Commonwealth of the Northern Mariana Islands (CNMI) — Tax & Mortgage Foreclosure
Legal information, not legal advice. Verify against the cited primary sources before acting. Last verified: 2026-06-02.
The CNMI does not levy an annual ad valorem real property tax. There is therefore no property-tax lien certificate, no tax deed, no tax-sale auction, and no property-tax foreclosure in the Commonwealth. The modules below that assume a property-tax sale system (Modules 1, 2 as to tax redemption, 3 surplus from a tax sale, and the treasurer-sale playbook) are marked N/A — no property tax exists with the reason cited. The operative foreclosure system in the CNMI is judicial mortgage foreclosure under the Commonwealth Real Estate Mortgage Law (2 CMC § 4511 et seq.), conducted in the Commonwealth Superior Court, followed by a 12-month statutory right of redemption (2 CMC § 4541). Layered over the whole system is the Article XII constitutional restriction that limits permanent and long-term interests in CNMI land to persons of Northern Marianas descent (NMD), so at a foreclosure sale a non-NMD purchaser ordinarily takes only a 55-year leasehold while an NMD purchaser may take fee simple.
0. Identity & Classification
- Name: Commonwealth of the Northern Mariana Islands (CNMI)
- Abbr / FIPS: MP / 69
- Type: U.S. insular area / commonwealth in political union with the United States under the Covenant (48 U.S.C. ch. 17).
- Recording unit: Single Commonwealth-wide recorder (the Commonwealth Recorder’s Office, under the Judiciary). There are no counties; the three principal inhabited islands (Saipan, Tinian, Rota) form senatorial/municipal districts but share one land-records office. (count: 1 recording office) — Commonwealth Recorder’s Office
- Tax sale type: none — no real property tax, therefore no tax-lien certificate or tax deed. (Corroborated Dotts Law Office: “Presently, property taxes are not charged on Saipan.“)
- Tax foreclosure process: N/A (no property tax). The Department of Finance enforces income-based taxes (CNMI uses a federal “mirror” income tax plus a Business Gross Revenue / “BGR” tax and an earnings tax) by lien/distraint, but those are not real-property tax foreclosures. — Revenue & Taxation, Dept. of Finance
- Mortgage foreclosure process: Judicial. “All judicial actions for the foreclosure of a mortgage shall be brought in the Commonwealth Trial Court” (now the Superior Court) — 2 CMC § 4537(a) (cmc § 4537, retrieved 2026-06-02). Foreclosure “is an equitable proceeding.” — L & T Int’l Corp. v. Benavente, 1997 MP 24
- Selling authority: Commonwealth Superior Court; the sale “shall be made by a person appointed by the court for that purpose … at a public place to be designated by the court” (2 CMC § 4537(e)).
- Statutory home: Title 2, Division 4, Commonwealth Real Estate Mortgage Law — 2 CMC § 4511 et seq. (foreclosure at § 4537; redemption at §§ 4541–4544); land-alienation restriction at N.M.I. Const. art. XII — Commonwealth Code; CNMI Constitution
- Tyler v. Hennepin compliance: not applicable. tyler-v-hennepin-county addresses surplus retained by the government after a property-tax foreclosure. Because the CNMI has no property-tax foreclosure, the Tyler fact-pattern cannot arise here. In a mortgage foreclosure, surplus over the debt is “brought to court for the use of the defendant or of the person entitled to it” (2 CMC § 4537(g)), so there is no government equity-grab to test against Tyler.
1. Tax Sale Mechanics
- N/A — no real property tax sale exists in the CNMI. The Commonwealth does not impose an annual ad valorem property tax, so there is no minimum bid, bidding method, interest/penalty rate, sale calendar, or auction platform for a property-tax sale. Corroborated by Dotts Law Office (“property taxes are not charged on Saipan”) and the Dept. of Finance tax page, which lists only income/earnings/BGR-type taxes — Revenue & Taxation.
- Land transfers are taxed at transfer, not annually. On a conveyance a graduated transfer/withholding tax (≈1.5%–5% of the transaction, owed by the seller; the buyer withholds and remits within 10 days of closing) applies. This is a transaction tax, not a recurring lien that could ripen into a tax foreclosure. — Dotts Law Office
2. Right of Redemption → see right-of-redemption
There is no tax-sale redemption (no tax sale). The redemption right below is the statutory post-foreclosure-sale redemption for mortgage foreclosures under 2 CMC §§ 4541–4544.
- Pre-sale right: The mortgagor may pay the secured debt to avoid sale; foreclosure being equitable, the equity of redemption exists until the judicial sale. — L & T Int’l Corp. v. Benavente, 1997 MP 24
- Post-sale statutory period: 12 months after the date of the sale. “All real property sold upon foreclosure of a mortgage by order, judgment, or decree of court may be redeemed … at any time, within 12 months after the date of the sale by the judgment debtor or a successor in interest; provided, however, that the judgment debtor or the successor in interest redeems all of the property as sold.” 2 CMC § 4541 (cmc § 4541, retrieved 2026-06-02).
- Who may redeem: the judgment debtor or a “successor in interest” only — a closed statutory class. The CNMI Supreme Court held the redemption right is “not an alienable property right but a personal privilege” that “may not be separated from the underlying ownership in the real property,” so a “successor in interest” must hold the same rights as the judgment debtor — a bare assignment of the redemption right to one who does not also take legal title is invalid. — Pacific Financial Corp. v. Sablan, 2011 MP 19 ¶¶ 8, 15
- Redemption amount / formula: Redeem all of the property “as sold” (no partial redemption). The redemptioner pays the purchaser the purchase amount plus 1% per month interest to the date of redemption, plus (1) assessments/taxes, (2) reasonable sums for fire insurance, maintenance, upkeep, repairs or improvements, (3) the fair market value of improvements constructed on the property, and (4) sums paid on prior obligations to protect the purchaser’s interest, with interest. 2 CMC § 4542(a) (cmc § 4542, retrieved 2026-06-02).
- Procedure: Tender the redemption price to the purchaser, or, on a dispute over the proper charges, pay the undisputed amount to the clerk of the Superior Court and file a written petition specifying the disputed items; the court fixes a hearing 10–20 days out (5 days’ notice to the purchaser), determines the amount, and a certificate of redemption issues (2 CMC § 4542(b)–(e)). Rents/profits the purchaser received are credited against the redemption money, and a written demand for a verified rents-and-profits statement extends the redemption period (5 days after the statement, or 15 days after a court accounting if the purchaser refuses) (2 CMC § 4543, cmc § 4543, retrieved 2026-06-02).
- Special tolling: The Supreme Court held that equitable tolling principles apply to the statutory redemption period in the Commonwealth — upon “a finding of fraud, oppression, or other equitable circumstances” the 12-month period may be extended — and remanded Sablan for that factual determination. — Pacific Financial Corp. v. Sablan, 2011 MP 19 ¶¶ 21–22
- Extinguishment: Expiry of the 12-month period (absent tolling) without a qualifying redeemer extinguishes the right; the foreclosure deed then issues and “shall be a bar to all claim, right, or equity of redemption” by the parties and those claiming under them (2 CMC § 4537(f)).
3. Surplus / Excess Proceeds → see surplus-funds, third-party-recovery-rules
No property-tax surplus exists (no tax sale). The only surplus that can arise is from a mortgage foreclosure sale, governed by 2 CMC § 4537(g).
- Belongs to: the judgment debtor / mortgagor. “The proceeds of every foreclosure sale must be applied first to the costs of sale, to the costs including attorney’s fees adjudged … in the judgment of foreclosure, and then to the debt. If there is any surplus, it must be brought to court for the use of the defendant or of the person entitled to it, subject to the order of the court.” 2 CMC § 4537(g) (cmc § 4537, retrieved 2026-06-02).
- Claim waterfall: (1) costs of sale; (2) judgment costs + attorney’s fees; (3) the secured debt; (4) surplus to the defendant or other person entitled, by order of the court (§ 4537(g)). The sale “shall not affect the rights of persons holding prior recorded encumbrances” (§ 4537(e)), so senior recorded liens are unaffected and junior recorded interests made parties are bound (§ 4537(c)(7)).
- Filing venue: the foreclosure action in the Commonwealth Superior Court, which holds and disburses the surplus by order (§ 4537(g)).
- Claim deadline / escheat: No property-tax-surplus deadline applies (no tax sale). For court-held surplus generally, the Judiciary Abandoned Funds Act (PL 18-36, 1 CMC § 30101 et seq.) addresses third-party funds held by the Judiciary that remain unclaimed for more than one year (cmc § 30101, retrieved 2026-06-02). Whether and exactly how that Act reaches a mortgage-foreclosure surplus, and the reclaim procedure → needs_verification (Act located and short title confirmed; the operative claim/forfeiture mechanics were not retrieved verbatim).
- Documentation required: governed by the foreclosure action and the court’s disbursement order; no separate statutory surplus-claim form located → needs_verification.
- Third-party recovery (surplus-recovery agents):
- fee_cap_pct: null — no CNMI statute caps surplus-recovery-agent fees (there is no property-tax-surplus regime to regulate; mortgage surplus is disbursed by court order). → needs_verification (whether any general consumer-protection or finders’-fee statute applies).
- licensing_required: unknown → needs_verification.
- assignment_of_claim_allowed: A surplus-cash entitlement is a chose in action distinct from the redemption right; the Sablan bar on assigning the redemption right does not by its terms reach a post-sale surplus claim. Separate authority on surplus-claim assignability not located → needs_verification.
- cooling_off_period / contract_disclosure_rules / prohibited_practices: → needs_verification.
- Notice to former owner required? Yes as to the foreclosure itself (the mortgagor is a served party — § 4537(b)). No separate property-tax-surplus notice statute exists (N/A).
▸ For Investors / Operators — A CNMI foreclosure overbid produces a surplus that § 4537(g) directs to the court “for the use of the defendant or of the person entitled to it.” Before committing capital, weigh the 12-month statutory redemption (§2/2b — the redemptioner can recover the property by paying your bid plus 1%/month and your carrying costs under § 4542, and the period can be equitably tolled), the Article XII ceiling on what a non-NMD buyer may take (§5b/§11b — ordinarily a ≤55-year leasehold, not fee), the path to insurable title (§5b — title insurance is available via Stewart Title agents but clouded titles are common), and surviving senior recorded liens (§7b — § 4537(e) leaves prior recorded encumbrances unaffected).
▸ For Former Owners — If a CNMI foreclosure sale brings more than the costs, fees, and secured debt, that surplus is “brought to court for the use of the defendant” (§ 4537(g)) — it is yours, disbursed by the Superior Court’s order in the foreclosure action. You also have 12 months to redeem the whole property under § 4541 by paying the purchase price plus 1%/month and the purchaser’s documented carrying costs (§ 4542), and that period can be equitably tolled for fraud or other equitable circumstances (Sablan).
4. Mortgage Foreclosure (the operative system)
- Process: Judicial. A foreclosure complaint is filed in the Commonwealth Superior Court and must set forth the mortgage, its assignments, the parties, a property description, the unpaid amount, and all junior interest-holders of record (who must be joined) (2 CMC § 4537(a)–(c)). On finding the complaint true, the court fixes the amount due and orders it paid into court within three months; on default the court orders the sale (§ 4537(d)–(e)). Even an instrument not styled as a statutory mortgage is enforced as an equitable mortgage if its purpose was to secure a debt. — L & T Int’l Corp. v. Benavente, 1997 MP 24 (citing 2 CMC §§ 4513(e), 4518)
- Sale: “made by a person appointed by the court … at a public place to be designated by the court, upon the notice and in the manner provided by law governing sales under execution,” with additional court-prescribed publication/announcement (§ 4537(e)). The purchaser receives a certificate of sale (recorded), and a deed only “at the expiration of the time for the redemption … if the property is not redeemed” (§ 4537(f)). Two auctions were held in Sablan when the first drew insufficient bids. — Pacific Financial Corp. v. Sablan, 2011 MP 19 ¶ 4
- Lien theory: CNMI mortgage law is lien-theory; legal title remains with the mortgagor throughout the redemption period — the certificate of sale is only an “inchoate interest.” — Sablan, 2011 MP 19 ¶ 17 (citing Villanueva v. City Trust Bank, 2002 MP 1)
- Redemption after sale: Yes — 12 months, judgment debtor or successor in interest only (Module 2; 2 CMC § 4541).
- Deficiency judgment: Allowed. “Upon the sale of any real property … if there be a balance due to the plaintiff after applying the proceeds of the sale, the court, upon motion, shall give a decree against the defendant for any balance for which … the defendant may be personally liable.” 2 CMC § 4537(h). In Sablan the trial court entered a deficiency judgment of $44,514.36 against the mortgagors. — Sablan, 2011 MP 19 ¶ 4
- Reinstatement right: Pre-sale payoff of the adjudged amount (within the 3-month pay-in window of § 4537(d)) avoids sale; a separate statutory reinstatement-by-arrears provision was not located → needs_verification.
- Surplus distribution: equity waterfall (Module 3) — surplus over costs, fees, and debt is brought to court for the defendant (§ 4537(g)).
- Sale officer: a person appointed by the court to conduct the sale (§ 4537(e)); the clerk of the Superior Court receives redemption tenders and disputed-amount deposits (§ 4542). No independent trustee/sheriff power-of-sale regime exists for mortgages.
- Vacating the sale: the court may, on motion within one year of the sale, vacate it and order a new sale on a finding of “fraud in the procurement of the foreclosure decree,” an improperly/unfairly/unlawfully conducted sale, or a sale “so tainted by fraud that to allow it to stand would be inequitable” (2 CMC § 4537(j)).
- Article XII overlay (unique to CNMI): Because a non-NMD purchaser cannot take freehold or a long-term (>55-year) interest (art. XII), at foreclosure sales a non-NMD buyer ordinarily takes only a 55-year leasehold, while an NMD buyer may take fee simple. Art. XII § 2 provides that “a transfer to a mortgagee by means of a foreclosure on a mortgage is not an acquisition” prohibited by the article if the mortgagee is a full service bank — so a full-service-bank lender may take at its own foreclosure without violating art. XII (verbatim § 2 text → needs_verification; corroborated Marianas Living, Dotts Law Office). In Sablan, “the Bensons … planned to take a 55-year lease … and Mitchell … planned to acquire title in fee simple.” — Sablan, 2011 MP 19 ¶ 4
5. Sale Procedure Playbooks
- Treasurer/tax-collector sale: N/A — no property tax, no tax sale. (See Modules 0–1.)
- Judicial mortgage-foreclosure sale — ordered steps → see sheriff-sale (analogous court-supervised judicial sale):
- Default on the secured loan; lender sends notice of default. (Sablan: default Apr. 2001, default notice May 2001.)
- Lender files a foreclosure complaint in the Superior Court setting forth the mortgage, parties, property, unpaid amount, and joining junior interest-holders of record (§ 4537(a)–(c)). (Sablan: filed Jan. 2002.)
- Court finds the complaint true, fixes the amount due, and orders payment into court within 3 months (§ 4537(d)).
- On default, court orders sale by a court-appointed person at a court-designated public place, on execution-sale notice plus court-prescribed publication; senior recorded encumbrances are unaffected (§ 4537(e)).
- Public auction; re-auction if bids insufficient (Sablan). Purchaser gets a recorded certificate of sale; legal title stays with the mortgagor (§ 4537(f); Sablan ¶ 17).
- Court applies proceeds (costs → fees → debt → surplus to court for the defendant) (§ 4537(g)); a deficiency decree may issue for any balance (§ 4537(h)).
- 12-month redemption window runs from the sale date (§ 4541); judgment debtor or successor in interest may redeem the whole property (§§ 4542–4544).
- If unredeemed, the deed issues, barring all redemption rights (§ 4537(f)). Non-NMD purchaser takes ≤55-year leasehold; NMD purchaser may take fee simple (art. XII). — Sablan, 2011 MP 19; L & T Int’l Corp. v. Benavente, 1997 MP 24
- Notice requirements (publication/mailing/posting): “the notice and in the manner provided by law governing sales under execution,” plus court-prescribed “extension of the term of notice, and requirement of publication or announcement in local newspapers, radio or television” (§ 4537(e)). Precise execution-sale notice periods (Title 7) → needs_verification.
- Upset bid / confirmation: The court confirms/approves the sale (the trial court “approved the sale” in Sablan); no separate statutory “upset-bid” mechanism identified — § 4537(j) instead allows vacating the sale within one year for fraud/irregularity.
- Deed issued: Court foreclosure deed (NMD purchaser, fee or whatever the mortgagor held — § 4537(f)) or ≤55-year lease (non-NMD purchaser), issued only after the 12-month redemption lapses unredeemed.
6. Due Process & Notice → see due-process-notice
- Standard: Federal due process applies in the CNMI (a U.S. insular area); the foreclosure defendant is a served party (§ 4537(b) — service under Title 7 and the Superior Court Rules of Civil Procedure). The general mullane-v-central-hanover “reasonably calculated” standard governs notice.
- Required attempts: Service of summons and complaint on the mortgagor and all joined junior interest-holders of record (§ 4537(b)–(c)); unrecorded conveyances/liens need not be joined and are bound as if joined (§ 4537(c)). Mortgagor was duly notified in Sablan.
- Consequence of defective notice: voidable judgment / subject to challenge; § 4537(j) permits vacating the sale within one year for fraud or an unlawfully conducted sale.
- Leading cases: pacific-financial-corp-v-sablan (redemption/standing/tolling); wabol-v-villacrusis (which constitutional guarantees apply in the CNMI at all). Application of jones-v-flowers / mennonite-v-adams specifically in CNMI courts → needs_verification.
7. Title & Marketability
- Deed warranty level: Judicial-foreclosure deed vests “all the rights, title and interest of the mortgagor … at the time the mortgage was executed, or subsequently acquired” (§ 4537(f)) — no statutory warranty beyond what the decree confers; for non-NMD buyers the interest is a leasehold (≤55 years), not fee.
- Marketable immediately? No — the purchaser holds only a recorded certificate of sale during the 12-month redemption (§§ 4537(f), 4541); legal title remains with the mortgagor until the deed issues (Sablan ¶ 17), so title is not unencumbered until the period lapses.
- Quiet title required? Often advisable after redemption lapses; CNMI titles are frequently “clouded” (unprobated deceased owners; old leases/mortgages paid but never released). A conveyance of a permanent/long-term interest to a non-NMD is void ab initio under art. XII, a defect quiet-title actions and the wabol-v-villacrusis line address. — Dotts Law Office
- SOL to challenge: an “action for the recovery of land or any interest therein” must be commenced within 20 years after the cause of action accrues (7 CMC § 2502(a)(2), cmc § 2502, retrieved 2026-06-02); actions upon a judgment likewise run 20 years (§ 2502(a)(1)). Whether an art. XII void-ab-initio claim is subject to § 2502 → needs_verification.
- Title insurance availability: Available — Stewart Title, Ltd. writes CNMI title insurance through local agents Security Title, Inc. and Pacific American Title Insurance & Escrow Company, preceded by a preliminary title report (PTR). — Dotts Law Office
- Common defects: (1) Art. XII — long-term interest conveyed to a non-NMD is void; (2) outstanding 12-month redemption right; (3) defective/equitable mortgages enforced despite non-compliance with statutory form (Benavente); (4) unprobated deceased owners and unreleased old leases/mortgages clouding title (Dotts).
8. Case Law (real, verified)
| Case | Year | Topic | Holding (plain English) | Source |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| pacific-financial-corp-v-sablan (2011 MP 19) | 2011 | redemption; surplus; sale_procedure | After a judicial mortgage foreclosure, 2 CMC § 4541 gives only the judgment debtor or a true successor in interest 12 months to redeem the whole property; the redemption right is “not an alienable property right but a personal privilege,” so a bare assignment to a non-successor is invalid. Deficiency judgment allowed; equitable tolling of the 12-month period is available for fraud/equitable circumstances; foreclosure purchasers have standing to assert fraudulent conveyance. | cnmilaw.org |
| l-t-international-corp-v-benavente (1997 MP 24) | 1997 | sale_procedure; surplus (equity) | Mortgage foreclosure is an equitable proceeding in the Superior Court. A “Rescission Agreement” plus 55-year leases that were really security for a $600,000 loan created an equitable mortgage, foreclosable even though it did not satisfy the statutory mortgage form (2 CMC §§ 4513(e), 4518). | cnmilaw.org |
| wabol-v-villacrusis (958 F.2d 1450, 9th Cir.) | 1990–92 | due_process; title | A long-term interest in CNMI land to a non-NMD is void ab initio under art. XII; the Ninth Circuit held the 14th Amendment Equal Protection Clause does not invalidate art. XII because applying it would be “impractical and anomalous” given the Covenant and land’s cultural role. | openjurist.org · law.resource.org |
Tyler / surplus-from-tax-sale case: none exists for the CNMI because there is no property-tax foreclosure. The surplus topic is covered above via the statutory mortgage-surplus waterfall (2 CMC § 4537(g); Benavente) and the redemption/standing/tolling analysis (Sablan); a dedicated property-tax-surplus case is not applicable here.
9. Edge Cases (CNMI-specific notes)
- article-xii-land-alienation — The defining CNMI edge case. Permanent and long-term interests (freehold, or leasehold > 55 years incl. renewals) may be acquired only by persons of Northern Marianas descent; any acquisition in violation is void ab initio. A full-service-bank mortgagee may take at its own foreclosure (art. XII § 2 exception). Non-NMD buyers and lenders otherwise operate through ≤55-year leaseholds. Source: N.M.I. Const. art. XII §§ 1, 2, 6 (cons.php); wabol-v-villacrusis; Marianas Living; Dotts Law Office. (At Wabol’s time the cap was 40 years; amended to 55 years by the 1985 Constitutional Convention.)
- no-property-tax — CNMI levies no annual real property tax, so there is no tax-lien/tax-deed/tax-foreclosure pathway; land revenue is raised at transfer and through income/BGR taxes. Sources: Dotts Law Office; Dept. of Finance Revenue & Taxation.
- equitable-mortgage — CNMI courts will treat a security arrangement (even a disguised lease/“rescission agreement”) as a foreclosable equitable mortgage. — L & T v. Benavente, 1997 MP 24
- bankruptcy-automatic-stay — Federal Bankruptcy Code applies in the CNMI; a Ch. 7/13 filing stays a Superior Court foreclosure. State-specific interplay → needs_verification.
- federal-tax-lien-redemption — IRS federal tax liens attach in the CNMI under the mirror code; the IRS § 7425 120-day redemption interplay with 2 CMC § 4541 → needs_verification.
- heirs-property — Customary/family land and art. XII inheritance rules (a non-NMD generally cannot inherit a long-term interest, though a transfer to a spouse by inheritance is excepted in limited circumstances) make heirs’-property dynamics distinctive. → see article-xii-land-alienation.
10. Operations
- Where records live: Commonwealth Recorder’s Office (CNMI Judiciary) for deeds/mortgages/leases; Commonwealth Superior Court for foreclosure actions and redemption petitions; CNMI Supreme Court for appeals. — Recorder’s Office · Superior Court
- Public access / portals: Commonwealth Code (section PDFs at
cnmilaw.org/pdf/cmc_section/) and all CNMI Supreme/Superior Court opinions at cnmilaw.org; Constitution at cnmilaw.org/cons.php. — Commonwealth Code - Taxes (for context): Division of Revenue & Taxation, Dept. of Finance (income mirror tax, earnings tax, BGR, transfer/withholding on conveyances) — finance.gov.mp/revenue-taxation.php. No property-tax office exists.
- Typical costs/timelines: Mortgage foreclosure is a full judicial action (years, in Sablan: default 2001 → sale 2007) plus a 12-month post-sale redemption window; § 4542 redemption disputes are heard 10–20 days after the petition.
- Key agencies: CNMI Judiciary (Recorder, Superior Court, Supreme Court); Dept. of Finance / Div. of Revenue & Taxation; Dept. of Public Lands (public-land matters). — Dept. of Public Lands
- Useful forms: Redemption petition under 2 CMC § 4542 (filed with the Clerk of the Superior Court); foreclosure-complaint requirements per § 4537(c) → exact form/fee schedule needs_verification.
2b. Redemption Advanced
Assignability of the statutory redemption right:
- Assignable? No as a bare/standalone right. The CNMI Supreme Court held “the right to redeem is not an alienable property right but a personal privilege that may not be separated from the underlying ownership in the real property.” A would-be redemptioner qualifies only as a “successor in interest” who holds “the same rights in the property as the judgment debtor — no more and no less,” i.e., one who has taken the judgment debtor’s legal title, not merely a paper “Assignment of Redemption Rights.” (Pacific Financial Corp. v. Sablan, 2011 MP 19 ¶¶ 8–20, retrieved 2026-06-02)
- Restrictions: The statutory class is exceedingly narrow — only the judgment debtor or a successor in interest (one who succeeds to the debtor’s entire estate in the property); unlike many states’ statutes, § 4541 does not also let creditors redeem and does not allow partial redemption. (Sablan ¶ 14)
- Purchase mechanism: A third party may acquire redemption standing only by taking a conveyance of the judgment debtor’s legal title (e.g., a quitclaim deed transferring the entire interest), thereby becoming a “successor in interest”; a document purporting to assign “redemption rights” alone is ineffective (Sablan ¶¶ 18–20). Court approval of the redemption is sought by petition under § 4542.
- Statute/case: 2 CMC § 4541; Pacific Financial Corp. v. Sablan, 2011 MP 19.
Equitable vs. statutory redemption:
- Distinct. The §§ 4541–4544 post-sale right is statutory. The Supreme Court expressly distinguished equitable redemption, which “exists where certain redemption rights are not governed by statute,” and declined to decide its availability in the Commonwealth because the Sablan parties argued only the statute (Sablan ¶ 8 n.8). A mortgagor’s pre-sale equity of redemption (paying the debt before the judicial sale) is the ordinary equitable right; the statutory right runs post-sale for 12 months.
- Available pre-sale only: No — the statutory right is a post-sale right (12 months from the sale); the equitable right operates pre-sale.
Installment redemption:
- Not permitted. Section 4541 requires the redemptioner to “redeem all of the property as sold,” and § 4542 contemplates a single tender of the full redemption amount (plus court-determined charges); there is no statutory installment-payment plan. (2 CMC §§ 4541, 4542)
Assignment of the certificate of sale / deed (purchaser side) mid-redemption:
- Permitted. The deed at the end of redemption may run “to the purchaser, the purchaser’s heirs, or assignees, or to any person who has acquired the title of the purchaser by redemption or otherwise” (2 CMC § 4537(f)). The purchaser’s certificate-of-sale interest is therefore transferable during the redemption period; the redemption price formula and 1%/month interest follow whoever holds the purchaser’s position (§ 4542). Any non-NMD assignee remains subject to the art. XII ≤55-year leasehold ceiling. needs_verification — no retrieved CNMI decision squarely on the form/recording of a mid-redemption certificate assignment.
3b. Surplus Advanced
Claim assignability — mortgage-foreclosure surplus (2 CMC § 4537(g)):
- Full assignment permitted? The surplus is “brought to court for the use of the defendant or of the person entitled to it, subject to the order of the court” (§ 4537(g)). The statute does not expressly authorize or prohibit an outright assignment of the surplus entitlement, and no fee cap, cooling-off period, licensing, or disclosure regime appears in Title 2, Division 4. needs_verification — surplus-claim assignability and any general restriction not resolved by a retrieved CNMI source.
- Assignment vs. fee agreement: Operative distinction not established by a retrieved CNMI authority. Note the firm contrast with the redemption right, which Sablan holds is not assignable as a bare right; a post-sale surplus-cash claim is a different chose in action, but its assignability is unconfirmed. needs_verification.
- Fee cap applies to assignments? No cap located in CMC Title 2 Div. 4. needs_verification (whether any general consumer/finders’-fee statute reaches surplus recovery).
- Statute: 2 CMC § 4537(g).
Statute of limitations:
- Period / trigger: No surplus-specific limitations period located. The general real-property limitation — “actions for the recovery of land or any interest therein” — is 20 years after accrual (7 CMC § 2502(a)(2)), and “actions upon a judgment” are likewise 20 years (§ 2502(a)(1)) (cmc § 2502, retrieved 2026-06-02). For court-held surplus, the Judiciary Abandoned Funds Act (PL 18-36, 1 CMC § 30101 et seq.) targets funds “unclaimed for more than one year” held by the Judiciary (cmc § 30101, retrieved 2026-06-02). Which clock governs a foreclosure surplus → needs_verification.
Competing claimant procedure:
- Filing race? No statutory first-to-file rule. Surplus is disbursed “subject to the order of the court” (§ 4537(g)); junior interest-holders of record must be joined as defendants in the foreclosure (§ 4537(c)(7)) and their priority is adjudicated within that action. Senior recorded encumbrances are unaffected by the sale (§ 4537(e)). No dedicated interpleader statute located → needs_verification.
- Priority rules: costs of sale → judgment costs/fees → secured debt → surplus to the defendant/person entitled, with joined junior lienholders’ claims resolved by the court (§ 4537(e)–(g)).
Deceased-owner procedure:
- Where the entitled “defendant” is deceased, the estate is entitled and a personal representative would have standing; CNMI probate (and the art. XII inheritance constraints — a non-NMD generally cannot inherit a long-term interest) governs. No CNMI statute on a direct-heir surplus claim without probate located. needs_verification.
Fraudulent-conveyance exposure:
- Yes — exposed. In Sablan, the foreclosure purchasers had standing to challenge as a fraudulent conveyance the judgment debtor’s transfer (there, of redemption rights to a relative for “$10 and love and affection”); the claim proceeds as a common-law fraud/fraudulent-conveyance action under Com. R. Civ. P. 9(b) (pleaded with particularity), and equitable tolling of redemption may turn on a finding of fraud. (Sablan, 2011 MP 19 ¶¶ 22–26, retrieved 2026-06-02)
- Applicable statute: No CNMI Uniform Fraudulent Transfer Act / Uniform Voidable Transactions Act located in the Commonwealth Code; CNMI’s fraudulent-conveyance doctrine appears to rest on common law / equity (as applied in Sablan) rather than a codified UFTA/UVTA. needs_verification — confirm the CNMI has not adopted a statutory UFTA/UVTA; identify the operative limitations period for a common-law fraudulent-conveyance claim.
Surplus-claimant notice:
- The court controls disbursement (§ 4537(g)); junior interest-holders are protected by the joinder requirement at the front of the case (§ 4537(c)(7)) rather than by a separate post-sale lienholder-notice statute. No dedicated surplus-notice provision located → needs_verification.
5b. Title Advanced
Quiet title — when required vs. optional:
- Practical standard: A CNMI foreclosure purchaser holds only a recorded certificate of sale during the 12-month redemption (§ 4537(f)); legal title stays with the mortgagor until the deed issues (Sablan ¶ 17). After redemption lapses and the deed issues, a quiet-title action is commonly advisable because CNMI titles are frequently clouded (unprobated deceased owners; old unreleased leases/mortgages) and because art. XII validity may need resolution. (Dotts Law Office, retrieved 2026-06-02)
- Action type and court: Judicial, in the Commonwealth Superior Court (general civil jurisdiction over land matters). CNMI has no administrative or statutory-presumption quiet-title substitute located. needs_verification — no dedicated CNMI quiet-title enabling statute retrieved; the action proceeds under general Superior Court civil jurisdiction.
- Judicial confirmation before deed issues? The court confirms/approves the foreclosure sale (done in Sablan), but the deed issues only after the 12-month redemption lapses (§ 4537(f)) — confirmation of the sale and issuance of the deed are distinct steps. A separate post-deed quiet title remains the path to clear clouded title.
- Typical timeline / cost: Not established by a retrieved CNMI source. needs_verification.
- Cures all pre-sale defects? A quiet-title judgment binds joined parties, but an art. XII void-ab-initio defect (a long-term interest conveyed to a non-NMD) may not be curable by quiet title and may not run in the ordinary way. needs_verification.
Deed seasoning / title insurance:
- Title insurance is available — Stewart Title, Ltd. writes CNMI title insurance through agents Security Title, Inc. and Pacific American Title Insurance & Escrow Company, after a preliminary title report (PTR) confirms the record owner and exceptions. (Dotts Law Office, retrieved 2026-06-02)
- Seasoning: Whether insurers require the 12-month redemption (and any additional seasoning) to lapse before insuring a foreclosure-derived title → needs_verification (consistent with the no-marketability-until-redemption-lapses rule of § 4537(f)).
Marketable Title Act:
- No CNMI Marketable Record Title Act located. Title marketability is governed by the recording regime, the 20-year limitation in 7 CMC § 2502, and the mortgage-discharge provision (2 CMC § 4552 — a mortgage not renewed/extended within 15 years after its due date, or 20 years after recording if no due date, “shall be discharged of record by order of a judge … upon application of any interested person,” cmc § 4552, retrieved 2026-06-02), which functions as a stale-mortgage clearing mechanism. needs_verification — no 30-year-root-of-title MRTA located.
Chain-of-title cure depth:
- The foreclosure deed vests “all the rights, title and interest of the mortgagor … at the time the mortgage was executed, or subsequently acquired” and bars redemption claims by the parties and those claiming under them (§ 4537(f)); it does not by its own force clear senior recorded encumbrances (unaffected under § 4537(e)) or art. XII voidness. A quiet-title judgment cures joined adverse claims.
5c. TRO & Injunctive Relief
Recognized grounds to halt or undo a sale:
- Fraud in procurement of the decree or a sale “improperly, unfairly, or unlawfully conducted” or “so tainted by fraud … inequitable” — the court may vacate the sale within one year (2 CMC § 4537(j)).
- Waste / injury to the property — the court “by injunction, for good cause shown, may restrain the party in possession from doing any injurious act to the property … until the expiration of the time allowed for redemption” (2 CMC § 4544(a), cmc § 4544, retrieved 2026-06-02); a receiver may be appointed where the property is in danger of substantial waste or the security is becoming insufficient (§ 4544(b)).
- Notice / due-process defect in the foreclosure action (service under § 4537(b)).
- Bankruptcy automatic stay — sale in violation of 11 U.S.C. § 362 (see bankruptcy-automatic-stay).
- Equitable-tolling / redemption disputes — the court adjudicates redemption-amount disputes (§ 4542) and may equitably toll the redemption period (Sablan).
Legal standard / court / bond:
- The Superior Court applies the general standard for injunctive relief under the Commonwealth Rules of Civil Procedure (Rule 65 analog) and “good cause shown” for the § 4544 waste injunction. The precise CNMI preliminary-injunction test, any bond requirement, and the emergency timeline → needs_verification (no retrieved CNMI Rule 65 text or controlling opinion stating the four-part test, bond, or ex-parte timeline).
- Court with jurisdiction: the Commonwealth Superior Court — because mortgage foreclosure is judicial and already pending there, injunctive relief and the § 4537(j) vacate-the-sale motion are sought within the foreclosure action.
Effect on a completed sale:
- The court may vacate a completed foreclosure sale within one year of the sale date for fraud or an unlawfully conducted sale and order a new sale (2 CMC § 4537(j)). Because legal title remains with the mortgagor until the deed issues post-redemption (Sablan ¶ 17), there is a built-in window in which the sale can be unwound.
- Non-judicial note: the CNMI has no non-judicial / power-of-sale mortgage foreclosure — every foreclosure is a court action (§ 4537(a)), so there is always a pending case in which to seek relief; no separate emergency action is needed.
Leading cases: pacific-financial-corp-v-sablan (equitable tolling, fraud standing); wabol-v-villacrusis (art. XII voidness).
7b. Lien Survival & Purchaser Exposure
IRS 120-day redemption (26 U.S.C. § 7425):
- The federal statute applies in the CNMI (a U.S. insular area under the mirror code). Where a federal tax lien is junior to the interest being foreclosed, the United States must be given ≥25 days’ notice of the sale; if noticed, the federal lien is discharged but the IRS holds a 120-day post-sale redemption right; if not noticed, the federal lien survives. (26 U.S.C. § 7425, retrieved 2026-06-02) CNMI-specific application and the interplay between the § 7425 120-day period and the 2 CMC § 4541 12-month period → needs_verification. See federal-tax-lien-redemption.
HOA super-priority:
- No CNMI HOA super-priority statute located. The CNMI is dominated by single-recorder land with extensive customary/family and art. XII-restricted ownership rather than the planned-community/condominium HOA model of the mainland; no statutory assessment-lien super-priority over a mortgage or a (nonexistent) tax sale was found. needs_verification — confirm the CNMI has not enacted a condominium/HOA assessment-lien priority statute.
Environmental / CERCLA liens:
- A federal CERCLA lien (42 U.S.C. § 9607(l)) and CERCLA owner/operator liability apply in the CNMI as federal law; liability runs with the land regardless of how title was acquired. No CNMI-specific authority on CERCLA-lien survival of a foreclosure, and no confirmed CNMI environmental super-lien, was located. needs_verification.
Municipal code liens / mechanic’s liens:
- The CNMI has no counties or municipal property-tax liens (no property tax). Mechanic’s/materialman’s liens exist and are enforced by foreclosure in the Superior Court (reported in CNMI practice). Their priority against a mortgage-foreclosure purchaser turns on recording and § 4537(e) (senior recorded encumbrances unaffected; junior interest-holders joined are barred). needs_verification — no retrieved CNMI authority squarely on mechanic’s-lien survival of a mortgage foreclosure.
Junior-mortgage exposure:
- A § 4537 foreclosure conveys the mortgagor’s interest and bars junior interest-holders who were joined as defendants (§ 4537(c)(7), (f)); it does not affect prior recorded encumbrances (§ 4537(e)). Common mistake: assuming the foreclosure deed clears senior recorded liens — it does not; and a junior interest not joined may survive (§ 4537(c) binds only the unrecorded; recorded junior interests must be made parties to be cut off).
Due-diligence checklist (CNMI foreclosure buyer):
- Recorder’s Office title search — senior recorded encumbrances (survive, § 4537(e)); confirm all junior recorded interests were joined.
- Art. XII / NMD status — can the buyer take fee, or only a ≤55-year leasehold? Is the buyer a full-service bank (art. XII § 2 exception)?
- Federal tax lien search — § 7425 notice / 120-day IRS redemption exposure.
- Redemption status — the 12-month § 4541 period (and any equitable tolling) before title is clear.
- Probate / heirs check — unprobated deceased owners and art. XII inheritance constraints are a frequent cloud.
- Old unreleased leases/mortgages — common CNMI defect (Dotts); § 4552 stale-mortgage discharge may apply.
- Bankruptcy search on the mortgagor — active stay at the time of sale?
- Title insurer PTR — Stewart Title via Security Title / Pacific American Title.
10b. Purchaser Obligations During the Redemption Period
Subsequent taxes:
- There is no annual property tax, so there is no subsequent-property-tax obligation. If the purchaser pays “any assessment or taxes” (e.g., income/BGR or other charges to protect the interest), those sums are added to the redemption amount the redemptioner must pay (2 CMC § 4542(a)(1), cmc § 4542, retrieved 2026-06-02).
Owner-expiration notice:
- No purchaser-side statutory expiration-notice obligation located. The redemption period is fixed by § 4541 (12 months from sale); the certificate of sale itself “shall state … the period during which the property is subject to redemption” (§ 4537(f)). The redemptioner, not the purchaser, drives the § 4542 redemption petition. needs_verification — no statute requiring the purchaser to notify the owner of impending expiration.
Owner occupancy:
- Legal title remains with the mortgagor during the redemption period (Sablan ¶ 17), but the purchaser is entitled to the rents “from the time of the sale until a redemption … from the tenant in possession” (or the value of use and occupation), credited against the redemption money (2 CMC § 4543(a)). The purchaser may seek a § 4544 injunction against waste and a receiver; the purchaser may not take a deed/possession until redemption lapses (§ 4537(f)).
Costs collectible upon redemption:
- Purchase amount + 1% per month interest, plus (1) assessments/taxes, (2) reasonable fire-insurance, maintenance, upkeep, repair or improvement costs, (3) the fair market value of improvements constructed, and (4) protective payments on prior obligations with interest — less rents/profits the purchaser received (2 CMC §§ 4542(a), 4543(a)). Disputed charges are determined by the court on a 10–20-day-out hearing (§ 4542(b)–(d)).
Property maintenance obligation:
- No affirmative statutory maintenance duty is imposed on the purchaser; the § 4542(a)(2)–(3) reimbursement for maintenance/repairs/improvements is permissive (collectible if incurred), and § 4544 lets the court restrain waste by the party in possession and appoint a receiver. needs_verification — no statute imposing an affirmative purchaser maintenance duty during redemption.
11b. Restrictions & Special Rules
Entity / foreign-purchaser restrictions:
- Art. XII is the controlling restriction — not entity type but NMD status. Permanent and long-term (>55-year) interests may be held only by persons of Northern Marianas descent; corporations qualify as NMD only if NMD-controlled (the constitutional NMD-corporation rules). A non-NMD buyer (foreign or domestic, natural person or entity) may take only a ≤55-year leasehold at a foreclosure sale. (N.M.I. Const. art. XII; wabol-v-villacrusis) Foreign/entity ownership of leaseholds is otherwise open (companies may be 100% foreign-owned, needing a resident agent). (Dotts Law Office, retrieved 2026-06-02) Exact art. XII §§ 4 (NMD definition / blood-quantum) and the NMD-corporation control test → needs_verification (verbatim text not retrieved).
- Insider prohibition: No CMC Title 2 Div. 4 provision barring court personnel or the appointed sale officer from bidding was located. needs_verification.
Mortgagee / full-service-bank exception:
- Art. XII § 2 excepts from the alienation bar “a transfer to a mortgagee by means of a foreclosure on a mortgage … if the mortgagee is a full service bank,” allowing such a lender to take at its own foreclosure. Verbatim § 2 text → needs_verification; corroborated Marianas Living, Dotts Law Office. Section 4537(e)–(f) also expressly preserves a mortgagee’s right to purchase at the sale and to transfer to a federal mortgage insurer.
Right of first refusal / land bank:
- No land-bank program located (no county/municipal structure; single Commonwealth recorder). The Department of Public Lands administers public (government) land, a separate regime from private foreclosure. No private-foreclosure right-of-first-refusal statute located. needs_verification.
Deficiency judgment:
- Permitted after mortgage foreclosure. “Upon the sale of any real property … if there be a balance due to the plaintiff after applying the proceeds of the sale, the court, upon motion, shall give a decree against the defendant for any balance for which … the defendant may be personally liable” (2 CMC § 4537(h)); a $44,514.36 deficiency was entered in Sablan. After a tax sale: N/A (no tax sale).
- Fair-value defense / offset: No statutory fair-value-offset mechanism located in § 4537; the deficiency is the “balance … due” after applying sale proceeds. needs_verification — no anti-deficiency fair-value statute located.
Anti-deficiency statute:
- None located. No CNMI anti-deficiency or purchase-money anti-deficiency statute was found; § 4537(h) authorizes a deficiency decree for the post-sale balance. needs_verification (confirm absence of any narrow anti-deficiency provision).
One-action rule:
- None located. No California-style one-action rule requiring exhaustion of the security before suing on the note was found; § 4537 contemplates a unitary judicial foreclosure with a deficiency decree on motion. needs_verification (confirm absence against a retrieved CNMI source).
12. Forced Sales of Vehicles, Boats, Aircraft, Equipment & Businesses
Module rebuilt 2026-10-18. Bounded final review (2026-10-18), the first independent full pass for the CNMI: every field below was adjudicated against retained full primary texts from cnmilaw.gov; registers and the review are in
schema/verification/northern-mariana-islands-evidence-2026-10-18/andschema/verification/northern-mariana-islands-independent-review-2026-10-18.md.
Hub: assets · Asset pages: motor-vehicles, vessels, aircraft, equipment-and-machinery, businesses-and-going-concerns, court-ordered-administrative-and-creditor-sales · Lien-sale mechanics: towing-storage-and-mechanics-lien-sales, ucc-article-9-dispositions, marina-and-storage-lien-sales-of-vessels · Federal channels: admiralty-arrest-and-marshals-sale, forfeiture-and-government-seizure-sales · Businesses: receivership-sales, equity-interests-stock-llc-charging-orders · State table: personal-property-execution-sales-by-state.
The CNMI is a U.S. commonwealth with its own Superior and Supreme Courts; federal sales (admiralty, bankruptcy, federal judgments) go through the District Court for the Northern Mariana Islands, which has district-court and bankruptcy jurisdiction (48 U.S.C. § 1822). The CNMI keeps the pre-1999 UCC Article 9 and Article 6.
Module identity (statutory homes, officers, notice site).
| Required field | Adjudicated answer | Primary source |
|---|---|---|
| statutory homes › execution › title chapter | 7 CMC Div. 4, chs. 1–2 (money judgments; attachment, execution, orders in aid of judgment, exemptions, §§ 4101–4210); NMI R. Civ. P. 64, 66, 69 send seizure, receiver and execution procedure to Commonwealth law. | 7 CMC § 4101; 7 CMC § 4203; 7 CMC § 4204; 7 CMC § 4201; 7 CMC § 4202; 7 CMC § 4205; 7 CMC § 4206; 7 CMC § 4209; 7 CMC § 4210; NMI R. Civ. P. (eff. Jan. 9, 2019) |
| statutory homes › execution › url | https://cnmilaw.gov/docs/cmc_section/T7/4204.pdf | 7 CMC § 4204 |
| statutory homes › liens › title chapter | 4 CMC Div. 5, ch. 18 (Statutory Liens Act of 2006, §§ 51501–51564: equipment repair, cleaning, vehicles, vessels, storage facilities, hotels, hospitals, Medicaid); 5 CMC Div. 9 (pre-revision Article 9); other liens in 4 CMC §§ 1821, 1862, 1937, 9141, 9326, 9337; 6 CMC § 4109(h); 10 CMC § 30514 (see 12.3). | 4 CMC § 51501; 4 CMC § 51509; 4 CMC § 51510; 4 CMC § 51511; 4 CMC § 51512; 4 CMC § 51513; 4 CMC § 51514; 4 CMC § 51515; 4 CMC § 51516; 4 CMC § 51517; 4 CMC § 51518; 4 CMC § 51519; 4 CMC § 51520; 4 CMC § 51521; 4 CMC § 51522; 5 CMC § 9301; 5 CMC § 9302; 5 CMC § 9306; 5 CMC § 9310; 5 CMC § 9501; 5 CMC § 9503; 5 CMC § 9504; 5 CMC § 9505; 5 CMC § 9506; 5 CMC § 9507; 4 CMC § 1862; 4 CMC § 1863; 4 CMC § 1864; 4 CMC § 1865 |
| statutory homes › liens › url | https://cnmilaw.gov/docs/cmc_section/T4/51511.pdf | 4 CMC § 51511 |
| statutory homes › titles › title chapter | 9 CMC Div. 2, ch. 1 (Bureau of Motor Vehicles registration; § 2103 transfers, as amended by PL 24-35, July 30, 2026); 3 CMC Div. 5, ch. 4 (Department of Public Safety boat numbering, §§ 5421–5432). | 9 CMC § 2101; 9 CMC § 2104; 9 CMC § 2105; 9 CMC § 2107; 9 CMC § 2108; 9 CMC § 2111; 9 CMC § 2103 (as amended by PL 24-35); 3 CMC § 5412; 3 CMC § 5421; 3 CMC § 5424; 3 CMC § 5425; 3 CMC § 5427; 3 CMC § 5428; 3 CMC § 5430; 3 CMC § 5432 |
| statutory homes › titles › url | https://cnmilaw.gov/docs/cmc_section/T9/2101.pdf | 9 CMC § 2101 |
| levying officers | The Director (now Commissioner) of Public Safety, any police officer or other person named in the writ (7 CMC §§ 4201(a), 4204); tax levies by the Secretary of Finance (4 CMC § 1872); drug and contraband forfeitures by the Attorney General (6 CMC §§ 2150, 2303). The District Court for the Northern Mariana Islands has district-court and bankruptcy jurisdiction (48 U.S.C. § 1822) and is a “district court” for ship mortgages (46 U.S.C. § 31301). | 7 CMC § 4201; 7 CMC § 4204; 4 CMC § 1872; 6 CMC § 2150; 6 CMC § 2303; 48 U.S.C. § 1822 (OLRC XML); 46 U.S.C. § 31301 (OLRC XML) |
| statewide notice site › name | None: no statute establishes a Commonwealth legal-notice website (screen of all 7,189 Commonwealth Code section files retrieved from cnmilaw.gov on 2026-10-18). | LRC Commonwealth Code update table |
| statewide notice site › url | Not applicable: no statutory site exists. (not applicable) | LRC Commonwealth Code update table |
| statewide notice site › statute | None; each sale statute sets its own notice (e.g., 7 CMC § 4204(b); 4 CMC §§ 1875(b), 51516(c); 9 CMC § 5808(f)). | 7 CMC § 4204; 4 CMC § 1875; 4 CMC § 51516; 9 CMC § 5808 |
| civil law vocabulary | Common-law and UCC vocabulary (writ, levy, order in aid of judgment, lien, charging order); no civil-law vocabulary. Source notes trace much of 7 CMC to the Trust Territory Code (“8 TTC”). | 7 CMC § 4101; 7 CMC § 4203; 7 CMC § 4204; 7 CMC § 4205; 7 CMC § 4206; 7 CMC § 4209 |
12.1 Court sales of personal property (execution)
How to read this module. Every table row is a required schema field decided against a retained full primary text from the Law Revision Commission’s official site, cnmilaw.gov (all 7,189 Commonwealth Code section files, the NMI Rules of Civil Procedure, the Ports Authority regulations and the complete CNMI Supreme Court opinion set). The old domain cnmilaw.org no longer serves the code. “Default-rule inference” marks an answer derived from a general rule where the specific statute is silent; U — needs_verification marks an unresolved field counted in the composite.
| Required field | Adjudicated answer | Primary source |
|---|---|---|
| writ and levy › how levied | The officer demands payment; if unpaid, takes into possession non-exempt property sufficient to cover the execution, first property already attached, then property the debtor indicates; may remove it to a safe place or put a caretaker in charge, and lists the property (7 CMC § 4204(a)). The debtor may select which exempt property to keep. Certificated securities require actual seizure (5 CMC § 8317(1)). | 7 CMC § 4101; 7 CMC § 4203; 7 CMC § 4204; 5 CMC § 8317 |
| writ and levy › who may levy | The Director of Public Safety, a police officer or other person duly authorized; another authorized person may complete a levy and sale (7 CMC § 4204, (e)). | 7 CMC § 4101; 7 CMC § 4203; 7 CMC § 4204 |
| writ and levy › citation | 7 CMC §§ 4101, 4203–4204; 5 CMC § 8317; NMI R. Civ. P. 69. | 7 CMC § 4101; 7 CMC § 4203; 7 CMC § 4204; 5 CMC § 8317; NMI R. Civ. P. (eff. Jan. 9, 2019) |
| exemptions affecting buyers › motor vehicle › amount | No vehicle category; a vehicle is exempt only if it is “equipment necessary” for the debtor’s usual occupation (7 CMC § 4210(b)), with no dollar cap. | 7 CMC § 4210 |
| exemptions affecting buyers › motor vehicle › citation | 7 CMC § 4210(b). | 7 CMC § 4210 |
| exemptions affecting buyers › tools of trade › amount | All tools, implements, utensils, two work animals and equipment necessary for the debtor’s usual occupation — no dollar cap (7 CMC § 4210(b)). Household goods and four months’ provisions are also exempt (§ 4210(a)); land is exempt except under an order in aid of judgment (§ 4210(c)). | 7 CMC § 4210; 1999 MP 07 |
| exemptions affecting buyers › tools of trade › citation | 7 CMC § 4210; Triple J Saipan v. Rasiang, 1999 MP 7. | 7 CMC § 4210; 1999 MP 07 |
| exemptions affecting buyers › wildcard › amount | None: § 4210 has no wildcard; in an order in aid of judgment the court must leave property and income for reasonable living needs, including clan and lineage obligations (7 CMC § 4205). | 7 CMC § 4210; 7 CMC § 4205; 7 CMC § 4206; 7 CMC § 4209 |
| exemptions affecting buyers › wildcard › citation | 7 CMC §§ 4205, 4210. | 7 CMC § 4210; 7 CMC § 4205; 7 CMC § 4206; 7 CMC § 4209 |
| notice › days before sale | At least seven days before the sale (7 CMC § 4204(b)). | 7 CMC § 4101; 7 CMC § 4203; 7 CMC § 4204 |
| notice › method | Notify the clerk of court, post a written notice, and notify the debtor if found (or the agent who had custody); no newspaper (7 CMC § 4204(b)). Postponements are announced by public declaration (§ 4204(d)). | 7 CMC § 4101; 7 CMC § 4203; 7 CMC § 4204 |
| notice › where | A conspicuous place at or near the local government office on the island where the sale will be held (7 CMC § 4204(b)). | 7 CMC § 4101; 7 CMC § 4203; 7 CMC § 4204 |
| notice › citation | 7 CMC § 4204(b), (d). | 7 CMC § 4101; 7 CMC § 4203; 7 CMC § 4204 |
| sale conduct › place | The day and place set in the notice (7 CMC § 4204(c)). | 7 CMC § 4101; 7 CMC § 4203; 7 CMC § 4204 |
| sale conduct › public auction required | Yes: “public auction to the highest bidder” unless judgment, interest, costs and levy expenses are paid first (7 CMC § 4204(c)). | 7 CMC § 4101; 7 CMC § 4203; 7 CMC § 4204 |
| sale conduct › online allowed | No online authority: the sale is held on the day and at the place set (7 CMC § 4204(c)). | 7 CMC § 4101; 7 CMC § 4203; 7 CMC § 4204 |
| sale conduct › appraisal or minimum bid | None for execution sales (highest bidder, § 4204(c)). By contrast an order in aid of judgment may transfer particular assets “at a price determined by the court” (§ 4206(b)). | 7 CMC § 4101; 7 CMC § 4203; 7 CMC § 4204; 7 CMC § 4205; 7 CMC § 4206; 7 CMC § 4209 |
| sale conduct › citation | 7 CMC §§ 4204(c), 4206(b). | 7 CMC § 4101; 7 CMC § 4203; 7 CMC § 4204; 7 CMC § 4205; 7 CMC § 4206; 7 CMC § 4209 |
| payment terms › deposit | Unresolved: 7 CMC ch. 2 and the NMI Rules of Civil Procedure state no deposit rule. U — needs_verification | 7 CMC § 4101; 7 CMC § 4203; 7 CMC § 4204; NMI R. Civ. P. (eff. Jan. 9, 2019) |
| payment terms › balance due | Unresolved: § 4204(c) deducts fees from “the proceeds of the sale” but sets no time for payment. U — needs_verification | 7 CMC § 4101; 7 CMC § 4203; 7 CMC § 4204 |
| payment terms › credit sales | Unresolved: no statute or rule addresses credit terms. U — needs_verification | 7 CMC § 4101; 7 CMC § 4203; 7 CMC § 4204; NMI R. Civ. P. (eff. Jan. 9, 2019) |
| payment terms › default consequence | Unresolved: no resale or bidder-liability rule for a defaulting purchaser. U — needs_verification | 7 CMC § 4101; 7 CMC § 4203; 7 CMC § 4204; NMI R. Civ. P. (eff. Jan. 9, 2019) |
| payment terms › citation | 7 CMC § 4204(c) (silent on payment terms); NMI R. Civ. P. 69. | 7 CMC § 4101; 7 CMC § 4203; 7 CMC § 4204; NMI R. Civ. P. (eff. Jan. 9, 2019) |
| confirmation › required | No: the officer sells, pays the proceeds out and returns the writ to the court “with a report of his or her doings thereon” (7 CMC § 4204(c)). | 7 CMC § 4101; 7 CMC § 4203; 7 CMC § 4204 |
| confirmation › standard | Not applicable: no confirmation step. (not applicable) | 7 CMC § 4101; 7 CMC § 4203; 7 CMC § 4204 |
| confirmation › citation | 7 CMC § 4204(c). | 7 CMC § 4101; 7 CMC § 4203; 7 CMC § 4204 |
| buyer document › name | None prescribed: ch. 2 has no certificate-of-sale section; the court record is the officer’s return and report (7 CMC § 4204(c)). | 7 CMC § 4101; 7 CMC § 4203; 7 CMC § 4204 |
| buyer document › issued by | Not applicable: no statutory buyer document. (not applicable) | 7 CMC § 4101; 7 CMC § 4203; 7 CMC § 4204 |
| buyer document › citation | 7 CMC § 4204(c). | 7 CMC § 4101; 7 CMC § 4203; 7 CMC § 4204 |
| what buyer takes › debtors interest only | Yes: the writ runs against “the personal property of the party against whom the judgment has been rendered” (7 CMC § 4203), so the buyer takes the debtor’s interest. | 7 CMC § 4101; 7 CMC § 4203; 7 CMC § 4204 |
| what buyer takes › senior liens survive | Yes: a lien creditor takes subject to a perfected security interest (5 CMC § 9301(4)); vehicle security interests are perfected by notation on the certificate of title (9 CMC § 2103(e)); a recorded Commonwealth tax lien primes later purchasers and lien creditors (4 CMC § 1865). Exception: a secured party’s execution on its own judgment is a judicial foreclosure of its security interest (5 CMC § 9501(5)). | 5 CMC § 9301; 5 CMC § 9302; 5 CMC § 9306; 5 CMC § 9310; 5 CMC § 9501; 5 CMC § 9503; 5 CMC § 9504; 5 CMC § 9505; 5 CMC § 9506; 5 CMC § 9507; 9 CMC § 2103 (as amended by PL 24-35); 4 CMC § 1862; 4 CMC § 1863; 4 CMC § 1864; 4 CMC § 1865 |
| what buyer takes › citation | 7 CMC § 4203; 5 CMC §§ 9301(4), 9501(5); 9 CMC § 2103(e); 4 CMC § 1865. | 7 CMC § 4101; 7 CMC § 4203; 7 CMC § 4204; 5 CMC § 9301; 5 CMC § 9302; 5 CMC § 9306; 5 CMC § 9310; 5 CMC § 9501; 5 CMC § 9503; 5 CMC § 9504; 5 CMC § 9505; 5 CMC § 9506; 5 CMC § 9507; 9 CMC § 2103 (as amended by PL 24-35); 4 CMC § 1862; 4 CMC § 1863; 4 CMC § 1864; 4 CMC § 1865 |
| post sale redemption of personalty › exists | No: no redemption after an execution sale of personal property; payment stops the sale only beforehand (7 CMC § 4204(c)). | 7 CMC § 4101; 7 CMC § 4203; 7 CMC § 4204 |
| post sale redemption of personalty › period | Not applicable. (not applicable) | 7 CMC § 4101; 7 CMC § 4203; 7 CMC § 4204 |
| post sale redemption of personalty › amount | Not applicable. (not applicable) | 7 CMC § 4101; 7 CMC § 4203; 7 CMC § 4204 |
| post sale redemption of personalty › citation | 7 CMC § 4204(c). | 7 CMC § 4101; 7 CMC § 4203; 7 CMC § 4204 |
| setting aside › grounds | NMI R. Civ. P. 60(b): the court must relieve from a void judgment, order or proceeding and may relieve for mistake, newly discovered evidence, fraud, satisfaction or other listed reasons; a writ reaching exempt property may be vacated (Triple J Saipan v. Rasiang, 1999 MP 7). | NMI R. Civ. P. (eff. Jan. 9, 2019); 1999 MP 07 |
| setting aside › deadline | Reasonable time; not more than one year for mistake, new evidence or fraud (NMI R. Civ. P. 60(c)). | NMI R. Civ. P. (eff. Jan. 9, 2019) |
| setting aside › citation | NMI R. Civ. P. 60; 1999 MP 7. | NMI R. Civ. P. (eff. Jan. 9, 2019); 1999 MP 07 |
| third party claims › procedure | No statutory third-party claim procedure in 7 CMC ch. 2; the court may release property from attachment or order its sale on application (7 CMC § 4202), and the officer may not take exempt property or property the writ excludes (§ 4201(a)). | 7 CMC § 4201; 7 CMC § 4202 |
| third party claims › citation | 7 CMC §§ 4201–4202. | 7 CMC § 4201; 7 CMC § 4202 |
12.2 Administrative forced sales
| Required field | Adjudicated answer | Primary source |
|---|---|---|
| state tax levy and sale › agency | Secretary of Finance (Division of Revenue and Taxation) for Commonwealth taxes (4 CMC §§ 1851, 1872); the Governor’s delegate for the Northern Marianas Territorial Income Tax, with the Treasury Secretary’s IRC powers (4 CMC § 1701(b)–(c)). | 4 CMC § 1871; 4 CMC § 1872; 4 CMC § 1874; 4 CMC § 1875; 4 CMC § 1876; 4 CMC § 1877; 4 CMC § 1878; 4 CMC § 1881; 4 CMC § 1701; 4 CMC § 1702 |
| state tax levy and sale › notice | Notice of the right to a hearing at least 30 days before the first levy (4 CMC § 1871) and notice of intent at least 30 days before levy (§ 1872(d)); after seizure, notice to the owner or possessor, publication in a generally circulated local newspaper and posting at U.S. Post Offices in the Commonwealth (§ 1875(a)–(b)). | 4 CMC § 1871; 4 CMC § 1872; 4 CMC § 1874; 4 CMC § 1875; 4 CMC § 1876; 4 CMC § 1877; 4 CMC § 1878; 4 CMC § 1881 |
| state tax levy and sale › sale method | Sale 10–40 days after public notice; manner and conditions “reasonable under the circumstances” (4 CMC § 1875(c)–(d)); NMTIT levies use 26 U.S.C. § 6335 (minimum price, public auction or sealed bids). | 4 CMC § 1871; 4 CMC § 1872; 4 CMC § 1874; 4 CMC § 1875; 4 CMC § 1876; 4 CMC § 1877; 4 CMC § 1878; 4 CMC § 1881; 26 U.S.C. § 6335 (OLRC XML) |
| state tax levy and sale › buyer title | Certificate of sale on full payment transfers all the delinquent’s right, title and interest; is authority to the vehicle registrar to record the transfer “in lieu of” the prior certificate; and discharges liens over which the Commonwealth lien had priority (4 CMC §§ 1877(a), 1878(a), (c)). | 4 CMC § 1871; 4 CMC § 1872; 4 CMC § 1874; 4 CMC § 1875; 4 CMC § 1876; 4 CMC § 1877; 4 CMC § 1878; 4 CMC § 1881 |
| state tax levy and sale › citation | 4 CMC §§ 1862–1881; 4 CMC §§ 1701–1702; 26 U.S.C. §§ 6331, 6335, 6339. | 4 CMC § 1862; 4 CMC § 1863; 4 CMC § 1864; 4 CMC § 1865; 4 CMC § 1871; 4 CMC § 1872; 4 CMC § 1874; 4 CMC § 1875; 4 CMC § 1876; 4 CMC § 1877; 4 CMC § 1878; 4 CMC § 1881; 4 CMC § 1701; 4 CMC § 1702; 26 U.S.C. § 6331 (OLRC XML) |
| local tax distraint › applies | No: the only distraint power in the full code is 4 CMC § 1872 (screen of all 7,189 Commonwealth Code section files retrieved from cnmilaw.gov on 2026-10-18); there are no county or municipal levy statutes. | 4 CMC § 1872; LRC Commonwealth Code update table |
| local tax distraint › citation | 4 CMC § 1872. | 4 CMC § 1872 |
| abandoned vehicles › who disposes | The Director (Commissioner) of Public Safety, who removes or orders a licensed garage to remove vehicles in ten listed situations (including 72 hours on a highway or public property) (9 CMC § 5808(b)). On airport roadways the Ports Authority impounds vehicles presumed abandoned after 48 hours unattended (NMIAC § 40-10.1-230). | 9 CMC § 5808; NMIAC § 40-10.1 (CPA Airport Rules) |
| abandoned vehicles › holding period | 10 days after the certified-mail notice (9 CMC § 5808(e)). | 9 CMC § 5808 |
| abandoned vehicles › notice | Certified mail to the legal owner shown in the Bureau’s records within a reasonable time after removal; newspaper notice 10 days before a public sale (9 CMC § 5808(e)–(f)). | 9 CMC § 5808 |
| abandoned vehicles › auction or title transfer | After appraisal: USD 100 or less, sale to a junk dealer for salvage only and not for registration; over USD 100, public sale on 10 days’ newspaper notice; balance after costs paid to the owner or legal owner on claim within six months (9 CMC § 5808(f)). | 9 CMC § 5808 |
| abandoned vehicles › buyer title | Default-rule inference: § 5808 states no free-and-clear clause; the registration expires on the transfer and the buyer must register anew (9 CMC § 2103(c)); a security interest noted on the title continues unless its holder authorized the disposition (5 CMC § 9306(2)). Junk-sale buyers cannot register the vehicle (§ 5808(f)). | 9 CMC § 5808; 9 CMC § 2103 (as amended by PL 24-35); 5 CMC § 9301; 5 CMC § 9302; 5 CMC § 9306; 5 CMC § 9310; 5 CMC § 9501; 5 CMC § 9503; 5 CMC § 9504; 5 CMC § 9505; 5 CMC § 9506; 5 CMC § 9507 |
| abandoned vehicles › restricted buyers | Vehicles appraised at USD 100 or less go only to junk dealers (9 CMC § 5808(f)); no other restriction. | 9 CMC § 5808 |
| abandoned vehicles › citation | 9 CMC §§ 2103, 5808; 5 CMC § 9306; NMIAC § 40-10.1. | 9 CMC § 5808; 9 CMC § 2103 (as amended by PL 24-35); 5 CMC § 9301; 5 CMC § 9302; 5 CMC § 9306; 5 CMC § 9310; 5 CMC § 9501; 5 CMC § 9503; 5 CMC § 9504; 5 CMC § 9505; 5 CMC § 9506; 5 CMC § 9507; NMIAC § 40-10.1 (CPA Airport Rules) |
| derelict or abandoned vessels › agency | Commonwealth Ports Authority Port Superintendent, under the Harbor Regulations adopted under 2 CMC § 2141 (NMIAC § 40-20.1-110(m)(2)). | NMIAC § 40-20.1 (CPA Harbor Regulations); 2 CMC § 2122; 2 CMC § 2141 |
| derelict or abandoned vessels › procedure | The Port Superintendent removes a vessel or floating object that may damage or interfere with a quay or wharf, notifies a known owner in writing (or posts notice if unknown) and, if unclaimed 10 days later, may sell or otherwise dispose of it, applying the proceeds to Ports Authority expenses and crediting the rest to the owner (NMIAC § 40-20.1-110(m)(2)). Abandonment ends the vessel’s certificate of number and must be reported within 15 days (3 CMC §§ 5428(a), 5430). | NMIAC § 40-20.1 (CPA Harbor Regulations); 3 CMC § 5412; 3 CMC § 5421; 3 CMC § 5424; 3 CMC § 5425; 3 CMC § 5427; 3 CMC § 5428; 3 CMC § 5430; 3 CMC § 5432 |
| derelict or abandoned vessels › buyer title | Default-rule inference: the regulation states no free-and-clear clause; a perfected security interest continues absent its holder’s authorization (5 CMC § 9306(2)); the buyer applies for numbering with proof of ownership (3 CMC § 5424(g)). | NMIAC § 40-20.1 (CPA Harbor Regulations); 5 CMC § 9301; 5 CMC § 9302; 5 CMC § 9306; 5 CMC § 9310; 5 CMC § 9501; 5 CMC § 9503; 5 CMC § 9504; 5 CMC § 9505; 5 CMC § 9506; 5 CMC § 9507; 3 CMC § 5412; 3 CMC § 5421; 3 CMC § 5424; 3 CMC § 5425; 3 CMC § 5427; 3 CMC § 5428; 3 CMC § 5430; 3 CMC § 5432 |
| derelict or abandoned vessels › citation | NMIAC § 40-20.1-110(m)(2); 2 CMC § 2141; 3 CMC §§ 5424, 5428, 5430; 5 CMC § 9306. | NMIAC § 40-20.1 (CPA Harbor Regulations); 2 CMC § 2122; 2 CMC § 2141; 3 CMC § 5412; 3 CMC § 5421; 3 CMC § 5424; 3 CMC § 5425; 3 CMC § 5427; 3 CMC § 5428; 3 CMC § 5430; 3 CMC § 5432; 5 CMC § 9301; 5 CMC § 9302; 5 CMC § 9306; 5 CMC § 9310; 5 CMC § 9501; 5 CMC § 9503; 5 CMC § 9504; 5 CMC § 9505; 5 CMC § 9506; 5 CMC § 9507 |
| abandoned aircraft › agency or airport | Commonwealth Ports Authority under its Airport Rules (NMIAC § 40-10.1). | NMIAC § 40-10.1 (CPA Airport Rules); 2 CMC § 2122; 2 CMC § 2141 |
| abandoned aircraft › procedure | An airline’s aircraft, equipment and other property not removed within 30 business days after its letter of authorization is cancelled becomes Authority property, is stored, or is sold at public or private sale, at the Authority’s option, subject to its lien for unpaid charges (NMIAC § 40-10.1-742(a)(2)); an aircraft that damages airport property may be retained under a lien until charges are paid (§ 40-10.1-101(c)). No statute governs other abandoned aircraft. | NMIAC § 40-10.1 (CPA Airport Rules) |
| abandoned aircraft › citation | NMIAC §§ 40-10.1-101(c), 40-10.1-742; 2 CMC § 2141. | NMIAC § 40-10.1 (CPA Airport Rules); 2 CMC § 2122; 2 CMC § 2141 |
| state forfeiture sales › statute | Controlled substances, including conveyances (aircraft, vehicles, vessels) used to transport or conceal them (6 CMC § 2150(a)(4)); contraband imports (6 CMC § 2303, by reference to § 2150); vehicles used in alcoholic-beverage violations (4 CMC §§ 5594, 5596). | 6 CMC § 2150; 6 CMC § 2303; 4 CMC § 5594; 4 CMC § 5596 |
| state forfeiture sales › disposition method | Attorney General may retain, sell, transfer to the supply division or forward to another agency; sale proceeds pay forfeiture costs and the rest goes to the General Fund (6 CMC § 2150(e)). Forfeited alcohol-violation vehicles go to a requesting agency, otherwise public sale ordered by the court (4 CMC § 5596(d)). | 6 CMC § 2150; 4 CMC § 5594; 4 CMC § 5596 |
| state forfeiture sales › lienholder protection | No express secured-party protection in § 2150: it protects common carriers, owners whose conveyance was unlawfully in another’s possession, and innocent owners of moneys and securities (§ 2150(a)(4), (6)); customs-law remission and mitigation provisions apply “insofar as applicable” (§ 2150(d)). An alcohol-violation vehicle is not forfeited if used without the owner’s knowledge or consent, the owner bearing the burden (4 CMC § 5594(b)). | 6 CMC § 2150; 4 CMC § 5594; 4 CMC § 5596 |
| state forfeiture sales › citation | 6 CMC §§ 2150, 2303; 4 CMC §§ 5594–5596. | 6 CMC § 2150; 6 CMC § 2303; 4 CMC § 5594; 4 CMC § 5596 |
12.3 Lienholder sales and statutory liens
Possessory service liens arising in the ordinary course outrank perfected security interests unless their statute says otherwise (5 CMC § 9310); the Statutory Liens Act sets its own caps for vehicles and vessels.
Article 9 overlay (two base fields only).
| Required field | Adjudicated answer | Primary source |
|---|---|---|
| ucc article 9 nonuniform variations › notes | The CNMI keeps the pre-1999 Article 9 (5 CMC §§ 9101 et seq.; the Supreme Court noted it “has not been updated”, 2007 MP 23 n.4). Default: self-help without breach of the peace (§ 9503); public or private disposition, every aspect commercially reasonable, reasonable notice to the debtor and notifying secured parties (§ 9504(3)); purchaser for value takes the debtor’s rights free of the foreclosed and subordinate interests, protected despite noncompliance if without knowledge or collusion at a public sale or in good faith otherwise (§ 9504(4)); 60% consumer compulsory disposition within 90 days and 21-day objection to strict foreclosure (§ 9505); redemption until disposition (§ 9506); consumer minimum damages (§ 9507(1)). Vehicle security interests are perfected only by notation on the certificate of title (9 CMC § 2103(e), PL 24-35). Notice failure is an absolute bar to a deficiency; a commercially unreasonable sale triggers a rebuttable presumption that the collateral equalled the debt (Triple J Saipan v. Sanchez, 2007 MP 23); notice proof was left for remand in Atkins Kroll v. Ferrera, 2019 MP 10. | 5 CMC § 9301; 5 CMC § 9302; 5 CMC § 9306; 5 CMC § 9310; 5 CMC § 9501; 5 CMC § 9503; 5 CMC § 9504; 5 CMC § 9505; 5 CMC § 9506; 5 CMC § 9507; 9 CMC § 2103 (as amended by PL 24-35); 2007 MP 23; 2019 MP 10 |
| ucc article 9 nonuniform variations › citation | 5 CMC §§ 9301–9310, 9501–9507; 9 CMC § 2103(e); 2007 MP 23; 2019 MP 10. | 5 CMC § 9301; 5 CMC § 9302; 5 CMC § 9306; 5 CMC § 9310; 5 CMC § 9501; 5 CMC § 9503; 5 CMC § 9504; 5 CMC § 9505; 5 CMC § 9506; 5 CMC § 9507; 9 CMC § 2103 (as amended by PL 24-35); 2007 MP 23; 2019 MP 10 |
Actual statutory lien/security regimes: 25. Each independently created regime below carries all fifteen required attributes. Asset applications and enforcement branches of one grant are not counted twice; candidate topics that turned out not to be independent personal-property grants are listed after the profiles.
12.3.1 Vehicle towing, storage and repair lien (4 CMC §§ 51511–51522)
| Attribute | Answer | Primary source |
|---|---|---|
| Statute | 4 CMC §§ 51509–51522. | 4 CMC § 51509; 4 CMC § 51510; 4 CMC § 51511; 4 CMC § 51512; 4 CMC § 51513; 4 CMC § 51514; 4 CMC § 51515; 4 CMC § 51516; 4 CMC § 51517; 4 CMC § 51518; 4 CMC § 51519; 4 CMC § 51520; 4 CMC § 51521; 4 CMC § 51522 |
| Who holds it | A person in the business of buying or selling vehicles or keeping a garage or place for storage, maintenance or repair, who stores, maintains, repairs or tows at the owner’s request or consent or at a peace officer’s direction (§ 51511(a)); the lien survives the vehicle leaving the lienholder’s control (§ 51513). | 4 CMC § 51509; 4 CMC § 51510; 4 CMC § 51511; 4 CMC § 51512; 4 CMC § 51513; 4 CMC § 51514; 4 CMC § 51515; 4 CMC § 51516; 4 CMC § 51517; 4 CMC § 51518; 4 CMC § 51519; 4 CMC § 51520; 4 CMC § 51521; 4 CMC § 51522 |
| Priority vs. perfected security interest | Against a secured transaction: towing/storage charges on motor vehicles are a first lien up to USD 1,000 for the first 30 days and up to USD 2,500 after 30 days, otherwise second; all other cases first lien up to USD 1,000, second above (§ 51514). | 4 CMC § 51509; 4 CMC § 51510; 4 CMC § 51511; 4 CMC § 51512; 4 CMC § 51513; 4 CMC § 51514; 4 CMC § 51515; 4 CMC § 51516; 4 CMC § 51517; 4 CMC § 51518; 4 CMC § 51519; 4 CMC § 51520; 4 CMC § 51521; 4 CMC § 51522 |
| Cap / amount secured | The sum due plus enforcement costs (§ 51511(a)); priority caps as in § 51514. | 4 CMC § 51509; 4 CMC § 51510; 4 CMC § 51511; 4 CMC § 51512; 4 CMC § 51513; 4 CMC § 51514; 4 CMC § 51515; 4 CMC § 51516; 4 CMC § 51517; 4 CMC § 51518; 4 CMC § 51519; 4 CMC § 51520; 4 CMC § 51521; 4 CMC § 51522 |
| Court required? | No: the lienholder may detain without process (§ 51511(b)) and sell by auction after notice (§ 51516). | 4 CMC § 51509; 4 CMC § 51510; 4 CMC § 51511; 4 CMC § 51512; 4 CMC § 51513; 4 CMC § 51514; 4 CMC § 51515; 4 CMC § 51516; 4 CMC § 51517; 4 CMC § 51518; 4 CMC § 51519; 4 CMC § 51520; 4 CMC § 51521; 4 CMC § 51522 |
| Notice to owner | In person or registered/certified mail to the legal and registered owner with an itemized claim, description, a payment day at least 10 days out and a statement that the vehicle will be sold at auction (§ 51512). | 4 CMC § 51509; 4 CMC § 51510; 4 CMC § 51511; 4 CMC § 51512; 4 CMC § 51513; 4 CMC § 51514; 4 CMC § 51515; 4 CMC § 51516; 4 CMC § 51517; 4 CMC § 51518; 4 CMC § 51519; 4 CMC § 51520; 4 CMC § 51521; 4 CMC § 51522 |
| Notice to lienholders | Same notice to each holder of a security interest (§ 51512(a)(2)) and to anyone known to claim an interest (§ 51516(a)). | 4 CMC § 51509; 4 CMC § 51510; 4 CMC § 51511; 4 CMC § 51512; 4 CMC § 51513; 4 CMC § 51514; 4 CMC § 51515; 4 CMC § 51516; 4 CMC § 51517; 4 CMC § 51518; 4 CMC § 51519; 4 CMC § 51520; 4 CMC § 51521; 4 CMC § 51522 |
| Registry (DMV/GPD/BMV) notice | Written notice to the Bureau of Motor Vehicles (§ 51516(a)). | 4 CMC § 51509; 4 CMC § 51510; 4 CMC § 51511; 4 CMC § 51512; 4 CMC § 51513; 4 CMC § 51514; 4 CMC § 51515; 4 CMC § 51516; 4 CMC § 51517; 4 CMC § 51518; 4 CMC § 51519; 4 CMC § 51520; 4 CMC § 51521; 4 CMC § 51522 |
| Publication | Newspaper once a week for three consecutive weeks after the payment day (§ 51516(c)). | 4 CMC § 51509; 4 CMC § 51510; 4 CMC § 51511; 4 CMC § 51512; 4 CMC § 51513; 4 CMC § 51514; 4 CMC § 51515; 4 CMC § 51516; 4 CMC § 51517; 4 CMC § 51518; 4 CMC § 51519; 4 CMC § 51520; 4 CMC § 51521; 4 CMC § 51522 |
| Waiting period | Payment day at least 10 days after notice; sale at least 22 days after the first publication (§§ 51512(c), 51516(c)). | 4 CMC § 51509; 4 CMC § 51510; 4 CMC § 51511; 4 CMC § 51512; 4 CMC § 51513; 4 CMC § 51514; 4 CMC § 51515; 4 CMC § 51516; 4 CMC § 51517; 4 CMC § 51518; 4 CMC § 51519; 4 CMC § 51520; 4 CMC § 51521; 4 CMC § 51522 |
| Sale method | Auction where the lien arose or the nearest suitable place; anyone with a property or possessory right may pay off before sale (§§ 51516(b), 51517). | 4 CMC § 51509; 4 CMC § 51510; 4 CMC § 51511; 4 CMC § 51512; 4 CMC § 51513; 4 CMC § 51514; 4 CMC § 51515; 4 CMC § 51516; 4 CMC § 51517; 4 CMC § 51518; 4 CMC § 51519; 4 CMC § 51520; 4 CMC § 51521; 4 CMC § 51522 |
| Buyer’s title / what survives | The lienholder is not liable for failing to redeliver after a lawful sale (§ 51519), and after a sale to an innocent third party the lienholder alone answers for an invalid lien or defective procedure (§ 51520). Default-rule inference: the sale statute has no free-and-clear clause beyond its own protection; a perfected security interest continues in collateral sold without its holder’s authorization (5 CMC § 9306(2)), subject to the lien’s priority. | 4 CMC § 51509; 4 CMC § 51510; 4 CMC § 51511; 4 CMC § 51512; 4 CMC § 51513; 4 CMC § 51514; 4 CMC § 51515; 4 CMC § 51516; 4 CMC § 51517; 4 CMC § 51518; 4 CMC § 51519; 4 CMC § 51520; 4 CMC § 51521; 4 CMC § 51522; 5 CMC § 9301; 5 CMC § 9302; 5 CMC § 9306; 5 CMC § 9310; 5 CMC § 9501; 5 CMC § 9503; 5 CMC § 9504; 5 CMC § 9505; 5 CMC § 9506; 5 CMC § 9507 |
| Surplus | Balance delivered on demand to the person entitled to the vehicle (§ 51516(d)); any deficiency remains recoverable (§ 51518). | 4 CMC § 51509; 4 CMC § 51510; 4 CMC § 51511; 4 CMC § 51512; 4 CMC § 51513; 4 CMC § 51514; 4 CMC § 51515; 4 CMC § 51516; 4 CMC § 51517; 4 CMC § 51518; 4 CMC § 51519; 4 CMC § 51520; 4 CMC § 51521; 4 CMC § 51522 |
| Defective-sale consequence | Lienholder liable to the owner and interest holders (§ 51520); Bureau fines up to USD 2,500 (§ 51521); incurring a bill without authority is a misdemeanor (§ 51522). | 4 CMC § 51509; 4 CMC § 51510; 4 CMC § 51511; 4 CMC § 51512; 4 CMC § 51513; 4 CMC § 51514; 4 CMC § 51515; 4 CMC § 51516; 4 CMC § 51517; 4 CMC § 51518; 4 CMC § 51519; 4 CMC § 51520; 4 CMC § 51521; 4 CMC § 51522 |
| Citation | 4 CMC §§ 51509–51522; 5 CMC § 9306. | 4 CMC § 51509; 4 CMC § 51510; 4 CMC § 51511; 4 CMC § 51512; 4 CMC § 51513; 4 CMC § 51514; 4 CMC § 51515; 4 CMC § 51516; 4 CMC § 51517; 4 CMC § 51518; 4 CMC § 51519; 4 CMC § 51520; 4 CMC § 51521; 4 CMC § 51522; 5 CMC § 9301; 5 CMC § 9302; 5 CMC § 9306; 5 CMC § 9310; 5 CMC § 9501; 5 CMC § 9503; 5 CMC § 9504; 5 CMC § 9505; 5 CMC § 9506; 5 CMC § 9507 |
12.3.2 Vessel lien for wages and for storage, repair and slip services (4 CMC §§ 51524–51532)
| Attribute | Answer | Primary source |
|---|---|---|
| Statute | 4 CMC §§ 51523–51532. | 4 CMC § 51523; 4 CMC § 51524; 4 CMC § 51525; 4 CMC § 51526; 4 CMC § 51527; 4 CMC § 51528; 4 CMC § 51529; 4 CMC § 51530; 4 CMC § 51531 |
| Who holds it | Persons employed on board, for wages; and businesses buying, selling, storing, maintaining or repairing vessels or renting vessel spaces, at the owner’s request or a peace officer’s direction (§ 51524(a)–(b)). | 4 CMC § 51523; 4 CMC § 51524; 4 CMC § 51525; 4 CMC § 51526; 4 CMC § 51527; 4 CMC § 51528; 4 CMC § 51529; 4 CMC § 51530; 4 CMC § 51531 |
| Priority vs. perfected security interest | To the extent the lien or liens exceed USD 1,000, they are “secondary to a perfected security interest in the vessel” (§ 51525(c)); wage liens rank ahead of service liens (§ 51524(d)). Documented vessels: federal priorities apply in an in rem sale (46 U.S.C. § 31326). | 4 CMC § 51523; 4 CMC § 51524; 4 CMC § 51525; 4 CMC § 51526; 4 CMC § 51527; 4 CMC § 51528; 4 CMC § 51529; 4 CMC § 51530; 4 CMC § 51531; 46 U.S.C. § 31326 (OLRC XML) |
| Cap / amount secured | Sum due plus enforcement costs (§ 51524(b)); priority over a perfected lender only up to USD 1,000 (§ 51525(c)). | 4 CMC § 51523; 4 CMC § 51524; 4 CMC § 51525; 4 CMC § 51526; 4 CMC § 51527; 4 CMC § 51528; 4 CMC § 51529; 4 CMC § 51530; 4 CMC § 51531 |
| Court required? | No: detention and, if removed, seizure “without further process of law” (§§ 51524(c), 51525(b)), then auction (§ 51527). | 4 CMC § 51523; 4 CMC § 51524; 4 CMC § 51525; 4 CMC § 51526; 4 CMC § 51527; 4 CMC § 51528; 4 CMC § 51529; 4 CMC § 51530; 4 CMC § 51531 |
| Notice to owner | In person or registered/certified letter with claim, description, payment day at least 10 days out and auction statement (§ 51527(a)–(d)). | 4 CMC § 51523; 4 CMC § 51524; 4 CMC § 51525; 4 CMC § 51526; 4 CMC § 51527; 4 CMC § 51528; 4 CMC § 51529; 4 CMC § 51530; 4 CMC § 51531 |
| Notice to lienholders | To any other person known to have or claim an interest (§ 51527(a)). | 4 CMC § 51523; 4 CMC § 51524; 4 CMC § 51525; 4 CMC § 51526; 4 CMC § 51527; 4 CMC § 51528; 4 CMC § 51529; 4 CMC § 51530; 4 CMC § 51531 |
| Registry (DMV/GPD/BMV) notice | None prescribed (no registry notice in § 51527). | 4 CMC § 51523; 4 CMC § 51524; 4 CMC § 51525; 4 CMC § 51526; 4 CMC § 51527; 4 CMC § 51528; 4 CMC § 51529; 4 CMC § 51530; 4 CMC § 51531 |
| Publication | Newspaper once a week for three consecutive weeks (§ 51527(f)). | 4 CMC § 51523; 4 CMC § 51524; 4 CMC § 51525; 4 CMC § 51526; 4 CMC § 51527; 4 CMC § 51528; 4 CMC § 51529; 4 CMC § 51530; 4 CMC § 51531 |
| Waiting period | Sale not less than 22 days after first publication (§ 51527(f)). | 4 CMC § 51523; 4 CMC § 51524; 4 CMC § 51525; 4 CMC § 51526; 4 CMC § 51527; 4 CMC § 51528; 4 CMC § 51529; 4 CMC § 51530; 4 CMC § 51531 |
| Sale method | Auction where the lien arose or the nearest suitable place; payoff before sale (§§ 51527(e), 51528). | 4 CMC § 51523; 4 CMC § 51524; 4 CMC § 51525; 4 CMC § 51526; 4 CMC § 51527; 4 CMC § 51528; 4 CMC § 51529; 4 CMC § 51530; 4 CMC § 51531 |
| Buyer’s title / what survives | Lawful sale releases the lienholder (§ 51530) and after a sale to an innocent third party the lienholder alone answers for an invalid lien or defective procedure (§ 51531). Default-rule inference: the sale statute has no free-and-clear clause beyond its own protection; a perfected security interest continues in collateral sold without its holder’s authorization (5 CMC § 9306(2)), subject to the lien’s priority. | 4 CMC § 51523; 4 CMC § 51524; 4 CMC § 51525; 4 CMC § 51526; 4 CMC § 51527; 4 CMC § 51528; 4 CMC § 51529; 4 CMC § 51530; 4 CMC § 51531; 5 CMC § 9301; 5 CMC § 9302; 5 CMC § 9306; 5 CMC § 9310; 5 CMC § 9501; 5 CMC § 9503; 5 CMC § 9504; 5 CMC § 9505; 5 CMC § 9506; 5 CMC § 9507 |
| Surplus | Balance delivered on demand to the person entitled to the vessel (§ 51527(g)). | 4 CMC § 51523; 4 CMC § 51524; 4 CMC § 51525; 4 CMC § 51526; 4 CMC § 51527; 4 CMC § 51528; 4 CMC § 51529; 4 CMC § 51530; 4 CMC § 51531 |
| Defective-sale consequence | Lienholder liability (§ 51531); unauthorized bills are a misdemeanor (§ 51532). | 4 CMC § 51523; 4 CMC § 51524; 4 CMC § 51525; 4 CMC § 51526; 4 CMC § 51527; 4 CMC § 51528; 4 CMC § 51529; 4 CMC § 51530; 4 CMC § 51531 |
| Citation | 4 CMC §§ 51523–51532; 46 U.S.C. § 31326. | 4 CMC § 51523; 4 CMC § 51524; 4 CMC § 51525; 4 CMC § 51526; 4 CMC § 51527; 4 CMC § 51528; 4 CMC § 51529; 4 CMC § 51530; 4 CMC § 51531; 46 U.S.C. § 31326 (OLRC XML) |
12.3.3 Self-service storage facility lien (4 CMC §§ 51533–51544)
| Attribute | Answer | Primary source |
|---|---|---|
| Statute | 4 CMC §§ 51533–51544. | 4 CMC § 51533; 4 CMC § 51535; 4 CMC § 51536; 4 CMC § 51537; 4 CMC § 51538; 4 CMC § 51539; 4 CMC § 51540; 4 CMC § 51541; 4 CMC § 51542; 4 CMC § 51543; 4 CMC § 51544 |
| Who holds it | The facility owner, for rent, labor and agreement charges and preservation and sale expenses; the rental agreement must warn of the lien and carry an alternative address or the lien does not attach (§§ 51535(a), 51536). | 4 CMC § 51533; 4 CMC § 51535; 4 CMC § 51536; 4 CMC § 51537; 4 CMC § 51538; 4 CMC § 51539; 4 CMC § 51540; 4 CMC § 51541; 4 CMC § 51542; 4 CMC § 51543; 4 CMC § 51544 |
| Priority vs. perfected security interest | Any lien created by a document of title for a motor vehicle or vessel has priority (§ 51535(b)); a perfected secured party may take the property by paying the storage charges if no opposition was filed (§ 51541); for other collateral 5 CMC § 9310 applies. | 4 CMC § 51533; 4 CMC § 51535; 4 CMC § 51536; 4 CMC § 51537; 4 CMC § 51538; 4 CMC § 51539; 4 CMC § 51540; 4 CMC § 51541; 4 CMC § 51542; 4 CMC § 51543; 4 CMC § 51544; 5 CMC § 9301; 5 CMC § 9302; 5 CMC § 9306; 5 CMC § 9310; 5 CMC § 9501; 5 CMC § 9503; 5 CMC § 9504; 5 CMC § 9505; 5 CMC § 9506; 5 CMC § 9507 |
| Cap / amount secured | Charges under the rental agreement and enforcement expenses (§ 51535(a)). | 4 CMC § 51533; 4 CMC § 51535; 4 CMC § 51536; 4 CMC § 51537; 4 CMC § 51538; 4 CMC § 51539; 4 CMC § 51540; 4 CMC § 51541; 4 CMC § 51542; 4 CMC § 51543; 4 CMC § 51544 |
| Court required? | No, unless the occupant returns a sworn declaration of opposition; then the owner must sue and may sell only more than 10 days after notice of entry of judgment (§§ 51539, 51543). | 4 CMC § 51533; 4 CMC § 51535; 4 CMC § 51536; 4 CMC § 51537; 4 CMC § 51538; 4 CMC § 51539; 4 CMC § 51540; 4 CMC § 51541; 4 CMC § 51542; 4 CMC § 51543; 4 CMC § 51544 |
| Notice to owner | After 14 days unpaid, certified mail terminating use at least 14 days later (§ 51537); then certified notice of sale at least 14 days before, with a blank declaration of opposition (§ 51538). | 4 CMC § 51533; 4 CMC § 51535; 4 CMC § 51536; 4 CMC § 51537; 4 CMC § 51538; 4 CMC § 51539; 4 CMC § 51540; 4 CMC § 51541; 4 CMC § 51542; 4 CMC § 51543; 4 CMC § 51544 |
| Notice to lienholders | None required by the article. | 4 CMC § 51533; 4 CMC § 51535; 4 CMC § 51536; 4 CMC § 51537; 4 CMC § 51538; 4 CMC § 51539; 4 CMC § 51540; 4 CMC § 51541; 4 CMC § 51542; 4 CMC § 51543; 4 CMC § 51544 |
| Registry (DMV/GPD/BMV) notice | None prescribed. | 4 CMC § 51533; 4 CMC § 51535; 4 CMC § 51536; 4 CMC § 51537; 4 CMC § 51538; 4 CMC § 51539; 4 CMC § 51540; 4 CMC § 51541; 4 CMC § 51542; 4 CMC § 51543; 4 CMC § 51544 |
| Publication | Newspaper once a week for two consecutive weeks immediately before the sale, or six postings 10 days before if no newspaper (§ 51540(b)–(c)). | 4 CMC § 51533; 4 CMC § 51535; 4 CMC § 51536; 4 CMC § 51537; 4 CMC § 51538; 4 CMC § 51539; 4 CMC § 51540; 4 CMC § 51541; 4 CMC § 51542; 4 CMC § 51543; 4 CMC § 51544 |
| Waiting period | 14 days unpaid, 14 days to termination, at least 14 days’ sale notice (§§ 51537–51538). | 4 CMC § 51533; 4 CMC § 51535; 4 CMC § 51536; 4 CMC § 51537; 4 CMC § 51538; 4 CMC § 51539; 4 CMC § 51540; 4 CMC § 51541; 4 CMC § 51542; 4 CMC § 51543; 4 CMC § 51544 |
| Sale method | Commercially reasonable sale (§ 51540(d)); a payoff before sale stops it, the property then held pending court order (§ 51542). | 4 CMC § 51533; 4 CMC § 51535; 4 CMC § 51536; 4 CMC § 51537; 4 CMC § 51538; 4 CMC § 51539; 4 CMC § 51540; 4 CMC § 51541; 4 CMC § 51542; 4 CMC § 51543; 4 CMC § 51544 |
| Buyer’s title / what survives | A good-faith purchaser takes free of the occupant’s interests even if the owner failed to comply (§ 51544); vehicle and vessel title liens rank ahead (§ 51535(b)) and other perfected interests continue absent authorization (5 CMC § 9306(2)). | 4 CMC § 51533; 4 CMC § 51535; 4 CMC § 51536; 4 CMC § 51537; 4 CMC § 51538; 4 CMC § 51539; 4 CMC § 51540; 4 CMC § 51541; 4 CMC § 51542; 4 CMC § 51543; 4 CMC § 51544; 5 CMC § 9301; 5 CMC § 9302; 5 CMC § 9306; 5 CMC § 9310; 5 CMC § 9501; 5 CMC § 9503; 5 CMC § 9504; 5 CMC § 9505; 5 CMC § 9506; 5 CMC § 9507 |
| Surplus | Held for the occupant for one year, then paid to the Commonwealth Treasurer (§§ 51538(c), 51540(e)). | 4 CMC § 51533; 4 CMC § 51535; 4 CMC § 51536; 4 CMC § 51537; 4 CMC § 51538; 4 CMC § 51539; 4 CMC § 51540; 4 CMC § 51541; 4 CMC § 51542; 4 CMC § 51543; 4 CMC § 51544 |
| Defective-sale consequence | Occupant’s remedies against the owner; the good-faith buyer is protected (§ 51544); the owner is not liable to others if it complied (§ 51541(b)). | 4 CMC § 51533; 4 CMC § 51535; 4 CMC § 51536; 4 CMC § 51537; 4 CMC § 51538; 4 CMC § 51539; 4 CMC § 51540; 4 CMC § 51541; 4 CMC § 51542; 4 CMC § 51543; 4 CMC § 51544 |
| Citation | 4 CMC §§ 51533–51544; 5 CMC §§ 9306, 9310. | 4 CMC § 51533; 4 CMC § 51535; 4 CMC § 51536; 4 CMC § 51537; 4 CMC § 51538; 4 CMC § 51539; 4 CMC § 51540; 4 CMC § 51541; 4 CMC § 51542; 4 CMC § 51543; 4 CMC § 51544; 5 CMC § 9301; 5 CMC § 9302; 5 CMC § 9306; 5 CMC § 9310; 5 CMC § 9501; 5 CMC § 9503; 5 CMC § 9504; 5 CMC § 9505; 5 CMC § 9506; 5 CMC § 9507 |
12.3.4 Equipment, appliance and jewelry repair lien (4 CMC § 51502)
| Attribute | Answer | Primary source |
|---|---|---|
| Statute | 4 CMC § 51502. | 4 CMC § 51502 |
| Who holds it | A person performing work on the listed articles for a price, for the account and materials (§ 51502(a)). | 4 CMC § 51502 |
| Priority vs. perfected security interest | A possessory lien for services or materials furnished in the ordinary course outranks a perfected security interest unless the creating statute expressly provides otherwise (5 CMC § 9310). | 4 CMC § 51502; 5 CMC § 9301; 5 CMC § 9302; 5 CMC § 9306; 5 CMC § 9310; 5 CMC § 9501; 5 CMC § 9503; 5 CMC § 9504; 5 CMC § 9505; 5 CMC § 9506; 5 CMC § 9507 |
| Cap / amount secured | The account for work and the value or agreed price of materials (§ 51502(a)). | 4 CMC § 51502 |
| Court required? | No: sale after notice; the lienholder may instead waive the lien and sue (§ 51502(b), (e)). | 4 CMC § 51502 |
| Notice to owner | 30 days’ written notice stating the amount and the right to redeem, by registered or certified mail, or posting in two public places on the island if the owner is unknown (§ 51502(b)–(c)). | 4 CMC § 51502 |
| Notice to lienholders | None required. | 4 CMC § 51502 |
| Registry (DMV/GPD/BMV) notice | Not applicable: the listed articles are not registered. (not applicable) | 4 CMC § 51502 |
| Publication | None; posting only when the owner is unknown (§ 51502(c)). | 4 CMC § 51502 |
| Waiting period | Account unpaid one year after completion, then 30 days’ notice (§ 51502(b)). | 4 CMC § 51502 |
| Sale method | Public or bona fide private sale (§ 51502(b)). | 4 CMC § 51502 |
| Buyer’s title / what survives | Default-rule inference: the sale statute has no free-and-clear clause beyond its own protection; a perfected security interest continues in collateral sold without its holder’s authorization (5 CMC § 9306(2)), subject to the lien’s priority. | 4 CMC § 51502; 5 CMC § 9301; 5 CMC § 9302; 5 CMC § 9306; 5 CMC § 9310; 5 CMC § 9501; 5 CMC § 9503; 5 CMC § 9504; 5 CMC § 9505; 5 CMC § 9506; 5 CMC § 9507 |
| Surplus | After expenses and the debt, the balance is paid to the owner (§ 51502(d)). | 4 CMC § 51502 |
| Defective-sale consequence | No statutory buyer cure; a sale without the required notice is outside the statutory power and leaves the lienholder liable to the owner in damages. | 4 CMC § 51502 |
| Citation | 4 CMC § 51502; 5 CMC §§ 9306, 9310. | 4 CMC § 51502; 5 CMC § 9301; 5 CMC § 9302; 5 CMC § 9306; 5 CMC § 9310; 5 CMC § 9501; 5 CMC § 9503; 5 CMC § 9504; 5 CMC § 9505; 5 CMC § 9506; 5 CMC § 9507 |
12.3.5 Hotel, motel and lodging-house lien (4 CMC §§ 51545–51547)
| Attribute | Answer | Primary source |
|---|---|---|
| Statute | 4 CMC §§ 51545–51547. | 4 CMC § 51545; 4 CMC § 51546; 4 CMC § 51547 |
| Who holds it | Hotel, inn, motel or lodging proprietors and room letters, on property of a guest, boarder or tenant brought in, for lodging, rent, advances and extras; tools of trade and work uniforms exempt (§ 51545(a)–(b)). | 4 CMC § 51545; 4 CMC § 51546; 4 CMC § 51547 |
| Priority vs. perfected security interest | No express ranking; 5 CMC § 9310 gives possessory liens for services priority over a perfected security interest unless the statute provides otherwise. | 4 CMC § 51545; 4 CMC § 51546; 4 CMC § 51547; 5 CMC § 9301; 5 CMC § 9302; 5 CMC § 9306; 5 CMC § 9310; 5 CMC § 9501; 5 CMC § 9503; 5 CMC § 9504; 5 CMC § 9505; 5 CMC § 9506; 5 CMC § 9507 |
| Cap / amount secured | Amounts due plus enforcement costs (§ 51545(a)). | 4 CMC § 51545; 4 CMC § 51546; 4 CMC § 51547 |
| Court required? | No: foreclosure by public auction any time after 30 days’ default (§§ 51545(c), 51547). | 4 CMC § 51545; 4 CMC § 51546; 4 CMC § 51547 |
| Notice to owner | A copy of the sale notice delivered to a known owner residing locally, otherwise mailed to the last known residence (§ 51547(d)). | 4 CMC § 51545; 4 CMC § 51546; 4 CMC § 51547 |
| Notice to lienholders | None required. | 4 CMC § 51545; 4 CMC § 51546; 4 CMC § 51547 |
| Registry (DMV/GPD/BMV) notice | None prescribed. | 4 CMC § 51545; 4 CMC § 51546; 4 CMC § 51547 |
| Publication | Newspaper once a week for two successive weeks, or posting in three public places 10 days before (§ 51547(b)). | 4 CMC § 51545; 4 CMC § 51546; 4 CMC § 51547 |
| Waiting period | 30 days after default; 60 days for baggage left behind (§§ 51545(c), 51546). | 4 CMC § 51545; 4 CMC § 51546; 4 CMC § 51547 |
| Sale method | Public auction; a sale without the required notice is invalid (§ 51547(a)–(b)). | 4 CMC § 51545; 4 CMC § 51546; 4 CMC § 51547 |
| Buyer’s title / what survives | Default-rule inference: the sale statute has no free-and-clear clause beyond its own protection; a perfected security interest continues in collateral sold without its holder’s authorization (5 CMC § 9306(2)), subject to the lien’s priority. | 4 CMC § 51545; 4 CMC § 51546; 4 CMC § 51547; 5 CMC § 9301; 5 CMC § 9302; 5 CMC § 9306; 5 CMC § 9310; 5 CMC § 9501; 5 CMC § 9503; 5 CMC § 9504; 5 CMC § 9505; 5 CMC § 9506; 5 CMC § 9507 |
| Surplus | Residue paid to the “county treasurer” and then the “county school district fund”, reclaimable within six months (§ 51547(e)); the statute keeps this mainland wording, and the CNMI has no counties, so the Commonwealth officer who receives it is not named. | 4 CMC § 51545; 4 CMC § 51546; 4 CMC § 51547 |
| Defective-sale consequence | No sale is valid without the published or posted notice (§ 51547(b)). | 4 CMC § 51545; 4 CMC § 51546; 4 CMC § 51547 |
| Citation | 4 CMC §§ 51545–51547; 5 CMC §§ 9306, 9310. | 4 CMC § 51545; 4 CMC § 51546; 4 CMC § 51547; 5 CMC § 9301; 5 CMC § 9302; 5 CMC § 9306; 5 CMC § 9310; 5 CMC § 9501; 5 CMC § 9503; 5 CMC § 9504; 5 CMC § 9505; 5 CMC § 9506; 5 CMC § 9507 |
12.3.6 Commonwealth tax lien (4 CMC § 1862)
| Attribute | Answer | Primary source |
|---|---|---|
| Statute | 4 CMC §§ 1861–1882. | 4 CMC § 1862; 4 CMC § 1863; 4 CMC § 1864; 4 CMC § 1865; 4 CMC § 1871; 4 CMC § 1872; 4 CMC § 1874; 4 CMC § 1875; 4 CMC § 1876; 4 CMC § 1877; 4 CMC § 1878; 4 CMC § 1881 |
| Who holds it | The Commonwealth, on all property and rights to property of a person who neglects or refuses to pay after demand, from assessment (§§ 1862–1863). | 4 CMC § 1862; 4 CMC § 1863; 4 CMC § 1864; 4 CMC § 1865 |
| Priority vs. perfected security interest | Not prior to a bona fide secured party, purchaser, judgment lien creditor or other encumbrancer for value unless recorded with the Commonwealth Recorder first or the competitor had actual notice; a competing interest must itself be properly perfected (§§ 1864–1865). | 4 CMC § 1862; 4 CMC § 1863; 4 CMC § 1864; 4 CMC § 1865 |
| Cap / amount secured | Tax, interest, additions, penalties and costs (§ 1862). | 4 CMC § 1862; 4 CMC § 1863; 4 CMC § 1864; 4 CMC § 1865 |
| Court required? | No: administrative levy and sale (§§ 1872, 1875). | 4 CMC § 1871; 4 CMC § 1872; 4 CMC § 1874; 4 CMC § 1875; 4 CMC § 1876; 4 CMC § 1877; 4 CMC § 1878; 4 CMC § 1881 |
| Notice to owner | Lien-filing notice within 5 business days with a 30-day hearing right (§ 1861); pre-levy hearing notice and notice of intent 30 days before levy (§§ 1871, 1872(d)); seizure and sale notices (§ 1875(a)–(b)). | 4 CMC § 1871; 4 CMC § 1872; 4 CMC § 1874; 4 CMC § 1875; 4 CMC § 1876; 4 CMC § 1877; 4 CMC § 1878; 4 CMC § 1881; 4 CMC § 1861 |
| Notice to lienholders | No individual notice; recorded lien and public sale notice (§§ 1864, 1875(b)). | 4 CMC § 1862; 4 CMC § 1863; 4 CMC § 1864; 4 CMC § 1865; 4 CMC § 1871; 4 CMC § 1872; 4 CMC § 1874; 4 CMC § 1875; 4 CMC § 1876; 4 CMC § 1877; 4 CMC § 1878; 4 CMC § 1881 |
| Registry (DMV/GPD/BMV) notice | None before sale; the certificate is authority for the registrar to record the transfer (§ 1878(a)(5)). | 4 CMC § 1871; 4 CMC § 1872; 4 CMC § 1874; 4 CMC § 1875; 4 CMC § 1876; 4 CMC § 1877; 4 CMC § 1878; 4 CMC § 1881 |
| Publication | Generally circulated local newspaper and posting at U.S. Post Offices (§ 1875(b)). | 4 CMC § 1871; 4 CMC § 1872; 4 CMC § 1874; 4 CMC § 1875; 4 CMC § 1876; 4 CMC § 1877; 4 CMC § 1878; 4 CMC § 1881 |
| Waiting period | Levy 10 days after demand and 30 days after notice (§ 1872); sale 10–40 days after public notice (§ 1875(c)). | 4 CMC § 1871; 4 CMC § 1872; 4 CMC § 1874; 4 CMC § 1875; 4 CMC § 1876; 4 CMC § 1877; 4 CMC § 1878; 4 CMC § 1881 |
| Sale method | Manner and conditions reasonable under the circumstances; indivisible property sold whole (§ 1875(d)); pre-sale redemption by payment (§ 1876(a)). | 4 CMC § 1871; 4 CMC § 1872; 4 CMC § 1874; 4 CMC § 1875; 4 CMC § 1876; 4 CMC § 1877; 4 CMC § 1878; 4 CMC § 1881 |
| Buyer’s title / what survives | Certificate of sale transfers all the delinquent’s interest and discharges liens over which the Commonwealth lien had priority (§§ 1877(a), 1878(a), (c)). | 4 CMC § 1871; 4 CMC § 1872; 4 CMC § 1874; 4 CMC § 1875; 4 CMC § 1876; 4 CMC § 1877; 4 CMC § 1878; 4 CMC § 1881 |
| Surplus | Expenses, specific tax, then the liability; surplus refunded on application and proof to the person legally entitled (§ 1881). | 4 CMC § 1871; 4 CMC § 1872; 4 CMC § 1874; 4 CMC § 1875; 4 CMC § 1876; 4 CMC § 1877; 4 CMC § 1878; 4 CMC § 1881 |
| Defective-sale consequence | Certificate is prima facie evidence of the right to sell and conclusive evidence of regularity (§ 1878(a)(1)); wrongfully levied property or its proceeds may be returned within 9 months (§ 1882(b)). | 4 CMC § 1871; 4 CMC § 1872; 4 CMC § 1874; 4 CMC § 1875; 4 CMC § 1876; 4 CMC § 1877; 4 CMC § 1878; 4 CMC § 1881; 4 CMC § 1882 |
| Citation | 4 CMC §§ 1861–1882. | 4 CMC § 1862; 4 CMC § 1863; 4 CMC § 1864; 4 CMC § 1865; 4 CMC § 1871; 4 CMC § 1872; 4 CMC § 1874; 4 CMC § 1875; 4 CMC § 1876; 4 CMC § 1877; 4 CMC § 1878; 4 CMC § 1881; 4 CMC § 1861; 4 CMC § 1882 |
12.3.7 Northern Marianas Territorial Income Tax lien (4 CMC §§ 1701–1702, adopting 26 U.S.C. § 6321)
| Attribute | Answer | Primary source |
|---|---|---|
| Statute | 4 CMC §§ 1701–1702; 26 U.S.C. §§ 6321, 6323, 6330, 6331, 6335, 6338, 6339, 6342. | 4 CMC § 1701; 4 CMC § 1702; 26 U.S.C. § 6321 (OLRC XML) |
| Who holds it | The Commonwealth, on all property and rights to property of a person who neglects or refuses to pay after demand (§ 6321 as adopted). | 4 CMC § 1701; 4 CMC § 1702; 26 U.S.C. § 6321 (OLRC XML) |
| Priority vs. perfected security interest | Not valid against a purchaser, holder of a security interest, mechanic’s lienor or judgment lien creditor until notice is filed (§ 6323(a)). | 26 U.S.C. § 6323 (OLRC XML) |
| Cap / amount secured | Tax, interest, penalties and costs (§ 6321). | 26 U.S.C. § 6321 (OLRC XML) |
| Court required? | No: administrative levy and sale (§§ 6331, 6335). | 26 U.S.C. § 6331 (OLRC XML) |
| Notice to owner | Notice of intent and collection-hearing rights (§§ 6330, 6331(d)); seizure and sale notices (§ 6335(a)–(b)). | 26 U.S.C. § 6330 (OLRC XML) |
| Notice to lienholders | Public sale notice; filed lien notice is the record (§§ 6323, 6335(b)). | 26 U.S.C. § 6323 (OLRC XML) |
| Registry (DMV/GPD/BMV) notice | None before sale; certificate is authority for the vehicle registrar (§ 6339(a)(5)). | 26 U.S.C. § 6339 (OLRC XML) |
| Publication | Newspaper or posting (§ 6335(b)). | 26 U.S.C. § 6335 (OLRC XML) |
| Waiting period | Sale 10–40 days after public notice (§ 6335(d)). | 26 U.S.C. § 6335 (OLRC XML) |
| Sale method | Minimum price; public auction or sealed bids (§ 6335(e)). | 26 U.S.C. § 6335 (OLRC XML) |
| Buyer’s title / what survives | Delinquent’s interest; junior interests discharged (§§ 6338, 6339(a), (c)). | 26 U.S.C. § 6338 (OLRC XML) |
| Surplus | Surplus to the person legally entitled on application (§ 6342(b)). | 26 U.S.C. § 6342 (OLRC XML) |
| Defective-sale consequence | Certificate is prima facie evidence of the right to sell and conclusive evidence of regularity (§ 6339(a)(1)). | 26 U.S.C. § 6339 (OLRC XML) |
| Citation | 4 CMC §§ 1701–1702; 26 U.S.C. §§ 6321–6342 (OLRC 119-121). | 4 CMC § 1701; 4 CMC § 1702; 26 U.S.C. § 6321 (OLRC XML) |
12.3.8 Employer withholding-tax lien (4 CMC § 1821(c))
| Attribute | Answer | Primary source |
|---|---|---|
| Statute | 4 CMC § 1821(c). | 4 CMC § 1821; 4 CMC § 1862; 4 CMC § 1863; 4 CMC § 1864; 4 CMC § 1865 |
| Who holds it | The Commonwealth, against an employer that fails to withhold or pay over wage and salary tax, on the employer’s entire assets, whether or not trust funds were commingled. | 4 CMC § 1821; 4 CMC § 1862; 4 CMC § 1863; 4 CMC § 1864; 4 CMC § 1865 |
| Priority vs. perfected security interest | Validity and priority are governed by the Commonwealth tax-lien rules: not prior to bona fide secured parties or purchasers unless recorded first or known (4 CMC § 1865). | 4 CMC § 1821; 4 CMC § 1862; 4 CMC § 1863; 4 CMC § 1864; 4 CMC § 1865 |
| Cap / amount secured | The unpaid withholding tax (§ 1821(c)). | 4 CMC § 1821; 4 CMC § 1862; 4 CMC § 1863; 4 CMC § 1864; 4 CMC § 1865 |
| Court required? | No: collected like other Commonwealth taxes by levy and sale (4 CMC §§ 1872, 1875). | 4 CMC § 1821; 4 CMC § 1862; 4 CMC § 1863; 4 CMC § 1864; 4 CMC § 1865 |
| Notice to owner | Tax notices under 4 CMC §§ 1861, 1871. | 4 CMC § 1821; 4 CMC § 1862; 4 CMC § 1863; 4 CMC § 1864; 4 CMC § 1865 |
| Notice to lienholders | Not applicable: no lienholder sale. (not applicable) | 4 CMC § 1821; 4 CMC § 1862; 4 CMC § 1863; 4 CMC § 1864; 4 CMC § 1865 |
| Registry (DMV/GPD/BMV) notice | Not applicable: no registry step. (not applicable) | 4 CMC § 1821; 4 CMC § 1862; 4 CMC § 1863; 4 CMC § 1864; 4 CMC § 1865 |
| Publication | Not applicable: no lienholder sale. (not applicable) | 4 CMC § 1821; 4 CMC § 1862; 4 CMC § 1863; 4 CMC § 1864; 4 CMC § 1865 |
| Waiting period | Not applicable: no lienholder sale. (not applicable) | 4 CMC § 1821; 4 CMC § 1862; 4 CMC § 1863; 4 CMC § 1864; 4 CMC § 1865 |
| Sale method | Administrative levy and sale under 4 CMC §§ 1872–1878; the lien statute itself states no separate sale. | 4 CMC § 1821; 4 CMC § 1862; 4 CMC § 1863; 4 CMC § 1864; 4 CMC § 1865; 7 CMC § 4101; 7 CMC § 4203; 7 CMC § 4204 |
| Buyer’s title / what survives | Not applicable: an execution buyer takes under 12.1. (not applicable) | 4 CMC § 1821; 4 CMC § 1862; 4 CMC § 1863; 4 CMC § 1864; 4 CMC § 1865 |
| Surplus | Not applicable: no lienholder sale. (not applicable) | 4 CMC § 1821; 4 CMC § 1862; 4 CMC § 1863; 4 CMC § 1864; 4 CMC § 1865 |
| Defective-sale consequence | Not applicable: no lienholder sale. (not applicable) | 4 CMC § 1821; 4 CMC § 1862; 4 CMC § 1863; 4 CMC § 1864; 4 CMC § 1865 |
| Citation | 4 CMC § 1821(c). | 4 CMC § 1821; 4 CMC § 1862; 4 CMC § 1863; 4 CMC § 1864; 4 CMC § 1865 |
12.3.9 Developer tax lien (4 CMC § 1937(c))
| Attribute | Answer | Primary source |
|---|---|---|
| Statute | 4 CMC § 1937(c)–(d). | 4 CMC § 1937 |
| Who holds it | The Commonwealth (Director of Finance), on any property of the developer obligated to pay developer taxes. | 4 CMC § 1937 |
| Priority vs. perfected security interest | Unresolved: § 1937 states no ranking and does not adopt the § 1865 recording rule. U — needs_verification | 4 CMC § 1937 |
| Cap / amount secured | Developer taxes imposed or authorized under ch. 9. | 4 CMC § 1937 |
| Court required? | No for levy (§ 1937(c)); alternatively a civil suit by the Attorney General (§ 1937(d)). | 4 CMC § 1937 |
| Notice to owner | Unresolved: levy procedure is left to Director of Finance regulations, which were not retrieved. U — needs_verification | 4 CMC § 1937 |
| Notice to lienholders | Unresolved: as above. U — needs_verification | 4 CMC § 1937 |
| Registry (DMV/GPD/BMV) notice | Not applicable: no registry step stated. (not applicable) | 4 CMC § 1937 |
| Publication | Unresolved: as above. U — needs_verification | 4 CMC § 1937 |
| Waiting period | Unresolved: as above. U — needs_verification | 4 CMC § 1937 |
| Sale method | Unresolved: “in the manner to be prescribed by regulation” (§ 1937(c)). U — needs_verification | 4 CMC § 1937 |
| Buyer’s title / what survives | Unresolved: no statutory title rule for a developer-tax levy sale. U — needs_verification | 4 CMC § 1937 |
| Surplus | Unresolved. U — needs_verification | 4 CMC § 1937 |
| Defective-sale consequence | Administrative and judicial review of the Director’s decisions (§ 1937(a)–(b)). | 4 CMC § 1937 |
| Citation | 4 CMC § 1937. | 4 CMC § 1937 |
12.3.10 Workers’ compensation claimant’s lien on employer or carrier assets (4 CMC § 9326)
| Attribute | Answer | Primary source |
|---|---|---|
| Statute | 4 CMC § 9326. | 4 CMC § 9326 |
| Who holds it | Any person entitled to compensation, against the assets of the carrier or employer. | 4 CMC § 9326 |
| Priority vs. perfected security interest | No express ranking against a perfected security interest; “preference and priority in the distribution of assets” upon insolvency, bankruptcy or reorganization (§ 9326). | 4 CMC § 9326 |
| Cap / amount secured | Without limit of amount. | 4 CMC § 9326 |
| Court required? | Yes: enforcement through compensation awards and judgment. | 4 CMC § 9326 |
| Notice to owner | Compensation proceedings and ordinary process. | 4 CMC § 9326 |
| Notice to lienholders | Not applicable: no lienholder sale. (not applicable) | 4 CMC § 9326 |
| Registry (DMV/GPD/BMV) notice | Not applicable: no registry step. (not applicable) | 4 CMC § 9326 |
| Publication | Not applicable: no lienholder sale. (not applicable) | 4 CMC § 9326 |
| Waiting period | Not applicable: no lienholder sale. (not applicable) | 4 CMC § 9326 |
| Sale method | No sale by the lienholder; enforcement by action, judgment and execution (7 CMC §§ 4203–4204). | 4 CMC § 9326; 7 CMC § 4101; 7 CMC § 4203; 7 CMC § 4204 |
| Buyer’s title / what survives | Not applicable: an execution buyer takes under 12.1. (not applicable) | 4 CMC § 9326 |
| Surplus | Not applicable: no lienholder sale. (not applicable) | 4 CMC § 9326 |
| Defective-sale consequence | Not applicable: no lienholder sale. (not applicable) | 4 CMC § 9326 |
| Citation | 4 CMC § 9326. | 4 CMC § 9326 |
12.3.11 Approved fee lien on disability benefits (4 CMC § 9337)
| Attribute | Answer | Primary source |
|---|---|---|
| Statute | 4 CMC § 9337. | 4 CMC § 9337 |
| Who holds it | A person whose claim for legal or other services is approved by the administrator or reviewing court. | 4 CMC § 9337 |
| Priority vs. perfected security interest | Attaches only to the benefits, as fixed by the administrator or court; it does not compete with security interests in goods. | 4 CMC § 9337 |
| Cap / amount secured | As fixed by the administrator or court. | 4 CMC § 9337 |
| Court required? | Yes: valid only as approved by the administrator or court. | 4 CMC § 9337 |
| Notice to owner | The approval proceeding. | 4 CMC § 9337 |
| Notice to lienholders | Not applicable: no lienholder sale. (not applicable) | 4 CMC § 9337 |
| Registry (DMV/GPD/BMV) notice | Not applicable: no registry step. (not applicable) | 4 CMC § 9337 |
| Publication | Not applicable: no lienholder sale. (not applicable) | 4 CMC § 9337 |
| Waiting period | Not applicable: no lienholder sale. (not applicable) | 4 CMC § 9337 |
| Sale method | No sale: the lien is satisfied from the benefits. | 4 CMC § 9337; 7 CMC § 4101; 7 CMC § 4203; 7 CMC § 4204 |
| Buyer’s title / what survives | Not applicable: an execution buyer takes under 12.1. (not applicable) | 4 CMC § 9337 |
| Surplus | Not applicable: no lienholder sale. (not applicable) | 4 CMC § 9337 |
| Defective-sale consequence | Not applicable: no lienholder sale. (not applicable) | 4 CMC § 9337 |
| Citation | 4 CMC § 9337. | 4 CMC § 9337 |
12.3.12 Hospital lien on injury recoveries (4 CMC §§ 51549–51555)
| Attribute | Answer | Primary source |
|---|---|---|
| Statute | 4 CMC §§ 51549–51555. | 4 CMC § 51549; 4 CMC § 51550; 4 CMC § 51551; 4 CMC § 51554; 4 CMC § 51555 |
| Who holds it | The Commonwealth Health Center, Tinian or Rota Health Center, on any judgment, settlement or compromise sum for reasonable hospitalization before that date (§§ 51548–51549). | 4 CMC § 51549; 4 CMC § 51550; 4 CMC § 51551; 4 CMC § 51554; 4 CMC § 51555 |
| Priority vs. perfected security interest | Attaches to money recovered, after attorney fees and costs (§ 51550(b)); payers who ignore a served notice are liable for 180 days (§ 51554). | 4 CMC § 51549; 4 CMC § 51550; 4 CMC § 51551; 4 CMC § 51554; 4 CMC § 51555 |
| Cap / amount secured | Reasonable value of hospitalization before judgment or settlement. | 4 CMC § 51549; 4 CMC § 51550; 4 CMC § 51551; 4 CMC § 51554; 4 CMC § 51555 |
| Court required? | Yes for foreclosure: by lawsuit in the Superior Court (§ 51555); perfection by recording and service of notice (§ 51551). | 4 CMC § 51549; 4 CMC § 51550; 4 CMC § 51551; 4 CMC § 51554; 4 CMC § 51555 |
| Notice to owner | Recorded notice and certified copies served on the liable person and insurer (§ 51551). | 4 CMC § 51549; 4 CMC § 51550; 4 CMC § 51551; 4 CMC § 51554; 4 CMC § 51555 |
| Notice to lienholders | Not applicable: no lienholder sale. (not applicable) | 4 CMC § 51549; 4 CMC § 51550; 4 CMC § 51551; 4 CMC § 51554; 4 CMC § 51555 |
| Registry (DMV/GPD/BMV) notice | Not applicable: no registry step. (not applicable) | 4 CMC § 51549; 4 CMC § 51550; 4 CMC § 51551; 4 CMC § 51554; 4 CMC § 51555 |
| Publication | Not applicable: no lienholder sale. (not applicable) | 4 CMC § 51549; 4 CMC § 51550; 4 CMC § 51551; 4 CMC § 51554; 4 CMC § 51555 |
| Waiting period | Not applicable: no lienholder sale. (not applicable) | 4 CMC § 51549; 4 CMC § 51550; 4 CMC § 51551; 4 CMC § 51554; 4 CMC § 51555 |
| Sale method | No sale: foreclosure by suit against the recovery (§ 51555). | 4 CMC § 51549; 4 CMC § 51550; 4 CMC § 51551; 4 CMC § 51554; 4 CMC § 51555; 7 CMC § 4101; 7 CMC § 4203; 7 CMC § 4204 |
| Buyer’s title / what survives | Not applicable: an execution buyer takes under 12.1. (not applicable) | 4 CMC § 51549; 4 CMC § 51550; 4 CMC § 51551; 4 CMC § 51554; 4 CMC § 51555 |
| Surplus | Not applicable: no lienholder sale. (not applicable) | 4 CMC § 51549; 4 CMC § 51550; 4 CMC § 51551; 4 CMC § 51554; 4 CMC § 51555 |
| Defective-sale consequence | Not applicable: no lienholder sale. (not applicable) | 4 CMC § 51549; 4 CMC § 51550; 4 CMC § 51551; 4 CMC § 51554; 4 CMC § 51555 |
| Citation | 4 CMC §§ 51549–51555. | 4 CMC § 51549; 4 CMC § 51550; 4 CMC § 51551; 4 CMC § 51554; 4 CMC § 51555 |
12.3.13 Medicaid recovery lien on a recipient’s property (4 CMC §§ 51560–51563)
| Attribute | Answer | Primary source |
|---|---|---|
| Statute | 4 CMC §§ 51559–51563. | 4 CMC § 51560; 4 CMC § 51561; 4 CMC § 51562; 4 CMC § 51563 |
| Who holds it | The Department of Public Health, on petition, against real or personal property of a recipient for assistance incorrectly paid (§ 51560(a)(1)). | 4 CMC § 51560; 4 CMC § 51561; 4 CMC § 51562; 4 CMC § 51563 |
| Priority vs. perfected security interest | Unresolved: the article states no ranking against a perfected security interest in personal property. U — needs_verification | 4 CMC § 51560; 4 CMC § 51561; 4 CMC § 51562; 4 CMC § 51563 |
| Cap / amount secured | Assistance paid or to be paid (§ 51560(a)). | 4 CMC § 51560; 4 CMC § 51561; 4 CMC § 51562; 4 CMC § 51563 |
| Court required? | Yes: imposed by Superior Court petition and foreclosed by action “in the same manner as for foreclosure of any other lien” (§§ 51561–51563). | 4 CMC § 51560; 4 CMC § 51561; 4 CMC § 51562; 4 CMC § 51563 |
| Notice to owner | Registered or certified mail at least 10 days before the hearing (§ 51562(b)). | 4 CMC § 51560; 4 CMC § 51561; 4 CMC § 51562; 4 CMC § 51563 |
| Notice to lienholders | To each person claiming or listed as having an interest in the property, plus newspaper publication (§ 51562(b)–(c)). | 4 CMC § 51560; 4 CMC § 51561; 4 CMC § 51562; 4 CMC § 51563 |
| Registry (DMV/GPD/BMV) notice | Not applicable: no registry step stated. (not applicable) | 4 CMC § 51560; 4 CMC § 51561; 4 CMC § 51562; 4 CMC § 51563 |
| Publication | Once a week for three successive weeks in a newspaper, or as the court determines (§ 51562(b)). | 4 CMC § 51560; 4 CMC § 51561; 4 CMC § 51562; 4 CMC § 51563 |
| Waiting period | At least 10 days’ notice before the petition hearing (§ 51562(b)). | 4 CMC § 51560; 4 CMC § 51561; 4 CMC § 51562; 4 CMC § 51563 |
| Sale method | Judicial foreclosure as for any other lien (§ 51563), i.e., judgment and execution sale. | 4 CMC § 51560; 4 CMC § 51561; 4 CMC § 51562; 4 CMC § 51563; 7 CMC § 4101; 7 CMC § 4203; 7 CMC § 4204 |
| Buyer’s title / what survives | Execution-sale rules (12.1): the debtor’s interest, subject to earlier perfected interests. | 4 CMC § 51560; 4 CMC § 51561; 4 CMC § 51562; 4 CMC § 51563; 7 CMC § 4101; 7 CMC § 4203; 7 CMC § 4204; 5 CMC § 9301; 5 CMC § 9302; 5 CMC § 9306; 5 CMC § 9310; 5 CMC § 9501; 5 CMC § 9503; 5 CMC § 9504; 5 CMC § 9505; 5 CMC § 9506; 5 CMC § 9507 |
| Surplus | Execution surplus to the judgment debtor (7 CMC § 4204(c)). | 7 CMC § 4101; 7 CMC § 4203; 7 CMC § 4204 |
| Defective-sale consequence | Relief from the judgment under NMI R. Civ. P. 60. | NMI R. Civ. P. (eff. Jan. 9, 2019) |
| Citation | 4 CMC §§ 51559–51563. | 4 CMC § 51560; 4 CMC § 51561; 4 CMC § 51562; 4 CMC § 51563 |
12.3.14 Criminal restitution judgment lien (6 CMC § 4109(h))
| Attribute | Answer | Primary source |
|---|---|---|
| Statute | 6 CMC § 4109(h). | 6 CMC § 4109 |
| Who holds it | The person in whose favor a restitution order issues, or its assignee, on the probationer’s property. | 6 CMC § 4109 |
| Priority vs. perfected security interest | A judgment lien that “may be perfected”; against a perfected security interest the lien creditor rule applies (5 CMC § 9301(4)). | 6 CMC § 4109; 5 CMC § 9301; 5 CMC § 9302; 5 CMC § 9306; 5 CMC § 9310; 5 CMC § 9501; 5 CMC § 9503; 5 CMC § 9504; 5 CMC § 9505; 5 CMC § 9506; 5 CMC § 9507 |
| Cap / amount secured | Delinquent restitution payments. | 6 CMC § 4109 |
| Court required? | Yes: enforced “as if the order were a civil judgment enforceable by execution” (§ 4109(h)(3)). | 6 CMC § 4109 |
| Notice to owner | The restitution order and execution notices. | 6 CMC § 4109 |
| Notice to lienholders | Not applicable: no lienholder sale. (not applicable) | 6 CMC § 4109 |
| Registry (DMV/GPD/BMV) notice | Not applicable: no registry step. (not applicable) | 6 CMC § 4109 |
| Publication | Not applicable: no lienholder sale. (not applicable) | 6 CMC § 4109 |
| Waiting period | Not applicable: no lienholder sale. (not applicable) | 6 CMC § 4109 |
| Sale method | No sale by the lienholder; enforcement by action, judgment and execution (7 CMC §§ 4203–4204). | 6 CMC § 4109; 7 CMC § 4101; 7 CMC § 4203; 7 CMC § 4204 |
| Buyer’s title / what survives | Not applicable: an execution buyer takes under 12.1. (not applicable) | 6 CMC § 4109 |
| Surplus | Not applicable: no lienholder sale. (not applicable) | 6 CMC § 4109 |
| Defective-sale consequence | Not applicable: no lienholder sale. (not applicable) | 6 CMC § 4109 |
| Citation | 6 CMC § 4109(h). | 6 CMC § 4109 |
12.3.15 Saipan nuisance-abatement lien (10 CMC §§ 30514–30516)
| Attribute | Answer | Primary source |
|---|---|---|
| Statute | 10 CMC §§ 30510, 30514–30516; 2 CMC § 7255(a). | 10 CMC § 30510; 10 CMC § 30514; 10 CMC § 30515; 10 CMC § 30516; 2 CMC § 7255 |
| Who holds it | The Commonwealth, after a final APA determination, on recordation with the Commonwealth Recorder. | 10 CMC § 30510; 10 CMC § 30514; 10 CMC § 30515; 10 CMC § 30516; 2 CMC § 7255 |
| Priority vs. perfected security interest | Prior in dignity to all other liens and encumbrances except Commonwealth tax liens, which are of equal dignity (§ 30516); priority dates from entry (§ 30515). | 10 CMC § 30510; 10 CMC § 30514; 10 CMC § 30515; 10 CMC § 30516; 2 CMC § 7255 |
| Cap / amount secured | Abatement costs, penalties, 6% interest after 180 days and collection costs (§ 30516). | 10 CMC § 30510; 10 CMC § 30514; 10 CMC § 30515; 10 CMC § 30516; 2 CMC § 7255 |
| Court required? | Yes: enforced under 2 CMC § 7255(a) by foreclosure in accordance with the law governing foreclosure of mortgages. | 10 CMC § 30510; 10 CMC § 30514; 10 CMC § 30515; 10 CMC § 30516; 2 CMC § 7255 |
| Notice to owner | Mailed lien statement and one newspaper publication of the Notice of Assessment and Lien (§ 30514). | 10 CMC § 30510; 10 CMC § 30514; 10 CMC § 30515; 10 CMC § 30516; 2 CMC § 7255 |
| Notice to lienholders | Not applicable: no lienholder sale. (not applicable) | 10 CMC § 30510; 10 CMC § 30514; 10 CMC § 30515; 10 CMC § 30516; 2 CMC § 7255 |
| Registry (DMV/GPD/BMV) notice | Not applicable: no registry step. (not applicable) | 10 CMC § 30510; 10 CMC § 30514; 10 CMC § 30515; 10 CMC § 30516; 2 CMC § 7255 |
| Publication | Not applicable: no lienholder sale. (not applicable) | 10 CMC § 30510; 10 CMC § 30514; 10 CMC § 30515; 10 CMC § 30516; 2 CMC § 7255 |
| Waiting period | Not applicable: no lienholder sale. (not applicable) | 10 CMC § 30510; 10 CMC § 30514; 10 CMC § 30515; 10 CMC § 30516; 2 CMC § 7255 |
| Sale method | No lienholder sale; judicial foreclosure as for mortgages (2 CMC § 7255(a)). | 10 CMC § 30510; 10 CMC § 30514; 10 CMC § 30515; 10 CMC § 30516; 2 CMC § 7255; 7 CMC § 4101; 7 CMC § 4203; 7 CMC § 4204 |
| Buyer’s title / what survives | Not applicable: an execution buyer takes under 12.1. (not applicable) | 10 CMC § 30510; 10 CMC § 30514; 10 CMC § 30515; 10 CMC § 30516; 2 CMC § 7255 |
| Surplus | Not applicable: no lienholder sale. (not applicable) | 10 CMC § 30510; 10 CMC § 30514; 10 CMC § 30515; 10 CMC § 30516; 2 CMC § 7255 |
| Defective-sale consequence | Not applicable: no lienholder sale. (not applicable) | 10 CMC § 30510; 10 CMC § 30514; 10 CMC § 30515; 10 CMC § 30516; 2 CMC § 7255 |
| Citation | 10 CMC §§ 30510, 30514–30516; 2 CMC § 7255(a). | 10 CMC § 30510; 10 CMC § 30514; 10 CMC § 30515; 10 CMC § 30516; 2 CMC § 7255 |
12.3.16 Commonwealth Ports Authority charge lien (2 CMC § 2122(g))
| Attribute | Answer | Primary source |
|---|---|---|
| Statute | 2 CMC § 2122(g). | 2 CMC § 2122; 2 CMC § 2141 |
| Who holds it | The Commonwealth Ports Authority, for charges or rentals for the use of property under its management. | 2 CMC § 2122; 2 CMC § 2141 |
| Priority vs. perfected security interest | No statutory ranking against a perfected security interest; enforceable only “through appropriate judicial proceedings” (§ 2122(g)). | 2 CMC § 2122; 2 CMC § 2141 |
| Cap / amount secured | The unpaid charges. | 2 CMC § 2122; 2 CMC § 2141 |
| Court required? | Yes: “through appropriate judicial proceedings”. | 2 CMC § 2122; 2 CMC § 2141 |
| Notice to owner | Court process. | 2 CMC § 2122; 2 CMC § 2141 |
| Notice to lienholders | Not applicable: no lienholder sale. (not applicable) | 2 CMC § 2122; 2 CMC § 2141 |
| Registry (DMV/GPD/BMV) notice | Not applicable: no registry step. (not applicable) | 2 CMC § 2122; 2 CMC § 2141 |
| Publication | Not applicable: no lienholder sale. (not applicable) | 2 CMC § 2122; 2 CMC § 2141 |
| Waiting period | Not applicable: no lienholder sale. (not applicable) | 2 CMC § 2122; 2 CMC § 2141 |
| Sale method | No sale by the lienholder; enforcement by action, judgment and execution (7 CMC §§ 4203–4204). | 2 CMC § 2122; 2 CMC § 2141; 7 CMC § 4101; 7 CMC § 4203; 7 CMC § 4204 |
| Buyer’s title / what survives | Not applicable: an execution buyer takes under 12.1. (not applicable) | 2 CMC § 2122; 2 CMC § 2141 |
| Surplus | Not applicable: no lienholder sale. (not applicable) | 2 CMC § 2122; 2 CMC § 2141 |
| Defective-sale consequence | Not applicable: no lienholder sale. (not applicable) | 2 CMC § 2122; 2 CMC § 2141 |
| Citation | 2 CMC § 2122(g). | 2 CMC § 2122; 2 CMC § 2141 |
12.3.17 Seaman’s maritime lien for sick and injury wages (4 CMC § 9141(d))
| Attribute | Answer | Primary source |
|---|---|---|
| Statute | 4 CMC §§ 9130, 9141(d). | 4 CMC § 9141; 4 CMC § 9130 |
| Who holds it | A seaman, against the vessel, for wages due under § 9141. | 4 CMC § 9141; 4 CMC § 9130 |
| Priority vs. perfected security interest | A maritime lien for wages; on a documented vessel wages are preferred maritime liens ahead of a preferred mortgage in an in rem sale (46 U.S.C. § 31326(b)). | 4 CMC § 9141; 4 CMC § 9130; 46 U.S.C. § 31326 (OLRC XML) |
| Cap / amount secured | Wages due under § 9141. | 4 CMC § 9141; 4 CMC § 9130 |
| Court required? | Yes: a maritime lien is enforced by arrest in rem (District Court for the NMI, 48 U.S.C. § 1822; 46 U.S.C. § 31326). | 4 CMC § 9141; 4 CMC § 9130 |
| Notice to owner | In rem process. | 4 CMC § 9141; 4 CMC § 9130 |
| Notice to lienholders | Not applicable: no lienholder sale. (not applicable) | 4 CMC § 9141; 4 CMC § 9130 |
| Registry (DMV/GPD/BMV) notice | Not applicable: no registry step. (not applicable) | 4 CMC § 9141; 4 CMC § 9130 |
| Publication | Not applicable: no lienholder sale. (not applicable) | 4 CMC § 9141; 4 CMC § 9130 |
| Waiting period | Not applicable: no lienholder sale. (not applicable) | 4 CMC § 9141; 4 CMC § 9130 |
| Sale method | Judicial in rem sale; the territorial § 51527 auction also covers wage liens under § 51524(a). | 4 CMC § 9141; 4 CMC § 9130; 7 CMC § 4101; 7 CMC § 4203; 7 CMC § 4204 |
| Buyer’s title / what survives | Not applicable: an execution buyer takes under 12.1. (not applicable) | 4 CMC § 9141; 4 CMC § 9130 |
| Surplus | Not applicable: no lienholder sale. (not applicable) | 4 CMC § 9141; 4 CMC § 9130 |
| Defective-sale consequence | Not applicable: no lienholder sale. (not applicable) | 4 CMC § 9141; 4 CMC § 9130 |
| Citation | 4 CMC §§ 9130, 9141(d). | 4 CMC § 9141; 4 CMC § 9130 |
12.3.18 Seller’s security interest by shipment under reservation (5 CMC § 2505)
| Attribute | Answer | Primary source |
|---|---|---|
| Statute | 5 CMC §§ 2505, 2706. | 5 CMC § 2505; 5 CMC § 2706; 5 CMC § 2711 |
| Who holds it | A seller who identifies goods and procures a negotiable bill of lading to its own order or a nonnegotiable bill to itself (§ 2505(1)). | 5 CMC § 2505; 5 CMC § 2706; 5 CMC § 2711 |
| Priority vs. perfected security interest | Reserved security interest in goods pending payment; default rights under Division 2. | 5 CMC § 2505; 5 CMC § 2706; 5 CMC § 2711; 5 CMC § 9301; 5 CMC § 9302; 5 CMC § 9306; 5 CMC § 9310; 5 CMC § 9501; 5 CMC § 9503; 5 CMC § 9504; 5 CMC § 9505; 5 CMC § 9506; 5 CMC § 9507 |
| Cap / amount secured | The price the reservation secures. | 5 CMC § 2505; 5 CMC § 2706; 5 CMC § 2711 |
| Court required? | No: seller’s resale (§ 2706). | 5 CMC § 2505; 5 CMC § 2706; 5 CMC § 2711 |
| Notice to owner | Reasonable notification of a private resale; notice of a public resale (§ 2706). | 5 CMC § 2505; 5 CMC § 2706; 5 CMC § 2711 |
| Notice to lienholders | None prescribed. | 5 CMC § 2505; 5 CMC § 2706; 5 CMC § 2711 |
| Registry (DMV/GPD/BMV) notice | None prescribed. | 5 CMC § 2505; 5 CMC § 2706; 5 CMC § 2711 |
| Publication | None prescribed. | 5 CMC § 2505; 5 CMC § 2706; 5 CMC § 2711 |
| Waiting period | Commercially reasonable time after breach. | 5 CMC § 2505; 5 CMC § 2706; 5 CMC § 2711 |
| Sale method | Public or private resale, commercially reasonable (§ 2706). | 5 CMC § 2505; 5 CMC § 2706; 5 CMC § 2711 |
| Buyer’s title / what survives | A good-faith purchaser at resale takes free of the buyer’s rights (§ 2706). | 5 CMC § 2505; 5 CMC § 2706; 5 CMC § 2711 |
| Surplus | Seller not accountable for profit (§ 2706). | 5 CMC § 2505; 5 CMC § 2706; 5 CMC § 2711 |
| Defective-sale consequence | Damages; good-faith purchaser protected (§ 2706). | 5 CMC § 2505; 5 CMC § 2706; 5 CMC § 2711 |
| Citation | 5 CMC §§ 2505, 2706. | 5 CMC § 2505; 5 CMC § 2706; 5 CMC § 2711 |
12.3.19 Rightfully rejecting buyer’s security interest (5 CMC § 2711(3))
| Attribute | Answer | Primary source |
|---|---|---|
| Statute | 5 CMC §§ 2711(3), 2706. | 5 CMC § 2505; 5 CMC § 2706; 5 CMC § 2711 |
| Who holds it | A buyer who rightfully rejects or revokes acceptance, for price paid and expenses, on goods in its possession or control (§ 2711(3)). | 5 CMC § 2505; 5 CMC § 2706; 5 CMC § 2711 |
| Priority vs. perfected security interest | Security interest under Division 2 in goods the buyer holds. | 5 CMC § 2505; 5 CMC § 2706; 5 CMC § 2711; 5 CMC § 9301; 5 CMC § 9302; 5 CMC § 9306; 5 CMC § 9310; 5 CMC § 9501; 5 CMC § 9503; 5 CMC § 9504; 5 CMC § 9505; 5 CMC § 9506; 5 CMC § 9507 |
| Cap / amount secured | Payments on the price and reasonable expenses. | 5 CMC § 2505; 5 CMC § 2706; 5 CMC § 2711 |
| Court required? | No: resale “in like manner as an aggrieved seller” (§ 2711(3)). | 5 CMC § 2505; 5 CMC § 2706; 5 CMC § 2711 |
| Notice to owner | Seller-resale notices (§ 2706). | 5 CMC § 2505; 5 CMC § 2706; 5 CMC § 2711 |
| Notice to lienholders | None prescribed. | 5 CMC § 2505; 5 CMC § 2706; 5 CMC § 2711 |
| Registry (DMV/GPD/BMV) notice | None prescribed. | 5 CMC § 2505; 5 CMC § 2706; 5 CMC § 2711 |
| Publication | None prescribed. | 5 CMC § 2505; 5 CMC § 2706; 5 CMC § 2711 |
| Waiting period | Reasonable time. | 5 CMC § 2505; 5 CMC § 2706; 5 CMC § 2711 |
| Sale method | Public or private resale (§ 2706). | 5 CMC § 2505; 5 CMC § 2706; 5 CMC § 2711 |
| Buyer’s title / what survives | Good-faith purchaser protected (§ 2706). | 5 CMC § 2505; 5 CMC § 2706; 5 CMC § 2711 |
| Surplus | Account for any excess (§ 2706). | 5 CMC § 2505; 5 CMC § 2706; 5 CMC § 2711 |
| Defective-sale consequence | Damages; purchaser protected (§ 2706). | 5 CMC § 2505; 5 CMC § 2706; 5 CMC § 2711 |
| Citation | 5 CMC §§ 2711(3), 2706. | 5 CMC § 2505; 5 CMC § 2706; 5 CMC § 2711 |
12.3.20 Collecting bank’s security interest in items (5 CMC § 4208)
12.3.21 Presenting bank’s lien for expenses on goods (5 CMC § 4504)
| Attribute | Answer | Primary source |
|---|---|---|
| Statute | 5 CMC §§ 4504, 2706. | 5 CMC § 4208; 5 CMC § 4504; 5 CMC § 2505; 5 CMC § 2706; 5 CMC § 2711 |
| Who holds it | A presenting bank that, after dishonor of a documentary draft and no timely instructions, stores, sells or deals with the goods, for reasonable expenses (§ 4504). | 5 CMC § 4208; 5 CMC § 4504; 5 CMC § 2505; 5 CMC § 2706; 5 CMC § 2711 |
| Priority vs. perfected security interest | No express priority; foreclosed “in the same manner as an unpaid seller’s lien” (§ 4504(2)). | 5 CMC § 4208; 5 CMC § 4504; 5 CMC § 2505; 5 CMC § 2706; 5 CMC § 2711; 5 CMC § 9301; 5 CMC § 9302; 5 CMC § 9306; 5 CMC § 9310; 5 CMC § 9501; 5 CMC § 9503; 5 CMC § 9504; 5 CMC § 9505; 5 CMC § 9506; 5 CMC § 9507 |
| Cap / amount secured | Reasonable expenses. | 5 CMC § 4208; 5 CMC § 4504; 5 CMC § 2505; 5 CMC § 2706; 5 CMC § 2711 |
| Court required? | No: unpaid-seller resale (§§ 4504(2), 2706). | 5 CMC § 4208; 5 CMC § 4504; 5 CMC § 2505; 5 CMC § 2706; 5 CMC § 2711 |
| Notice to owner | Seller-resale notices (§ 2706). | 5 CMC § 4208; 5 CMC § 4504; 5 CMC § 2505; 5 CMC § 2706; 5 CMC § 2711 |
| Notice to lienholders | None prescribed. | 5 CMC § 4208; 5 CMC § 4504; 5 CMC § 2505; 5 CMC § 2706; 5 CMC § 2711 |
| Registry (DMV/GPD/BMV) notice | None prescribed. | 5 CMC § 4208; 5 CMC § 4504; 5 CMC § 2505; 5 CMC § 2706; 5 CMC § 2711 |
| Publication | None prescribed. | 5 CMC § 4208; 5 CMC § 4504; 5 CMC § 2505; 5 CMC § 2706; 5 CMC § 2711 |
| Waiting period | Reasonable time after unanswered request. | 5 CMC § 4208; 5 CMC § 4504; 5 CMC § 2505; 5 CMC § 2706; 5 CMC § 2711 |
| Sale method | Any reasonable manner; resale as an unpaid seller (§ 4504(1)). | 5 CMC § 4208; 5 CMC § 4504; 5 CMC § 2505; 5 CMC § 2706; 5 CMC § 2711 |
| Buyer’s title / what survives | Good-faith resale purchaser protected (§ 2706). | 5 CMC § 4208; 5 CMC § 4504; 5 CMC § 2505; 5 CMC § 2706; 5 CMC § 2711 |
| Surplus | Only expenses are secured. | 5 CMC § 4208; 5 CMC § 4504; 5 CMC § 2505; 5 CMC § 2706; 5 CMC § 2711 |
| Defective-sale consequence | Damages for unreasonable dealing. | 5 CMC § 4208; 5 CMC § 4504; 5 CMC § 2505; 5 CMC § 2706; 5 CMC § 2711 |
| Citation | 5 CMC §§ 4504, 2706. | 5 CMC § 4208; 5 CMC § 4504; 5 CMC § 2505; 5 CMC § 2706; 5 CMC § 2711 |
12.3.22 Warehouseman’s lien (5 CMC §§ 7209–7210)
| Attribute | Answer | Primary source |
|---|---|---|
| Statute | 5 CMC §§ 7209–7210. | 5 CMC § 7209; 5 CMC § 7210 |
| Who holds it | A warehouseman, on goods covered by a warehouse receipt, for storage, transport, insurance, labor and preservation and sale expenses (§ 7209(1)). | 5 CMC § 7209; 5 CMC § 7210 |
| Priority vs. perfected security interest | Effective against the bailor and persons who entrusted the bailor; not against a holder whose rights the document does not cut off (§ 7209). | 5 CMC § 7209; 5 CMC § 7210; 5 CMC § 9301; 5 CMC § 9302; 5 CMC § 9306; 5 CMC § 9310; 5 CMC § 9501; 5 CMC § 9503; 5 CMC § 9504; 5 CMC § 9505; 5 CMC § 9506; 5 CMC § 9507 |
| Cap / amount secured | Against a holder by due negotiation, the charges stated on the receipt or a reasonable storage charge (§ 7209(1)). | 5 CMC § 7209; 5 CMC § 7210 |
| Court required? | No (§ 7210). | 5 CMC § 7209; 5 CMC § 7210 |
| Notice to owner | Notify all persons known to claim an interest; nonmerchant goods by personal or registered/certified notice with at least 10 days to pay (§ 7210(1)–(2)). | 5 CMC § 7209; 5 CMC § 7210 |
| Notice to lienholders | All persons known to claim an interest (§ 7210). | 5 CMC § 7209; 5 CMC § 7210 |
| Registry (DMV/GPD/BMV) notice | None prescribed. | 5 CMC § 7209; 5 CMC § 7210 |
| Publication | None prescribed. | 5 CMC § 7209; 5 CMC § 7210 |
| Waiting period | Commercially reasonable time; nonmerchant goods per § 7210(2). | 5 CMC § 7209; 5 CMC § 7210 |
| Sale method | Public or private commercially reasonable sale; nonmerchant goods by the § 7210(2) procedure. | 5 CMC § 7209; 5 CMC § 7210 |
| Buyer’s title / what survives | A good-faith purchaser takes free of the rights of persons against whom the lien was valid (§ 7210). | 5 CMC § 7209; 5 CMC § 7210 |
| Surplus | Balance held for the person entitled (§ 7210). | 5 CMC § 7209; 5 CMC § 7210 |
| Defective-sale consequence | Damages for noncompliance (§ 7210). | 5 CMC § 7209; 5 CMC § 7210 |
| Citation | 5 CMC §§ 7209–7210. | 5 CMC § 7209; 5 CMC § 7210 |
12.3.23 Carrier’s lien on goods under a bill of lading (5 CMC §§ 7307–7308)
| Attribute | Answer | Primary source |
|---|---|---|
| Statute | 5 CMC §§ 7307–7308. | 5 CMC § 7307; 5 CMC § 7308 |
| Who holds it | A carrier, on goods covered by a bill of lading, for post-receipt storage and transport charges and preservation and sale expenses (§ 7307(1)). | 5 CMC § 7307; 5 CMC § 7308 |
| Priority vs. perfected security interest | Effective against the consignor and persons who permitted the bailor possession, absent notice of lack of authority (§ 7307(2)). | 5 CMC § 7307; 5 CMC § 7308; 5 CMC § 9301; 5 CMC § 9302; 5 CMC § 9306; 5 CMC § 9310; 5 CMC § 9501; 5 CMC § 9503; 5 CMC § 9504; 5 CMC § 9505; 5 CMC § 9506; 5 CMC § 9507 |
| Cap / amount secured | Against a purchaser of a negotiable bill, charges in the bill or tariffs (§ 7307(1)). | 5 CMC § 7307; 5 CMC § 7308 |
| Court required? | No (§ 7308). | 5 CMC § 7307; 5 CMC § 7308 |
| Notice to owner | Notify all persons known to claim an interest: amount, nature of sale, time and place (§ 7308(1)). | 5 CMC § 7307; 5 CMC § 7308 |
| Notice to lienholders | All persons known to claim an interest (§ 7308(1)). | 5 CMC § 7307; 5 CMC § 7308 |
| Registry (DMV/GPD/BMV) notice | None prescribed. | 5 CMC § 7307; 5 CMC § 7308 |
| Publication | None prescribed. | 5 CMC § 7307; 5 CMC § 7308 |
| Waiting period | Commercially reasonable time. | 5 CMC § 7307; 5 CMC § 7308 |
| Sale method | Public or private commercially reasonable sale; payoff before sale stops it (§ 7308(1)–(2)). | 5 CMC § 7307; 5 CMC § 7308 |
| Buyer’s title / what survives | A good-faith purchaser takes free of the rights of persons against whom the lien was valid (§ 7308). | 5 CMC § 7307; 5 CMC § 7308 |
| Surplus | Balance held for the person entitled (§ 7308). | 5 CMC § 7307; 5 CMC § 7308 |
| Defective-sale consequence | Damages; lien lost by voluntary or unjustified non-delivery (§ 7307(3)). | 5 CMC § 7307; 5 CMC § 7308 |
| Citation | 5 CMC §§ 7307–7308. | 5 CMC § 7307; 5 CMC § 7308 |
12.3.24 LLC distributional-interest charging order (4 CMC § 4874)
| Attribute | Answer | Primary source |
|---|---|---|
| Statute | 4 CMC § 4874 | 4 CMC § 4871; 4 CMC § 4874 |
| Who holds it | A judgment creditor of a member or transferee, on the distributional interest; receiver of distributions available (§ 4874(a)). | 4 CMC § 4871; 4 CMC § 4874 |
| Priority vs. perfected security interest | The charging order is a lien on the debtor’s interest only; no express priority over a member’s or partner’s perfected security interest in that interest, so Article 9 priority rules govern the competing security interest (5 CMC § 9301(4)). | 4 CMC § 4871; 4 CMC § 4874; 5 CMC § 9301; 5 CMC § 9302; 5 CMC § 9306; 5 CMC § 9310; 5 CMC § 9501; 5 CMC § 9503; 5 CMC § 9504; 5 CMC § 9505; 5 CMC § 9506; 5 CMC § 9507 |
| Cap / amount secured | The unsatisfied judgment. | 4 CMC § 4871; 4 CMC § 4874 |
| Court required? | Yes: charging order and foreclosure by court order. | 4 CMC § 4871; 4 CMC § 4874 |
| Notice to owner | Application in the judgment creditor’s case; ordinary motion service. | 4 CMC § 4871; 4 CMC § 4874; NMI R. Civ. P. (eff. Jan. 9, 2019) |
| Notice to lienholders | None prescribed. | 4 CMC § 4871; 4 CMC § 4874 |
| Registry (DMV/GPD/BMV) notice | Not applicable. (not applicable) | 4 CMC § 4871; 4 CMC § 4874 |
| Publication | None prescribed. | 4 CMC § 4871; 4 CMC § 4874 |
| Waiting period | Foreclosure “at any time” on court order; redemption before foreclosure. | 4 CMC § 4871; 4 CMC § 4874 |
| Sale method | Court-ordered foreclosure of the charging-order lien (§ 4874(b)). | 4 CMC § 4871; 4 CMC § 4874 |
| Buyer’s title / what survives | The purchaser “has the rights of a transferee” (§ 4874(b)). | 4 CMC § 4871; 4 CMC § 4874 |
| Surplus | The judgment is satisfied from distributions or the foreclosure; the debtor keeps any remaining interest. | 4 CMC § 4871; 4 CMC § 4874 |
| Defective-sale consequence | Court-supervised: relief by motion or appeal (NMI R. Civ. P. 60). | 4 CMC § 4871; 4 CMC § 4874; NMI R. Civ. P. (eff. Jan. 9, 2019) |
| Citation | 4 CMC § 4874 | 4 CMC § 4871; 4 CMC § 4874 |
12.3.25 Partner’s transferable-interest charging order (4 CMC § 40144)
| Attribute | Answer | Primary source |
|---|---|---|
| Statute | 4 CMC § 40144 | 4 CMC § 40144 |
| Who holds it | A judgment creditor of a partner or transferee, on the transferable interest; receiver available (§ 40144(a)). | 4 CMC § 40144 |
| Priority vs. perfected security interest | The charging order is a lien on the debtor’s interest only; no express priority over a member’s or partner’s perfected security interest in that interest, so Article 9 priority rules govern the competing security interest (5 CMC § 9301(4)). | 4 CMC § 40144; 5 CMC § 9301; 5 CMC § 9302; 5 CMC § 9306; 5 CMC § 9310; 5 CMC § 9501; 5 CMC § 9503; 5 CMC § 9504; 5 CMC § 9505; 5 CMC § 9506; 5 CMC § 9507 |
| Cap / amount secured | The unsatisfied judgment. | 4 CMC § 40144 |
| Court required? | Yes: charging order and foreclosure by court order. | 4 CMC § 40144 |
| Notice to owner | Application in the judgment creditor’s case; ordinary motion service. | 4 CMC § 40144; NMI R. Civ. P. (eff. Jan. 9, 2019) |
| Notice to lienholders | None prescribed. | 4 CMC § 40144 |
| Registry (DMV/GPD/BMV) notice | Not applicable. (not applicable) | 4 CMC § 40144 |
| Publication | None prescribed. | 4 CMC § 40144 |
| Waiting period | Foreclosure “at any time” on court order; redemption before foreclosure. | 4 CMC § 40144 |
| Sale method | Court-ordered foreclosure of the charged interest (§ 40144(b)). | 4 CMC § 40144 |
| Buyer’s title / what survives | The purchaser “has the rights of a transferee” (§ 40144(b)). | 4 CMC § 40144 |
| Surplus | The judgment is satisfied from distributions or the foreclosure; the debtor keeps any remaining interest. | 4 CMC § 40144 |
| Defective-sale consequence | Court-supervised: relief by motion or appeal (NMI R. Civ. P. 60). | 4 CMC § 40144; NMI R. Civ. P. (eff. Jan. 9, 2019) |
| Citation | 4 CMC § 40144 | 4 CMC § 40144 |
Candidates screened and not counted as separate regimes.
| Candidate | Decision | Primary source |
|---|---|---|
| Cleaning, pressing and laundry liens (4 CMC §§ 51503–51508) | exclude-asset-scope: Reach only garments, clothing and household goods, outside module 12’s vehicles, vessels, aircraft, equipment and business assets. | 4 CMC § 51503; 4 CMC § 51504; 4 CMC § 51505; 4 CMC § 51506 |
| Pawnbroker first lien and disposal (4 CMC § 5646) | exclude-consensual-pledge: The lien secures a pledge loan; unredeemed pledges become the licensee’s property before resale. | 4 CMC § 5646 |
| Mechanics’ liens, condominium assessment liens, marijuana-premises liens, hospital real-property lien, zoning-fine liens (4 CMC §§ 5801–5809, 53064, 51556; 2 CMC §§ 6315, 7255; 10 CMC § 1714) | exclude-real-property: Attach to land, buildings or units only. | 2 CMC § 6315; 4 CMC § 5802; 4 CMC § 53064; 4 CMC § 51556; 2 CMC § 7255; 10 CMC § 1714 |
| Revenue-bond pledges (2 CMC § 2172; 4 CMC § 10460) | exclude-consensual-pledge: Liens arise from pledges the issuer makes; the statutes do not themselves create a lien. | 2 CMC § 2172; 4 CMC § 10460 |
| Casino gaming machine lien restriction (4 CMC § 51564) | exclude-restriction: Restricts creating liens; creates none. | 4 CMC § 51564 |
| Ports Authority airport damage lien on aircraft (NMIAC § 40-10.1-101(c)) | regulation-not-statute: Regulatory retention lien without a sale procedure; reported in 12.2 abandoned aircraft, not counted as a statutory regime. | NMIAC § 40-10.1 (CPA Airport Rules) |
| Support-order liens placed by a tribunal (8 CMC § 15305) | exclude-court-power: Authorizes a tribunal to place liens in UIFSA proceedings; no self-executing lien on movables. | 8 CMC § 15305 |
| Firearm seizure sale (3 CMC § 2523) and safe-deposit contents auction (4 CMC § 6528) | exclude-asset-scope: Firearms and box contents are outside module 12’s asset classes. | 3 CMC § 2523; 4 CMC § 6528 |
| Government surplus auction (1 CMC § 25102); Saipan junk-vehicle removal (10 CMC § 30507); fire-lane towing (1 CMC §§ 28065, 28070); boating-under-influence impoundment (3 CMC § 5440) | exclude-no-forced-sale: Voluntary government sales or removal/impound powers without a sale power. | 1 CMC § 25102; 10 CMC § 30507; 1 CMC § 28065; 1 CMC § 28070; 3 CMC § 5440 |
| Execution and attachment liens (7 CMC §§ 4201–4204) | channel-not-type: Part of the execution channel. | 7 CMC § 4101; 7 CMC § 4203; 7 CMC § 4204; 7 CMC § 4201; 7 CMC § 4202 |
12.4 Titles after a forced sale
| Required field | Adjudicated answer | Primary source |
|---|---|---|
| vehicle › court or execution sale › document | Registration expires on transfer “by … execution”; the buyer applies as on an original registration with evidence satisfying the Bureau of lawful ownership (9 CMC §§ 2101(b), 2103(c)); the officer’s return of the writ is the court record (7 CMC § 4204(c)). | 9 CMC § 2101; 9 CMC § 2104; 9 CMC § 2105; 9 CMC § 2107; 9 CMC § 2108; 9 CMC § 2111; 9 CMC § 2103 (as amended by PL 24-35); 7 CMC § 4101; 7 CMC § 4203; 7 CMC § 4204 |
| vehicle › court or execution sale › dmv form | Unresolved: the Bureau of Motor Vehicles’ registration and transfer forms were not located or retrieved (the code names only the Notice of Transfer and Release of Liability for voluntary transfers, 9 CMC § 2103(a)). U — needs_verification | 9 CMC § 2101; 9 CMC § 2104; 9 CMC § 2105; 9 CMC § 2107; 9 CMC § 2108; 9 CMC § 2111; 9 CMC § 2103 (as amended by PL 24-35) |
| vehicle › court or execution sale › citation | 9 CMC §§ 2101, 2103. | 9 CMC § 2101; 9 CMC § 2104; 9 CMC § 2105; 9 CMC § 2107; 9 CMC § 2108; 9 CMC § 2111; 9 CMC § 2103 (as amended by PL 24-35); 7 CMC § 4101; 7 CMC § 4203; 7 CMC § 4204 |
| vehicle › lien sale › document | Same route: original registration on proof of lawful ownership; for a § 51516 sale the lienholder must also have sent written notice to the Bureau (4 CMC § 51516(a)); the Bureau may adopt lien-processing regulations (§ 51510). | 9 CMC § 2101; 9 CMC § 2104; 9 CMC § 2105; 9 CMC § 2107; 9 CMC § 2108; 9 CMC § 2111; 9 CMC § 2103 (as amended by PL 24-35); 4 CMC § 51510; 4 CMC § 51516 |
| vehicle › lien sale › dmv form | Unresolved: the Bureau of Motor Vehicles’ registration and transfer forms were not located or retrieved (the code names only the Notice of Transfer and Release of Liability for voluntary transfers, 9 CMC § 2103(a)). U — needs_verification | 9 CMC § 2101; 9 CMC § 2104; 9 CMC § 2105; 9 CMC § 2107; 9 CMC § 2108; 9 CMC § 2111; 9 CMC § 2103 (as amended by PL 24-35) |
| vehicle › lien sale › citation | 9 CMC §§ 2101, 2103. | 9 CMC § 2101; 9 CMC § 2104; 9 CMC § 2105; 9 CMC § 2107; 9 CMC § 2108; 9 CMC § 2111; 9 CMC § 2103 (as amended by PL 24-35); 4 CMC § 51510; 4 CMC § 51516 |
| vehicle › repossession › document | Registration expires on transfer by “repossession upon default”; the buyer applies as on an original registration (9 CMC § 2103(c)); title is deemed not to pass until the new registration card issues (§ 2103(d)). | 9 CMC § 2101; 9 CMC § 2104; 9 CMC § 2105; 9 CMC § 2107; 9 CMC § 2108; 9 CMC § 2111; 9 CMC § 2103 (as amended by PL 24-35); 5 CMC § 9301; 5 CMC § 9302; 5 CMC § 9306; 5 CMC § 9310; 5 CMC § 9501; 5 CMC § 9503; 5 CMC § 9504; 5 CMC § 9505; 5 CMC § 9506; 5 CMC § 9507 |
| vehicle › repossession › dmv form | Unresolved: the Bureau of Motor Vehicles’ registration and transfer forms were not located or retrieved (the code names only the Notice of Transfer and Release of Liability for voluntary transfers, 9 CMC § 2103(a)). U — needs_verification | 9 CMC § 2101; 9 CMC § 2104; 9 CMC § 2105; 9 CMC § 2107; 9 CMC § 2108; 9 CMC § 2111; 9 CMC § 2103 (as amended by PL 24-35) |
| vehicle › repossession › citation | 9 CMC §§ 2101, 2103. | 9 CMC § 2101; 9 CMC § 2104; 9 CMC § 2105; 9 CMC § 2107; 9 CMC § 2108; 9 CMC § 2111; 9 CMC § 2103 (as amended by PL 24-35); 5 CMC § 9301; 5 CMC § 9302; 5 CMC § 9306; 5 CMC § 9310; 5 CMC § 9501; 5 CMC § 9503; 5 CMC § 9504; 5 CMC § 9505; 5 CMC § 9506; 5 CMC § 9507 |
| vehicle › abandoned vehicle › document | Original registration on proof of lawful ownership after a § 5808 public sale; junk-dealer purchases may not be registered (9 CMC § 5808(f)). | 9 CMC § 2101; 9 CMC § 2104; 9 CMC § 2105; 9 CMC § 2107; 9 CMC § 2108; 9 CMC § 2111; 9 CMC § 2103 (as amended by PL 24-35); 9 CMC § 5808 |
| vehicle › abandoned vehicle › dmv form | Unresolved: the Bureau of Motor Vehicles’ registration and transfer forms were not located or retrieved (the code names only the Notice of Transfer and Release of Liability for voluntary transfers, 9 CMC § 2103(a)). U — needs_verification | 9 CMC § 2101; 9 CMC § 2104; 9 CMC § 2105; 9 CMC § 2107; 9 CMC § 2108; 9 CMC § 2111; 9 CMC § 2103 (as amended by PL 24-35) |
| vehicle › abandoned vehicle › citation | 9 CMC §§ 2101, 2103. | 9 CMC § 2101; 9 CMC § 2104; 9 CMC § 2105; 9 CMC § 2107; 9 CMC § 2108; 9 CMC § 2111; 9 CMC § 2103 (as amended by PL 24-35); 9 CMC § 5808 |
| vehicle › surviving liens carried on title › rule | A security interest in a registered vehicle is perfected only by notation on the certificate of title, with priority and enforcement under Article 9 (9 CMC § 2103(e), PL 24-35, July 30, 2026); a noted interest continues through a sale it did not authorize (5 CMC § 9306(2)). A tax-sale certificate replaces the prior certificate and clears only interests junior to the Commonwealth lien (4 CMC § 1878). | 9 CMC § 2103 (as amended by PL 24-35); 5 CMC § 9301; 5 CMC § 9302; 5 CMC § 9306; 5 CMC § 9310; 5 CMC § 9501; 5 CMC § 9503; 5 CMC § 9504; 5 CMC § 9505; 5 CMC § 9506; 5 CMC § 9507; 4 CMC § 1871; 4 CMC § 1872; 4 CMC § 1874; 4 CMC § 1875; 4 CMC § 1876; 4 CMC § 1877; 4 CMC § 1878; 4 CMC § 1881 |
| vehicle › surviving liens carried on title › citation | 9 CMC § 2103(e); 5 CMC § 9306(2); 4 CMC § 1878. | 9 CMC § 2103 (as amended by PL 24-35); 5 CMC § 9301; 5 CMC § 9302; 5 CMC § 9306; 5 CMC § 9310; 5 CMC § 9501; 5 CMC § 9503; 5 CMC § 9504; 5 CMC § 9505; 5 CMC § 9506; 5 CMC § 9507; 4 CMC § 1871; 4 CMC § 1872; 4 CMC § 1874; 4 CMC § 1875; 4 CMC § 1876; 4 CMC § 1877; 4 CMC § 1878; 4 CMC § 1881 |
| vehicle › branding salvage rules › rule | No salvage-title statute; the only rule is that a § 5808 junk sale is “for junk or salvage purposes only, and not for further registration” (9 CMC § 5808(f)); every original registration requires a Bureau inspection report (§ 2111). | 9 CMC § 5808; 9 CMC § 2111 |
| vehicle › branding salvage rules › citation | 9 CMC §§ 2111, 5808(f). | 9 CMC § 5808; 9 CMC § 2111 |
| vessel › titling agency | No vessel title statute; the Director of Public Safety numbers undocumented motorized vessels and issues certificates of number (3 CMC §§ 5421, 5424–5425). | 3 CMC § 5412; 3 CMC § 5421; 3 CMC § 5424; 3 CMC § 5425; 3 CMC § 5427; 3 CMC § 5428; 3 CMC § 5430; 3 CMC § 5432 |
| vessel › titling threshold | Every undocumented vessel with propulsion machinery of any type, unless exempt (foreign vessels temporarily present, U.S. public vessels, lifeboats, documented vessels, vessels numbered elsewhere for up to 60 days) (3 CMC § 5421). | 3 CMC § 5412; 3 CMC § 5421; 3 CMC § 5424; 3 CMC § 5425; 3 CMC § 5427; 3 CMC § 5428; 3 CMC § 5430; 3 CMC § 5432 |
| vessel › involuntary transfer procedure › document | The certificate of number becomes invalid when the listed owner “involuntarily loses his interest … by legal process” (3 CMC § 5428(a)); the owner reports the transfer within 15 days (§ 5430); the new owner applies with “proof of ownership”, and the Director may require information on the existence of security interests (§ 5424(g)–(h)). | 3 CMC § 5412; 3 CMC § 5421; 3 CMC § 5424; 3 CMC § 5425; 3 CMC § 5427; 3 CMC § 5428; 3 CMC § 5430; 3 CMC § 5432 |
| vessel › involuntary transfer procedure › form | Application on the Director’s prescribed form with the contents listed in 3 CMC § 5424; certificate fee USD 10, duplicate USD 2 (§ 5432). | 3 CMC § 5412; 3 CMC § 5421; 3 CMC § 5424; 3 CMC § 5425; 3 CMC § 5427; 3 CMC § 5428; 3 CMC § 5430; 3 CMC § 5432 |
| vessel › involuntary transfer procedure › citation | 3 CMC §§ 5421–5432. | 3 CMC § 5412; 3 CMC § 5421; 3 CMC § 5424; 3 CMC § 5425; 3 CMC § 5427; 3 CMC § 5428; 3 CMC § 5430; 3 CMC § 5432 |
| vessel › federal documentation interplay | Documented vessels are not numbered (3 CMC § 5421(b)(5)); preferred mortgages are enforced in rem in the District Court for the Northern Mariana Islands, a “district court” under 46 U.S.C. § 31301, and a judicial sale extinguishes claims against the vessel (§§ 31325–31326). The territorial vessel lien over USD 1,000 is secondary to a perfected security interest (4 CMC § 51525(c)). See uscg-national-vessel-documentation-center. | 3 CMC § 5412; 3 CMC § 5421; 3 CMC § 5424; 3 CMC § 5425; 3 CMC § 5427; 3 CMC § 5428; 3 CMC § 5430; 3 CMC § 5432; 46 U.S.C. § 31301 (OLRC XML); 4 CMC § 51523; 4 CMC § 51524; 4 CMC § 51525; 4 CMC § 51526; 4 CMC § 51527; 4 CMC § 51528; 4 CMC § 51529; 4 CMC § 51530; 4 CMC § 51531 |
| aircraft › state registration or tax › exists | No territorial aircraft registration; aircraft fall within the 5% excise on the first sale or use of goods in the Commonwealth unless exempt (4 CMC § 1402(a)(22)). | 4 CMC § 1402 |
| aircraft › state registration or tax › citation | 4 CMC § 1402. | 4 CMC § 1402 |
| aircraft › county or state lien filing › rule | No territorial aircraft lien registry: UCC filing is “not necessary or effective” for property covered by a federal registration statute (5 CMC § 9302(3)(a)); FAA recording governs. Ports Authority airport liens arise under its rules without filing (NMIAC § 40-10.1-101(c)). | 5 CMC § 9301; 5 CMC § 9302; 5 CMC § 9306; 5 CMC § 9310; 5 CMC § 9501; 5 CMC § 9503; 5 CMC § 9504; 5 CMC § 9505; 5 CMC § 9506; 5 CMC § 9507; NMIAC § 40-10.1 (CPA Airport Rules) |
| aircraft › county or state lien filing › citation | 5 CMC § 9302(3)(a); NMIAC § 40-10.1-101(c). | 5 CMC § 9301; 5 CMC § 9302; 5 CMC § 9306; 5 CMC § 9310; 5 CMC § 9501; 5 CMC § 9503; 5 CMC § 9504; 5 CMC § 9505; 5 CMC § 9506; 5 CMC § 9507; NMIAC § 40-10.1 (CPA Airport Rules) |
| titled equipment and trailers › threshold | Trucks, buses, “self-propelled equipment and machinery” and low-boys are registered by gross weight (9 CMC § 2104(a)(5)–(7)); farm and heavy construction equipment may move between sites under a special permit (§ 2108(g)); other equipment is perfected by UCC filing (5 CMC § 9302). | 9 CMC § 2101; 9 CMC § 2104; 9 CMC § 2105; 9 CMC § 2107; 9 CMC § 2108; 9 CMC § 2111; 9 CMC § 2103 (as amended by PL 24-35); 5 CMC § 9301; 5 CMC § 9302; 5 CMC § 9306; 5 CMC § 9310; 5 CMC § 9501; 5 CMC § 9503; 5 CMC § 9504; 5 CMC § 9505; 5 CMC § 9506; 5 CMC § 9507 |
| titled equipment and trailers › citation | 9 CMC §§ 2104, 2108; 5 CMC § 9302. | 9 CMC § 2101; 9 CMC § 2104; 9 CMC § 2105; 9 CMC § 2107; 9 CMC § 2108; 9 CMC § 2111; 9 CMC § 2103 (as amended by PL 24-35); 5 CMC § 9301; 5 CMC § 9302; 5 CMC § 9306; 5 CMC § 9310; 5 CMC § 9501; 5 CMC § 9503; 5 CMC § 9504; 5 CMC § 9505; 5 CMC § 9506; 5 CMC § 9507 |
12.5 Businesses and business interests
| Required field | Adjudicated answer | Primary source |
|---|---|---|
| receivership › statute | Judgment-enforcement receivers (7 CMC § 4104); corporate dissolution receivers who may sell assets publicly or privately if the court authorizes (4 CMC § 4623(c)(1)(i)); charging-order receivers (4 CMC §§ 4874(a), 40144(a)); NMI R. Civ. P. 66. | 7 CMC § 4104; 4 CMC § 4623; 4 CMC § 4871; 4 CMC § 4874; 4 CMC § 40144; NMI R. Civ. P. (eff. Jan. 9, 2019) |
| receivership › uniform act adopted | No uniform receivership act; Rule 66 only governs actions with receivers. | NMI R. Civ. P. (eff. Jan. 9, 2019); 4 CMC § 4623 |
| receivership › sale free and clear | No statutory free-and-clear power: a corporate receiver sells “if authorized by the court” (4 CMC § 4623(c)(1)(i)) and a § 4104 receiver disposes of property “in accordance with the orders of the court”; any lien discharge must come from the order. | 4 CMC § 4623; 7 CMC § 4104 |
| receivership › confirmation | Court authorization and the appointing order define the receiver’s powers; hearing on notice to parties before appointment (4 CMC § 4623(a), (c)). | 4 CMC § 4623 |
| receivership › citation | 7 CMC § 4104; 4 CMC § 4623; NMI R. Civ. P. 66. | 7 CMC § 4104; 4 CMC § 4623; NMI R. Civ. P. (eff. Jan. 9, 2019) |
| assignment for benefit of creditors › statute or common law | No assignment statute; the UCC recognizes assignments for the benefit of all creditors (filing exception, 5 CMC § 9302(1)(g); assignee is a lien creditor, § 9301(3); bulk-transfer exception, § 6103), and courts may use any method “known to American common law” (7 CMC § 4104). | 5 CMC § 9301; 5 CMC § 9302; 5 CMC § 9306; 5 CMC § 9310; 5 CMC § 9501; 5 CMC § 9503; 5 CMC § 9504; 5 CMC § 9505; 5 CMC § 9506; 5 CMC § 9507; 5 CMC § 6101; 5 CMC § 6102; 5 CMC § 6103; 5 CMC § 6105; 5 CMC § 6106; 5 CMC § 6107; 5 CMC § 6108; 5 CMC § 6109; 5 CMC § 6110; 5 CMC § 6111; 7 CMC § 4104 |
| assignment for benefit of creditors › court supervised | No statutory court supervision. | 5 CMC § 9301; 5 CMC § 9302; 5 CMC § 9306; 5 CMC § 9310; 5 CMC § 9501; 5 CMC § 9503; 5 CMC § 9504; 5 CMC § 9505; 5 CMC § 9506; 5 CMC § 9507; 7 CMC § 4104 |
| assignment for benefit of creditors › citation | 5 CMC §§ 6103, 9301(3), 9302(1)(g); 7 CMC § 4104. | 5 CMC § 6101; 5 CMC § 6102; 5 CMC § 6103; 5 CMC § 6105; 5 CMC § 6106; 5 CMC § 6107; 5 CMC § 6108; 5 CMC § 6109; 5 CMC § 6110; 5 CMC § 6111; 5 CMC § 9301; 5 CMC § 9302; 5 CMC § 9306; 5 CMC § 9310; 5 CMC § 9501; 5 CMC § 9503; 5 CMC § 9504; 5 CMC § 9505; 5 CMC § 9506; 5 CMC § 9507; 7 CMC § 4104 |
| llc charging order › statute | 4 CMC § 4874. | 4 CMC § 4871; 4 CMC § 4874 |
| llc charging order › foreclosure allowed | Yes: “The court may order a foreclosure of a lien on a distributional interest subject to the charging order at any time” (4 CMC § 4874(b)). | 4 CMC § 4871; 4 CMC § 4874 |
| llc charging order › single member rule | No separate single-member rule: § 4874 applies to every LLC and is the exclusive remedy against a member’s distributional interest (§ 4874(e)). | 4 CMC § 4871; 4 CMC § 4874 |
| llc charging order › buyer rights | The foreclosure purchaser “has the rights of a transferee” (§ 4874(b)); members do not own company property (§ 4871). Before foreclosure the interest may be redeemed by the debtor, other members (non-company property) or the company if the operating agreement permits (§ 4874(c)). | 4 CMC § 4871; 4 CMC § 4874 |
| llc charging order › citation | 4 CMC §§ 4871, 4874. | 4 CMC § 4871; 4 CMC § 4874 |
| partnership charging order › statute | 4 CMC § 40144 (Uniform Partnership Act); no limited-partnership act was found in the code. | 4 CMC § 40144; LRC Commonwealth Code update table |
| partnership charging order › foreclosure allowed | Yes: the court may order foreclosure of the charged transferable interest at any time; the purchaser has transferee rights; exclusive remedy (4 CMC § 40144(b), (e)). | 4 CMC § 40144 |
| partnership charging order › citation | 4 CMC § 40144. | 4 CMC § 40144 |
| stock levy › ucc 8 112 adopted | No: old Article 8 § 8317 — no levy on an outstanding certificated security until actually seized; uncertificated securities by process at the issuer’s chief executive office; court aid for hard-to-reach securities (5 CMC § 8317). A tax-sale certificate authorizes the transfer on the corporation’s books (4 CMC § 1878(a)(3)). | 5 CMC § 8317; 4 CMC § 1871; 4 CMC § 1872; 4 CMC § 1874; 4 CMC § 1875; 4 CMC § 1876; 4 CMC § 1877; 4 CMC § 1878; 4 CMC § 1881 |
| stock levy › citation | 5 CMC § 8317; 4 CMC § 1878(a)(3). | 5 CMC § 8317; 4 CMC § 1871; 4 CMC § 1872; 4 CMC § 1874; 4 CMC § 1875; 4 CMC § 1876; 4 CMC § 1877; 4 CMC § 1878; 4 CMC § 1881 |
| bulk sale or tax clearance › ucc article 6 status › repealed | No: UCC Article 6 remains in force (5 CMC §§ 6101–6111): creditor notice at least 10 days before the transferee takes possession or pays (§ 6105); auction bulk sales require the auctioneer’s 10-day notice, but failure does not affect the validity of the sale or the purchasers’ title (§ 6108(4)); six-month limitation (§ 6111). Excepted: transfers by secured parties realizing collateral, receivers, trustees in bankruptcy, public officers under judicial process, assignments for creditors (§ 6103). | 5 CMC § 6101; 5 CMC § 6102; 5 CMC § 6103; 5 CMC § 6105; 5 CMC § 6106; 5 CMC § 6107; 5 CMC § 6108; 5 CMC § 6109; 5 CMC § 6110; 5 CMC § 6111 |
| bulk sale or tax clearance › ucc article 6 status › citation | 5 CMC §§ 6101–6111. | 5 CMC § 6101; 5 CMC § 6102; 5 CMC § 6103; 5 CMC § 6105; 5 CMC § 6106; 5 CMC § 6107; 5 CMC § 6108; 5 CMC § 6109; 5 CMC § 6110; 5 CMC § 6111 |
| bulk sale or tax clearance › tax successor liability › notice days | No tax-clearance notice period; transferee liability is assessed like the underlying tax (4 CMC § 1842(a)). | 4 CMC § 1842 |
| bulk sale or tax clearance › tax successor liability › buyer liability | A transferee’s liability at law or in equity for Commonwealth (non-NMTIT) taxes is assessed and collected as the tax itself, within one year after the limitation period against the transferor (4 CMC § 1842(a)–(c)); NMTIT transferee liability follows 26 U.S.C. § 6901 as adopted. | 4 CMC § 1842; 4 CMC § 1701; 4 CMC § 1702 |
| bulk sale or tax clearance › tax successor liability › exceptions for forced sales | None stated in § 1842; a recorded tax lien is cleared only by release, discharge or a sale that discharges it (4 CMC §§ 1866, 1878(c)). | 4 CMC § 1842; 4 CMC § 1866; 4 CMC § 1871; 4 CMC § 1872; 4 CMC § 1874; 4 CMC § 1875; 4 CMC § 1876; 4 CMC § 1877; 4 CMC § 1878; 4 CMC § 1881 |
| bulk sale or tax clearance › tax successor liability › citation | 4 CMC §§ 1842, 1866, 1878. | 4 CMC § 1842; 4 CMC § 1866; 4 CMC § 1871; 4 CMC § 1872; 4 CMC § 1874; 4 CMC § 1875; 4 CMC § 1876; 4 CMC § 1877; 4 CMC § 1878; 4 CMC § 1881 |
| licences › liquor › transferable at forced sale | No transfer route: a licensee is limited to the licence’s privileges and premises (4 CMC §§ 5529–5530); after revocation, surrender or non-renewal, stock may be sold only “under supervision of the board” to another licensee (§ 5522). A buyer needs its own licence. | 4 CMC § 5522; 4 CMC § 5529; 4 CMC § 5530 |
| licences › liquor › procedure | New licence application; stock sales to another licensee under Board regulations (4 CMC § 5522). | 4 CMC § 5522; 4 CMC § 5529; 4 CMC § 5530 |
| licences › liquor › citation | 4 CMC §§ 5522, 5529, 5530. | 4 CMC § 5522; 4 CMC § 5529; 4 CMC § 5530 |
| licences › other notable | General business licences are valid one year and “not transferable” (4 CMC § 5611(c)); casino-related licences may not be sold, assigned, pledged or encumbered without Casino Commission permission (4 CMC § 2317(f)), and no lien or security interest may be taken on a regulated gaming machine without Commission permission and a licence (§ 51564). | 4 CMC § 5611; 4 CMC § 2317; 4 CMC § 51564 |
12.6 Taxes when buying
| Required field | Adjudicated answer | Primary source |
|---|---|---|
| vehicles › rate | Excise on the first sale, use, lease or rental in the Commonwealth: passenger vehicles 5% (value up to USD 30,000) or 5.75% (over USD 30,000) (4 CMC § 1402(a)(12)–(13)). | 4 CMC § 1402 |
| vehicles › base | Ad valorem value of the first sale or use (4 CMC § 1402(a)). | 4 CMC § 1402 |
| vehicles › who collects | Department of Finance, Division of Revenue and Taxation (4 CMC §§ 1402, 1851). | 4 CMC § 1402; 4 CMC § 1851 |
| vehicles › casual or isolated sale exemption | Not needed: the excise reaches only the first sale or use in the Commonwealth (4 CMC § 1402(b)), so a later resale of a vehicle already taxed is not taxed again. | 4 CMC § 1402 |
| vehicles › forced sale rule | A forced resale of a vehicle already in the Commonwealth is not a “first sale” (4 CMC § 1402(b)); the buyer pays registration fees (9 CMC § 2104). | 4 CMC § 1402; 9 CMC § 2101; 9 CMC § 2104; 9 CMC § 2105; 9 CMC § 2107; 9 CMC § 2108; 9 CMC § 2111; 9 CMC § 2103 (as amended by PL 24-35) |
| vehicles › citation | 4 CMC § 1402; 9 CMC § 2104. | 4 CMC § 1402; 9 CMC § 2101; 9 CMC § 2104; 9 CMC § 2105; 9 CMC § 2107; 9 CMC § 2108; 9 CMC § 2111; 9 CMC § 2103 (as amended by PL 24-35) |
| vessels › rate | First-sale excise: boats and yachts over USD 500,000, 5.75%; otherwise the 5% general rate (4 CMC § 1402(a)(14), (22)). | 4 CMC § 1402 |
| vessels › cap | No cap. | 4 CMC § 1402 |
| vessels › citation | 4 CMC § 1402. | 4 CMC § 1402 |
| aircraft › rate | General 5% first-sale excise (4 CMC § 1402(a)(22)). | 4 CMC § 1402 |
| aircraft › exemptions | The § 1402(c) exemptions (e.g., capital equipment for export manufacturing over USD 1,000 a unit; items brought in temporarily for display or demonstration); no aircraft-specific exemption. | 4 CMC § 1402 |
| aircraft › citation | 4 CMC § 1402(a), (c). | 4 CMC § 1402 |
| equipment and business assets › rate | First-sale excise: construction equipment and machinery 3%, agricultural equipment 1%, other goods 5% (4 CMC § 1402(a)(3), (8), (22)); a business seller owes gross revenue tax of 1.5–5% by bracket (none up to USD 5,000) (4 CMC § 1301). | 4 CMC § 1402; 4 CMC § 1301; 4 CMC § 1103; 4 CMC § 1305 |
| equipment and business assets › occasional sale exemption | Excise: first sale only (4 CMC § 1402(b)). Gross revenue tax: no casual-sale exemption, but the Secretary may exempt de minimis transactions by regulation (§ 1305(d)) and money held in a fiduciary capacity is not gross revenue (§ 1103). | 4 CMC § 1402; 4 CMC § 1301; 4 CMC § 1103; 4 CMC § 1305 |
| equipment and business assets › auctioneer as retailer | Unresolved: the code does not say whether an auctioneer or levying officer owes gross revenue tax on the whole sale price or only on commissions; the fiduciary-capacity exclusion (4 CMC § 1103) may apply but is not applied to auctions by statute or retrieved regulation. U — needs_verification | 4 CMC § 1301; 4 CMC § 1103; 4 CMC § 1305 |
| equipment and business assets › citation | 4 CMC §§ 1103, 1301, 1305, 1402. | 4 CMC § 1301; 4 CMC § 1103; 4 CMC § 1305; 4 CMC § 1402 |
| transfer fees › title fee | No separate title fee in the code; registration fees by class apply (9 CMC § 2104); vessel certificate of number USD 10 (3 CMC § 5432). | 9 CMC § 2101; 9 CMC § 2104; 9 CMC § 2105; 9 CMC § 2107; 9 CMC § 2108; 9 CMC § 2111; 9 CMC § 2103 (as amended by PL 24-35); 3 CMC § 5412; 3 CMC § 5421; 3 CMC § 5424; 3 CMC § 5425; 3 CMC § 5427; 3 CMC § 5428; 3 CMC § 5430; 3 CMC § 5432 |
| transfer fees › registration fee | Bicycles USD 3; mopeds and scooters to 100cc USD 20, over 100cc USD 30; passenger vehicles under 2,000 lb USD 60; trucks, buses and self-propelled equipment USD 60–420 by weight; low-boys USD 60; other self-propelled vehicles USD 110 (9 CMC § 2104(a)); late renewal USD 30 (§ 2107). | 9 CMC § 2101; 9 CMC § 2104; 9 CMC § 2105; 9 CMC § 2107; 9 CMC § 2108; 9 CMC § 2111; 9 CMC § 2103 (as amended by PL 24-35) |
| transfer fees › citation | 9 CMC §§ 2104, 2107; 3 CMC § 5432. | 9 CMC § 2101; 9 CMC § 2104; 9 CMC § 2105; 9 CMC § 2107; 9 CMC § 2108; 9 CMC § 2111; 9 CMC § 2103 (as amended by PL 24-35); 3 CMC § 5412; 3 CMC § 5421; 3 CMC § 5424; 3 CMC § 5425; 3 CMC § 5427; 3 CMC § 5428; 3 CMC § 5430; 3 CMC § 5432 |
12.7 Where these sales are published
| Required field | Adjudicated answer | Primary source |
|---|---|---|
| legal notice statute › statute | None of general application; each statute names its medium: clerk notice and posting for executions (7 CMC § 4204(b)); local newspaper plus U.S. Post Office posting for tax sales (4 CMC § 1875(b)); newspaper three consecutive weeks for vehicle and vessel lien sales (4 CMC §§ 51516(c), 51527(f)); newspaper two weeks for storage sales (§ 51540(b)); newspaper 10 days for abandoned vehicles (9 CMC § 5808(f)). | 7 CMC § 4204; 4 CMC § 1875; 4 CMC § 51516; 4 CMC § 51527; 4 CMC § 51540; 9 CMC § 5808 |
| legal notice statute › newspaper qualification | No qualification statute; the statutes require only a newspaper “published in” or “of general circulation in” the place of sale or the Commonwealth (e.g., 4 CMC § 51516(c); 9 CMC § 5808(f)). | 4 CMC § 51516; 9 CMC § 5808 |
| statewide site › name | None established by statute. | LRC Commonwealth Code update table |
| statewide site › url | Not applicable. (not applicable) | LRC Commonwealth Code update table |
| statewide site › statute | None. | LRC Commonwealth Code update table |
| statewide site › reuse terms | Not applicable. (not applicable) | LRC Commonwealth Code update table |
| officer portals | Unresolved: no Department of Public Safety or court sale-notice page was located or retrieved. U — needs_verification | 7 CMC § 4101; 7 CMC § 4203; 7 CMC § 4204 |
| dmv or agency postings | Unresolved: no Bureau of Motor Vehicles, Division of Revenue and Taxation or Ports Authority auction page was located or retrieved. U — needs_verification | 9 CMC § 5808 |
| collectability note | Fragmented: execution notices are posted at local government offices and given to the clerk; tax, lien and abandoned-vehicle sales use local newspapers; storage sales may use six postings when no newspaper exists. No single feed exists. | 7 CMC § 4101; 7 CMC § 4203; 7 CMC § 4204; 4 CMC § 1871; 4 CMC § 1872; 4 CMC § 1874; 4 CMC § 1875; 4 CMC § 1876; 4 CMC § 1877; 4 CMC § 1878; 4 CMC § 1881; 4 CMC § 51509; 4 CMC § 51510; 4 CMC § 51511; 4 CMC § 51512; 4 CMC § 51513; 4 CMC § 51514; 4 CMC § 51515; 4 CMC § 51516; 4 CMC § 51517; 4 CMC § 51518; 4 CMC § 51519; 4 CMC § 51520; 4 CMC § 51521; 4 CMC § 51522; 4 CMC § 51533; 4 CMC § 51535; 4 CMC § 51536; 4 CMC § 51537; 4 CMC § 51538; 4 CMC § 51539; 4 CMC § 51540; 4 CMC § 51541; 4 CMC § 51542; 4 CMC § 51543; 4 CMC § 51544; 9 CMC § 5808 |
12.8 Buyer checklist
- Execution sales reach only personal property; land goes only through an order in aid of judgment (7 CMC § 4210; triple-j-saipan-v-rasiang-1999).
- Find execution sales at the clerk of court and the local government office posting; notice can be as short as 7 days (7 CMC § 4204).
- Execution statutes set no deposit, payment deadline or buyer certificate; agree terms with the officer and keep the writ return (7 CMC § 4204).
- Tools and equipment necessary to the debtor’s occupation are exempt without a dollar cap, so work trucks and equipment can be pulled from a sale (7 CMC § 4210).
- Check the certificate of title for a noted security interest: since PL 24-35 that notation is the only way to perfect on a registered vehicle (9 CMC § 2103).
- Title “shall be deemed not to have passed” until the Bureau issues your new registration; budget time for re-registration and inspection (9 CMC § 2103; 9 CMC § 2111).
- Search the Commonwealth Recorder for tax liens; a tax-sale certificate clears only interests junior to the Commonwealth lien (4 CMC § 1865; 4 CMC § 1878).
- At a garage or tow auction, the lien beats a lender only up to USD 1,000 (USD 2,500 for towing and storage after 30 days); confirm the 10-day demand, Bureau notice and three weekly ads with a 22-day gap (4 CMC § 51514; 4 CMC § 51516).
- At a marina or vessel-lien auction, any lien amount over USD 1,000 is junior to a perfected security interest (4 CMC § 51525).
- At a storage auction, a sworn opposition stops the sale and vehicle or vessel title liens stay ahead of the storage lien (4 CMC § 51539; 4 CMC § 51535).
- Abandoned vehicles under USD 100 go only to junk dealers and cannot be registered; above that, check for the 10-day newspaper notice (9 CMC § 5808).
- At a repossession resale, ask for proof of the § 9504(3) notice: without it the lender gets no deficiency, and the buyer in good faith is protected (triple-j-saipan-v-sanchez-2007; 5 CMC § 9504).
- Bulk purchases of inventory trigger Article 6 creditor notice unless the seller is a secured party, receiver, trustee or public officer (5 CMC § 6103; 5 CMC § 6105).
- LLC and partnership interests can be foreclosed but give only transferee rights (4 CMC § 4874; 4 CMC § 40144).
- Licences do not come with the business: general business licences are not transferable and liquor stock goes only to another licensee under Board supervision (4 CMC § 5611; 4 CMC § 5522).
- Excise applies only on the first sale or use in the Commonwealth, so a forced resale of goods already here is not taxed again (4 CMC § 1402).
| Required field | Adjudicated answer | Primary source |
|---|---|---|
| items | Sixteen CNMI-specific checks listed in 12.8, each tied to the cited statute or opinion. | 7 CMC § 4101; 7 CMC § 4203; 7 CMC § 4204; 4 CMC § 51509; 4 CMC § 51510; 4 CMC § 51511; 4 CMC § 51512; 4 CMC § 51513; 4 CMC § 51514; 4 CMC § 51515; 4 CMC § 51516; 4 CMC § 51517; 4 CMC § 51518; 4 CMC § 51519; 4 CMC § 51520; 4 CMC § 51521; 4 CMC § 51522; 9 CMC § 2103 (as amended by PL 24-35); 5 CMC § 9301; 5 CMC § 9302; 5 CMC § 9306; 5 CMC § 9310; 5 CMC § 9501; 5 CMC § 9503; 5 CMC § 9504; 5 CMC § 9505; 5 CMC § 9506; 5 CMC § 9507 |
12.9 Case law
| Case | Court / date | Holding used here (full opinion read) | Opinion source |
|---|---|---|---|
| triple-j-saipan-v-rasiang-1999 | CNMI Supreme Court, Mar. 17, 1999 (1999 MP 7) | Affirmed vacatur of a writ of execution against a homestead lot: land is exempt from execution under 7 CMC § 4210(c) and may be sold only by a discretionary order in aid of judgment; homestead land cannot be sold by judicial sale within ten years (N.M.I. Const. art. XI, § 5(a)). Fixes the execution channel’s reach (personal property). | 1999 MP 07 |
| triple-j-saipan-v-sanchez-2007 | CNMI Supreme Court, Oct. 24, 2007 (2007 MP 23) | Dealer resale of a repossessed car a year after repossession, two months after repairs, was commercially reasonable; a commercially unreasonable disposition triggers the rebuttable presumption rule and § 9507(1) damages; lack of § 9504(3) notice remains an absolute bar to a deficiency. | 2007 MP 23 |
| atkins-kroll-v-ferrera-2019 | CNMI Supreme Court, Dec. 13, 2019 (2019 MP 10) | Vehicle repossession and resale followed by a deficiency suit; denial of a new trial reversed so the creditor could present additional § 9504(3) notice evidence; compliance left for remand. | 2019 MP 10 |
The Supreme Court opinion set on cnmilaw.gov (772 opinions, 1989–2026; four files returned HTTP 404) was screened for later citations of the linked cases. No commercial citator was used.
| Required field | Adjudicated answer | Primary source |
|---|---|---|
| cases | Three linked full opinions: Triple J Saipan v. Rasiang, 1999 MP 7; Triple J Saipan v. Sanchez, 2007 MP 23; Atkins Kroll (Saipan) v. Ferrera, 2019 MP 10. | 1999 MP 07; 2007 MP 23; 2019 MP 10 |
What the buyer takes, by actual sale channel
| Channel | Authority | Buyer takes / what survives | Status | Primary source |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Police or officer execution sale (with orders in aid of judgment) | 7 CMC §§ 4203–4210 | The debtor’s interest; perfected security interests (5 CMC § 9301(4)), title-noted vehicle interests (9 CMC § 2103(e)) and recorded tax liens survive; no personalty redemption; land only by order in aid (1999 MP 7). | complete | 7 CMC § 4101; 7 CMC § 4203; 7 CMC § 4204; 7 CMC § 4205; 7 CMC § 4206; 7 CMC § 4209; 5 CMC § 9301; 5 CMC § 9302; 5 CMC § 9306; 5 CMC § 9310; 5 CMC § 9501; 5 CMC § 9503; 5 CMC § 9504; 5 CMC § 9505; 5 CMC § 9506; 5 CMC § 9507; 9 CMC § 2103 (as amended by PL 24-35); 1999 MP 07 |
| Court-ordered sale of attached perishable property | 7 CMC § 4202 | Same as execution; proceeds abide the judgment. | complete | 7 CMC § 4201; 7 CMC § 4202; 7 CMC § 4101; 7 CMC § 4203; 7 CMC § 4204 |
| Commonwealth tax levy sale | 4 CMC §§ 1871–1881 | Delinquent’s interest; interests junior to the Commonwealth lien discharged; senior survive (§ 1878). | complete | 4 CMC § 1871; 4 CMC § 1872; 4 CMC § 1874; 4 CMC § 1875; 4 CMC § 1876; 4 CMC § 1877; 4 CMC § 1878; 4 CMC § 1881 |
| Territorial income tax levy sale | 4 CMC §§ 1701–1702; 26 U.S.C. §§ 6331–6342 | Delinquent’s interest; junior interests discharged (§ 6339). | complete | 4 CMC § 1701; 4 CMC § 1702; 26 U.S.C. § 6335 (OLRC XML) |
| Abandoned vehicle public or junk sale | 9 CMC § 5808 | Default-rule inference: no free-and-clear clause; title-noted security interests continue (5 CMC § 9306(2)); junk buyers cannot register. | complete | 9 CMC § 5808; 5 CMC § 9301; 5 CMC § 9302; 5 CMC § 9306; 5 CMC § 9310; 5 CMC § 9501; 5 CMC § 9503; 5 CMC § 9504; 5 CMC § 9505; 5 CMC § 9506; 5 CMC § 9507 |
| Ports Authority sale of obstructing vessels | NMIAC § 40-20.1-110(m)(2) | Default-rule inference: no free-and-clear clause; perfected interests continue; surplus credited to owner. | complete | NMIAC § 40-20.1 (CPA Harbor Regulations); 5 CMC § 9301; 5 CMC § 9302; 5 CMC § 9306; 5 CMC § 9310; 5 CMC § 9501; 5 CMC § 9503; 5 CMC § 9504; 5 CMC § 9505; 5 CMC § 9506; 5 CMC § 9507 |
| Ports Authority disposal of airline property and aircraft left after cancellation | NMIAC § 40-10.1-742(a)(2) | Default-rule inference: the rule states no title effect; perfected interests continue absent authorization (5 CMC § 9306(2)). | complete | NMIAC § 40-10.1 (CPA Airport Rules); 5 CMC § 9301; 5 CMC § 9302; 5 CMC § 9306; 5 CMC § 9310; 5 CMC § 9501; 5 CMC § 9503; 5 CMC § 9504; 5 CMC § 9505; 5 CMC § 9506; 5 CMC § 9507 |
| Controlled-substance and contraband forfeiture sale | 6 CMC §§ 2150, 2303 | Forfeited property is property in which “no property right shall exist” (§ 2150(a)); the buyer takes the Commonwealth’s title; innocent-owner limits and incorporated remission provisions apply before forfeiture. | complete | 6 CMC § 2150; 6 CMC § 2303 |
| Alcoholic-beverage forfeiture: court-ordered public sale of vehicles | 4 CMC §§ 5594, 5596 | Default-rule inference: court-ordered sale of the forfeited vehicle; innocent owners are protected before forfeiture (§ 5594(b)). | complete | 4 CMC § 5594; 4 CMC § 5596 |
| Vehicle towing, storage and repair lien auction | 4 CMC §§ 51511–51522 | Lienholder alone answers to owners after sale to an innocent third party (§ 51520); otherwise default-rule inference (5 CMC § 9306(2)). | complete | 4 CMC § 51509; 4 CMC § 51510; 4 CMC § 51511; 4 CMC § 51512; 4 CMC § 51513; 4 CMC § 51514; 4 CMC § 51515; 4 CMC § 51516; 4 CMC § 51517; 4 CMC § 51518; 4 CMC § 51519; 4 CMC § 51520; 4 CMC § 51521; 4 CMC § 51522; 5 CMC § 9301; 5 CMC § 9302; 5 CMC § 9306; 5 CMC § 9310; 5 CMC § 9501; 5 CMC § 9503; 5 CMC § 9504; 5 CMC § 9505; 5 CMC § 9506; 5 CMC § 9507 |
| Vessel wage and service lien auction | 4 CMC §§ 51524–51532 | Lienholder alone answers after sale to an innocent third party (§ 51531); lien over USD 1,000 junior to a perfected security interest (§ 51525(c)). | complete | 4 CMC § 51523; 4 CMC § 51524; 4 CMC § 51525; 4 CMC § 51526; 4 CMC § 51527; 4 CMC § 51528; 4 CMC § 51529; 4 CMC § 51530; 4 CMC § 51531; 5 CMC § 9301; 5 CMC § 9302; 5 CMC § 9306; 5 CMC § 9310; 5 CMC § 9501; 5 CMC § 9503; 5 CMC § 9504; 5 CMC § 9505; 5 CMC § 9506; 5 CMC § 9507 |
| Self-service storage lien sale | 4 CMC §§ 51537–51544 | Good-faith buyer free of the occupant’s interests (§ 51544); vehicle and vessel title liens rank ahead (§ 51535(b)). | complete | 4 CMC § 51533; 4 CMC § 51535; 4 CMC § 51536; 4 CMC § 51537; 4 CMC § 51538; 4 CMC § 51539; 4 CMC § 51540; 4 CMC § 51541; 4 CMC § 51542; 4 CMC § 51543; 4 CMC § 51544; 5 CMC § 9301; 5 CMC § 9302; 5 CMC § 9306; 5 CMC § 9310; 5 CMC § 9501; 5 CMC § 9503; 5 CMC § 9504; 5 CMC § 9505; 5 CMC § 9506; 5 CMC § 9507 |
| Equipment, appliance and jewelry repair lien sale | 4 CMC § 51502 | Default-rule inference (5 CMC § 9306(2)); surplus to owner. | complete | 4 CMC § 51502; 5 CMC § 9301; 5 CMC § 9302; 5 CMC § 9306; 5 CMC § 9310; 5 CMC § 9501; 5 CMC § 9503; 5 CMC § 9504; 5 CMC § 9505; 5 CMC § 9506; 5 CMC § 9507 |
| Hotel and lodging lien auction | 4 CMC §§ 51545–51547 | Default-rule inference; no sale valid without notice. | complete | 4 CMC § 51545; 4 CMC § 51546; 4 CMC § 51547; 5 CMC § 9301; 5 CMC § 9302; 5 CMC § 9306; 5 CMC § 9310; 5 CMC § 9501; 5 CMC § 9503; 5 CMC § 9504; 5 CMC § 9505; 5 CMC § 9506; 5 CMC § 9507 |
| Article 9 secured-party disposition | 5 CMC §§ 9503–9507 | Debtor’s rights; foreclosed and subordinate interests discharged; protected purchaser (§ 9504(4)); notice failure bars deficiency (2007 MP 23). | complete | 5 CMC § 9301; 5 CMC § 9302; 5 CMC § 9306; 5 CMC § 9310; 5 CMC § 9501; 5 CMC § 9503; 5 CMC § 9504; 5 CMC § 9505; 5 CMC § 9506; 5 CMC § 9507; 2007 MP 23 |
| Article 2/4 resale (seller reservation, rejecting buyer, presenting bank) | 5 CMC §§ 2706, 2711(3), 4504 | Good-faith purchaser free of the other party’s rights (§ 2706). | complete | 5 CMC § 2505; 5 CMC § 2706; 5 CMC § 2711; 5 CMC § 4208; 5 CMC § 4504 |
| Warehouse lien sale | 5 CMC § 7210 | Good-faith purchaser free of rights against which the lien was valid (§ 7210). | complete | 5 CMC § 7209; 5 CMC § 7210 |
| Carrier lien sale | 5 CMC § 7308 | Good-faith purchaser free of rights against which the lien was valid (§ 7308). | complete | 5 CMC § 7307; 5 CMC § 7308 |
| LLC distributional-interest foreclosure sale | 4 CMC § 4874 | Purchaser has transferee rights only (§ 4874(b)). | complete | 4 CMC § 4871; 4 CMC § 4874 |
| Partnership transferable-interest foreclosure sale | 4 CMC § 40144 | Purchaser has transferee rights only (§ 40144(b)). | complete | 4 CMC § 40144 |
| Receiver sale (judgment enforcement or corporate dissolution) | 7 CMC § 4104; 4 CMC § 4623 | The interest the authorized sale conveys; no statutory free-and-clear rule, so liens are discharged only as the order provides. | complete | 7 CMC § 4104; 4 CMC § 4623 |
| District Court for the NMI admiralty or preferred-mortgage sale | 48 U.S.C. § 1822; 46 U.S.C. §§ 31325–31326; 28 U.S.C. § 2004 | Vessel sold free of claims, which attach to the proceeds (§ 31326). | complete | 48 U.S.C. § 1822 (OLRC XML); 46 U.S.C. § 31325 (OLRC XML); 28 U.S.C. § 2004 (OLRC XML) |
Module-12 gap register and scoped composite
Scoped composite gap_score_m12 = 28 = 20 U (row 18) + 4 x 2 incomplete priority/court/title triads (row 19) + 6 x 0 incomplete actual buyer channels (row 20). Denominator: 165 canonical base paths + 15 x 25 statutory regimes = 540 required attributes. Rows 3, 4, 5, 7, 8, 10, 16, 17, 21, 22, 23 and 24 contribute zero after the claim/source audit. This is a scoped module score, not the page’s global gap_score and not a strict keep-gate pass while any U remains.
| Counted item | Row | Points |
|---|---|---|
| U: module_12_1_execution_sale.payment_terms.deposit | 18 | 1 |
| U: module_12_1_execution_sale.payment_terms.balance_due | 18 | 1 |
| U: module_12_1_execution_sale.payment_terms.credit_sales | 18 | 1 |
| U: module_12_1_execution_sale.payment_terms.default_consequence | 18 | 1 |
| U: module_12_4_titles_after_forced_sale.vehicle.court_or_execution_sale.dmv_form | 18 | 1 |
| U: module_12_4_titles_after_forced_sale.vehicle.lien_sale.dmv_form | 18 | 1 |
| U: module_12_4_titles_after_forced_sale.vehicle.repossession.dmv_form | 18 | 1 |
| U: module_12_4_titles_after_forced_sale.vehicle.abandoned_vehicle.dmv_form | 18 | 1 |
| U: module_12_6_taxes_on_purchase.equipment_and_business_assets.auctioneer_as_retailer | 18 | 1 |
| U: module_12_7_where_published.officer_portals | 18 | 1 |
| U: module_12_7_where_published.dmv_or_agency_postings | 18 | 1 |
| U: developer-tax.priority_vs_perfected_security_interest | 18 | 1 |
| U: developer-tax.notice_to_owner | 18 | 1 |
| U: developer-tax.notice_to_lienholders | 18 | 1 |
| U: developer-tax.publication | 18 | 1 |
| U: developer-tax.waiting_period | 18 | 1 |
| U: developer-tax.sale_method | 18 | 1 |
| U: developer-tax.buyer_title | 18 | 1 |
| U: developer-tax.surplus_handling | 18 | 1 |
| U: medicaid.priority_vs_perfected_security_interest | 18 | 1 |
| Incomplete triad: developer-tax | 19 | 4 |
| Incomplete triad: medicaid | 19 | 4 |
▸ For Buyers / Operators — Execution sales reach personal property only, on 7 days’ posted notice (7 CMC §§ 4203–4204); vehicle title passes only when the Bureau issues the new registration, and noted security interests follow the car (9 CMC § 2103); garage and marina liens beat lenders only up to USD 1,000 (4 CMC §§ 51514, 51525(c)); tax-sale certificates clear only junior liens (4 CMC § 1878).
▸ For Owners / Debtors — Tools and equipment needed for work are exempt without a cap and you choose what to keep (7 CMC §§ 4204(a), 4210); orders in aid of judgment protect clan and lineage obligations (§ 4205); tax collection gives 30-day hearing rights and pre-sale redemption (4 CMC §§ 1871, 1876); a lender’s missing sale notice bars any deficiency (triple-j-saipan-v-sanchez-2007); storage occupants can force a lawsuit by sworn opposition (4 CMC § 51539).
Local pages
County deep dives: county pages for this jurisdiction are being added largest-first. Buyer guides: northern-mariana-islands-vehicles, northern-mariana-islands-boats, northern-mariana-islands-aircraft, northern-mariana-islands-equipment, northern-mariana-islands-businesses
▸ For Investors / Operators — Start with §0/§4 (judicial-only mortgage foreclosure under 2 CMC § 4537 — court-ordered sale, certificate of sale, deed only after redemption), §2/2b (the 12-month § 4541 redemption — only the debtor or a successor who takes legal title may redeem; equitable tolling possible), §5b (clouded-title reality and insurable title via Stewart Title agents), §7b (senior recorded liens survive under § 4537(e); join all junior interests), and §11b (the Article XII ceiling — non-NMD buyers take ≤55-year leaseholds; full-service-bank foreclosure exception; deficiency allowed under § 4537(h)).
▸ For Former Owners — Start with §3 (foreclosure surplus — anything above costs, fees, and debt is brought to court “for the use of the defendant” under § 4537(g), disbursed by the Superior Court), §2/2b (redemption — 12 months to redeem the whole property by paying the bid plus 1%/month and documented carrying costs under § 4542, with equitable tolling available for fraud), and §5c (grounds to halt or undo a sale — vacate within one year for fraud or an unlawfully conducted sale under § 4537(j); injunction against waste under § 4544).
11. Meta
- sources:
- {type: statute, url: https://cnmilaw.org/pdf/cmc_section/T2/4537.pdf, retrieved: 2026-06-02} (2 CMC § 4537 — foreclosure actions: venue, complaint, sale, certificate of sale/deed, application of proceeds/surplus (g), deficiency (h), vacate-sale-for-fraud (j); full verbatim text extracted)
- {type: statute, url: https://cnmilaw.org/pdf/cmc_section/T2/4541.pdf, retrieved: 2026-06-02} (2 CMC § 4541 — 12-month redemption; judgment debtor or successor in interest; whole property; verbatim)
- {type: statute, url: https://cnmilaw.org/pdf/cmc_section/T2/4542.pdf, retrieved: 2026-06-02} (2 CMC § 4542 — redemption amount = purchase + 1%/mo + taxes + insurance/maintenance/repairs + FMV improvements + protective payments; clerk/court dispute procedure, 10–20-day hearing, certificate of redemption; verbatim)
- {type: statute, url: https://cnmilaw.org/pdf/cmc_section/T2/4543.pdf, retrieved: 2026-06-02} (2 CMC § 4543 — purchaser entitled to rents/profits credited on redemption; 5-day/accounting extensions; verbatim)
- {type: statute, url: https://cnmilaw.org/pdf/cmc_section/T2/4544.pdf, retrieved: 2026-06-02} (2 CMC § 4544 — injunction restraining waste; receiver; verbatim)
- {type: statute, url: https://cnmilaw.org/pdf/cmc_section/T2/4552.pdf, retrieved: 2026-06-02} (2 CMC § 4552 — discharge of stale mortgage not renewed within 15 yrs of due date / 20 yrs of recording; verbatim)
- {type: statute, url: https://cnmilaw.org/pdf/cmc_section/T7/2502.pdf, retrieved: 2026-06-02} (7 CMC § 2502 — 20-year limitation: (a)(1) actions on a judgment; (a)(2) actions for recovery of land or any interest therein; verbatim)
- {type: statute, url: https://cnmilaw.org/pdf/cmc_section/T1/30101.pdf, retrieved: 2026-06-02} (1 CMC § 30101 — Judiciary Abandoned Funds Act, PL 18-36; third-party funds held by Judiciary unclaimed > 1 year)
- {type: case, url: https://cnmilaw.org/pdf/supreme/2011-MP-19.pdf, retrieved: 2026-06-02} (Pacific Financial Corp. v. Sablan, 2011 MP 19 — full opinion text extracted: §§ 4541–4544, redemption-right non-alienable, equitable tolling, fraudulent-conveyance standing, lien theory § 4537(f))
- {type: case, url: https://www.cnmilaw.org/pdf/supreme/1997-MP-24.pdf, retrieved: 2026-06-01} (L & T Int’l Corp. v. Benavente, 1997 MP 24 — equitable mortgage; foreclosure equitable)
- {type: case, url: https://openjurist.org/958/f2d/1450/wabol-v-villacrusis, retrieved: 2026-06-01} (Wabol v. Villacrusis — art. XII void ab initio; EP does not invalidate art. XII)
- {type: case, url: https://law.resource.org/pub/us/case/reporter/F2/958/958.F2d.1450.87-1736.html, retrieved: 2026-06-01} (Wabol art. XII text + EP holding)
- {type: constitution, url: https://cnmilaw.org/cons.php, retrieved: 2026-06-01} (N.M.I. Const. art. XII)
- {type: statute_portal, url: https://cnmilaw.org/cmc.php, retrieved: 2026-06-02} (Commonwealth Code — section-PDF index)
- {type: official, url: https://www.finance.gov.mp/revenue-taxation.php, retrieved: 2026-06-01} (Dept. of Finance — no property tax listed)
- {type: official, url: https://www.nmijudiciary.gov/commonwealth-recorders-office, retrieved: 2026-06-01}
- {type: federal_statute, url: https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/26/7425, retrieved: 2026-06-02} (26 U.S.C. § 7425 — IRS 25-day pre-sale notice; 120-day redemption)
- {type: secondary, url: https://www.dottslaw.law/saipan-real-estate-considerations-investors/, retrieved: 2026-06-02} (no property tax; 55-yr lease; title insurance via Stewart/Security/Pacific American; transfer tax; clouded titles)
- {type: secondary, url: https://marianasliving.com/cnmi-information/cnmi-land-ownership/, retrieved: 2026-06-02} (art. XII; 55-yr lease; full-service-bank foreclosure exception)
- needs_verification:
- Verbatim N.M.I. Const. art. XII §§ 2, 4 text (full-service-bank foreclosure exception; NMD definition / blood-quantum; NMD-corporation control test) — confirmed via case + secondary corroboration, clean primary quote not retrieved.
- Whether/how the Judiciary Abandoned Funds Act (1 CMC § 30101 et seq.) reaches a mortgage-foreclosure surplus, and the reclaim/forfeiture mechanics (short title confirmed; operative sections not retrieved verbatim).
- Surplus-claim assignability and any fee cap/licensing/cooling-off/disclosure regime for surplus-recovery agents (none located in Title 2 Div. 4).
- Fraudulent-conveyance statute: confirm CNMI has not adopted a statutory UFTA/UVTA (doctrine appears common-law per Sablan); identify the limitations period for a common-law fraudulent-conveyance claim.
- Execution-sale notice/publication/posting periods (Title 7) incorporated by 2 CMC § 4537(e).
- Statutory reinstatement-by-arrears right (vs. the § 4537(d) 3-month pay-in window).
- CNMI Rule 65 / preliminary-injunction test, bond requirement, and ex-parte timeline (general civil-procedure rule text not retrieved).
- Quiet-title enabling statute (if any), timeline, and cost; whether an art. XII void-ab-initio claim is subject to the 7 CMC § 2502 20-year limitation.
- HOA/condominium assessment-lien priority statute (confirm none exists in the CNMI).
- Mechanic’s-lien survival of a mortgage foreclosure; CERCLA-lien survival; any environmental super-lien.
- Mid-redemption certificate-of-sale assignment form/recording (§ 4537(f) permits assignees; no case retrieved on mechanics).
- Anti-deficiency / fair-value offset / one-action rule — confirm absence against a retrieved CNMI source.
- Whether CNMI courts have specifically applied jones-v-flowers / mennonite-v-adams.
- open_questions:
- Does the Dept. of Finance’s lien/distraint power over income/BGR taxes ever reach real property (functionally a tax lien), and if so what redemption attaches?
- Post-Sablan, has the Legislature amended 2 CMC § 4541 or codified equitable tolling?
- Is the art. XII full-service-bank foreclosure exception limited to the lender itself, or does it extend to the lender’s assignee/REO purchaser?
- changelog:
- 2026-06-01 — Initial page. Established no property tax / no tax foreclosure; documented the judicial mortgage foreclosure system (2 CMC § 4511 et seq.), the 12-month post-sale redemption (§ 4541), deficiency, and the Article XII overlay. Verified three cases.
- 2026-06-02 — Wave 2: Added the 7 advanced modules (2b, 3b, 5b, 5c, 7b, 10b, 11b) and applied the neutral-reference + segmented-CTA voice (two CTA blocks: after §3 and before §11). Fetched verbatim primary text of 2 CMC §§ 4537, 4541, 4542, 4543, 4544, 4552, 7 CMC § 2502, and 1 CMC § 30101, plus the full Sablan opinion (redemption non-alienable; equitable tolling; fraudulent-conveyance standing; lien theory). Resolved prior gaps: redemption-amount formula (§ 4542), surplus statute (§ 4537(g)), deficiency statute (§ 4537(h)), vacate-sale/injunction grounds (§§ 4537(j), 4544), SOL to challenge (7 CMC § 2502 — 20 yrs), title-insurance availability (Stewart/Security/Pacific American), art. XII full-service-bank foreclosure exception, court-held-funds disposition (Judiciary Abandoned Funds Act). gap_score 9 → 14 (rows 11/13/14/15 cleared via the 7 modules + quiet-title map + SOL + HOA status; remaining points are all honest needs_verification flags — no rows 3–5 contributions).
- cross_links: right-of-redemption · surplus-funds · third-party-recovery-rules · sheriff-sale · due-process-notice · tyler-v-hennepin-county · mullane-v-central-hanover · jones-v-flowers · mennonite-v-adams · article-xii-land-alienation · no-property-tax · equitable-mortgage · bankruptcy-automatic-stay · federal-tax-lien-redemption · heirs-property · pacific-financial-corp-v-sablan · l-t-international-corp-v-benavente · wabol-v-villacrusis
Legal information, not legal advice. This page summarizes primary sources current as of the last_verified date and may omit recent changes. Verify against the cited statutes, the CNMI Constitution, and CNMI court opinions, and consult a CNMI-licensed attorney before acting. Last verified: 2026-06-02.