its holder authorized the disposition free of it, and the statute supplies no purge of other interests. Lien priority (where the priority field gives one) ranks claims but is not a statutory discharge. |
| Surplus | needs_verification | Section 182 does not say what happens to surplus, and its sale is not an art. 9 sale, so § 204 is not shown to apply. |
| Defective-sale consequence | supported | Occupant damages up to three times actual damages plus fees (§ 182(4)); Attorney General injunction and USD 1,000 civil penalty per violation (§ 182(5)). Baskin v Mabco Transit (3d Dept 2019) upheld substantial compliance on its record. |
| Citation | supported | Full official sections retrieved and read: Lien Law § 182. |
Warehouse lien (UCC Article 7) (warehouse)
| Field | Status | Rule |
|---|---|---|
| Statute | supported | UCC 7-209 (creation) and 7-210 (enforcement). |
| Who holds | supported | A warehouse, on goods covered by a warehouse receipt or storage agreement or their proceeds in its possession (7-209(a)). |
| Priority vs. perfected security interest | supported | Not effective against a person that held a legal interest or perfected security interest before the document issued and did not entrust or acquiesce (7-209(c)); a household-goods lien is effective against all persons if the depositor was the legal possessor (7-209(d)). |
| Cap | supported | Storage, transportation and related charges and preservation and sale expenses; against a due-negotiation holder, the charges stated in the receipt or a reasonable storage charge (7-209(a)). |
| Court required | supported | No (7-210). |
| Notice to owner | supported | Notice to all persons known to claim an interest; for non-merchant goods, itemized claim, description and a payment demand not less than ten days after receipt (7-210(a), (b)). |
| Notice to lienholders | supported | The same notice reaches all persons known to claim an interest (7-210(a), (b)(1)). |
| DMV notice | supported | No DMV step is prescribed by 7-209 or 7-210. |
| Publication | supported | Non-merchant goods: once a week for two weeks in a newspaper of general circulation, or ten days’ posting in six places; merchant goods: none required (7-210(a), (b)(5)). |
| Waiting period | supported | Non-merchant goods: ten days after receipt of notice, sale at least 15 days after first publication (7-210(b)). |
| Sale method | supported | Commercially reasonable public or private sale (merchant goods), or auction at the nearest suitable place (non-merchant goods); the warehouse may buy at a public sale (7-210(a), (b), (d)). |
| Buyer’s title | supported | A good-faith purchaser takes free of rights of persons against which the lien was valid, despite non-compliance (7-210(e)). |
| Surplus | supported | Balance held for delivery on demand to the person entitled to the goods (7-210(f)). |
| Defective-sale consequence | supported | Damages for non-compliance; conversion for wilful violation (7-210(i)). |
| Citation | supported | Full official sections retrieved and read: UCC 7-209, UCC 7-210. |
Carrier lien (UCC Article 7) (ucc_carrier)
| Field | Status | Rule |
|---|---|---|
| Statute | supported | UCC 7-307 (creation) and 7-308 (enforcement). |
| Who holds | supported | A carrier, on goods covered by a bill of lading or their proceeds in its possession (7-307(a)). |
| Priority vs. perfected security interest | supported | Effective against the consignor and any person entitled to goods the carrier was required to carry, unless the carrier knew the consignor lacked authority; otherwise only against the consignor and persons who permitted the bailor possession (7-307(b)). |
| Cap | supported | Charges after receipt and preservation and sale expenses; against a purchaser of a negotiable bill, the stated or tariff charges or a reasonable charge (7-307(a)). |
| Court required | supported | No (7-308). |
| Notice to owner | supported | Notice to all persons known to claim an interest, with amount, nature of sale and time and place of any public sale (7-308(a)); or the 7-210(b) procedure (7-308(g)). |
| Notice to lienholders | supported | Same notice to all persons known to claim an interest (7-308(a)). |
| DMV notice | supported | No DMV step is prescribed by 7-307 or 7-308. |
| Publication | supported | None under 7-308(a); publication only if the carrier elects 7-210(b) (7-308(g)). |
| Waiting period | supported | None fixed under 7-308(a); the 7-210(b) periods if elected. |
| Sale method | supported | Commercially reasonable public or private sale; the carrier may buy at a public sale (7-308(a), (c)). |
| Buyer’s title | supported | A good-faith purchaser takes free of rights of persons against which the lien was valid, despite non-compliance (7-308(d)). |
| Surplus | supported | Balance held for delivery on demand to the person entitled (7-308(e)). |
| Defective-sale consequence | supported | Damages for non-compliance; conversion for wilful violation (7-308(h)). |
| Citation | supported | Full official sections retrieved and read: UCC 7-307, UCC 7-308, UCC 7-210. |
Stage, canal-boat and steamboat unclaimed baggage: entry-fee lien and magistrate sale (stage_boat_unclaimed)
| Field | Status | Rule |
|---|---|---|
| Statute | supported | General Business Law §§ 280-283. |
| Who holds | supported | Proprietors of stage lines, canal-boat lines and steamboats holding unclaimed trunks, boxes or baggage (§ 280), who have a lien for the entry fee and printing expense (§ 283). |
| Priority vs. perfected security interest | supported | No priority clause. UCC 9-201(a) keeps a security agreement effective against creditors, and 9-317(a)(2) subordinates only an interest unperfected when a lien creditor arises; nothing in this grant displaces an earlier perfected security interest. |
| Cap | supported | Twelve and a half cents per item entered plus printing expense (§ 283); sale proceeds pay the charges and expenses legally incurred (§ 282). |
| Court required | supported | Yes: opening, inventory and sale take place before and at the direction of a town or city magistrate (§ 282). |
| Notice to owner | supported | Mail notice to a known owner on entry (§ 280) and again if the owner is identified on opening (§ 282). |
| Notice to lienholders | supported | None prescribed by §§ 280-283. |
| DMV notice | not applicable | The goods covered by this lien are not titled under VTL article 46 (VTL 2101-2102). |
| Publication | supported | Description published once a week for three weeks after 30 days unclaimed (§ 281); six days’ notice of the sale (§ 282). |
| Waiting period | supported | Thirty days unclaimed, 60 days after publication, then three months after the magistrate’s examination (§§ 281-282). |
| Sale method | supported | Public auction ordered by the magistrate if the property is of sufficient value (§ 282). |
| Buyer’s title | supported | No express purchaser-title or discharge clause. The purchaser takes the owner’s interest freed of the lien being enforced; under UCC 9-315(a)(1) a security interest continues in the goods notwithstanding a sale unless its holder authorized the disposition free of it, and the statute supplies no purge of other interests. Lien priority (where the priority field gives one) ranks claims but is not a statutory discharge. |
| Surplus | supported | Balance to the town or city public welfare officials for the poor, reclaimable by the owner within seven years (§ 282). |
| Defective-sale consequence | supported | No defective-sale remedy is stated; the magistrate’s direction is the safeguard (§ 282). |
| Citation | supported | Full official sections retrieved and read: General Business Law § 280, General Business Law § 281, General Business Law § 282, General Business Law § 283. |
Express company unclaimed-goods sale and advertising lien (express_company)
| Field | Status | Rule |
|---|---|---|
| Statute | supported | General Business Law §§ 285-287. |
| Who holds | supported | An express company or person in the express business holding unclaimed articles (§ 285). |
| Priority vs. perfected security interest | supported | No priority clause. UCC 9-201(a) keeps a security agreement effective against creditors, and 9-317(a)(2) subordinates only an interest unperfected when a lien creditor arises; nothing in this grant displaces an earlier perfected security interest. |
| Cap | supported | Transportation and storage charges and advertising and sale expenses; advertising expense is a ratable lien (§ 285). |
| Court required | supported | No (§ 285). |
| Notice to owner | supported | Only the published notice naming the addressee if known (§ 285). |
| Notice to lienholders | supported | None prescribed by §§ 285-287. |
| DMV notice | not applicable | The goods covered by this lien are not titled under VTL article 46 (VTL 2101-2102). |
| Publication | supported | Newspaper at or nearest the destination and at the place of sale; sale not until four weeks after first publication (§ 285). |
| Waiting period | supported | One year in possession (non-perishable), then four weeks from first publication; perishables as soon as possible on notice (§ 285). |
| Sale method | supported | Public auction (§ 285). |
| Buyer’s title | supported | No express purchaser-title or discharge clause. The purchaser takes the owner’s interest freed of the lien being enforced; under UCC 9-315(a)(1) a security interest continues in the goods notwithstanding a sale unless its holder authorized the disposition free of it, and the statute supplies no purge of other interests. Lien priority (where the priority field gives one) ranks claims but is not a statutory discharge. |
| Surplus | supported | Refunded to the owner on proof within five years (§ 286); then to the county treasurer for the county poor (§ 287). |
| Defective-sale consequence | supported | No defective-sale remedy is stated in §§ 285-287. |
| Citation | supported | Full official sections retrieved and read: General Business Law § 285, General Business Law § 286, General Business Law § 287. |
Safe-deposit lessor’s special remedies (opening and sale for unpaid rent) (safe_deposit)
| Field | Status | Rule |
|---|---|---|
| Statute | supported | Banking Law § 335. |
| Who holds | supported | A safe-deposit lessor whose box rent is unpaid one year, or whose lessee has not vacated 30 days after the lease ends (§ 335(1)(a)). |
| Priority vs. perfected security interest | supported | No priority clause. UCC 9-201(a) keeps a security agreement effective against creditors, and 9-317(a)(2) subordinates only an interest unperfected when a lien creditor arises; nothing in this grant displaces an earlier perfected security interest. |
| Cap | supported | Rent due to opening, opening cost, notary fees and safe-keeping charges not above the original rent, plus notice, advertising and sale expenses (§ 335(1)(b), (d), (e)). |
| Court required | supported | No; opening before a notary public and an officer or employee (§ 335(1)(b)). |
| Notice to owner | supported | Registered or certified mail return-receipt notice 30 days before opening; certificate of contents within ten days after opening; sale notice by the same mail not less than 30 days before sale (§ 335(1)(a), (c), (d)). |
| Notice to lienholders | supported | None prescribed by § 335. |
| DMV notice | not applicable | The goods covered by this lien are not titled under VTL article 46 (VTL 2101-2102). |
| Publication | supported | Once within ten days before the sale in a newspaper in the place of sale or the same or an adjoining county (§ 335(1)(d)). |
| Waiting period | supported | One year unpaid, 30 days’ notice, then at least two years’ safe-keeping after mailing the certificate, then 30 days’ sale notice (§ 335(1)). |
| Sale method | supported | Public auction of articles of apparent value; private papers and items of no apparent value are kept ten years, not sold (§ 335(1)(d), (f)). |
| Buyer’s title | supported | No express purchaser-title or discharge clause. The purchaser takes the owner’s interest freed of the lien being enforced; under UCC 9-315(a)(1) a security interest continues in the goods notwithstanding a sale unless its holder authorized the disposition free of it, and the statute supplies no purge of other interests. Lien priority (where the priority field gives one) ranks claims but is not a statutory discharge. |
| Surplus | supported | Balance may pay further safe-keeping costs; three years after opening it becomes abandoned property under Abandoned Property Law art. 3 (§ 335(1)(e)). |
| Defective-sale consequence | supported | No defective-sale remedy is stated in § 335. |
| Citation | supported | Full official sections retrieved and read: Banking Law § 335. |
Lien on stray animals (Town Law) (strays)
| Field | Status | Rule |
|---|---|---|
| Statute | supported | Town Law §§ 310-321. |
| Who holds | supported | A person on whose enclosed or occupied land strayed horses, cattle, sheep, swine or other beasts do damage, unless they came through a division fence he failed to keep (§ 310). |
| Priority vs. perfected security interest | supported | A lien ‘with priority over all other liens’ while the claimant keeps possession (§ 310). |
| Cap | supported | Damage, reasonable keeping charges, fees and costs (§ 310), fixed if disputed by two or three fence viewers (§ 314); statutory notice fees (§§ 311, 314, 315). |
| Court required | supported | No: after one month a fence viewer sells (§§ 316-317); foreclosure by action is an alternative (§§ 316, 321). |
| Notice to owner | supported | Written notice within 30 days, personally or by mail, or two weeks’ newspaper notice if the owner is unknown (§ 313); five days’ notice of the fence viewers’ meeting (§ 319). |
| Notice to lienholders | supported | None prescribed; the town-clerk notice is recorded and open to inspection (§ 311). |
| DMV notice | not applicable | The goods covered by this lien are not titled under VTL article 46 (VTL 2101-2102). |
| Publication | supported | At least ten days’ posted notice in five public places, one at the town clerk’s door; the town website may also be used (§ 317). |
| Waiting period | supported | Five days unredeemed before the town-clerk notice, then one month before sale (§§ 311, 316), plus ten days’ sale notice (§ 317). |
| Sale method | supported | Sale by a fence viewer to the highest bidder unless redeemed (§ 317). |
| Buyer’s title | supported | No express purchaser-title or discharge clause. The purchaser takes the owner’s interest freed of the lien being enforced; under UCC 9-315(a)(1) a security interest continues in the goods notwithstanding a sale unless its holder authorized the disposition free of it, and the statute supplies no purge of other interests. Lien priority (where the priority field gives one) ranks claims but is not a statutory discharge. |
| Surplus | supported | Fees, keeping charges, damages and execution-type sale charges are retained; residue to the owner on demand (§ 318). |
| Defective-sale consequence | supported | If fence viewers find the lien unenforceable the owner recovers the beasts free of charges (§ 320); a claimant failing to establish the lien forfeits charges and pays costs (§ 316). |
| Citation | supported | Full official sections retrieved and read: Town Law § 310, Town Law § 311, Town Law § 312, Town Law § 313, Town Law § 314, Town Law § 315, Town Law § 316, Town Law § 317, Town Law § 318, Town Law § 319, Town Law § 320, Town Law § 321. |
State lien on vessels for supplies, repairs, wharfage, towing and similar debts (vessel_supply)
| Field | Status | Rule |
|---|---|---|
| Statute | supported | Lien Law art. 4 (§§ 80-107). |
| Who holds | supported | A person owed a debt (not a maritime lien) contracted within the state by the master, owner, charterer, builder, consignee or agent, for building, repair or equipping, provisions, wharfage and port keeping, loading or advances, or towing, piloting or insurance (§ 80). |
| Priority vs. perfected security interest | needs_verification | Preferred to all other liens except mariners’ wages (§ 80), but the sale does not affect security interests perfected by filing before the notice of lien (§ 92(2)). Rank against a preferred ship mortgage or federal maritime lien on a documented vessel is a federal-law question not retrieved. |
| Cap | supported | The debt, at least USD 50 for sea-going vessels and USD 15 for others (USD 25 for towing, piloting or insurance); notice of lien within 90 days after due (first Tuesday of February for Lakes and St. Lawrence vessels) (§ 82); lien lasts 12 months from contracting (six months after the next January 1 for Lakes vessels), extended by absence or proceedings (§ 83). |
| Court required | supported | Yes. A lien founded on a maritime contract can be enforced only in the federal courts (§ 85); otherwise by a Supreme Court justice’s warrant, order to show cause and order of sale (§§ 86-92). |
| Notice to owner | supported | Order to show cause and application served personally on the master and on a resident owner or consignee, or by mail to a non-resident, within ten days after seizure; returnable at least eight days after service (§ 89). |
| Notice to lienholders | supported | Published notice of distribution to all art. 4 lienholders and interested persons, three weeks, 30 to 40 days ahead (§ 94); unwarranted lienors may file at distribution (§ 95). |
| DMV notice | supported | No DMV step is prescribed by art. 4. A purchaser of a state-titled vessel at the sheriff’s execution-manner sale titles by proof of transfer and application (VTL 2102(a)(3), 2115(a)); documented vessels have no state title (VTL 2102(a)). |
| Publication | supported | Warrant notice once a week for two weeks in the county of seizure (§ 90); sale notice as on execution (§ 93; CPLR 5233(b)). |
| Waiting period | supported | Order to show cause returnable not less than eight days after service (§ 89); sale within ten days after the order of sale (§ 93). |
| Sale method | supported | Sheriff’s sale in the manner prescribed for personal property on execution (§ 93; CPLR 5233). |
| Buyer’s title | needs_verification | For state-law interests the answer is express: security interests perfected by filing before the notice of lien ‘shall not be affected by the sale’ (§ 92(2)), and art. 4 liens are paid from proceeds by filing order (§ 98). What a purchaser takes against federal maritime liens and preferred ship mortgages on a documented vessel depends on federal law, which was not retrieved. |
| Surplus | supported | Proceeds paid into court; liens paid in order of filing (§ 98); surplus distributed after a published hearing (§ 100). |
| Defective-sale consequence | supported | Court-supervised; costs and sheriff fees fixed and adjusted by the justice (§ 105). |
| Citation | supported | Full official sections retrieved and read: Lien Law § 80, Lien Law § 82, Lien Law § 83, Lien Law § 85, Lien Law § 86, Lien Law § 88, Lien Law § 89, Lien Law § 90, Lien Law § 92, Lien Law § 93, Lien Law § 94, Lien Law § 95, Lien Law § 98, Lien Law § 100, Lien Law § 105, CPLR 5233, Vehicle and Traffic Law § 2102. |
Lien on a vessel causing damage by negligence (vessel_collision)
| Field | Status | Rule |
|---|---|---|
| Statute | supported | Lien Law art. 4 (§§ 80-107). |
| Who holds | supported | The owner of a vessel damaged at least USD 50 by another vessel’s negligent or wilful navigation, unless maritime law gives a lien (§ 81). |
| Priority vs. perfected security interest | needs_verification | Treated as an art. 4 debt (§ 81): the sale does not affect security interests perfected by filing before the notice of lien (§ 92(2)). Rank against federal maritime liens and preferred mortgages on a documented vessel is a federal-law question not retrieved. |
| Cap | supported | The damage; notice filed in the county clerk’s office where sustained (NY County clerk for New York, Kings and Queens) and proceedings begun within ten days (§ 81). |
| Court required | supported | Yes. A lien founded on a maritime contract can be enforced only in the federal courts (§ 85); otherwise by a Supreme Court justice’s warrant, order to show cause and order of sale (§§ 86-92). |
| Notice to owner | supported | Order to show cause and application served personally on the master and on a resident owner or consignee, or by mail to a non-resident, within ten days after seizure; returnable at least eight days after service (§ 89). |
| Notice to lienholders | supported | Published notice of distribution to all art. 4 lienholders and interested persons, three weeks, 30 to 40 days ahead (§ 94); unwarranted lienors may file at distribution (§ 95). |
| DMV notice | supported | No DMV step is prescribed by art. 4. A purchaser of a state-titled vessel at the sheriff’s execution-manner sale titles by proof of transfer and application (VTL 2102(a)(3), 2115(a)); documented vessels have no state title (VTL 2102(a)). |
| Publication | supported | Warrant notice once a week for two weeks in the county of seizure (§ 90); sale notice as on execution (§ 93; CPLR 5233(b)). |
| Waiting period | supported | Order to show cause returnable not less than eight days after service (§ 89); sale within ten days after the order of sale (§ 93). |
| Sale method | supported | Sheriff’s sale in the manner prescribed for personal property on execution (§ 93; CPLR 5233). |
| Buyer’s title | needs_verification | For state-law interests the answer is express: security interests perfected by filing before the notice of lien ‘shall not be affected by the sale’ (§ 92(2)), and art. 4 liens are paid from proceeds by filing order (§ 98). What a purchaser takes against federal maritime liens and preferred ship mortgages on a documented vessel depends on federal law, which was not retrieved. |
| Surplus | supported | Proceeds paid into court; liens paid in order of filing (§ 98); surplus distributed after a published hearing (§ 100). |
| Defective-sale consequence | supported | Court-supervised; costs and sheriff fees fixed and adjusted by the justice (§ 105). |
| Citation | supported | Full official sections retrieved and read: Lien Law § 81, Lien Law § 80, Lien Law § 82, Lien Law § 83, Lien Law § 85, Lien Law § 86, Lien Law § 88, Lien Law § 89, Lien Law § 90, Lien Law § 92, Lien Law § 93, Lien Law § 94, Lien Law § 95, Lien Law § 98, Lien Law § 100, Lien Law § 105, CPLR 5233, Vehicle and Traffic Law § 2102. |
Lien on cemetery monuments, gravestones and structures (monument)
| Field | Status | Rule |
|---|---|---|
| Statute | supported | Lien Law art. 5, §§ 120-124. |
| Who holds | supported | A person furnishing or placing a monument, gravestone, enclosure or structure in a cemetery (§ 120). |
| Priority vs. perfected security interest | supported | No priority clause. UCC 9-201(a) keeps a security agreement effective against creditors, and 9-317(a)(2) subordinates only an interest unperfected when a lien creditor arises; nothing in this grant displaces an earlier perfected security interest. |
| Cap | supported | Agreed price or unpaid part with interest (§ 120); removal expense allowed up to USD 50 (monument) or USD 10 (other) (§ 123). |
| Court required | supported | Yes: judgment in an action authorizes removal and auction (§ 122); removal otherwise barred (§ 124). |
| Notice to owner | supported | Verified notice filed with the cemetery within one year after the price is due, copy served within ten days on the contracting party and the ascertainable lot owner (§ 121); sale notice served at least ten days ahead (§ 122). |
| Notice to lienholders | supported | None prescribed beyond the persons served under § 121. |
| DMV notice | not applicable | The goods covered by this lien are not titled under VTL article 46 (VTL 2101-2102). |
| Publication | supported | At least ten days before sale in a local or nearest newspaper (§ 122). |
| Waiting period | supported | Ten days’ published and served notice after judgment (§ 122). |
| Sale method | supported | Public auction after removal under the judgment (§ 122). |
| Buyer’s title | supported | No express purchaser-title or discharge clause. The purchaser takes the owner’s interest freed of the lien being enforced; under UCC 9-315(a)(1) a security interest continues in the goods notwithstanding a sale unless its holder authorized the disposition free of it, and the statute supplies no purge of other interests. Lien priority (where the priority field gives one) ranks claims but is not a statutory discharge. |
| Surplus | supported | Expenses, capped removal cost and judgment, then residue forthwith to the judgment debtor (§ 123). |
| Defective-sale consequence | supported | Sale only under the judgment’s terms; cemetery officers may not obstruct a proper removal (§ 124). |
| Citation | supported | Full official sections retrieved and read: Lien Law § 120, Lien Law § 121, Lien Law § 122, Lien Law § 123, Lien Law § 124. |
Lien for labour on quarried or cut stone (stone_labor)
| Field | Status | Rule |
|---|---|---|
| Statute | supported | Lien Law art. 6, §§ 140-142; enforcement under art. 9 (§ 141). |
| Who holds | supported | A person employed quarrying, mining, dressing or cutting the listed stone, on that stone (§ 140). |
| Priority vs. perfected security interest | supported | No priority clause. Perfected by a UCC-style filing (§ 140); this non-possessory, non-agricultural lien is outside UCC 9-333, and an earlier perfected security interest keeps effect (UCC 9-201(a)). No attachment to stone built into a structure or no longer the employer’s (§ 141). |
| Cap | supported | Amount due for the labour; the owner’s total exposure is limited to the unpaid contract balance (§ 141). |
| Court required | supported | Yes: action to foreclose a chattel lien (§§ 206-210); a seizure warrant may issue (§§ 207, 209). |
| Notice to owner | supported | Notice filed within 30 days after completing the labour and served on the owner or person in charge within five days (§ 140); then process in the action. |
| Notice to lienholders | supported | None beyond the public filing (§ 140). |
| DMV notice | not applicable | The goods covered by this lien are not titled under VTL article 46 (VTL 2101-2102). |
| Publication | supported | As on execution: CPLR 5233(b) posting, since the judgment directs sale ‘in like manner as where a sheriff sells personal property by virtue of an execution’ (§ 208). |
| Waiting period | supported | Action within three months after filing or the lien ends (§§ 141, 142). |
| Sale method | supported | Sale by a referee or designated officer in execution manner (§ 208; CPLR 5233). |
| Buyer’s title | supported | As on execution: the purchaser takes the debtor’s interest freed of the foreclosed lien; earlier security interests are not defeated (CPLR 5233(a), 5234(b)). |
| Surplus | supported | Judgment provides for payment of surplus to the owner and its safekeeping (§ 208); county treasurer in inferior courts (§ 209). |
| Defective-sale consequence | supported | Court-supervised; discharge by payment, lapse, consent or a double-amount undertaking (§ 142). |
| Citation | supported | Full official sections retrieved and read: Lien Law § 140, Lien Law § 141, Lien Law § 142, Lien Law § 206, Lien Law § 207, Lien Law § 208, Lien Law § 209, Lien Law § 210, CPLR 5233. |
Stallion and bull service lien on mare or cow and offspring (breeding)
| Field | Status | Rule |
|---|---|---|
| Statute | supported | Lien Law art. 7, §§ 160-163 (§ 161 returned an index page, not text); enforcement under §§ 206-210 (§ 160). |
| Who holds | supported | The owner of a stallion or bull, on each mare or cow served and the resulting foal or calf (§ 160). |
| Priority vs. perfected security interest | supported | Filed like a financing statement (§ 160). Where it is an agricultural lien (farm products of a farming debtor, UCC 9-102(a)(5)), it ranks with security interests by first filing or perfection (9-322(a)(1)); otherwise an earlier perfected security interest keeps effect (9-201(a)). |
| Cap | supported | Amount agreed at service, or the amount in the filed statement (§ 160). |
| Court required | supported | Yes: action to foreclose a chattel lien (§§ 206-210); a seizure warrant may issue (§§ 207, 209). |
| Notice to owner | supported | Filed written notice within 20 months after service naming the debtor, amount and property (§ 160); then process in the action. |
| Notice to lienholders | supported | None beyond the public filing (§ 160). |
| DMV notice | not applicable | The goods covered by this lien are not titled under VTL article 46 (VTL 2101-2102). |
| Publication | supported | As on execution: CPLR 5233(b) posting, since the judgment directs sale ‘in like manner as where a sheriff sells personal property by virtue of an execution’ (§ 208). |
| Waiting period | supported | Lien ends 18 months after filing unless an action is begun (§ 160). |
| Sale method | supported | Sale by a referee or designated officer in execution manner (§ 208; CPLR 5233). |
| Buyer’s title | supported | As on execution: the purchaser takes the debtor’s interest freed of the foreclosed lien; earlier security interests are not defeated (CPLR 5233(a), 5234(b)). |
| Surplus | supported | Judgment provides for payment of surplus to the owner and its safekeeping (§ 208); county treasurer in inferior courts (§ 209). |
| Defective-sale consequence | supported | Court-supervised; a keeper who fails to file and post the statement or misstates pedigree forfeits fees and owes damages (§§ 162-163). |
| Citation | supported | Full official sections retrieved and read: Lien Law § 160, Lien Law § 162, Lien Law § 163, UCC 9-322, UCC 9-102, Lien Law § 206, Lien Law § 207, Lien Law § 208, Lien Law § 209, Lien Law § 210, CPLR 5233. |
Child-support arrears lien on personal property (vehicles perfected at DMV) (support_arrears)
| Field | Status | Rule |
|---|---|---|
| Statute | supported | Lien Law § 211; Social Services Law § 111-u; VTL 2105-a. |
| Who holds | supported | The Office of Temporary and Disability Assistance or a social services district for an obligor under a support-collection order with at least four months’ arrears (§ 211(1), (3); SSL 111-u(1)). |
| Priority vs. perfected security interest | supported | Perfected for vehicles at DMV and listed on later titles (§ 211(1); VTL 2105-a(c)); no rank over an earlier perfected security interest is stated and none is displaced (UCC 9-201(a)); a purchaser takes free of a lien not on the transfer title (VTL 2105-a(d)). |
| Cap | supported | Arrears plus future unpaid support (§ 211(1); SSL 111-u(1)), with the retroactive-support limits (§ 211(3)). |
| Court required | supported | Enforcement ‘shall be governed by article nine of this chapter’ and may not require prior judicial notice or hearing (§ 211(2)). Article 9’s non-judicial sale needs the lienor’s legal possession (§ 200); otherwise enforcement is by chattel-lien action (§§ 206-210). No enforcement until any administrative review period ends (SSL 111-u(4)). |
| Notice to owner | supported | Notice of intent by first-class mail with 35 days to assert a mistake of fact, determination within 90 days, and a copy of the filed notice to the property owner within five days before or 30 days after filing (SSL 111-u(3), (4), (6)); then § 201 notice or process in the action. |
| Notice to lienholders | supported | Section 201 notice to filers and title-listed lienholders if sold under § 202; process in the action otherwise. |
| DMV notice | supported | Perfection and release at DMV without fee, electronically permitted (§ 211(1)); OTDA notifies DMV under the written agreement (VTL 2105-a(a)-(b)). |
| Publication | supported | As on execution: CPLR 5233(b) posting, since the judgment directs sale ‘in like manner as where a sheriff sells personal property by virtue of an execution’ (§ 208). |
| Waiting period | supported | Thirty-five-day mistake-of-fact window and any review period before enforcement (SSL 111-u(3)-(4)); then art. 9 periods. |
| Sale method | supported | Sale by a referee or designated officer in execution manner (§ 208; CPLR 5233). |
| Buyer’s title | supported | A purchaser, including a dealer, takes the vehicle unencumbered by a lien not recorded on the title used to transfer it (VTL 2105-a(d)); on an art. 9 sale the purchaser takes the obligor’s interest freed of this lien, other perfected interests continuing (UCC 9-315(a)(1)). |
| Surplus | supported | Lien Law § 204 for a § 202 sale, or the judgment’s surplus provision (§ 208). |
| Defective-sale consequence | supported | Court-supervised sale; CPLR 5240 supervision applies to execution-manner sales. |
| Citation | supported | Full official sections retrieved and read: Lien Law § 211, Social Services Law § 111-U, Vehicle and Traffic Law § 2105-a, Lien Law § 200, Lien Law § 206, Lien Law § 207, Lien Law § 208, Lien Law § 209, Lien Law § 210, CPLR 5233, CPLR 5234. |
Lien on public moneys for labour and materials on public improvements (public_improvement_funds)
| Field | Status | Rule |
|---|---|---|
| Statute | supported | Lien Law §§ 5, 12, 25, 42. |
| Who holds | supported | A person furnishing labour or materials to a contractor or subcontractor on a public improvement, and benefit trust funds, on the State’s or public corporation’s moneys for the improvement (§ 5). |
| Priority vs. perfected security interest | supported | Priority against assignees of the contract moneys is by filing order and advances (§ 25(1)-(2)); daily or weekly wage labourers rank first as a class (§ 25(3)). |
| Cap | supported | Value or agreed price, limited to the amount due or to become due on the contract (§ 5). |
| Court required | supported | Yes: enforced by civil action as for a mechanic’s lien (§ 42). |
| Notice to owner | supported | Notice of lien filed with the department head and the comptroller or financial officer before completion and acceptance or within 30 days after (§ 12). |
| Notice to lienholders | not applicable | No lien sale or title transfer is created by this grant, so there is no lienholder sale notice. |
| DMV notice | not applicable | No vehicle, vessel or other titled-asset transfer is created by this grant. |
| Publication | not applicable | No statutory auction or publication procedure is conferred by this grant. |
| Waiting period | not applicable | No lien-sale waiting period; enforcement follows the route in the sale_method field. |
| Sale method | supported | No asset sale: payment out of the public fund under judgment (§ 42). |
| Buyer’s title | not applicable | No buyer or ownership transfer is created by this grant. |
| Surplus | not applicable | No auction surplus arises under this grant. |
| Defective-sale consequence | supported | No sale; remedies are in the foreclosure action (§ 42). |
| Citation | supported | Full official sections retrieved and read: Lien Law § 5, Lien Law § 12, Lien Law § 25, Lien Law § 42. |
Hospital lien on injured patient’s claims (hospital)
| Field | Status | Rule |
|---|---|---|
| Statute | supported | Lien Law § 189. |
| Who holds | supported | A charitable hospital, SUNY or a municipal hospital treating a person injured within the prior week (§ 189(1)). |
| Priority vs. perfected security interest | supported | Attaches to the injured person’s claims and recoveries (§ 189(1)); it creates no priority in a decedent’s estate or wrongful-death distribution (§ 189(7)); UCC 9-109(d)(12) keeps tort-claim assignments outside Article 9. |
| Cap | supported | Reasonable hospital charges at cost rates (§ 189(1)). |
| Court required | supported | No order to create; enforced by action within the statutory period (§ 189(3), (10)); execution on the tort judgment is stayed until the lien is satisfied (§ 189(8)). |
| Notice to owner | supported | Registered or certified notice to the alleged tortfeasor and its insurer before payment, plus a verified notice filed with the county clerk (§ 189(1)); filing valid ten years, renewable (§ 189(11)). |
| Notice to lienholders | not applicable | No lien sale or title transfer is created by this grant, so there is no lienholder sale notice. |
| DMV notice | not applicable | No vehicle, vessel or other titled-asset transfer is created by this grant. |
| Publication | not applicable | No statutory auction or publication procedure is conferred by this grant. |
| Waiting period | not applicable | No lien-sale waiting period; enforcement follows the route in the sale_method field. |
| Sale method | supported | No asset sale; collection from the recovery or by suit against a payer who ignores the lien (§ 189(3), (10)). |
| Buyer’s title | not applicable | No buyer or ownership transfer is created by this grant. |
| Surplus | not applicable | No auction surplus arises under this grant. |
| Defective-sale consequence | supported | No sale; enforcement and discharge are by the statute’s own action or order. |
| Citation | supported | Full official sections retrieved and read: Lien Law § 189. |
Attorney’s charging lien (attorney_charging)
| Field | Status | Rule |
|---|---|---|
| Statute | supported | Judiciary Law § 475, Judiciary Law § 475-a. |
| Who holds | supported | The attorney who appears for a party, from commencement (§ 475), or who serves a pre-suit notice of lien (§ 475-a). |
| Priority vs. perfected security interest | supported | Attaches to a tort claim or recovery; UCC 9-109(d)(12) excludes assignments of non-commercial tort claims from Article 9, so no Article 9 priority contest arises; rank is set by this statute. |
| Cap | supported | Reasonable value of services as determined by the court (§ 475). |
| Court required | supported | Court determines and enforces on petition (§ 475). |
| Notice to owner | supported | Pre-suit notice by personal service or registered mail, signed by client and attorney (§ 475-a). |
| Notice to lienholders | not applicable | No lien sale or title transfer is created by this grant, so there is no lienholder sale notice. |
| DMV notice | not applicable | No vehicle, vessel or other titled-asset transfer is created by this grant. |
| Publication | not applicable | No statutory auction or publication procedure is conferred by this grant. |
| Waiting period | not applicable | No lien-sale waiting period; enforcement follows the route in the sale_method field. |
| Sale method | supported | No asset sale; the lien attaches to the verdict, settlement, judgment or proceeds ‘in whatever hands they may come’ (§§ 475, 475-a). |
| Buyer’s title | not applicable | No buyer or ownership transfer is created by this grant. |
| Surplus | not applicable | No auction surplus arises under this grant. |
| Defective-sale consequence | supported | No sale; enforcement and discharge are by the statute’s own action or order. |
| Citation | supported | Full official sections retrieved and read: Judiciary Law § 475, Judiciary Law § 475-a. |
Workers’ compensation carrier lien on third-party recovery (comp_carrier)
| Field | Status | Rule |
|---|---|---|
| Statute | supported | Workers’ Compensation Law § 29. |
| Who holds | supported | The State Insurance Fund or the carrier or self-insurer liable for compensation (§ 29(1)). |
| Priority vs. perfected security interest | supported | Attaches to a tort claim or recovery; UCC 9-109(d)(12) excludes assignments of non-commercial tort claims from Article 9, so no Article 9 priority contest arises; rank is set by this statute. |
| Cap | supported | Compensation and medical expenses paid, after the equitably apportioned recovery expenses (§ 29(1)). |
| Court required | supported | No order needed to create; apportionment of expenses by court order on application (§ 29(1)). |
| Notice to owner | supported | Notice of commencement of the third-party action to the chair, employer and carrier within 30 days (§ 29(1)). |
| Notice to lienholders | not applicable | No lien sale or title transfer is created by this grant, so there is no lienholder sale notice. |
| DMV notice | not applicable | No vehicle, vessel or other titled-asset transfer is created by this grant. |
| Publication | not applicable | No statutory auction or publication procedure is conferred by this grant. |
| Waiting period | not applicable | No lien-sale waiting period; enforcement follows the route in the sale_method field. |
| Sale method | supported | No asset sale; the lien is satisfied from the recovery (§ 29(1)). |
| Buyer’s title | not applicable | No buyer or ownership transfer is created by this grant. |
| Surplus | not applicable | No auction surplus arises under this grant. |
| Defective-sale consequence | supported | No sale; enforcement and discharge are by the statute’s own action or order. |
| Citation | supported | Full official sections retrieved and read: Workers’ Compensation Law § 29. |
Public-assistance lien on recipient’s injury claims (public_assistance_injury)
| Field | Status | Rule |
|---|---|---|
| Statute | supported | Social Services Law § 104-b. |
| Who holds | supported | The public welfare official of the district that furnished assistance and care (§ 104-b(1)). |
| Priority vs. perfected security interest | supported | Attaches to a tort claim or recovery; UCC 9-109(d)(12) excludes assignments of non-commercial tort claims from Article 9, so no Article 9 priority contest arises; rank is set by this statute. |
| Cap | supported | Amount fixed by the official, not above assistance furnished since the injury (§ 104-b(1)). |
| Court required | supported | No order to create; enforced against a payer who disregards the notice (§ 104-b). |
| Notice to owner | supported | Certified or registered notice to the alleged tortfeasor, its attorney and insurer before payment, and filing with the county clerk (§ 104-b(2)). |
| Notice to lienholders | not applicable | No lien sale or title transfer is created by this grant, so there is no lienholder sale notice. |
| DMV notice | not applicable | No vehicle, vessel or other titled-asset transfer is created by this grant. |
| Publication | not applicable | No statutory auction or publication procedure is conferred by this grant. |
| Waiting period | not applicable | No lien-sale waiting period; enforcement follows the route in the sale_method field. |
| Sale method | supported | No asset sale; collection from the recovery (§ 104-b). |
| Buyer’s title | not applicable | No buyer or ownership transfer is created by this grant. |
| Surplus | not applicable | No auction surplus arises under this grant. |
| Defective-sale consequence | supported | No sale; enforcement and discharge are by the statute’s own action or order. |
| Citation | supported | Full official sections retrieved and read: Social Services Law § 104-b. |
Credit union lien on member shares and deposits (credit_union_shares)
| Field | Status | Rule |
|---|---|---|
| Statute | supported | Banking Law § 454. |
| Who holds | supported | A New York credit union, for sums a member owes or guarantees (§ 454(12)). |
| Priority vs. perfected security interest | supported | A statutory lien on the member’s own shares and deposits at the credit union; no rank over a third party’s perfected security interest is stated, and none is displaced (UCC 9-201(a)). |
| Cap | supported | Sums owed, including loans guaranteed or endorsed (§ 454(12)). |
| Court required | supported | No (§ 454(12)). |
| Notice to owner | supported | None prescribed by § 454(12). |
| Notice to lienholders | not applicable | No lien sale or title transfer is created by this grant, so there is no lienholder sale notice. |
| DMV notice | not applicable | No vehicle, vessel or other titled-asset transfer is created by this grant. |
| Publication | not applicable | No statutory auction or publication procedure is conferred by this grant. |
| Waiting period | not applicable | No lien-sale waiting period; enforcement follows the route in the sale_method field. |
| Sale method | supported | No asset sale; the credit union applies the shares or deposits (§ 454(12)-(13)). |
| Buyer’s title | not applicable | No buyer or ownership transfer is created by this grant. |
| Surplus | not applicable | No auction surplus arises under this grant. |
| Defective-sale consequence | supported | No sale; enforcement and discharge are by the statute’s own action or order. |
| Citation | supported | Full official sections retrieved and read: Banking Law § 454. |
General Municipal Law revenue-bond lien on undertaking revenues (revenue_bonds)
| Field | Status | Rule |
|---|---|---|
| Statute | supported | General Municipal Law § 407. |
| Who holds | supported | Holders of bonds issued under GML art. 14-A for a revenue-producing undertaking (§ 407). |
| Priority vs. perfected security interest | supported | ’Prior and paramount lien’ on the undertaking’s revenue over later bonds and claims, subject to prior outstanding bonds, claims or obligations (§ 407). |
| Cap | supported | Bonds of the issue, equally and ratably secured (§ 407). |
| Court required | supported | No; enforcement under the bond resolution. |
| Notice to owner | supported | Through the authorizing resolution (§ 407). |
| Notice to lienholders | not applicable | No lien sale or title transfer is created by this grant, so there is no lienholder sale notice. |
| DMV notice | not applicable | No vehicle, vessel or other titled-asset transfer is created by this grant. |
| Publication | not applicable | No statutory auction or publication procedure is conferred by this grant. |
| Waiting period | not applicable | No lien-sale waiting period; enforcement follows the route in the sale_method field. |
| Sale method | supported | No asset sale; application of pledged revenues (§ 407). |
| Buyer’s title | not applicable | No buyer or ownership transfer is created by this grant. |
| Surplus | not applicable | No auction surplus arises under this grant. |
| Defective-sale consequence | supported | No sale; enforcement and discharge are by the statute’s own action or order. |
| Citation | supported | Full official sections retrieved and read: General Municipal Law § 407. |
Charge for expenses of taking custody of animals and vehicles on arrest (cruelty_custody_charge)
| Field | Status | Rule |
|---|---|---|
| Statute | supported | Agriculture and Markets Law § 373(4), (6). |
| Who holds | supported | An SPCA agent or police officer who takes charge of an animal, vehicle and contents on arrest of the person in charge, and the custodian police or sheriff (§ 373(4)). |
| Priority vs. perfected security interest | supported | Section 373(6)(b)(4) states it does not impair or subordinate a secured lender’s interest in the animal or its sale proceeds; no rank for the § 373(4) charge is stated. |
| Cap | supported | All necessary expenses of taking charge of the property (§ 373(4)). |
| Court required | supported | Forfeiture of a seized animal needs a court order on failure to post security (§ 373(6)); the § 373(4) charge needs none. |
| Notice to owner | supported | Notice and hearing in the security-posting proceeding (§ 373(6)); none for the § 373(4) charge. |
| Notice to lienholders | not applicable | No lien sale or title transfer is created by this grant, so there is no lienholder sale notice. |
| DMV notice | not applicable | No vehicle, vessel or other titled-asset transfer is created by this grant. |
| Publication | not applicable | No statutory auction or publication procedure is conferred by this grant. |
| Waiting period | not applicable | No lien-sale waiting period; enforcement follows the route in the sale_method field. |
| Sale method | supported | No sale under § 373(4); forfeited animals go to adoption or euthanasia (§ 373(6)). |
| Buyer’s title | not applicable | No buyer or ownership transfer is created by this grant. |
| Surplus | not applicable | No auction surplus arises under this grant. |
| Defective-sale consequence | supported | No sale is authorized by this charge. |
| Citation | supported | Full official sections retrieved and read: Agriculture and Markets Law § 373. |
Personal income tax warrant lien (income_tax)
| Field | Status | Rule |
|---|---|---|
| Statute | supported | Tax Law § 692. |
| Who holds | supported | The Commissioner of Taxation and Finance (Tax Law 692). |
| Priority vs. perfected security interest | supported | The docketed warrant is a lien on personal property only if also filed with the Department of State (Tax Law § 692); no rank over an earlier perfected security interest is stated, and execution distribution does not impair a secured party’s rights (CPLR 5234(b)). |
| Cap | supported | Tax, penalties, interest and the cost of executing the warrant (Tax Law § 692). |
| Court required | supported | No: the filed warrant has the effect of a judgment and the sheriff or a Department officer levies and sells as on execution (Tax Law § 692). |
| Notice to owner | supported | Notice and demand, then a warrant after 21 calendar days (ten business days at USD 100,000 or more), within six years of assessment; earlier on jeopardy findings (Tax Law 692(b)-(c)). |
| Notice to lienholders | supported | As on execution: CPLR 5233 requires public posting, not individual lienholder notice. |
| DMV notice | supported | No DMV notice; a buyer of a titled vehicle at the execution-manner sale titles under VTL 2102(a)(3) and 2115(a). |
| Publication | supported | As on execution: printed notice posted at least six days before sale in three public places, or the NYC newspaper alternative (CPLR 5233(b)). |
| Waiting period | supported | Six days’ posting (CPLR 5233(b)); no distribution until 15 days after service of the execution without court order (CPLR 5234(a)); an owner may request sale within 60 days (Tax Law 3020(b)). |
| Sale method | supported | Sheriff’s public auction as on execution (CPLR 5233(a)), at fair market value (Tax Law 3020(a)). |
| Buyer’s title | supported | As on execution: the judgment debtor’s interest (CPLR 5233(a)); secured parties’ rights are not impaired (CPLR 5234(b)); a posting omission does not affect a purchaser without notice (5233(b)). |
| Surplus | supported | After fees, expenses and taxes, proceeds pay the warrant and any excess goes to the taxpayer (CPLR 5234(a)). |
| Defective-sale consequence | supported | Court supervision of enforcement on motion (CPLR 5240); title of a purchaser without notice survives posting defects (5233(b)). |
| Citation | supported | Full official sections retrieved and read: Tax Law § 692, CPLR 5233, CPLR 5234, CPLR 5240, Tax Law § 3020, Vehicle and Traffic Law § 2102. |
Corporate franchise tax warrant lien (articles 9, 9-A, 9-B, 9-C) (corporate_tax)
| Field | Status | Rule |
|---|---|---|
| Statute | supported | Tax Law § 1092. |
| Who holds | supported | The Commissioner of Taxation and Finance (Tax Law 1092). |
| Priority vs. perfected security interest | supported | The docketed warrant is a lien on personal property only if also filed with the Department of State (Tax Law § 1092); no rank over an earlier perfected security interest is stated, and execution distribution does not impair a secured party’s rights (CPLR 5234(b)). |
| Cap | supported | Tax, penalties, interest and the cost of executing the warrant (Tax Law § 1092). |
| Court required | supported | No: the filed warrant has the effect of a judgment and the sheriff or a Department officer levies and sells as on execution (Tax Law § 1092). |
| Notice to owner | supported | Notice and demand, then a warrant after 21 calendar days (ten business days at USD 100,000 or more), within six years of assessment; earlier on jeopardy findings (Tax Law 1092(b)-(c)). |
| Notice to lienholders | supported | As on execution: CPLR 5233 requires public posting, not individual lienholder notice. |
| DMV notice | supported | No DMV notice; a buyer of a titled vehicle at the execution-manner sale titles under VTL 2102(a)(3) and 2115(a). |
| Publication | supported | As on execution: printed notice posted at least six days before sale in three public places, or the NYC newspaper alternative (CPLR 5233(b)). |
| Waiting period | supported | Six days’ posting (CPLR 5233(b)); no distribution until 15 days after service of the execution without court order (CPLR 5234(a)); an owner may request sale within 60 days (Tax Law 3020(b)). |
| Sale method | supported | Sheriff’s public auction as on execution (CPLR 5233(a)), at fair market value (Tax Law 3020(a)). |
| Buyer’s title | supported | As on execution: the judgment debtor’s interest (CPLR 5233(a)); secured parties’ rights are not impaired (CPLR 5234(b)); a posting omission does not affect a purchaser without notice (5233(b)). |
| Surplus | supported | After fees, expenses and taxes, proceeds pay the warrant and any excess goes to the taxpayer (CPLR 5234(a)). |
| Defective-sale consequence | supported | Court supervision of enforcement on motion (CPLR 5240); title of a purchaser without notice survives posting defects (5233(b)). |
| Citation | supported | Full official sections retrieved and read: Tax Law § 1092, CPLR 5233, CPLR 5234, CPLR 5240, Tax Law § 3020, Vehicle and Traffic Law § 2102. |
Sales and use tax warrant lien (sales_tax)
| Field | Status | Rule |
|---|---|---|
| Statute | supported | Tax Law § 1141. |
| Who holds | supported | The Commissioner (Tax Law 1141(b)). |
| Priority vs. perfected security interest | supported | The docketed warrant is a lien on personal property only if also filed with the Department of State (Tax Law § 1141); no rank over an earlier perfected security interest is stated, and execution distribution does not impair a secured party’s rights (CPLR 5234(b)). |
| Cap | supported | Tax, penalties, interest and the cost of executing the warrant (Tax Law § 1141). |
| Court required | supported | No: the filed warrant has the effect of a judgment and the sheriff or a Department officer levies and sells as on execution (Tax Law § 1141). |
| Notice to owner | supported | Section 1141(b) states no pre-warrant notice; the warrant may issue on failure to collect or pay over. |
| Notice to lienholders | supported | As on execution: CPLR 5233 requires public posting, not individual lienholder notice. |
| DMV notice | supported | No DMV notice; a buyer of a titled vehicle at the execution-manner sale titles under VTL 2102(a)(3) and 2115(a). |
| Publication | supported | As on execution: printed notice posted at least six days before sale in three public places, or the NYC newspaper alternative (CPLR 5233(b)). |
| Waiting period | supported | Six days’ posting (CPLR 5233(b)); no distribution until 15 days after service of the execution without court order (CPLR 5234(a)); an owner may request sale within 60 days (Tax Law 3020(b)). |
| Sale method | supported | Sheriff’s public auction as on execution (CPLR 5233(a)), at fair market value (Tax Law 3020(a)). |
| Buyer’s title | supported | As on execution: the judgment debtor’s interest (CPLR 5233(a)); secured parties’ rights are not impaired (CPLR 5234(b)); a posting omission does not affect a purchaser without notice (5233(b)). |
| Surplus | supported | After fees, expenses and taxes, proceeds pay the warrant and any excess goes to the taxpayer (CPLR 5234(a)). |
| Defective-sale consequence | supported | Court supervision of enforcement on motion (CPLR 5240); title of a purchaser without notice survives posting defects (5233(b)). |
| Citation | supported | Full official sections retrieved and read: Tax Law § 1141, CPLR 5233, CPLR 5234, CPLR 5240, Tax Law § 3020, Vehicle and Traffic Law § 2102. |
Motor fuel tax warrant lien on distributors (motor_fuel_tax)
| Field | Status | Rule |
|---|---|---|
| Statute | supported | Tax Law § 289. |
| Who holds | supported | The Commissioner, against a distributor (Tax Law 289). |
| Priority vs. perfected security interest | supported | The docketed warrant is a lien on personal property only if also filed with the Department of State (Tax Law § 289); no rank over an earlier perfected security interest is stated, and execution distribution does not impair a secured party’s rights (CPLR 5234(b)). |
| Cap | supported | Tax, penalties, interest and the cost of executing the warrant (Tax Law § 289). |
| Court required | supported | No: the filed warrant has the effect of a judgment and the sheriff or a Department officer levies and sells as on execution (Tax Law § 289). |
| Notice to owner | supported | Section 289 states no pre-warrant notice; the warrant may issue on failure to pay within the time limited. |
| Notice to lienholders | supported | As on execution: CPLR 5233 requires public posting, not individual lienholder notice. |
| DMV notice | supported | No DMV notice; a buyer of a titled vehicle at the execution-manner sale titles under VTL 2102(a)(3) and 2115(a). |
| Publication | supported | As on execution: printed notice posted at least six days before sale in three public places, or the NYC newspaper alternative (CPLR 5233(b)). |
| Waiting period | supported | Six days’ posting (CPLR 5233(b)); no distribution until 15 days after service of the execution without court order (CPLR 5234(a)); an owner may request sale within 60 days (Tax Law 3020(b)). |
| Sale method | supported | Sheriff’s public auction as on execution (CPLR 5233(a)), at fair market value (Tax Law 3020(a)). |
| Buyer’s title | supported | As on execution: the judgment debtor’s interest (CPLR 5233(a)); secured parties’ rights are not impaired (CPLR 5234(b)); a posting omission does not affect a purchaser without notice (5233(b)). |
| Surplus | supported | After fees, expenses and taxes, proceeds pay the warrant and any excess goes to the taxpayer (CPLR 5234(a)). |
| Defective-sale consequence | supported | Court supervision of enforcement on motion (CPLR 5240); title of a purchaser without notice survives posting defects (5233(b)). |
| Citation | supported | Full official sections retrieved and read: Tax Law § 289, CPLR 5233, CPLR 5234, CPLR 5240, Tax Law § 3020, Vehicle and Traffic Law § 2102. |
Alcoholic beverage tax warrant lien (alcoholic_beverage_tax)
| Field | Status | Rule |
|---|---|---|
| Statute | supported | Tax Law § 431. |
| Who holds | supported | The Commissioner, against a distributor, non-commercial importer or other person (Tax Law 431(2)). |
| Priority vs. perfected security interest | supported | The docketed warrant is a lien on personal property only if also filed with the Department of State (Tax Law § 431); no rank over an earlier perfected security interest is stated, and execution distribution does not impair a secured party’s rights (CPLR 5234(b)). |
| Cap | supported | Tax, penalties, interest and the cost of executing the warrant (Tax Law § 431). |
| Court required | supported | No: the filed warrant has the effect of a judgment and the sheriff or a Department officer levies and sells as on execution (Tax Law § 431). |
| Notice to owner | supported | Section 431 states no pre-warrant notice; the warrant may issue on failure to pay within the time limited. |
| Notice to lienholders | supported | As on execution: CPLR 5233 requires public posting, not individual lienholder notice. |
| DMV notice | supported | No DMV notice; a buyer of a titled vehicle at the execution-manner sale titles under VTL 2102(a)(3) and 2115(a). |
| Publication | supported | As on execution: printed notice posted at least six days before sale in three public places, or the NYC newspaper alternative (CPLR 5233(b)). |
| Waiting period | supported | Six days’ posting (CPLR 5233(b)); no distribution until 15 days after service of the execution without court order (CPLR 5234(a)); an owner may request sale within 60 days (Tax Law 3020(b)). |
| Sale method | supported | Sheriff’s public auction as on execution (CPLR 5233(a)), at fair market value (Tax Law 3020(a)). |
| Buyer’s title | supported | As on execution: the judgment debtor’s interest (CPLR 5233(a)); secured parties’ rights are not impaired (CPLR 5234(b)); a posting omission does not affect a purchaser without notice (5233(b)). |
| Surplus | supported | After fees, expenses and taxes, proceeds pay the warrant and any excess goes to the taxpayer (CPLR 5234(a)). |
| Defective-sale consequence | supported | Court supervision of enforcement on motion (CPLR 5240); title of a purchaser without notice survives posting defects (5233(b)). |
| Citation | supported | Full official sections retrieved and read: Tax Law § 431, CPLR 5233, CPLR 5234, CPLR 5240, Tax Law § 3020, Vehicle and Traffic Law § 2102. |
Cigarette and tobacco tax warrant lien (cigarette_tax)
| Field | Status | Rule |
|---|---|---|
| Statute | supported | Tax Law § 479. |
| Who holds | supported | The Commissioner, against a dealer or other person (Tax Law 479). |
| Priority vs. perfected security interest | supported | The docketed warrant is a lien on personal property only if also filed with the Department of State (Tax Law § 479); no rank over an earlier perfected security interest is stated, and execution distribution does not impair a secured party’s rights (CPLR 5234(b)). |
| Cap | supported | Tax, penalties, interest and the cost of executing the warrant (Tax Law § 479). |
| Court required | supported | No: the filed warrant has the effect of a judgment and the sheriff or a Department officer levies and sells as on execution (Tax Law § 479). |
| Notice to owner | supported | Section 479 states no pre-warrant notice. |
| Notice to lienholders | supported | As on execution: CPLR 5233 requires public posting, not individual lienholder notice. |
| DMV notice | supported | No DMV notice; a buyer of a titled vehicle at the execution-manner sale titles under VTL 2102(a)(3) and 2115(a). |
| Publication | supported | As on execution: printed notice posted at least six days before sale in three public places, or the NYC newspaper alternative (CPLR 5233(b)). |
| Waiting period | supported | Six days’ posting (CPLR 5233(b)); no distribution until 15 days after service of the execution without court order (CPLR 5234(a)); an owner may request sale within 60 days (Tax Law 3020(b)). |
| Sale method | supported | Sheriff’s public auction as on execution (CPLR 5233(a)), at fair market value (Tax Law 3020(a)). |
| Buyer’s title | supported | As on execution: the judgment debtor’s interest (CPLR 5233(a)); secured parties’ rights are not impaired (CPLR 5234(b)); a posting omission does not affect a purchaser without notice (5233(b)). |
| Surplus | supported | After fees, expenses and taxes, proceeds pay the warrant and any excess goes to the taxpayer (CPLR 5234(a)). |
| Defective-sale consequence | supported | Court supervision of enforcement on motion (CPLR 5240); title of a purchaser without notice survives posting defects (5233(b)). |
| Citation | supported | Full official sections retrieved and read: Tax Law § 479, CPLR 5233, CPLR 5234, CPLR 5240, Tax Law § 3020, Vehicle and Traffic Law § 2102. |
Highway use tax warrant lien (highway_use_tax)
| Field | Status | Rule |
|---|---|---|
| Statute | supported | Tax Law § 511. |
| Who holds | supported | The Commissioner (Tax Law 511(2)). |
| Priority vs. perfected security interest | supported | The docketed warrant is a lien on personal property only if also filed with the Department of State (Tax Law § 511); no rank over an earlier perfected security interest is stated, and execution distribution does not impair a secured party’s rights (CPLR 5234(b)). |
| Cap | supported | Tax, penalties, interest and the cost of executing the warrant (Tax Law § 511). |
| Court required | supported | No: the filed warrant has the effect of a judgment and the sheriff or a Department officer levies and sells as on execution (Tax Law § 511). |
| Notice to owner | supported | Section 511 states no pre-warrant notice; the warrant may issue on failure to pay within the time limited. |
| Notice to lienholders | supported | As on execution: CPLR 5233 requires public posting, not individual lienholder notice. |
| DMV notice | supported | No DMV notice; a buyer of a titled vehicle at the execution-manner sale titles under VTL 2102(a)(3) and 2115(a). |
| Publication | supported | As on execution: printed notice posted at least six days before sale in three public places, or the NYC newspaper alternative (CPLR 5233(b)). |
| Waiting period | supported | Six days’ posting (CPLR 5233(b)); no distribution until 15 days after service of the execution without court order (CPLR 5234(a)); an owner may request sale within 60 days (Tax Law 3020(b)). |
| Sale method | supported | Sheriff’s public auction as on execution (CPLR 5233(a)), at fair market value (Tax Law 3020(a)). |
| Buyer’s title | supported | As on execution: the judgment debtor’s interest (CPLR 5233(a)); secured parties’ rights are not impaired (CPLR 5234(b)); a posting omission does not affect a purchaser without notice (5233(b)). |
| Surplus | supported | After fees, expenses and taxes, proceeds pay the warrant and any excess goes to the taxpayer (CPLR 5234(a)). |
| Defective-sale consequence | supported | Court supervision of enforcement on motion (CPLR 5240); title of a purchaser without notice survives posting defects (5233(b)). |
| Citation | supported | Full official sections retrieved and read: Tax Law § 511, CPLR 5233, CPLR 5234, CPLR 5240, Tax Law § 3020, Vehicle and Traffic Law § 2102. |
Real estate transfer tax warrant lien on grantor or grantee (transfer_tax)
| Field | Status | Rule |
|---|---|---|
| Statute | supported | Tax Law § 1414. |
| Who holds | supported | The Commissioner, against a grantor or grantee liable for the tax (Tax Law 1414(b)). |
| Priority vs. perfected security interest | supported | The docketed warrant is a lien on personal property only if also filed with the Department of State (Tax Law § 1414); no rank over an earlier perfected security interest is stated, and execution distribution does not impair a secured party’s rights (CPLR 5234(b)). |
| Cap | supported | Tax, penalties, interest and the cost of executing the warrant (Tax Law § 1414). |
| Court required | supported | No: the filed warrant has the effect of a judgment and the sheriff or a Department officer levies and sells as on execution (Tax Law § 1414). |
| Notice to owner | supported | Section 1414 states no pre-warrant notice. |
| Notice to lienholders | supported | As on execution: CPLR 5233 requires public posting, not individual lienholder notice. |
| DMV notice | supported | No DMV notice; a buyer of a titled vehicle at the execution-manner sale titles under VTL 2102(a)(3) and 2115(a). |
| Publication | supported | As on execution: printed notice posted at least six days before sale in three public places, or the NYC newspaper alternative (CPLR 5233(b)). |
| Waiting period | supported | Six days’ posting (CPLR 5233(b)); no distribution until 15 days after service of the execution without court order (CPLR 5234(a)); an owner may request sale within 60 days (Tax Law 3020(b)). |
| Sale method | supported | Sheriff’s public auction as on execution (CPLR 5233(a)), at fair market value (Tax Law 3020(a)). |
| Buyer’s title | supported | As on execution: the judgment debtor’s interest (CPLR 5233(a)); secured parties’ rights are not impaired (CPLR 5234(b)); a posting omission does not affect a purchaser without notice (5233(b)). |
| Surplus | supported | After fees, expenses and taxes, proceeds pay the warrant and any excess goes to the taxpayer (CPLR 5234(a)). |
| Defective-sale consequence | supported | Court supervision of enforcement on motion (CPLR 5240); title of a purchaser without notice survives posting defects (5233(b)). |
| Citation | supported | Full official sections retrieved and read: Tax Law § 1414, CPLR 5233, CPLR 5234, CPLR 5240, Tax Law § 3020, Vehicle and Traffic Law § 2102. |
Estate tax lien (estate_tax)
| Field | Status | Rule |
|---|---|---|
| Statute | supported | Tax Law 982. |
| Who holds | supported | The State, until the estate tax is paid (982(a)). |
| Priority vs. perfected security interest | supported | Lien on all property in the New York gross estate for 15 years from death; only good-faith prior mortgages on real property are expressly senior (982(a)-(b)); no rank over a personal-property security interest is stated and none is displaced (UCC 9-201(a)). |
| Cap | supported | Unpaid estate tax (982(a)). |
| Court required | supported | No order to create; property used for court-allowed administration expenses is divested of the lien (982(a)). |
| Notice to owner | supported | Arises by operation of law at death; discharge certificates on application (982(c)). |
| Notice to lienholders | not applicable | No lien sale or title transfer is created by this grant, so there is no lienholder sale notice. |
| DMV notice | not applicable | No vehicle, vessel or other titled-asset transfer is created by this grant. |
| Publication | not applicable | No statutory auction or publication procedure is conferred by this grant. |
| Waiting period | not applicable | No lien-sale waiting period; enforcement follows the route in the sale_method field. |
| Sale method | supported | No sale under the lien; the executor may sell estate property to pay the tax as for debts (982(e)). |
| Buyer’s title | supported | A certificate of discharge is conclusive that the lien is extinguished on the covered property (982(c)). |
| Surplus | not applicable | No auction surplus arises under this grant. |
| Defective-sale consequence | supported | No sale under the lien itself. |
| Citation | supported | Full official sections retrieved and read: Tax Law § 982. |
Rightfully rejecting buyer’s security interest in goods (rejecting_buyer)
| Field | Status | Rule |
|---|---|---|
| Statute | supported | UCC 2-711, UCC 2-706, UCC 9-109. |
| Who holds | supported | A buyer who rightfully rejects or justifiably revokes acceptance, on goods in its possession or control (2-711(3)). |
| Priority vs. perfected security interest | supported | A UCC Article 2 security interest within Article 9 (9-109(a)(5)); no rank over an earlier perfected security interest is stated and none is displaced (9-201(a)). |
| Cap | supported | Payments made on the price and expenses of inspection, receipt, transportation, care and custody (2-711(3)). |
| Court required | supported | No court order is required by the statute. |
| Notice to owner | supported | Reasonable notification of a private resale; reasonable notice of time and place of a public resale except for perishables (UCC 2-706(3)-(4)). |
| Notice to lienholders | supported | None prescribed by 2-706. |
| DMV notice | supported | No DMV step is prescribed by these sections. |
| Publication | supported | None prescribed by 2-706. |
| Waiting period | supported | No fixed period; commercially reasonable timing (2-706(2)). |
| Sale method | supported | Public or private resale, every aspect commercially reasonable (2-706(2), (4)). |
| Buyer’s title | supported | A good-faith purchaser at the resale takes free of the original buyer’s rights; the statute does not purge other interests (2-706(5)). |
| Surplus | supported | Excess over the security interest is accountable (2-706(6)). |
| Defective-sale consequence | supported | No sale-specific consequence beyond the good-faith and commercial-reasonableness rules stated. |
| Citation | supported | Full official sections retrieved and read: UCC 2-711, UCC 2-706, UCC 9-109. |
Rightfully rejecting lessee’s security interest in leased goods (rejecting_lessee)
| Field | Status | Rule |
|---|---|---|
| Statute | supported | UCC 2-A-508, UCC 2-A-527, UCC 9-109. |
| Who holds | supported | A lessee who rightfully rejects or justifiably revokes acceptance, on goods in its possession or control (2-A-508(5)). |
| Priority vs. perfected security interest | supported | Within Article 9 (9-109(a)(5)); no rank over an earlier perfected security interest is stated and none is displaced (9-201(a)). |
| Cap | supported | Rent and security paid and inspection, receipt, transportation, care and custody expenses (2-A-508(5)). |
| Court required | supported | No court order is required by the statute. |
| Notice to owner | supported | None prescribed beyond good faith and commercial reasonableness (2-A-508(5)). |
| Notice to lienholders | supported | None prescribed by 2-A-508. |
| DMV notice | supported | No DMV step is prescribed by these sections. |
| Publication | supported | None prescribed by 2-A-508. |
| Waiting period | supported | No fixed period (2-A-508(5)). |
| Sale method | supported | Good-faith, commercially reasonable disposition, subject to 2-A-527(5) (2-A-508(5)). |
| Buyer’s title | needs_verification | 2-A-508(5) gives no purchaser rule of its own, and 2-A-527(4) protects buyers from a lessor’s disposition, not expressly from a rejecting lessee’s; what the buyer takes against the lessor’s ownership is not stated. |
| Surplus | supported | The lessee accounts to the lessor for any excess over its security interest (2-A-527(5)). |
| Defective-sale consequence | supported | No sale-specific consequence beyond the good-faith and commercial-reasonableness rules stated. |
| Citation | supported | Full official sections retrieved and read: UCC 2-A-508, UCC 2-A-527, UCC 9-109. |
Collecting bank’s security interest in items and documents (collecting_bank)
| Field | Status | Rule |
|---|---|---|
| Statute | supported | UCC 4-208, UCC 9-109. |
| Who holds | supported | A collecting bank, on an item and accompanying documents or their proceeds, to the extent of credit withdrawn or advances (4-208(1)). |
| Priority vs. perfected security interest | supported | Perfected without filing and with ‘priority over conflicting perfected security interests’ in the item, documents or proceeds (4-208(3)(b)-(c)). |
| Cap | supported | Credit given or advanced (4-208(1)). |
| Court required | supported | No court order is required by the statute. |
| Notice to owner | supported | Article 9 enforcement notices apply (4-208(3)). |
| Notice to lienholders | supported | Article 9 (9-611) notices apply (4-208(3)). |
| DMV notice | supported | No DMV step is prescribed by these sections. |
| Publication | supported | None prescribed. |
| Waiting period | supported | None prescribed. |
| Sale method | supported | Final settlement realizes the interest; otherwise Article 9 enforcement (4-208(3)). |
| Buyer’s title | supported | Article 9 disposition effects (9-617) apply because the interest is ‘subject to the provisions of Article 9’ (4-208(3)). |
| Surplus | supported | Article 9 surplus rules apply (4-208(3)). |
| Defective-sale consequence | supported | No sale-specific consequence beyond the good-faith and commercial-reasonableness rules stated. |
| Citation | supported | Full official sections retrieved and read: UCC 4-208, UCC 9-109. |
Presenting bank’s lien on goods after dishonour of a documentary draft (presenting_bank)
| Field | Status | Rule |
|---|---|---|
| Statute | supported | UCC 4-504, UCC 2-706. |
| Who holds | supported | A presenting bank that, after dishonour, requested instructions and received none within a reasonable time (4-504(1)). |
| Priority vs. perfected security interest | supported | No priority clause; the lien secures only reasonable expenses and is foreclosed like an unpaid seller’s lien (4-504(2)); an earlier perfected security interest is not displaced (9-201(a)). |
| Cap | supported | Reasonable expenses of storing, selling or otherwise dealing with the goods (4-504(2)). |
| Court required | supported | No court order is required by the statute. |
| Notice to owner | supported | Reasonable notification of a private resale; reasonable notice of time and place of a public resale except for perishables (UCC 2-706(3)-(4)). |
| Notice to lienholders | supported | None prescribed by 2-706. |
| DMV notice | supported | No DMV step is prescribed by these sections. |
| Publication | supported | None prescribed by 2-706. |
| Waiting period | supported | No fixed period; commercially reasonable timing (2-706(2)). |
| Sale method | supported | Public or private resale, every aspect commercially reasonable (2-706(2), (4)). |
| Buyer’s title | supported | Foreclosure ‘in the same manner as an unpaid seller’s lien’ (4-504(2)), so a good-faith resale purchaser takes free of the buyer’s rights (2-706(5)); other interests are not purged. |
| Surplus | supported | Unpaid-seller resale accounting (2-706(6)). |
| Defective-sale consequence | supported | No sale-specific consequence beyond the good-faith and commercial-reasonableness rules stated. |
| Citation | supported | Full official sections retrieved and read: UCC 4-504, UCC 2-706. |
Letter-of-credit issuer’s or nominated person’s security interest in documents (lc_issuer)
| Field | Status | Rule |
|---|---|---|
| Statute | supported | UCC 5-118, UCC 9-109. |
| Who holds | supported | An issuer or nominated person that honours or gives value for a presentation (5-118(a)). |
| Priority vs. perfected security interest | supported | Enforceable without a security agreement and perfected; for a tangible document not held by the debtor, priority over a conflicting security interest (5-118(b)). |
| Cap | supported | Value given and not reimbursed (5-118(b)). |
| Court required | supported | No court order is required by the statute. |
| Notice to owner | supported | Article 9 notices apply (5-118(b)). |
| Notice to lienholders | supported | Article 9 notices apply (5-118(b)). |
| DMV notice | supported | No DMV step is prescribed by these sections. |
| Publication | supported | None prescribed. |
| Waiting period | supported | None prescribed. |
| Sale method | supported | Article 9 enforcement (5-118(b)). |
| Buyer’s title | supported | Article 9 disposition effects (9-617) apply (5-118(b)). |
| Surplus | supported | Article 9 surplus rules apply (5-118(b)). |
| Defective-sale consequence | supported | No sale-specific consequence beyond the good-faith and commercial-reasonableness rules stated. |
| Citation | supported | Full official sections retrieved and read: UCC 5-118, UCC 9-109. |
Securities intermediary’s and delivering dealer’s purchase-price security interest (securities_intermediary)
| Field | Status | Rule |
|---|---|---|
| Statute | supported | UCC 9-206. |
| Who holds | supported | A securities intermediary crediting a financial asset before payment, or a dealer delivering a certificated security against payment (9-206(a), (c)). |
| Priority vs. perfected security interest | supported | Automatically attaching security interests under Article 9 (9-206); rank under Article 9’s investment-property rules, no special rank stated. |
| Cap | supported | The purchase price or the payment due for delivery (9-206(b), (d)). |
| Court required | supported | No court order is required by the statute. |
| Notice to owner | supported | Article 9 notices apply. |
| Notice to lienholders | supported | Article 9 notices apply. |
| DMV notice | supported | No DMV step is prescribed by these sections. |
| Publication | supported | None prescribed. |
| Waiting period | supported | None prescribed. |
| Sale method | supported | Article 9 enforcement. |
| Buyer’s title | supported | Article 9 disposition effects (9-617) apply. |
| Surplus | supported | Article 9 surplus rules apply. |
| Defective-sale consequence | supported | No sale-specific consequence beyond the good-faith and commercial-reasonableness rules stated. |
| Citation | supported | Full official sections retrieved and read: UCC 9-206. |
12.4 Titles after a forced sale
Vehicles.
The actual title-only application is MV-82TON (5/25) †; it supplements, rather than replaces, each involuntary-transfer source document below.
| Path | Document the buyer gets / DMV filing | Citation |
|---|---|---|
| Court or execution sale | Sheriff’s or marshal’s sale “to satisfy a judgment” is a recognised title event, including for non-residents if the sale was held in NY. The transferee sends DMV “the last certificate of title, if available, proof of the transfer, and his application” | VTL § 2102(a)(3); § 2115(a) |
| Garage / tow lien sale | Full MV-901C package: prior-owner/lienholder verification; MV-901A plus proof of service; police-tow notices with RRR receipts; original newspaper clipping; affidavit of publication; MV-901B; VIN verification; proof of business and claim; statement of acquisition; MV-82TON or MV-82B title application; FS-6T sales-tax clearance or MV-50; USD 50 title fee. The buyer “must obtain a Certificate of Title in the purchaser’s own name before registering or reselling” | DMV MV-901C (rev. 2/26); VTL § 2102(a)(3) (“a sale to foreclose a garageman’s lien”) |
| Repossession | MV-950 (1/19) † affirmation and bill of sale, available title and title application. MV-909 (11/24), printed p. 8 † requires an original affirmation and explains releases for other liens; unreleased open liens are carried forward. Whether a particular other lien was substantively discharged requires UCC 9-617 analysis | VTL § 2115(b); UCC 9-617 |
| Abandoned vehicle | Local vesting under § 1224; authority need not title before resale (§ 2102(c)). MV-906A affidavit and authority bill of sale/MV-907A identified in § 12.2; actual MV-907A (1/25) front/back and instructions retrieved in CR-81 (5/26), printed pp. 33–35, 63–64 †. MV-906A is locally printed/numbered under the labeled § 18.5 copy, not a missing centralized downloadable blank. Current Part 18/threshold reconciliation and lien extinguishment still needs_verification. MV-37 (9/21) † is the separate restricted private-property scrap route | VTL § 1224; § 12.2 source limitations |
| Self-storage vehicle or boat | MV-905 (11/15) †, signed by operator/buyer, with proof of mailing, publication dates, VIN/HIN and disclosures. Title Services reviews the application/support before registration. Exact additional statewide packet and the statute/form publication interaction remain needs_verification | Lien Law 182; VTL 2115(a); MV-905 |
| Sub-USD 500 tow-lien vehicle to a dismantler | No retitling: MV-901D (11/15) † certification/bill of sale and MV-901DI (2/26) † instructions, including prior-owner/lien verification, notice, business/claim evidence, VIN tracing/photo and acquisition statement. MV-901DI’s wording allowing certified or first-class mail conflicts with § 201’s certified-RRR and first-class requirement; follow the statute, with administrative reconciliation needs_verification | Lien Law § 202(3); § 201 |
- Surviving liens and the title.
- A new title after an involuntary transfer “is not conclusive upon the rights of an owner or lienholder named in the old certificate” (VTL § 2115(c)).
- Where ownership or the absence of undisclosed security interests is unclear, the DMV may withhold title, or require a surety bond of 1.5 times value held for three years (VTL § 2105). DMV applies this to “NO HIT” garage-lien vehicles (MV-901C ¶ 1).
- Lienholders appear on the title “in the order of their apparent priority,” and the title is “prima facie evidence of the facts appearing on it” (VTL § 2108).
- A certificate of title itself cannot be levied on, “but this subsection does not prevent a lawful levy upon the vehicle” (§ 2108(d)).
- Security interests are perfected by delivery to the DMV (VTL § 2118).
- Voluntary resale after purchase. The transferee applies within 30 days, and the transfer is not valid against third parties until perfected (VTL § 2113).
- Salvage and junk.
- Insurers, dismantlers and others acquiring junk or salvage vehicles file a statement of acquisition, which serves as proof of ownership and as a title application if the vehicle is rebuilt.
- No one may sell or solicit bids on a junk or salvage vehicle “without notifying any prospective purchaser or bidder of the existence or non-existence of any security interest” (VTL § 429).
- DMV’s Salvage Vehicle Examination instructions †, retrieved 2026-10-17, state that a post-May 18, 1999 title for a rebuilt salvage vehicle bears REBUILT SALVAGE, and examination precedes title/registration. This is an anti-theft examination, not a safety/emissions inspection. The actual MV-83SAL (10/25) † specifies USD 205 for title/out-of-state title/marshal sale/police bill of sale/garage lien, USD 200 for MV-907A or owner-retained salvage, and the fee in DMV’s letter where applicable; support includes original ownership, bill of sale, tax proof, identity and applicable lien/release. A missed examination requires a new USD 150 fee. Neither a sheriff sale nor successful examination erases a nonretitling scrap restriction.
- Exclusions (VTL § 2102(a)).
- Untitled: pre-1973-model vehicles; trailers under 1,000 lb unladen; snowmobiles; off-highway and limited-use motorcycles; implements of husbandry; special mobile equipment.
- The DMV may also exclude vehicles more than nine model years old by regulation (§ 2102(e)). Whether such a regulation is in force — needs_verification.
Vessels.
- Titling agency: the DMV, under the same VTL article (§ 2108(a)(5) refers to “hull material if a vessel”).
- Threshold. Excluded from titling are vessels not required to be, and not, registered in NY; model-year 1986 or earlier; any vessel with a valid U.S. or foreign marine document; and any vessel under 14 feet (VTL § 2102(a)(13)–(16)). Registered, undocumented vessels of 14 feet or more and model-year 1987 or later are therefore titled.
- Involuntary transfer: VTL § 2115, with the MV-901C package for marina or garage liens (hull identification number verification ¶ 8). The actual MV-82B (8/24) † is the boat registration/title application; it includes liens, tax information and ownership proof. It is not itself a marina foreclosure bill of sale.
- Federal documentation interplay. Documented vessels are outside the state title. Liens and transfers run through the NVDC — uscg-national-vessel-documentation-center, vessels.
Aircraft.
- State registration or tax: the NYSDOT aviation FAQ † states that a privately owned airplane need not be registered with NY State. This does not exclude airport-specific based-aircraft registration or federal registration under GBL 243. The FAQ’s broad tax language is not used: current Tax Law 1115(a)(21)/(21-a) controls exemptions (§ 12.6). A558/S2300, 2025–2026 session †, remains in Assembly Transportation Committee (January 7, 2026 referral shown on retrieval), not enacted registration law. This closes that proposed-bill confusion, not every airport’s local requirement.
- County or state lien filing: Lien Law § 184 is possessory and has no filing requirement. Whether a NY UCC filing is sufficient or necessary for a particular aircraft/security collateral requires federal/state analysis, not an assumed DMV filing. FAA’s Record an Aircraft Claim of Lien (updated June 21, 2022) accepts nonconsensual claims only where state law provides for recording; its manual’s § 4.5.12 list does not include NY. Do not infer that a § 184 possessory lien is FAA-recordable merely because a consensual aircraft security agreement is.
- Actual federal transfer evidence: FAA Aircraft Registration and Recordation Processes, § 2.2.5(o) distinguishes a judicial-sale officer bill of sale, consensual repossession certification, judicial consensual foreclosure order, and nonconsensual lien sale. The latter must reflect applicable-law compliance; the examiner may demand advertisements, postings, affidavits or other evidence. The public manual warns uncontrolled copy; verify master revision, and its unprinted currency is not certified here. A state bill of sale is not automatic FAA registration or a priority adjudication — aircraft-title-liens-and-the-faa-registry.
Titled equipment and trailers.
- Trailers of 1,000 lb or more unladen are titled. Lighter trailers and pole trailers are not (VTL § 2102(a)(9)).
- “Special mobile equipment” and “implement[s] of husbandry” are excluded (§ 2102(a)(6)–(7)) and do not receive DMV title by that provision. Particular transfer-proof or other recording requirements remain needs_verification; exclusion from DMV title is not itself a complete conveyancing/document rule.
12.5 Businesses and business interests
Receivership.
- Enforcement receiver (CPLR 5228). On a judgment creditor’s motion, the court “may appoint a receiver who may be authorized to administer, collect, improve, lease, repair or sell any real or personal property in which the judgment debtor has an interest.” The order specifies duties. Commissions are capped at 5%. The oath, undertaking, accounts and removal rules of CPLR 6402–6405 apply.
- Temporary receiver pendente lite where property is in danger of being “removed from the state, or lost, materially injured or destroyed.” The court may authorize the receiver to “take and hold real and personal property, and sue for, collect and sell debts or claims” (CPLR 6401).
- Corporate permanent receiver. The receiver is vested with title to all corporate property and may “sell at public or private sale all the property vested in him, in such manner and on such terms and conditions as the court shall direct” (BCL § 1206). BCL § 1207(a)(1) ordinarily requires two weekly notices in two county newspapers (specified foreign-corporation exception) and at least six months from first publication for claims. For article 10/11 dissolution receiverships, § 1207 instead makes § 1007’s notice/claim rules controlling; the § 1207 procedure is not universal. Section 1007 also sets at least six months for its published claim notice, adds known-creditor mailing and exceptions to barring claims, including specified government tax claims. The controlling notice procedure, not just an assumed claims deadline, must therefore be identified for the receivership type.
- Uniform act adopted: no. The 2026-10-18 heading scan of every consolidated-law table of contents found no Uniform Commercial Real Estate Receivership Act; the Senate’s consolidated † and unconsolidated † and court-act † inventories, together with the complete chapter/article inventories for CPLR, BCL, RPAPL and RPL, contain no Uniform Commercial Real Estate Receivership Act enactment. This is an inventory-based status conclusion, not a holding of a case or a claim that New York has no specialized receiverships. The operative provisions above remain the native enforcement, temporary and corporate regimes. The current court fiduciary instructions † likewise direct receivers to CPLR article 64 and BCL article 12; uniform court rules are not a uniform receivership statute. Inventory PDFs establish article placement, not full section text.
- Sale free and clear: only on court-ordered terms (BCL § 1206(b)(2); CPLR 5228(a)). No statute gives a general power to sell free of non-consenting secured parties.
- Confirmation: the court directs the manner and terms of sale; no separate confirmation statute.
Assignment for the benefit of creditors (Debtor and Creditor Law art. 2).
- Statutory and court-supervised. The assignment must be in writing, acknowledged and recorded in the county clerk’s office (DCL § 3).
- Bond before sale. The assignee must post a bond within 30 days “and before he shall have any power or authority to sell” (§ 6).
- Court powers. The county or Supreme Court has “the powers of a court of equity” (§ 20). It may allow or disallow claims, authorise operation of the business, recover fraudulent transfers under § 15(6), recover qualifying preferences within four months under the distinct § 15(6-a), and allow secured creditors only the deficiency over their collateral (§ 15).
- Claims notice: at least 10 days (§ 5).
- Buyer title / survival: DCL 3/6 establish the assignment and authority to sell; they do not establish a general discharge of nonconsenting secured claims. Obtain the actual assignment, bond, sale order and releases. With no free-and-clear power stated, security interests continue (UCC 9-315(a)(1)) unless the court’s order binds their holders; this is separate from tax-successor exclusions below.
LLC charging order (LLC Law § 607).
- The court “may charge the membership interest … To the extent so charged, the judgment creditor has only the rights of an assignee.” Exemption laws still apply.
- “No creditor of a member shall have any right to obtain possession of, or otherwise exercise legal or equitable remedies with respect to, the property of the limited liability company.”
- Exclusivity and turnover: 79-madison-v-ebrahimzadeh-2022 † holds that § 607 is not exclusive: CPLR 5225/5240 can support direct turnover of a proven membership interest rather than a sheriff’s auction. Its debtor was the sole owner. National Auditing (2024), 226 AD3d 515 † applies New York enforcement law to turnover of a foreign-LLC interest. This is turnover authority, not an adjudication of a separate foreclosure procedure for an existing charging lien; § 607 itself provides no foreclosure sale.
- Single-/multi-member and buyer rights: a § 607 charge carries assignee economic rights under LLC 603; admission generally follows the operating agreement or § 604. A direct turnover is a different remedy. TBG Funding (Feb. 12, 2026) † allowed turnover of interests in both wholly debtor-owned and multi-member LLCs on its record; Finance Holding v Farzam (Apr. 7, 2026) † selected a charging order where a nondebtor equal member objected. These trial decisions establish neither mandatory turnover nor automatic management rights for every auction purchaser. The LLC’s own assets remain distinct under § 607(b).
Partnership charging order (Partnership Law § 54).
- The court may charge the partner’s interest and appoint a receiver of the partner’s share of profits.
- The interest “may be redeemed at any time before foreclosure, or in case of a sale being directed by the court may be purchased without thereby causing a dissolution.” The statute thus contemplates foreclosure / court-directed sale of the charged interest.
- Buyer rights: PTR 53 ordinarily conveys the assigning partner’s profit entitlement, not management, information or inspection rights absent agreement; on dissolution it supplies the assignor’s interest/accounting right. Purchasing the economic interest is not purchasing the partnership’s particular assets.
Stock levy.
- UCC 8-112 adopted (UCC 8-112).
- Certificated shares: reached “only by actual seizure of the security certificate” (or by process on the issuer if surrendered).
- Uncertificated shares: process on the issuer at its chief executive office.
- Security entitlements: process on the intermediary.
- Lien sale of securities. A lien sale of a security requires the § 202(1) public auction and a prescribed description (Lien Law § 202(1)).
- Buyer rights: UCC 8-302 generally transfers the rights the transferor had or could transfer, with its limited-interest/adverse-claim exceptions. Execution additionally remains debtor-interest-only under CPLR 5233/5234; a generic stock levy is not a promise of free-and-clear acquisition of the issuer’s own assets.
Bulk sale / tax clearance.
- UCC Article 6: repealed effective July 1, 2001, as expressly recognized in
Parent v Amity Autoworld, 15 Misc 3d 633, 637 (2007) †.
The current official UCC index † also omits Article 6.
The retrieved
UCC6-101PDF is a whole-law/index fallback, not text of an operative § 6-101. A repeal chapter citation alone is not treated as a retrieved session law. - Sales-tax bulk-sale notice (Tax Law § 1141(c)).
- Who and when: whenever a person required to collect sales tax sells “in bulk … any part or the whole of his business assets, otherwise than in the ordinary course of business,” the purchaser must notify the Department by registered mail at least 10 days before taking possession or paying. This applies whether or not taxes are owed.
- Escrow lien: if the purchaser does not notify, or the Department signals a possible claim, the price becomes subject to a first priority right and lien. The Department has 90 days to state its claim; silence releases the purchaser.
- Personal liability: a non-complying purchaser is personally liable for the seller’s sales taxes, up to the greater of the purchase price or fair market value of the assets.
- Distress-sale exclusions: DTF memorandum TSB-M-83(6)S (Apr. 7, 1983) describes exclusions for realization/settlement of a valid lien, mortgage or security interest, and transfers by executors, administrators, receivers, bankruptcy trustees or public officers under judicial process. north-shore-cadillac-v-tax-appeals-tribunal-2004 † applies 20 NYCRR 537.1(a)(4)(i) but rejects the exclusion where the owner sold directly after the lender postponed its auction; paying a secured lender from proceeds did not turn that sale into enforcement. An ABC assignee is not expressly named in that list. The assignment to the assignee and a later sale by the assignee are separate transactions; the word “assignee” in § 1141(c) does not itself grant an exemption. No blanket ABC exclusion is established by the retrieved text; a claim that a particular assignee qualifies as a receiver/public officer or realizes a valid security interest requires its actual authority/transaction. That particular treatment remains needs_verification. The full 20 NYCRR 537.1 was retrieved from Cornell’s unofficial regulatory copy, including the two exclusion clauses in (a)(4). Official current consolidated Part 537/amendment reconciliation remains needs_verification after the official public endpoint returned 403; the historical guidance, opinion and labeled copy are not an unqualified 2026 regulation certification. The current DTF rulemaking portal links that unofficial, not certified, online compilation. Its 2023, 2024, 2025 and 2026 action inventories contain no Part 537 amendment, but the 2026 page was last updated August 12; that is not a through-October supplement.
- Actual form: AU-196.10 (5/26), Notification of Sale, Transfer, or Assignment in Bulk. DTF’s Bulk Sales bulletin specifies receipt at least 10 days before payment or possession, whichever first, and permits registered mail, certified mail RRR or hand delivery. The agency’s current posting retains a June 24, 2013 issue date. Stock acquisition alone while both entities continue separately is distinguished from a business-asset transfer in that bulletin.
- Mailing versus receipt; release clock. The full, labeled unofficial § 537.2(b)–(c) distinguishes timely registered or certified-RRR mailing with a postal-employee-postmarked sender’s receipt from defective/other mailing requiring actual receipt. Thus the bulletin’s receipt instruction must not be substituted for the regulation’s qualified mailing rule. Its (c)(6) and § 537.4(a)(2) defer deemed receipt for an early notice to ten days before the later scheduled/actual sale and address revised notices. Do not calculate the statutory 90-day release from early physical delivery alone. These detailed regulatory rules retain the stated official-currentness limitation.
Licences.
- Liquor. A licence “shall not be transferable to any other person or to any other premises …
except in the discretion of the authority” (ABC Law § 111).
“No license shall be transferable or assignable” except a sole proprietor’s conversion to a wholly
owned corporation (ABC Law § 114(2)).
- A forced-sale bill of sale alone does not transfer the licence. The buyer needs SLA approval
under the applicable new-licence/change procedure; § 111 expressly reserves authority discretion.
The SLA online-permits instructions †, retrieved
2026-10-17, identify a Sheriff Marshall, Receiver, Executor, Assignee Permit, USD 36,
authorizing one transaction in beverages obtained pursuant to judicial process. This is not
a transfer of the operating licence. Its linked Business Express information is public;
submitting that online application requires NY.gov login, which was not attempted. Public
operating-licence/change packets are nevertheless available; login is not a research prerequisite:
- Court-appointed receiver/ABC representative: Endorsement Certificate, form 37, rev. 03/02/26 †, four pages. Complete A/E plus B/C/D for court appointments. Supply court authorization, applicant statement, personal questionnaire, photo ID/color photo, subsequent fingerprinting and, if the certificate changes, a bond rider. Receiver/assignee selections cost USD 13 per checked box for grocery/drug stores or USD 64 for other licences. Public Applicant Statement † and Personal Questionnaire † are also retrieved. An endorsement is not an automatic licence transfer to the eventual asset buyer.
- Change within the licensed corporation/LLC: the Corporate Change application †, six pages (instruction cover 10/31/25; application pages 03/02/26), charges USD 128 and requires ownership/office-change documents, new-principal disclosures and financing proof. Change is conditional on prior approval; SLA’s change instructions † specify applicable exceptions and NYC substantial-change community-board notice. This is not the asset buyer’s new-entity licence route.
- Buyer operating pending a retail licence: temporary retail form ST-35, rev. 02/26/26 †, three pages, has an existing-business-purchase selection requiring a sale/conveyance contract and licensed operation within 30 days before filing. A complete retail-licence application must precede or accompany it; the old licence must be surrendered, placed in safekeeping or deemed abandoned. The discretionary initial permit lasts 180 days, costs USD 128 for the specified beer/grocery/drug categories or USD 640 per bar otherwise, and does not guarantee the permanent licence. Its inventory-transfer instructions separately require a liquidator’s permit/fee or a no-stock-transfer statement. SLA’s new-licence instructions † identify licence-specific Business Express forms. No application or fingerprint appointment was submitted. The incorporation exception is not a general forced-sale rule.
- Where a licence was revoked, the authority may refuse a new licence for the premises for two years. Non-arm’s-length sales are presumed suspect (ABC Law § 113).
- The State Liquor Authority must be made a party to proceedings affecting licences (ABC Law § 124).
- A forced-sale bill of sale alone does not transfer the licence. The buyer needs SLA approval
under the applicable new-licence/change procedure; § 111 expressly reserves authority discretion.
The SLA online-permits instructions †, retrieved
2026-10-17, identify a Sheriff Marshall, Receiver, Executor, Assignee Permit, USD 36,
authorizing one transaction in beverages obtained pursuant to judicial process. This is not
a transfer of the operating licence. Its linked Business Express information is public;
submitting that online application requires NY.gov login, which was not attempted. Public
operating-licence/change packets are nevertheless available; login is not a research prerequisite:
- Other notable — bounded examples, not every regulated industry:
- DMV repair-shop registration is required when VTL art. 12-A applies. An unregistered shop has no § 184 lien when registration is required (Lien Law § 184(4)). VTL 398-c(3)–(4) specifies applications, partnership/name changes and fiduciary/corporate/location amendments. Actual MV-253G (4/25) † expressly requires an original application when acquiring a business, not that amendment form. VS-1R (2/26) † is the repair-only original application, USD 160, with VS-145 (8/24) † entity/identity, sales-tax, employment-insurance, zoning and premises requirements; DMV’s public opening instructions † explain review and registration. The CR-82 (5/26) agency reproduction †, § 82.12, distinguishes unchanged ownership from a change requiring new-shop compliance. MV-253G says amendments/duplicates are free, although § 82.12’s reproduced text still says USD 5 for specified amendments; that fee-text discrepancy is disclosed, not silently harmonized. This is an identified acquisition/approval procedure, not automatic transfer.
- NYC tow-company example: the DCWP ownership-change instructions †, retrieved 2026-10-17, require prior written approval before acquiring 10% or more or the specified partnership changes; the licence becomes void without required prior approval. Submit the request at least 30 days before the change. The actual 11-page owner/partner request (4/9/2026) † contains ownership/background disclosures, towing-specific employment questions and applicable fingerprint requirements. For a new licence, the public tow-company checklist † lists business/tax, vehicle registration, premises, insurance and bond documents. These are public approval instructions, not a submitted application or statewide towing-licence rule. NYC towing/storage business proof at lien sales remains separately required by MV-901C ¶ 7.
12.6 Taxes when buying
| Asset | Rule (citation) |
|---|---|
| Vehicles — rate and base | 4% state on taxable retail receipts (§§ 1101(b)(3), 1105(a)), plus applicable local/MCTD taxes. The current DTF general-rate table, Publication 718 (2/25), effective March 1, 2025, linked by its current-period index, gives NYC 8.875%, Erie 8.75%, Albany 8%. Identify the transaction’s proper taxing locality; this is not a single statewide combined rate |
| Vehicles — who collects | Tax Law § 1132(f)–(g) requires tax-paid/no-tax-due proof before new registration (same-owner renewals excepted), and makes DMV/county clerks collection agents for tax due on nondealer sales and compensating use at the specified registration/title functions. The NYC officer’s vehicle-auction instructions † contemplate tax at auction, with resale-certificate relief. Preserve proof rather than assume a second tax payment at registration. Lien-sale buyers file FS-6T or MV-50 with the title application (MV-901C) |
| Vehicles — casual-sale exemption | None for vehicles or boats. The residential-sale exemption (receipts under USD 600 a year) “shall also not apply to (A) sales at a private residence conducted by an auctioneer, sheriff or other third party, (B) a sale held to liquidate an estate or (C) the sale of boats, snowmobiles or motor vehicles” (Tax Law § 1115(a)(18)) |
| Vehicles — forced-sale rule | No statutory exemption for sheriff, lien or repossession sales was located. Execution proceeds bear “any taxes levied upon sale” before distribution (CPLR 5234(a)) |
| Vessels | Applicable combined retail rate, but receipts over USD 230,000 for a vessel, including an outboard motor/trailer sold with it, are exempt (§ 1115(jj)). Separate exemptions cover commercial vessels primarily in interstate/foreign commerce (§ 1115(a)(8)) and qualifying commercial fishing vessels (§ 1115(a)(24)); not every working boat qualifies |
| Aircraft | § 1115(a)(21-a) exempts defined general-aviation aircraft and installed machinery/equipment; its definition excludes commercial/military aircraft and drones. Section 1115(a)(21) separately covers commercial aircraft primarily in intrastate/interstate/foreign commerce and specified equipment/maintenance property. Do not import the DOT FAQ’s categorical statement about commercial-aircraft tax |
| Equipment / business assets | Taxable retail tangible-property receipts: 4% plus applicable local tax (§§ 1101(b)(4), 1105(a)), subject to asset/use exemptions rather than a general forced-sale exemption. The USD 600 residential occasional-sale rule excludes sheriff/auctioneer sales (§ 1115(a)(18)). DTF’s Sales From Your Home bulletin, estate-sales/auctions section, expressly assigns collection to auctioneer/sheriff/third party. DTF TSB-A-24(48)S (Oct. 16, 2024) includes a buyer’s premium in taxable receipts on its stated facts. Tax Law § 1101(a) includes receivers, trustees, assignees and other fiduciaries in “person”; § 1131(1) includes vendors among persons required to collect. A fiduciary making taxable sales as a vendor therefore has collection obligations, not a status-based exemption. This does not by itself impose personal liability for every preappointment debt or resolve the distinct bulk-sale exclusions. Bulk-sale successor liability is a separate issue (§ 12.5) |
| Transfer fees | Current title application USD 50 (manufactured/mobile home USD 125); § 2125 prints a scheduled April 1, 2028 change to USD 5 / USD 25. Lien notation USD 5; duplicate USD 20. DMV may impose, rather than automatically charges, a fee-equivalent late penalty after ten days (§ 2125(b)). Registration varies by class/weight under VTL 401; DMV’s fee table † separates two-year weight-based registration, title, plate and county/MCTD charges. No flat forced-sale registration fee is established |
12.7 Where these sales are published
Official postings observed (checked 18 Oct 2026)
-
New York City Department of Finance — Auctions: Sheriff and City Marshal vehicle execution-sale PDFs by borough and sale date, with year, make, VIN and lienholder columns.
-
Suffolk County Police Department, Impound Section — Upcoming Auctions: abandoned/impounded vehicle auction lists; the 21 November 2026 list contained 99 lots and 96 VINs.
-
Legal-notice statute. Where law requires newspaper publication, a “newspaper” must be of general circulation, printed and distributed at least weekly for one year, with paid circulation and periodicals-mail entry, subject to § 60(a)‘s express grandfather exceptions for qualifying older publications. Free advertising papers do not qualify (General Construction Law § 60).
-
Execution sales. Posting in three public places at least 6 days before the sale. In NYC, the auction columns of a qualifying daily (CPLR 5233(b)).
-
Lien sales.
- Art. 9 liens: two weekly insertions in a newspaper “published in the town or city where such sale is to be held,” or six postings (Lien Law § 202(1)).
- Warehouse: newspaper “of general circulation where the sale is to be held” (UCC 7-210(b)(5)).
- Art. 4 vessel warrants: newspaper in the county of seizure (Lien Law § 90).
-
Wrecks: four successive weeks in county newspapers (Nav. Law § 139).
-
Corporate receivers: two newspapers, two weeks (BCL § 1207(a)(1)).
-
Statewide site: none established by statute (module identity), so there are no statutory reuse terms. No reuse or automated-collection permission is inferred for local newspapers or officer pages.
-
Officer portals.
- NYC DOF Auctions †, full substantive page
retrieved 2026-10-17, lists sheriff/marshal vehicle notices for October 16–30, 2026; this is the
current vehicle portal. Its separate property-auction link is dated 2021 and is not certified as
a current personalty calendar. The older
services-auctions.pagerenders January 2024 dates: successful retrieval alone does not make that calendar current. Vehicle terms are full immediate cash, Certificate of Sale, removal by 5 p.m. or USD 20/day storage, deemed abandoned if not removed within 96 hours after that deadline, and recorded liens can survive. The FAQ exempts the buyer from the former registrant’s parking tickets; it does not discharge title liens. - Erie County Sheriff Civil Enforcement, changed September 8, 2026, links its scheduled sheriff-sale portal and describes personalty auctions at the property location, documents and payment terms (§ 12.1). Its statutory sale postings remain local. This verifies one upstate officer’s practice, not all 57 non-NYC counties.
- Onondaga field operations describes execution levies; it is an operational contact source, not proof of a current personalty auction calendar. County-specific terms outside the retrieved NYC/Erie examples remain needs_verification.
- NYC DOF Auctions †, full substantive page
retrieved 2026-10-17, lists sheriff/marshal vehicle notices for October 16–30, 2026; this is the
current vehicle portal. Its separate property-auction link is dated 2021 and is not certified as
a current personalty calendar. The older
-
DMV / agency postings. No statute requires DMV to post lien or execution sales (heading scan); MV-901C † describes title evidence and newspaper advertising, not a posting service. DTF Seizures is a procedure page, not an evidenced complete inventory of upcoming seized-business auctions.
-
Collectability.
- Execution and lien-sale notices are hyper-local: physical postings, or one local newspaper per town.
- GCL § 60 supplies general newspaper qualifications; each sale statute adds its own geographic and timing requirements. A portal listing does not replace them.
- Verified discovery is fragmented among officer vehicle pages, local postings and newspapers. Repository completeness, notice reuse licences and automated-collection permission remain needs_verification; no scraping permission is inferred from public visibility.
12.8 Buyer checklist (New York)
- Garage / tow / marina / hangar lien sale: check any release of possession after 30 days from accrual, not just a release lasting 30 days; § 184(1) voids the lien against pre-accrual security interests even after possession is reacquired.
- Police tows: obtain copies of the 5-working-day owner notice and the 20-day certified-mail RRR notice to secured parties. A late compliant notice starts storage accrual at mailing; a substantively defective notice is a different problem (Lien Law § 184(2), (5); palisades-funding-v-joes-garage-2023; nissan-motor-acceptance-v-all-county-towing-2018).
- Check that the § 201 notice (MV-901A) itemizes the debt and the authority to tow or store, and is verified before service. A post-dated verification voided a sale in ally-financial-v-bills-towing-2020.
- Confirm the 10-day § 201-a window ran from proper service. Defective service means the window never started (palisades-funding-v-joes-garage-2023).
- Check the sale was held in the town where the lien arose, after two weekly publications, 15+ days after the first (Lien Law § 202(1)). Collect the original clipping and affidavit of publication (MV-901C ¶¶ 4–5).
- Obtain the full MV-901C support package: MV-901B, title abstract, VIN/HIN verification, proof of business (MV-61P for repairs), statement of acquisition. Do not assume every title-support document is delivered automatically at the auction; verify its availability before bidding.
- Under-USD 500 tow vehicles sold to dismantlers can never be titled (Lien Law § 202(3)).
- Sheriff / marshal execution sale: you take only the debtor’s interest. Run a DMV lien check and a UCC search, because perfected security interests survive (CPLR 5233(a), 5234(b); VTL § 2118(a)).
- A DMV title after an involuntary transfer is not conclusive against prior owners or lienholders (VTL § 2115(c)). For “NO HIT” vehicles, DMV may require a 1.5-times-value bond under VTL § 2105; it is not automatically required in every such file.
- Self-storage contents: the operator’s lien is superior to all security interests (Lien Law § 182(6)), but titled vehicles in units still need title paperwork.
- Budget sales tax and tax-clearance evidence before registration; an officer may collect at auction, while DMV/county clerks collect applicable unpaid tax under § 1132(g). There is no casual-sale break for vehicles or boats, and sheriff and auctioneer sales are excluded from the USD 600 exemption (Tax Law §§ 1115(a)(18), 1132(f)). Boats are exempt above USD 230,000 (§ 1115(jj)); general aviation aircraft are exempt (§ 1115(a)(21-a)).
- Buying business assets: distinguish a real lien/receiver/judicial sale from an owner sale merely paying a lender. Where bulk-sale notice applies, file AU-196.10 at least ten days before payment or possession, whichever first; preserve escrow/release evidence (Tax Law § 1141(c); North Shore Cadillac; § 12.5). ABC treatment and current consolidated-rule review remain open.
- Liquor licence: a bill of sale supplies no automatic transfer; secure SLA authorization and determine the appropriate application, including premises-revocation restrictions (ABC 111, 113, 114(2)).
- LLC interests: distinguish an economic charge from court-ordered turnover and member admission; inspect the actual order and operating agreement (LLC 603/604/607; 79 Madison). A member’s creditor does not thereby own the LLC’s specific property.
- Self-storage vehicle/boat: obtain MV-905 and all title-support evidence; reconcile its publication certifications with § 182’s 30-day payment notice, and issue fresh sale-date notice if rescheduled (Magomedov; § 12.3.5).
- Municipal abandoned vehicle: distinguish § 1224, the authority acquisition affidavit and title-law packet from a private § 184 lien. MV-37 scrap and § 202(3) scrap are separate, nonretitling paths (§§ 12.2, 12.4).
12.9 Case law
| Case | Holding (forced-sale relevance) |
|---|---|
| palisades-funding-v-joes-garage-2023 — App. Div. 3d Dept. 2023 | Failure to prove compliant police-tow storage notice supported lien invalidity and conversion liability despite retitling; damages were left for discovery. Improper sale-notice service did not start § 201-a time. This is not a holding that every late notice voids all towing/storage charges |
| ally-financial-v-bills-towing-2020 — App. Div. 3d Dept. 2020 | A § 201 notice that omits the basis of the lien and is verified after service is defective. The lien-sale auction (bought in by the tower) was invalidated, with the lien left to be paid |
| nissan-motor-acceptance-v-all-county-towing-2018 — 161 AD3d 1423 (3d Dept 2018) | A § 184(5) notice that never says the tower “claims a lien” invalidates the storage lien. The towing charge survives |
| magomedov-v-self-storage-management-2023 † — 221 AD3d 682 | A valid § 182 lien did not excuse sale on a rescheduled date without new notice. Statutory/conversion liability established; damages remitted |
| slattery-v-strongs-marine-2024 † — 230 AD3d 611 | Marina sale without diligent personal-service attempt before mailing supported conversion liability; mailing bills was no substitute |
| mercedes-benz-financial-v-clutch-towing-2024 † — 84 Misc 3d 643 | Owner-requested tow distinguished from § 184(2)/(5) police-tow notice; trial court reduced charges for unreasonable delay rather than importing police-tow rules |
| 79-madison-v-ebrahimzadeh-2022 † — 203 AD3d 589 | Section 607 is nonexclusive; direct turnover of a proven LLC interest authorized under CPLR 5225/5240. No universal auction-buyer management-right rule |
| north-shore-cadillac-v-tax-appeals-tribunal-2004 † — 13 AD3d 994 | A distressed owner’s direct asset sale did not qualify as realization of a valid lien merely because proceeds paid the lender |
| shimamoto-v-s-and-f-warehouses-2002 † — 99 NY2d 165 | No willful-conversion recovery on that record; statutory commercial-reasonableness damages required causal proof, and no prior return demand was necessary for that claim. Former § 7-211 notice discussion must not be transplanted into revised Article 7 without reconciliation |
| huntington-national-bank-v-jonathan-auto-2008 † — 2008 NY Slip Op 31644(U) | Trial court invalidated a garage sale conducted despite a stay, cancelled an unproved owner-consent lien and ordered the buyer to return the car; purported bona-fide-purchaser protection was not established. Not a universal innocent-buyer holding |
| baskin-v-mabco-transit-2019 — 176 AD3d 1539 | Substantial statutory notice compliance on the occupant’s forwarding-address/default record; purchaser claim dismissed. Federal state-action and broader NY constitutional notice analyses remain distinct. Former ten-day statutory timing is not current thirty-day law |
| flagg-bros-v-brooks-1978 — 436 U.S. 149 (1978) | The proposed private warehouse sale on that record was not attributable to the State. No public official participated in the proposed sale; the decision does not decide every police-assisted/private sale, statutory validity or purchaser title |
Case-retention limit (2026-10-18). Full official opinions are retained for Palisades, Bill’s Towing and Nissan (Third Department slip opinions preserved from 10/17 and hash-checked), Baskin (Third Department, retrieved 2026-10-18) and Flagg (LII). The other entries marked † were read on 10/17 from hosts that now refuse automated requests; their bodies were not kept, so they are cited for context only and support no field marked supported. Later treatment is separate: the Palisades reargument/leave motion was denied February 22, 2024; Nissan is cited in Palisades and in Cabrera (2026); 79 Madison is applied in National Auditing (2024) and discussed in the differing 2026 trial rulings above. Full public citator/appeal-history and comprehensive subsequent-treatment confirmation remain needs_verification. No unqualified good-law badge follows from these searches. Historical trial decisions on LLC remedies must be read against the later appellate turnover decisions, not used to restore charging-order exclusivity.
▸ For Buyers / Operators — What survives each channel: an execution or tax-warrant sale conveys only the debtor’s interest, with secured parties untouched (§ 12.1). Lien-sale validity turns on strict notice compliance (§ 12.3.1–12.3.3 and the § 12.9 cases). Title paperwork is in § 12.4 (MV-901C; VTL §§ 2105, 2115(c)). Bulk-sale tax exposure is in § 12.5 (Tax Law § 1141(c)), and tax at registration in § 12.6.
▸ For Owners / Debtors — Exemption amounts and DFS indexing are in § 12.1 (CPLR 5205). There is a 10-day special proceeding to contest a lien (Lien Law §§ 182(7), 201-a), and redemption before sale (§ 203). Surplus rules: Lien Law § 204 (30 days, then the local treasurer, 5 years); VTL § 1224(6)(b) (one-year hold); CPLR 5234(a) (excess paid to the debtor). The tax-warrant window is 21 days / 10 business days (Tax Law § 692(c)).
Local pages
County deep dives: albany-ny, bronx-ny, dutchess-ny, erie-ny, kings-ny, monroe-ny, nassau-ny, new-york-ny, niagara-ny, oneida-ny, onondaga-ny, orange-ny, queens-ny, richmond-ny, rockland-ny, saratoga-ny, suffolk-ny, westchester-ny Other counties (forced sales of personal property only, module C11): allegany-ny, broome-ny, cattaraugus-ny, cayuga-ny, chautauqua-ny, chemung-ny, chenango-ny, clinton-ny, columbia-ny, cortland-ny, delaware-ny, essex-ny, franklin-ny, fulton-ny, genesee-ny, greene-ny, hamilton-ny, herkimer-ny, jefferson-ny, lewis-ny, livingston-ny, madison-ny, montgomery-ny, ontario-ny, orleans-ny, oswego-ny, otsego-ny, putnam-ny, rensselaer-ny, schenectady-ny, schoharie-ny, schuyler-ny, seneca-ny, st-lawrence-ny, steuben-ny, sullivan-ny, tioga-ny, tompkins-ny, ulster-ny, warren-ny, washington-ny, wayne-ny, wyoming-ny, yates-ny Unclaimed funds agency: unclaimed-property-new-york Buyer guides: new-york-vehicles, new-york-boats, new-york-aircraft, new-york-equipment, new-york-businesses
Legal information, not legal advice. This page summarizes statutes and cases as of the last_verified date and may be incomplete or out of date; New York’s surplus regime in particular is new (2024) and actively litigated. Verify against the cited primary sources and consult a licensed New York attorney before acting.