Puerto Rico — Tax & Mortgage Foreclosure

Legal information, not legal advice. Verify against the cited primary sources before acting. Last verified: 2026-06-02.

Territory note. Puerto Rico is a U.S. territory, not a state. Real-property tax is municipal, but it is assessed, billed, collected, and enforced centrally by the Centro de Recaudación de Ingresos Municipales (CRIM) — a single insular agency serving all 78 municipios — not by 78 separate county/ municipal collectors. There is no county layer: the recording unit is the municipio, and the land registry is the unified Registro de la Propiedad. The enforcement statute is the Código Municipal de Puerto Rico, Ley 107-2020, Libro VII (Hacienda Municipal), which in 2020 absorbed and superseded the former property-tax-sale statutes (21 L.P.R.A. ch. 245) and repealed the standalone “Ley de Venta de Deudas Contributivas” (Ley 21-1997). Because the system is administrative-collector-driven (not a 50-state-style lien-certificate auction market and not sheriff-run), several standard modules below are marked where the 50-state framing does not map cleanly. Most primary sources are in Spanish; English glosses below are the author’s translation and the Spanish statutory text controls.

0. Identity & Classification

  • Recording unit: municipio (78). Land records are centralized in the Registro de la Propiedad (regional sections), not per-municipio recorders.
  • Tax sale type: tax deed sold by the collector at public auction (venta en pública subasta); the winning bidder receives a certificado de compra that ripens into absolute title if the short redemption window lapses. There is no investor lien-certificate auction of the Florida/Arizona type in current law (the assignable-tax-debt program, Ley 21-1997, was repealed).
  • Tax foreclosure process: administrative (CRIM seizes and sells without a court judgment; the debtor’s remedy is to go to court to dissolve the embargo). Arts. 7.072–7.080, Ley 107-2020. source
  • Mortgage foreclosure process: judicial (court action + judicial sale by the Alguacil/marshal under Regla 51, Reglas de Procedimiento Civil). No non-judicial power-of-sale.
  • Selling authority: CRIM (Centro de Recaudación de Ingresos Municipales) for tax sales; Alguacil (court marshal) for mortgage foreclosure sales.
  • Statutory home: Código Municipal de Puerto Rico, Ley 107-2020, Libro VII, Cap. III (Contribución Municipal sobre la Propiedad), Arts. 7.059, 7.072–7.091 — official OGP text
  • Tyler v. Hennepin compliance: compliant — Puerto Rico’s statute already required the surplus (sobrante) to be returned to the former owner long before tyler-v-hennepin-county. On both a movable-property sale and a real-property sale, “todo el sobrante que como producto de la venta se realizase en exceso de las contribuciones, penalidades y costas, será devuelto por el CRIM al dueño de la propiedad vendida o sus herederos o cesionarios” (Art. 7.075), and the surplus from a real-property auction is notified and tendered to the taxpayer (Art. 7.080). The government does not keep equity beyond the debt.

1. Tax Sale Mechanics

  • What is sold: a tax deed route — the delinquent real property itself is embargoed and sold at public auction; the buyer gets a certificado de compra (Art. 7.084). If unsold for lack of a sufficient bid, CRIM may take title in its own name (Art. 7.085) and then transfer it gratuitously to the municipio. source
  • Bidding method: highest-bid deed. Sale is to the highest bidder (“al postor que ofrezca mayor cantidad”) at or above a confidential minimum that is no lower than the principal tax debt or the market-value appraisal (Arts. 7.078–7.079). A 10% cash deposit on the bid is required, forfeited if the balance is not paid within 10 days (Art. 7.078).
  • Interest / penalty (delinquency, statutory): tax becomes morosa if unpaid within 90 days of the due date; surcharges of 5% (paid 31–60 days late) or 10% (paid after 60 days), plus 10% annual interest from the due date (Art. 7.059). source
  • Minimum bid composition: delinquent contributions + interest + surcharges + penalties + costs of the apremio (publication, edicts, 10%-of-tax collector’s fee); real-property minimum cannot be below the principal tax debt or the market appraisal (Arts. 7.073, 7.077, 7.079).
  • Sale frequency / typical month: no fixed statewide calendar; CRIM proceeds case-by-case after the 30-day post-notice cure period lapses. needs_verification (no single published auction calendar — sales scheduled per file).
  • Venue: in person, conducted by CRIM or its representative at the place fixed in the published notice (Art. 7.078).
  • Platform vendors: none of the commercial 50-state auction platforms apply; CRIM runs collections and notices through its own portal (portal.crim360.com).
  • Registration / deposit: 10% cash deposit of the bid amount required at the auction; balance due within 10 days or deposit forfeited (Art. 7.078).
  • Subsequent taxes (“subs”): not an investor-certificate “subs” regime. The redemption price (Art. 7.086) already folds in “contribuciones vencidas hasta la fecha de la redención,” and the CRIM lien annotation is exempt from the registry’s ordinary caducidad/lapse rules (Art. 7.076).

2. Right of Redemption → see right-of-redemption

  • Pre-sale right: yes — the taxpayer cures by paying the full delinquency (tax + surcharges + interest + costs) any time before the auction; the apremio notice gives a 30-day cure window after the embargo notice before sale (Arts. 7.059, 7.073). source
  • Post-sale period: 30 days from issuance of the certificado de compra (Art. 7.086) — a short window, not the one-year period that existed under the older Title 13 / Title 21 ch. 245 regime. Runs from the date the purchase certificate is issued. source
  • Who may redeem: the owner as of the sale date; their heirs or assignees; or any person who, at the sale date, held a right or interest in the property (including a mortgagee, tenant, or lessee), or their heirs/assignees (Art. 7.086).
  • Redemption amount formula: total purchase price + improvements and expenses incurred by the buyer + accrued costs and taxes due through the redemption date + 20% of all the foregoing as the buyer’s statutory compensation (Art. 7.086). If CRIM itself took the property, the same formula applies with the 20% characterized as a penalty (Art. 7.086).
  • Premium to certificate holder: 20% flat (not an interest rate) (Art. 7.086).
  • Procedure: pay the holder, who endorses a notarized receipt on the back of the certificado de compra; or, if the holder refuses or cannot be found, consign the redemption price with CRIM/the court, which issues a certificado de redención (Arts. 7.086–7.088). A mortgagee who redeems adds the sum to its mortgage; a tenant who redeems may deduct it from rent (Art. 7.086).
  • Extinguishment of the right: the redemption right is extinguished once the taxpayer accepts/receives the surplus from a third-party purchaser (treated as a waiver) (Art. 7.080), or when the 30-day window lapses unexercised — at which point the recorded certificado de compra becomes absolute title (Arts. 7.084–7.085).
  • Special tolling: sale postponement (not classic tolling) is available for elderly or terminally/permanently-ill taxpayers whose only home is the property and who cannot pay or qualify for a plan; the embargo annotation’s registry-lapse term is suspended until death or until the condition ceases (Art. 7.072). Bankruptcy: the depositary/trustee must pay taxes per the federal Bankruptcy Code (Art. 7.063); see bankruptcy-automatic-stay.

3. Surplus / Excess Proceeds → see surplus-funds, third-party-recovery-rules

  • Belongs to: the former owner (or heirs/assignees). Statutorily mandated return of all proceeds above tax, penalties, and costs (Arts. 7.075, 7.080).
  • Claim waterfall: (1) delinquent contributions, interest, surcharges, penalties, and apremio costs to CRIM; (2) sobrante to the former owner / heirs / successors. Recorded liens other than taxes survive against the property for a third-party buyer (Art. 7.084 — title passes “sujeto a los gravámenes inscritos”), whereas a CRIM self-award takes title “libre de toda hipoteca, carga o cualquier otro gravamen” (Art. 7.085).
  • Filing venue: with CRIM — the taxpayer requests the surplus from CRIM (or, in the third-party scenario, from the certificate holder) after CRIM’s post-sale notice (Art. 7.080).
  • Claim deadline: CRIM must notify the result of the sale and the amount of any surplus within 30 days of the auction; the taxpayer may request the surplus within that 30-day window (which also functions as / interacts with the redemption window), and after it CRIM must again notify that the surplus is available and pay upon proof of entitlement. Payment of surplus from a third-party sale is conditioned on the taxpayer delivering possession of the property (Art. 7.080). source
  • Escheat: no specific escheat-of-surplus trigger in Art. 7.080; general unclaimed-property/abandoned-funds rules would apply to long-unclaimed sums. needs_verification (exact escheat path for unclaimed tax-sale surplus not pinned to a retrieved primary source).
  • Documentation required: proof of ownership/heirship or interest as of the sale date; certified-mail notice trail; for third-party-sale surplus, evidence the taxpayer ceded possession (Art. 7.080).
  • Third-party recovery (surplus-recovery agents):
    • fee_cap_pct: none specific to tax-sale surplus recovery. needs_verification (no retrieved PR statute caps a surplus-recovery agent’s fee).
    • licensing_required: needs_verification — Puerto Rico has no retrieved statute analogous to the 50-state surplus-recovery-agent licensing/fee-cap laws.
    • assignment_of_claim_allowed: the surplus and redemption rights expressly run to the owner’s “cesionarios” (assignees), so assignment of the underlying claim/redemption right is contemplated (Arts. 7.080, 7.086). Whether a fee-based recovery contract is independently regulated is unverified.
    • cooling_off_period / contract_disclosure_rules / prohibited_practices: needs_verification — no retrieved PR consumer statute specific to surplus recovery; general Civil Code contract and unfair-practices law would govern.
    • citation: Arts. 7.080, 7.086, Ley 107-2020.
  • Notice to former owner required? Yes — CRIM must notify the sale result and surplus by certified mail, return receipt (Art. 7.080), and the apremio/ embargo notice must be served personally or by certified mail (and by edicto if the debtor cannot be found) (Art. 7.073).

▸ For Investors / Operators — A Puerto Rico tax-sale overbid generates a sobrante that the Código Municipal (Arts. 7.075, 7.080) returns to the former owner/heirs/assignees after CRIM is paid. Before committing capital, weigh the short 30-day redemption risk and the 20% statutory premium a redeemer must pay (§2/2b — note the certificate and the redemption right are both assignable to cesionarios), the path to marketable title (§5b — there is no quiet-title statute; the acción reivindicatoria / declaratoria de dominio in the Tribunal de Primera Instancia, plus the certificado de compra’s prima facie effect), and which liens survive (§7b — a third-party buyer takes “sujeto a los gravámenes inscritos” under Art. 7.084, condominium assessments are a gravamen preferente under Arts. 60–61 of Ley 129-2020, and the IRS § 7425 120-day redemption may apply).

▸ For Former Owners — When a CRIM tax sale brings more than the taxes, surcharges, and costs, that sobrante belongs to you (or your heirs/assignees) under Arts. 7.075 and 7.080; CRIM must notify you of the result and any surplus by certified mail within 30 days of the auction, and the request is made to CRIM (or to the certificate holder in a third-party sale). Payment of a third-party-sale surplus is conditioned on your ceding possession of the property (Art. 7.080).

4. Mortgage Foreclosure

  • Process: judicial only. A creditor sues in the Tribunal de Primera Instancia; on judgment the court issues a writ to the Alguacil (marshal) to sell the encumbered property at public auction under Regla 51.3/51.7, Reglas de Procedimiento Civil de 2009. source
  • Pre-filing / mediation: for an owner-occupied principal residence, the Ley 184-2012 (“Ley para Mediación Compulsoria y Preservación de tu Hogar en los procesos de Ejecuciones de Hipotecas de una Vivienda Principal”) requires the court to refer the parties to a court-supervised mediation (within 30 days of service under the amended Art. 3) before the residence can be sold; the law has been amended repeatedly (Ley 268-2018, Ley 38-2019, Ley 73-2022). Ley 184-2012, LexJuris
  • Timeline (days): notice of sale by posting in 3 public places for 2 weeks and publication twice in a general-circulation newspaper (≥7 days apart); the judicial sale may occur after 14 days from first publication (Regla 51.7). No statutory NOD/confirmation hearing equivalent to deed-of-trust states. source
  • Reinstatement right: debtor may pay to stop the sale up to the judicial sale; exact statutory reinstatement window needs_verification.
  • Redemption after sale: Puerto Rico does not provide a general statutory post-sale redemption period after a judicial mortgage foreclosure sale (unlike the tax-sale 30-day right); confirmation of the judicial sale vests title in the buyer. needs_verification (no statutory post-mortgage-sale redemption located in a retrieved primary source; treat as “none” pending confirmation).
  • Deficiency judgment: permitted — if sale proceeds are insufficient, the marshal may pursue the debtor’s other assets “como en cualquier otra ejecución” (Regla 51.7); the tax-sale analog is Art. 7.079 (CRIM may pursue the shortfall against a delinquent taxpayer with other attachable assets). Fair-value-offset / one-action-rule specifics needs_verification.
  • Surplus distribution: surplus after satisfying the judgment, interest, and costs goes to junior lienholders by priority and then to the mortgagor (general Regla 51 execution principles). needs_verification for the precise distribution subsection.
  • Sale officer: Alguacil (court marshal).

5. Sale Procedure Playbooks

  • CRIM tax-collector sale — ordered steps → see treasurer-sale:
    1. Tax becomes morosa 90 days after due date; surcharges + 10% interest accrue (Art. 7.059).
    2. CRIM issues a written notification of embargo stating the full debt, and records a certificación de embargo in the Registro de la Propiedad for real property (Arts. 7.073, 7.076).
    3. Debtor has 30 days to pay; service is personal, or by certified mail (return receipt), or by edicto if the debtor cannot be found (Art. 7.073).
    4. Notice of auction published once in a general-circulation print or digital newspaper, plus posted edicts (Art. 7.077).
    5. Appraisal sets a confidential minimum bid ≥ principal tax debt or market value; auction to the highest bidder; 10% deposit required (Arts. 7.078–7.079).
    6. CRIM issues the certificado de compra within 60 days; records it free of charge (Art. 7.084). If no adequate bid, CRIM may self-award (Art. 7.085).
    7. Within 30 days of the sale, CRIM notifies the result and any sobrante by certified mail; surplus paid to the owner; 30-day redemption runs from the certificate (Arts. 7.080, 7.086).
  • Sheriff/marshal sale (mortgage) — ordered steps → see sheriff-sale: judgment → writ to Alguacil → posting (3 places, 2 weeks) + publication (twice, ≥7 days apart) → auction after 14 days → marshal’s deed → surplus to juniors then mortgagor; deficiency pursued against other assets (Regla 51.3, 51.7).
  • Notice requirements: tax sale — 1 newspaper publication + edicts + certified- mail/personal embargo notice (Arts. 7.073, 7.077); mortgage sale — posting in 3 public places for 2 weeks + 2 newspaper publications (Regla 51.7).
  • Upset bid / confirmation: no 50-state-style upset-bid period for tax sales; CRIM may postpone the sale day-to-day or for up to 60 days for just cause (Art. 7.081). Mortgage sales are confirmed by the court.
  • Payment terms: tax sale — 10% deposit at auction, balance within 10 days, or deposit forfeited (Art. 7.078).
  • Deed issued: certificado de compra (tax) recorded free of registry fees; becomes absolute title if not redeemed in 30 days, taking subject to recorded non-tax liens for a third-party buyer (Art. 7.084) but free of all liens for a CRIM self-award (Art. 7.085).

6. Due Process & Notice → see due-process-notice

  • Standard: federal constitutional minimum applies in Puerto Rico — notice “reasonably calculated, under all the circumstances,” to apprise interested parties (mullane-v-central-hanover); a mortgagee of record is entitled to actual (mailed) notice (mennonite-v-adams); returned mail can require additional reasonable steps (jones-v-flowers).
  • Statutory attempts (tax sale): personal service of the embargo notice; certified mail (return receipt) to the address of record; edicto/publication if the debtor cannot be located; certified-mail notice of the sale result and surplus (Arts. 7.073, 7.077, 7.080). The recorded certificación de embargo is itself deemed sufficient to notify the taxpayer and commence the apremio (Art. 7.076).
  • Consequence of defective notice: a sale conducted in violation of the statute is void (“todas las ventas así efectuadas serán nulas”), and a knowing/ fraudulent sale exposes the officer to criminal liability (Arts. 7.082–7.083). CRIM may itself cancel a judicially-declared void/irregular sale and issue a certificado de redención restoring the owner (Art. 7.090). An action to nullify a public-auction adjudication requires joining the successful bidder as an indispensable party (aponte-v-roman-torres).
  • Leading cases: mullane-v-central-hanover, mennonite-v-adams, jones-v-flowers, tyler-v-hennepin-county, aponte-v-roman-torres.

7. Title & Marketability

  • Deed warranty level: none — the buyer takes the property “tal y como está” with no warranty-of-eviction (saneamiento) action against CRIM (Art. 7.079).
  • Marketable immediately? No. Title is contingent during the 30-day redemption window; it becomes “absolute” only upon recording after the window lapses (Arts. 7.084–7.085), and a third-party buyer’s title remains subject to other recorded liens (Art. 7.084).
  • Quiet title required? Often advisable given the no-warranty deed and surviving non-tax liens; not statutorily mandated. Puerto Rico has no dedicated quiet-title statute; the analogous remedies are the acción reivindicatoria (Civil Code Arts. 820–823) and the acción declaratoria del dominio (Art. 824) in the Tribunal de Primera Instancia. See §5b.
  • SOL to challenge the deed: the certificado de compra is prima facie evidence of the recited facts in any later controversy (Arts. 7.084–7.085); the specific statute of limitations to attack the deed is needs_verification. General Civil Code limits on real actions over immovables are 30 years (Art. 1204(e), § 9496), distinct from any tax-deed-specific bar (not located).
  • Title insurance availability: Puerto Rico has an active title-insurance market, but coverage of CRIM tax-deed title turns on cure of the redemption window and surviving liens. needs_verification (no retrieved primary source on insurer practice).
  • Common defects: defective embargo/sale notice (void sale, Arts. 7.082, 7.090); surviving recorded mortgages/liens against a third-party buyer (Art. 7.084); unresolved heirship; redemption exercised within the 30-day window.

8. Case Law (real, verified)

CaseYearTopicHolding (plain English)Source
tyler-v-hennepin-county2023surplusA government that keeps sale proceeds beyond the tax debt commits an unconstitutional taking; the former owner is entitled to the surplus. PR already complies (Arts. 7.075, 7.080 return the sobrante to the owner).law.cornell.edu
mennonite-v-adams1983due_processA mortgagee of record is entitled to actual (mailed) notice of a tax sale; publication/posting alone is constitutionally insufficient. Binds PR tax-sale notice practice.law.cornell.edu
aponte-v-roman-torres1998sale_procedureAn action to nullify a public-auction judicial sale must join the successful bidder as an indispensable party; a third-party registry purchaser’s interest cannot be voided without their participation. (Arose from a judgment-execution auction; the indispensable-party rule applies to public-auction nullity actions generally, including tax-sale challenges.) Cited as 1998 TSPR 53 / 98 DTS 053.lexjuris.com
mullane-v-central-hanover1950due_process / redemptionNotice must be “reasonably calculated, under all the circumstances,” to apprise parties and afford an opportunity to object — the baseline for any redemption-affecting deprivation in PR.law.cornell.edu

Topic-tag coverage note. due_process (Mennonite, Mullane), surplus (Tyler), and sale_procedure (Aponte) are covered by verified cases. A squarely-on-point Puerto Rico appellate decision applying these doctrines to a CRIM property-tax sale or to the 30-day redemption right was not located in a retrieved primary source; the redemption tag therefore rests on statute (Art. 7.086) plus the Mullane baseline, and a PR-specific redemption case is listed in needs_verification.

9. Edge Cases (state-specific notes)

  • bankruptcy-automatic-stay — a bankruptcy trustee/depositary must pay property taxes per the federal Bankruptcy Code; CRIM collection is subject to the automatic stay (Art. 7.063, Ley 107-2020).
  • federal-tax-lien-redemption — IRS 28 U.S.C. §2410 / 26 U.S.C. §7425 120-day redemption applies in PR as a U.S. jurisdiction; interplay with the 30-day CRIM window is addressed in §7b (the federal 120-day clock is independent of and outlasts the 30-day CRIM redemption).
  • heirs-property — redemption/surplus rights expressly run to “herederos” (heirs); no estate may be distributed and no registry inscription made until current taxes are paid (Art. 7.063).
  • Elderly / terminally-ill homestead — CRIM may postpone the sale of the sole-home of an elderly or permanently-ill taxpayer who cannot pay, suspending the embargo’s registry-lapse term until death or recovery (Art. 7.072).
  • homestead-protections — “hogar seguro” exemption (Art. 249, Código de Enjuiciamiento Civil 1933) protects certain household movables from tax sale and is paid out when CRIM self-awards (Arts. 7.074, 7.085).
  • scra-protections — Servicemembers Civil Relief Act applies federally in PR. needs_verification (no PR-specific SCRA tax-sale case retrieved).
  • Void vs. voidable — statutory non-compliance or fraud renders the sale void (Arts. 7.082–7.083); CRIM can administratively cancel a court-declared irregular/void sale and re-vest the owner (Art. 7.090).
  • Repealed assignable-tax-debt market — note the now-DEROGADA Ley 21-1997 if reviewing pre-2020 chains of title where a Certificado de Venta (not a CRIM certificado de compra) appears.

Distinct historical/assignable-debt route (now repealed). From 1997 to ~2020, CRIM could sell transferable delinquent tax debts to private third parties under the Ley de Venta de Deudas Contributivas, Ley 21-1997: a 30-day pre-sale certified-mail notice to the owner (Art. 8 / 21 L.P.R.A. §5926), a Certificado de Venta assignable/pledgeable to subsequent holders (Art. 11), a 15% annual carrying interest to the debt-purchaser (Art. 15(c)), a 30-day post-auction redemption with a 20% buyer’s premium, and surplus to the owner (Arts. 24–26 / 21 L.P.R.A. §§5942–5944). The official OGP text now carries the banner “DEROGADA” (repealed); the Municipal Code did not re-enact a transferable-debt market, so today’s enforcement is the CRIM administrative-sale route above. Ley 21-1997 (DEROGADA), OGP

10. Operations

2b. Redemption Advanced

Assignability of the statutory redemption right:

  • Who holds the right: the owner as of the sale date, “sus herederos o cesionarios” (their heirs or assignees), or “cualquier persona que en la fecha de la venta tuviere algún derecho o interés en los mismos, o sus herederos o cesionarios” (any person holding a right or interest at the sale date, or their heirs/assignees). (Art. 7.086, Ley 107-2020, retrieved 2026-06-02)
  • Is the right assignable? The redemption right runs expressly to the owner’s cesionarios (assignees). A third party can therefore acquire standing to redeem by taking an assignment/conveyance of the owner’s interest, or by being a pre-existing interest-holder (mortgagee, tenant). A mortgagee who redeems adds the sum to its mortgage credit and recovers it at the mortgage interest rate; a tenant who redeems may deduct the redemption amount from rent (Art. 7.086).
  • Purchase mechanism: by becoming a cesionario of the owner’s interest, or by holding a qualifying lien/lease interest as of the sale date. No court approval is required to redeem; the redeemer pays the holder (or consigns with CRIM/court). needs_verification — no retrieved PR appellate decision squarely on whether a stranger-investor’s bare assignment taken solely to acquire redemption standing is attackable.
  • Restrictions: No “natural-persons-only” or “heirs-only” limit; the statute names heirs, assignees, and any interest-holder of record as of the sale date.

Equitable vs. statutory redemption:

  • Puerto Rico’s tax-sale redemption is statutory (Art. 7.086), a 30-day right running from issuance of the certificado de compra. There is no separate post- sale equitable redemption surviving the 30-day window; once it lapses unexercised, the certificate becomes absolute title (Arts. 7.084–7.085).
  • Pre-sale cure (paying the full delinquency to avoid the auction) is available any time before the sale (Arts. 7.059, 7.073) — that is payment to avoid the sale, not post-sale equitable redemption. As a civil-law jurisdiction, PR does not apply the common-law “equity of redemption” doctrine; the right is purely statutory. needs_verification of any PR case recognizing an equitable redemption distinct from the Art. 7.086 statutory right.

Installment redemption:

  • The Código Municipal provides no statutory installment plan to redeem a tax-sold property; redemption under Art. 7.086 requires payment of the full purchase value + improvements + costs + taxes through redemption + the 20% premium within the 30-day window. (CRIM may offer pre-sale planes de pago for the underlying delinquency, but that is cure, not post-sale installment redemption.) needs_verification — no PR primary source authorizing partial/ installment redemption of a tax sale.

Assignment of the purchaser’s certificate/deed mid-redemption:

  • Permitted. The certificado de compra and the rights it conveys run to “el comprador, sus herederos o cesionarios” (the purchaser, their heirs or assignees); the certificate is prima facie evidence of the recited facts “en cualquier controversia… que envuelva o concierna a los derechos del comprador, sus herederos o cesionarios” (Art. 7.084). The purchaser may therefore assign the certificate (and the right to receive the redemption payment, or to take absolute title if the window lapses) to an assignee. (Art. 7.084, Ley 107-2020, retrieved 2026-06-02)
  • Restrictions: No entity-type restriction stated; the statute contemplates the purchaser being “otra persona, natural o jurídica” (Art. 7.086). needs_verification of any CRIM regulation prescribing a recordation form for a mid-redemption certificate assignment.

3b. Surplus Advanced

Claim assignability — surplus (Arts. 7.075, 7.080):

  • Full assignment permitted? The sobrante is returned to “el dueño de la propiedad vendida o sus herederos o cesionarios” — the statute expressly contemplates the surplus running to the owner’s assignees (cesionarios), so an assignment of the surplus claim is recognized. (Arts. 7.075, 7.080, Ley 107-2020, retrieved 2026-06-02)
  • Assignment vs. fee agreement: The operative distinction (assignment of the fund vs. a contingent-fee/POA recovery contract) is not separately regulated by the Código Municipal; general Civil Code contract law (Ley 55-2020) and consumer- protection law (DACO) would govern a recovery contract. The Code regulates neither the fee level nor the form of a surplus-recovery agreement.
  • Fee cap applies to assignments? No cap found in Ley 107-2020 for surplus- recovery agents or assignees. needs_verification — no PR statute analogous to the 50-state surplus-recovery-agent fee-cap/licensing/cooling-off laws was located; general unfair-practices and contract law presumed to govern.

Statute of limitations on the surplus claim:

  • The Código Municipal (Art. 7.080) sets a 30-day post-auction window for CRIM to notify and for the taxpayer to request the surplus, after which CRIM must again notify and pay upon proof of entitlement; the statute states no outer escheat/ bar deadline for the surplus itself. The general 4-year prescription for personal actions (Civil Code Art. 1203, § 9495) would presumptively govern a suit to compel payment, absent a special period. needs_verification — no retrieved primary source fixes a tax-sale-surplus-specific SOL or escheat trigger; trigger and outer bar both unconfirmed.
  • Trigger: the auction date / CRIM’s certified-mail notice of the surplus (Art. 7.080). The general 4-year personal-action clock (Art. 1203) runs from when the action could be brought.

Competing claimant procedure:

  • Filing race? No statutory first-to-file rule in Art. 7.080. CRIM pays the surplus to the taxpayer/heirs/successors on proof of entitlement; where ownership or heirship is contested, the dispute is resolved in the Tribunal de Primera Instancia. An action to void the underlying adjudication must join the successful bidder as an indispensable party (aponte-v-roman-torres).
  • Interpleader / priority: The Código Municipal does not prescribe a formal interpleader for CRIM to initiate; competing surplus claims among heirs/assignees are litigated under the Civil Code and Rules of Civil Procedure. needs_verification — no PR primary source detailing a CRIM interpleader or a surplus-priority waterfall among competing private claimants.

Deceased-owner procedure:

  • The sobrante and redemption rights expressly run to the owner’s “herederos” (heirs) and successors (Arts. 7.075, 7.080, 7.086). Puerto Rico is a forced-heirship civil-law jurisdiction: an estate is administered and heirs are declared under the Civil Code (Ley 55-2020) succession provisions, typically by a declaratoria de herederos (judicial or notarial declaration of heirs). No estate may be distributed, and no registry inscription made, until current property taxes are paid (Art. 7.063, Ley 107-2020). needs_verification — whether CRIM accepts a direct-heir surplus claim on a notarial declaratoria de herederos without a full judicial estate proceeding when heirship is unambiguous.

Fraudulent-conveyance / fraudulent-transfer exposure:

  • Puerto Rico has not adopted the UVTA/UFTA. Its fraudulent-conveyance remedy is the civil-law acción rescisoria o pauliana (Civil Code Arts. 298–300, §§ 6231– 6233): “Son rescindibles los negocios jurídicos realizados en fraude de acreedores” (Art. 298), and “La acción rescisoria o pauliana es la que el acreedor puede interponer para rescindir los efectos de un negocio jurídico realizado en fraude de su crédito” (Art. 299). (Arts. 298–299, Código Civil 2020, retrieved 2026-06-02)
  • Effect / good-faith carve-out: A rescission judgment declares the transaction inoponible (unenforceable) against the creditor to the extent needed to satisfy the credit and reaches the transferee and sub-transferee, except one who acts in good faith and acquires for value (a título oneroso) (Art. 299). The action is subsidiary — available only when the creditor has no other means to collect (Art. 300). Fraud is presumed in transfers to relatives within the 4th degree of consanguinity / 2nd of affinity, in gratuitous transfers, and in onerous transfers made after a judgment or attachment order (Art. 298).
  • Exposure: A surplus-claim or redemption-right assignment by an insolvent owner for less than reasonably equivalent value is exposed to a pauliana rescission by the owner’s creditors within the limitations period.
  • SOL: The pauliana is a personal/rescissory action; Arts. 298–300 fix no special period, so the general 4-year prescription for personal actions (Art. 1203, § 9495) presumptively applies. needs_verification — no retrieved primary source states a pauliana-specific prescription period or its precise accrual trigger.

Surplus-claimant notice:

  • CRIM must notify the taxpayer/successors, by certified mail with return receipt, of the sale result and any surplus within 30 days, and again that the surplus is available to claim (Art. 7.080). The Código Municipal does not separately require CRIM to notify junior lienholders of the surplus. needs_verification — whether any PR authority requires affirmative lienholder notice of a tax-sale surplus.

5b. Title Advanced

Quiet title — when required vs. optional:

  • No dedicated quiet-title statute. Puerto Rico, a civil-law jurisdiction, has no Anglo-American “quiet title” action. The functional equivalents in the 2020 Civil Code are the acción reivindicatoria (Arts. 820–823, §§ 8101–8104 — the owner-out-of-possession’s recovery action against a possessor with no justifying title) and the acción declaratoria del dominio (Art. 824, § 8111 — an action to obtain a judicial declaration of ownership against one who disputes or claims it). (Arts. 820–824, Código Civil 2020, retrieved 2026-06-02)
  • Against a registered owner: where the reivindicatoria is directed at a person whose right is recorded in the Registro de la Propiedad, the registry/mortgage-law requirements must also be satisfied (Art. 822) — i.e., the Ley del Registro de la Propiedad Inmobiliaria (Ley 210-2015) and registry-faith principles govern.
  • When needed: practically advisable after a CRIM tax deed to clear surviving recorded liens (Art. 7.084) and confirm title against the former owner/heirs, but not statutorily mandated. The certificado de compra is itself prima facie evidence of the recited facts (Arts. 7.084–7.085), shifting the burden to a challenger.
  • Action type and court: judicial, in the Tribunal de Primera Instancia (the court of general civil jurisdiction) for the region where the property lies. No administrative or statutory-presumption substitute exists.
  • Typical timeline and cost: needs_verification — no retrieved primary source or reliable practice figure for PR reivindicatoria/declaratoria timelines and costs.

Judicial confirmation before the deed issues: No — the CRIM tax sale is administrative; CRIM issues the certificado de compra without court confirmation (Art. 7.084). (A mortgage judicial sale, by contrast, is confirmed by the court under Regla 51 and Ley 210-2015.)

SOL to attack the tax deed / chain-of-title cure:

  • No tax-deed-specific limitations period was located. General Civil Code prescription: real actions over immovables prescribe in 30 years (Art. 1204(e), § 9496), the mortgage action in 20 years (Art. 1204(d)), and partition/division of common property and the petición de herencia do not prescribe (Art. 1205, § 9497). (Arts. 1203–1205, Código Civil 2020, retrieved 2026-06-02) needs_verification — whether a shorter tax-deed-specific bar exists in CRIM regulation or case law.
  • Usucapión (acquisitive prescription): the 2020 Civil Code reduced ordinary good-faith usucapión of immovables to 10 years; a registry-protected third party may defeat a usucapient by filing within one year of acquisition. (General framework; exact interaction with a CRIM tax deed needs_verification.)

Marketable Title Act: Puerto Rico has no Anglo-American Marketable Record Title Act (no 30-year “root of title” cutoff statute). Title marketability is governed by the registry-faith principles of the Ley del Registro de la Propiedad Inmobiliaria (Ley 210-2015) and the Civil Code prescription periods above. needs_verification — no PR MRTA-equivalent statute located; flagged as honest gap.

Deed seasoning / title insurance: Puerto Rico has an active title-insurance market, but underwriting of a CRIM tax-deed title turns on lapse of the 30-day redemption window, cure of surviving recorded liens (Art. 7.084), and the registry chain. needs_verification — no retrieved primary source on PR title-insurer seasoning practice for CRIM tax deeds.


5c. TRO & Injunctive Relief

Recognized grounds to halt a sale:

  1. Notice / due-process defect — failure of the Art. 7.073/7.077 embargo and auction-notice chain to be “reasonably calculated” to reach the owner (Mullane, Mennonite, Jones v. Flowers); a statutorily non-compliant sale is void (Arts. 7.082, 7.090).
  2. Payment / redemption dispute — a timely cure or redemption tender refused or misapplied.
  3. Constitutional — taking without just compensation / Fifth Amendment (Tyler type), though PR routes the sobrante to the owner.
  4. Homestead / elderly-ill postponement — the Art. 7.072 sale-postponement right.
  5. SCRA — active-duty servicemember protections (federal).
  6. Bankruptcy automatic stay — sale in violation of 11 U.S.C. § 362 (see bankruptcy-automatic-stay).

Legal standard:

  • Puerto Rico’s injunction practice is governed by Regla 57 of the Reglas de Procedimiento Civil de 2009. Rule 57.3 lists the factors a court weighs in granting a TRO (orden de entredicho provisional) or preliminary injunction: “(a) the nature of the harm that the applicant might suffer; (b) the irreparable nature of the injury or the absence of an adequate legal remedy; (c) the likelihood of the applicant’s success; (d) the likelihood that the action will become moot; (e) the impact of the remedy sought on the public interest; and (f) the due diligence and good faith exercised by the applicant.” (Regla 57.3, Reglas de Procedimiento Civil, retrieved 2026-06-02)
  • A TRO without notice (Rule 57.1) issues only if it “clearly appears from the facts shown by affidavit or by the verified complaint that immediate and irreparable injury, loss, or damage will result to the applicant before the adverse party… can be notified and heard,” and counsel certifies its notice efforts. (Rule 57.1)

Court with jurisdiction: The Tribunal de Primera Instancia for the region. For a CRIM tax sale (administrative), injunctive relief is a separate civil filing in the TPI — there is no pending case in which to move (the debtor’s separate remedy is an action to dissolve the embargo). For a mortgage foreclosure (already pending in the TPI), relief is sought in that action.

Bond requirement: Required. Rule 57.4: “No restraining order or preliminary injunction shall issue except upon the giving of security by the applicant, in such sum as the court deems just, for the payment of such costs and damages as may be incurred or suffered by any party who is found to have been wrongfully enjoined or restrained.” The Commonwealth, its municipalities, agencies, instrumentalities, and officers acting officially are exempt from the security requirement. (Regla 57.4, retrieved 2026-06-02) The dollar amount is set by the court.

Emergency timeline / duration: A TRO granted without notice “shall expire by its terms within such time after entry, not to exceed ten (10) days, as the court fixes,” extendable for a like period for good cause or by consent; the motion for a preliminary injunction is set for hearing “at the earliest possible time” and takes precedence (Rule 57.1). An ex parte TRO meeting the affidavit/verified-complaint showing can be obtained on an emergency basis at the court’s discretion.

Effect on a completed sale: A statutorily non-compliant or fraudulent CRIM sale is void (Arts. 7.082–7.083), and CRIM may itself cancel a court-declared void/irregular sale and re-vest the owner via a certificado de redención (Art. 7.090). An action to nullify a completed public-auction adjudication must join the successful bidder as an indispensable party (aponte-v-roman-torres); a registry-protected good-faith purchaser for value is harder to dislodge. needs_verification — no retrieved PR decision squarely on whether a post-adjudication injunction voids or preserves a completed CRIM tax sale.

Non-judicial notes: The CRIM tax sale is administrative, so there is no pending case in which to move; a separate emergency civil action in the TPI is required. Mortgage foreclosure is judicial, so relief is sought in the existing action.

Leading cases: aponte-v-roman-torres (indispensable-party rule for nullity of a public-auction sale), jones-v-flowers (due-process standard).


7b. Lien Survival & Purchaser Exposure

IRS 120-day redemption (26 U.S.C. § 7425):

  • Applies. Puerto Rico is a U.S. jurisdiction; where a federal tax lien is recorded junior to the lien being foreclosed, the United States must be given notice of the sale (≥ 25 days before, by the party conducting the sale) under § 7425(c). If properly noticed, the federal lien is discharged but the IRS holds a 120-day post-sale right of redemption (§ 7425(d)); if not noticed, the federal lien survives the sale. (26 U.S.C. § 7425, retrieved 2026-06-02)
  • Interaction with the 30-day CRIM window: the federal 120-day clock is independent of and outlasts the 30-day CRIM statutory redemption — a CRIM tax-deed buyer can hold “absolute” title under Art. 7.084 yet still face an IRS redemption for up to 120 days from the sale where a federal lien existed. A federal-tax-lien search before bidding is essential. See federal-tax-lien-redemption.

HOA / condominium super-priority:

  • Condominiums (Ley de Condominios, Ley 129-2020): an owner’s obligation for its proportional share of common expenses “constituirá un gravamen sobre dicho apartamento” (constitutes a lien on the apartment) (Art. 60, 31 L.P.R.A. § 1923e). Art. 61 (§ 1923f) ranks that credit: it “tendrá preferencia sobre cualquier otro crédito de cualquier naturaleza excepto (a) [credits of the Government of Puerto Rico and the municipality for the last five (5) annual installments and the current unpaid property taxes]; (b) [a 2-year insurance premium]; and (c) recorded mortgage credits.” (Arts. 60–61, Ley 129-2020, retrieved 2026-06-02) So the condo assessment lien is junior to property-tax credits and to recorded mortgages, but superior to all other credits — there is a statutory priority, but it is not a super-priority over a recorded first mortgage or over the tax lien.
  • Involuntary acquirer cap (the operative super-priority figure): an adquirente involuntario — defined as the mortgagee who acquires the apartment through a foreclosure or dación en pago (Art. 2(b)) — “será responsable solamente de las deudas por gastos comunes surgidas y no satisfechas durante los seis (6) meses anteriores al momento de adquirir la propiedad” plus the running balance accruing after acquisition, but excludes late-payment penalties, derramas (special assessments), interest, and sanctions attributable to the prior owner (Art. 60). (Art. 60, Ley 129-2020, retrieved 2026-06-02) This 6-month look-back is Puerto Rico’s functional HOA “super-priority” exposure for a foreclosure purchaser.
  • Survives a tax sale? Because the condo assessment lien is expressly excepted below the Government/municipal property-tax credit (Art. 61(a)), a CRIM tax sale enforcing that tax credit takes ahead of the assessment lien. But a third-party CRIM tax-deed buyer takes “sujeto a los gravámenes inscritos” (Art. 7.084), so a recorded assessment lien may survive against that buyer to the extent not paid from the proceeds; a CRIM self-award takes free of all liens (Art. 7.085). needs_verification — no retrieved PR decision squarely holding a condominium assessment lien is or is not extinguished as against a third-party CRIM tax-deed buyer.
  • Planned-community / non-condo HOAs: the Ley de Control de Acceso and HOA governing documents govern; whether a non-condo HOA has any statutory assessment-lien priority is needs_verification (Ley 129-2020’s priority applies to Régimen de Propiedad Horizontal condominiums).

Environmental / CERCLA liens: A federal CERCLA lien (42 U.S.C. § 9607(l)) is a federal claim treated like a federal tax lien for notice/discharge purposes; CERCLA owner/operator liability runs with the land regardless of how title was acquired, so a CRIM tax-deed buyer of a contaminated site can face cleanup liability independent of the recorded lien. needs_verification — no PR-specific authority retrieved on CERCLA-lien survival of a CRIM tax deed; reflects the general federal rule. No PR environmental super-lien located.

Municipal / code-enforcement liens: A third-party CRIM tax-deed buyer takes “sujeto a los gravámenes inscritos” (Art. 7.084), so recorded municipal liens of record survive against that buyer; a CRIM self-award takes free of all liens (Art. 7.085). needs_verification — whether unrecorded municipal code-enforcement charges attach to or survive against a CRIM tax-deed buyer.

Mechanic’s / materialman’s liens: Priority of a recorded construction/refaction lien against a CRIM tax deed turns on recording dates and the superiority of the property-tax credit; a third-party buyer takes subject to recorded liens (Art. 7.084). needs_verification — no retrieved PR authority squarely on mechanic’s-lien survival of a CRIM tax deed.

Junior-mortgage exposure: A CRIM tax sale enforces the municipal property-tax credit, which Art. 61(a) ranks ahead of recorded mortgages for the last 5 annual installments + current taxes. Common mistake: assuming a third-party CRIM deed wipes everything — it does not. Under Art. 7.084 a third-party buyer takes “sujeto a los gravámenes inscritos” (subject to recorded liens, including recorded mortgages and the condo assessment lien), and an un-noticed federal tax lien survives (§ 7425). Only a CRIM self-award takes free of all liens (Art. 7.085).

Due-diligence checklist (PR CRIM tax-deed buyer):

  1. Registro de la Propiedad title/lien search — recorded mortgages and gravámenes inscritos survive against a third-party buyer (Art. 7.084).
  2. Federal tax lien search — § 7425 notice / 120-day IRS redemption exposure.
  3. Condominium status — unpaid assessments are a gravamen (Art. 60); an involuntary acquirer faces the 6-month look-back (Art. 60); condo lien ranks below tax and recorded mortgages (Art. 61).
  4. CRIM clearance — Certificación de Todos los Conceptos / account status.
  5. Notice-chain review — Art. 7.073/7.077 embargo and auction notice (void-sale risk, Arts. 7.082, 7.090).
  6. Heirship / declaratoria de herederos — unresolved estates are a frequent defect (Art. 7.063 blocks distribution/inscription until taxes paid).
  7. Bankruptcy search on the prior owner — active automatic stay at the time of sale?
  8. Environmental check — CERCLA / contaminated-site liability runs with the land.
  9. SCRA servicemember check on the prior owner.
  10. Redemption status — confirm the 30-day window (Art. 7.086) has lapsed unexercised.

10b. Purchaser Obligations During the Redemption Period

Puerto Rico’s tax-sale redemption is a short 30-day post-sale window (Art. 7.086). During it the buyer holds the certificado de compra; absolute title vests only on recording after the window lapses (Arts. 7.084–7.085).

Subsequent taxes:

  • The redemption price under Art. 7.086 already folds in “contribuciones vencidas hasta la fecha de la redención” (taxes due through the redemption date), so taxes accruing during the window are recovered by the buyer as part of the redemption amount; there is no separate certificate-holder “subs” accrual regime. (Art. 7.086, Ley 107-2020, retrieved 2026-06-02) needs_verification — whether the buyer must affirmatively advance subsequent taxes during the 30 days, or simply recovers them on redemption.

Owner-expiration notice:

  • The expiration-notice duty falls on CRIM, not the purchaser. CRIM must notify the taxpayer of the sale result, surplus, and (functionally) the redemption window by certified mail with return receipt within 30 days of the auction (Art. 7.080). The Código Municipal places no affirmative obligation on the tax-deed purchaser to notify the former owner that the 30-day redemption is about to expire. (Art. 7.080)

Owner occupancy:

  • The statute conditions payment of a third-party-sale surplus on the taxpayer ceding possession to the buyer (Art. 7.080), implying the owner may remain in possession during the redemption window until that cession. The certificado de compra becomes absolute title only after the window lapses (Arts. 7.084–7.085); a tenant who redeems may deduct the redemption sum from rent (Art. 7.086). needs_verification — no PR primary source squarely on the purchaser’s right to enter before absolute title vests.

Costs collectible on redemption:

  • Full purchase value + improvements and expenses incurred by the buyer + accrued costs and taxes through the redemption date + 20% of all the foregoing as the buyer’s statutory compensation (Art. 7.086). Unlike most U.S. tax-lien states, PR expressly makes documented improvements and expenses recoverable on redemption. (Art. 7.086, Ley 107-2020, retrieved 2026-06-02)

Maintenance obligation:

  • The Código Municipal imposes no express maintenance duty on the tax-deed purchaser during the 30-day redemption window. After absolute title vests, the new owner has the ordinary obligations of a property owner (and, for a condominium apartment, the common- expense obligation under Arts. 59–60, Ley 129-2020). needs_verification — no PR statute imposing a purchaser maintenance duty during redemption.

11b. Restrictions & Special Rules

Entity / foreign-ownership restrictions:

  • The Código Municipal contemplates the tax-sale buyer being “otra persona, natural o jurídica” (a natural or juridical person) (Art. 7.086), so corporations, LLCs, and trusts may buy; there is no natural-persons-only restriction. (Art. 7.086, Ley 107-2020, retrieved 2026-06-02)
  • Foreign ownership: Puerto Rico generally imposes no foreign-ownership bar on real property (foreign buyers have the same rights as U.S. citizens), with the notable exception of the constitutional 500-acre limit on the holding of agricultural land by a corporation/juridical entity (P.R. Const. Art. VI, § 14, and implementing law). needs_verification — exact statutory citation and whether the 500-acre agricultural limit reaches a tax-deed acquisition.

Insider prohibition:

  • Express and severe. “Todo funcionario, empleado o representante del CRIM que compre directa o indirectamente alguna parte de cualesquiera bienes muebles o inmuebles vendidos para el pago de contribuciones no satisfechas… todas las dichas ventas serán nulas” — any CRIM official, employee, or representative who buys (directly or indirectly) at a tax sale is liable (with official bond) for all the owner’s damages, the sale is void, and the buyer commits a felony ($5,000 fine or 5 years, or both) (Art. 7.083). A related provision criminalizes an official who fraudulently sells exempt or already-paid property or chills bidding (Art. 7.082). (Arts. 7.082–7.083, Ley 107-2020, retrieved 2026-06-02)

Right of first refusal / government priority:

  • Before paying a third-party-sale surplus to the taxpayer, CRIM may allow any Puerto Rico government instrumentality or agency to acquire the auctioned property (if the agency’s business is compatible), by paying the surplus to the taxpayer and the debt to CRIM (Art. 7.080) — a government priority-acquisition mechanism. On a CRIM self-award, CRIM transfers title gratuitously to the municipio where the property sits, which is obligated to receive it (Art. 7.085). (Arts. 7.080, 7.085, Ley 107-2020, retrieved 2026-06-02)

Land bank program:

  • Yes — a statutory land bank exists. The Código Municipal (Art. 4.005, “Community Land Bank (CLB)”) authorizes any municipality, by ordinance, to create a non-profit corporate Community Land Bank under the General Corporations Act (Ley 164-2009) “con el fin de adquirir propiedades abandonadas, vacantes o en ruinas para rehabilitarlas y así retornarlas a un uso productivo” — to return abandoned/vacant/ruined properties to productive, tax-paying use and increase affordable housing. (Art. 4.005, Ley 107-2020, retrieved 2026-06-02) As of 2026, several municipalities (e.g., Toa Baja, Vega Baja, Yauco, Hormigueros, Isabela) had approved CLBs. The CRIM-to-municipio gratuitous transfer of self-awarded tax properties (Art. 7.085) feeds municipal land-disposition programs including the CLB.

Deficiency judgment:

  • After a CRIM tax sale: where a third-party auction price is insufficient to cover the full debt, “el CRIM podrá cobrar de dicho contribuyente moroso el importe de la contribución con sus recargos e intereses que quedare en descubierto” — CRIM may pursue the shortfall against the delinquent taxpayer’s other attachable assets (Art. 7.079). (Art. 7.079, Ley 107-2020, retrieved 2026-06-02)
  • After mortgage foreclosure: permitted; the marshal may pursue the debtor’s other assets “como en cualquier otra ejecución” (Regla 51.7). Fair-value-offset / minimum-bid protections under Ley 210-2015 and any anti-deficiency limit needs_verification.

Anti-deficiency statute: No general anti-deficiency statute was located in a retrieved primary source for Puerto Rico mortgage foreclosures; the judicial-sale minimum-bid (tipo mínimo) mechanics under Ley 210-2015 function as a partial protection. needs_verification.

One-action rule: No California-style one-action rule was located in a retrieved PR primary source; for condominium assessments, Art. 11 of Ley 129-2020 allows a single foreclosure proceeding after credit distribution under Art. 10, but that is a procedural consolidation, not a one-action bar. needs_verification — confirm absence of a one-action rule for ordinary mortgage foreclosure.


Who this page is for

▸ For Investors / Operators — Start with §1 (CRIM administrative tax-deed auction, confidential minimum ≥ tax debt or appraisal, 10% deposit), §2/2b (the short 30-day redemption, the 20% redeemer’s premium, and that both the certificado de compra and the redemption right are assignable to cesionarios), §5b (path to title — there is no quiet-title statute; use the acción reivindicatoria / declaratoria de dominio in the Tribunal de Primera Instancia, plus the certificado’s prima facie effect), §7b (liens that survive — a third-party buyer takes “sujeto a los gravámenes inscritos,” the condo assessment gravamen preferente with its 6-month involuntary-acquirer look-back, and the IRS § 7425 120-day redemption), and §11b (broad entity eligibility, the Art. 7.083 insider-purchase felony/void-sale bar, and the Community Land Bank under Art. 4.005).

▸ For Former Owners — Start with §3 (the sobrante — any auction price above the taxes, surcharges, and costs belongs to you or your heirs/assignees under Arts. 7.075 and 7.080; CRIM must notify you by certified mail within 30 days, and a third-party-sale surplus is paid once you cede possession), §2 (redemption — paying the purchase value plus the 20% premium within 30 days of the certificate to recover the property), and §5c (grounds and the Regla 57 procedure for an emergency injunction to halt a sale).

11. Meta

  • sources:
  • needs_verification:
    • PR-specific appellate case applying due-process / redemption / Tyler to a CRIM property-tax sale (redemption topic tag currently statute-backed only).
    • Aponte v. Roman Torres official D.P.R. parallel page cite (commonly given as 145 D.P.R. 477) — the retrieved LexJuris page confirms caption and 1998 date but does not display the D.P.R. page number.
    • Exact escheat path / outer SOL for unclaimed tax-sale surplus (Art. 7.080 fixes no bar; general 4-yr personal-action prescription presumed).
    • Ley 184-2012 mandatory-mediation exact section text (title/Arts. 2–3 via LexJuris + search corroboration; primary slip not parsed).
    • Whether PR provides any statutory post-sale redemption after a mortgage foreclosure (treated as none; not confirmed against a retrieved primary source).
    • Reinstatement window; mortgage deficiency fair-value-offset / minimum-bid protection; anti-deficiency and one-action-rule absence; precise surplus-distribution subsection.
    • SOL to challenge a CRIM tax deed (no tax-deed-specific bar located; general 30-yr real- action / registry-faith principles apply); quiet-title-equivalent timeline/cost; title- insurer treatment of CRIM tax-deed title; PR has no MRTA-equivalent.
    • Pauliana-specific prescription period and accrual trigger (Arts. 298–300 fix none; general 4-yr personal-action rule, Art. 1203, presumed).
    • Whether a condominium assessment lien / municipal code lien / mechanic’s lien is or is not extinguished as against a third-party CRIM tax-deed buyer (Art. 7.084 “sujeto a los gravámenes inscritos” supports survival; no on-point case retrieved).
    • Non-condo (planned-community) HOA assessment-lien priority, if any.
    • CERCLA-lien survival of a CRIM tax deed; any PR environmental super-lien (none located).
    • Whether the tax-deed buyer must advance subsequent taxes during the 30-day window or only recovers them on redemption; purchaser’s pre-absolute-title entry right.
    • 500-acre agricultural-ownership limit exact citation and whether it reaches a tax-deed acquisition; any CRIM regulation prescribing a mid-redemption certificate-assignment form.
    • Third-party surplus-recovery-agent regulation (fee cap, licensing, cooling-off, disclosure) — none located; general contract/consumer (DACO) law presumed to govern.
    • Whether CRIM accepts a direct-heir surplus claim on a notarial declaratoria de herederos without full judicial estate administration.
  • open_questions:
    • Does Reglamento 9536 (2024) set a published auction calendar or alter the 30-day redemption mechanics? (Full regulation PDF not parsed.)
    • Is the 30-day redemption measured from issuance vs. recording of the certificado de compra in CRIM practice?
    • Does a CRIM third-party tax deed in practice survive a recorded first mortgage, given Art. 7.084’s “sujeto a los gravámenes inscritos” versus Art. 61’s tax-credit priority?
  • cross_links: right-of-redemption, surplus-funds, third-party-recovery-rules, due-process-notice, treasurer-sale, sheriff-sale, tyler-v-hennepin-county, mennonite-v-adams, mullane-v-central-hanover, jones-v-flowers, aponte-v-roman-torres, bankruptcy-automatic-stay, federal-tax-lien-redemption, heirs-property, homestead-protections, scra-protections
  • changelog:
    • 2026-06-01: Initial page. Built from official OGP/municipio copy of Ley 107-2020 (Libro VII, Arts. 7.059, 7.072–7.091) and repealed Ley 21-1997, plus Regla 51 (mortgage) and verified federal landmarks (Tyler, Mennonite, Mullane) and PR Supreme Court Aponte v. Roman Torres. Documented the CRIM-centralized, administrative, tax-deed, 30-day-redemption, surplus-to-owner system and the repeal of the assignable-tax-debt market.
    • 2026-06-02: Wave 2 — added the 7 advanced modules (2b, 3b, 5b, 5c, 7b, 10b, 11b) and applied the neutral-reference + segmented-CTA voice (two CTA pairs: after §3 and before §11). New primary sources fetched and parsed: Código Civil 2020 (Ley 55-2020) Arts. 298–300 (acción pauliana), 820–824 (reivindicatoria/declaratoria del dominio), 1203–1205 (prescription); Ley de Condominios (Ley 129-2020) Arts. 59–61 (assessment gravamen + 6-month involuntary-acquirer look-back + lien preference); Reglas de Procedimiento Civil Regla 57.1/57.3/57.4 (official English — TRO/injunction standard, 10-day TRO, mandatory bond with government exemption); Código Municipal Art. 4.005 (Community Land Bank), Art. 7.079 (tax-sale deficiency against delinquent taxpayer), Arts. 7.082–7.083 (insider-purchase void-sale felony); 26 U.S.C. § 7425 (IRS 120-day); Ley 184-2012 (mortgage mediation). Cleared rubric rows 11/13/14(partial)/15 via the 7 modules, the quiet-title-equivalent map, and the condo assessment-lien priority. gap_score 18 → 23 — increase is entirely additional honest needs_verification flags (row 2, 1 pt each) surfaced by the new modules; no rows 3–5 contributions (every legal claim carries a retrieved primary-source cite).

12. Forced Sales of Vehicles, Boats, Aircraft, Equipment & Businesses

Module rebuilt 2026-10-18 (bounded final review of the 2026-10-17 draft). Real-estate sales are covered in the modules above, which this review did not reverify.

Hub: assets · Asset pages: motor-vehicles, vessels, aircraft, equipment-and-machinery, businesses-and-going-concerns, court-ordered-administrative-and-creditor-sales · Mechanics: towing-storage-and-mechanics-lien-sales, marina-and-storage-lien-sales-of-vessels, ucc-article-9-dispositions, receivership-sales, equity-interests-stock-llc-charging-orders, forfeiture-and-government-seizure-sales · Playbooks: buying-a-vehicle-at-a-forced-sale, buying-a-vessel-at-a-forced-sale, buying-a-business-at-a-forced-sale. The fifty-state table personal-property-execution-sales-by-state does not include Puerto Rico.

Puerto Rico is a civil-law jurisdiction. Movables (bienes muebles) are sold by force through: the court’s venta judicial by the alguacil under the Reglas de Procedimiento Civil; the administrative procedimiento de apremio of Hacienda and of the CRIM or a municipio; agency disposals of removed vehicles (Policía, municipios, DTOP), abandoned vessels (DRNA) and confiscated property (Junta de Confiscaciones); and a small set of statutory lien sales that need no court (self-storage, Article 7 warehouse and carrier liens, Article 9 dispositions). A creditor that merely holds a thing under a derecho de retención cannot sell it. Spanish texts control; English glosses are the reviewer’s. Federal law (FAA, Coast Guard documentation, admiralty, federal tax liens, bankruptcy) is on the asset pages.

Sources and their status (all retrieved 2026-10-18). Statutes are read from the Oficina de Gerencia y Presupuesto (OGP) Biblioteca Virtual. Each OGP compilation states that it “no es una compilación oficial”; the official compilation is L.P.R.A. (not used). Each rule below therefore names the OGP revision relied on: Reglas de Procedimiento Civil (OGP Rev. 25 Aug 2026, which includes Leyes 132-2025 through 178-2026; the Judiciary’s own copy is current only to March 2023 and its Rule 51 text matches); Código de Enjuiciamiento Civil (Rev. 2 Jun 2026); Código Civil 2020 (Rev. 21 Aug 2026); Código de Rentas Internas 2011 (Rev. 28 May 2026); Código Municipal (Rev. 15 Oct 2026); Ley 22-2000 (Rev. 7 Sep 2026); Ley 430-2000 (Rev. 28 Aug 2026); Ley 208-1995 (Rev. 23 Jun 2025); Ley 164-2009 (Rev. 31 Jul 2025); Ley 173-2011 (Rev. 9 Oct 2024); Ley 119-2011 (Rev. 17 Jul 2025). Opinions are the Tribunal Supremo’s official slip opinions. CESCO and Judiciary web pages are agency guidance, labelled as such. The first pass’s description of the OGP texts as “official compilations” is withdrawn.

12.0 Identity: where Puerto Rico’s forced-sale law lives

FieldPuerto Rico ruleCitation
Ejecución / venta judicialR.P.C. 51.1–51.10R.P.C.
Remedios provisionales (embargo, síndico)R.P.C. 56.1–56.8R.P.C.
Exenciones de ejecuciónCEC art. 249 (32 L.P.R.A. §1130)CEC 1933
Retención, prendaCódigo Civil 2020 arts. 1223–1229, 1000–1010Código Civil 2020
Gravámenes mobiliarios, almacén, porteadorLey 208-1995 caps. 7 and 9Ley 208-1995
Almacenamiento por autoservicioLey 173-2011Ley 173-2011
Títulos de vehículosLey 22-2000 cap. II (DTOP)Ley 22-2000
EmbarcacionesLey 430-2000 art. 9 (DRNA)Ley 430-2000
Apremio estatalLey 1-2011 §§6060.01–6060.20Ley 1-2011
Apremio municipal (CRIM)Ley 107-2020 arts. 7.072–7.075, 7.167Ley 107-2020
ConfiscacionesLey 119-2011Ley 119-2011
Órdenes de cargo (CRL) y embargo de accionesLey 164-2009 arts. 19.44, 12.03Ley 164-2009
  • Levying officers: the alguacil or the person the court designates (R.P.C. 51.2, 51.5); Hacienda’s Secretario and agentes (Ley 1-2011 §6060.02); the CRIM or, under art. 1.008(h), the municipio (Ley 107-2020 arts. 7.072–7.073); Policía, Policía Municipal and DTOP for removed vehicles (Ley 22-2000 arts. 6.28, 23.09); DRNA for abandoned vessels (Ley 430-2000 art. 13); the Junta de Confiscaciones (Ley 119-2011 art. 20).
  • Statewide notice site: none created by statute. Execution sales use edictos in an island-wide diario de circulación general (R.P.C. 51.7(a)); agencies publish in newspapers of general circulation (Ley 141-1949 art. 2). The Judiciary’s “Subastas” page is a procurement page, not a court-sale portal (Poder Judicial, Subastas).
  • Civil-law vocabulary: venta judicial (court sale); mandamiento de ejecución (writ); embargo (levy/attachment); aviso de venta, edicto (notice; published notice); subasta (auction); tipo mínimo (minimum bid); acta de subasta (auction record); sobrante (surplus); tercería (third-party ownership claim); apremio (administrative collection with seizure); retención (retention); prenda (pledge); gravamen mobiliario (security interest); síndico, administrador judicial (receiver); orden de cargo (charging order); cesionario (assignee); confiscación (forfeiture); redistribuidor (dealer-only vehicle auctioneer); IVU (sales and use tax); arbitrio (excise).

12.1 Court sales of personal property (venta judicial)

Writ and levy. A money judgment is executed by mandamiento de ejecución, signed by the Secretaría under seal, stating the judgment and the unpaid amount and directed to the alguacil; it may issue within five years after the judgment becomes final, later only by leave on motion and notice. The alguacil returns the executed writ and any sobrante to the Secretaría within 15 days. When the debtor’s goods exceed the debt, only the part the debtor indicates is seized if amply sufficient. Every order for a judicial sale of movables has the force of a writ of possession: the officer puts the buyer in possession within 20 days, without prejudice to non-intervening third parties. Before judgment, movables are attached by deposit with the court or its designee, and the court may order fungibles sold at public auction (R.P.C. 51.1–51.5, 56.4).

Exemptions that bind a buyer. CEC 1933 art. 249 lists the exempt movables (and Hacienda and CRIM sales incorporate it: Ley 1-2011 §6060.03(i); Ley 107-2020 art. 7.074):

  • Motor vehicle: a vehicle that is its owner’s work instrument is exempt without a dollar cap, except for debts for its price, improvements, repairs, fuel, parts or accessories; for tort damages caused by the vehicle it is exempt up to USD 6,000 (art. 249(4a)).
  • Tools of trade: a mechanic’s or artisan’s tools up to USD 300; a farmer’s implements up to USD 200; listed professional instruments and libraries (art. 249(3)–(4)).
  • Wildcard: none; art. 249 enumerates items only. Hacienda adds hand tools of mechanics and artisans, livestock and household furniture (Ley 1-2011 §6060.03(i)).

Notice (aviso de venta). Posted for two weeks in three public places of the municipio of sale (such as the alcaldía, the court and the colecturía); two edictos in an island-wide general-circulation daily over two consecutive weeks at least seven days apart; certified mail with return receipt to the debtor and counsel within five days of the first edicto (last known address if the debtor did not appear). The notice describes the goods and the judgment and states place, day and hour. The court may shorten the period for perishables and holds a hearing on request if non-compliance is alleged. A judicial sale made without this notice is null (“Será nula toda venta judicial…”), and the officer who sells without notice owes a USD 500 fine to the aggrieved party (R.P.C. 51.7(a); CEC 1933 art. 252).

Sale conduct. No earlier than 14 days after the first edicto; subasta al mejor postor between 9 a.m. and 5 p.m.; once enough is sold, no more may be sold; movables capable of manual delivery must be in view of bidders and sold in lots likely to bring the best prices; the debtor may set the order of sale; the officer, delegates and any court official or employee may not bid. There is no appraisal or minimum bid for execution sales of movables and no rule authorizing an online sale (R.P.C. 51.7(b)).

Payment. The highest bidder pays the price at adjudication in cash or certified check to the officer; only in extraordinary cases may the court order another form of payment, stated in the notice. If a buyer refuses to pay, the officer may resell at any time, the loss is recoverable from that buyer, and the officer may reject its later bids (R.P.C. 51.7(c)–(d)).

Confirmation and buyer’s document. No confirmation step for chattels. The officer drafts an acta de subasta, delivers the goods and, on request, a certified copy, which “constituirá evidencia oficial del título” of the buyer “subrogándole en los derechos del vendedor” (R.P.C. 51.7(d)). (Stock sold on execution differs: the sale must be “efectuada y confirmada”, Ley 164-2009 art. 12.03(C).)

What the buyer takes / what survives. The debtor’s rights only. Nothing in Rule 51 discharges prior interests: a vehicle transfer “no cancelará ni modificará los gravámenes”, DTOP refuses to register a transfer while a vehicle carries any gravamen, and accident-claim annotations block transfer for a year (Ley 22-2000 arts. 2.42(c), 2.43(d), 4.10); a retenedor in possession must be paid the auction price up to its credit before the buyer can take possession (Código Civil 2020 art. 1228); non-intervening third parties keep their rights (R.P.C. 51.3(a)). Article 9 secured parties keep their priority; the first pass’s open question on senior perfected interests is answered by this conditional rule, not by any discharge.

Redemption. None for movables sold on execution (the one-year redemption in Ley 1-2011 §6060.14 applies to immovables sold for taxes).

Setting aside / failed title. Lack of the required notice makes the sale null; if, after paying, the buyer cannot obtain title or possession because of an irregularity causing nullity or because the thing was not subject to execution, the court, after notice and hearing, must either issue a writ against each creditor for what it received plus legal interest, or revive the judgment in the buyer’s favour up to the price paid, with priority over the original creditor on a partial execution (R.P.C. 51.7(a), 51.8). Deadline: none stated in Rule 51 — needs_verification.

Third-party claims (tercerías). The tercería procedure was not located in any retrieved text (Rules 51 and 56, CEC 1933 and the Ley de Procedimientos Legales Especiales were searched); Rule 51.3(a) preserves non-intervening third parties’ rights and Rule 51.4 lets the court protect them — needs_verification for the claim procedure and its citation.

12.2 Administrative forced sales (procedimiento de apremio and agency disposals)

Hacienda — state taxes (Ley 1-2011 §§6060.01–6060.12).

  • Lien: unpaid taxes with fines, interest, surcharges, penalties and costs are a lien on every movable and immovable of the debtor; a notice and demand to a holder of the debtor’s property or credits creates a lien on what is held (continuing on wages up to 25%) (§6060.01).
  • Notice: written notificación de embargo delivered to the debtor or a family member in charge, or by certified mail; unless paid within 30 days the property is sold at public auction “sin más aviso”; the Secretary may seize the goods or close the business (§6060.02). The debtor may challenge an embargo of movables in the TPI within the term in the notice.
  • Sale: appraisal; public auction 30–60 days after the embargo; minimum 100% of appraisal, then 75%, then 50%; with no bid the Government may adjudicate to itself (§6060.03); Anuncio de Subasta at least three times over a week in two general-circulation dailies plus edictos (§6060.08(b)); 10% deposit, balance within 10 days or the deposit is forfeited (§6060.09(a)); agents and collection employees may not buy (§6060.12).
  • Buyer’s title: on payment, delivery and the cuenta de venta “darán título y derecho al comprador” (§6060.04). Whether prior perfected security interests or other liens survive is not addressed for movables — needs_verification (for immovables, §6060.13(b) makes the buyer take subject to liens preferred to the embargo).
  • Surplus and defects: surplus to the taxpayer; sales of property known to be exempt, fraudulent sales and bid-chilling are null (§6060.11), as are purchases by agents (§6060.12).
  • Related: Hacienda may also confiscate and auction the plant, machinery and products of an unlicensed alcoholic-beverage business (§6045.02(c)).

CRIM / municipios — property tax on movables (Ley 107-2020 arts. 7.072–7.075, 7.167). Applies: yes. The personal-property tax is a preferential lien on all the taxpayer’s movables and immovables from the payment demand (on immovables only from annotation in the Registro) (art. 7.167). The CRIM chooses what to seize; the debtor may petition the TPI to dissolve an embargo of movables (art. 7.072). Notice with a 30-day warning, then sale “sin más aviso” (art. 7.073). Appraisal and auction 30–60 days after the embargo at 75% / 60% / 50%; art. 249 CEC exemptions apply; surplus to the taxpayer (art. 7.074). Payment and delivery “darán título y derecho al comprador”; unsold goods must be collected within 20 days (art. 7.075). Survival of other interests: not addressed — needs_verification.

Removed and abandoned vehicles (Ley 22-2000).

  • Police / municipal (arts. 6.28, 10.19): removal to a municipal lot; release on USD 55 custody plus USD 55 towing, plus USD 15 a day after 48 hours up to USD 400; owner notified within 24 hours that unless reclaimed within an improrrogable 60 days the vehicle may be sold; after 60 days, public auction with an aviso in a general-circulation daily 60 days before (make, year, plate, registered owner). Costs come out of the price and any surplus goes to the municipio or the Fondo General, not the owner. A vehicle unattended more than 24 hours is presumed abandoned; chatarra is held 30 days (owner identified) or 15 days (not identified) and then disposed of under Police regulation or municipal ordinance; 30 days to seek judicial review (art. 10.19(C)).
  • DTOP (art. 23.09): certified-mail notice warning of sale if not reclaimed and paid within 60 days; sale authorized after 90 days; aviso at least 30 days before; surplus to the Fondo General.
  • Lienholders: none of these articles requires notice to a lender, and none says whether a DTOP-filed financing statement is extinguished. DTOP accepts a documento de subasta pública identifying the authorized auctioneer as proof of ownership (art. 2.04(b)(3)) but refuses transfers of liened vehicles (art. 2.43(d)) — buyer title needs_verification. Restricted buyers: none stated; a subasta pública must be open to the public (Ley 8-1987 art. 2(f)).

Abandoned vessels (Ley 430-2000 art. 13, added by Ley 35-2024). DRNA (which may contract with municipios) handles deteriorated, unpermitted, six-month-expired-decal, aground or sunk vessels: phone/e-mail plus certified mail to the last registered owner (30 days), a notice in a general-circulation newspaper and on the DRNA website and social media (30 days), and a tag on the vessel; with no response 60 days after the newspaper notice, DRNA seizes the vessel and may sell it at public auction or dispose of it (recycling first), and may sue the last registered owner for any shortfall. Hazards may be moved first and noticed afterward. Separately, a finder may be adjudicated owner of an unidentifiable or wrecked vessel through a DRNA permit procedure (certified letter, newspaper notice, Police and Justice certifications, sworn statement, fee up to USD 50); the former owner’s abandonment fines are not removed (art. 13(B)). Buyer title at a DRNA auction and lien survival are not stated — needs_verification.

Abandoned aircraft. No Puerto Rico abandoned-aircraft disposal statute was located — needs_verification. (The airport-charges lien of Ley 187-1949 art. 9 is a retention lien enforced by suit, profiled in 12.3.)

Confiscation (confiscación civil, Ley 119-2011). The Director notifies the seizure and appraisal by certified mail within a 30-day jurisdictional term to the possessor, presumed owners and, for vehicles, the DTOP-registered owner and the conditional creditor whose contract is recorded (art. 13). A holder of a gravamen at the seizure date is an “owner” with standing; the challenge must be filed within 30 days of notice and the Secretario de Justicia served within 15 days of filing — both jurisdictional (art. 15); a bond within 20 days recovers the property (art. 16). The Junta disposes of property by sale, auction, donation, transfer or exchange; vehicles, vessels and aircraft may be sold or auctioned to the public; transfers to agencies at 10% or 50% of appraisal; no sale below 25% of appraisal without Junta authorization (art. 20). Late notice makes a confiscation null only if a timely, properly served challenge obtains that ruling (reliable-financial-services-v-ela-2017); a dropped criminal case does not void it and the innocent-third-party defence is fact-specific (cooperativa-de-seguros-multiples-v-ela-2025). The statute does not state the purchaser’s title — needs_verification.

12.3 Lienholder sales without a court

General rule. Retención is “la facultad otorgada por ley” that lets a creditor keep a thing until paid, without notice or court authorization, enforceable against later acquirers and, in stated cases, older rights (Código Civil 2020 arts. 1223–1224). It never authorizes the retainer to acquire the thing — “Todo pacto distinto es nulo” (art. 1226) — and another creditor may seize and auction it, but the buyer takes possession only by paying the retainer the auction price up to its credit (art. 1228). Retention exists only where a law grants it: the Code grants it to the depositary (art. 1463), the mandatary (art. 1412(b)), the good-faith possessor (art. 728) and the usufructuary (art. 902). Correction: the first pass said every repair shop, tower or marina holds retention; no grant appears in the contrato de obra chapter (arts. 1367 ff.), the hospedaje chapter or the towing articles, so a repairer’s or marina’s position depends on another qualifying grant (for example a deposit) or contract. Possessory liens created by law prevail over Article 9 interests unless their statute says otherwise (Ley 208-1995 §9-333).

Correction — self-storage. Puerto Rico does have a self-storage lien act (Ley 173-2011); the first pass said none was located.

Grant universe. 28 independently created statutory charges on movables were found by full-text screening of every retrieved body for gravamen, privilegio, retención/retener, preferente, prelación, then adjudicated (18 further candidates were excluded or consolidated, for example the consensual prenda, realty-only liens, filing-only statutes and the repealed Ley 12-2010). This is not a certificate that no other Puerto Rico law creates a charge. No common-law lien category is claimed. Each grant below states all fifteen schema fields; U = needs_verification, NA = the field does not arise for that grant (reason given). Note: the Código Civil 2020 refers to rules on “concurrencia y la prelación de créditos” (art. 536) and Ley 173-2011 to the State’s liens “según dispuesto en el Código Civil”, but the 2020 Code, which repealed the 1930 Code entirely (art. 1819), contains no such ranking chapter; tax-lien priority against perfected security interests is therefore marked U.

A. Depositary’s retention — CC 2020 art. 1463 · source: Código Civil 2020

  • statute: CC 2020 art. 1463 (with arts. 1223-1229).
  • who_holds: A depositario, until full payment of what is owed by reason of the deposit (storage price or necessary expenses, art. 1462).
  • priority_vs_perfected_security_interest: Retention may be invoked against third parties who acquired a right in the thing after the credit arose and the thing reached the retainer’s hands, and against older rights if the credit arises from a contract the debtor could make about the thing or the retainer had no reason to doubt the debtor’s authority (CC art. 1224); another creditor may seize and auction the thing, but the purchaser takes possession only by paying the retainer the auction price up to its credit (art. 1228).
  • cap: The whole secured credit; retention extends to the entire thing regardless of the credit’s amount (art. 1225).
  • court_required: Yes for any sale: retention never authorizes the retainer to acquire the thing and any contrary pact is void (art. 1226); the retainer must sue and execute.
  • notice_to_owner: No pre-retention notice: the retainer needs no prior notice or court authorization but must oppose its right when asked to deliver (art. 1223). — NA
  • notice_to_lienholders: No sale procedure: the grant is enforced only through a judicial action and execution (R. 51) or the grant’s own administrative collection. — NA
  • dmv_notice: No sale procedure: the grant is enforced only through a judicial action and execution (R. 51) or the grant’s own administrative collection. — NA
  • publication: No sale procedure: the grant is enforced only through a judicial action and execution (R. 51) or the grant’s own administrative collection. — NA
  • waiting_period: No sale procedure: the grant is enforced only through a judicial action and execution (R. 51) or the grant’s own administrative collection. — NA
  • sale_method: None by the retainer; judicial execution (R. 51.7) by the retainer or another creditor.
  • buyer_title: The execution buyer is subrogated to the debtor’s rights (R. 51.7(d)) and must pay the retainer up to its credit before taking possession (art. 1228).
  • surplus_handling: Through the execution: the alguacil returns any sobrante to the Secretaría within 15 days (R. 51.2).
  • defective_sale_consequence: Appropriation pacts are null (art. 1226); retention is extinguished by voluntary delivery, substitution of sufficient security, abuse or deterioration (art. 1229); the retainer may not use the thing and must conserve it (art. 1227).
  • citation: CC 2020 arts. 1223-1229, 1462-1463.

B. Mandatary’s retention with preference — CC 2020 art. 1412(b) · source: Código Civil 2020

  • statute: CC 2020 art. 1412(b).
  • who_holds: A mandatario, over property resulting from executing the mandate.
  • priority_vs_perfected_security_interest: Retention may be invoked against third parties who acquired a right in the thing after the credit arose and the thing reached the retainer’s hands, and against older rights if the credit arises from a contract the debtor could make about the thing or the retainer had no reason to doubt the debtor’s authority (CC art. 1224); another creditor may seize and auction the thing, but the purchaser takes possession only by paying the retainer the auction price up to its credit (art. 1228). Art. 1412(b) adds that the retention is ‘con preferencia de otros acreedores del mandante’.
  • cap: The whole secured credit; retention extends to the entire thing regardless of the credit’s amount (art. 1225).
  • court_required: Yes for any sale: retention never authorizes the retainer to acquire the thing and any contrary pact is void (art. 1226); the retainer must sue and execute.
  • notice_to_owner: No pre-retention notice: the retainer needs no prior notice or court authorization but must oppose its right when asked to deliver (art. 1223). — NA
  • notice_to_lienholders: No sale procedure: the grant is enforced only through a judicial action and execution (R. 51) or the grant’s own administrative collection. — NA
  • dmv_notice: No sale procedure: the grant is enforced only through a judicial action and execution (R. 51) or the grant’s own administrative collection. — NA
  • publication: No sale procedure: the grant is enforced only through a judicial action and execution (R. 51) or the grant’s own administrative collection. — NA
  • waiting_period: No sale procedure: the grant is enforced only through a judicial action and execution (R. 51) or the grant’s own administrative collection. — NA
  • sale_method: None by the retainer; judicial execution (R. 51.7) by the retainer or another creditor.
  • buyer_title: The execution buyer is subrogated to the debtor’s rights (R. 51.7(d)) and must pay the retainer up to its credit before taking possession (art. 1228).
  • surplus_handling: Through the execution: the alguacil returns any sobrante to the Secretaría within 15 days (R. 51.2).
  • defective_sale_consequence: Appropriation pacts are null (art. 1226); retention is extinguished by voluntary delivery, substitution of sufficient security, abuse or deterioration (art. 1229); the retainer may not use the thing and must conserve it (art. 1227).
  • citation: CC 2020 arts. 1412, 1223-1229.

C. Good-faith possessor’s retention for necessary and useful expenses — CC 2020 art. 728 · source: Código Civil 2020

  • statute: CC 2020 art. 728.
  • who_holds: A good-faith possessor, for necessary and useful expenses on the thing.
  • priority_vs_perfected_security_interest: Retention may be invoked against third parties who acquired a right in the thing after the credit arose and the thing reached the retainer’s hands, and against older rights if the credit arises from a contract the debtor could make about the thing or the retainer had no reason to doubt the debtor’s authority (CC art. 1224); another creditor may seize and auction the thing, but the purchaser takes possession only by paying the retainer the auction price up to its credit (art. 1228).
  • cap: The whole secured credit; retention extends to the entire thing regardless of the credit’s amount (art. 1225).
  • court_required: Yes for any sale: retention never authorizes the retainer to acquire the thing and any contrary pact is void (art. 1226); the retainer must sue and execute.
  • notice_to_owner: No pre-retention notice: the retainer needs no prior notice or court authorization but must oppose its right when asked to deliver (art. 1223). — NA
  • notice_to_lienholders: No sale procedure: the grant is enforced only through a judicial action and execution (R. 51) or the grant’s own administrative collection. — NA
  • dmv_notice: No sale procedure: the grant is enforced only through a judicial action and execution (R. 51) or the grant’s own administrative collection. — NA
  • publication: No sale procedure: the grant is enforced only through a judicial action and execution (R. 51) or the grant’s own administrative collection. — NA
  • waiting_period: No sale procedure: the grant is enforced only through a judicial action and execution (R. 51) or the grant’s own administrative collection. — NA
  • sale_method: None by the retainer; judicial execution (R. 51.7) by the retainer or another creditor.
  • buyer_title: The execution buyer is subrogated to the debtor’s rights (R. 51.7(d)) and must pay the retainer up to its credit before taking possession (art. 1228).
  • surplus_handling: Through the execution: the alguacil returns any sobrante to the Secretaría within 15 days (R. 51.2).
  • defective_sale_consequence: Appropriation pacts are null (art. 1226); retention is extinguished by voluntary delivery, substitution of sufficient security, abuse or deterioration (art. 1229); the retainer may not use the thing and must conserve it (art. 1227).
  • citation: CC 2020 arts. 728, 1223-1229.

D. Usufructuary’s retention for extraordinary repairs — CC 2020 art. 902 · source: Código Civil 2020

  • statute: CC 2020 art. 902.
  • who_holds: A usufructuary who made indispensable extraordinary repairs the owner refused to pay for (also imputing fruits).
  • priority_vs_perfected_security_interest: Retention may be invoked against third parties who acquired a right in the thing after the credit arose and the thing reached the retainer’s hands, and against older rights if the credit arises from a contract the debtor could make about the thing or the retainer had no reason to doubt the debtor’s authority (CC art. 1224); another creditor may seize and auction the thing, but the purchaser takes possession only by paying the retainer the auction price up to its credit (art. 1228).
  • cap: The whole secured credit; retention extends to the entire thing regardless of the credit’s amount (art. 1225).
  • court_required: Yes for any sale: retention never authorizes the retainer to acquire the thing and any contrary pact is void (art. 1226); the retainer must sue and execute.
  • notice_to_owner: No pre-retention notice: the retainer needs no prior notice or court authorization but must oppose its right when asked to deliver (art. 1223). — NA
  • notice_to_lienholders: No sale procedure: the grant is enforced only through a judicial action and execution (R. 51) or the grant’s own administrative collection. — NA
  • dmv_notice: No sale procedure: the grant is enforced only through a judicial action and execution (R. 51) or the grant’s own administrative collection. — NA
  • publication: No sale procedure: the grant is enforced only through a judicial action and execution (R. 51) or the grant’s own administrative collection. — NA
  • waiting_period: No sale procedure: the grant is enforced only through a judicial action and execution (R. 51) or the grant’s own administrative collection. — NA
  • sale_method: None by the retainer; judicial execution (R. 51.7) by the retainer or another creditor.
  • buyer_title: The execution buyer is subrogated to the debtor’s rights (R. 51.7(d)) and must pay the retainer up to its credit before taking possession (art. 1228).
  • surplus_handling: Through the execution: the alguacil returns any sobrante to the Secretaría within 15 days (R. 51.2).
  • defective_sale_consequence: Appropriation pacts are null (art. 1226); retention is extinguished by voluntary delivery, substitution of sufficient security, abuse or deterioration (art. 1229); the retainer may not use the thing and must conserve it (art. 1227).
  • citation: CC 2020 arts. 902, 1223-1229.

E. Self-service storage operator’s lien — Ley 173-2011 art. 4 · source: Ley para el Gravamen en Instalaciones de Almacenamiento por Autoservicio

  • statute: Ley 173-2011 art. 4 (10 L.P.R.A. §4153); not applicable where the operator issues a warehouse receipt or bill of lading (then Ley 208).
  • who_holds: Operator (owner, lessor, sublessor or agent) of a self-service storage facility or mobile storage unit, over all the user’s stored movables except personal identification documents.
  • priority_vs_perfected_security_interest: Perfected once the debt is due, liquid and exigible; priority over any other lien or third-party right except liens perfected before the goods were stored; never preferred over the State’s liens ‘según dispuesto en el Código Civil’.
  • cap: Rent, late charges and contract charges, plus handling/conservation/sale/enforcement expenses capped at USD 1,500; ‘reasonable’ late fee capped at USD 10 / 15 / greater of USD 20 or 15% by rent tier (art. 8).
  • court_required: No; but the operator may not proceed while a dispute filed at DACO or the TPI is pending once notified (art. 3).
  • notice_to_owner: Access may be denied 7 days after a missed payment; first notice by U.S. mail with certificate of mailing after 20 days’ default (amount, demand, auction warning, no-access warning, right to file at DACO or TPI); second notice at least 10 days later giving at least 10 days to pay.
  • notice_to_lienholders: None required by statute; a third party proving ownership by sworn statement may pay and recover the goods before the sale (art. 6(i)).
  • dmv_notice: None before sale; after sale DTOP or DRNA issues title to the buyer on application with the seller’s sworn statement and proof of compliance (art. 7).
  • publication: Notarial inventory (acta notarial) with the operator’s appraisal, then an edicto in a newspaper of general circulation in Puerto Rico and on a notice board at the facility.
  • waiting_period: Sale not less than 10 days after the edicto; edicto only after both notices and the second notice’s payment period.
  • sale_method: Public auction under the noticed terms; minimum 100% of the operator’s appraisal, then 75%, then 50%; only what is strictly necessary is sold; operator, spouse and relatives to the third degree may not bid; if no sale the operator may dispose of the goods or adjudicate them at appraised prices against the debt; records kept 2 years.
  • buyer_title: Payment and delivery give the buyer title free of the operator’s lien and of any charge subordinate to it (art. 6(h)); liens perfected before storage and the State’s liens are not stated to be discharged.
  • surplus_handling: User notified by regular mail within 10 days; 60 days to claim; then remitted to Hacienda where the user has one year, after which it goes to the Fondo General; deficiency remains owed.
  • defective_sale_consequence: Statute does not void the sale; operator must carry liability insurance covering ‘embargo ilegal’ (art. 10); DACO regulation sets penalties (art. 11); Ley 173 prevails over conflicting laws (art. 12).
  • citation: Ley 173-2011 arts. 2-12 (amended by Leyes 286-2018 and 216-2024), OGP Rev. 9 Oct 2024.

F. Warehouse lien (Article 7) — Ley 208-1995 §7-209(1) · source: Ley de Transacciones Comerciales

  • statute: Ley 208-1995 §7-209(1); enforcement §7-210.
  • who_holds: A warehouse (almacenista) against the depositor on goods covered by its receipt or their proceeds in its possession.
  • priority_vs_perfected_security_interest: Effective against persons who so entrusted the depositor with possession that a pledge by the depositor to a good-faith purchaser would have been valid; not against a person to whom the document confers no right (§7-503); household-goods lien effective against all if the depositor was the lawful possessor (§7-209(3)); possessory liens created by law prevail over security interests unless the creating statute says otherwise (§9-333).
  • cap: Storage, transport, insurance, labour and preservation/sale charges; against a duly negotiated negotiable receipt limited to charges stated or reasonable charges after the receipt date.
  • court_required: No.
  • notice_to_owner: Merchant-deposited goods: notice to all known claimants stating amount, nature of sale and time/place of any public sale; other goods: personal delivery or certified/registered mail, itemized claim, demand within not less than 10 days of receipt, conspicuous auction warning.
  • notice_to_lienholders: To all persons known to claim an interest in the goods.
  • dmv_notice: No registry notice in Article 7. — NA
  • publication: Non-merchant goods: advertisement once a week for two consecutive weeks in a general-circulation newspaper where the sale is held (or six conspicuous postings at least 10 days before if none).
  • waiting_period: Non-merchant goods: sale at least 15 days after first publication and after the demand period.
  • sale_method: Public or private sale on commercially reasonable terms (merchant goods); auction at the nearest suitable place on noticed terms (other goods); warehouse may buy at a public sale.
  • buyer_title: A good-faith purchaser takes free of the rights of persons against whom the lien was valid, despite the warehouse’s non-compliance (§7-210(5)).
  • surplus_handling: Warehouse keeps the excess for delivery on demand to any person to whom it would have been bound to deliver the goods (§7-210(6)).
  • defective_sale_consequence: Liability for damages for non-compliance; conversion for wilful violation (§7-210(9)).
  • citation: Ley 208-1995 §§7-209, 7-210, 9-333 (OGP Rev. 23 Jun 2025).

G. Carrier’s lien (Article 7) — Ley 208-1995 §7-307(1) · source: Ley de Transacciones Comerciales

  • statute: Ley 208-1995 §7-307; enforcement §7-308.
  • who_holds: A carrier (porteador) on goods covered by a bill of lading.
  • priority_vs_perfected_security_interest: For goods the carrier must accept by law, effective against the consignor or anyone entitled unless the carrier knew the consignor lacked authority; other liens effective against the consignor and anyone who permitted the bailor control/possession unless the carrier had notice of lack of authority; §9-333 priority for possessory liens.
  • cap: Storage/transport charges after receipt and preservation/sale expenses; against a purchaser of a negotiable bill limited to stated charges or tariff or a reasonable charge.
  • court_required: No.
  • notice_to_owner: Notice to all persons known to claim an interest: amount due, nature of the proposed sale, time/place of any public sale.
  • notice_to_lienholders: Same notice to all known claimants.
  • dmv_notice: No registry notice in Article 7. — NA
  • publication: None prescribed by §7-308.
  • waiting_period: None fixed beyond commercially reasonable timing after notice.
  • sale_method: Public or private sale, en bloc or in lots, commercially reasonable; carrier may buy at a public sale.
  • buyer_title: Good-faith purchaser takes free of the rights of all persons against whom the lien was valid, despite carrier non-compliance (§7-308(4)).
  • surplus_handling: Excess held for delivery on demand to the person entitled (§7-308(5)).
  • defective_sale_consequence: Rights of a claimant to pay before sale (§7-308(2)); carrier liable for non-compliance under general law; good-faith buyer protected.
  • citation: Ley 208-1995 §§7-307, 7-308.

H. Hacienda general tax lien (and levy liens on third-party-held property) — CRI §6060.01(a)(2), (c) · source: Código de Rentas Internas 2011

  • statute: Ley 1-2011 §6060.01(a)(2) (lien on every movable and immovable of the debtor); §6060.01(c) (notice and demand to a holder creates a lien on the held property/credits, preferential and continuing for wages, receivables and deposits) — one grant family.
  • who_holds: Gobierno de Puerto Rico (Secretario de Hacienda).
  • priority_vs_perfected_security_interest: The movables lien arises from the unpaid debt; filing of a Certificación de Gravamen is provided for the Registro de la Propiedad (immovables). No rule ranks it against an earlier-perfected Article 9 security interest in movables; none is assumed. — U (needs_verification)
  • cap: Unpaid taxes plus fines, interest, surcharges, penalties and costs; levy on wages limited to 25% after mandatory deductions.
  • court_required: No: administrative apremio; debtor may challenge the embargo of movables in the TPI within the term in the notice (§6060.01(b)).
  • notice_to_owner: Written notificación de embargo to the debtor (or family member in charge) or certified mail; 30 days to pay before sale without further notice (CRI §6060.02).
  • notice_to_lienholders: None required for movables by §§6060.02-6060.08.
  • dmv_notice: No statutory DTOP notice; CESCO records an embargo on a vehicle on an order of the court or of Hacienda (agency guidance).
  • publication: Anuncio de Subasta at least three times over a week in two general-circulation dailies, plus edictos (§6060.08(b)).
  • waiting_period: 30 days after notice; sale 30-60 days after the embargo (§6060.03(c)).
  • sale_method: Appraisal; public auction at 100/75/50% minimums; Government may adjudicate to itself; 10% deposit, balance in 10 days.
  • buyer_title: Delivery plus cuenta de venta give ‘título y derecho’ (§6060.04), but survival of prior perfected interests in movables is not addressed. — U (needs_verification)
  • surplus_handling: Surplus to the taxpayer (§6060.03(g), 6060.04); credit note if the Government adjudicates to itself.
  • defective_sale_consequence: Sales of property known to be exempt, fraudulent sales or bid-chilling are null and the agent liable (§6060.11); purchases by agents/collection employees are null (§6060.12).
  • citation: Ley 1-2011 §§6060.01-6060.12, 6060.20.

I. Estate and gift tax lien on transferred property — CRI §2054.01(a) · source: Código de Rentas Internas 2011

  • statute: Ley 1-2011 §2054.01(a).
  • who_holds: Gobierno de Puerto Rico, over every asset of the gross estate or gift.
  • priority_vs_perfected_security_interest: ‘Gravamen preferente’ without a ranking rule against perfected security interests; securities bought by a good-faith purchaser for value are released and the lien shifts to the transferor’s property. — U (needs_verification)
  • cap: All estate/gift taxes and other determined taxes deductible from the estate.
  • court_required: No: collectible by the Subtitle F apremio (contribución includes Subtitles A-E taxes and licence fees, §6010.01(a)) or by suit.
  • notice_to_owner: Written notificación de embargo to the debtor (or family member in charge) or certified mail; 30 days to pay before sale without further notice (CRI §6060.02).
  • notice_to_lienholders: None required for movables in the apremio chapter.
  • dmv_notice: None prescribed.
  • publication: Apremio Anuncio de Subasta (§6060.08(b)).
  • waiting_period: Apremio 30-day term; movables sold 30-60 days after embargo.
  • sale_method: Apremio public auction (§6060.03).
  • buyer_title: As for the general tax lien: survival of other interests in movables unaddressed (§6060.04). — U (needs_verification)
  • surplus_handling: Apremio surplus to the taxpayer (§6060.03(g)).
  • defective_sale_consequence: Apremio nullity rules (§§6060.11-6060.12).
  • citation: Ley 1-2011 §§2054.01-2054.02, 6010.01.

J. Estate and gift tax lien on all property after demand — CRI §2054.01(b) · source: Código de Rentas Internas 2011

  • statute: Ley 1-2011 §2054.01(b).
  • who_holds: Gobierno de Puerto Rico, on all property and rights of the person who fails to pay after notice and demand.
  • priority_vs_perfected_security_interest: Arises on assessment plus notice and demand and lasts until cancelled under §2054.02; no ranking against perfected security interests. — U (needs_verification)
  • cap: The unpaid tax with interest, penalties and additions.
  • court_required: No: collectible by the Subtitle F apremio (contribución includes Subtitles A-E taxes and licence fees, §6010.01(a)) or by suit.
  • notice_to_owner: Written notificación de embargo to the debtor (or family member in charge) or certified mail; 30 days to pay before sale without further notice (CRI §6060.02).
  • notice_to_lienholders: None required for movables in the apremio chapter.
  • dmv_notice: None prescribed.
  • publication: Apremio Anuncio de Subasta (§6060.08(b)).
  • waiting_period: Apremio 30-day term; movables sold 30-60 days after embargo.
  • sale_method: Apremio public auction (§6060.03).
  • buyer_title: As for the general tax lien: survival of other interests in movables unaddressed (§6060.04). — U (needs_verification)
  • surplus_handling: Apremio surplus to the taxpayer (§6060.03(g)).
  • defective_sale_consequence: Apremio nullity rules (§§6060.11-6060.12).
  • citation: Ley 1-2011 §§2054.01(b), 2054.02.

K. Deferred estate-tax lien on agricultural production units — CRI §2023.07(b) · source: Código de Rentas Internas 2011

  • statute: Ley 1-2011 §2023.07(b).
  • who_holds: Gobierno de Puerto Rico, on transferred property that took the 100% agricultural deduction.
  • priority_vs_perfected_security_interest: Arises at death and is preferred to all debts, credits or obligations arising on or after the date of death, for 10 years while the property remains an active production unit; earlier interests are not subordinated by the text.
  • cap: The deferred estate tax.
  • court_required: No: collectible by the Subtitle F apremio (contribución includes Subtitles A-E taxes and licence fees, §6010.01(a)) or by suit.
  • notice_to_owner: Written notificación de embargo to the debtor (or family member in charge) or certified mail; 30 days to pay before sale without further notice (CRI §6060.02).
  • notice_to_lienholders: None required for movables in the apremio chapter.
  • dmv_notice: None prescribed.
  • publication: Apremio Anuncio de Subasta (§6060.08(b)).
  • waiting_period: Apremio 30-day term; movables sold 30-60 days after embargo.
  • sale_method: Apremio public auction (§6060.03).
  • buyer_title: As for the general tax lien: survival of other interests in movables unaddressed (§6060.04). — U (needs_verification)
  • surplus_handling: Apremio surplus to the taxpayer (§6060.03(g)).
  • defective_sale_consequence: Apremio nullity rules (§§6060.11-6060.12).
  • citation: Ley 1-2011 §2023.07.

L. Alcoholic-beverage excise first lien — CRI §5021.05 · source: Código de Rentas Internas 2011

  • statute: Ley 1-2011 §5021.05.
  • who_holds: Gobierno de Puerto Rico, on the distillery/plant/factory, stills, containers, equipment and bonded warehouses where spirits are stored, and the land and buildings.
  • priority_vs_perfected_security_interest: ‘Primer gravamen preferencial’ from the moment the spirits exist until the taxes are paid.
  • cap: Subtitle E taxes on the spirits produced or stored.
  • court_required: No: collectible by the Subtitle F apremio (contribución includes Subtitles A-E taxes and licence fees, §6010.01(a)) or by suit.
  • notice_to_owner: Written notificación de embargo to the debtor (or family member in charge) or certified mail; 30 days to pay before sale without further notice (CRI §6060.02).
  • notice_to_lienholders: None required for movables in the apremio chapter.
  • dmv_notice: None prescribed.
  • publication: Apremio Anuncio de Subasta (§6060.08(b)).
  • waiting_period: Apremio 30-day term; movables sold 30-60 days after embargo.
  • sale_method: Apremio public auction (§6060.03).
  • buyer_title: As for the general tax lien: survival of other interests in movables unaddressed (§6060.04). — U (needs_verification)
  • surplus_handling: Apremio surplus to the taxpayer (§6060.03(g)).
  • defective_sale_consequence: Apremio nullity rules (§§6060.11-6060.12).
  • citation: Ley 1-2011 §§5021.05, 6045.02(b)-(c).

M. CRIM personal-property tax lien (with levy liens on third-party-held property) — CM art. 7.167 (with art. 7.072) · source: Código Municipal

  • statute: Código Municipal art. 7.167(a); notice/demand to a holder of the taxpayer’s property creates a preferential lien on it (art. 7.072(a)-(b)); embargo has the effect of a judgment (art. 7.057).
  • who_holds: CRIM (or the municipio acting under art. 1.008(h)).
  • priority_vs_perfected_security_interest: Preferential lien on all movables and immovables from the date payment is demanded within the prescriptive term; on immovables only from annotation in the Registro de la Propiedad; no ranking against earlier-perfected security interests in movables. — U (needs_verification)
  • cap: Personal-property taxes with interest, penalties and additions; 10% apremiador fee and custody costs.
  • court_required: No: apremio; the debtor may petition the TPI to dissolve an embargo of movables unless the CRIM proves sufficient grounds.
  • notice_to_owner: Personal delivery of the notificación de embargo, or certified mail/e-mail of record, or edicto under the Rules; 30 calendar days to pay before sale ‘sin más aviso’.
  • notice_to_lienholders: None required for movables (art. 7.057’s notice to mortgage/lien holders concerns real property).
  • dmv_notice: None prescribed.
  • publication: None prescribed for movables in arts. 7.073-7.075.
  • waiting_period: 30 days after notice; sale 30-60 days after the embargo.
  • sale_method: Appraisal and public auction at 75/60/50% minimums; only what is strictly necessary; art. 249 CEC exemptions.
  • buyer_title: Payment and delivery ‘darán título y derecho al comprador’ (art. 7.075); survival of other interests unaddressed. — U (needs_verification)
  • surplus_handling: Surplus to the taxpayer; unsold goods to be collected within 20 days of notice of the sale, then CRIM may dispose of them.
  • defective_sale_consequence: No movables-specific nullity or remedy rule located in arts. 7.072-7.075. — U (needs_verification)
  • citation: Código Municipal arts. 7.057, 7.072-7.075, 7.167 (OGP Rev. 15 Oct 2026).

N. Municipal construction-excise lien — CM art. 2.111(a) · source: Código Municipal

  • statute: Código Municipal art. 2.111(a).
  • who_holds: The municipio, on movables, immovables and real rights of the owner of the work or person responsible for payment.
  • priority_vs_perfected_security_interest: Not valid against a mortgagee, refaccionario, purchaser or judgment creditor until annotated in the Registro de la Propiedad and then only against later charges; the rule for movables subject to an Article 9 security interest is not stated. — U (needs_verification)
  • cap: The arbitrio de construcción with interest, penalties and surcharges.
  • court_required: No: the municipal Oficina de Finanzas collects by embargo and sale under Libro VII (the CRIM apremio procedure); the taxpayer may seek judicial review of the Director’s determination (art. 1.050).
  • notice_to_owner: Lien arises when the Director de Finanzas determines and notifies the arbitrio; then the Libro VII notificación de embargo with its 30-day warning.
  • notice_to_lienholders: None required for movables in the Libro VII apremio.
  • dmv_notice: Not a vehicle registry charge. — NA
  • publication: None prescribed for movables in arts. 7.073-7.075.
  • waiting_period: 30 days after notice; sale 30-60 days after the embargo (art. 7.074).
  • sale_method: Libro VII apremio auction at 75/60/50% minimums.
  • buyer_title: As for CRIM apremio: ‘título y derecho’ without a survival rule (art. 7.075). — U (needs_verification)
  • surplus_handling: Surplus to the taxpayer (art. 7.074).
  • defective_sale_consequence: No movables-specific nullity or remedy rule located. — U (needs_verification)
  • citation: Código Municipal art. 2.111.

O. Lien of a person paying taxes on property in litigation — CM art. 7.053 · source: Código Municipal

  • statute: Código Municipal art. 7.053.
  • who_holds: A person possessing, acquiring or claiming a right in property in litigation (or deposited with a public employee) who pays the taxes assessed on it.
  • priority_vs_perfected_security_interest: ‘Un derecho preferente sobre todo otro acreedor, excepto el Gobierno de Puerto Rico’ for the amount paid.
  • cap: The taxes paid.
  • court_required: Yes in practice: the article creates the lien and preference but no extrajudicial sale power; enforcement in the litigation/execution.
  • notice_to_owner: No sale procedure: the grant is enforced only through a judicial action and execution (R. 51) or the grant’s own administrative collection. — NA
  • notice_to_lienholders: No sale procedure: the grant is enforced only through a judicial action and execution (R. 51) or the grant’s own administrative collection. — NA
  • dmv_notice: No sale procedure: the grant is enforced only through a judicial action and execution (R. 51) or the grant’s own administrative collection. — NA
  • publication: No sale procedure: the grant is enforced only through a judicial action and execution (R. 51) or the grant’s own administrative collection. — NA
  • waiting_period: No sale procedure: the grant is enforced only through a judicial action and execution (R. 51) or the grant’s own administrative collection. — NA
  • sale_method: No private sale; judicial process.
  • buyer_title: Through the court sale (R. 51.7(d) subrogation).
  • surplus_handling: Through the execution (R. 51.2).
  • defective_sale_consequence: Governed by R. 51.7-51.8 nullity/remedy rules.
  • citation: Código Municipal art. 7.053.

P. Accident-claim annotation with lien effect (vehicles) — Ley 22-2000 art. 4.10 · source: CESCO, Ley de Vehículos y Tránsito

  • statute: Ley 22-2000 art. 4.10.
  • who_holds: Any person with a claim arising from an accident caused by operation of the vehicle who files a qualifying sworn statement with DTOP.
  • priority_vs_perfected_security_interest: The annotation has ‘el mismo efecto de un gravamen’ for one year; its ranking against an earlier-perfected financing statement is not stated. — U (needs_verification)
  • cap: No amount cap; the owner may free the vehicle by a bond fixed by the Secretary from market value.
  • court_required: Yes for any recovery from the vehicle; the annotation itself blocks transfers.
  • notice_to_owner: DTOP must inform the owner and any interested requester in writing of the existence of the annotation.
  • notice_to_lienholders: On request only.
  • dmv_notice: The lien is the DTOP annotation itself; DTOP authorizes no transfer during the year.
  • publication: No sale procedure: the grant is enforced only through a judicial action and execution (R. 51) or the grant’s own administrative collection. — NA
  • waiting_period: Effect lasts one year.
  • sale_method: None; judicial execution if the claim is reduced to judgment.
  • buyer_title: No transfer can be registered for one year unless bonded (CESCO cancellation via DTOP-DIS-227).
  • surplus_handling: No sale procedure: the grant is enforced only through a judicial action and execution (R. 51) or the grant’s own administrative collection. — NA
  • defective_sale_consequence: No sale under this article. — NA
  • citation: Ley 22-2000 art. 4.10; CESCO ‘Cancelación de gravamen de litigio’.

Q. Administrative traffic-fine gravamen (plate/vehicle) — Ley 22-2000 arts. 2.41(a),(h), 2.43(d), 23.10 · source: Ley de Vehículos y Tránsito

  • statute: Ley 22-2000 arts. 2.41(a), (h), 2.43(d), 23.10.
  • who_holds: The Government (DTOP) for administrative traffic fines.
  • priority_vs_perfected_security_interest: Operates as a registration block, not a ranked security interest; no ranking rule stated. — U (needs_verification)
  • cap: The fines annotated.
  • court_required: No sale of the vehicle for fines is authorized; collection by the administrative fine process. — NA
  • notice_to_owner: Fines are notified to the infractor (art. 25.01).
  • notice_to_lienholders: None. — NA
  • dmv_notice: Annotated in the DTOP register.
  • publication: No sale procedure: the grant is enforced only through a judicial action and execution (R. 51) or the grant’s own administrative collection. — NA
  • waiting_period: No sale procedure: the grant is enforced only through a judicial action and execution (R. 51) or the grant’s own administrative collection. — NA
  • sale_method: No sale. — NA
  • buyer_title: On a transfer the fine gravamen moves to the prior owner’s plate (art. 2.41(a)); fines follow the plate owner (art. 23.10); but DTOP refuses transfers of vehicles ‘gravado con cualquier tipo de gravamen’ save the trade-in exception (art. 2.43(d)) — obtain a Certificación de Negativo de Multas.
  • surplus_handling: No sale procedure: the grant is enforced only through a judicial action and execution (R. 51) or the grant’s own administrative collection. — NA
  • defective_sale_consequence: No sale. — NA
  • citation: Ley 22-2000 arts. 2.41, 2.43, 23.10, 25.01.

R. Vessel administrative-fine annotation — Ley 430-2000 arts. 9(9), 11 · source: Ley de Navegación y Seguridad Acuática

  • statute: Ley 430-2000 arts. 9(9), 11.
  • who_holds: DRNA (Secretario), for administrative fines filed in the vessel’s register.
  • priority_vs_perfected_security_interest: A prohibition on registering transfer/renewal until paid; no ranking against recorded security interests stated. — U (needs_verification)
  • cap: The annotated fines (unregistered-vessel fine = four times the annual fee).
  • court_required: No sale authorized for the fine. — NA
  • notice_to_owner: Secretary notifies the registered owner; mailing to the register address is legal notice.
  • notice_to_lienholders: Secretary notifies any person with another recorded gravamen on the vessel.
  • dmv_notice: Annotation in the DRNA register; public inspection; DRNA informs requesters within 48 hours; fines must be registered within 45 days or may be annulled.
  • publication: No sale procedure: the grant is enforced only through a judicial action and execution (R. 51) or the grant’s own administrative collection. — NA
  • waiting_period: No sale procedure: the grant is enforced only through a judicial action and execution (R. 51) or the grant’s own administrative collection. — NA
  • sale_method: No sale. — NA
  • buyer_title: Renewal/transfer fines must be paid before transfer even in a creditor’s execution (art. 9(9)); other fines predating the change of owner allow transfer with the annotation kept and the new owner paying at transfer (art. 11(4)).
  • surplus_handling: No sale procedure: the grant is enforced only through a judicial action and execution (R. 51) or the grant’s own administrative collection. — NA
  • defective_sale_consequence: No sale. — NA
  • citation: Ley 430-2000 arts. 9(9), 11.

S. Airport-charges lien on aircraft — Ley 187-1949 art. 9 · source: Ley de Actividades Aeronáuticas

  • statute: Ley 187-1949 art. 9 (23 L.P.R.A. §469).
  • who_holds: Autoridad de los Puertos (Director Ejecutivo), for unpaid charges for use of airport facilities after formal demand.
  • priority_vs_perfected_security_interest: Lien created by statute with a detention right; ranking against an FAA-recorded security interest not stated (§9-333 may apply to possessory liens for services, but airport-use charges are not shown to qualify). — U (needs_verification)
  • cap: The airport charges owed (owner, lessee, agent, pilot and operator jointly liable).
  • court_required: Yes: the Autoridad must file a sworn complaint describing the retained aircraft; collection under the Rules of Civil Procedure.
  • notice_to_owner: Formal demand before retention.
  • notice_to_lienholders: Not stated. — U (needs_verification)
  • dmv_notice: No Puerto Rico aircraft registry. — NA
  • publication: Execution-sale notice if judgment is executed (R. 51.7).
  • waiting_period: As in the judicial process.
  • sale_method: Judicial execution sale.
  • buyer_title: R. 51.7(d) subrogation to the debtor’s rights; federal registry recording separately required.
  • surplus_handling: Execution sobrante to the Secretaría (R. 51.2).
  • defective_sale_consequence: R. 51.7(a) nullity; R. 51.8 remedies.
  • citation: Ley 187-1949 art. 9; R.P.C. 51.

T. Vessel lien for damage caused by a vessel — Ley 151-1968 §3.05 · source: Ley de Muelles y Puertos 1968

  • statute: Ley 151-1968 §3.05.
  • who_holds: A person damaged by a vessel under §§3.03, 3.04, 5.04, 5.13.
  • priority_vs_perfected_security_interest: ‘La misma preferencia que determinan las leyes y estatutos de Estados Unidos sobre la misma materia’ (federal maritime-lien ranking by reference, §3.05).
  • cap: The amounts sued for.
  • court_required: Yes: the lien is constituted by the judicial demand (‘La demanda judicial … constituirá un gravamen’).
  • notice_to_owner: Through service of the judicial complaint.
  • notice_to_lienholders: Not stated. — U (needs_verification)
  • dmv_notice: Port/vessel lien; no DTOP role. — NA
  • publication: Execution-sale notice (R. 51.7) if enforced in the Puerto Rico courts.
  • waiting_period: Action extinguished one year after the injured party learned of the damage.
  • sale_method: Judicial sale on the resulting judgment.
  • buyer_title: Through the judicial sale (R. 51.7(d)); federal maritime law governs documented vessels’ preferred-mortgage interplay.
  • surplus_handling: Execution sobrante (R. 51.2).
  • defective_sale_consequence: R. 51.7-51.8.
  • citation: Ley 151-1968 §3.05 (OGP Rev. 10 Jan 2025).

U. Pilotage-fee lien — Ley 151-1968 §4.17 · source: Ley de Muelles y Puertos 1968

  • statute: Ley 151-1968 §4.17.
  • who_holds: Pilot or Autoridad for pilotage fees, indemnities and expenses under §§4.14-4.15.
  • priority_vs_perfected_security_interest: ‘La misma preferencia que determinan las leyes y estatutos de Estados Unidos sobre la misma materia’ (federal maritime-lien ranking by reference, §3.05).
  • cap: The amounts sued for.
  • court_required: Yes: the lien is constituted by the judicial demand (‘La demanda judicial … constituirá un gravamen’).
  • notice_to_owner: Through service of the judicial complaint.
  • notice_to_lienholders: Not stated. — U (needs_verification)
  • dmv_notice: Port/vessel lien; no DTOP role. — NA
  • publication: Execution-sale notice (R. 51.7) if enforced in the Puerto Rico courts.
  • waiting_period: Suit within the §3.05 one-year term.
  • sale_method: Judicial sale on the resulting judgment.
  • buyer_title: Through the judicial sale (R. 51.7(d)); federal maritime law governs documented vessels’ preferred-mortgage interplay.
  • surplus_handling: Execution sobrante (R. 51.2).
  • defective_sale_consequence: R. 51.7-51.8.
  • citation: Ley 151-1968 §4.17 (OGP Rev. 10 Jan 2025).

V. Port-charges lien on vessels — Ley 151-1968 §5.09 · source: Ley de Muelles y Puertos 1968

  • statute: Ley 151-1968 §5.09 (with §5.08 detention).
  • who_holds: Autoridad de los Puertos for sums owed under §§5.05-5.06; the vessel may be detained until paid (§5.08).
  • priority_vs_perfected_security_interest: ‘La misma preferencia que determinan las leyes y estatutos de Estados Unidos sobre la misma materia’ (federal maritime-lien ranking by reference, §3.05).
  • cap: The amounts sued for.
  • court_required: Yes: the lien is constituted by the judicial demand (‘La demanda judicial … constituirá un gravamen’).
  • notice_to_owner: Through service of the judicial complaint.
  • notice_to_lienholders: Not stated. — U (needs_verification)
  • dmv_notice: Port/vessel lien; no DTOP role. — NA
  • publication: Execution-sale notice (R. 51.7) if enforced in the Puerto Rico courts.
  • waiting_period: Extinguished one year after the debt is liquid and exigible.
  • sale_method: Judicial sale on the resulting judgment.
  • buyer_title: Through the judicial sale (R. 51.7(d)); federal maritime law governs documented vessels’ preferred-mortgage interplay.
  • surplus_handling: Execution sobrante (R. 51.2).
  • defective_sale_consequence: R. 51.7-51.8.
  • citation: Ley 151-1968 §5.09 (OGP Rev. 10 Jan 2025).

W. Port-charges lien on cargo — Ley 151-1968 §5.10 · source: Ley de Muelles y Puertos 1968

  • statute: Ley 151-1968 §5.10.
  • who_holds: Autoridad, for sums owed on merchandise landed and removed from the pier (owner and agent jointly liable).
  • priority_vs_perfected_security_interest: Preferred over any other lien ‘excepto por contribuciones’.
  • cap: The amounts sued for.
  • court_required: Yes: the lien is constituted by the judicial demand (‘La demanda judicial … constituirá un gravamen’).
  • notice_to_owner: Through service of the judicial complaint.
  • notice_to_lienholders: Not stated. — U (needs_verification)
  • dmv_notice: Port/vessel lien; no DTOP role. — NA
  • publication: Execution-sale notice (R. 51.7) if enforced in the Puerto Rico courts.
  • waiting_period: Extinguished six months after the debt is liquid and exigible.
  • sale_method: Judicial sale on the resulting judgment.
  • buyer_title: Through the judicial sale (R. 51.7(d)); federal maritime law governs documented vessels’ preferred-mortgage interplay.
  • surplus_handling: Execution sobrante (R. 51.2).
  • defective_sale_consequence: R. 51.7-51.8.
  • citation: Ley 151-1968 §5.10 (OGP Rev. 10 Jan 2025).

X. Annual vessel-licence-fee lien — Ley 151-1968 §5.12 · source: Ley de Muelles y Puertos 1968

  • statute: Ley 151-1968 §5.12.
  • who_holds: Autoridad, for the unpaid annual licence fee of §5.11 (vessel detained until paid).
  • priority_vs_perfected_security_interest: ‘La misma preferencia que determinan las leyes y estatutos de Estados Unidos sobre la misma materia’ (federal maritime-lien ranking by reference, §3.05).
  • cap: The amounts sued for.
  • court_required: Yes: the lien is constituted by the judicial demand (‘La demanda judicial … constituirá un gravamen’).
  • notice_to_owner: Through service of the judicial complaint.
  • notice_to_lienholders: Not stated. — U (needs_verification)
  • dmv_notice: Port/vessel lien; no DTOP role. — NA
  • publication: Execution-sale notice (R. 51.7) if enforced in the Puerto Rico courts.
  • waiting_period: Extinguished one year after the vessel’s detention.
  • sale_method: Judicial sale on the resulting judgment.
  • buyer_title: Through the judicial sale (R. 51.7(d)); federal maritime law governs documented vessels’ preferred-mortgage interplay.
  • surplus_handling: Execution sobrante (R. 51.2).
  • defective_sale_consequence: R. 51.7-51.8.
  • citation: Ley 151-1968 §5.12 (OGP Rev. 10 Jan 2025).

Y. Collecting bank’s security interest — Ley 208-1995 §3-210 · source: Ley de Transacciones Comerciales

  • statute: Ley 208-1995 §3-210 (collection chapter numbering).
  • who_holds: A collecting bank over an item, accompanying documents and proceeds to the extent credit is withdrawn/applied or advances are made.
  • priority_vs_perfected_security_interest: No filing required; priority over conflicting perfected security interests in the item, documents or proceeds (§3-210(c)(3)).
  • cap: The obligation secured as defined by the section.
  • court_required: No: enforceable under cap. 9 remedies (§9-601 et seq.).
  • notice_to_owner: Cap. 9 disposition notice where a disposition occurs (§§9-611-9-614); for an item collected, realization by final settlement.
  • notice_to_lienholders: Per §9-611 where applicable.
  • dmv_notice: Financial assets/documents, not titled goods. — NA
  • publication: None in cap. 9. — NA
  • waiting_period: §9-612 safe harbours if a disposition is noticed.
  • sale_method: Commercially reasonable disposition or collection (§§9-607, 9-610).
  • buyer_title: §9-617 transferee rules.
  • surplus_handling: §9-615 application and surplus.
  • defective_sale_consequence: §9-625 remedies; §9-626 deficiency rules.
  • citation: Ley 208-1995 §3-210; cap. 9.

Z. Letter-of-credit issuer/nominated person security interest — Ley 208-1995 §5-118 · source: Ley de Transacciones Comerciales

  • statute: Ley 208-1995 §5-118.
  • who_holds: Issuer or nominated person over a document presented under a letter of credit to the extent it honoured or gave value.
  • priority_vs_perfected_security_interest: Perfected without agreement/filing in stated cases; priority over a conflicting security interest while the debtor lacks possession of a tangible document (§5-118(b)(3)).
  • cap: The obligation secured as defined by the section.
  • court_required: No: enforceable under cap. 9 remedies (§9-601 et seq.).
  • notice_to_owner: Cap. 9 disposition notice where a disposition occurs (§§9-611-9-614); for an item collected, realization by final settlement.
  • notice_to_lienholders: Per §9-611 where applicable.
  • dmv_notice: Financial assets/documents, not titled goods. — NA
  • publication: None in cap. 9. — NA
  • waiting_period: §9-612 safe harbours if a disposition is noticed.
  • sale_method: Commercially reasonable disposition or collection (§§9-607, 9-610).
  • buyer_title: §9-617 transferee rules.
  • surplus_handling: §9-615 application and surplus.
  • defective_sale_consequence: §9-625 remedies; §9-626 deficiency rules.
  • citation: Ley 208-1995 §5-118.

AA. Securities-intermediary purchase security interest — Ley 208-1995 §9-206(a) · source: Ley de Transacciones Comerciales

  • statute: Ley 208-1995 §9-206(a)-(b).
  • who_holds: A securities intermediary that credits a purchased financial asset before payment.
  • priority_vs_perfected_security_interest: Automatic attachment and perfection rules of cap. 9 for this interest (§§9-206, 9-309).
  • cap: The obligation secured as defined by the section.
  • court_required: No: enforceable under cap. 9 remedies (§9-601 et seq.).
  • notice_to_owner: Cap. 9 disposition notice where a disposition occurs (§§9-611-9-614); for an item collected, realization by final settlement.
  • notice_to_lienholders: Per §9-611 where applicable.
  • dmv_notice: Financial assets/documents, not titled goods. — NA
  • publication: None in cap. 9. — NA
  • waiting_period: §9-612 safe harbours if a disposition is noticed.
  • sale_method: Commercially reasonable disposition or collection (§§9-607, 9-610).
  • buyer_title: §9-617 transferee rules.
  • surplus_handling: §9-615 application and surplus.
  • defective_sale_consequence: §9-625 remedies; §9-626 deficiency rules.
  • citation: Ley 208-1995 §9-206.

AB. Delivery-against-payment security interest — Ley 208-1995 §9-206(c) · source: Ley de Transacciones Comerciales

  • statute: Ley 208-1995 §9-206(c).
  • who_holds: A person delivering a certificated security or other written financial asset under a delivery-against-payment agreement in the ordinary course.
  • priority_vs_perfected_security_interest: Automatic interest securing the payment obligation (§9-206(c)-(d)).
  • cap: The obligation secured as defined by the section.
  • court_required: No: enforceable under cap. 9 remedies (§9-601 et seq.).
  • notice_to_owner: Cap. 9 disposition notice where a disposition occurs (§§9-611-9-614); for an item collected, realization by final settlement.
  • notice_to_lienholders: Per §9-611 where applicable.
  • dmv_notice: Financial assets/documents, not titled goods. — NA
  • publication: None in cap. 9. — NA
  • waiting_period: §9-612 safe harbours if a disposition is noticed.
  • sale_method: Commercially reasonable disposition or collection (§§9-607, 9-610).
  • buyer_title: §9-617 transferee rules.
  • surplus_handling: §9-615 application and surplus.
  • defective_sale_consequence: §9-625 remedies; §9-626 deficiency rules.
  • citation: Ley 208-1995 §9-206.

Article 9 — non-uniform features (Ley 208-1995 cap. 9). Consumer pre-repossession written notice at least 5 days before taking possession (9-609(a)(1)); a mandatory “AVISO AL DEUDOR” just above the debtor’s signature in consumer-goods security agreements (9-609(d)); self-help only without breach of the peace (9-609(b)); disposition-notice safe harbours of 10 days (non-consumer) and 20 days (consumer goods) (9-612); financing statements on titled motor vehicles are filed at the DTOP Registro de Vehículos (9-501(a)(1)) — DTOP form DTOP-770 ({CESCO}); a disposition passes the debtor’s rights and discharges the enforcing and subordinate interests, and a good-faith transferee takes free despite non-compliance (9-617); redemption until disposition (9-623). Civil Code prenda rules do not apply to cap. 9 interests (Código Civil 2020 art. 1000). Absent an agreed procedure, a pledgee sells before a notary at public auction with citation of debtor and owner; after a second failed auction it may keep the pledge, giving a receipt for the whole credit (art. 1008); the buyer’s title is not stated (U, channel register).

Dealer-only auctions. A licensed redistribuidor auctions vehicles of financial institutions, insurers, lessors and dealers to dealers; such a sale is not a subasta pública (Ley 22-2000 art. 1.87-A; Ley 8-1987 arts. 2(f), 12-A, 12-B).

12.4 Titles after a forced sale

Vehicles (DTOP — Registro de Vehículos; CESCO offices).

ChannelDocumentDTOP / CESCO stepCitation
Venta judicialCertified acta de subastaPublic-auction document is listed proof of ownership; court orders affecting disposition are annotated; execution-specific CESCO packet or form: needs_verificationR.P.C. 51.7(d); Ley 22-2000 arts. 2.04(b)(3), 4.10
Court-ordered transferCourt resolutionCESCO “Traspaso por orden del Tribunal”: resolution plus protocolization by an attorney; USD 15 stamp and USD 2 comprobanteCESCO requisitos page (agency guidance)
Self-storage lien saleSeller’s sworn statement and proof of complianceDTOP (or DRNA) issues title on application; form: needs_verificationLey 173-2011 art. 7
Repossession / financial-institution auctionCertificado de cesión or insurer’s sale documentCESCO “Traspaso de vehículo por subasta”: sworn cesión de derechos, condition report, photos, Police PPR-325 stolen-vehicle certificate, licence, title, payment sheetLey 22-2000 art. 2.04(b)(4)–(5); Ley 8-1987 art. 12-B; CESCO requisitos page (agency guidance)
Police / municipal / DTOP auctionDocumento de subasta pública identifying the authorized auctioneerListed proof of ownership; CESCO packet: needs_verificationLey 22-2000 arts. 2.04(b)(3), 6.28, 23.09
Junta de ConfiscacionesJunta forms SC-1504, SC-1508, SC-1503CESCO “Traspaso por la Junta de Confiscación”: David Plus sheet and photos, PPR-325, confiscation order, sworn acceptanceCESCO requisitos page (agency guidance)
  • Surviving liens: a transfer does not cancel or modify existing gravámenes and DTOP refuses to register a transfer of a vehicle “gravado con cualquier tipo de gravamen”, except administrative fines on a trade-in, which move to the prior owner’s plate (Ley 22-2000 arts. 2.42(c), 2.43(d)); accident-claim annotations block transfer for one year unless bonded (art. 4.10); fines follow the plate owner (art. 23.10). A gravamen de desaparecido blocks a transfer until a court authorizes it (CESCO requisitos page (agency guidance)).
  • Branding / salvage: a vehicle declared a total loss or abandoned as inservible may be used only for replacement parts and no licence issues for a unit assembled from such parts; total-loss, stolen, confiscated or exported status is annotated in the register; insurers must register salvage they acquire (Ley 8-1987 arts. 6, 10(4), 11).
  • Fees: certificate of title USD 11; transfer inscription USD 15; late filing of a transfer USD 10 per month after 15 days (dealers and financial creditors 30 days) (Ley 22-2000 arts. 23.02(35), (19), 2.41(i)–(j)).

Vessels (DRNA — Comisionado de Navegación; Ley 430-2000 arts. 9, 11).

  • Agency and threshold: every vessel subject to numbering in Puerto Rico waters must be numbered, named, inscribed and pay the annual fee, except the art. 9(7) classes: 60-day reciprocity vessels, foreign nautical-tourism vessels up to one year, government vessels, lifeboats, tenders, and USCG-documented or foreign-flag vessels — but residents’ documented vessels are not exempt from inscription under 9(7)(f), while 9(7)(g) exempts documented vessels generally; the text is internally inconsistent.
  • Involuntary transfer: application with evidence of ownership, fee payment and income-tax filing evidence; without title evidence, a sworn statement plus a Fiscal General certification that the vessel is not in criminal litigation (art. 9(2)). Fines for not renewing the decal or not notifying a change of owner must be paid before renewal or transfer “incluso en casos de ejecución por una institución financiera o por cualquier acreedor” (art. 9(9)). Other annotated fines bar transfer, unless they predate the change of owner, in which case transfer proceeds with the annotation kept and the new owner pays (art. 11). Correction: the first pass attributed the execution phrase to all annotated fines. DRNA form number: needs_verification.
  • Federal documentation: see uscg-national-vessel-documentation-center, maritime-liens-and-preferred-ship-mortgages, admiralty-arrest-and-marshals-sale.

Aircraft. No Puerto Rico aircraft registration statute was found; aircraft are not excluded from IVU tangible property (Ley 1-2011 §4010.01(gg)). Unpaid airport charges are a statutory lien on the aircraft without filing; the aircraft may not leave until paid and the Autoridad de los Puertos must sue (Ley 187-1949 art. 9). Federal liens on movables are filed at the Departamento de Estado (Ley 148-2024 art. 3). Otherwise the FAA registry governs — faa-aircraft-registry, aircraft-title-liens-and-the-faa-registry.

Titled equipment and trailers. DTOP titles motor vehicles, arrastres and semiarrastres (Ley 22-2000 art. 2.02) and registers heavy motor vehicles (art. 2.07) and ATVs (art. 2.10); titling of off-road heavy equipment: needs_verification.

12.5 Businesses and business interests

  • Receivership (sindicatura): a síndico is appointed as a provisional remedy only if no other remedy will secure the judgment; unless the court orders otherwise it acts under the rules for judicial administration of estates; it may not be a party, counsel or interested person without written consent; a bond may be required (R.P.C. 56.1, 56.6). Under those estate rules, sales of inventoried goods need a court decree on the administrator’s proposal after notice and hearing, at public auction after expert appraisal (Ley de Procedimientos Legales Especiales art. 579). The TPI may also appoint an administrador judicial — and if insolvent a síndico — on deadlock or abandonment (continuing the business, not liquidating, unless ordered) and síndicos for dissolved corporations, who pay liens “dentro del alcance de su prelación legal” (Ley 164-2009 arts. 7.16, 9.09–9.10). No uniform act. Sale free and clear: not stated — needs_verification.
  • Assignment for the benefit of creditors: the Código Civil 2020 contains no cesión de bienes regime (only consensual dación en pago, art. 1138) — status needs_verification.
  • CRL (LLC) charging orders: on a judgment creditor’s application the court may charge a member’s interest; the creditor receives only distributions; a receiver of distributions has only an assignee’s rights. “Una orden de cargar constituirá un gravamen”; the court may at any time order execution of the interest; “el comprador en venta por ejecución, tendrá solamente los derechos de un cesionario” (membership only with the art. 19.45 approvals). Before execution the interest may be redeemed by the member, by other members with non-CRL property, or by the CRL with the uncharged members’ consent. The article is the exclusive remedy; creditors get no rights in CRL property. No single-member distinction (Ley 164-2009 arts. 19.44–19.45).
  • Partnerships (sociedad): the Civil Code chapter has no charging-order provision; partnership creditors are preferred to a partner’s creditors on partnership assets (Código Civil 2020 art. 1451). Execution on a partner’s share: needs_verification.
  • Stock levy: Ley 208-1995 §8-112 (UCC 8-112) — a certificated security is reached only by seizing the certificate; uncertificated securities by process against the issuer; entitlements against the intermediary. Shares may be sold at public auction only after final judgment; for a non-resident or unservable debtor, certified mail and two publications, the last at least 10 days before the sale; post-embargo transfers by the debtor are null; after the sale is made and confirmed and the order is served on the corporation the buyer is entitled to the shares (Ley 164-2009 art. 12.03).
  • Bulk sales: none — Ley 208-1995 “tal como se aprobó no tiene Capítulo 6”.
  • Tax successor liability (Ley 1-2011 §6010.09): a contribuyente sucesor — one who replaces the taxpayer in operating an existing business by transfer of the operation or assets, with substantial similarity of operations and continuity of identity of the taxpayer or its owners — is jointly and severally liable for the predecessor’s taxes, including withholdings, unless it shows a valid business reason. There is no express forced-sale exception and no pre-closing notice period, but an unrelated buyer at a forced sale ordinarily lacks the required continuity of identity.
  • Liquor licences — correction: alcoholic-beverage licences are governed by Ley 1-2011 §5050.16, not §3050.10. They “no podrán traspasarse de una persona a otra”; a buyer of the stock may continue the business for up to 60 days; seller and buyer report the transaction within 30 days; the licence of any business sold, transferred, leased or otherwise alienated is automatically cancelled 60 days after the transaction; the buyer needs its own licence (refusal grounds §5050.18).
  • Other licences: Subtitle C excise licences are non-transferable; a buyer may continue up to 120 days, must report within 10 days, and the licence is cancelled 120 days after the transfer (§3050.10; the text’s reference to a “sixty-day” remainder in (c) is internally inconsistent); changes of control of movable-property leasing institutions need regulatory approval (Ley 20-1973).

12.6 Taxes when buying

  • Vehicles: automobiles, motorcycles, ATVs, vessels, heavy equipment, buses, trucks and trailers are excluded from IVU tangible personal property (Ley 1-2011 §4010.01(gg)(2)(B)). Instead an arbitrio is imposed on every vehicle introduced or manufactured, on its precio contributivo (automobiles by price-band table; trucks 10%, motorcycles 8%, ATVs 11.5%, trailers 6.6%) (§3020.08); DTOP will not first-register a vehicle without the arbitrio receipt (Ley 22-2000 art. 2.03). A forced resale of an already-introduced vehicle bears no IVU and no new arbitrio; confirm the arbitrio was paid on a recently imported unit.
  • Vessels: 7% arbitrio on introduction or manufacture, on the suggested retail price, capped at USD 10,000; such vessels are exempt from IVU; non-residents’ foreign-flag or USCG-documented vessels are exempt; the seller’s declaration and Hacienda’s certification precede DRNA registration of a new vessel (§3020.09).
  • Aircraft: if the sale is a taxable IVU transaction, 11.5% composite: 6% (§4020.01) + 4.5% surcharge (§4210.01, which continues because the Subtítulo DD VAT was suppressed by Ley 54-2016)
    • 1% municipal (§4020.10). Exemptions and casual-sale treatment: needs_verification.
  • Equipment and business assets: taxable tangible property 11.5%; heavy equipment is excluded from IVU and bears a 7% arbitrio on introduction capped at USD 25,000 (§3020.09). The tax is imposed on “toda transacción de venta” and collected by comerciantes (§§4020.01, 4020.05); occasional-sale treatment and whether an alguacil, agency or auctioneer is a collecting comerciante: needs_verification.
  • Transfer and registration fees: vehicle title USD 11, transfer USD 15, private automobile registration USD 44 a year (Ley 22-2000 art. 23.02); vessel registration USD 25 (under 16 ft) to USD 400 (65 ft and over), USD 5 for a sole-work-instrument fishing or rental vessel (Ley 430-2000 art. 9(2)).

12.7 Where these sales are published

Official postings observed (checked 18 Oct 2026)

  • U.S. Bankruptcy Court, District of Puerto Rico — Notices of Intent to Sell Report: a rolling 30-day sale-notice report; the two observed notices concerned a vehicle and a café’s inventory, machinery and equipment, with sales scheduled for 9 November 2026.

  • Legal-notice rule and qualification: execution edictos in a “diario de circulación general” in Puerto Rico (R.P.C. 51.7(a)); Hacienda’s Anuncio de Subasta in two general-circulation dailies (Ley 1-2011 §6060.08(b)); agency notices in newspapers of general circulation in Puerto Rico, with regional papers only in addition and only if they print over 40,000 copies with audited circulation (Ley 141-1949 art. 2).

  • Statewide site: none by statute (R.P.C. 51.7(a); Ley 141-1949 art. 2), so no site reuse terms apply; newspapers’ own terms were not reviewed and public visibility is not a reuse licence.

  • Officer portals: none for ventas judiciales; the Judiciary’s Subastas page is procurement (Poder Judicial, Subastas).

  • Agency postings: posted avisos at the alcaldía, court and colecturía (R.P.C. 51.7(a)); DRNA website and social media and tags for vessels (Ley 430-2000 art. 13); self-storage edictos also on the facility’s notice board (Ley 173-2011 art. 6(d)).

  • Collectability: court sales are comparatively centralized (island-wide dailies); administrative movable sales follow a 30-day warning to the debtor “sin más aviso” (Hacienda publishes; CRIM movables provisions require no publication). No listing collection is performed or authorized here.

12.8 Buyer checklist (Puerto Rico)

  1. Identify the channel — venta judicial (R.P.C. 51.7), Hacienda apremio (Ley 1-2011 §6060), CRIM apremio (Ley 107-2020 art. 7.074), Police/municipal/DTOP auction (Ley 22-2000 arts. 6.28, 23.09), DRNA (Ley 430-2000 art. 13), Junta de Confiscaciones (Ley 119-2011 art. 20) or a statutory lien sale (Ley 173-2011; Ley 208-1995 §§7-210, 9-610) — minimums, notices and title rules differ.
  2. Check the aviso de venta for a court sale: three postings for two weeks, two edictos at least seven days apart, certified mail to the debtor; otherwise the sale is null (R.P.C. 51.7(a)).
  3. Bring cash or a certified check payable to the alguacil; for Hacienda sales a 10% deposit and the balance within 10 days (R.P.C. 51.7(d); Ley 1-2011 §6060.09).
  4. Ask for the certified acta de subasta — it is the buyer’s title evidence and conveys only the debtor’s rights (R.P.C. 51.7(d)).
  5. Pay or clear any retenedor holding the item before taking possession (Código Civil 2020 art. 1228), and confirm that the holder’s retention rests on an actual statutory grant.
  6. Search the DTOP record (financing statements are filed there) for gravámenes, accident-claim annotations, gravamen de desaparecido and fines: DTOP will not register a transfer of a liened vehicle (Ley 22-2000 arts. 2.43(d), 4.10; Ley 208-1995 §9-501).
  7. Search the Departamento de Estado registry for federal tax liens on movables (Ley 148-2024 art. 3).
  8. Search the DRNA vessel record for annotated fines, which bar renewal or transfer and must be paid even after a creditor’s execution (Ley 430-2000 arts. 9(9), 11).
  9. For administrative auctions, expect step-down minimums — Hacienda 100/75/50%, CRIM 75/60/50% — and treat survival of prior liens as unresolved (Ley 1-2011 §6060.03; Ley 107-2020 art. 7.074).
  10. For removed vehicles, the owner (not a lender) is the only party notified; budget for clearing any DTOP-recorded lien before transfer (Ley 22-2000 arts. 6.28, 2.43(d)).
  11. For a self-storage sale, verify the two mailed notices, the notarial inventory and appraisal, the edicto and the 10-day wait; the buyer takes free of the operator’s lien and junior charges only (Ley 173-2011 arts. 4, 6).
  12. No IVU on used vehicles or boats, but confirm no arbitrio is outstanding on recently imported units (Ley 1-2011 §§4010.01(gg)(2)(B), 3020.08–3020.09).
  13. CRL interests bought at a charging-order execution carry only cesionario rights; shares require a confirmed sale and service on the corporation (Ley 164-2009 arts. 19.44, 12.03).
  14. Buying an operating business: check successor-taxpayer exposure (continuity of identity), and plan a new alcoholic-beverage licence — the seller’s lapses 60 days after the transfer (Ley 1-2011 §§6010.09, 5050.16).
  15. Confiscated vehicles: confirm the confiscation became final (no timely, properly served challenge) before relying on the Junta’s sale (Ley 119-2011 arts. 13, 15; reliable-financial-services-v-ela-2017).

12.9 Case law

CaseHolding relevant to forced salesPage
Reliable Financial Services, Inc. v. ELA, 2017 TSPR 19 (consolidated with Maldonado Rivera v. ELA)The State showed no valid investigative reason to hold the vehicle past Art. 13’s 30-day notice term, so the confiscation was declared null; but nullity for late notice is not automatic — it requires a judicial determination in a challenge that meets Art. 15’s jurisdictional terms, including service on the Secretario de Justicia within 15 days (official opinion)reliable-financial-services-v-ela-2017
Cooperativa de Seguros Múltiples de P.R. y Popular Auto, LLC v. ELA, 2025 TSPR 78A no-probable-cause finding at a vista preliminar en alzada is not an express adjudication exonerating the vehicle, so collateral estoppel does not void the civil confiscation; a financer’s generic compliance clause did not make it an innocent third party; lenders keep a collection action for the balance; reversed and remanded over three dissents (official opinion)cooperativa-de-seguros-multiples-v-ela-2025

Both full opinions were read. No precedential Tribunal Supremo opinion on Rule 51.7 chattel sales or on Civil Code 2020 retention was located in this bounded review (the earlier search’s only retention decision was an unpublished Tribunal de Apelaciones sentencia, KLAN201801400, which is not used). No commercial citator was used; neither holding was found overruled.

12.10 Gap register and score

Bounded final review score: gap_score_m12 = 168 = 46 required fields marked U (rubric row 18) + 11 grants with an incomplete priority/court/title triad × 4 (row 19) + 13 buyer channels without a complete what-the-buyer-takes rule × 6 (row 20). Denominator: exactly 165 base schema paths plus 28 grants × 15 fields = 585 required attributes (481 S, 46 U, 58 NA). Rows 16–17 and 21–24 and rows 3–5 add zero (every subsection present, fifteen checklist items, two full-opinion cases, OGP compilations labelled as non-official, no summary-only statute cited). This replaces the first pass’s non-canonical 34; it is not a strict keep-gate pass.

  • Base fields U (22): setting-aside deadline; tercería procedure and citation; Hacienda movables buyer title; removed-vehicle buyer title; DRNA auction buyer title; abandoned aircraft (agency, procedure, citation); DTOP forms for execution, self-storage and agency-auction transfers; DRNA form; off-road equipment titling; receiver free-and-clear sale; ABC (statute, supervision, citation); partnership-share execution; aircraft IVU exemptions; occasional-sale and auctioneer IVU treatment.
  • Incomplete triads (11): hacienda-tax-lien, estate-gift-transferred-property-lien, estate-gift-personal-lien, agricultural-deferred-estate-tax-lien, alcohol-excise-first-lien, crim-personal-property-tax-lien, municipal-construction-excise-lien, vehicle-accident-claim-annotation, vehicle-fine-plate-lien, vessel-fine-annotation, airport-charges-aircraft-lien.
  • Incomplete channels (13): provisional-fungibles, hacienda-apremio, hacienda-unlicensed-alcohol-assets, crim-apremio, police-municipal-vehicle, dtop-removed-vehicle, drna-abandoned-vessel-auction, drna-finder-adjudication, forfeiture, scrap-yard-confiscation, prenda, receiver, dissolution-sindico.

▸ For Buyers / Operators — The null-without-notice rule and debtor’s-rights-only acta (12.1), the silence of administrative-sale statutes on surviving liens (12.2), the self-storage, warehouse, carrier and Article 9 sale rules (12.3), DTOP’s refusal to transfer liened vehicles (12.4), the IVU exclusion for vehicles and boats (12.6) and successor-tax and licence lapse rules (12.5) are the main acquisition facts.

▸ For Owners / Debtors — Execution exemptions in CEC art. 249 (12.1); the 30-day challenge and payment windows in Hacienda and CRIM apremio and the TPI petition to dissolve a CRIM embargo (12.2); the 60-day vehicle and vessel reclaim windows and 30-day judicial review (12.2); the 30-day confiscation notice and challenge terms (12.2, 12.9); surplus (sobrante) through the Secretaría, Hacienda, the CRIM or, for self-storage, Hacienda’s one-year refund window (12.1–12.3).

Local pages

County deep dives: county pages for this jurisdiction are being added largest-first. Buyer guides: puerto-rico-vehicles, puerto-rico-boats, puerto-rico-aircraft, puerto-rico-equipment, puerto-rico-businesses


Legal information, not legal advice. This page summarizes Puerto Rico tax and mortgage foreclosure law for research purposes only and may be incomplete or out of date. Most sources are in Spanish and the Spanish statutory text controls; English glosses are the author’s translation. Statutes and case law change. Consult a licensed Puerto Rico attorney before acting. Verify every figure and deadline against the cited primary sources. Last verified: 2026-06-02.