Massachusetts — Tax & Mortgage Foreclosure

Legal information, not legal advice. Verify against the cited primary sources before acting. Last verified: 2026-06-01.

Massachusetts is structurally unusual: it does not run a true public tax-lien auction in most municipalities. Instead the municipality makes a “tax taking” (or, less commonly, a sale) under G.L. c. 60, which creates a tax title held by the city/town; the right of redemption is then foreclosed by a judicial petition in the Land Court (G.L. c. 60 §§ 65–75). A municipality may also assign its tax receivables to a private buyer (e.g., “Tallage”), who then forecloses in the Land Court in its own name. Until St. 2024, c. 140 (effective largely Nov. 1, 2024), the foreclosing holder kept the entire property regardless of surplus equity — the exact “home-equity theft” condemned in tyler-v-hennepin-county. Massachusetts has now reformed that scheme (excess-equity return + interest rate cut from 16% to 8%).

0. Identity & Classification

  • Recording unit: county (Registries of Deeds; some counties have multiple registry districts). The selling/foreclosing layer is municipal (each city or town’s treasurer/collector). Massachusetts has 14 counties / 21 registry districts and 351 cities and towns.
  • Tax sale type: redeemable tax title via municipal “taking” (a hybrid; the municipality takes title subject to a right of redemption, then forecloses judicially). True public tax-lien-certificate auctions are not the norm. — G.L. c. 60 §§ 53, 54, 61.
  • Tax foreclosure process: judicial — exclusive jurisdiction in the Land Court, G.L. c. 60 §§ 64, 65.
  • Mortgage foreclosure process: both, but predominantly non-judicial power of sale under G.L. c. 244 § 14.
  • Selling/foreclosing authority: municipal treasurer/collector (or a private assignee of the tax title); the foreclosure court is the Land Court.
  • Statutory home: Tax — Title IX, Chapter 60 (Collection of Local Taxes). Mortgage — Chapter 244 (Foreclosure and Redemption of Mortgages).
  • Tyler v. Hennepin compliance: reformed_post_Tyler — St. 2024, c. 140 added G.L. c. 60 § 64A requiring the former owner to receive excess equity after a foreclosure, and created a retroactive superior-court claim for judgments entered on/after May 25, 2021. (Mass. House press release; Nat’l Law Review summary)

1. Tax Sale Mechanics

  • What is sold / created: the collector “takes” the parcel for unpaid taxes and records an instrument of taking at the registry (G.L. c. 60 § 53), creating a tax title in the municipality. (A collector’s sale under §§ 43–45 is an alternative but is rarely used today.) The municipality may later assign the tax title/receivable to a private buyer under G.L. c. 60 § 2C/52.
  • Bidding method: not a competitive lien auction in the typical case; the taking is administrative. Where a municipality assigns receivables in bulk, pricing is by negotiated/bulk sale, not a redemption-period bid-down. — see Tallage Lincoln, LLC v. Williams, 485 Mass. 449 (2020) (assignment of tax title).
  • Interest / penalty: 8% per annum on the tax-title account, running from the date of the taking/sale, per G.L. c. 60 § 62 (rate reduced from 16% to 8% by St. 2024, c. 140). Pre-taking delinquent taxes accrue interest at 14% under G.L. c. 59 § 57 until the taking. (§ 62)
  • Minimum bid composition (redemption/payoff): unpaid tax + interest + lawful charges added to the tax-title account (subsequent-year taxes are certified to the account under G.L. c. 60 § 61).
  • Sale frequency / typical month: takings occur on the municipality’s own schedule after the demand and 14-day notice of taking are satisfied; no fixed statewide auction calendar.
  • Venue / platforms: administrative taking recorded at the registry; bulk assignments are private transactions. No standard statewide online auction platform. — needs_verification for current municipal vendors.
  • Subsequent taxes (“subs”): the municipality (or assignee) certifies later unpaid taxes to the existing tax-title account under G.L. c. 60 § 61. Per Tallage Lincoln, an assignee may not add its own post-assignment tax payments to the redemption amount in the manner the statute reserves to the municipality. (485 Mass. 449)

2. Right of Redemption → see right-of-redemption

  • Pre-foreclosure right (broad): any person with an interest in the land (or heirs/assigns) may redeem at any time before a petition to foreclose is filed by paying the tax-title account + 8% interest + lawful charges — G.L. c. 60 § 62. (§ 62)
  • Post-petition redemption: even after the foreclosure petition is filed, the owner may redeem on terms set by the Land Court until judgment of foreclosure enters — G.L. c. 60 § 76 (Land Court jurisdiction; petition for redemption). (cited in Land Court FAQ)
  • Who may redeem: the owner, mortgagee, lienholder, heir, or assign — any “person having an interest in” the land. — G.L. c. 60 § 62.
  • Amount formula: tax-title account balance (taxes + certified subs) + 8% interest from date of taking + lawful charges (and, if redeeming from a private purchaser/assignee, that party’s costs and recording/examination fees as capped by statute). — G.L. c. 60 § 62.
  • Premium to certificate holder: N/A — Massachusetts does not pay a bid-down premium to a certificate holder; the holder’s return is the 8% statutory interest on the account.
  • Procedure / extinguishment: redemption is made to the treasurer, who issues a certificate of redemption; recording it at the registry ends the municipality’s interest. The right of redemption is extinguished only by the Land Court’s judgment of foreclosure — G.L. c. 60 §§ 64, 69; thereafter title is absolute (subject to the post-judgment vacatur window). (§ 64 via Justia)
  • Special tolling: post-judgment, a petition/motion to vacate the foreclosure may be filed within one year for “extraordinary circumstances” (Land Court FAQ); the one-year bar may be excused where due-process notice was defective — Town of Andover v. State Financial Services, Inc., 48 Mass. App. Ct. 536 (2000). Standard SCRA / minority / incapacity tolling — needs_verification for the precise c. 60 cross-reference.

3. Surplus / Excess Proceeds → see surplus-funds, third-party-recovery-rules

  • Belongs to: the former owner (post-reform). Before St. 2024, c. 140, the foreclosing municipality/assignee kept the entire property/equity — the practice struck down in tyler-v-hennepin-county and, as applied, in Mills v. City of Springfield (Hampden Sup. Ct. 2024). (Boston Globe coverage)
  • Mechanism (G.L. c. 60 § 64A, eff. ~Nov. 1, 2024): after a final Land Court judgment of foreclosure, the municipality must elect either to (a) retain the property for municipal use, or (b) list it for sale; in either case the excess equity must be accounted for and returned to the former owner on written request. “Excess equity” = surplus above the tax-title account balance as of the judgment date plus the reasonable costs of selling/appraising the property under § 64A. (D’Ambrosio LLP summary quoting § 64A; Nat’l Law Review)
  • Claim waterfall: tax-title account (taxes + interest + charges) → reasonable sale/appraisal/holding costs → former owner (subject to other recorded liens per the title report). — G.L. c. 60 § 64A.
  • Filing venue: written request to the municipality (or to the purchaser of tax receivables) under § 64A; disputes are resolved in court. Retroactive claims (judgments entered on/after May 25, 2021 but before the Act) are filed by complaint in the Superior Court. (Nat’l Law Review)
  • Claim deadline: retroactive Superior Court claims must be filed within 12 months of the Act’s effective date (commentators note ambiguity whether that is July 1, 2025 or Nov. 1, 2025). The prospective § 64A claim deadline (post-judgment window) — needs_verification for exact statutory text. (Nat’l Law Review)
  • Escheat: disposition of unclaimed excess equity (whether it routes to the state Treasurer’s unclaimed-property under G.L. c. 200A) — needs_verification; the § 64A text retrieved does not pin the escheat destination.
  • Documentation required: written request identifying the former owner and property; proof of identity/interest; title evidence of any senior liens — per § 64A process. — needs_verification for the standardized form.
  • Third-party recovery (recovery agents):
    • No tax-surplus-specific recovery-agent statute governs c. 60 § 64A excess- equity claims as of this verification. The closest analog is the unclaimed- property “finder” rule, G.L. c. 200A § 13, which (for property reported to the state Treasurer) makes finder agreements unenforceable if signed within 24 months of the property’s delivery to the Division; agreements after 24 months are valid only if in writing, signed by the owner, disclosing the nature and value of the property and the holder’s name/address, with the fee capped at 10%, and an owner may always challenge “excessive or unjust” compensation. Implementing reg: 960 CMR 4.06. (c. 200A § 13 / 960 CMR 4.06, summarized)
    • fee_cap_pct: 10% for c. 200A unclaimed-property finders; no statutory cap confirmed for direct c. 60 § 64A excess-equity claims against a municipality. needs_verification whether c. 200A § 13 reaches § 64A funds.
    • licensing_required: no general license; debt-collection-style conduct is constrained by G.L. c. 93 § 49 and Ch. 93A consumer-protection law.
    • assignment_of_claim_allowed: needs_verification.
    • cooling_off_period: the c. 200A 24-month unenforceability window functions as one for unclaimed-property finders. — G.L. c. 200A § 13.
    • prohibited_practices: unfair/deceptive collection conduct under G.L. c. 93 § 49; unfair/deceptive acts under G.L. c. 93A. (c. 93 § 49)
  • Notice to former owner required? Yes — § 64A is triggered by/contemplates notice and a written request from the former owner; the reform’s purpose is to return equity to the former owner.

▸ For Investors / Operators — Massachusetts does not run a typical lien auction; the municipality makes a “tax taking” under G.L. c. 60 and forecloses the right of redemption by judicial petition in the Land Court, and may assign the tax title to a private buyer (the “Tallage model”). Before committing capital, weigh the redemption risk (§2/2b — any interest-holder may redeem at 8% interest until the Land Court judgment, and Tallage Lincoln limits what an assignee may add to the redemption amount), the path to marketable title (§5b — the § 64 judgment is “absolute” but subject to the § 69A one-year vacatur window, and there is no Marketable Title Act), and which liens survive (§7b — the c. 183A § 6 condominium 6-month super-lien, the c. 21E § 13 environmental super-lien on commercial property, and the IRS § 7425 120-day redemption).

▸ For Former Owners — Under the St. 2024, c. 140 reform, when a c. 60 foreclosure leaves excess equity above the tax-title account, the former owner is entitled to it (G.L. c. 60 § 64A); the judgment holder must send a certified-mail accounting and a claim is made by written request to the municipality (or to a purchaser of tax receivables), with an 18-month claim window from the notice. Foreclosure judgments entered on/after May 25, 2021 but before the Act carry a retroactive Superior Court claim, filed by complaint within 12 months of the Act’s effective date.

4. Mortgage Foreclosure

  • Process: both available; non-judicial power of sale under G.L. c. 244 § 14 is the dominant method (most mortgages contain a statutory power of sale). A separate “Servicemembers case” is filed to confirm the borrower is not entitled to SCRA protection before sale. (Mass. mortgage-foreclosure law overview)
  • Pre-acceleration cure / loss mitigation:
    • G.L. c. 244 § 35A — 90-day right to cure a payment default before acceleration (once per 5-year period). (§ 35A)
    • G.L. c. 244 § 35B — for “certain mortgage loans,” creditor must send a loan-modification notice; the modification-review process runs up to 150 days. (§ 35B)
  • Timeline (days): notice of default/right to cure 90 days (§ 35A); § 35B review up to 150 days; notice of sale by publication + mailing per § 14; sale; no confirmation hearing for a power-of-sale foreclosure.
  • Reinstatement right: yes via the § 35A 90-day cure before acceleration.
  • Redemption after sale: none for a non-judicial power-of-sale foreclosure — the borrower’s equity of redemption ends at the sale; redemption rights exist only before sale (equity of redemption). (Mass. mortgage-foreclosure overview)
  • Deficiency judgment: allowed, but the lender must mail a statutory “Notice of Intent to Foreclose and of Deficiency” at least 21 days before the sale and sue within 2 years of the sale — G.L. c. 244 § 17B. (Mass. mortgage-foreclosure overview)
  • Surplus distribution: after the mortgage and foreclosure costs are paid, surplus from a power-of-sale foreclosure is held for junior lienholders then the former owner; the foreclosing mortgagee holds proceeds as trustee. — G.L. c. 244 § 14. needs_verification for the exact distribution-priority subsection.
  • Sale officer: the mortgagee/trustee conducts the power-of-sale auction (not a sheriff).

5. Sale Procedure Playbooks

  • Municipal tax taking & Land Court foreclosure — ordered steps → see treasurer-sale:
    1. Collector issues demand for unpaid tax (G.L. c. 60 § 16).
    2. Collector publishes/posts and gives 14-day notice of taking (G.L. c. 60 § 53).
    3. Collector records the instrument of taking at the registry → municipal tax title (§ 53); subsequent unpaid taxes certified to the account (§ 61).
    4. Optional: municipality assigns the tax title/receivable to a private buyer (§ 2C/52).
    5. After the statutory waiting period (generally 6 months from the taking; immediate where parcel is low-value/abandoned per §§ 65, 81A/81B), holder files a petition to foreclose all rights of redemption in the Land Court (§ 65). (§ 65)
    6. Land Court orders title examination, issues citation/notice to all interested parties (sometimes by publication); answer; hearing; finding.
    7. Owner may redeem on court-set terms until judgment (§ 76).
    8. Judgment of foreclosure → absolute title in the holder (§ 64), now subject to § 64A excess-equity accounting.
  • Sheriff sale: N/A for tax foreclosure (judicial Land Court process, not a sheriff sale). Sheriff/levy sales arise in execution on money judgments, not c. 60 tax foreclosure.
  • Notice requirements: demand + 14-day notice of taking (§ 53); Land Court citation to all parties of record, with publication where required, and actual mailed notice to known parties as a constitutional floor (Andover; mullane-v-central-hanover). (Land Court FAQ)
  • Upset bid / confirmation: none — the Land Court judgment, not a bid auction, transfers title.
  • Payment terms: redemption/payoff to the treasurer; assignment purchase per the municipality’s bulk-sale terms.
  • Deed issued: the instrument of taking (or collector’s deed) plus the Land Court judgment; title is statutorily absolute post-judgment (§ 64), not a warranty deed.

6. Due Process & Notice → see due-process-notice

  • Standard: notice “reasonably calculated, under all the circumstances, to apprise interested parties” — mullane-v-central-hanover (339 U.S. 306 (1950)), expressly applied to Massachusetts tax foreclosure in Town of Andover v. State Financial Services, Inc., 48 Mass. App. Ct. 536 (2000).
  • Required attempts: Land Court citation to all parties named in the title examination; actual mailed notice to parties whose identity and address are known; publication for unknown/unlocatable parties.
  • Consequence of defective notice: voidable — the foreclosure judgment may be vacated (the one-year statutory bar is excused where due process was denied), but title is not automatically void. — Andover, 48 Mass. App. Ct. 536.
  • Leading cases: tyler-v-hennepin-county, town-of-andover-v-state-financial-services, tallage-lincoln-v-williams, mills-v-city-of-springfield, mullane-v-central-hanover.

7. Title & Marketability

  • Deed warranty level: none — title passes by instrument of taking + Land Court judgment (statutorily “absolute,” not warranted). — G.L. c. 60 § 64.
  • Marketable immediately? Practically no until the one-year vacatur window has run and any § 64A excess-equity obligation is resolved; many purchasers quiet title or wait out the vacatur period.
  • Quiet title required? Often advisable; the § 64 judgment is intended to be conclusive but is subject to the vacatur/due-process exceptions.
  • SOL to challenge deed: generally 1 year to move to vacate the foreclosure judgment (Land Court FAQ), extendable where due process was denied (Andover). needs_verification for the exact c. 60 § 69A text.
  • Title insurance availability: generally available after the vacatur window / quiet title; underwriters scrutinize notice compliance and § 64A. — needs_verification for current underwriter standards.
  • Common defects: defective/absent mailed notice to known parties; certified- mail returned-unclaimed (cf. jones-v-flowers); assignee over-stating the redemption amount (Tallage); pre-reform foreclosures that retained surplus equity (Tyler/§ 64A exposure).

8. Case Law (real, verified)

CaseYearTopicHolding (plain English)Source
tyler-v-hennepin-county2023surplusKeeping surplus equity beyond the tax debt is an unconstitutional taking (5th Am.); 598 U.S. 631.https://www.mbmllc.com/chapter-60-foreclosure-massachusetts.html
tallage-lincoln-v-williams2020redemption / surplusSJC: a private assignee of a municipal tax title may not add its own subsequent tax payments to the redemption amount under G.L. c. 60 § 52; 485 Mass. 449.https://law.justia.com/cases/massachusetts/supreme-court/2020/sjc-12847.html
town-of-andover-v-state-financial-services2000due_process / sale_procedureApp. Ct.: where the owner’s identity and address are known, actual notice is constitutionally required; foreclosure decree vacated despite the one-year bar; 48 Mass. App. Ct. 536, citing Mullane.https://law.justia.com/cases/massachusetts/court-of-appeals/volumes/48/48massappct536.html
mills-v-city-of-springfield2024surplusHampden Superior Court (Callan, J.): G.L. c. 60 is unconstitutional as applied where it lets a municipality keep equity far exceeding the tax debt (~$1,636 debt vs. ~$145k–$230k property); statute “requires legislative correction.” (trial-level; persuasive, not binding)https://www.bostonglobe.com/2024/04/21/business/massachusetts-court-property-unpaid-taxes-equity-theft/
mullane-v-central-hanover1950due_processNotice must be “reasonably calculated, under all the circumstances, to apprise interested parties”; 339 U.S. 306.https://caselaw.findlaw.com/court/us-supreme-court/339/306.html

9. Edge Cases (state-specific notes)

  • bankruptcy-automatic-stay — a Chapter 13 filing can halt a Land Court tax foreclosure and treat the tax-title account through the plan; the redemption right is property of the estate if the petition precedes judgment. — needs_verification for MA-specific Land Court bankruptcy interplay.
  • federal-tax-lien-redemption — an IRS lien junior to the municipal tax title carries a 120-day federal right of redemption (26 U.S.C. § 7425) after the foreclosure. — needs_verification for MA application.
  • heirs-property — co-tenant heirs each hold an “interest” that can redeem under § 62; defective notice to one heir supports vacatur (Andover logic).
  • tyler-v-hennepin-county — Massachusetts reformed via St. 2024, c. 140 (§ 64A excess equity; retroactive Superior Court claims for judgments on/after May 25, 2021).
  • HOA super-priority — N/A in Massachusetts (no Nevada-style HOA super-lien for the foreclosure context). — needs_verification.
  • Manufactured homes / SCRA / life estates — needs_verification for MA-specific c. 60 treatment; SCRA is enforced via the Servicemembers case in the mortgage context (G.L. c. 244 § 14).
  • Assignee abuse — Tallage Lincoln limits what an assignee may charge the redeeming owner, a recurring edge case where municipalities sell receivables.

10. Operations

12. Forced Sales of Vehicles, Boats, Aircraft, Equipment & Businesses

Module rebuilt 2026-10-17; bounded final review 2026-10-18. Scoped module-12 gap score 23: 23 attributes and 0 buyer channels remain open (listed in 12.10). This is not a publication-readiness or nationwide legal certification. Real-estate sales are covered in the modules above. Internal evidence: schema/verification/massachusetts-independent-review-2026-10-18.md.

Cross-reference: assets · motor-vehicles · vessels · aircraft · equipment-and-machinery · businesses-and-going-concerns · court-ordered-administrative-and-creditor-sales · personal-property-execution-sales-by-state · towing-storage-and-mechanics-lien-sales · marina-and-storage-lien-sales-of-vessels · aircraft-mechanics-liens-and-non-judicial-sales · ucc-article-9-dispositions · equity-interests-stock-llc-charging-orders · forfeiture-and-government-seizure-sales

This module is the Massachusetts layer of the forced-sale material. Federal regimes (admiralty arrest, the FAA Aircraft Registry, IRS levy, bankruptcy § 363 sales) are explained on the asset pages linked above and are not repeated here.

Source base. Every General Law cited was read on October 18, 2026 in the text the General Court publishes at malegislature.gov (section pages retained with request times and hashes). Currentness was screened against the 2025 and 2026 session-law lists: the statewide acts that amend chapters used here (2025 c. 9, amending c. 90D, § 11A on electronic lien releases; 2026 c. 101, adding an affordable-housing materials exemption to c. 64H, § 6) do not change any rule stated below. Registry of Motor Vehicles and Department of Revenue forms, fee schedules and guidance, and the court rules, are published on mass.gov, which refused automated access (HTTP 403) and was not retried; points that depend on them are open in 12.10. Amounts use “USD”.

12.0 Statutory homes, officers and notice infrastructure

TopicMassachusetts homeSource
ExecutionG.L. c. 235, §§ 29-52 (levy and sale of personal property, exemptions § 34); attachment c. 223 (encumbered goods §§ 74-83)c. 235, § 36; c. 223, § 74
Statutory liensG.L. c. 255, §§ 14-39A, with c. 105A (self-service storage), c. 159B, § 6B (tow storage) and the other grants in 12.3 (48 in all)c. 255, § 26
Certificates of titlec. 90D (Registrar of Motor Vehicles); c. 90B, § 36 (titled motorboats)c. 90D, § 17; c. 90B, § 36
Levying officersSheriffs and constables (c. 235, § 23); a bonded constable serves within the town up to USD 200 on a USD 1,000 bond or USD 7,000 on a USD 5,000 bond, with sheriffs’ powers to require aidc. 41, § 92; c. 41, § 94
Statewide notice websiteLegal notices required in a newspaper must also appear on the newspaper’s website and on a “statewide website” maintained cooperatively by a majority of Massachusetts newspapers; free search, searchable full text and a 90-day archive; website errors do not defeat a compliant print notice. The statute does not name the sitec. 4, § 13
Civil-law vocabularyNot applicable (common-law state)—

Channel summary — what the buyer takes / what survives

ChannelAuthorityWhat the buyer takes / what survives
Sheriff/constable execution salec. 235, §§ 36-44Debtor’s interest; perfected security interests continue; proceeds to attaching creditors in order of service.
Consent or perishable sale of attached goodsc. 223, §§ 87-93Sold as on execution; proceeds stand in place of the goods subject to the attachments.
Department of Revenue levy salec. 62C, §§ 53-60Certificate of sale; discharges liens junior to the Commonwealth’s; senior interests survive.
IV-D agency levy salec. 119A, § 6(b)(6); c. 62C, §§ 56-60As a DOR certificate of sale; superior perfected liens survive.
Local collector’s distraint salec. 60, §§ 24-28Taxpayer’s goods; no title rule stated, so perfected security interests continue.
Controlled-substance forfeiture salec. 94C, § 47Forfeited interest; perfected security interest at filing not extinguished.
Police auction of abandoned vehicles and lost propertyc. 90, § 22C; c. 135, §§ 7-11No title rule stated; owner may claim net proceeds for 2 years.
State police, DCR, MBTA and MassDOT lost-property auctionsc. 22C, §§ 45-48; c. 92, §§ 89-94; c. 161A, § 5B; c. 6C, § 21No title rule stated; owners may claim proceeds within the stated periods.
Carriers’ unclaimed baggage, goods and perishables salesc. 135, §§ 1, 5, 6No title rule stated; proceeds to the Commonwealth or owner as stated.
State Treasurer sale of abandoned propertyc. 200A, § 9’Absolute title to the purchaser’.
Sale of former prisoners’ unclaimed propertyc. 127, § 96BSale to the highest of three dealers’ offers; no title rule stated.
Court-ordered lien sale (garage, animal, manufactured housing, aircraft, private tow)c. 255, §§ 26-31Under the court’s order; interests not bound by the order continue.
Accident/police-tow storage salec. 255, § 39A; c. 159B, § 6BNo free-and-clear clause; surplus to owner or court clerk.
Vessel lien court sale or abandoned-vessel auctionc. 255, §§ 17, 20; c. 254, §§ 18-19New title documents from the marine title division on the abandoned route; excess to the Abandoned Vessel Trust Fund.
Chapter 91 abandoned-vessel title claim and auctionc. 91, §§ 40-41Title subject to valid liens, including Article 9 security interests.
Processors’ lien auctionc. 255, § 31BNo free-and-clear clause.
Jewelers’, cleaners’ and other-article work lien salesc. 255, §§ 31C, 31D, 31FNo free-and-clear clause.
Molders’ lien auctionc. 255, § 31GMolder’s lien primes; no free-and-clear clause; subject to patent/copyright rights.
Self-service storage lien salec. 105A, § 4Good-faith purchaser free of rights of persons against whom the lien was valid.
Warehouse and carrier lien salesc. 106, §§ 7-210, 7-308Good-faith purchaser free of rights of persons against which the lien was valid.
Warehouser’s sale of property removed in summary processc. 239, § 4As a § 7-210 sale; tenant may buy in bloc or parcels.
Pawnbroker’s sale of unredeemed pledgesc. 140, § 71Pledgor’s interest; registered-mail notice 10 days before sale; surplus to the person entitled.
Auction of impounded or distrained beastsc. 49, §§ 36-38No title rule stated; proceeds held 2 years for the owner.
Article 9 dispositionc. 106, §§ 9-610-9-617Debtor’s rights free of the foreclosed and subordinate interests (good faith); senior interests survive.
Receiver’s salec. 156D, § 14.32; c. 156B, §§ 104-106As the court authorizes.
Assignee’s sale for the benefit of creditorsc. 203, § 40Good-faith trustee sales stand against later insolvency proceedings; no free-and-clear rule.
Museum acquisition and sale of unclaimed loaned propertyc. 200B, §§ 4-5Museum acquires title after 1 year unanswered notice and may sell (§ 4); unknown lenders: title free from all claims after 7 years (§ 5).
Court-directed sale of a charged partnership interestc. 108A, § 28Charged interest; assignee’s rights only.

12.1 Court sales of personal property (execution)

Writ and levy

  • What execution reaches. “All property which by common law is liable to be taken on execution, may be taken and sold thereon, except as otherwise expressly provided.” The creditor chooses the levy; for personal property the officer proceeds under §§ 31-51. c. 235, §§ 29, 31
  • Doubtful ownership. The officer may require security from the creditor before taking or continuing to hold goods of doubtful ownership, and may refuse or discharge the levy if none is given. c. 235, § 35
  • Securities. Certificated securities are reached only by seizure of the certificate (or process on the issuer if surrendered); uncertificated securities and entitlements by process on the issuer or intermediary; process on a secured party in possession. c. 106, § 8-112 Shares may not be attached in an action seeking only money damages. c. 223, § 71
  • Vessels. A ship or vessel may be attached only on an affidavit and a justice’s certificate that the plaintiff reasonably expects to recover at least one third of the damages claimed. c. 223, § 44

Exemptions that can limit a sale

ExemptionMassachusetts ruleSource
Motor vehicleAn automobile needed for personal transportation or employment, to USD 7,500 wholesale resale value; USD 15,000 if the debtor is handicapped or 60 or olderc. 235, § 34, Sixteenth
Tools of the tradeTools, implements and fixtures to USD 5,000; materials and stock to USD 5,000c. 235, § 34, Fifth, Sixth
Household goodsFurniture to USD 15,000; necessary apparel, bedding, one each of heating unit, stove, refrigerator, freezer and water heaterc. 235, § 34, First, Second
Wild cardUSD 1,000 in any personal property plus up to USD 5,000 of unused furniture, tools and automobile amountsc. 235, § 34, Seventeenth
JewelryUSD 1,225 in jewelry held for personal or household usec. 235, § 34, Eighteenth
Fishing gearBoats, tackle and nets of a fisherman in actual use, to USD 1,500c. 235, § 34, Ninth

The same exemptions apply to attachment. c. 223, § 42

Notice of sale

  • The officer posts notice of time and place at least 48 hours before the sale in a public place in the town of sale, or advertises in a newspaper published in the town of the debtor’s last residence. c. 235, § 37
  • If the goods are worth more than USD 300, either party may require newspaper notice, and the sale may then be held after 4 days and within 30 days of seizure. c. 235, § 38
  • A term for years (other than a lease of 100 years with 50 left, treated as land) is sold like personal property after 14 days’ written notice left with the debtor and posted on the premises. c. 235, § 46

Sale conduct, minimum bid and payment

  • Timing. Seized goods are kept at the debtor’s expense at least four days and sold by public auction within fourteen days of seizure, unless the debtor first redeems by satisfying the execution. c. 235, § 36 Adjournments up to 7 days at a time by public declaration; an enjoined sale awaits the court’s order. c. 235, §§ 39-40
  • Online sales are not authorized: c. 235 requires a public auction at a noticed time and place, unlike the police lost-property statute, which expressly allows Internet sales (c. 135, § 8).
  • No minimum bid for chattels on execution; attached perishables are appraised by three sworn disinterested persons before sale. c. 223, §§ 88-92
  • Bidder default. If the highest bidder refuses to take and pay, the officer resells at once or within 10 days with notice and accounts for damages recovered from the first bidder for the loss. c. 235, § 41 Deposit, time to pay and credit are not set by statute (12.10).
  • Before judgment. With the written consent of the debtor and all attaching creditors, attached goods may be sold as on execution, the proceeds standing in place of the goods. c. 223, § 87

Confirmation, buyer’s document, distribution

  • No confirmation. The officer’s return particularly describes each article sold and its price; there is no court approval step. An officer guilty of fraud in the sale or return is liable in tort for five times the actual damage. c. 235, § 42
  • Proceeds. Charges and the execution first, then other attaching or executing creditors in the order their writs were served, residue to the debtor on demand. c. 235, §§ 43-44
  • Vehicles are retitled on the last title if available, “proof of the transfer” and an application. c. 90D, § 17(a)

What the buyer takes / what survives

  • The buyer takes the debtor’s interest; c. 235 has no provision discharging senior liens. A security agreement is effective against purchasers and creditors, and a security interest continues in collateral after disposition unless the secured party authorized it. c. 106, § 9-201(a); c. 106, § 9-315(a)(1)
  • Encumbered goods. Mortgaged, pledged or lien-encumbered goods may be attached as if unencumbered only if the attaching creditor pays or tenders the secured amount within 10 days after the secured party’s written demand; otherwise the attachment is dissolved and the goods restored. A redeeming creditor is repaid first from the proceeds. c. 223, §§ 74-77
  • A lien creditor primes only a security interest not yet perfected (or not filed with an authenticated agreement). c. 106, § 9-317(a)(2)

Post-sale redemption, setting aside, third-party claims

  • Redemption is available only before the sale, by satisfying the execution. c. 235, § 36
  • Setting aside. No statute states grounds or a deadline to vacate a completed chattel sale (12.10).
  • Third-party claims. Goods attached or taken on execution but claimed by someone other than the defendant may be replevied. c. 247, § 7

12.2 Administrative forced sales

State tax (Department of Revenue)

  • Lien. Unpaid tax after demand is a lien on all property; it is not valid against a mortgagee, pledgee, purchaser or judgment creditor until notice is filed (personal property: in the Article 9 filing office). c. 62C, § 50
  • Levy. Ten days after demand (immediately on a jeopardy finding) the Commissioner may levy, including “distraint and seizure by any means,” and may seize and sell real or personal property. c. 62C, § 53
  • Sale. Written notice to the owner (or possessor) of the sum demanded and the property seized; newspaper notice in the county (postings only if none); sale 10 to 40 days after notice; adjournments not over one month in all; the Commissioner sets a minimum price, and if no one bids it the property is purchased for the Commonwealth; a defaulting bidder’s payment is forfeited on resale. c. 62C, § 56 Perishables are appraised and returned on payment or bond, otherwise sold. c. 62C, § 57
  • Redemption. Personal property only before sale. c. 62C, § 58
  • What the buyer takes. A certificate of sale that is conclusive evidence of regularity, transfers “all right, title and interest of the party delinquent,” for a motor vehicle authorizes the Registrar to record the transfer, and discharges “all liens, encumbrances and title over which the lien of the commonwealth … had priority.” Senior interests survive. c. 62C, §§ 59-60
  • Corporate transfers. A corporation selling substantially all Massachusetts assets outside the ordinary course must give 5 days’ notice and pay its taxes or a lien attaches immediately before the transfer, enforceable by levy; it does not apply to sales by receivers, ABC assignees, bankruptcy trustees or officers under judicial process. c. 62C, § 51

Local tax distraint

  • After demand, 14 days’ nonpayment and warrants, the collector may levy “by distress, or seizure and sale” of the taxpayer’s goods, except trade tools, beasts of the plough, military equipment, necessary housekeeping utensils, bedding and apparel; sale by public auction within 30 days after 48 hours’ posted notice on the DOR’s plain-language multilingual form; one adjournment up to 3 days; surplus to the owner. c. 60, §§ 24-28 The statute states no title rule, so a perfected security interest continues (c. 106, § 9-315).

Abandoned vehicles

  • Removal. A vehicle standing over 72 hours without permission and worth less than removal and disposal costs may be disposed of as refuse; others go to the police custodian of lost property (or state police or DCR custody). c. 90, § 22C Cities and towns that accept c. 90, § 22B(b)-(k) run parking-clerk tag-and-hearing programs. c. 90, § 22B
  • Sale. After one month unclaimed (owner unknown) or 10 days after a known owner receives registered-mail notice, by public auction or any other licensed auction service, including over the Internet, after newspaper notice once in each of three successive weeks. c. 135, § 8 Proceeds go to the city treasury; the owner may claim them within 2 years after sale. c. 135, §§ 10-11 State police and DCR custody: six months and one newspaper notice. c. 22C, §§ 45-48; c. 92, §§ 89-94
  • Buyer’s title. No title or lien-discharge rule is stated; retitling is on proof of the involuntary transfer (c. 90D, § 17(a)), and a perfected security interest is not shown discharged.

Abandoned vessels

  • A vessel moored or grounded without consent more than 90 days is prima facie abandoned. c. 91, § 39 A claimant checks theft status, sends certified mail to the owner, known lienholders and the department, publishes three consecutive printings, and after 90 days applies with a notarized affidavit; equal claimants trigger an auction. Title is granted “subject to any lien which is valid and enforceable under any other statute, including section 9 of chapter 106.” c. 91, §§ 40-41
  • Vessel lienholders have a separate abandoned-vessel route (12.3); sale surpluses fund the Abandoned Vessel Trust Fund, held 2 years for the former owner. c. 10, § 35GG

Abandoned aircraft

  • No General Law section disposes of abandoned aircraft (catchline scan of every chapter). Airport operators use the c. 255, § 31E lien (12.3).

Forfeiture and unclaimed property

  • Controlled substances. In-rem petition; certified or registered mail to the owner and apparent interest holders; hearing at least 2 weeks after notice; the final order may provide for “sale at public auction or by competitive bidding.” “No forfeiture under this section shall extinguish a perfected security interest held by a creditor in a conveyance … at the time of the filing of the forfeiture action.” c. 94C, § 47
  • Unclaimed property. The State Treasurer sells at public sale after county newspaper notice; “all sales … shall pass absolute title to the purchaser.” c. 200A, § 9
  • Carriers. Unclaimed passenger baggage after 120 days (5 weeks’ notice), unclaimed rail, express or vessel goods after one year (3 weeks’ notice), and undeliverable perishables may be sold. c. 135, §§ 1, 5-6

12.3 Lienholder sales without a court — and the court default

Massachusetts has 48 independently created statutory liens, charges or automatic security interests reaching personal property. Each is profiled below with the fifteen required attributes; an identical grant repeated in several statutes is profiled once.

  • Court default. A lien for work and labor, storage, care or money expended on personal property (other than vessel liens) is enforced by a civil action to have the property sold, after a written demand unpaid 10 days (animal, garage and manufactured-housing liens) or 60 days (others); the court may order the sale, and surplus goes to the owner. These sections do not restrict any other lawful disposition. c. 255, §§ 26, 29, 31
  • Owner’s protections. Before sale the owner may dissolve the lien by bond, or terminate a bailee’s lien by a double-penalty surety bond, and may replevy goods detained under a lien where the contract did not state total charges in writing. c. 255, §§ 32-36
  • Priority baseline. A possessory lien for services or materials furnished with respect to goods in the ordinary course has priority over a security interest unless its statute expressly provides otherwise. c. 106, § 9-333 Against a conditional vendor or lessor, a bailee’s lien without notice prevails unless the goods were delivered after breach and the vendor demands them within 90 days. c. 255, § 35

Vessel liens (c. 255, §§ 14-20)

1. Vessel construction, repair and supply lien — c. 255, § 14
AttributeRule
StatuteG.L. c. 255, § 14; enforcement §§ 15-17, 20.
Who holds itPersons owed for labor, materials, launching ways, provisions, stores or other articles furnished for a vessel in Massachusetts under contract with the owners or their agents or builders.
Priority vs perfected security interest’Preferred to all others on such vessel, except that for mariners’ wages’ (§§ 14, 14A); state enforcement yields where the contract is maritime and enforcement is within exclusive federal jurisdiction (§ 17).
Amount / capThe debt for the labor, materials or supplies (§ 14).
Court required?Yes by default: civil action in District or Superior Court with a writ of attachment, proceeding under c. 254 so far as applicable (§ 17); no civil action is required for the abandoned-vessel route (§ 17, second paragraph).
Notice to ownerAbandoned route: certified mail to the owner of record stating the lien amount and proposed sale, plus newspaper notice; title is presumed abandoned if no reply within 90 days (§ 17).
Notice to lienholdersNot required by § 17; in the court route, parties summoned in the action are marshalled (§ 20).
Registry / division noticeAbandoned route: notarized affidavit filed with the marine title division of the Department of Environmental Police (§ 17).
PublicationAbandoned route: 3 consecutive days in a newspaper of general circulation in the owner’s town (§ 17); court route: notice as for land sales on execution or as the court orders (c. 254, § 19).
Waiting period90 days after certified notice or publication, whichever is later (§ 17). The § 14 lien is dissolved unless a sworn statement is filed with the town clerk within 30 days after the vessel leaves port (§ 15).
Sale methodCourt-ordered sale by an officer qualified to serve civil process (c. 254, § 18), or public auction or other disposal on the abandoned route (§ 17).
What the buyer takesOn the abandoned route the marine title division issues new title documents to the auction purchaser (§ 17); the statute does not say other recorded interests are discharged, so a perfected security interest is not shown to be cut off (c. 106, § 9-315(a)(1)).
SurplusClaims marshalled; labor liens get a one-third larger percentage if proceeds are short; excess over liens to the Abandoned Vessel Trust Fund, held 2 years for the former owner (§ 20; c. 10, § 35GG).
Defective saleNo purchaser cure is stated; the court route allows bond dissolution of attachment without dissolving the lien (§ 17).
CitationG.L. c. 255, §§ 14, 15-17, 20; c. 254, §§ 18-19; c. 10, § 35GG.

Sources: c. 255, § 14 · c. 255, § 14A · c. 255, § 15 · c. 255, § 17 · c. 255, § 20 · c. 254, § 18 · c. 254, § 19 · c. 10, § 35GG

2. Vessel storage lien (vessels 40 feet or less) — c. 255, § 14A
AttributeRule
StatuteG.L. c. 255, § 14A; enforcement §§ 15-17, 20.
Who holds itPersons owed for wet or land storage (with incidental labor, stands and cradles) of a vessel not more than 40 feet long.
Priority vs perfected security interest’Preferred to all others on such vessel, except that for mariners’ wages’ (§§ 14, 14A); state enforcement yields where the contract is maritime and enforcement is within exclusive federal jurisdiction (§ 17).
Amount / capThe storage debt including incidental labor and materials (§ 14A).
Court required?Yes by default: civil action in District or Superior Court with a writ of attachment, proceeding under c. 254 so far as applicable (§ 17); no civil action is required for the abandoned-vessel route (§ 17, second paragraph).
Notice to ownerAbandoned route: certified mail to the owner of record stating the lien amount and proposed sale, plus newspaper notice; title is presumed abandoned if no reply within 90 days (§ 17).
Notice to lienholdersNot required by § 17; in the court route, parties summoned in the action are marshalled (§ 20).
Registry / division noticeAbandoned route: notarized affidavit filed with the marine title division of the Department of Environmental Police (§ 17).
PublicationAbandoned route: 3 consecutive days in a newspaper of general circulation in the owner’s town (§ 17); court route: notice as for land sales on execution or as the court orders (c. 254, § 19).
Waiting period90 days after certified notice or publication, whichever is later (§ 17).
Sale methodCourt-ordered sale by an officer qualified to serve civil process (c. 254, § 18), or public auction or other disposal on the abandoned route (§ 17).
What the buyer takesOn the abandoned route the marine title division issues new title documents to the auction purchaser (§ 17); the statute does not say other recorded interests are discharged, so a perfected security interest is not shown to be cut off (c. 106, § 9-315(a)(1)).
SurplusClaims marshalled; labor liens get a one-third larger percentage if proceeds are short; excess over liens to the Abandoned Vessel Trust Fund, held 2 years for the former owner (§ 20; c. 10, § 35GG).
Defective saleNo purchaser cure is stated; the court route allows bond dissolution of attachment without dissolving the lien (§ 17).
CitationG.L. c. 255, §§ 14A, 15-17, 20; c. 254, §§ 18-19; c. 10, § 35GG.

Sources: c. 255, § 14 · c. 255, § 14A · c. 255, § 15 · c. 255, § 17 · c. 255, § 20 · c. 254, § 18 · c. 254, § 19 · c. 10, § 35GG

Court-enforced liens under c. 255, §§ 26-31

3. Lien for pasturing, boarding or keeping domestic animals — c. 255, § 24
AttributeRule
StatuteG.L. c. 255, § 24; enforcement §§ 26-29.
Who holds itPersons with proper charges for pasturing, boarding or keeping horses or other domestic animals brought or placed with the owner’s consent.
Priority vs perfected security interestA possessory lien for services or materials furnished with respect to goods in the ordinary course of business has priority over a security interest unless its statute expressly provides otherwise (c. 106, § 9-333); § 24 does not. Statutory application.
Amount / capProper charges for pasturing, boarding or keeping (§ 24).
Court required?Yes: civil action in Superior or District Court to have the property sold, after a written demand left unpaid 10 days (c. 255, § 26); the court may order sale and fixes the amount due (§ 29).
Notice to ownerWritten demand delivered or left at the debtor’s abode (or mailed if outside Massachusetts); 10 days to pay (§ 26); then service in the civil action.
Notice to lienholdersNone prescribed by §§ 26-29; other interest holders are bound only as parties to the action.
Registry / division noticeNone prescribed; a vehicle buyer titles on proof of the court-ordered transfer (c. 90D, § 17(a)).
PublicationNone fixed by statute; as the court orders (§ 29).
Waiting period10 days after demand, then the action (§ 26).
Sale methodCourt-ordered sale (§ 29); §§ 24-29 do not restrict other lawful disposition (§ 31).
What the buyer takesThe buyer takes under the court’s order of sale (§ 29); no statutory free-and-clear rule, so interests not bound by the order continue (c. 106, § 9-315(a)(1)).
SurplusProceeds after debt, costs and charges paid to the owner on demand (§ 29).
Defective saleBefore sale the owner may dissolve the lien by bond (§§ 32-34) or replevy where charges were not stated in writing (§ 36); no purchaser cure is stated.
CitationG.L. c. 255, §§ 24, 26, 29, 31-34.

Sources: c. 255, § 24 · c. 106, § 9-333 · c. 255, § 26 · c. 255, § 29 · c. 255, § 31 · c. 255, § 32 · c. 255, § 33 · c. 255, § 34

4. Garage keeper’s and repairer’s lien on motor vehicles — c. 255, § 25
AttributeRule
StatuteG.L. c. 255, § 25 (also the lien a garage acquires on an accident-tow vehicle when the owner assents to continued storage, § 39A); enforcement §§ 26-29.
Who holds itPublic garages storing and caring for motor vehicles placed with the owner’s consent, and persons inspecting, reconditioning or repairing motor vehicles.
Priority vs perfected security interestA possessory lien for services or materials furnished with respect to goods in the ordinary course of business has priority over a security interest unless its statute expressly provides otherwise (c. 106, § 9-333); § 25 does not. Statutory application. Section 25 itself contemplates ‘the holder of a security interest that does not have priority over the lien’.
Amount / capProper charges for storage, work and care (§ 25); the lien survives if the owner regains the vehicle by fraud, trick or a dishonored check.
Court required?Yes: civil action in Superior or District Court to have the property sold, after a written demand left unpaid 10 days (c. 255, § 26); the court may order sale and fixes the amount due (§ 29).
Notice to ownerWritten demand delivered or left at the debtor’s abode (or mailed if outside Massachusetts); 10 days to pay (§ 26); then service in the civil action.
Notice to lienholdersNone prescribed by §§ 26-29; other interest holders are bound only as parties to the action.
Registry / division noticeNone prescribed; a vehicle buyer titles on proof of the court-ordered transfer (c. 90D, § 17(a)).
PublicationNone fixed by statute; as the court orders (§ 29).
Waiting period10 days after demand, then the action (§ 26).
Sale methodCourt-ordered sale (§ 29); §§ 24-29 do not restrict other lawful disposition (§ 31).
What the buyer takesThe buyer takes under the court’s order of sale (§ 29); no statutory free-and-clear rule, so interests not bound by the order continue (c. 106, § 9-315(a)(1)).
SurplusProceeds after debt, costs and charges paid to the owner on demand (§ 29).
Defective saleBefore sale the owner may dissolve the lien by bond (§§ 32-34) or replevy where charges were not stated in writing (§ 36); no purchaser cure is stated.
CitationG.L. c. 255, §§ 25, 26, 29, 31-34, 39A.

Sources: c. 255, § 25 · c. 255, § 39A · c. 106, § 9-333 · c. 255, § 26 · c. 255, § 29 · c. 255, § 31 · c. 255, § 32 · c. 255, § 33 · c. 255, § 34

5. Manufactured housing community operator’s lien — c. 255, § 25A
AttributeRule
StatuteG.L. c. 255, § 25A; enforcement §§ 26-29.
Who holds itOperators of manufactured housing communities, on manufactured homes and their contents.
Priority vs perfected security interestFor storage and care, a possessory service lien has 9-333 priority because § 25A does not provide otherwise; for site rental and taxes, which are not services furnished with respect to the goods, no statute ranks the lien ahead of an earlier security interest (c. 106, §§ 9-201(a), 9-333). Statutory application.
Amount / capProper charges for site rental, facilities, storage and care, and taxes assessed because the home occupied a site (§ 25A).
Court required?Yes: civil action in Superior or District Court to have the property sold, after a written demand left unpaid 10 days (c. 255, § 26); the court may order sale and fixes the amount due (§ 29).
Notice to ownerWritten demand delivered or left at the debtor’s abode (or mailed if outside Massachusetts); 10 days to pay (§ 26); then service in the civil action.
Notice to lienholdersNone prescribed by §§ 26-29; other interest holders are bound only as parties to the action.
Registry / division noticeNone prescribed; a vehicle buyer titles on proof of the court-ordered transfer (c. 90D, § 17(a)).
PublicationNone fixed by statute; as the court orders (§ 29).
Waiting period10 days after demand, then the action (§ 26).
Sale methodCourt-ordered sale (§ 29); §§ 24-29 do not restrict other lawful disposition (§ 31).
What the buyer takesThe buyer takes under the court’s order of sale (§ 29); no statutory free-and-clear rule, so interests not bound by the order continue (c. 106, § 9-315(a)(1)).
SurplusProceeds after debt, costs and charges paid to the owner on demand (§ 29).
Defective saleBefore sale the owner may dissolve the lien by bond (§§ 32-34) or replevy where charges were not stated in writing (§ 36); no purchaser cure is stated.
CitationG.L. c. 255, §§ 25A, 26, 29, 31-34.

Sources: c. 255, § 25A · c. 106, § 9-333 · c. 106, § 9-201 · c. 255, § 26 · c. 255, § 29 · c. 255, § 31 · c. 255, § 32 · c. 255, § 33 · c. 255, § 34

6. Airport landing, parking, storage and tie-down lien — c. 255, § 31E (first paragraph)
AttributeRule
StatuteG.L. c. 255, § 31E, first paragraph; enforcement §§ 26-31.
Who holds itPersons (including the Commonwealth) maintaining public landing, parking, storage and tie-down facilities on an airport, for aircraft placed with the owner’s consent.
Priority vs perfected security interestA possessory lien for services or materials furnished with respect to goods in the ordinary course of business has priority over a security interest unless its statute expressly provides otherwise (c. 106, § 9-333); § 31E does not. Statutory application. The lien does not attach after purchase by an innocent purchaser for value in possession unless filed with the FAA Aircraft Registry first or the purchaser had written notice.
Amount / capProper charges for landing, parking, storage, tie-down and care; waived unless a verified statement is filed with the FAA Aircraft Registry within 60 days after last furnishing (§ 31E).
Court required?Yes: civil action in Superior or District Court to have the property sold, after a written demand left unpaid 60 days (c. 255, § 26); the court may order sale and fixes the amount due (§ 29).
Notice to ownerWritten demand delivered or left at the debtor’s abode (or mailed if outside Massachusetts); 60 days to pay (§ 26); then service in the civil action.
Notice to lienholdersNone prescribed by §§ 26-29; other interest holders are bound only as parties to the action.
Registry / division noticeNone prescribed; a vehicle buyer titles on proof of the court-ordered transfer (c. 90D, § 17(a)).
PublicationNone fixed by statute; as the court orders (§ 29).
Waiting period60 days after demand, then the action (§ 26).
Sale methodCourt-ordered sale (§ 29); §§ 24-29 do not restrict other lawful disposition (§ 31).
What the buyer takesThe buyer takes under the court’s order of sale (§ 29); no statutory free-and-clear rule, so interests not bound by the order continue (c. 106, § 9-315(a)(1)).
SurplusProceeds after debt, costs and charges paid to the owner on demand (§ 29).
Defective saleBefore sale the owner may dissolve the lien by bond (§§ 32-34) or replevy where charges were not stated in writing (§ 36); no purchaser cure is stated.
CitationG.L. c. 255, §§ 26-31, 31E.

Sources: c. 255, § 31E · c. 106, § 9-333 · c. 255, § 26 · c. 255, § 29 · c. 255, § 31 · c. 255, § 32 · c. 255, § 33 · c. 255, § 34

7. Aircraft repairer’s lien — c. 255, § 31E (second paragraph)
AttributeRule
StatuteG.L. c. 255, § 31E, second paragraph; enforcement §§ 26-31.
Who holds itAny person who lawfully repairs an aircraft in Massachusetts.
Priority vs perfected security interestA possessory lien for services or materials furnished with respect to goods in the ordinary course of business has priority over a security interest unless its statute expressly provides otherwise (c. 106, § 9-333); § 31E does not. Statutory application. Unfiled liens do not attach against an innocent purchaser for value in possession (§ 31E).
Amount / capProper charges; waived unless a verified statement is filed with the FAA Aircraft Registry within 60 days after last furnishing (§ 31E).
Court required?Yes: civil action in Superior or District Court to have the property sold, after a written demand left unpaid 60 days (c. 255, § 26); the court may order sale and fixes the amount due (§ 29).
Notice to ownerWritten demand delivered or left at the debtor’s abode (or mailed if outside Massachusetts); 60 days to pay (§ 26); then service in the civil action.
Notice to lienholdersNone prescribed by §§ 26-29; other interest holders are bound only as parties to the action.
Registry / division noticeNone prescribed; a vehicle buyer titles on proof of the court-ordered transfer (c. 90D, § 17(a)).
PublicationNone fixed by statute; as the court orders (§ 29).
Waiting period60 days after demand, then the action (§ 26).
Sale methodCourt-ordered sale (§ 29); §§ 24-29 do not restrict other lawful disposition (§ 31).
What the buyer takesThe buyer takes under the court’s order of sale (§ 29); no statutory free-and-clear rule, so interests not bound by the order continue (c. 106, § 9-315(a)(1)).
SurplusProceeds after debt, costs and charges paid to the owner on demand (§ 29).
Defective saleBefore sale the owner may dissolve the lien by bond (§§ 32-34) or replevy where charges were not stated in writing (§ 36); no purchaser cure is stated.
CitationG.L. c. 255, §§ 26-31, 31E.

Sources: c. 255, § 31E · c. 106, § 9-333 · c. 255, § 26 · c. 255, § 29 · c. 255, § 31 · c. 255, § 32 · c. 255, § 33 · c. 255, § 34

8. Private-property tower’s right to hold vehicle for charges — c. 266, § 120D
AttributeRule
StatuteG.L. c. 266, § 120D (‘may hold such vehicle until the registered owner pays the removal and storage charges’).
Who holds itA person lawfully holding a vehicle removed from a private way or property after the required police notification.
Priority vs perfected security interestA possessory lien for services or materials furnished with respect to goods in the ordinary course of business has priority over a security interest unless its statute expressly provides otherwise (c. 106, § 9-333); Section 120D does not. Statutory application.
Amount / capRemoval and storage charges capped at the c. 159B, § 6B public maxima (§ 120D); a non-complying tower must release without charges.
Court required?Yes: civil action in Superior or District Court to have the property sold, after a written demand left unpaid 60 days (c. 255, § 26); the court may order sale and fixes the amount due (§ 29).
Notice to ownerWritten demand delivered or left at the debtor’s abode (or mailed if outside Massachusetts); 60 days to pay (§ 26); then service in the civil action.
Notice to lienholdersNone prescribed by §§ 26-29; other interest holders are bound only as parties to the action.
Registry / division noticeNone prescribed; a vehicle buyer titles on proof of the court-ordered transfer (c. 90D, § 17(a)).
PublicationNone fixed by statute; as the court orders (§ 29).
Waiting period60 days after demand, then the action (§ 26).
Sale methodCourt-ordered sale (§ 29); §§ 24-29 do not restrict other lawful disposition (§ 31).
What the buyer takesThe buyer takes under the court’s order of sale (§ 29); no statutory free-and-clear rule, so interests not bound by the order continue (c. 106, § 9-315(a)(1)).
SurplusProceeds after debt, costs and charges paid to the owner on demand (§ 29).
Defective saleBefore sale the owner may dissolve the lien by bond (§§ 32-34) or replevy where charges were not stated in writing (§ 36); no purchaser cure is stated.
CitationG.L. c. 266, § 120D; c. 255, §§ 26, 29.

Sources: c. 266, § 120D · c. 106, § 9-333 · c. 255, § 26 · c. 255, § 29 · c. 255, § 31 · c. 255, § 32 · c. 255, § 33 · c. 255, § 34

Self-help sale liens

9. Textile, leather and materials processors’ lien — c. 255, § 31A
AttributeRule
StatuteG.L. c. 255, §§ 31A-31B.
Who holds itPersons spinning, dyeing, finishing or otherwise processing cotton, wool, silk, synthetic fibers, leather, wood, metals, paper, plastics and electrical-component materials, on goods in their possession (extending to unpaid balances for other goods of the same owner).
Priority vs perfected security interest’Priority over any title, lien, interest or encumbrance of any owner’ (§ 31A), ‘owner’ including a factor, consignee or agent; as a possessory processing lien it also has 9-333 priority (c. 106, § 9-333) because the statute does not provide otherwise.
Amount / capWork, labor and materials, including the unpaid balance for other goods of the same owner (§ 31A).
Court required?No: public auction 10 days after the earliest item becomes payable (§ 31B); the remedy is additional to others.
Notice to ownerRegistered mail of the sale notice at least 5 days before sale if the owner’s address is known or ascertainable (§ 31B).
Notice to lienholdersNone prescribed.
Registry / division noticeNot applicable — Processed goods are not titled property.
PublicationOnce in each of 2 successive weeks in a newspaper in the town (or county), the last at least 5 days before sale (§ 31B).
Waiting period10 days after the earliest item is due (§ 31B).
Sale methodPublic auction; divisible goods sold only as needed (§ 31B).
What the buyer takesNo free-and-clear clause; the buyer takes the owner’s interest, and a security interest continues in collateral after disposition unless the secured party authorized it (c. 106, § 9-315(a)(1)).
SurplusBalance to the owner or person entitled (§ 31B).
Defective saleNo purchaser cure is stated.
CitationG.L. c. 255, §§ 31A-31B.

Sources: c. 255, § 31A · c. 255, § 31B · c. 106, § 9-315

10. Jewelers’ lien on watches, clocks, silverware and jewelry — c. 255, § 31C
AttributeRule
StatuteG.L. c. 255, § 31C.
Who holds itPersons performing work on a watch, clock, silverware or jewelry for a price who give the statutory printed receipt and post § 31C.
Priority vs perfected security interestA possessory lien for services or materials furnished with respect to goods in the ordinary course of business has priority over a security interest unless its statute expressly provides otherwise (c. 106, § 9-333); § 31C does not. Statutory application.
Amount / capThe account due for the work and materials furnished (§ 31C).
Court required?No: the lienor may sell at public or bona fide private sale after the statutory period and notice; the remedy is in addition to others.
Notice to ownerWritten notice to the owner stating the amount due and the 30-day redemption right, by mail to the last known address or, if owner or address is unknown, posting in two public places in the town.
Notice to lienholdersNone prescribed.
Registry / division noticeNone prescribed.
PublicationNone prescribed beyond the posting alternative.
Waiting periodAccount unpaid 1 year after completion of the work, then 30 days after the written notice (§ 31C).
Sale methodPublic or bona fide private sale.
What the buyer takesNo free-and-clear clause; the buyer takes the owner’s interest, and a security interest continues in collateral after disposition unless the secured party authorized it (c. 106, § 9-315(a)(1)).
SurplusExpenses and the debt paid; balance to the owner.
Defective saleNo purchaser cure is stated.
CitationG.L. c. 255, § 31C; c. 106, §§ 9-315, 9-333.

Sources: c. 255, § 31C · c. 106, § 9-333 · c. 106, § 9-315

11. Cleaners’ and storers’ lien on clothing and household goods — c. 255, § 31D
AttributeRule
StatuteG.L. c. 255, § 31D.
Who holds itPersons cleaning, pressing, dyeing, altering, repairing or storing clothing or household goods for a price.
Priority vs perfected security interestA possessory lien for services or materials furnished with respect to goods in the ordinary course of business has priority over a security interest unless its statute expressly provides otherwise (c. 106, § 9-333); § 31D does not. Statutory application.
Amount / capThe account for work or storage and materials (§ 31D).
Court required?No: the lienor may sell at public or bona fide private sale after the statutory period and notice; the remedy is in addition to others.
Notice to ownerWritten notice to the owner stating the amount due and the 30-day redemption right, by mail to the last known address or, if owner or address is unknown, posting in two public places in the town.
Notice to lienholdersNone prescribed.
Registry / division noticeNone prescribed.
PublicationNone prescribed beyond the posting alternative.
Waiting periodAccount unpaid 90 days after completion (or after the agreed storage term, or 120 days from storage), then 30 days after written notice (§ 31D).
Sale methodPublic or bona fide private sale, or donation to a charitable corporation.
What the buyer takesNo free-and-clear clause; the buyer takes the owner’s interest, and a security interest continues in collateral after disposition unless the secured party authorized it (c. 106, § 9-315(a)(1)).
SurplusExpenses and the debt paid; balance to the owner.
Defective saleNo purchaser cure is stated.
CitationG.L. c. 255, § 31D; c. 106, §§ 9-315, 9-333.

Sources: c. 255, § 31D · c. 106, § 9-333 · c. 106, § 9-315

12. Lien for work on paintings, photographs and other personal property — c. 255, § 31F
AttributeRule
StatuteG.L. c. 255, § 31F.
Who holds itPersons performing work on a painting, photograph or other piece of personal property for a price who give the statutory printed receipt and post § 31F.
Priority vs perfected security interestA possessory lien for services or materials furnished with respect to goods in the ordinary course of business has priority over a security interest unless its statute expressly provides otherwise (c. 106, § 9-333); § 31F does not. Statutory application.
Amount / capThe account due for the work and materials (§ 31F).
Court required?No: the lienor may sell at public or bona fide private sale after the statutory period and notice; the remedy is in addition to others.
Notice to ownerWritten notice to the owner stating the amount due and the 30-day redemption right, by mail to the last known address or, if owner or address is unknown, posting in two public places in the town.
Notice to lienholdersNone prescribed.
Registry / division noticeNone prescribed.
PublicationNone prescribed beyond the posting alternative.
Waiting periodAccount unpaid 1 year after completion, then 30 days after written notice (§ 31F).
Sale methodPublic or bona fide private sale.
What the buyer takesNo free-and-clear clause; the buyer takes the owner’s interest, and a security interest continues in collateral after disposition unless the secured party authorized it (c. 106, § 9-315(a)(1)).
SurplusExpenses and the debt paid; balance to the owner.
Defective saleNo purchaser cure is stated.
CitationG.L. c. 255, § 31F; c. 106, §§ 9-315, 9-333.

Sources: c. 255, § 31F · c. 106, § 9-333 · c. 106, § 9-315

13. Molders’ lien on dies, molds, forms, plates, art and patterns — c. 255, § 31G
AttributeRule
StatuteG.L. c. 255, § 31G.
Who holds itMolders (as defined in c. 94, § 320), on a customer’s dies, molds, forms, engraving plates, original art or patterns in their hands, dependent on possession.
Priority vs perfected security interest’Priority over any title, lien, interest or encumbrance’ in the item (§ 31G(b)); not applicable if the customer gave written notice of defect and returned the products within 30 days of delivery.
Amount / capBalance due for manufacturing or fabrication work and related materials (§ 31G(b)).
Court required?No: public auction (§ 31G(d)).
Notice to ownerWritten lien notice and demand, by hand or registered mail (§ 31G(c)); registered mail, return receipt, of intent to sell 30 days after receipt with description, time, place and itemized amount (§ 31G(e)).
Notice to lienholdersNone before sale; excess proceeds go to any lienholder known at the time of sale (§ 31G(g)).
Registry / division noticeNot applicable — Not titled property.
PublicationOnly if the receipt is not returned or notice is undeliverable: newspaper notice in the customer’s last known business town (§ 31G(f)).
Waiting period60 days after the customer receives the lien notice, then 30 days after receipt of the sale notice (§ 31G(d)-(e)).
Sale methodPublic auction, subject to the customer’s federal patent or copyright rights (§ 31G(d)).
What the buyer takesThe molder’s lien primes other interests, but § 31G states no free-and-clear clause; a buyer takes subject to interests not discharged by law (c. 106, § 9-315(a)(1)) and to the customer’s patent or copyright rights.
SurplusExpenses and debt paid; excess to any known lienholder, then the customer, or the State Treasurer if the customer’s address is unknown (§ 31G(g)).
Defective saleNo purchaser cure is stated.
CitationG.L. c. 255, § 31G.

Sources: c. 255, § 31G · c. 106, § 9-315

14. Motor vehicle storage facility lien for police-ordered and accident tows — c. 159B, § 6B
AttributeRule
StatuteG.L. c. 159B, § 6B; enforced under the sale provisions of c. 255, § 39A.
Who holds itA motor vehicle storage facility, for transportation and storage charges on vehicles towed by police or public order, after an accident, or after theft (§ 6B).
Priority vs perfected security interestA possessory lien for services or materials furnished with respect to goods in the ordinary course of business has priority over a security interest unless its statute expressly provides otherwise (c. 106, § 9-333); Section 6B does not. Statutory application.
Amount / capDepartment maximum towing rates (local rates may be lower); storage USD 35 per 24 hours for lighted, fenced outdoor facilities, half that for others (§ 6B).
Court required?No: sale under c. 255, § 39A.
Notice to ownerRegistered mail, return receipt, on receiving owner information; after 60 days unclaimed, registered-mail notice of charges and that the vehicle will be sold if not claimed within 21 days (c. 255, § 39A).
Notice to lienholdersNone prescribed by § 39A.
Registry / division noticeNone to the Registrar; notice to the chief of police at least 5 days before sale (§ 39A).
PublicationThree successive weeks in a newspaper published or circulating in the town (§ 39A).
Waiting period60 days from placement, then 21 days after the final notice (§ 39A).
Sale methodPublic or private sale (§ 39A).
What the buyer takesNo free-and-clear clause; the buyer takes the owner’s interest, and a security interest continues in collateral after disposition unless the secured party authorized it (c. 106, § 9-315(a)(1)). Retitling is on proof of the involuntary transfer (c. 90D, § 17(a)).
SurplusStatement to the registered owner; balance paid to the owner if the address is known, otherwise deposited with the district court clerk in trust (§ 39A).
Defective saleNo purchaser cure is stated.
CitationG.L. c. 159B, § 6B; c. 255, § 39A.

Sources: c. 159B, § 6B · c. 255, § 39A · c. 106, § 9-333 · c. 106, § 9-315

15. Self-service storage operator’s lien — c. 105A, § 3
AttributeRule
StatuteG.L. c. 105A, §§ 3-5.
Who holds itThe operator of a self-service storage facility, on all personal property in the leased space; lost by voluntary or unjustified refusal to deliver (§ 3).
Priority vs perfected security interestNo statute ranks this lien against an earlier security interest; under c. 106, § 9-201(a) a security agreement is effective against purchasers and creditors, and the § 9-333 possessory-service rule does not reach space rental, which is not a service furnished with respect to the goods. Statutory application.
Amount / capRent, labor, insurance and preservation and sale expenses (§ 3); late fee presumptively reasonable at the greater of USD 20 or 20% of monthly rent (§ 5).
Court required?No: public or private sale (§ 4).
Notice to ownerFirst notice by regular mail or email no sooner than 5 days after default; second by email, verified mail or hand delivery no sooner than 14 days after default with a demand of at least 14 days (§ 4(1)-(3)).
Notice to lienholdersBoth notices go to ‘all other persons known to claim an interest’ (§ 4(1)-(2)).
Registry / division noticeNone; a vehicle unpaid 60 days may be towed by an insured tower, who must then follow c. 255, § 39A (§ 4(13)).
PublicationOnce a week for 2 consecutive weeks in a newspaper, a weekly county periodical, or another commercially reasonable manner (three independent bidders makes it commercially reasonable) (§ 4(4)).
Waiting periodSale at least 15 days after the first publication (§ 4(4)).
Sale methodPublic or private sale at the facility, nearest suitable place or a publicly accessible website; operator may buy at public sale (§ 4(6)-(7)).
What the buyer takesA good-faith purchaser takes free of the rights of persons against whom the lien was valid, despite noncompliance (§ 4(9)).
SurplusBalance held for release on demand to the occupant or person entitled (§ 4(10)).
Defective saleDamages for noncompliance; conversion if willful (§ 4(12)).
CitationG.L. c. 105A, §§ 3-5.

Sources: c. 105A, § 3 · c. 105A, § 4 · c. 105A, § 5 · c. 106, § 9-201 · c. 106, § 9-333

16. Warehouse lien (UCC 7-209) — c. 106, § 7-209(a)
AttributeRule
StatuteG.L. c. 106, § 7-209(a); a reserved security interest (§ 7-209(b)) is consensual.
Who holds itA warehouse, on goods covered by its receipt or storage agreement (or proceeds) in its possession.
Priority vs perfected security interestNot effective against a holder of a prior legal interest or perfected security interest who did not entrust or acquiesce; household-goods liens bind all persons if the depositor was the legal possessor (§ 7-209(c)-(d)).
Amount / capStorage, transportation, insurance, labor and sale charges; limited against a holder by due negotiation (§ 7-209(a)).
Court required?No: commercially reasonable sale, or the § 7-210(b) procedure for non-merchant goods.
Notice to ownerNotification to all persons known to claim an interest; for non-merchant goods an itemized demand at least 10 days after receipt (§ 7-210(a)-(b)).
Notice to lienholdersSame notification (§ 7-210).
Registry / division noticeNone prescribed.
PublicationNon-merchant goods: weekly for 2 consecutive weeks in a newspaper where the sale is held, or posting in 6 conspicuous places at least 10 days before sale (§ 7-210(b)(5)).
Waiting periodAfter the demand period and the advertisement (§ 7-210(b)).
Sale methodCommercially reasonable public or private sale; auction at the nearest suitable place for non-merchant goods; warehouse may buy (§ 7-210).
What the buyer takesA good-faith purchaser takes free of rights of persons against which the lien was valid, despite noncompliance (§ 7-210(e)).
SurplusBalance held for delivery on demand (§ 7-210(f)).
Defective saleDamages; conversion if willful (§ 7-210(i)); lien lost by voluntary delivery (§ 7-209(e)).
CitationG.L. c. 106, §§ 7-209, 7-210.

Sources: c. 106, § 7-209 · c. 106, § 7-210

17. Carrier lien (UCC 7-307) — c. 106, § 7-307
AttributeRule
StatuteG.L. c. 106, § 7-307.
Who holds itA carrier, on goods covered by a bill of lading (or proceeds) in its possession.
Priority vs perfected security interestEffective against the consignor or person entitled for goods the carrier had to receive, absent notice of lack of authority; otherwise against the consignor and persons who permitted the bailor possession (§ 7-307(b)).
Amount / capStorage and transportation charges and preservation and sale expenses; against a purchaser of a negotiable bill, stated or tariff charges or a reasonable charge (§ 7-307(a)).
Court required?No: § 7-308(a) sale or the § 7-210(b) procedure (§ 7-308(g)).
Notice to ownerNotification to all persons known to claim an interest (§ 7-308(a)).
Notice to lienholdersSame (§ 7-308(a)).
Registry / division noticeNone prescribed.
PublicationNone for a § 7-308(a) sale; the § 7-210(b) advertisement if that procedure is used.
Waiting periodCommercially reasonable time after notification.
Sale methodPublic or private sale on commercially reasonable terms; carrier may buy (§ 7-308).
What the buyer takesA good-faith purchaser takes free of rights of persons against which the lien was valid, despite noncompliance (§ 7-308(d)).
SurplusBalance held for delivery on demand (§ 7-308(e)).
Defective saleDamages; conversion if willful (§ 7-308(h)); lien lost by voluntary delivery (§ 7-307(c)).
CitationG.L. c. 106, §§ 7-307, 7-308.

Sources: c. 106, § 7-307 · c. 106, § 7-308 · c. 106, § 7-210

18. Public warehouser’s lien on property removed in summary process — c. 239, § 4(e)
AttributeRule
StatuteG.L. c. 239, § 4.
Who holds itA licensed public warehouser that accepts a tenant’s property removed on a summary-process execution.
Priority vs perfected security interestNo statute ranks this lien against an earlier security interest; under c. 106, § 9-201(a) a security agreement is effective against purchasers and creditors, and the § 9-333 possessory-service rule does not reach storage imposed by the eviction statute only to the extent its charges comply with § 4; the statute adds no priority rule. Statutory application.
Amount / capLawful storage charges at rates filed with the Division of Occupational Licensure and not above fair market rates (§ 4(b), (e)).
Court required?No: after 6 months’ storage, enforcement under c. 106, § 7-210(b) (§ 4(e)).
Notice to ownerWarehouse receipt within 7 days stating the 6-month sale rule and auction publication; monthly statements of charges (§ 4(b), (d)); then the § 7-210(b) demand.
Notice to lienholdersThe § 7-210(b) notification to all persons known to claim an interest.
Registry / division noticeNone prescribed.
PublicationAs § 7-210(b)(5) requires, in the publication identified in the receipt (§ 4(d)).
Waiting periodAt least 6 months; the tenant may postpone sale 3 months by paying half the fees and costs (§ 4(e)).
Sale methodAuction under § 7-210(b); the tenant may buy items in bloc or parcels regardless of the sale terms (§ 4(f)).
What the buyer takesA good-faith purchaser takes free of rights of persons against which the lien was valid (c. 106, § 7-210(e)).
SurplusBalance held for delivery on demand (§ 4(e)).
Defective saleNoncompliance forfeits the lien (§ 4(e)); civil penalty up to USD 5,000 (§ 4(g)).
CitationG.L. c. 239, § 4; c. 106, § 7-210.

Sources: c. 239, § 4 · c. 106, § 7-210

19. Distrainor’s and pound keeper’s charges on impounded beasts — c. 49, §§ 27, 32
AttributeRule
StatuteG.L. c. 49, §§ 24-39.
Who holds itPound keepers and field drivers (fees and keeping) and persons who distrain beasts damaging their land (damages and feeding charges).
Priority vs perfected security interestNo statute ranks this lien against an earlier security interest; under c. 106, § 9-201(a) a security agreement is effective against purchasers and creditors, and the § 9-333 possessory-service rule does not reach damage claims and impounding fees, which are not ordinary-course services furnished with respect to the goods. Statutory application.
Amount / capFees, keeping expenses, the distrainor’s demanded damages and charges, advertising and costs (§§ 27, 32), as determined by two disinterested persons if disputed (§§ 35-36).
Court required?No: determination by two disinterested persons on a warrant from a justice of the peace or town clerk, then auction (§§ 36-37).
Notice to ownerWritten notice within 24 hours to an owner known and living within 6 miles (§ 33); otherwise posting within 48 hours (§ 34).
Notice to lienholdersNone prescribed.
Registry / division noticeNot applicable — Animals are not titled property.
PublicationIf no person is entitled to notice: posting in the town and two adjoining towns, and for beasts over USD 30 unclaimed 7 days, newspaper notice 3 weeks successively (§ 34); sale notice posted 24 hours (§ 37).
Waiting period14 days after notice or last publication before the determination (§ 36).
Sale methodAuction in the town where impounded (§ 37).
What the buyer takesNo free-and-clear clause; the buyer takes the owner’s interest, and a security interest continues in collateral after disposition unless the secured party authorized it (c. 106, § 9-315(a)(1)).
SurplusProceeds after damages, costs and charges deposited in the town treasury for the owner, claimable within 2 years (§ 38).
Defective saleIllegality may be raised by replevin (§ 41); no purchaser cure is stated.
CitationG.L. c. 49, §§ 24-41; c. 247, § 1.

Sources: c. 49, § 27 · c. 49, § 29 · c. 49, § 31 · c. 49, § 32 · c. 49, § 33 · c. 49, § 34 · c. 49, § 35 · c. 49, § 36 · c. 49, § 37 · c. 49, § 38 · c. 49, § 39

20. Presenting bank’s lien for expenses on goods after dishonor — c. 106, § 4-504(b)
AttributeRule
StatuteG.L. c. 106, § 4-504.
Who holds itA presenting bank that deals with goods after dishonor of a documentary draft without timely instructions.
Priority vs perfected security interestNo priority rule is stated; foreclosure is as an unpaid seller’s lien, whose resale passes title free of the original buyer’s rights only (§ 2-706(5)). Statutory application.
Amount / capReasonable expenses (§ 4-504(b)).
Court required?No: foreclosed like an unpaid seller’s lien by resale (§ 2-706).
Notice to ownerReasonable notification of a private resale (§ 2-706(3)).
Notice to lienholdersNone prescribed.
Registry / division noticeNone prescribed.
PublicationNone prescribed.
Waiting periodA reasonable time after seasonable request for instructions (§ 4-504(a)).
Sale methodPublic or private resale (§ 2-706).
What the buyer takesA good-faith resale purchaser takes free of the original buyer’s rights (§ 2-706(5)).
SurplusExpenses retained; balance follows the draft’s owner.
Defective saleDamages for a resale not commercially reasonable.
CitationG.L. c. 106, §§ 2-706, 4-504.

Sources: c. 106, § 4-504 · c. 106, § 2-706

Museum loans

21. Museum’s lien for conservation or disposal costs on loaned property — c. 200B, § 3(b)(1)
AttributeRule
StatuteG.L. c. 200B, § 3.
Who holds itA museum that applies conservation measures to, or disposes of, loaned or undocumented property under § 3(a), unless a written loan agreement provides otherwise.
Priority vs perfected security interestA possessory lien for services or materials furnished with respect to goods in the ordinary course of business has priority over a security interest unless its statute expressly provides otherwise (c. 106, § 9-333); Section 3 does not. Statutory application.
Amount / capThe costs incurred by the museum (§ 3(b)(1)).
Court required?No lien-specific procedure (‘may enforce a lien’); realized by suit and execution, or the museum may terminate the loan and acquire title after a year’s unanswered notice (§ 4).
Notice to ownerNotice to the lender within 30 days of an emergency disposal (§ 3(a)(2)(i)); otherwise as § 3 requires.
Notice to lienholdersNone prescribed.
Registry / division noticeNone prescribed; a titled vehicle sold on execution is retitled on proof of the involuntary transfer (c. 90D, § 17(a)).
PublicationExecution-sale notice: posting 48 hours in a public place in the town of sale or a newspaper notice (c. 235, § 37).
Waiting periodGoods seized on execution are kept at least 4 days and sold within 14 days (30 days where newspaper notice is requested) (c. 235, §§ 36, 38).
Sale methodPublic auction by the officer on execution (c. 235, § 36).
What the buyer takesThe execution buyer takes the debtor’s interest; c. 235 has no provision discharging senior liens, and a perfected security interest continues (c. 106, §§ 9-201(a), 9-315(a)(1)).
SurplusCharges and the execution paid, then later attaching or executing creditors in order of service, residue to the debtor (c. 235, §§ 43-44).
Defective saleNo purchaser cure is stated; an officer guilty of fraud in the sale or return is liable for five times actual damage (c. 235, § 42).
CitationG.L. c. 200B, §§ 3-4.

Sources: c. 200B, § 3 · c. 200B, § 4 · c. 106, § 9-333 · c. 235, § 29 · c. 235, § 31 · c. 235, § 36 · c. 235, § 37 · c. 235, § 38 · c. 235, § 41 · c. 235, § 42 · c. 235, § 43 · c. 235, § 44

Other possessory and statutory liens without a sale procedure

22. Consignee’s lien for advances on consigned merchandise — c. 104, § 2, c. 104, § 3
AttributeRule
StatuteG.L. c. 104, §§ 2-3 (one grant for advances on consigned merchandise stated for two entrustment situations, consolidated); § 6 preserves the consignee’s lien for shipment and care expenses.
Who holds itA consignee or factor that advanced money, merchandise or negotiable security on the faith of a consignment, without notice that the shipper lacked ownership (§§ 2-3).
Priority vs perfected security interestNo statute ranks this lien against an earlier security interest; under c. 106, § 9-201(a) a security agreement is effective against purchasers and creditors, and the § 9-333 possessory-service rule does not reach advances of money, which are not services furnished with respect to the goods. Statutory application.
Amount / capThe money, merchandise or security advanced (§§ 2-3).
Court required?No lien-specific procedure; the consignee holds the goods and, absent a power of sale, realizes the lien by suit and execution. The owner may recover the goods on tender (§ 6).
Notice to ownerNo lien-specific notice; ordinary process in the enforcement action.
Notice to lienholdersNone prescribed.
Registry / division noticeNone prescribed; a titled vehicle sold on execution is retitled on proof of the involuntary transfer (c. 90D, § 17(a)).
PublicationExecution-sale notice: posting 48 hours in a public place in the town of sale or a newspaper notice (c. 235, § 37).
Waiting periodGoods seized on execution are kept at least 4 days and sold within 14 days (30 days where newspaper notice is requested) (c. 235, §§ 36, 38).
Sale methodPublic auction by the officer on execution (c. 235, § 36).
What the buyer takesThe execution buyer takes the debtor’s interest; c. 235 has no provision discharging senior liens, and a perfected security interest continues (c. 106, §§ 9-201(a), 9-315(a)(1)).
SurplusCharges and the execution paid, then later attaching or executing creditors in order of service, residue to the debtor (c. 235, §§ 43-44).
Defective saleNo purchaser cure is stated; an officer guilty of fraud in the sale or return is liable for five times actual damage (c. 235, § 42).
CitationG.L. c. 104, §§ 2-3, 6.

Sources: c. 104, § 2 · c. 104, § 3 · c. 104, § 6 · c. 106, § 9-201

23. Pilot’s lien for pilotage fees — c. 103, § 17
AttributeRule
StatuteG.L. c. 103, § 17.
Who holds itA pilot, on the hull and appurtenances of a vessel liable for pilotage fees under c. 103.
Priority vs perfected security interestNo priority rule is stated; the lien lasts 60 days after the services; federal maritime law is outside this State layer.
Amount / capPilotage fees (§ 17).
Court required?Yes in effect: the lien ‘shall not be enforced until approved by the commissioners’ (§ 17), and no sale procedure is provided, so it is realized by suit and execution.
Notice to ownerNo lien-specific notice; ordinary process in the enforcement action.
Notice to lienholdersNone prescribed.
Registry / division noticeNone prescribed; a titled vehicle sold on execution is retitled on proof of the involuntary transfer (c. 90D, § 17(a)).
PublicationExecution-sale notice: posting 48 hours in a public place in the town of sale or a newspaper notice (c. 235, § 37).
Waiting periodGoods seized on execution are kept at least 4 days and sold within 14 days (30 days where newspaper notice is requested) (c. 235, §§ 36, 38).
Sale methodPublic auction by the officer on execution (c. 235, § 36).
What the buyer takesThe execution buyer takes the debtor’s interest; c. 235 has no provision discharging senior liens, and a perfected security interest continues (c. 106, §§ 9-201(a), 9-315(a)(1)).
SurplusCharges and the execution paid, then later attaching or executing creditors in order of service, residue to the debtor (c. 235, §§ 43-44).
Defective saleNo purchaser cure is stated; an officer guilty of fraud in the sale or return is liable for five times actual damage (c. 235, § 42).
CitationG.L. c. 103, § 17.

Sources: c. 103, § 17 · c. 235, § 29 · c. 235, § 31 · c. 235, § 36 · c. 235, § 37 · c. 235, § 38 · c. 235, § 41 · c. 235, § 42 · c. 235, § 43 · c. 235, § 44

24. Railroad’s lien for feeding transported animals — c. 272, § 81
AttributeRule
StatuteG.L. c. 272, § 81.
Who holds itA railroad corporation that feeds, waters and shelters animals unloaded in transit when the owner or custodian defaults.
Priority vs perfected security interestA possessory lien for services or materials furnished with respect to goods in the ordinary course of business has priority over a security interest unless its statute expressly provides otherwise (c. 106, § 9-333); Section 81 does not. Statutory application.
Amount / capFood, care and custody furnished (§ 81).
Court required?Yes: no lien-specific sale procedure is provided, so the lien is realized by suit, judgment and execution (c. 235, §§ 29-44).
Notice to ownerNo lien-specific notice; ordinary process in the enforcement action.
Notice to lienholdersNone prescribed.
Registry / division noticeNone prescribed; a titled vehicle sold on execution is retitled on proof of the involuntary transfer (c. 90D, § 17(a)).
PublicationExecution-sale notice: posting 48 hours in a public place in the town of sale or a newspaper notice (c. 235, § 37).
Waiting periodGoods seized on execution are kept at least 4 days and sold within 14 days (30 days where newspaper notice is requested) (c. 235, §§ 36, 38).
Sale methodPublic auction by the officer on execution (c. 235, § 36).
What the buyer takesThe execution buyer takes the debtor’s interest; c. 235 has no provision discharging senior liens, and a perfected security interest continues (c. 106, §§ 9-201(a), 9-315(a)(1)).
SurplusCharges and the execution paid, then later attaching or executing creditors in order of service, residue to the debtor (c. 235, §§ 43-44).
Defective saleNo purchaser cure is stated; an officer guilty of fraud in the sale or return is liable for five times actual damage (c. 235, § 42).
CitationG.L. c. 272, § 81.

Sources: c. 272, § 81 · c. 106, § 9-333 · c. 235, § 29 · c. 235, § 31 · c. 235, § 36 · c. 235, § 37 · c. 235, § 38 · c. 235, § 41 · c. 235, § 42 · c. 235, § 43 · c. 235, § 44

25. Arresting person’s lien for care of animals — c. 272, § 82
AttributeRule
StatuteG.L. c. 272, § 82.
Who holds itA person who arrests someone for animal-transport violations and cares for the animals until the owner takes charge (up to 60 days after notice).
Priority vs perfected security interestA possessory lien for services or materials furnished with respect to goods in the ordinary course of business has priority over a security interest unless its statute expressly provides otherwise (c. 106, § 9-333); Section 82 does not. Statutory application.
Amount / capExpense of care and provision (§ 82).
Court required?Yes: no lien-specific sale procedure is provided, so the lien is realized by suit, judgment and execution (c. 235, §§ 29-44).
Notice to ownerReasonable diligence to notify the owner of the arrest (§ 82).
Notice to lienholdersNone prescribed.
Registry / division noticeNone prescribed; a titled vehicle sold on execution is retitled on proof of the involuntary transfer (c. 90D, § 17(a)).
PublicationExecution-sale notice: posting 48 hours in a public place in the town of sale or a newspaper notice (c. 235, § 37).
Waiting periodGoods seized on execution are kept at least 4 days and sold within 14 days (30 days where newspaper notice is requested) (c. 235, §§ 36, 38).
Sale methodPublic auction by the officer on execution (c. 235, § 36).
What the buyer takesThe execution buyer takes the debtor’s interest; c. 235 has no provision discharging senior liens, and a perfected security interest continues (c. 106, §§ 9-201(a), 9-315(a)(1)).
SurplusCharges and the execution paid, then later attaching or executing creditors in order of service, residue to the debtor (c. 235, §§ 43-44).
Defective saleNo purchaser cure is stated; an officer guilty of fraud in the sale or return is liable for five times actual damage (c. 235, § 42).
CitationG.L. c. 272, § 82.

Sources: c. 272, § 82 · c. 106, § 9-333 · c. 235, § 29 · c. 235, § 31 · c. 235, § 36 · c. 235, § 37 · c. 235, § 38 · c. 235, § 41 · c. 235, § 42 · c. 235, § 43 · c. 235, § 44

UCC security interests arising by statute

26. Seller’s security interest reserved by shipment (statutory security interest) — c. 106, § 2-505(1)
AttributeRule
Statutec. 106, § 2-505(1); subject to Article 9 as the section states.
Who holds itA seller that procures a negotiable bill to its own order, or a nonnegotiable bill to itself or nominee, for identified goods.
Priority vs perfected security interestPriority over a conflicting security interest created by the debtor until the debtor obtains possession (§ 9-110(4)).
Amount / capThe price secured.
Court required?No: enforcement under the incorporated Article 2/2A resale or Article 9 rules.
Notice to ownerReasonable notification of a private resale (c. 106, § 2-706(3), as incorporated).
Notice to lienholdersOnly as the incorporated rule requires (c. 106, § 9-611 for Article 9 dispositions).
Registry / division noticeNone prescribed.
PublicationNone prescribed.
Waiting periodNo fixed period; reasonable notification.
Sale methodArticle 2 resale (§ 2-706).
What the buyer takesA good-faith resale purchaser takes free of the rights of the original buyer or lessee (c. 106, §§ 2-706(5), 2A-527(4)).
SurplusSeller not accountable for resale profit (§ 2-706(6)).
Defective saleDamages under the incorporated article for noncompliance.
Citationc. 106, § 2-505(1).

Sources: c. 106, § 2-505 · c. 106, § 9-110 · c. 106, § 2-706

27. Rejecting or revoking buyer’s security interest (statutory security interest) — c. 106, § 2-711(3)
AttributeRule
Statutec. 106, § 2-711(3); subject to Article 9 as the section states.
Who holds itA buyer who rightfully rejects or justifiably revokes acceptance, on goods in its possession or control.
Priority vs perfected security interestPriority over a conflicting security interest created by the debtor until the debtor obtains possession (§ 9-110(4)).
Amount / capPayments on the price and inspection, receipt, transport, care and custody expenses (§ 2-711(3)).
Court required?No: enforcement under the incorporated Article 2/2A resale or Article 9 rules.
Notice to ownerReasonable notification of a private resale (c. 106, § 2-706(3), as incorporated).
Notice to lienholdersOnly as the incorporated rule requires (c. 106, § 9-611 for Article 9 dispositions).
Registry / division noticeNone prescribed.
PublicationNone prescribed.
Waiting periodNo fixed period; reasonable notification.
Sale methodResale ‘in like manner as an aggrieved seller’ (§§ 2-711(3), 2-706).
What the buyer takesA good-faith resale purchaser takes free of the rights of the original buyer or lessee (c. 106, §§ 2-706(5), 2A-527(4)).
SurplusBuyer accounts for any excess over its security interest (§ 2-706(6)).
Defective saleDamages under the incorporated article for noncompliance.
Citationc. 106, § 2-711(3).

Sources: c. 106, § 2-711 · c. 106, § 9-110 · c. 106, § 2-706

28. Rejecting or revoking lessee’s security interest (statutory security interest) — c. 106, § 2A-508(5)
AttributeRule
Statutec. 106, § 2A-508(5); subject to Article 9 as the section states.
Who holds itA lessee who rightfully rejects or justifiably revokes acceptance, on goods in its possession or control.
Priority vs perfected security interestPriority over a conflicting security interest created by the debtor until the debtor obtains possession (§ 9-110(4)).
Amount / capRent and security paid and inspection, receipt, transport and care expenses (§ 2A-508(5)).
Court required?No: enforcement under the incorporated Article 2/2A resale or Article 9 rules.
Notice to ownerReasonable notification of a private resale (c. 106, § 2-706(3), as incorporated).
Notice to lienholdersOnly as the incorporated rule requires (c. 106, § 9-611 for Article 9 dispositions).
Registry / division noticeNone prescribed.
PublicationNone prescribed.
Waiting periodNo fixed period; reasonable notification.
Sale methodGood-faith, commercially reasonable disposition (§ 2A-508(5)).
What the buyer takesA good-faith buyer or sublessee from the disposition takes free of the original lease (§ 2A-527(4)).
SurplusLessee accounts for any excess (§ 2A-527(5)).
Defective saleDamages under the incorporated article for noncompliance.
Citationc. 106, § 2A-508(5).

Sources: c. 106, § 2A-508 · c. 106, § 9-110 · c. 106, § 2A-527

29. Collecting bank’s security interest in items (statutory security interest) — c. 106, § 4-210
AttributeRule
Statutec. 106, § 4-210; subject to Article 9 as the section states.
Who holds itA collecting bank, on an item, accompanying documents or proceeds, to the extent of credit withdrawn, available or advanced.
Priority vs perfected security interestPriority over conflicting perfected security interests in the item, documents or proceeds (§ 4-210(c)(3)).
Amount / capCredit withdrawn, applied, available or advanced (§ 4-210(a)).
Court required?No: enforcement under the incorporated Article 2/2A resale or Article 9 rules.
Notice to ownerArticle 9 notification only if goods or documents are disposed of (c. 106, § 9-611).
Notice to lienholdersOnly as the incorporated rule requires (c. 106, § 9-611 for Article 9 dispositions).
Registry / division noticeNone prescribed.
PublicationNone prescribed.
Waiting periodNo fixed period; reasonable notification.
Sale methodCollection; final settlement realizes the interest (§ 4-210(c)).
What the buyer takesA good-faith Article 9 transferee takes the debtor’s rights free of the foreclosed and subordinate interests (c. 106, § 9-617).
SurplusArticle 9 rules apply.
Defective saleDamages under the incorporated article for noncompliance.
Citationc. 106, § 4-210.

Sources: c. 106, § 4-210 · c. 106, § 9-617

30. Letter-of-credit issuer’s or nominated person’s security interest (statutory security interest) — c. 106, § 5-118
AttributeRule
Statutec. 106, § 5-118; subject to Article 9 as the section states.
Who holds itAn issuer or nominated person that honors or gives value for a presentation.
Priority vs perfected security interestPerfected without filing and, for tangible documents not held by the debtor, priority over conflicting security interests (§ 5-118(b)).
Amount / capValue given and not reimbursed (§ 5-118(b)).
Court required?No: enforcement under the incorporated Article 2/2A resale or Article 9 rules.
Notice to ownerArticle 9 notification (c. 106, § 9-611).
Notice to lienholdersOnly as the incorporated rule requires (c. 106, § 9-611 for Article 9 dispositions).
Registry / division noticeNone prescribed.
PublicationNone prescribed.
Waiting periodNo fixed period; reasonable notification.
Sale methodArticle 9 disposition.
What the buyer takesA good-faith Article 9 transferee takes the debtor’s rights free of the foreclosed and subordinate interests (c. 106, § 9-617).
SurplusArticle 9 rules apply.
Defective saleDamages under the incorporated article for noncompliance.
Citationc. 106, § 5-118.

Sources: c. 106, § 5-118 · c. 106, § 9-617

31. Securities intermediary’s purchase-price security interest (statutory security interest) — c. 106, § 9-206(a)
AttributeRule
Statutec. 106, § 9-206(a); subject to Article 9 as the section states.
Who holds itA securities intermediary that credits a financial asset before the buyer pays.
Priority vs perfected security interestArticle 9 investment-property priority rules apply.
Amount / capThe purchase price (§ 9-206(b)).
Court required?No: enforcement under the incorporated Article 2/2A resale or Article 9 rules.
Notice to ownerArticle 9 notification where required (c. 106, § 9-611).
Notice to lienholdersOnly as the incorporated rule requires (c. 106, § 9-611 for Article 9 dispositions).
Registry / division noticeNone prescribed.
PublicationNone prescribed.
Waiting periodNo fixed period; reasonable notification.
Sale methodArticle 9 disposition of the entitlement.
What the buyer takesA good-faith Article 9 transferee takes the debtor’s rights free of the foreclosed and subordinate interests (c. 106, § 9-617).
SurplusArticle 9 rules apply.
Defective saleDamages under the incorporated article for noncompliance.
Citationc. 106, § 9-206(a).

Sources: c. 106, § 9-206 · c. 106, § 9-617

32. Deliverer’s security interest in delivery-against-payment transfers (statutory security interest) — c. 106, § 9-206(c)
AttributeRule
Statutec. 106, § 9-206(c); subject to Article 9 as the section states.
Who holds itA person delivering a certificated security or written financial asset between dealers under a delivery-against-payment agreement.
Priority vs perfected security interestPerfected on attachment (§ 9-309(9)); Article 9 priority rules otherwise.
Amount / capPayment due for the delivery (§ 9-206(d)).
Court required?No: enforcement under the incorporated Article 2/2A resale or Article 9 rules.
Notice to ownerArticle 9 notification (c. 106, § 9-611).
Notice to lienholdersOnly as the incorporated rule requires (c. 106, § 9-611 for Article 9 dispositions).
Registry / division noticeNone prescribed.
PublicationNone prescribed.
Waiting periodNo fixed period; reasonable notification.
Sale methodArticle 9 disposition.
What the buyer takesA good-faith Article 9 transferee takes the debtor’s rights free of the foreclosed and subordinate interests (c. 106, § 9-617).
SurplusArticle 9 rules apply.
Defective saleDamages under the incorporated article for noncompliance.
Citationc. 106, § 9-206(c).

Sources: c. 106, § 9-206 · c. 106, § 9-617

Liens on recoveries and awards

33. Hospital and health-plan lien on injury recoveries — c. 111, § 70A
AttributeRule
StatuteG.L. c. 111, §§ 70A-70C.
Who holds itHospitals (and HMOs and medical or dental service corporations for benefits paid) that treated a person injured in an accident not covered by c. 152.
Priority vs perfected security interestOperates on the net recovery only; the attorney’s lien takes precedence (§ 70A).
Amount / capReasonable and necessary charges, not above ward rates (§ 70A).
Court required?No sale; the charge is satisfied from the fund, recovery or account it attaches to.
Notice to ownerCertified-mail notice to the injured person, attorney, alleged tortfeasor and insurer before judgment or settlement (§ 70B).
Notice to lienholdersNot applicable beyond § 70B.
Registry / division noticeNot applicable — Not applicable: the grant attaches to money, a recovery, an account or an interest, not titled goods.
PublicationNot applicable — No sale or publication is created by this grant.
Waiting periodNot applicable — No sale is authorized by this grant.
Sale methodNot applicable — Satisfaction by payment, setoff or court order; no auction is created.
What the buyer takesNo buyer channel is created by this grant.
SurplusLimited to the secured amount.
Defective saleA payor with notice who pays over the recovery is liable up to the net amount; action within 1 year (§ 70C).
CitationG.L. c. 111, §§ 70A-70C.

Sources: c. 111, § 70A · c. 111, § 70B · c. 111, § 70C

34. Attorney’s lien for fees — c. 221, § 50
AttributeRule
StatuteG.L. c. 221, § 50.
Who holds itAn attorney who appears for a client in a court or agency proceeding, on the cause of action, judgment and proceeds.
Priority vs perfected security interestApplies to the claim, judgment and proceeds; takes precedence over the hospital lien (c. 111, § 70A) and limits execution set-off (c. 235, § 27).
Amount / capReasonable fees and expenses.
Court required?Yes: the court may determine and enforce the lien on request (§ 50).
Notice to ownerNone prescribed.
Notice to lienholdersNone prescribed.
Registry / division noticeNot applicable — Not applicable: the grant attaches to money, a recovery, an account or an interest, not titled goods.
PublicationNot applicable — No sale or publication is created by this grant.
Waiting periodNot applicable — No sale is authorized by this grant.
Sale methodNot applicable — Satisfaction by payment, setoff or court order; no auction is created.
What the buyer takesNo buyer channel is created by this grant.
SurplusLimited to the secured amount.
Defective saleDetermined and enforced by the court (§ 50).
CitationG.L. c. 221, § 50.

Sources: c. 221, § 50 · c. 235, § 27

35. Insurer and agency lien on workers’ compensation awards — c. 152, § 46A
AttributeRule
StatuteG.L. c. 152, § 46A.
Who holds itAccident and health insurers, service corporations, the Department of Transitional Assistance, MassHealth and employers that paid benefits for a compensable injury, and the IV-D agency for child support.
Priority vs perfected security interestAgainst the award or lump sum only; child support is paid first (§ 46A).
Amount / capBenefits paid, never more than the award (§ 46A).
Court required?No sale; the charge is satisfied from the fund, recovery or account it attaches to.
Notice to ownerClaim filed with the Department of Industrial Accidents (§ 46A).
Notice to lienholdersNot applicable.
Registry / division noticeNot applicable — Not applicable: the grant attaches to money, a recovery, an account or an interest, not titled goods.
PublicationNot applicable — No sale or publication is created by this grant.
Waiting periodNot applicable — No sale is authorized by this grant.
Sale methodNot applicable — Satisfaction by payment, setoff or court order; no auction is created.
What the buyer takesNo buyer channel is created by this grant.
SurplusLimited to the secured amount.
Defective saleThe reviewing board fixes a fair amount if parties disagree; payment discharges the lien (§ 46A).
CitationG.L. c. 152, § 46A.

Sources: c. 152, § 46A

Tax and government liens

36. State tax lien (Department of Revenue) — c. 62C, § 50
AttributeRule
StatuteG.L. c. 62C, § 50; levy and sale §§ 53-60.
Who holds itThe Commonwealth, on all property and rights to property of a person who neglects to pay tax after demand.
Priority vs perfected security interestNot valid against a mortgagee, pledgee, purchaser or judgment creditor until notice is filed (personal property: in the Article 9 filing office) (§ 50(b)); securities purchasers without notice are protected (§ 50(c)).
Amount / capTax, interest, additions and costs; 10 years or longer as IRC § 6322 allows (§ 50(a)).
Court required?No: levy 10 days after demand, including distraint and seizure, with power to sell (§ 53); a civil action is an alternative (§ 50(e)).
Notice to ownerWritten notice of the sum demanded and an account of property seized (§ 56(a)).
Notice to lienholdersNone individually; public notice (§ 56(b)).
Registry / division noticeThe certificate of sale is notice and authority to the Registrar to record the transfer (§ 60(a)(5)).
PublicationNewspaper in the county; posting at the town hall and two other public places only if no county newspaper (§ 56(b)).
Waiting periodSale 10 to 40 days after public notice; adjournments not over one month in all (§ 56(d)).
Sale methodSale at or above a minimum price the Commissioner sets, else purchased for the Commonwealth (§ 56(e)(1)); perishables appraised and sold (§ 57).
What the buyer takesCertificate of sale transfers the delinquent’s interest and discharges liens over which the Commonwealth’s lien had priority (§ 60(a), (c)); senior interests survive.
SurplusNot stated in §§ 56-60 beyond application to tax and expenses; personal property may be redeemed only before sale (§ 58(a)).
Defective saleThe certificate is conclusive evidence of regularity (§ 60(a)(1)); defaulting bidders forfeit amounts paid on resale (§ 56(e)(3)).
CitationG.L. c. 62C, §§ 50, 53, 56-60.

Sources: c. 62C, § 50 · c. 62C, § 53 · c. 62C, § 56 · c. 62C, § 57 · c. 62C, § 58 · c. 62C, § 59 · c. 62C, § 60

37. State lien on assets of a corporation transferring its business — c. 62C, § 51
AttributeRule
StatuteG.L. c. 62C, §§ 51-52.
Who holds itThe Commonwealth, on all Massachusetts assets of a business corporation that sells substantially all its assets outside the ordinary course without the 5-day notice, returns and payment (§ 51).
Priority vs perfected security interestEffective immediately before the transfer for the Commonwealth’s exclusive benefit (§ 51); does not apply to good-faith security transfers (§ 51). No ranking against earlier perfected interests is stated.
Amount / capTaxes due to the date of transfer; terminates within 3 years (§ 51).
Court required?No for personal property: enforced under §§ 53-64 without the 10-day demand period (§ 51).
Notice to ownerAs in a § 56 levy sale.
Notice to lienholdersPublic notice under § 56(b).
Registry / division noticeCertificate of sale authorizes retitling (§ 60(a)(5)).
PublicationAs § 56(b).
Waiting periodAs § 56(d).
Sale methodLevy sale under § 56.
What the buyer takesAs a § 60 certificate of sale.
SurplusAs in a § 56 sale.
Defective saleA written waiver is conclusive that the lien never arose or ended (§§ 51-52); the section excludes transfers by receivers, ABC assignees, bankruptcy trustees and public officers under judicial process (§ 51).
CitationG.L. c. 62C, §§ 51-52, 53, 56, 60.

Sources: c. 62C, § 51 · c. 62C, § 52 · c. 62C, § 53 · c. 62C, § 56 · c. 62C, § 60

38. Massachusetts estate tax lien — c. 65C, § 14
AttributeRule
StatuteG.L. c. 65C, § 14.
Who holds itThe Commonwealth, on the decedent’s Massachusetts gross estate for 10 years.
Priority vs perfected security interestDivested from property sold or disposed of for value by a person entitled, attaching to proceeds (§ 14(e)); not valid against security purchasers without notice (§ 14(c)).
Amount / capThe estate tax.
Court required?No sale procedure; the lien shifts to proceeds of authorized dispositions.
Notice to ownerNone prescribed.
Notice to lienholdersNone prescribed.
Registry / division noticeNot applicable — Not applicable: the grant attaches to money, a recovery, an account or an interest, not titled goods.
PublicationNot applicable — No sale or publication is created by this grant.
Waiting periodNot applicable — No sale is authorized by this grant.
Sale methodNot applicable — Satisfaction by payment, setoff or court order; no auction is created.
What the buyer takesNo buyer channel is created by this grant.
SurplusLimited to the secured amount.
Defective saleReleased or discharged by the Commissioner’s certificate (§ 14(d)).
CitationG.L. c. 65C, § 14.

Sources: c. 65C, § 14

39. Child support lien — c. 119A, § 6(b)
AttributeRule
StatuteG.L. c. 119A, § 6(b).
Who holds itThe obligee (enforced by the IV-D agency), on all of the obligor’s property once recorded.
Priority vs perfected security interestThe perfected lien is not subordinate to any recorded lien except one perfected earlier (§ 6(b)(3)).
Amount / capUnpaid child support, including future accruals; 10 years from perfection, renewable (§ 6(b)(1), (5)).
Court required?No: after the 30-day notice period the IV-D agency may levy; for tangible personal property it proceeds under c. 62C, §§ 56, 58-60 (§ 6(b)(6)); civil action alternative (§ 6(b)(9)).
Notice to ownerWritten notice of unpaid support (§ 6(b)(2)) and notice of any lien, levy or seizure (§ 6(b)(10)).
Notice to lienholdersNone individually; filing with the state secretary, Registrar or other lien office (§ 6(b)(3)).
Registry / division noticeNotice of the lien may be filed with the Registrar of Motor Vehicles (§ 6(b)(3)).
PublicationAs c. 62C, § 56(b).
Waiting period30 days after notice (§ 6(b)(2), (6)), then the c. 62C, § 56 period.
Sale methodLevy sale as under c. 62C, § 56.
What the buyer takesAs a c. 62C, § 60 certificate of sale; the agency takes rights remaining after superior perfected liens (§ 6(b)(6)).
SurplusRights to property remaining after superior perfected liens (§ 6(b)(6)).
Defective saleAdministrative and judicial review (§ 17) is the obligor’s remedy; no purchaser cure is stated.
CitationG.L. c. 119A, § 6; c. 62C, §§ 56, 58-60.

Sources: c. 119A, § 6 · c. 62C, § 56 · c. 62C, § 58 · c. 62C, § 59 · c. 62C, § 60

40. Lien for repayment of fraudulently obtained public assistance — c. 18, § 29(a)
AttributeRule
StatuteG.L. c. 18, § 29.
Who holds itThe Commonwealth (Bureau of Special Investigations), on all property of an obligor who agreed or was ordered to repay.
Priority vs perfected security interestNot valid against a mortgagee, pledgee, purchaser or judgment creditor until notice is filed (personal property: with the state secretary) (§ 29(a)(2)).
Amount / capThe repayment with interest; 6 years, renewable (§ 29(a)(1)).
Court required?No: levy and sale under cc. 235 and 236 (§ 29(b)), or a civil action (§ 29(c)).
Notice to ownerWritten notice of the lien, levy or seizure (§ 29(d)).
Notice to lienholdersNone prescribed.
Registry / division noticeNone prescribed; a titled vehicle sold on execution is retitled on proof of the involuntary transfer (c. 90D, § 17(a)).
PublicationExecution-sale notice: posting 48 hours in a public place in the town of sale or a newspaper notice (c. 235, § 37).
Waiting periodGoods seized on execution are kept at least 4 days and sold within 14 days (30 days where newspaper notice is requested) (c. 235, §§ 36, 38).
Sale methodPublic auction by the officer on execution (c. 235, § 36).
What the buyer takesThe execution buyer takes the debtor’s interest; c. 235 has no provision discharging senior liens, and a perfected security interest continues (c. 106, §§ 9-201(a), 9-315(a)(1)).
SurplusCharges and the execution paid, then later attaching or executing creditors in order of service, residue to the debtor (c. 235, §§ 43-44).
Defective saleNo purchaser cure is stated; an officer guilty of fraud in the sale or return is liable for five times actual damage (c. 235, § 42).
CitationG.L. c. 18, § 29.

Sources: c. 18, § 29 · c. 235, § 29 · c. 235, § 31 · c. 235, § 36 · c. 235, § 37 · c. 235, § 38 · c. 235, § 41 · c. 235, § 42 · c. 235, § 43 · c. 235, § 44

41. Unemployment contribution lien — c. 151A, § 16
AttributeRule
StatuteG.L. c. 151A, §§ 15-16.
Who holds itThe Department of Unemployment Assistance (Commonwealth), on all of an employer’s property.
Priority vs perfected security interest’Subordinate … to claims for unpaid wages and prior recorded liens’; not valid against later good-faith purchasers, mortgagees or attaching creditors until notice is recorded (personal property: with the city or town clerk) (§ 16).
Amount / capJudgments and overdue contributions with interest or penalties; terminates in 10 years (20 for judgments) (§ 16).
Court required?Yes: civil action to enforce the lien (§ 16), or execution on a filed certificate with no exemption allowed (§ 15).
Notice to ownerNo lien-specific notice; ordinary process in the enforcement action.
Notice to lienholdersNone prescribed.
Registry / division noticeNone prescribed; a titled vehicle sold on execution is retitled on proof of the involuntary transfer (c. 90D, § 17(a)).
PublicationExecution-sale notice: posting 48 hours in a public place in the town of sale or a newspaper notice (c. 235, § 37).
Waiting periodGoods seized on execution are kept at least 4 days and sold within 14 days (30 days where newspaper notice is requested) (c. 235, §§ 36, 38).
Sale methodPublic auction by the officer on execution (c. 235, § 36).
What the buyer takesThe execution buyer takes the debtor’s interest; c. 235 has no provision discharging senior liens, and a perfected security interest continues (c. 106, §§ 9-201(a), 9-315(a)(1)).
SurplusCharges and the execution paid, then later attaching or executing creditors in order of service, residue to the debtor (c. 235, §§ 43-44).
Defective saleNo purchaser cure is stated; an officer guilty of fraud in the sale or return is liable for five times actual damage (c. 235, § 42).
CitationG.L. c. 151A, §§ 15-16.

Sources: c. 151A, § 15 · c. 151A, § 16 · c. 235, § 29 · c. 235, § 31 · c. 235, § 36 · c. 235, § 37 · c. 235, § 38 · c. 235, § 41 · c. 235, § 42 · c. 235, § 43 · c. 235, § 44

42. Workers’ compensation stop-work penalty and trust-fund lien — c. 152, § 25C(8)
AttributeRule
StatuteG.L. c. 152, § 25C(8).
Who holds itThe Department of Industrial Accidents (Commonwealth), on all of the employer’s property.
Priority vs perfected security interestSubordinate to unpaid wages and prior recorded liens; not valid against later good-faith purchasers or attaching creditors until notice is recorded (personal property: with the city or town clerk) (§ 25C(8)).
Amount / capJudgments for trust-fund reimbursement and stop-work penalties (§ 25C(8)).
Court required?Yes: no lien-specific sale procedure is provided, so the lien is realized by suit, judgment and execution (c. 235, §§ 29-44).
Notice to ownerNo lien-specific notice; ordinary process in the enforcement action.
Notice to lienholdersNone prescribed.
Registry / division noticeNone prescribed; a titled vehicle sold on execution is retitled on proof of the involuntary transfer (c. 90D, § 17(a)).
PublicationExecution-sale notice: posting 48 hours in a public place in the town of sale or a newspaper notice (c. 235, § 37).
Waiting periodGoods seized on execution are kept at least 4 days and sold within 14 days (30 days where newspaper notice is requested) (c. 235, §§ 36, 38).
Sale methodPublic auction by the officer on execution (c. 235, § 36).
What the buyer takesThe execution buyer takes the debtor’s interest; c. 235 has no provision discharging senior liens, and a perfected security interest continues (c. 106, §§ 9-201(a), 9-315(a)(1)).
SurplusCharges and the execution paid, then later attaching or executing creditors in order of service, residue to the debtor (c. 235, §§ 43-44).
Defective saleNo purchaser cure is stated; an officer guilty of fraud in the sale or return is liable for five times actual damage (c. 235, § 42).
CitationG.L. c. 152, § 25C(8).

Sources: c. 152, § 25C · c. 235, § 29 · c. 235, § 31 · c. 235, § 36 · c. 235, § 37 · c. 235, § 38 · c. 235, § 41 · c. 235, § 42 · c. 235, § 43 · c. 235, § 44

43. Environmental response-cost lien — c. 21E, § 13, c. 21K, § 8
AttributeRule
StatuteG.L. c. 21E, § 13 and c. 21K, § 8 — the same response-liability lien for two programs, consolidated.
Who holds itThe Commonwealth, on property (including personal property and vessels) of persons liable, once a statement of claim is recorded or filed.
Priority vs perfected security interestFor the site described, priority over encumbrances previously recorded (except housing); for other personal property, the Article 9 priority rules (c. 21E, § 13; c. 21K, § 8).
Amount / capThe liability with 12% interest.
Court required?Yes: action to enforce or foreclose by the statutory deadline; for property held by a secured lender, disposition under Article 9 Part 6 (c. 21E, § 13).
Notice to ownerStatement of claim recorded or filed (personal property: under Article 9).
Notice to lienholdersFiling gives notice; none individually.
Registry / division noticeNone prescribed.
PublicationAs the court orders, or the Article 9 rules.
Waiting periodEnforcement deadline in c. 21E, § 11A.
Sale methodCourt foreclosure, or Article 9 disposition for secured-lender property (c. 21E, § 13).
What the buyer takesUnder the court’s order, or the Article 9 transferee rule (c. 106, § 9-617).
SurplusAs the court orders or Article 9 provides.
Defective saleLien dissolved if no enforcement action by the deadline (c. 21E, § 13).
CitationG.L. c. 21E, § 13; c. 21K, § 8.

Sources: c. 21E, § 13 · c. 21K, § 8 · c. 106, § 9-610 · c. 106, § 9-617

44. Retail electric supplier alternative-compliance-payment lien — c. 21N, § 12
AttributeRule
StatuteG.L. c. 21N, § 12.
Who holds itThe Department of Environmental Protection, on all property of an indebted retail electric supplier.
Priority vs perfected security interestNot perfected against mortgagees, pledgees, purchasers or creditors until notice is filed (personal property: Article 9 filing office) (§ 12(b)).
Amount / capThe payment, interest and penalties; 10 years, refileable (§ 12(a)).
Court required?Yes: civil action in Superior Court to collect or enforce the lien (§ 12(c)).
Notice to ownerNo lien-specific notice; ordinary process in the enforcement action.
Notice to lienholdersNone prescribed.
Registry / division noticeNone prescribed; a titled vehicle sold on execution is retitled on proof of the involuntary transfer (c. 90D, § 17(a)).
PublicationExecution-sale notice: posting 48 hours in a public place in the town of sale or a newspaper notice (c. 235, § 37).
Waiting periodGoods seized on execution are kept at least 4 days and sold within 14 days (30 days where newspaper notice is requested) (c. 235, §§ 36, 38).
Sale methodPublic auction by the officer on execution (c. 235, § 36).
What the buyer takesThe execution buyer takes the debtor’s interest; c. 235 has no provision discharging senior liens, and a perfected security interest continues (c. 106, §§ 9-201(a), 9-315(a)(1)).
SurplusCharges and the execution paid, then later attaching or executing creditors in order of service, residue to the debtor (c. 235, §§ 43-44).
Defective saleNo purchaser cure is stated; an officer guilty of fraud in the sale or return is liable for five times actual damage (c. 235, § 42).
CitationG.L. c. 21N, § 12.

Sources: c. 21N, § 12 · c. 235, § 29 · c. 235, § 31 · c. 235, § 36 · c. 235, § 37 · c. 235, § 38 · c. 235, § 41 · c. 235, § 42 · c. 235, § 43 · c. 235, § 44

45. Commonwealth lien for nursing-home receivership expenditures — c. 111, § 72Q
AttributeRule
StatuteG.L. c. 111, § 72Q.
Who holds itThe Commonwealth, for expenditures under § 72O, on the facility building, land and fixtures, equipment or goods used in its operation.
Priority vs perfected security interestPrior to fraudulent mortgages or liens and to mortgages or liens of insiders, controlling persons or related parties (§ 72Q); no stated priority over other perfected security interests.
Amount / capExpenditures under § 72O.
Court required?Yes: no lien-specific sale procedure is provided, so the lien is realized by suit, judgment and execution (c. 235, §§ 29-44).
Notice to ownerThe receiver files notice of the lien (§ 72Q).
Notice to lienholdersNone prescribed.
Registry / division noticeNone prescribed; a titled vehicle sold on execution is retitled on proof of the involuntary transfer (c. 90D, § 17(a)).
PublicationExecution-sale notice: posting 48 hours in a public place in the town of sale or a newspaper notice (c. 235, § 37).
Waiting periodGoods seized on execution are kept at least 4 days and sold within 14 days (30 days where newspaper notice is requested) (c. 235, §§ 36, 38).
Sale methodPublic auction by the officer on execution (c. 235, § 36).
What the buyer takesThe execution buyer takes the debtor’s interest; c. 235 has no provision discharging senior liens, and a perfected security interest continues (c. 106, §§ 9-201(a), 9-315(a)(1)).
SurplusCharges and the execution paid, then later attaching or executing creditors in order of service, residue to the debtor (c. 235, §§ 43-44).
Defective saleNo purchaser cure is stated; an officer guilty of fraud in the sale or return is liable for five times actual damage (c. 235, § 42).
CitationG.L. c. 111, § 72Q.

Sources: c. 111, § 72Q · c. 235, § 29 · c. 235, § 31 · c. 235, § 36 · c. 235, § 37 · c. 235, § 38 · c. 235, § 41 · c. 235, § 42 · c. 235, § 43 · c. 235, § 44

Judicial and charging liens

46. Attachment and execution-seizure lien — c. 223, § 42, c. 235, § 47
AttributeRule
StatuteG.L. c. 223, § 42 (attached property ‘held as security to satisfy such judgment’) and c. 235, § 47 (seized property ‘shall remain bound’).
Who holds itA plaintiff whose writ of attachment, or a creditor whose execution, is levied on the debtor’s personal property.
Priority vs perfected security interestEncumbered goods may be attached ‘as if unencumbered’ only if the creditor pays or tenders the secured amount within 10 days after the secured party’s demand; otherwise the attachment dissolves (c. 223, §§ 74-75); a lien creditor primes only unperfected security interests (c. 106, § 9-317(a)(2)).
Amount / capThe claim as reduced to judgment, interest and costs.
Court required?Yes: writ of attachment and execution on a judgment.
Notice to ownerNo lien-specific notice; ordinary process in the enforcement action.
Notice to lienholdersNone prescribed.
Registry / division noticeNone prescribed; a titled vehicle sold on execution is retitled on proof of the involuntary transfer (c. 90D, § 17(a)).
PublicationExecution-sale notice: posting 48 hours in a public place in the town of sale or a newspaper notice (c. 235, § 37).
Waiting periodGoods seized on execution are kept at least 4 days and sold within 14 days (30 days where newspaper notice is requested) (c. 235, §§ 36, 38).
Sale methodPublic auction by the officer on execution (c. 235, § 36).
What the buyer takesThe execution buyer takes the debtor’s interest; c. 235 has no provision discharging senior liens, and a perfected security interest continues (c. 106, §§ 9-201(a), 9-315(a)(1)).
SurplusCharges and the execution paid, then later attaching or executing creditors in order of service, residue to the debtor (c. 235, §§ 43-44).
Defective saleNo purchaser cure is stated; an officer guilty of fraud in the sale or return is liable for five times actual damage (c. 235, § 42).
CitationG.L. c. 223, §§ 42, 74-83; c. 235, §§ 36-47.

Sources: c. 223, § 42 · c. 223, § 74 · c. 223, § 75 · c. 223, § 77 · c. 235, § 47 · c. 235, § 29 · c. 235, § 31 · c. 235, § 36 · c. 235, § 37 · c. 235, § 38 · c. 235, § 41 · c. 235, § 42 · c. 235, § 43 · c. 235, § 44

47. LLC charging order — c. 156C, § 40
AttributeRule
StatuteG.L. c. 156C, § 40.
Who holds itA judgment creditor of an LLC member.
Priority vs perfected security interestCharges the member’s LLC interest; the creditor has only an assignee’s rights (§ 40).
Amount / capThe unsatisfied judgment with interest.
Court required?Yes: court charging order.
Notice to ownerOn application to the court.
Notice to lienholdersNone prescribed.
Registry / division noticeNot applicable — Not applicable: the grant attaches to money, a recovery, an account or an interest, not titled goods.
PublicationNot applicable — No sale or publication is created by this grant.
Waiting periodNot applicable — No sale is authorized by this grant.
Sale methodNot applicable — Satisfaction by payment, setoff or court order; no auction is created.
What the buyer takesNo buyer channel is created by this grant.
SurplusLimited to the secured amount.
Defective saleSection 40 neither authorizes nor bars foreclosure; no sale procedure is created.
CitationG.L. c. 156C, §§ 39-41.

Sources: c. 156C, § 39 · c. 156C, § 40 · c. 156C, § 41

48. Partnership charging order — c. 108A, § 28
AttributeRule
StatuteG.L. c. 108A, § 28.
Who holds itA judgment creditor of a partner.
Priority vs perfected security interestNot ranked; charges the partner’s interest (§ 28(1)).
Amount / capThe unsatisfied judgment with interest.
Court required?Yes: Superior Court charging order, receiver of profits, and any sale the court directs (§ 28).
Notice to ownerOn application to the court.
Notice to lienholdersNone prescribed.
Registry / division noticeNot applicable — Partnership interests are not titled.
PublicationAs the court directs.
Waiting periodAs the court directs.
Sale methodCourt-directed sale of the charged interest (§ 28(2)).
What the buyer takesThe charged interest, which gives only an assignee’s profit rights (§ 27); purchase by partners does not dissolve the partnership (§ 28(2)).
SurplusAs the court orders.
Defective saleRedemption before foreclosure (§ 28(2)).
CitationG.L. c. 108A, §§ 27-28.

Sources: c. 108A, § 27 · c. 108A, § 28

UCC Article 9 — Massachusetts variations

  • Part 6 is uniform: disposition, notification (including to filed secured parties for non-consumer goods), redemption before disposition and transferee rights; a good-faith transferee takes free of the security interest and subordinate liens even if the secured party failed to comply. c. 106, §§ 9-611, 9-617, 9-623
  • The deficiency rules of 9-626(a) are limited to non-consumer transactions; the court decides the rule for consumer transactions. c. 106, § 9-626 Article 9 yields to Massachusetts consumer statutes. c. 106, § 9-201(b)-(c)
  • Consumer overlays. Before proceeding against collateral the creditor must send a right-to-cure notice at least 10 days after default giving 21 days to cure; self-help repossession only for a material default without force, breach of the peace or entry on the debtor’s property; redemption within 20 days after repossession; no deficiency on unpaid balances of USD 2,000 or less; larger deficiencies measured against fair market value; police notice within one hour of a vehicle repossession. c. 255B, §§ 20A-20C; c. 255, §§ 13I-13J See williams-v-american-honda-finance-2018.

12.4 Titles after a forced sale

Motor vehicles (Registrar of Motor Vehicles)

ChannelDocumentSource
Execution, court or lien saleLast title if available, proof of the transfer, application in the Registrar’s formc. 90D, § 17(a)
DOR levy saleThe Commissioner’s certificate of sale, which voids the prior titlec. 62C, § 60(a)(5)
Repossession by a lienholder named on the titleLast title, application and the lienholder’s affidavit that the vehicle was repossessed and the owner’s interest lawfully terminated or sold; a lienholder holding for resale need not retitlec. 90D, § 17(b)
  • Surviving liens. A title issued after an involuntary transfer “is not conclusive upon the rights of an owner or lienholder named in the old certificate.” c. 90D, § 17(c) Perfection on titled vehicles is by title application and is exclusive, except for dealer inventory. c. 90D, §§ 21, 26; c. 106, § 9-311(d)
  • Salvage. Insurers acquiring total-loss vehicles surrender the title within 10 days and apply for a salvage title; such vehicles may not be titled or registered until § 20D is met; insurers and Class 2/3 dealers holding vehicles abandoned over 30 days may apply after two written attempts to reach owner and lienholder. c. 90D, § 20

Vessels

  • Threshold. A “titled motorboat” is a machinery-propelled vessel 14 feet or longer without a federal marine document; no interest is acquired until a certificate issues in the acquirer’s name. c. 90B, § 36
  • Involuntary transfer. On transfer by operation of law (including execution sale), the transferee files proof and an application within 30 days; a repossessing lienholder holding for resale must retitle. c. 90B, § 36(i) Security interests in titled motorboats are perfected by delivery to the division. c. 90B, § 36(m)
  • Federal documentation. Documented vessels are outside the title and numbering systems. c. 90B, § 2 See uscg-national-vessel-documentation-center.

Aircraft

  • State registration exists: operators register the federal aircraft certificate with the aeronautics commission; fees are in lieu of all personal property taxes on aircraft. c. 90, § 49 Liens are filed with the FAA Aircraft Registry (12.3). See faa-aircraft-registry.

Titled equipment and trailers

  • No title is needed for trailers of 3,000 pounds gross weight or less, special mobile equipment, implements of husbandry or manufactured homes. c. 90D, § 2 Search UCC filings for such equipment (see equipment-and-machinery).

12.5 Businesses and business interests

  • Receivership. No general commercial receivership act (catchline scan). In a judicial dissolution the court may appoint receivers who may sell “at a public or private sale, if authorized by the court”; the appointing court has exclusive jurisdiction. c. 156D, § 14.32 Receivers may also be appointed for dissolved corporations or corporations with unsatisfied executions, paying debts ratably. c. 156B, §§ 104-106 Appointment within 4 months dissolves earlier attachments unless the court continues them. c. 223, § 130
  • Assignment for the benefit of creditors. A common-law trust: a trustee’s good-faith acts converting the assigned property stand despite later insolvency proceedings. c. 203, § 40 ABC sales are outside auctioneer licensing. c. 100, § 11
  • LLC charging orders. The creditor “has only the rights of an assignee”; exemptions still apply. c. 156C, § 40 Assignees get economic rights only, absent member approval or operating-agreement procedure. c. 156C, §§ 39, 41
  • Partnership charging orders. The court may appoint a receiver of the partner’s profits; the interest may be redeemed before foreclosure or purchased when the court directs a sale, without dissolution. c. 108A, § 28
  • Bulk sales. The published c. 106 contains no Article 6.
  • Tax successor liability. A successor to a vendor that sells out its business or stock of goods must withhold enough of the price for sales and use tax until a Commissioner’s certificate; a purchaser who fails to withhold is personally liable up to the purchase price; the Commissioner must answer within 90 days or the purchaser is released; the certificate excludes Employment Security Fund obligations. c. 62C, § 44
  • Liquor licences are “transferable only as provided in this chapter”: transfer between persons requires licensing-authority approval (appeal to the commission); a receiver or bankruptcy trustee may operate under the licence until it ends; a licence may be pledged only with local and commission approval. c. 138, § 23
  • Auctioneers. Anyone acting as auctioneer must be licensed and collects sales tax; sheriffs, collectors, lienholders, ABC assignees and court-ordered sales are exempt, but their agents are not. c. 100, §§ 2, 8, 11

12.6 Taxes when buying

AssetRuleSource
General rate6.25% sales tax; 6.25% use taxc. 64H, § 2; c. 64I, § 2
Vehicles and trailersPurchaser pays the Registrar; for non-dealer sales the base is the greater of price or clean trade-in value; no registration until the tax is paidc. 64I, §§ 4, 26; c. 64H, § 25
Casual and forced salesThe casual-sale exemption does not exempt vehicles, trailers, boats or airplanes from use tax; non-dealer purchases are taxable except from a spouse, parent, sibling or child; no forced-sale exemptionc. 64H, § 6(c); c. 64I, § 7(b)
Vessels6.25% use tax on non-dealer purchases; no cap statedc. 64I, §§ 2, 7
AircraftExempt (sales and use), with repair partsc. 64H, § 6(uu)-(vv); c. 64I, § 7(d)-(e)
Equipment and business assets6.25%; isolated sales by non-vendors exempt; auction sellers are retailersc. 64H, §§ 1, 6(c); c. 100, § 8

Title and registration fees are set administratively and were not retrieved (12.10).

12.7 Where these sales are published

ChannelWhere notice appearsSource
Execution sale48-hour posting in the town of sale or a newspaper in the debtor’s town; newspaper on request above USD 300c. 235, §§ 37-38
DOR levy saleCounty newspaper; postings if nonec. 62C, § 56(b)
Collector’s distraint48-hour postingc. 60, § 25
Police auction of abandoned vehicles and lost propertyNewspaper once a week for 3 weeks; sale may be onlinec. 135, § 8
Tow-storage saleNewspaper 3 successive weeks; police chief 5 daysc. 255, § 39A
Vessel lienholder’s abandoned-vessel saleNewspaper in the owner’s town 3 consecutive daysc. 255, § 17
Self-storageNewspaper, weekly periodical or other commercially reasonable channel, 2 weeks; sale may be onlinec. 105A, § 4
Warehouse (non-merchant goods)Newspaper weekly 2 weeks, or 6 postingsc. 106, § 7-210
  • Statewide site. The repository required by c. 4, § 13 is unnamed in the statute and was not retrieved; reuse terms are unknown (12.10).
  • Officer portals. Sheriffs post locally; the Essex County Sheriff’s civil-process page has a “Notice of Sale” section, which on 2026-10-18 stated that no notices were posted.
  • Collectability. Fragmented: execution and distraint sales can be noticed by a 48-hour posting alone; only newspaper-noticed channels reach the repository.

12.8 Buyer checklist

  1. Execution sales move fast: goods can be sold 4 days after seizure on a 48-hour posting and must be sold within 14 days (30 if newspaper notice was requested) (c. 235, §§ 36-38).
  2. Senior security interests survive an execution sale (c. 106, §§ 9-201, 9-315); check title records and UCC filings.
  3. Exemptions: a car worth up to USD 7,500 (USD 15,000 for elderly or handicapped debtors), USD 5,000 of tools and USD 5,000 of stock are exempt (c. 235, § 34).
  4. DOR sales: take the certificate of sale; it discharges only liens junior to the Commonwealth’s (c. 62C, § 60).
  5. Tow-storage cars: confirm the 60-day and 21-day registered notices, 3 weeks of newspaper notice and the 5-day police-chief notice (c. 255, § 39A); no lender notice is required, and no free-and-clear clause applies.
  6. Garage, animal, manufactured-home and aircraft liens need a court order (c. 255, §§ 26, 29, 31E).
  7. Aircraft: search the FAA Registry for Massachusetts repair and airport liens (60-day filing); an unfiled lien does not bind an innocent purchaser in possession (c. 255, § 31E).
  8. Boats: an abandoned-vessel lien buyer needs the marine title division’s documents (c. 255, § 17); a c. 91 title is subject to valid liens (c. 91, § 41); boats 14 feet and longer must be titled (c. 90B, § 36).
  9. Self-storage buyers in good faith take free even if the operator erred (c. 105A, § 4(9)).
  10. Molds and dies: the molder’s lien primes other interests, but the sale is subject to the customer’s patent and copyright rights (c. 255, § 31G).
  11. Forfeited conveyances remain subject to a perfected security interest that existed at filing (c. 94C, § 47(a)(9)).
  12. Unclaimed-property sales by the State Treasurer pass absolute title (c. 200A, § 9).
  13. Use tax: budget 6.25% on the greater of price or clean trade-in value for non-dealer vehicle purchases; aircraft are exempt (c. 64I, §§ 4, 7).
  14. Business buyers should obtain the c. 62C, § 44 certificate and check the § 51 corporate-transfer lien; liquor licences need approval (c. 138, § 23).
  15. Partnership interests can be bought at a court-directed charging-order sale (c. 108A, § 28); an LLC charging order gives only assignee rights (c. 156C, § 40).

12.9 Case law

CaseHolding relevant to forced sales of personal property
williams-v-american-honda-finance-2018 — No. 16-1275 (1st Cir. Oct. 24, 2018), after the SJC’s answers reported at 98 N.E.3d 169 (Mass. 2018)In c. 255B consumer vehicle transactions, post-repossession and post-sale notices must “expressly describe the deficiency as the difference between the amount owed on the loan and the fair market value of the vehicle”; notices tracking the UCC 9-614(3) safe-harbor form describing the deficiency by sale proceeds did not comply; the court reversed the compliance ruling and vacated dismissal of the UCC and c. 93A claims
in-re-pbbpc-2013 — 484 B.R. 860 (B.A.P. 1st Cir. 2013)The debtor’s Massachusetts unemployment experience rate was an “interest” in the sold assets under 11 U.S.C. § 363(f), so the sale order freed the buyer from successor rating; the parties did not dispute that a § 363(f) condition was met, and the preemption issue was waived

Decision evidence and limits. Both opinions were read in full from the federal courts’ own sites (the First Circuit’s 2018 opinion and 2017 certification; the Bankruptcy Appellate Panel’s slip opinion). The other Massachusetts case pages — liberty-mutual-v-market-street-garage-1974, kagan-v-ford-motor-credit-1980, source-one-financial-v-mccarthys-towing-2014, field-v-fletcher-1906 and milbank-v-littlefield-1941 — were not re-verified in this review: the archives that host them (static.case.law, masscasesarchive.com, CourtListener) disallow automated access in their robots.txt files, and no official free source was located; their holdings are not relied on in this module. Each case page keeps good_law_status: needs_verification.

12.10 Open questions after the bounded final review

ItemWhy it remains open
Deposit, time to pay and credit at an execution saleChapter 235 is silent; court rules and sheriff terms not retrievable
Setting aside a completed chattel execution saleNo statute; § 42 gives damages, not rescission
Registry and division form identifiers (court/lien sale, repossession, abandoned vehicle, motorboat involuntary transfer)Statutes leave forms to the Registrar and division; mass.gov refused access
Title and registration feesSet administratively; mass.gov refused access
LLC charging-order foreclosure and single-member ruleChapter 156C, § 40 is silent; no retrieved authority
Forced-sale exception to c. 62C, § 44Section 44 states none; DOR guidance not retrievable
Statewide notice repository (name, address, reuse terms) and newspaper qualificationChapter 4, § 13 does not name the site or define a qualifying newspaper; the site was not retrieved

▸ For Buyers / Operators — The provisions that move price and risk are the survival of perfected security interests at execution sales and the tender rule for encumbered goods (12.1), the DOR certificate-of-sale effect (12.2), the court-order default for most liens and the narrow non-court routes in § 39A, § 17, §§ 31B-31G and c. 105A (12.3), title-based perfection for vehicles and motorboats (12.4), the § 44 tax certificate (12.5) and use tax on non-dealer purchases (12.6).

▸ For Owners / Debtors — The relevant provisions are the c. 235, § 34 exemptions and redemption before an execution sale (12.1), the ten-day demand before a DOR levy and redemption before sale (12.2), the written demand and bond-dissolution and replevin rights before lien sales (12.3), the c. 255B cure notice, 20-day redemption and fair-market-value deficiency rule for financed cars (12.3), and the two-year windows to claim proceeds of police auctions and abandoned-vessel sales (12.2).

Local pages

County deep dives: barnstable-ma, bristol-ma, essex-ma, hampden-ma, middlesex-ma, norfolk-ma, plymouth-ma, suffolk-ma, worcester-ma Other counties (forced sales of personal property only, module C11): berkshire-ma, dukes-ma, franklin-ma, hampshire-ma, nantucket-ma

Unclaimed funds agency: unclaimed-property-massachusetts

Who this page is for

▸ For Investors / Operators — Start with §1 (the municipal “taking” and tax-title account at 8% interest, certification of subsequent taxes under § 61, and bulk assignment of receivables), §2/2b (redemption until the Land Court judgment, installment redemption at the court’s § 68 discretion, and the Tallage Lincoln limit on what an assignee may charge), §5b (path to marketable title — the “absolute” § 64 judgment, the § 69A one-year vacatur window, quiet title under c. 240 § 6 in the Land Court, and the absence of a Marketable Title Act), §7b (liens that survive — the c. 183A § 6 condominium 6-month super-lien, the c. 21E § 13 environmental super-lien on non-residential property, and the IRS § 7425 120-day redemption), and §11b (broad entity eligibility for tax-title assignees, c. 268A insider-conflict limits, no deficiency after a tax foreclosure).

▸ For Former Owners — Start with §3 (the § 64A excess-equity return — surplus above the tax-title account and reasonable sale/appraisal costs belongs to you; the judgment holder must send a certified-mail accounting and you submit a written request within the 18-month window, with a retroactive Superior Court route for judgments on/after May 25, 2021), §2 (redemption — paying the tax-title account plus 8% interest until the Land Court judgment, including on court-set terms post-petition), and §5c (grounds, the discretionary Rule 65 bond, and procedure for an emergency motion to halt a sale).

11. Meta


2b. Redemption Advanced

Assignability of Redemption Right

  • Assignable? The statutory redemption right under G.L. c. 60 § 62 is held by “any person having an interest in land” including “heirs and assigns” — the statute’s text expressly contemplates that the right passes to assigns. Mortgagees who redeem may add the amount paid to the mortgage debt (§ 62, mortgagee sub-clause). The statute does not prohibit an owner from assigning the redemption right to a third party; however, there is no express authorization for outright assignment to a stranger-to-title either. Practical rule: assignment of the redemption right to a third party is permitted insofar as the assignee acquires the owner’s “interest in land” (e.g., by deed or court-approved assignment), because § 62 defines the eligible party by their property interest, not personal identity. — G.L. c. 60 § 62. (§ 62)
  • Restrictions: No statutory restriction limits assignment to heirs or mortgagees only; the category is open to any person with a cognizable property interest. A purchaser of the owner’s equity (e.g., a judgment creditor or a deed grantee) steps into the owner’s shoes and may exercise the redemption right. — G.L. c. 60 § 62. needs_verification — no MA appellate decision directly addresses outright assignment of the bare redemption right without a transfer of the underlying property interest.
  • Statute or case: G.L. c. 60 § 62 (statutory text “heirs and assigns”); Tallage Lincoln, LLC v. Williams, 485 Mass. 449 (2020) (confirms that private assignees of the municipal tax title — distinct from the redemption right — are bound by § 62 redemption terms).
  • Purchase mechanism: deed conveying the underlying property interest or court-approved assignment; no separate “assignment of redemption right” instrument is contemplated by the statute.

Equitable Redemption

  • Distinct from statutory? In Massachusetts, “redemption of real estate from a tax sale is wholly by statute” — the right is a creature of statute, not equity. Courts have declined to imply equitable redemption rights beyond what c. 60 provides. The equitable power of the Land Court under § 68 to “fix terms” and “impose such other terms as justice and the circumstances warrant” is a procedural equity, not a substantive equitable redemption right separate from the statutory one. — G.L. c. 60 § 68; goldmanpease.com noting redemption is “wholly by statute.” needs_verification for a specific SJC case stating this doctrine explicitly.
  • Available pre-sale only? Yes, in practical terms: the statutory redemption right exists from the taking until the Land Court judgment of foreclosure (§ 62 / § 68); after judgment, the only avenue is a motion to vacate under § 69A (within 1 year; extraordinary circumstances required). There is no post-judgment equitable redemption track.
  • Notes: The Land Court’s § 68 discretion includes allowing installment redemption on terms the court deems just. The interest rate applicable in Land Court redemption orders is 8% per annum (post-St. 2024 c. 140).

Installment Redemption

  • Permitted? Yes, at the Land Court’s discretion under § 68 (“fix the terms” for redemption; “impose such other terms as justice and the circumstances warrant”). — G.L. c. 60 § 68.
  • Statute: G.L. c. 60 § 68.

Assignment of Tax Certificate / Deed Mid-Redemption

  • Permitted? Yes — the municipality may assign the tax title (not a certificate per se) to a private buyer under G.L. c. 60 § 52 via public auction (minimum 14-day notice by publication and posting; minimum price ≥ redemption amount; 10-day advance notice to owner of record; multilingual notice for Class One residential). The assignee is bound by the same redemption terms as the municipality. (§ 52 via mass.gov fetch)
  • Restrictions: price must not be less than the redemption amount; any foreclosure extension granted before assignment binds the assignee. An assignee may not add its own subsequent tax payments to the redemption amount in the manner § 52 reserves to the municipality. — Tallage Lincoln, 485 Mass. 449 (2020). (Justia)
  • Statute: G.L. c. 60 § 52.

3b. Surplus Advanced

Claim Assignability

  • Full assignment permitted? G.L. c. 60 § 64 expressly preserves the right of “the owner of the land at the time of foreclosure, and of those holding an interest in the land at the time of foreclosure and their heirs, successors and assigns,” to receive excess equity under § 64A. This language recognizes that the excess-equity claim may pass by succession, but it does not affirmatively authorize outright sale of the claim to a third-party recovery agent. No Massachusetts statute expressly permits or prohibits full assignment of the § 64A excess-equity claim. needs_verification — post-reform litigation will likely clarify whether a bare-claim assignment (not a conveyance of property interest) is enforceable.
  • Assignment vs. fee agreement distinction: A contingency-fee agreement with a recovery agent (the agent collects a percentage if recovery succeeds) is likely enforceable under general contract law. A full assignment (owner conveys the entire claim to the agent, who collects 100% and remits the remainder) is legally untested for § 64A claims. For G.L. c. 200A unclaimed property, the finder-fee framework (G.L. c. 200A § 13) limits fees and voids agreements signed within 24 months of delivery to the Division — but it is needs_verification whether § 200A § 13 governs § 64A claims held by a municipality (vs. only those delivered to the State Treasurer).
  • Fee cap applies to assignments? If c. 200A § 13 applies (10% cap), it would apply to the finder’s fee regardless of whether the instrument is called a fee agreement or an assignment. needs_verification.
  • Statute: G.L. c. 60 §§ 64, 64A; G.L. c. 200A § 13.

Statute of Limitations

  • Period: Parties entitled to excess equity must submit a claim within 18 months of the date of the notice (the certified-mail accounting notice the judgment holder must send within 30 days of sale or appraisal). — G.L. c. 60 § 64A (retrieved via mass.gov search summary; direct text fetch blocked).
  • Trigger date: date of the judgment holder’s certified-mail notice of written itemized accounting (sent within 30 days after sale of property or receipt of appraisal). — G.L. c. 60 § 64A.
  • Dispute SOL: A party may file a complaint in Superior Court within 12 months of the date of the notice of written itemized accounting to challenge the accounting. — G.L. c. 60 § 64A. (Mass.gov search result)
  • Retroactive claims: For judgments entered on/after May 25, 2021 but before the Act’s effective date (~Nov. 1, 2024), a separate Superior Court complaint must be filed within 12 months of the Act’s effective date. needs_verification for the exact trigger date (July 1 vs. Nov. 1, 2025).
  • Escheat: Excess equity unclaimed within 19 months is disposed of “pursuant to chapter 200A” (unclaimed property). — G.L. c. 60 § 64A (via § 64A fetch from malegislature.gov).
  • Citation: G.L. c. 60 § 64A (St. 2024, c. 140, § 93, eff. Nov. 1, 2024).

Competing Claimant Procedure

  • Priority rules: § 64A gives the judgment holder a “claim waterfall” in the written itemized accounting: tax-title account (taxes + interest + lawful charges) → reasonable costs of sale/appraisal/holding → excess to claimants. Among competing claimants (multiple mortgagees, lienholders, former owner), G.L. c. 60 § 64A vests jurisdiction in the Superior Court of the county where the property is located to resolve disputes. (§64A via mass.gov search)
  • Interpleader used? The Superior Court mechanism under § 64A effectively functions as an interpleader proceeding; parties may file a complaint to determine their entitlements. No explicit interpleader statute is cited in § 64A itself, but standard Mass. R. Civ. P. interpleader is available. — needs_verification for confirmed interpleader practice under § 64A.
  • Filing race: No — the statute does not award priority on a first-to-file basis. Priority follows established lien priority (senior liens paid first).
  • Citation: G.L. c. 60 § 64A; G.L. c. 244 § 14 (mortgage surplus priority logic by analogy).

Deceased Owner Procedure

  • Probate required first? Not always first, but the personal representative of the estate has standing to make the § 64A written request and file a Superior Court complaint. G.L. c. 60 §§ 64 and 64A use the phrase “their heirs, successors and assigns,” allowing direct heir claims; however, where the estate is the legal title holder, a properly appointed personal representative (G.L. c. 190B, the Massachusetts Uniform Probate Code) must act.
  • Personal rep has standing? Yes — as the legal representative of the deceased owner’s estate. — G.L. c. 190B § 3-807 (claimant against an estate) by analogy; G.L. c. 60 § 64A (“heirs, successors and assigns”).
  • Direct heir claim permitted? Yes — the “heirs” language of §§ 64/64A permits direct heir claims without requiring a formally appointed administrator, provided heirs can establish their interest (intestate succession under G.L. c. 190B Article II, or by will). needs_verification for a Land Court or Superior Court decision confirming direct-heir standing under § 64A.
  • Notes: Where title was in a deceased owner’s name at the time of foreclosure, the municipality’s § 64A certified-mail notice goes to the “last known address.” For heirs who discover the foreclosure after the notice window, the 18-month claim deadline runs from the date of that notice.

Fraudulent Conveyance Exposure

  • Assignment voidable by creditors? Yes — under G.L. c. 109A (the Massachusetts Uniform Fraudulent Transfer Act, the state’s UFTA), a transfer of the § 64A excess-equity claim by an insolvent owner could be challenged by creditors as a fraudulent transfer if made without receiving “reasonably equivalent value” or with intent to hinder/delay/defraud creditors. (c. 109A table of contents retrieved)
  • Applicable statute: G.L. c. 109A (Uniform Fraudulent Transfer Act). Massachusetts has not yet enacted the revised UVTA as of this verification; the UFTA framework remains operative.
  • Notes: A 4-year lookback period applies to constructive fraud claims; actual fraud claims have a 4-year limitations period from discovery. If a distressed owner assigns a § 64A claim for nominal consideration while insolvent, a creditor could claw back the claim value; an assignment for fair consideration is less exposed to such a challenge.
  • Citation: G.L. c. 109A §§ 5–6, 10.

Surplus Claimant Notice

  • Court must notify lienholders? Under § 64A, the judgment holder (not the court) must send certified-mail notice of the accounting to “any parties entitled to claim excess equity, or their successors in interest, to their last known address or place of business” within 30 days of the sale or appraisal. The Superior Court, once a complaint is filed, may issue further notice. — G.L. c. 60 § 64A. (Mass.gov §64A search result)
  • Method: Certified mail to last known address.
  • Timeline: Within 30 days after sale of property or receipt of the appraisal; claim deadline 18 months from notice; dispute complaint deadline 12 months from notice.
  • Citation: G.L. c. 60 § 64A.

5b. Title Advanced

Quiet Title Action

  • When required: A formal quiet title action under G.L. c. 240 § 6 is not automatically required after a Land Court judgment of foreclosure — the judgment itself is intended to be “absolute” (§ 64) and conclusive as to all parties cited in the proceeding. However, a quiet title action is strongly recommended (and frequently required by title insurers) where: (a) the one-year post-judgment vacatur window (§ 69A) has not yet run; (b) there is a potential due-process notice defect (known parties not actually notified); (c) the title examiner identifies pre-taking defects not resolved by the Land Court proceeding; or (d) the property is registered (Torrens) land requiring a separate Land Court proceeding. Practically, many practitioners treat quiet title as “often advisable” rather than mandatory. — G.L. c. 240 § 6; G.L. c. 60 § 64; Town of Andover v. State Financial Services, 48 Mass. App. Ct. 536 (2000) (due-process defect permits vacatur, underscoring risk of not clearing title). (G.L. c. 240 § 6)
  • Action type: Judicial — filed as a civil action in the Land Court (most common for real property title matters), or alternatively in the Superior Court or Supreme Judicial Court. G.L. c. 240 § 6 authorizes all three venues. The Land Court is preferred given its specialized expertise in title matters. (massrealestatelawblog.com)
  • Court with jurisdiction: Land Court Department (primary); Superior Court (available). G.L. c. 240 §§ 6–10.
  • Typical timeline: 3–6 months for an uncontested matter; significantly longer if contested or if service by publication is required (add 2–3 months for publication). — massrealestatelawblog.com.
  • Typical cost: Minimum $5,000 in attorney fees and expenses (filing fees, service, publication where applicable); contested matters substantially more. — massrealestatelawblog.com.
  • Cures all pre-sale defects? The Land Court’s § 60 foreclosure judgment itself is designed to extinguish all pre-taking claims of the cited parties. A subsequent G.L. c. 240 quiet title action can address defects the § 60 proceeding may have missed (e.g., parties not cited, registered-land issues, boundary disputes). — G.L. c. 240 § 6.
  • Citation: G.L. c. 240 § 6; G.L. c. 60 § 64; G.L. c. 60 § 69A.

Deed Seasoning

  • Insurers require seasoning? Yes — general-market title insurers treat Massachusetts tax-title (Land Court judgment + instrument of taking) titles with caution given the § 69A one-year vacatur window and due-process notice risks. Industry guidance (Agents National Title, referencing general tax deed underwriting practice) suggests insurers typically want 20 years of post- tax-deed record (or the state’s adverse-possession period) before insuring without a quiet title or other cure. In the Massachusetts-specific context, many practitioners apply a 1-year minimum (waiting out § 69A) and underwriters then assess notice compliance on a case-by-case basis. needs_verification for current Stewart/Old Republic/First American specific MA requirements.
  • Typical seasoning years: needs_verification — general industry default is 20 years for tax deeds without a quiet title; Massachusetts’s judicial Land Court process (producing a judgment rather than a deed alone) may allow underwriting after the § 69A 1-year window if notice is demonstrably clean.
  • Rationale: The § 69A vacatur right (1 year from judgment, extendable for due-process violations) creates a title cloud that underwriters must assess. Prior to St. 2024, c. 140, the additional Tyler-reform exposure also discouraged immediate coverage.

Title Insurance

  • Immediate availability: Generally not available immediately after judgment — underwriters require at minimum expiration of the § 69A 1-year vacatur window, clean title examination, and verified notice compliance.
  • Conditions for immediate: Title insurers may issue coverage earlier if: (a) notice was served personally or by certified mail (not publication only), (b) no known due-process defect exists, and (c) the § 64A excess-equity accounting has been completed. needs_verification for specific MA underwriter forms.
  • Insurers known to write: Stewart Title, First American, Old Republic — all write Massachusetts residential and commercial title insurance; their specific requirements for post-Land-Court-judgment policies are needs_verification.
  • Quitclaim or special warranty only? The instrument itself is an instrument of taking + Land Court judgment (no warranty deed); subsequent resale by the municipality typically uses a quitclaim deed or municipal deed.

Marketable Title Act

  • Exists? No — Massachusetts has not enacted a Marketable Record Title Act. Proposed legislation (“Landowner’s Title Protection Act”) has been introduced in prior sessions but not enacted. — see Mass. Bill SD.84 (190th session, proposed; not enacted). needs_verification for any post-2024 legislation.
  • Lookback years: N/A.
  • Statute: None enacted as of 2026-06-02.

Judicial Confirmation

  • Required before deed issues? The Land Court judgment of foreclosure under G.L. c. 60 § 64 is itself the judicial act that transfers and “absolutely” vests title. No separate confirmation hearing or deed-issuance hearing is required — the judgment is self-executing as to title. The instrument of taking (recorded at the registry) plus the judgment are the operative title documents. — G.L. c. 60 §§ 53, 64.
  • Tribunal: Land Court Department.
  • Timeline: Judgment issues at the conclusion of the Land Court foreclosure proceeding (typically 1–2+ years from petition filing).
  • Citation: G.L. c. 60 §§ 64, 65.

Chain of Title Cure

  • Depth: The Land Court § 60 foreclosure extinguishes all redemption rights of all cited parties (§ 64 “absolute title”); it functions like a quiet title as to those parties. Pre-taking defects involving uncited parties are not resolved by the foreclosure judgment and require a separate G.L. c. 240 quiet title action. Municipal tax liens are senior to virtually all pre-existing encumbrances under Massachusetts recording/lien-priority law.
  • Notes: Chain of title searches conventionally cover 50 years (REBA standard); the earliest instrument should be a warranty or quitclaim deed with no facial defects. Without a Marketable Title Act, ancient defects may persist unless a quiet title addresses them.

5c. TRO & Injunctive Relief

Recognized Grounds

A TRO or preliminary injunction to halt a Massachusetts tax (Land Court) or mortgage (non-judicial) foreclosure sale may be sought on the following grounds:

  1. Due-process / defective notice — the foreclosing party failed to provide constitutionally adequate notice to known parties (Town of Andover; Mullane).
  2. Payment dispute — the stated redemption amount is incorrect (e.g., an assignee inflated charges as in Tallage Lincoln).
  3. Constitutional / Tyler surplus — the foreclosure would result in unconstitutional retention of equity (now partially addressed by § 64A, but transition-period cases remain).
  4. Bankruptcy automatic stay — 11 U.S.C. § 362 operates as an automatic injunction; no separate TRO needed in bankruptcy, but the Land Court must acknowledge the stay.
  5. SCRA / Servicemembers — borrower is on active duty; in the mortgage context, the Servicemembers case procedure prevents foreclosure without court approval.
  6. Procedural defect in taking — collector failed to comply with demand / notice-of-taking requirements (§ 53).

Massachusetts four-part preliminary-injunction test (common law, applied via Mass. R. Civ. P. 65): the moving party must show (1) likelihood of success on the merits, (2) irreparable harm in the absence of relief, (3) the balance of harms favors the plaintiff, and (4) the public interest does not weigh against issuance. Rule 65 addresses only procedure; the substantive standard is common-law. (Rule 65 procedural framework — mass.gov search summary) For a TRO specifically, the moving party must show “immediate and irreparable harm” on affidavit or verified complaint — Massachusetts Rule 65(a).

Court with Jurisdiction

  • Tax foreclosure (Land Court proceeding): The Land Court Department has exclusive jurisdiction over c. 60 tax-title foreclosure cases and is the proper court for injunctive relief within those proceedings. A respondent may also seek emergency injunctive relief from the Superior Court in parallel if a separate constitutional claim is asserted.
  • Mortgage foreclosure (non-judicial): Since there is no pending court case, the borrower must affirmatively file suit in Superior Court (or the Land Court if title is implicated) and move for a TRO simultaneously with the complaint. The Superior Court hears most mortgage-foreclosure injunction matters. — Mass. R. Civ. P. 65; G.L. c. 240 § 6 (Land Court title jurisdiction).

Bond Required?

  • Discretionary under Mass. R. Civ. P. 65(c): “no restraining order or preliminary injunction shall issue except upon the giving of security…in such sum as the court deems proper.” However, Rule 65(c) explicitly allows the court to waive or reduce the bond where the applicant’s means are limited or the opposing party’s interest is otherwise secured (e.g., the secured lender has collateral exceeding the debt). needs_verification for Land Court-specific bond practice in tax-foreclosure TRO motions.
  • Post-judgment possession bond (c. 239 § 6A): If the foreclosing holder brings a summary-process action for possession after judgment, the occupant may be required to post a bond covering accrued “rent” (from foreclosure judgment date to possession) and damages. — G.L. c. 239 § 6A. (Justia)

Emergency Timeline

24–72 hours if the motion is properly filed with an affidavit showing imminent irreparable harm (e.g., a sale scheduled within days). The Land Court and Superior Court each have emergency sessions for TROs without notice. A sale scheduled in weeks typically generates a preliminary injunction hearing set within 7–14 days. needs_verification for current Land Court TRO practice.

Effect on Completed Sale

  • Tax foreclosure (Land Court judgment): The Land Court judgment is a judicial act; a sale cannot be “completed” without the judgment. If a § 69A motion to vacate is granted (within 1 year; extraordinary circumstances), all § 64A excess-equity obligations are also suspended. A judgment that issued before effective TRO can be vacated under § 69A but title protection for innocent third-party purchasers for value may limit vacatur. — G.L. c. 60 § 69A.
  • Mortgage foreclosure (non-judicial): Massachusetts courts have ruled that a completed non-judicial power-of-sale foreclosure generally cannot be unwound once a bona fide purchaser for value acquires the property; injunctive relief is unavailable as a practical matter after the gavel falls unless the sale itself was void (not merely voidable). needs_verification for a controlling SJC decision on post-sale TRO effect in mortgage context.

Non-Judicial Foreclosure Notes

Massachusetts mortgage foreclosures are predominantly non-judicial (power of sale, G.L. c. 244 § 14). A borrower seeking to enjoin a non-judicial foreclosure must file a complaint in Superior Court (or Land Court for title issues) concurrently with a TRO motion, because there is no pending court case in which to seek relief. Grounds narrow considerably for non-judicial sales: the borrower must show a likely defect in the lender’s power-of-sale compliance (e.g., failure to send § 35A cure notice, failure to conduct § 35B modification review, or failure to send § 17B deficiency-notice) — not just dissatisfaction with the outcome. — G.L. c. 244 §§ 14, 35A, 35B, 17B.

Leading Cases

town-of-andover-v-state-financial-services (due-process defect; vacatur of Land Court judgment); mullane-v-central-hanover (constitutional notice standard underlying TRO grounds); tallage-lincoln-v-williams (assignee overreach supporting payment-dispute ground).


7b. Lien Survival & Purchaser Exposure

IRS 120-Day Redemption Right

  • Applies? Yes — 26 U.S.C. § 7425(d) grants the federal government a right to redeem real property within 120 calendar days of a sale that discharges a federal tax lien senior to the selling authority’s claim, or the period allowed by state law, whichever is longer. Massachusetts’s c. 60 tax-title foreclosure is a judicial proceeding (Land Court), so the IRS must also be given 25-day advance notice of the sale under § 7425(b) if a federal tax lien is of record; failure to give that notice means the sale does not extinguish the federal lien and the IRS retains its lien position against the new titleholder. (26 U.S.C. § 7425; IRS IRM 5.12.4)
  • Procedure: The IRS sends its redemption offer within the 120-day window to the title holder of record; the redemption amount equals the price paid at sale plus interest. In the Massachusetts judicial-foreclosure context, the IRS must be joined as a defendant in the Land Court proceeding if its lien is of record; failure to join means the IRS lien survives the judgment. — 28 U.S.C. § 2410; 26 U.S.C. § 7425(d).
  • Citation: 26 U.S.C. § 7425(d); 26 CFR § 301.7425-4; 28 U.S.C. § 2410.

HOA / Condominium Super-Priority

  • Super-priority exists? Yes — Massachusetts is a super-lien state for condominium associations under G.L. c. 183A § 6(c). The condominium association’s assessment lien has priority over even a first mortgage for up to 6 months of common expense assessments immediately preceding the association’s enforcement action, plus enforcement costs and attorney fees (when proper notice is given to the first-lien holder). (G.L. c. 183A § 6 — fetched; newenglandcondo.com)
  • Statute: G.L. c. 183A § 6(c).
  • Cap: 6 months of regular monthly common-expense assessments plus enforcement costs and attorney fees (with proper notice to first lienholder).
  • Survives tax sale? No — a Massachusetts tax-title foreclosure (Land Court judgment) extinguishes the condominium association’s lien for common charges that accrued prior to the foreclosure decree. However, the foreclosing holder (municipality or assignee) becomes responsible for common charges accruing after the date of taking through the date of the judgment. — Land Court decisions cited in newenglandcondo.com “Ahead of the Line” (2011). needs_verification for a reported Land Court case citation.
  • Survives mortgage foreclosure? The super-priority portion (6 months) must be paid from the mortgage foreclosure sale proceeds before the first mortgagee is satisfied; the remainder of the HOA lien is junior to the first mortgage and is extinguished by the foreclosure. — G.L. c. 183A § 6(c).
  • Leading cases: needs_verification for a reported MA case specifically on HOA lien survival in tax sale context.

Environmental Liens (CERCLA / Chapter 21E)

  • CERCLA lien survives tax sale? The federal CERCLA lien (42 U.S.C. § 9607(l)) is subordinate to all liens perfected under state law before the Notice of Federal CERCLA Lien is recorded; it is senior to liens recorded after. Whether a Massachusetts tax-title foreclosure extinguishes a junior CERCLA lien is needs_verification — the federal CERCLA statute provides that the lien continues on the property unless the government consents to its release; the IRS/EPA must be joined in the Land Court proceeding (28 U.S.C. § 2410) for the lien to be extinguished.
  • State superfund super-lien (G.L. c. 21E § 13)? Yes — Massachusetts has a state environmental super-lien under G.L. c. 21E § 13. For non-residential property (excluding property devoted primarily to single- or multi-family housing), the c. 21E lien is senior to all previously recorded encumbrances as to the contaminated site. The super-lien persists until the commissioner issues a release. (G.L. c. 21E § 13 — fetched)
    • needs_verification whether the G.L. c. 21E § 13 super-lien survives a municipal tax-title foreclosure (i.e., is senior to the municipal tax lien itself). Tax liens are generally given first priority under G.L. c. 60, but federal and state environmental super-liens may present a competing claim.
  • Notes: For residential property (single/multi-family), the c. 21E lien is subordinate to prior-recorded encumbrances — no super-lien status.

Municipal Code / Blight Liens

  • Survive tax sale? Municipal code-enforcement liens (e.g., for building-code violations, demolition orders, abandoned-property abatements) are statutory liens that typically have priority under the municipality’s specific authorizing statute. In the Land Court foreclosure process, liens of parties cited in the proceeding are extinguished by the foreclosure judgment. Code liens recorded before the taking and cited in the Land Court proceeding are extinguished; uncited liens may survive. needs_verification for specific statutory authority on post-taking code liens.
  • Statute: Varies by municipality; most derive from G.L. c. 139 (nuisance), G.L. c. 143 (building code), or municipal ordinances.
  • Notes: Post-taking code violations (accruing while the municipality holds the tax title) are a municipality’s own obligation and do not burden the eventual purchaser from the municipality. Post-assignment (assignee holds tax title) code-violation liability is needs_verification.

Mechanic Liens

  • Survive tax sale if noticed? Mechanic’s liens under G.L. c. 254 must be recorded to perfect priority. A mechanic’s lien recorded before the instrument of taking may have priority equal to or junior to the municipal tax lien depending on the specific statutory priority rules. Parties holding perfected mechanic’s liens should be cited in the Land Court proceeding; if cited, their lien is extinguished by the judgment. If not cited, the lien may survive. needs_verification for direct authority.
  • Notes: In practice, a thorough title examination for the Land Court proceeding should identify all recorded mechanic’s liens; the Land Court citation process notifies all parties of record.

Junior Mortgage / Senior Lien Exposure

  • Purchaser takes subject to senior liens? The municipal tax lien under G.L. c. 60 has priority over all mortgages and other liens (municipal tax liens are always senior to private encumbrances in Massachusetts). After a Land Court judgment under § 64, the foreclosing holder takes absolute title free of all junior liens of cited parties. A purchaser from the foreclosing holder (post-judgment) acquires free-and-clear title as to cited parties; lienholders who were not cited are not bound by the judgment.
  • Common mistake notes: Purchasing a tax title (the municipal’s interest in the taking) before the Land Court judgment does not give absolute title; the purchaser of the tax title (not a post-judgment purchaser) still faces the redemption right of the owner and all cited parties.

Due Diligence Items

Items bearing on a Massachusetts tax-title or post-Land-Court-judgment purchase:

  1. IRS tax lien search — federal liens of record; if the IRS was not cited, its lien survives the Land Court judgment.
  2. State tax lien search — DOR liens (G.L. c. 62C § 50).
  3. G.L. c. 21E environmental lien search — MassDEP records for super-lien filings on commercial/industrial property.
  4. UCC search — for personal property liens that may attach to fixtures.
  5. Condominium/HOA status (G.L. c. 183A § 6) — 6-month super-priority assessment arrears, even against a first mortgagee.
  6. Mechanic’s lien search — G.L. c. 254 filings at the registry.
  7. Municipal code violations — local building/health department records.
  8. § 64A excess-equity obligation — does the property still have an open excess-equity claim or Superior Court dispute?
  9. SCRA / Servicemembers status — if the property is owner-occupied, confirm no active-duty protected borrower.
  10. § 69A vacatur window — if the Land Court judgment is less than 1 year old, the foreclosure judgment is still subject to vacatur on extraordinary- circumstances grounds.

10b. Purchaser Obligations During Redemption

Must Pay Subsequent Taxes?

  • Required? The municipality (or its private assignee) that holds the tax title is responsible for ensuring subsequent taxes are certified to the tax-title account under G.L. c. 60 § 61. The collector must certify all subsequent unpaid taxes to the treasurer by September 1 of the following year. Once certified, those taxes become part of the redemption amount the owner must pay. The municipality does not “pay” subsequent taxes in the conventional sense — it certifies them; for an assignee, paying subsequent taxes out-of-pocket and then seeking reimbursement at redemption was limited by Tallage Lincoln (the assignee may not add post-assignment tax payments to the redemption amount in the manner § 52 reserves to the municipality). — G.L. c. 60 § 61; Tallage Lincoln, LLC v. Williams, 485 Mass. 449 (2020). (§ 61 fetch)
  • Consequence of failure: If subsequent taxes are not certified to the account by the collector, they are not included in the redemption amount and cannot be collected from the redeeming owner. The municipality retains its right to pursue those taxes independently.
  • Citation: G.L. c. 60 § 61.

Must Notify Owner of Expiration?

  • Required? Under G.L. c. 60 § 64A (St. 2024, c. 140), after the Land Court enters a final judgment of foreclosure, the judgment holder must: (a) within 14 days of the judgment becoming final, elect whether to retain or sell the property, and (b) notify the former owners and all others known to hold the right of redemption by certified mail to their last known address of the election and applicable rights under § 64A. This notice functions as the “expiration notice” — it informs the former owner that the redemption right has been extinguished by the judgment. — G.L. c. 60 § 64A. (mass.gov §64A search)
  • Form: Certified mail; content must explain the judgment holder’s election (retain or sell) and the rights/procedures applicable under § 64A (excess equity claim).
  • Timing: Within 14 days of the Land Court judgment becoming final.
  • Consequence of failure: Failure to give § 64A notice could expose the judgment holder to Superior Court claims by the former owner for excess equity. needs_verification for an express statutory consequence of late/failed notice under § 64A beyond the excess-equity liability.
  • Citation: G.L. c. 60 § 64A (St. 2024, c. 140, § 93, eff. Nov. 1, 2024).

Owner Occupancy Right

  • Owner may remain? After the Land Court judgment of foreclosure, the former owner has no automatic right to remain in possession against the foreclosing holder. The judgment gives absolute title to the holder (§ 64). If the former owner remains, the holder may bring a summary-process action for possession under G.L. c. 239. — G.L. c. 60 § 64; G.L. c. 239 § 6A.
  • Purchaser may enter? The judgment holder (or its successor) may take possession after judgment, subject to any summary-process proceeding required to remove a remaining occupant. The holder is not required to provide any specific notice to vacate beyond what summary process requires (G.L. c. 239). needs_verification for any c. 60-specific occupancy protection for the former owner between judgment and possession.
  • Citation: G.L. c. 60 § 64; G.L. c. 239 §§ 1, 6A.

Costs Collectible Upon Redemption

If the owner redeems before the Land Court judgment, the redeeming party pays the tax-title account balance plus:

  • Bid/taking amount plus 8% interest (post-reform) from the date of the taking — G.L. c. 60 § 62.
  • Subsequent taxes certified to the account — G.L. c. 60 § 61.
  • Lawful charges added to the account (recording fees, title examination costs, etc.) — G.L. c. 60 § 62.
  • Court costs and reasonable attorney fees (if petition to foreclose has been filed) — G.L. c. 60 § 68; § 65 (court may award legal fees to municipality/assignee upon motion).
  • Documented improvements? The statute does not provide a right to collect for improvements made to the property during the redemption period; the statutory redemption amount is limited to the charges enumerated in §§ 61, 62, 65, and 68. needs_verification for any equity-based improvement recovery outside the statute.
  • Citation: G.L. c. 60 §§ 61, 62, 65, 68.

Property Maintenance Obligation

  • Required? No express statutory maintenance obligation on the municipality or assignee holding the tax title during the redemption period (between taking and Land Court judgment). The municipality is responsible for maintaining property it owns in its governmental capacity under general municipal law, but the tax title is a security interest, not full ownership — the original owner remains in legal possession pre-judgment and bears maintenance obligations.
  • Standard: General municipal property maintenance standards apply to municipally-held properties post-judgment (after the holder acquires absolute title); prior to judgment, the owner-in-possession remains responsible.
  • Citation: G.L. c. 60 §§ 53, 64 (ownership transfer mechanics); needs_verification for a specific c. 60 maintenance-obligation provision.

11b. Restrictions & Special Rules

Entity Purchase Restrictions

  • Natural persons only? No — G.L. c. 60 § 52 permits municipalities to assign tax titles to the highest bidder at public auction, with no restriction limiting buyers to natural persons. Entities (LLCs, corporations, trusts) may acquire tax titles and tax receivables. Private-party assignees such as Tallage LLC and Tallage Lincoln LLC have been active in Massachusetts and their entity status has not been challenged. — G.L. c. 60 § 52; Tallage Lincoln, LLC v. Williams, 485 Mass. 449 (2020). (§ 52 fetch)
  • LLC permitted? Yes.
  • Foreign entity permitted? Yes — G.L. c. 60 imposes no residency or domestic-entity requirement for purchasers of tax titles. Foreign LLCs must register to do business in Massachusetts if they acquire property (Secretary of State foreign LLC registration), but this is a business-registration requirement, not a bar to purchasing. needs_verification for any new restrictions in St. 2024, c. 140.
  • Notes: Massachusetts allows municipalities to assign tax receivables in bulk to private investment entities (the “Tallage model”). No statutory prohibition on entity purchasers was identified in G.L. c. 60 as reviewed.
  • Citation: G.L. c. 60 § 52.

Insider Prohibition

  • Who prohibited? G.L. c. 60 does not contain an express insider bidding prohibition analogous to sheriff-sale conflict-of-interest rules. However, the tax collector and municipal treasurer who conduct the taking and manage the tax-title account are subject to general conflict-of-interest law under G.L. c. 268A (the Massachusetts Conflict of Interest Law), which prohibits public employees from participating in decisions in which they have a financial interest.
  • Scope: Municipal officials involved in tax-title decisions cannot acquire those same titles for personal gain. The § 52 public-auction process is designed to prevent insider self-dealing by requiring public notice and minimum price.
  • Citation: G.L. c. 268A (conflict-of-interest law); G.L. c. 60 § 52 (public auction requirement). needs_verification for a DLS or AG opinion specifically addressing tax-title insider bidding.

Right of First Refusal

  • Municipalities? No general right of first refusal by the municipality on private tax-lien/deed resales — the municipality already holds the tax title and may choose to foreclose, assign, or retain. No ROFR in the reverse direction (municipality first-refusal on private resales of post-judgment properties) was identified in G.L. c. 60. needs_verification.
  • CDCs / nonprofits? No right of first refusal for CDCs or nonprofits under G.L. c. 60 was identified. (Compare G.L. cc. 61, 61A, 61B — agricultural and conservation land — where municipalities and certain entities have ROFR before a property is converted to non-qualifying use; this does not apply to ordinary tax-title sales.)
  • Land banks? needs_verification — see Land Bank Program below.
  • Match window: N/A (no ROFR confirmed in c. 60 context).
  • Citation: needs_verification for any ROFR in the Massachusetts tax-sale context.

Land Bank Program

  • Exists? Massachusetts does not have a single statewide land-bank statute specifically for tax-foreclosed properties comparable to Michigan’s or Ohio’s land-bank programs. Individual municipalities may establish local land-bank-type entities under their home-rule authority or pursuant to specific enabling acts (e.g., urban renewal, MGL c. 121A). The DLS (Division of Local Services) provides guidance on municipalities retaining tax-title properties for redevelopment.
  • Name: No single statewide program name. Some municipalities (e.g., Boston) operate urban renewal/affordable housing agencies that receive tax-title properties from the city.
  • Statute: No unified land-bank statute for tax-foreclosed properties identified as of 2026-06-02. needs_verification for any post-2024 legislation.
  • Receives unsold properties? Municipalities that hold tax titles after Land Court judgment and elect to retain under § 64A may convey to housing authorities, CDCs, or affordable-housing trusts under general municipal law. needs_verification for a specific statutory program.
  • Operational notes: Massachusetts’s model is municipal retention and discretionary conveyance (under § 64A’s elect-to-retain option), not a formal land-bank clearinghouse.

Deficiency Judgment

  • Permitted after tax sale? No — a tax-title foreclosure is a Land Court judgment that extinguishes the former owner’s equity; there is no “deficiency” concept because the municipality’s claim is for unpaid taxes (a fixed amount), not a loan. The excess-equity obligation runs in the other direction (§ 64A requires the foreclosing holder to return excess equity above the tax debt). A deficiency action is not applicable in the c. 60 tax context.
  • Permitted after mortgage foreclosure? Yes — under G.L. c. 244 § 17B, the lender may pursue a deficiency action if it sent written notice of intent to seek a deficiency at least 21 days before the foreclosure sale by registered mail with return receipt. The lender must commence the deficiency suit within 2 years of the foreclosure sale (G.L. c. 244 § 17A). — (§ 17B; § 17A fetch)
  • Fair value defense? Massachusetts does not have a statutory fair-value defense (credit bidding at the foreclosure sale against the deficiency amount). The deficiency is the difference between the sale price and the outstanding loan balance. needs_verification for any judicial fair-value doctrine in Massachusetts.
  • Citation: G.L. c. 244 §§ 17A, 17B.

Anti-Deficiency Statute

  • Exists? No general anti-deficiency statute in Massachusetts — lenders are not broadly barred from seeking deficiency judgments after mortgage foreclosure. The procedural prerequisite (§ 17B pre-sale notice) is a condition of pursuit, not a prohibition. Borrowers who were not given the required § 17B notice cannot be subjected to a deficiency action.
  • Scope: N/A — no anti-deficiency statute; the § 17B notice requirement is a procedural safeguard, not a substantive bar.
  • Citation: G.L. c. 244 § 17B (notice requirement as de facto bar if not given).

One-Action Rule

  • Exists? No — Massachusetts does not have a one-action rule. The lender may pursue the non-judicial power-of-sale foreclosure (under c. 244 § 14) and then file a separate civil action for the deficiency judgment (within 2 years, § 17A). The two actions are sequential, not prohibited. — G.L. c. 244 §§ 14, 17A, 17B.
  • Citation: G.L. c. 244 §§ 14, 17A.
  • Notes: The lack of a one-action rule means that Massachusetts lenders face minimal procedural constraint in pursuing both the collateral and the borrower, subject only to the § 17B notice prerequisite and the 2-year deficiency SOL.